A85827:174
A discourse apologeticalA discours apologetical
A discourse apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and loud lies in his Merlin or Pasquil for the year 1654. are clearly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fully refuted; and his malicious and murderous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidently evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatory of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. author [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.A discours apologetical; wherein Lilies lewd and lowd lies in his Merlin or Pasqil for the yeer 1654. are cleerly laid open; his shameful desertion of his own cause is further discovered; his shameless slanders fullie refuted; and his malicious and murtherous mind, inciting to a general massacre of Gods ministers, from his own pen, evidentlie evinced. Together with an advertisement concerning two allegations produced in the close of his postscript. And a postscript concerning an epistle dedicatorie of one J. Gadburie. By Tho. Gataker B.D. autor [sic] of the annotations on Jer. 10.2 and of the vindication of them.
London: printed by R. Ibbitson for Thomas Newberry, 1654
Title page typeset from the transcription.
An Advertisement concerning two Allegations in Lilies Postscript.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First, Because (he saith) he will not enter the lists with any but Scholars. Secondly, Because he will not be Sea-bounded, and judged in his future Discourse by an Island. None, it seems, in this poor Island are of ability or sufficiency to judge of his writings; they are so feeble, miserably defective, and shalowbraind, ⟨p. 76⟩for want of his Scholastical and Mystical Divinity, which he wishes he could have brought over with him, wherewith to improve them. But why did he not then publish his former Debate by it self, that it might suddenly have flown oversea, but give it out by morsels and mammocks, either in the Pulpit, or by the Press or both amidst the intervals of a large English Discourse? And in the next place he falls to threatening of him that shall oppose him. If the Adversary, saith he, shall be obstinate (as they must be deemed all, that meddle with ought of his) let him know, that my Pen shall not spend Ink hereafter but in the Latin language. And withal, I promise, saith he, my Reader, that I will not only endeavour to satisfy him in the present matter, but I will dress the matter in warm Language. Withal subjoining a long addition of vain boasting what rare and precious stuff he will therein entertain his Reader with. Now in part of this denunciation he hath much failed; in part, if I mistake him not, he hath not at all failed to make his word good; For whereas an Answer in Latin to his Latin difficulty hath been tendered 1unto him, as himself acknowledgeth; which he might, if he had so pleased, have replied unto in Latin, and so published it together with his former Latin Debate extracted out of his former Work: he hath returned only some few parcels or patches in Latin, dispersed and dis-jected like Absirtus his limbs, all put together not making up four whole pages at most, inserted into an English Work consisting of Pages upward of 450. Wherein also he is so far from giving any real satisfaction to his Reader, that he doth not so much as afford him his Answerers own words in the language required; only picks out some curtailed Objections, as he termeth them, framed as himself pleaseth, and delivered in English, and without the Arguments to back them annexed, and after a little sorry stuff sub-joined, turns over the rest, with a Caetera omnia ut aberrantia à scopo & assument amera rejicio, 2and so lets them go.