TO THE READER.
25 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
TO THE READER.
Christian Reader,
I Shall briefly give you an account what moved me to undertake this task: 1. I observed it very common among Christians, when we have been speaking about some Minister, godly, eminent, &c. against whom no objection can be made; but if he were a man of the Presbyterial judgement, they would make sleight account of him. He? He is a Presbyterian, and if you have said so, Presbyterian is crime enough; hence to separate from a Presbyterial Minister, though never so able and godly, they think it no offence at all; this made me search what they had to say against these Presbyterial men, whether their grounds for such contempt were solid, as also for their separation.
I Shall briefly give you an account what moved me to undertake this taske: 1. I observed it very common among Christians, when we have beene speaking about some Minister, godly, eminent, &c. against whom no objection can be made; but if he were a man of the Presbyterial judgement, they would make sleight account of him. Hee? He is a Presbyterian, and if you have said so, Presbyterian is crime enough; hence to separate from a Presbyterial Minister, though never so able and godly, they thinke it no offence at all; this made me search what they had to say against these Presbyterial men, whether their grounds for such contempt were solid, as also for their separation.
2. I received two Letters from New England from a worthy Divine, one some longer time since, the other but lately, in which there were these passages: In the first, which was writ after the overthrow of Duke Hamilton he hath this passage, We do not know what to pray for in your behalf: God hath removed adversaries, fought miraculously for you against the Scots, and put the power of things into such hands, as have been most active for the godly party, and yet your condition is as miserable as ever, the Lord help, for vain is the help of man: I much fear, you that are the godly Ministers, have been too passive, and not so zealous against Errors and Heresies, as you ought, and therefore it is just with the Lord, to let in these inundations of hellish opinions upon you, which damp all power of Religion, wheresoever they become; though I am not worthy to be reckoned among the godly Ministers, yet my conscience doth not accuse me of this fault, I am rather judged a man too severe. In his other Letter, which came at the end of this Summer, he wrote thus:
2. I received two Letters from New England from a worthy Divine, one some longer time since, the other but lately, in which there were these passages: In the first, which was writ after the overthrow of Duke Hamilton he hath this passage, We doe not know what to pray for in your behalfe: God hath removed adversaries, fought miraculously for you against the Scots, and put the power of things into such hands, as have beene most active for the godly party, and yet your condition is as miserable as ever, the Lord helpe, for vaine is the helpe of man: I much feare, you that are the godly Ministers, have beene too passive, and not so zealous against Errours and Heresies, as you ought, and therefore it is just with the Lord, to let in these inundations of hellish opinions upon you, which damp all power of Religion, wheresoever they become; though I am not worthy to be reckoned among the godly Ministers, yet my conscience doth not accuse me of this fault, I am rather judged a man too severe. In his other Letter, which came at the end of this Summer, he wrote thus:
It's the wonderment of this side of the world, that you that are ⟨image 6⟩godly, and may agree, yet will not. Neither doth my conscience accuse me in this point, I hope I shall clear it by the ensuing Discourse.
It's the wonderment of this side of the world, that you that are ⟨image 6⟩godly, and may agree, yet will not. Neither doth my conscience accuse me in this point, I hope I shall cleare it by the ensuing Discourse.
3. Among the many crimes charged upon the Independent Churches, I have noted these two especially; 1. That they are but a back door for Errors and Heresies. 2. That they regard nothing but their own interest, so long as they have their liberty, though there are Ministers as godly, able, and learned, and many hundreds of true visible Churches in the Nation besides theirs, yet they regard not them, nor their comfort; being therefore set down by Mr. Edwards in his Catalogue of Independents, I thought I would clear my self of all these things, and though I be but amongst the meanest, and not worth the regarding, yet to discharge my self, and to have my spirit free, when ever God shall visit us for these Divisions, Errors, Heresies, &c. [for what can we expect but some rod, if we continue in the frame we now are in?] I have made bold humbly to address my self to our Congregational Divines, to be seech them, to take those offers, which the Presbyterial brethren make for agreement, that so we may strengthen one another against the common adversaries, that trouble our Reformation.
3. Among the many crimes charged upon the Independent Churches, I have noted these two especially; 1. That they are but a backe doore for Errours and Heresies. 2. That they regard nothing but their owne interest, so long as they have their liberty, though there are Ministers as godly, able, and learned, and many hundreds of true visible Churches in the Nation besides theirs, yet they regard not them, nor their comfort; being therefore set downe by Mr. Edwards in his Catalogue of Independents, I thought I would cleare my selfe of all these things, and though I be but amongst the meanest, and not worth the regarding, yet to discharge my selfe, and to have my spirit free, when ever God shall visit us for these Divisions, Errours, Heresies, &c. [for what can we expect but some rod, if we continue in the frame we now are in?] I have made bold humbly to addresse my selfe to our Congregational Divines, to be seech them, to take those offers, which the Presbyteriall brethren make for agreement, that so we may strengthen one another against the common adversaries, that trouble our Reformation.
