pp. 3–4052 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
May it please your Majesty,
May it please your Majestly,
AS in our Paper of October the third, in Answer to your Majesties of October the second We did, so now again we do acknowledge, that the Scriptures cited in the Margin of your Majesties Paper do prove, that the Apostles in their own persons; That Timothy, and Titus, and the Angels of the Churches, had power respectively, to do those things, which are in those places of Scripture specified; But as then, so now also we humbly do deny, that any of the persons or Officers fore-mentioned were Bishops, as district from ⟨p. 4⟩Presbyters, or did exercise Episcopal Government in that sense; Or that this was in the least measure proved by the alleged Scriptures, and therefore our Negative not being to the same point, or state of the Question which was affirmed; We humbly conceive that we should not be interpreted, to have in effect, denied the very same thing, which we had before granted, or to have acknowledged that the several Scriptures do prove the thing, for which they are cited by your Majesty; And, if that, which we granted were all, that, by the Scriptures cited in your Margin, your Majesty intended to prove; It will follow, That nothing hath yet been proved on your Majesties part, to make up that conclusion which is pretended.
AS in our Paper of October the third, in Answer to your Majesties of October the second We did, so now againe we do acknowledge, that the Scriptures cited in the Margin of your Majesties Paper do prove, that the Apostles in their own persons; That Timothy, and Titus, and the Angels of the Churches, had power respectively, to do those things, which are in those places of Scripture specified; But as then, so now also we humbly do deny, that any of the persons or Officers fore-mentioned were Bishops, as district from ⟨p. 4⟩Presbyters, or did exercise Episcopall Government in that sence; Or that this was in the least measure proved by the alleadged Scriptures, and therefore our Negative not being to the same point, or state of the Question which was affirmed; We humby conceive that we should not be interpreted, to have in effect, denyed the very same thing, which we had before granted, or to have acknowledged that the severall Scriptures do prove the thing, for which they are cited by your Majesty; And, if that, which we granted were all, that, by the Scriptures cited in your Margin, your Majesty intended to prove; It will follow, That nothing hath yet beene proved on your Majesties part, to make up that conclusion which is pretended.
As then we stood upon the Negative to that assertion, so we now crave leave to represent to your Majesty, that your reply doth not infirm the Evidence given in maintenance thereof. The Reason given by your Majesty in this Paper, to support your assertion: That the persons that exercised the power aforesaid were Bishops in distinct sense, is taken from a description of Episcopal Government; which is (as your Majesty saith) nothing else, but the Government of the Churches within a certain Precinct (commonly called a Diocese) committed to one single person, with sufficient authority over the Presbyters, and people of those Churches for that end; which Government so described, being for substance of the thing it self in all the three forementioned particulars, (Ordaining, giving rules of Discipline, and Censures) found in Scriptures, ⟨p. 5⟩except we will contend about names & words, must be acknowledged in the sense aforesaid to be sufficiently proved from Scriptures: and your Majesty saith further, that the Bishops do not challenge more, or other power to belong to them, in respect of their Episcopal office, as it is distinct from that of Presbyters, then what properly falls under one of those three.
As then we stood upon the Negative to that assertion, so we now crave leave to represent to your Majesty, that your reply doth not infirme the Evidence given in maintenance thereof. The Reason given by your Majesty in this Paper, to support your assertion: That the persons that exercised the power aforesaid were Bishops in distinct sence, is taken from a description of Episcopall Government; which is (as your Majesty saith) nothing else, but the Government of the Churches within a certaine Precinct (commonly called a Diocesse) committed to one single person, with sufficient authority over the Presbyters, and people of those Churches for that end; which Government so described, being for substance of the thing it selfe in all the three forementioned particulars, (Ordaining, giving rules of Discipline, and Censures) found in Scriptures, ⟨p. 5⟩except we will contend about names & words, must be acknowledged in the sense aforesaid to be sufficiently proved from Scriptures: and your Majesty saith further, that the Bishops do not challeng more, or other power to belong to them, in respect of their Episcopal office, as it is distinct from that of Presbyters, then what properly fals under one of those three.
We desire to speak both to the Bishops challenge, and to your Majesties description of Episcopal government. And first to their Challenge; because it is first expressed in your Majesties reply.
We desire to speak both to the Bishops challenge, and to your Majesties description of Episcopal government. And first to their Challenge; because it is first exprest in your Majesties reply.
