A86003:27
Male audis or An answer to Mr. Coleman his Malè dicis. Wherein the repugnancy…
Male audis or An answer to Mr. Coleman his Malè dicis. Wherein the repugnancy of his Erastian doctrine to the word of God, to the solemn League and Covenant, and to the ordinances of Parliament: also his contradictions, tergiversations, heterodoxies, calumnies, and perverting of testimonies, are made more apparent then formerly. Together with some animadversions upon Master Hussey his Plea for Christian magistracy: showing, that in divers of the afore mentioned particulars he hath miscarried as much, and in some particulars more then Mr Coleman. / By George Gillespie, minister at Edinburgh. Published by authority.Male audis or An answer to Mr. Coleman his Malè dicis. Wherein the repugnancy of his Erastian doctrine to the word of God, to the solemne League and Covenant, and to the ordinances of Parliament: also his contradictions, tergiversations, heterodoxies, calumnies, and perverting of testimonies, are made more apparent then formerly. Together with some animadversions upon Master Hussey his Plea for Christian magistracy: shewing, that in divers of the afore mentioned particulars he hath miscarried as much, and in some particulars more then Mr Coleman. / By George Gillespie, minister at Edinbrugh. Published by authority.
London: printed for Robert Bostocke, 1646
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6. I having charged Master Colemans doctrine with this consequence, That there ought to be neither Suspension from the Sacrament, nor Excommunication, nor Ordination, nor ⟨p. 9⟩Deposition of Ministers, nor receiving of Appeals, except all these things be done by the Civil Magistrate: Which things I said, are most of them corrective, and all of them more then Doctrinal. In stead of making answer, the Reverend Brother expresseth the error which I objected to him thus, That here are no Church-Censures, which is the Quaesitum saith he, Male dicis, pag. 10. Here again he brings an imagination of his own, both for matter and words, in stead of that which I said, and doth not take the Argument right. If the Ministers power be merely Doctrinal, and Government wholly in the Magistrates hands, then all the particulars enumerated, for instance, Suspension from the Sacrament, and the receiving of Appeals (which he must not bring under the Quaesitum, except he bring the Ordinance of Parliament under the Quaesitum) shall be wholly in the Magistrates hand, and Elderships may not suspend from the Sacrament, Classes and Synods may not receive Appeals, which yet by the Ordinance they have power to do. One of the particulars (and but one) the Reverend Brother hath here touched, and it is thus; For Ordination of Ministers, I say it is within the Commission of Teaching, and so appertains to the Doctrinal part. This is the effect of his zeal to maintain, that all Ecclesiastical Ministerial power is merely Doctrinal. But mark the consequence of it. He that holds Ordination of Ministers to be within the Commission of Teaching, and to appertain to the Doctrinal part, must hold by consequence▪ that the power of Ordination is given uni as well as unitati, that is, That every single Minister hath power to ordain, as well as the Classis. But Master Coleman holds Ordination of Ministers to be within the Commission of Teaching, &c. The reason of the Proposition is clear, because the Commission of Teaching belongs to every single Minister; so that if the power of Ordination be within that Commission, it must needs belong to every single Minister, Quid Respondes?
6. I having charged Master Colemans doctrine with this consequence, That there ought to be neither Suspension from the Sacrament, nor Excommunication, nor Ordination, nor ⟨p. 9⟩Deposition of Ministers, nor receiving of Appeals, except all these things be done by the Civil Magistrate: Which things I said, are most of them corrective, and all of them more then Doctrinal. In stead of making answer, the Reverend Brother expresseth the error which I objected to him thus, That here are no Church-Censures, which is the Quaesitum saith he, Male dicis, pag. 10. Here again he brings an imagination of his own, both for matter and words, in stead of that which I said, and doth not take the Argument right. If the Ministers power be meerly Doctrinal, and Government wholly in the Magistrates hands, then all the particulars enumerated, for instance, Suspension from the Sacrament, and the receiving of Appeals (which he must not bring under the Quaesitum, except he bring the Ordinance of Parliament under the Quaesitum) shall be wholly in the Magistrates hand, and Elderships may not suspend from the Sacrament, Classes and Synods may not receive Appeals, which yet by the Ordinance they have power to do. One of the particulars (and but one) the Reverend Brother hath here touched, and it is thus; For Ordination of Ministers, I say it is within the Commission of Teaching, and so appertains to the Doctrinal part. This is the effect of his zeal to maintain, that all Ecclesiastical Ministerial power is meerly Doctrinal. But mark the consequence of it. He that holds Ordination of Ministers to be within the Commission of Teaching, and to appertain to the Doctrinal part, must hold by consequence that the power of Ordination is given uni as well as unitati, that is, That every single Minister hath power to ordain, as well as the Classis. But Master Coleman holds Ordination of Ministers to be within the Commission of Teaching, &c. The reason of the Proposition is clear, because the Commission of Teaching belongs to every single Minister; so that if the power of Ordination be within that Commission, it must needs belong to every single Minister, Quid Respondes?