I thought to have taken occasion here to clear my self from what Mr. Edwards had writ concerning me, but the man being dead, I rather let it alone, (for sin, I thank God, he hath charged me with none) I know, if ever the Lord bring such an unworthy wretch as I am to heaven, I shall not bear Mr. Edwards a grudge for what unkindness he hath offered to me here. But whereas Mr. Edwards hath branded me for an Independent; some of (miserable) Colchester have told me that I have altered my principles; but I know no reason why the one should charge me to be an Independent, nor the other for departing from my principles; for I never declared any thing in public, but only once, which was concerning the matter and form of a visible Church: for the government of the Church never troubled me, but how to have the people reformed, and scandalous persons debarred from the seals of the Covenant, and persons brought into a posture fit for Discipline, but what is this to Independency? Once also I expressed this, that I conceived, a Church organized, and walking regularly might execute all the power of the Keys within it self. I never expressed any thing more there concerning Church-work, but did labour to keep alive the old truths, which I found my heart had more need of, then to ⟨image 6⟩preach about Church-government in such a Town, as that was. But if you say, though I did not express it openly, yet I was an Independent in my judgement: but how can men charge me with that, whi•c neither in public, nor private they ever heard me express? but then to deal plainly I shall set down what manner of Independent then I was, and then you shall see how much I am altered. In these points I did join with the Congregational-men.
I thought to have taken occasion here to cleare my selfe from what Mr. Edwards had writ concerning me, but the man being dead, I rather let it alone, (for sin, I thanke God, he hath charged me with none) I know, if ever the Lord bring such an unworthy wretch as I am to heaven, I shall not beare Mr. Edwards a grudge for what unkindnesse he hath offered to me here. But whereas Mr. Edwards hath branded me for an Independent; some of (miserable) Colchester have told me that I have altered my principles; but I know no reason why the one should charge me to be an Independent, nor the other for departing from my principles; for I never declared any thing in publike, but onely once, which was concerning the matter and forme of a visible Church: for the government of the Church never troubled me, but how to have the people reformed, and scandalous persons debarred from the seales of the Covenant, and persons brought into a posture fit for Discipline, but what is this to Independency? Once also I expressed this, that I conceived, a Church organized, and walking regularly might execute all the power of the Keyes within it self. I never expressed any thing more there concerning Church-worke, but did labour to keep alive the old truths, which I found my heart had more need of, then to
First, I thought none but visible Saints to be fit matter for a Church.
Secondly, 1I thought a promise from the people to subject themselves to Church-discipline was of very great concernment, to carry on Discipline with strength and comfort, as likewise to subject themselves to all other Ordinances, as became Christians.
- 1So the Belgic Churches.So the Belgick Churches.
Thirdly, though I did own the Churches of England for true Churches, yet because for want of Catechising and Discipline, they were overgrown with ignorance and profaneness: I did desire the grossly ignorant and profane to stay a while, before I gave t heir children the seal of Baptism, that having got knowledge, and conversation freed from scandal, the Ordinance might be administered with more comfort.
Thirdly, though I did owne the Churches of England for true Churches, yet because for want of Catechising and Discipline, they were overgrowne with ignorance and prophanenesse: I did desire the grosly ignorant and prophane to stay a while, before I gave t heir children the seale of Baptisme, that having got knowledge, and conversation freed from scandall, the Ordinance might be administred with more comfort.
Fourthly, I thought that if Churches were now constituting, the Officers should not receive any into Church-fellowship against the consent of the people, giving sufficient proof against them.
Fourthly, I thought that if Churches were now constituting, the Officers should not receive any into Church-fellowship against the consent of the people, giving sufficient proofe against them.
Fifthly, I thought the Officers ought not excommunicate any person, If the people did not consent to them [not that a Church must be obstructed, if two or three have a mind to be cross.]
Fifthly, I thought the Officers ought not excommunicate any person, If the people did not consent to them [not that a Church must be obstructed, if two or three have a minde to be crosse.]
Sixthly, I thought a particular Church organized to be the first subject of the power of the Keys, and according as Mr. Cotton held it out: but this I did not express publicly.
Sixtly, I thought a particular Church organized to be the first subject of the power of the Keyes, and according as Mr. Cotton held it out: but this I did not expresse publikely.
Seventhly, I did somewhat question whether the Officers of one Church had power to excommunicate in another Church.
But in these points I was no Independent.