The Challenge we undertake in two respects: 1. In respect of the Power challenged, 2. In respect of that ground, or Tenure upon which the claim is laid. The Power challenged consists of three particulars; Ordaining, giving Rules of Discipline, and Censures. No more, no other, in respect of their Episcopal office. We see not, by what warrant this Writ of partition is taken forth, by which the Apostolical office is thus sha•ed or divided; The Governing part into the Bishops hands; the Teaching, and administering Sacraments, into the Presbyters. For besides that the Scripture makes no such enclosure, or partition wall; it appears, the challenge is grown to more then was pretended unto in the times of grown Episcopacy. Jerome, and Chrysostom do both acknowledge for their time, that the Bishop and Presbyter differed only in the matter of Ordination: and learned Doctor Bilson makes some abatement in the claim of three, saying, the things proper to Bishops, which might not be common to Presbyters, are singularly of Succeeding, and superiority in Ordaining.
The Challenge we undertake in two respects: 1. In respect of the Power challenged, 2. In respect of that ground, or Tenure upon which the claim is laid. The Power challenged consists of three particulars; Ordaining, giving Rules of Discipline, and Censures. No more, no other, in respect of their Episcopal office. We see not, by what warrant this Writ of partition is taken forth, by which the Apostolical office is thus sha•ed or divided; The Governing part into the Bishops hands; the Teaching, and administring Sacraments, into the Pr••byters. For besides that the Scripture makes no such inclosure, or partition wall; it appeares, the challenge is grown to more then was pretended unto in the times of growne Episcopacie. Jerome, and Chrysostome do both acknowledge for their time, that the Bishop and Presbyter differed only in the matter of Ordination: and learned Doctor Bilson makes some abatement in the claim of three, saying, the things proper to Bishops, which might not be common to Presbyters, are singularly of Succeeding, and superiority in Ordaining.
The tenure or ground upon which the claim is made is Apostolical, which with us is all one with Divine Institution. And this, as far as we have learned, hath not been anciently, openly, or generally avowed in this Church of England, either in time of Popery, or of the first Reformation; and whensoever the pretension hath been made, it was not without the contradiction of learned, and godly men. The abettors of the challenge, that they might resolve it at last into the Scripture, did choose the most plausible way of ascending by the scale of Succession; going up the River to find the Head: but when they came to Scriptures, & found it like the head of Nile (which cannot be found) they shrouded it under the name and countenance of the Angels of the Churches, and of Timothy and Titus. Those that would carry it higher, endeavoured to imp it into the Apostolical office, and so at last called it a Divine Institution, not in force of any express precept, but implicit practise of the Apostles; and so the Apostolical office (excepting the gifts, or enablements confessed only extraordinary) is brought down to be Episcopal, and the Episcopal raised up to be Apostolical. Whereupon it follows, that the highest Officers in the Church are put into a lower orb; an extraordinary office turned into an ordinary distinct office, confounded with that which in the Scripture is not found; a temporary, and an extinct office revived. And indeed if the definitions of both be rightly made, they are so incompatible to the same subject, that he that will take both must lose the one: aut Apostolus Episcopatum, aut Apostolatum Episcopus. For the Apostles, though they did not in many things ut aliud, yet they acted alio nomine & alio munere, then ⟨p. 7⟩Presbyters, or Bishops can do: and if they were indeed Bishops, and their government properly Episcopal in distinct sense, then it is not needful to go so far about to prove Episcopal government of Divine institution, because they practised it; but to assert expressly, that Christ instituted it immediately in them.
The tenure or ground upon which the claim is made is Apostolical, which with us is all one with Divine Institution. And this, as far as we have learned, hath not been anciently, openly, or generally avowed in this Church of England, either in time of Popery, or of the first Reformation; and whensoever the pretension hath been made, it was not without the contradiction of learned, and godly men. The abettors of the challenge, that they might resolve it at last into the Scripture, did chuse the most plausible way of ascending by the scale of Succession; going up the River to find the Head: but when they came to Scriptures, & found it like the head of Nile (which cannot be found) they shrowded it under the name and countenance of the Angels of the Churches, and of Timothy and Titus. Those that would carry it higher, endeavoured to impe it into the Apostolical office, and so at last called it a Divine Institution, not in force of any expresse precept, but implicite practise of the Apostles; and so the Apostolical office (excepting the gifts, or enablements confest only extraordinary) is brought down to be Episcopal, and the Episcopal raised up to be Apostolical. Whereupon it follows, that the highest Officers in the Church are put into a lower orb; an extraordinary office turn'd into an ordinary distinct office, confounded with that which in the Scripture is not found; a temporary, and an extinct office revived. And indeed if the definitions of both be rightly made, they are so incompatible to the same subject, that he that will take both must lose the one: aut Apostolus Episcopatum, aut Apostolatum Episcopus. For the Apostles, though they did not in many things ut aliud, yet they acted alio nomine & alio munere, then
