A89568:27
The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honourable Commissioners of Parliament, at the…The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honorable Commissioners of Parliament, at the…
The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honourable Commissioners of Parliament, at the treaty at Newport in the Isle of Wight. To the second paper delivered to them by his Majesty, Octob. 6. 1648. about episcopal government. Delivered to his Majesty, October 17. I appoint Abel Roper to print this copy, entitled The humble answer of the Divines, &c. Richard Vines,The humble answer of the Divines attending the Honorable Commissioners of Parliament, at the treaty at Newport in the Isle of Wight. To the second paper delivered to them by his Majesty, Octob. 6. 1648. about episcopall government. Delivered to his Majesty, October 17. I appoint Abel Roper to print this copie, entituled The humble answer of the Divines, &c. Richard Vines,
London: printed for Abel Roper, 1648
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thirdly, Your Majesty saith that that which we so confidently affirm of Timothy and Titus, their acting as Evangelists is by some denied and refuted, yea even with scorn rejected by some rigid Presbyterians, and that which we so confidently deny, that they were Bishops, is confirmed by the consentient testimony of all antiquity, recorded by Jerome himself that they were Bishops of Pauls ordination, acknowledged by very many late Divines, and that a Catalogue of 27 Bishops of Ephesus lineally succeeding from Timothy out of good Record is vouched by Dr. Reynolds and other Writers.
Thirdly, Your Majesty saith that that which we so confidently affirme of Timothy and Titus, their acting as Evangelists is by some denyed and refuted, yea even with scorne rejected by some rigid Presbyterians, and that which we so confidently deny, that they were Bishops, is consirmed by the consentient testimony of all antiquity, recorded by Ierome himselfe that they were Bishops of Pauls ordination, acknowledged by very many late Divines, and that a Catalogue of 27 Bishops of Ephesus lineally succeeding from Timothy out of good Record is vouched by Dr. Reynolds and other Writers.
Our confidence (as Your Majesty is pleased to call it) was in our Answer expressed in these words, we cannot say that Timothy and Titus were Bishops in the sense of Your Majesty, but extraordinary officers or Evangelists, in which opinion we were then clear, not out of a total ignorance ⟨p. 19⟩of those Testimonies which might be alleged against it, but from intrinsic arguments out of Scripture, from which Your Majesty hath not produced any one to the contrary, nor is our confidence weakened by such replies as these, the Scripture never calls them Bishops, but the Fathers do, the Scripture calls Timothy an Evangelist, some of late have refuted it, and rejected it with scorn, the Scripture relates their motions from Church to Church, but some affirm them to be fixed at Ephesus and in Crete, the Scripture makes distinction of Evangelists and Pastors, but some say that Timothy and Titus were both, we cannot give Your Majesty a present account of Scultetus and Gherard's Arguments, but do believe that M. Gillespie and Rutherford are able with greater strength to refute that opinion of Timothy and Titus their being Bishops, then they do (if they do) with scorn reject this of their being Evangelists; As for testimonies and catalogues though we undervalue them not, yet Your Majesty will be pleased to allow us the use of our Reason, so far as not to erect an office in the Church, which is not found in Scripture, upon general appellations or titles and allusions frequently found in the Fathers, especially when they speak vulgarly, and not as to a point in debate, for even Jerome who as Your Majesty saith doth Record that Timothy and Titus were made Bishops, and that of St. Pauls Ordination, doth when he speaks to the point between Your Majesty and us, give the Bishops to understand that they are superior to Presbyters consueitudine magis quam Dominicae veritatis disposition;