First, I could not be clear that the people were the first subject of the power of the Keys.
First, I could not be clear that the people were the first subject of the power of the Keyes.
Secondly, neither that the Fraternity had power to ordain formally.
Thirdly, that a Minister should preach only as a gifted broth er out of his own place.
Thirdly, that a Minister should preach onely as a gifted broth er out of his owne place.
Fourthly, I could not consent to have the godly people taken away from a godly Presbyterian, into an Independent Church.
Fifthly, I could not approve that Independent Churches should ⟨image 7⟩refuse to communicate with Presbyterial Churches, though there were good store of visible Saints, for want of an explicit Covenant.
Fifthly, I could not approve that Independent Churches should ⟨image 7⟩refuse to communicate with Presbyteriall Churches, though there were good store of visible Saints, for want of an explicite Covenant.
By this time, I hope I shall be no rank Independent: But where is then my thanging of my principles? let these men prove it, for I am the same still, only since I read Mr. Hudson, I do somewhat waver about the first subject of the Keys and this is all my change.
By this time, I hope I shall be no ranke Independent: But where is then my thanging of my principles? let these men prove it, for I am the same still, onely since I read Mr. Hudson, I doe somewhat waver about the first subject of the Keyes and this is all my change.
That my mind may be cleared against whom I write; I observe Separatists are not all of a size; some separate from Ministers & Churches, and get into their private houses, own no officers, but please themselves with their own gifts and opinions; these are the persons whom I chiefly aim at, as such that so trouble us, that no Church-discipline can hold so long as they stand.
That my minde may be cleared against whom I write; I observe Separatists are not all of a size; some separate from Ministers & Churches, and get into their private houses, owne no officers, but please themselves with their owne gifts and opinions; these are the persons whom I chiefly aime at, as such that so trouble us, that no Church-discipline can hold so long as they stand.
Others live in places where there are visible and real Saints, the Ministry godly, and able, yea, it may be called to the place by these persons, but because they cannot have all they would picking a quarrel with the Ordination of their Minister, &c. they choose some other Minister in some other Town, and so depart from the Presbyterial to a Congregational Church, continuing still in the same Parish; It is well these men hold up Ordinances and Officers, yet the grounds of their practice the ensuing Discourse will try. I am sure, peace and unity among Churches cannot possibly stand with this practice; it is very sad that we should not yield a little, where we may, nay where we ought, for peace with our brethren whom we cannot but judge holy and sincere.
Others live in places where there are visible and reall Saints, the Ministry godly, and able, yea, it may be called to the place by these persons, but because they cannot have all they would picking a quarrell with the Ordination of their Minister, &c. they choose some other Minister in some other Towne, and so depart from the Prebyterial to a Congregational Church, continuing still in the same Parish; It is well these men hold up Ordinances and Officers, yet the grounds of their practice the ensuing Discourse will try. I am sure, peace and unity among Churches cannot possibly stand with this practice; it is very sad that we should not yeeld a little, where we may, nay where we ought, for peace with our brethren whom we cannot but judge holy and sincere.
If there should sometimes fall out a quotation somewhat sharp, yet I pray do not think that I apply it to all Separatists, but to some among them, who may deserve it.
If there should sometimes fall out a quotation somewhat sharp, yet I pray doe not thinke that I apply it to all Separatists, but to some among them, who may deserve it.
What success my poor endeavours shall find, I know not, I look for little good they shall do amongst the Separatists, who with an imperious scorn neglect to listen to, or read any thing, which tends to overthrow their practice; and though they be so confuted, as they are not able to answer a word, yet they scorn to acknowledge their error, and return to the Congregations, from which they have separated, which to me is a clear demonstration, that however these men pretend conscience, yet it is no such thing; for were these men lead by a pure conscience, considering how they separate from holy men, such also as have been instruments of their souls good, considering also how they weaken their hands, grieve their spirits, they would hear, read, pray, take any course, that they might be sure to be found in the truth. 1But I leave the success to God, my desire was, to serve my Generation, and there I rest.
What successe my poore endeavours shall finde, I know not, I looke for little good they shall doe amongst the Separatists, who with an imperious scorn neglect to listen to, or read any thing, which tends to overthrow their practice; and though they be so confuted, as they are not able to answer a word, yet they scorne to acknowledge their error, and returne to the Congregations, from which they have separated, which to me is a clear demonstration, that however these men pretend conscience, yet it is no such thing; for were these men lead by a pure conscience, considering how they separate from holy men, such also as have beene instruments of their soules good, considering also how they weaken their hands, grieve their spirits, they would heare, read, pray, take any course, that they might be sure to be found in the truth. 1But I leave the successe to God, my desire was, to serve my Generation, and there I rest.