For your Majesties definition of Episcopal government, it is extracted out of the Bishops of later date, then Scripture times, and doth not suit to that Meridian, under which there were more Bishops then one in a Precinct, or Church; and it is as fully competent to Archiepiscopal, and Patriarchal government, as Episcopal. The parts of this definition, materially, and abstractly considered, may be found in Scripture. The Apostles, Timothy and Titus, were single persons, but not limited to a Precinct: The government of the Angels was limited to a Precinct, but not in single persons. In several offices, not to be confounded, the parts of this definition may be •ound; but the aggregation of them altogether into one ordinary Officer cannot be •ound. And if that word, ordinary, and standing Government, had been made the genus in your Majesties definition (as it ought to be) We should crave leave to say it would be gratis dictum, if not petitio principii: for the Scripture doth not put all these parts together in a Bishop, who never borrowed of Apostles, Evangelists and Angels, the matter of Governing and Ordaining, and left the other of Teaching, dispensing Sacraments and dealing only in foro interno, to Presbyters, until after times. By this that hath been said, it is manifest enough, that we contend not first de nomine: about the name of Episcopal Government: which yet ⟨p. 8⟩(though names serve for distinction) is not called or distinguished by that name in Scripture. Nor secondly de opere about the work, whether the work of Governing, ordering, preaching &c. be of continuance in the Church, Which we clearly acknowledge; But thirdly de munere, about the Office, it being a great fallacy to argue, That the Apostles did the same work which Bishops or Presbyters are to do in ordinary. Therefore they were of the same Office: for as it is said of the liberal, and learned Arts one and the same thing may be handled in divers of them, and yet these Arts are distinguished by the formalis ratio of handling of them, so we say of Offices, they are distinguished by their callings and Commissions, though not by the work, as all those that are named, (Eph. 4. 11.) Apostles, Prophets, Evangelists, Pastors and Teachers, are designed to one and the same general and common work: The work of the Ministry, ver. 12.
For your Majesties definition of Episcopal government, it is extracted out of the Bishops of later date, then Scripture times, and doth not sute to that Meridian, under which there were more Bishops then one in a Precinct, or Church; and it is as fully competent to Archiepiscopal, and Patriarchal government, as Episcopal. The parts of this definition, materially, and abstractly considered, may be found in Scripture. The Apostles, Timothy and Titus, were single persons, but not limited to a Precinct: The government of the Angels was limited to a Precinct, but not in single persons. In several offices, not to be confounded, the parts of this definition may be ound; but the aggregation of them altogether into one ordinary Officer cannot be ound. And if that word, ordinary, and standing Government, had been made the genus in your Majesties definition (as it ought to be) We should crave leave to say it would be gratis dictum, if not petitio principii: for the Scripture doth not put all these parts together in a Bishop, who never borrowed of Apostles, Evangelists and Angels, the matter of Governing and Ordaining, and left the other of Teaching, dispensing Sacraments and dealing onely in foro interno, to Presbyters, untill after times. By this that hath been said, it is manifest enough, that we contend not first de nomine: about the name of Episcopall Government: which yet
And yet they are not therefore all one, for •ts said, some Apostles, some Prophets, some Evangelists, and some Pastors and Teachers; A Dictator in Rome and an ordinary Tribune. Moses and the subordinate governors of Israel. The Court of Parliament and of the Kings-Bench, an Apostle and a Presbyter or Deacon may agree in some common work, and yet no confusion of Offices follows thereupon.
And yet they are not therefore all one, for •ts said, some Apostles, some Prophets, some Evangelists, and some Pastors and Teachers; A Dictator in Rome and an ordinary Tribune. Moses and the subordinate governours of Israel. The Court of Parliament and of the Kings-Bench, an Apostle and a Presbyter or Deacon may agree in some common worke, and yet no confusion of Offices followes thereupon.
To that which your Majesty conceives, that the most that can be proved from all, or any of those places, by us alleged (to prove that the Name, Office, and work of Bishops and Presbyters is one and the same in all things, and not in the least distinguished) Is that the word Bishop is used in them to signify a Presbyter, and that consequently the Offi•, and work mentioned ⟨p. 9⟩in these places as the Office and work of a Bishop are the Office of a Presbyter, which is confessed on all sides. We make this humble return, that though there be no supposition, so much as implied, that the Office of a Bishop and a Presbyter, are distinct in any thing (for the names are mutually reciprocal,) yet we take your Majesties concession, that in these times of the Church, and places of Scripture, there was no distinct Office of Bishops and Presbyters; and consequently that the identity of the Office must stand, until there can be found a clear distinction or division in the Scriptures; And if we had argued the identity of Functions from the Community of names, and some part of the work, the Argument might have been justly termed a fallacy, but we proved them the same Office from the fame work, per omnia, being allowed so to do by the fullness of those two words used in the Acts and St. Peter his Epistle [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] under the force of which words the Bishops claim their whole power of Government and Jurisdiction, and we found no little weight added to our Argument from that in the Acts, where the Apostle departing from the Ephesian Presbyters or Bishops, as never to see their faces more, commits (as by a final charge) the Government of that Church, both over particular Presbyters and people; not to Timothy who then stood at his elbow, but to the Presbyters under the name of Bishops, made by the Holy Ghost, whom we read to have set many Bishops over one Church, not one over either one or many, and the Apostles arguing from the same qualification of a Presbyter ⟨p. 10⟩and of a Bishop in order to ordination or putting him into Office, fully proves them to be two names of the same order or function: the diverse Orders of Presbyter and Deacon, being diversly characterised, upon these grounds (we hope without fallacy) we conceive it justly proved, that a Bishop and a Presbyter are wholly the same.
To that which your Majesty conceives, that the most that can be proved from all, or any of those places, by us alleadged (to prove that the Name, Office, and work of Bishops and Presbyters is one and the same in all things, and not in the least distinguisht) Is that the word Bishop is used in them to signifie a Presbyter, and that consequently the Offi, and work mentioned
That Timothy and Titus were single persons, having authority of Government, we acknowledge; but deny, that from thence any argument can be made unto either single Bishop or Presbyter: for though a single Presbyter by the power of his Order (as they call it) may preach the Word and dispense the Sacraments; yet by that example of the Presbytery, their Laying on of hands, and that Rule of Telling the Church in matter of scandal, it seems manifest, that Ordination and Censures are not to be exercised by a single Presbyter; neither hath your Majesty hitherto proved, either the names of Bishops and Presbyters, or the function, to be in other places of Scripture at all distinguished; You having wholly waved the notice or answer of that we did assert (and do yet desire some demonstration of the contrary) viz. That the Scripture doth not afford us the least notice of any qualification, any ordination, any work or duty, any honour peculiarly belonging to a Bishop distinct from a Presbyter; the assignment of which, or any of them unto a Bishop, by the Scripture, would put this question near to an issue. That GOD should intend a distinct and highest kind of Officer for Government in the Church, and yet not express any qualification, work, ⟨p. 11⟩or way of constituting and ordaining of him, seems unto us improbable. Concerning the signification of the word Episcopus, importing an Overseer, or one that hath a charge committed to him, for instance of watching a Beacon, or keeping sheep, and the application of the name to such persons as have inspection of the Churches of Christ committed to them in spiritualibus: We also give our suffrage, but not to that distinction of Episcopus gregis, and Episcopus pastorum & gregis; both because it is the [Greek or Hebrew] or point in question; and also because your Majesty having signified that Episcopus imports a keeper of sheep, yet you have not said that it signifies also a keeper of shepherds. As to that which is affirmed by your Majesty, that the peculiar of the function of Bishops is Church-government; and that the reason why the word Episcopus is usually applied to Presbytery, was because Church Governors had then another title of greater eminency, to wit, that of Apostle; until the Government of the Church came into the hands of their successors; & then the names were by common usage very soon appropriated;
That Timothy and Titus were single persons, having authority of Government, we acknowledge; but deny, that from thence any argument can be made unto either single Bishop or Presbyter: for though a single Presbyter by the power of his Order (as they call it) may preach the Word and dispense the Sacraments; yet by that example of the Presbyterie, their Laying on of hands, and that Rule of Telling the Church in matter of scandal, it seems manifest, that Ordination and Censures are not to be exercised by a single Presbyter; neither hath your Majesty hitherto proved, either the names of Bishops and Presbyters, or the function, to be in other places of Scripture at all distinguished; You having wholly waved the notice or answer of that we did assert (and do yet desire some demonstration of the contrary) viz. That the Scripture doth not afford us the least notice of any qualification, any ordination, any work or duty, any honour peculiarly belonging to a Bishop distinct from a Presbyter; the assignment of which, or any of them unto a Bishop, by the Scripture, would put this question neer to an issue. That GOD should intend a distinct and highest kind of Officer for Government in the Church, and yet not expresse any qualification, work,
That of Episcopus to Ecclesiastical Governors, That of Presbyter to the ordinary Ministers. This assertion your Majesty is pleased to make without any demonstration; for whom the Scripture calls Presbyters, Rulers, and Pastors and Teachers, it calls Governors; and commits to them the charge of feeding and inspection as we have proved, and that without any mention of Church Government peculiar to a Bishop; we deny not, but some of ⟨p. 12⟩the Fathers have conceived the notion that Bishops were called Apostles, till the names of Presbyter and Episcopus became appropriate, which is either an allusion or conceit, without Evidence of Scripture; for, while the Function was one, the names were not divided; when the Function was divided, the name was divided also, and indeed impropriate; but we that look for the same warrant, for the division of an Office, as for the Constitution, cannot find that this appropriation of names, was made till afterwards, or in process of time, as Theodoret (one of the Fathers of this conceit) affirms, whose saying, when it is run out of the pale of Scripture time, we can no further follow; from which premises laid altogether, we did conclude the clearness of our assertion, that in the Scriptures of the New Testament, a Bishop distinct from a Presbyter in Qualification, Ordination, Office or dignity is not found, the contrary whereof, though your Majesty saith, that you have seen confirmed by great variety of credible Testimony, yet we believe those testimonies are rather strong in asserting, then in demonstrating the Scriptures Original of a Bishop, which is declared against by a cloud of witnesses, named in the latter end of our former Answer, unto which we should refer if matter of right were not properly triable by Scripture, as matter of Fact is by Testimony.
That of Episcopus to Ecclesiastical Governours, That of Presbyter to the ordinary Ministers. This asser•ion your Majesty is pleased to make without any demonstration; for whom the Scripture cals Presbyters, Rulers, and Pastors and Teachers, it calls Governors; and commits to them the charge of feeding and inspection as we have proved, and that without any mention of Church Government peculiar to a Bishop; we deny not, but some of ⟨p. 12⟩the Fathers have conceived the notion that Bishops were called Apostles, till the names of Presbyter and Episcopus became appropriate, which is either an allusion or conceipt, without Evidence of Scripture; for, while the Function was one, the names were not divided; when the Function was divided, the name was divided also, and indeed impropriate; but we that look for the same warrant, for the division of an Office, as for the Constitution, cannot find that this appropriation of names, was made till afterwards, or in processe of time, as Theodoret (one of the Fathers of this conceit) affirms, whose saying, when it is run out of the pale of Scripture time, we can no further follow; from which premises laid altogether, we did conclude the cleernes of our assertion, that in the Scriptures of the New Testament, a Bishop distinct from a Presbyter in Qualification, Ordination, Office or dignity is not found, the contrary wherof, though your Majesty saith, that you have seene confirmed by great variety of credible Testimony, yet we believe those testimonies are rather strong in asserting, then in demonstrating the Scriptures Originall of a Bishop, which is declared against by a cloud of witnesses, named in the latter end of our former Answer, unto which we should refer if matter of right were not properly tryable by Scripture, as matter of Fact is by Testimony.
We said that the Apostles were the highest order of Officers of the Church, that they were extraordinary, that they were distinguished from all other Officers, and that their Government was not Episcopal, but ⟨p. 13⟩Apostolical; to which Answer, your Majesty being not satisfied, doth oppose certain assertions, That Christ himself and the Apostles received their Authority by Mission, their Ability by Unction; That the Mission of the Apostles was ordinary, and to continue to the end of the world; but the Unction, whereby they were enabled to both Offices & Functions, Teaching and Governing was indeed extraordinary, That in their Unction they were not necessarily to have successors, but necessarily in their Mission or Office of Teaching and Governing, That in these two ordinary Offices, their ordinary successors are Presbyters & Bishops, That Presbyters qua Presbyters do immediately succeed them in the Office of Teaching, and Bishops qua Bishops immediately in the Office of Governing; The demonstration of which last alone, would have carried in it more conviction then all these Assertions put together; Officers are distinguished by that whereby they are constituted, their Commission, which being produced, Signed by one place of Scripture, gives surer evidence, then a Pedigree drawn forth by such a series of distinctions as do not distinguish him into another Officer from a Presbyter; whether this chain of distinction be strong, and the links of it sufficiently tacked together, we crave leave to examine, Christ saith, your Majesty, was the Apostle and Bishop of our souls, and he made the Apostles both Apostles and Bishops; we do not conceive that your Majesty means that the Apostles succeeded Christ as the chief Apostle, and that as Bishops, they succeed Christ as a Bishop, least ⟨p. 14⟩thereby Christ his Mission as an Apostle and Bishop might be conceived as ordinary as their Mission is said to be; But we apprehend your Majesty to mean, that the Office of Apostle and Bishop, was eminently contained in Christs office, as the office of a Bishop was eminently contained in that of Apostleship; but thence it will not follow that inferior offices being contained in the superior eminently, are therefore existent in it formally;
Wee said that the Apostles were the highest order of Officers of the Church, that they were extraordinary, that they were distinguisht from all other Officers, and that their Government was not Episcopall, but ⟨p. 13⟩
For because all honours and dignities are eminently contained in your Majesty, would it therefore follow that your Majesty is formally and distinctly a Baron of the Realm, as it is asserted the Apostles to have been Bishops in distinct sense; That Mission refers to Office and authority, and Unction only to Ability, we cannot consent: for besides that the breathing of Christ upon his Disciples, saying, Receive ye the Holy Ghost, doth refer to mission as well as unction; we conceive that in the proper anointing of Kings, or other Officers, the natural use and effect of the oil upon the body, was not so much intended, as the solemn and ceremonious use of it in the inauguration of them; so there is relation to Office in unction, as well as to conferring of abilities; else how are Kings or Priests or Prophets said to be anointed? And what good sense could be made of that expression in Scripture, of anointing one in another's room: to omit, that Christ by this construction should be called the Messiah in respect of abilities only. And although we should grant your Majesties explication of Mission and Unction, yet it will not follow that the mission of the Apostles ⟨p. 15⟩was ordinary, and their unction only extraordinary: That into which there is succession, was ordinary; That into which there is no succession, (for succession is not unto abilities or gifts) extraordinary; and so the Apostles were ordinary officers in all whereunto there is properly any succession, and that is office. They differed from Bishops in that wherein one Apostle or Officer of the same order might differ from another, to wit, in abilities and measure of Spirit, but not in that wherein one order of officers is above another by their office;
For because all honours and dignities are eminently contained in your Majesty, would it therefore follow that your Majesty is formally and distinctly a Baron of the Realm, as it is asserted the Apostles to have been Bishops in distinct sense; That Mission refers to Office and authority, and Vnction only to Ability, we cannot consent: for besides that the breathing of Christ upon his Disciples, saying, Receive ye the Holy Ghost, doth refer to mission as well as unction; we conceive that in the proper anointing of Kings, or other Officers, the naturall use and effect of the oyle upon the body, was not so much intended, as the solemn and ceremonious use of it in the inauguration of them; so there is relation to Office in unction, as well as to conferring of abilities; else how are Kings or Priests or Prophets said to be anointed? And what good sense could be made of that expression in Scripture, of anointing one in anothers room: to omit, that Christ by this construction should be called the Messias in respect of abilities only. And although we should grant your Majesties explication of Mission and Ʋnction, yet it will not follow that the mission of the Apostles
To which we cannot give consent, for since no man is denominated an officer from his mere abilities or gifts, so neither can the Apostles be called extraordinary officers, because of extraordinary gifts, but that the Apostles mission and office (as well as their abilities) was extraordinary and temporary, doth appear in that it was by immediate Commission from Christ without any intervention, of men, either in Election or Ordination, for planting an authoritative governing of all Churches through the World, comprehending in it all other Officers of the Church whatsoever, and therefore it seems to us very unreasonable that the Office and authority of the Apostles should be drawn down to an ordinary, thereby to make it, as it were, a fit stock, into which the ordinary Office of a Bishop may be ingrafted, nor doth the continuance of Teaching and Governing in the Church more render the office of teaching and governing in the Apostles an ordinary office, then the office of teaching, and ⟨p. 16⟩governing in Christ himself, render his Office therefore Ordinary. The reason given, That the Office of Teaching and Governing, was ordinary in the Apostles, because of the continuance of them in the Church (we crave leave to say) is that great mistake which runs through the whole file of your Majesties discourse, for though there be a Succession in the work of Teaching and Governing, yet there is no Succession in the Commission or Office by which the Apostles performed them; for the Office of Christ, of Apostles, of Evangelists, of Prophets, is thence also concluded Ordinary, as to Teaching and Governing, and the distinction of Offices Extraordinary and Ordinary eatenus destroyed; The Succession may be into the same work, not into the same Commission and Office, the Ordinary Officers, which are to manage the work of Teaching and Government, are constituted, settled and limited by warrant of Scripture, as by another Commission then that which the Apostles had;
To which we cannot give consent, for since no man is denominated an officer from his meer abilities or gifts, so neither can the Apostles be called extraordinary officers, because of extraordinary gifts, but that the Apostles mission and office (as well as their abilities) was extraordinary and temporay, doth appeare in that it was by immediate Commission from Christ without any intervention, of men, either in Election or Ordination, for planting an authoritative governing of all Churches through the World, comprehending in it all other Officers of the Church whatsoever, and therefore it seemes to us very unreasonable that the Office and authority of the Apostles should be drawn down to an ordinary, thereby to make it, as it were, a fit stock, into which the ordinary Office of a Bishop may be ingrafted, nor doth the continuance of Teaching and Governing in the Church more render the office of teaching and governing in the Apostles an ordinary office, then the office of teaching, and
And if your Majesty had shown us some Record out of Scripture, warranting the division of the office of teaching and governing into two hands, and the appropriation of teaching to Presbyters, of governing to Bishops, the question had been determined, otherwise we must look upon the dissolving of the Apostolical Office, and distribution of it into these two hands, as the dictate of men who have a mind, by such a precarious Argument, to challenge to themselves the Keys of Authority, and leave the Word to the Presbyters.
And if your Majesty had shewn us some Record out of Scripture, warranting the division of the office of teaching and governing into two hands, and the appropriation of teaching to Presbyters, of governing to Bishops, the question had been determined, otherwise we must look upon the dissolving of the Apostolicall Office, and distribution of it into these two hands, as the dictate of men who have a minde, by such a precarious Argument, to challenge to themselves the Keyes of Authority, and leave the Word to the Presbyters.
In our answer to the instances of Timothy and Titus (which Doctor Bilson acknowledgeth to be the main erection of Episcopal power, if the proofs of their being Bishops, do stand, or subversion, if the answer that they were Evangelists be good) Your Majesty finds very little satisfaction though all that is said therein could be proved.
In our answer to the instances of Timothy and Titus (which Doctor Bilson acknowledgeth to be the maine erection of Episcopall power, if the proofes of their being Bishops, doe stand, or subversion, if the answer that they were Evangelists be good) Your Majesty finds very little satisfaction though all that is said therein could be proved.
First, because the Scriptures no where implieth any such things at all, that Titus was an Evangelist, neither doth the text clearly prove, that Timothy was so.
First, because the Scriptures no where implyeth any such things at all, that Titus was an Evangelist, neither doth the text cleerly prove, that Timothy was so.
1. The name of Bishop, the Scripture neither expressly nor by implication gives to either, the work which they are enjoined to do is common to Apostles, Evangelists, Pastors & Teachers, and cannot of it self make a character of one distinct and proper office; But that there was such an order of Officers in the Church as Evangelists reckoned amongst the extraordinary and temporary Offices and that Timothy was one of that Order, and that both Timothy and Titus were not ordained to one particular Church, but were companions and fellow Labourers with the Apostles, sent abroad to several Churches as occasion did require, it is as we (humbly conceive) clear enough in Scripture, and not denied by the learned defenders of Episcopal Government nor (as we remember) by Scultetus himself during the time of their travails.
1. The name of Bishop, the Scripture neither expresly nor by implication gives to either, the work which they are injoyned to do is common to Apostles, Evangelists, Pastors & Teachers, and cannot of it self make a character of one distinct and proper office; But that there was such an order of Officers in the Church as Evangelists reckoned amongst the extraordinary and temporary Offices and that Timothy was one of that Order, and that both Timethy and Titus were not ordained to one particular Church, but were companions and fellow Labourers with the Apostles, sent abroad to severall Churches as occasion did require, it is as we (humbly conceive) clear enough in Scripture, and not denyed by the learned defenders of Episcopall Government nor (as we remember) by Scultetus himselfe during the time of their travailes.
2. To that which Your Majesty secondly saith, That we cannot make it appear by any Text of Scripture that the Office of Evangelist is such as we have described, his work seeming, 2 Tim. 2. 4, 5. to be nothing else but diligence in preaching the word, notwithstanding all impediments and oppositions, We humbly Answer, That exact definitions of these or other Church Officers are hard to be found in any Text of Scripture, ⟨p. 16⟩[…] ⟨p. 17⟩[…] ⟨p. 18⟩but by comparing one place of Scripture with another, it may be proved aswell that they were, as what the Apostles and Presbyters were, the description by us given being a Character made up by collation of Scriptures, from which Mr. Hooker doth not much vary, saying that Evangelists were Presbyters of Principal sufficiency whom 1the Apostles sent abroad & used as Agents in Ecclesiastical Affairs, wheresoever they saw need. And that Pastors & Teachers, were settled in some certain charge and thereby differed from Evangelists, whose work that it should be nothing but diligence in preaching, &c, which is common to Apostles, Evangelists, Pastors and Teachers, and so not distinctive of this particular Office, argueth to us, that as the Apostles Office was divided into Episcopal and Apostolical, so this also is to be divided in Episcopal and Evangelistical, Ordination and Censures belonging to Timothy as a Bishop, and diligence in Preaching only being left to the Evangelists, which division (as we humbly conceive) is not warranted by the Scripture.
2. To that which Your Majesty secondly saith, That we cannot make it appeare by any Text of Scripture that the Office of Evangelist is such as we have discribed, his worke seeming, 2 Tim. 2. 4, 5. to be nothing else but diligence in preaching the word, notwithstanding all impediments and oppositions, We humbly Answer, That exact definitions of these or other Church Officers are hard to bee found in any Text of Scripture, ⟨p. 16⟩
Thirdly, Your Majesty saith that that which we so confidently affirm of Timothy and Titus, their acting as Evangelists is by some denied and refuted, yea even with scorn rejected by some rigid Presbyterians, and that which we so confidently deny, that they were Bishops, is confirmed by the consentient testimony of all antiquity, recorded by Jerome himself that they were Bishops of Pauls ordination, acknowledged by very many late Divines, and that a Catalogue of 27 Bishops of Ephesus lineally succeeding from Timothy out of good Record is vouched by Dr. Reynolds and other Writers.
Thirdly, Your Majesty saith that that which we so confidently affirme of Timothy and Titus, their acting as Evangelists is by some denyed and refuted, yea even with scorne rejected by some rigid Presbyterians, and that which we so confidently deny, that they were Bishops, is consirmed by the consentient testimony of all antiquity, recorded by Ierome himselfe that they were Bishops of Pauls ordination, acknowledged by very many late Divines, and that a Catalogue of 27 Bishops of Ephesus lineally succeeding from Timothy out of good Record is vouched by Dr. Reynolds and other Writers.
Our confidence (as Your Majesty is pleased to call it) was in our Answer expressed in these words, we cannot say that Timothy and Titus were Bishops in the sense of Your Majesty, but extraordinary officers or Evangelists, in which opinion we were then clear, not out of a total ignorance ⟨p. 19⟩of those Testimonies which might be alleged against it, but from intrinsic arguments out of Scripture, from which Your Majesty hath not produced any one to the contrary, nor is our confidence weakened by such replies as these, the Scripture never calls them Bishops, but the Fathers do, the Scripture calls Timothy an Evangelist, some of late have refuted it, and rejected it with scorn, the Scripture relates their motions from Church to Church, but some affirm them to be fixed at Ephesus and in Crete, the Scripture makes distinction of Evangelists and Pastors, but some say that Timothy and Titus were both, we cannot give Your Majesty a present account of Scultetus and Gherard's Arguments, but do believe that M. Gillespie and Rutherford are able with greater strength to refute that opinion of Timothy and Titus their being Bishops, then they do (if they do) with scorn reject this of their being Evangelists; As for testimonies and catalogues though we undervalue them not, yet Your Majesty will be pleased to allow us the use of our Reason, so far as not to erect an office in the Church, which is not found in Scripture, upon general appellations or titles and allusions frequently found in the Fathers, especially when they speak vulgarly, and not as to a point in debate, for even Jerome who as Your Majesty saith doth Record that Timothy and Titus were made Bishops, and that of St. Pauls Ordination, doth when he speaks to the point between Your Majesty and us, give the Bishops to understand that they are superior to Presbyters consueitudine magis quam Dominicae veritatis disposition;
Our confidence (as Your Majesty is pleased to call it) was in our Answer exprest in these words, wee cannot say that Timothy and Titus were Bishops in the sense of Your Majesty, but extraordinary officers or Evangelists, in which opinion we were then clear, not out of a totall ignorance ⟨p. 19⟩of those Testimonies which might be alledged against it, but from intrinsick arguments out of Scripture, from which Your Majesty hath not produced any one to the contrary, nor is our confidence weakned by such replys as these, the Scripture never cals them Bishops, but the Fathers do, the Scripture calls Timothy an Evangelist, some of late have refuted it, and rejected it with scorn, the Scripture relates their motions from Church to Church, but some affirme them to be fixed at Ephesus and in Creet, the Scripture makes distinction of Evangelists and Pastors, but some say that Timothy and Titus were both, we cannot give Your Majesty a present account of Scultetus and Gherards Arguments, but do believe that M. Gillespi and Rutherford are able with greater strength to refute that opinion of Timothy and Titus their being Bishops, then they do (if they do) with scorne reject this of their being Evangelists; As for testimonies and catalogues though we undervalue them not, yet Your Majesty will be pleased to allow us the use of our Reason, so far as not to erect an office in the Church, which is not found in Scripture, upon generall appellations or titles and allusions frequently found in the Fathers, especially when they speake vulgarly, and not as to a point in debate, for even Ierome who as Your Majesty saith doth Record that Timothy and Titus were made Bishops, and that of St. Pauls Ordination, doth when he speaks to the poynt between Your Majesty and us, give the Bishops to understand that they are superior to Presbyters consueitudine magis quam Dominicae veritatis dispositione;
for catalogues their credit rests upon the first witnesses from whom they are reported by tradition from hand to hand, whose writings are many times suppositions, dubius or not extant, besides that these catalogues do resolve themselves into some Apostle or Evangelist as the first Bishop, as the catalogue of Jerusalem ⟨p. 20⟩into the Apostle James, that of Antioch into Peter, that of Rome into Peter and Paul, that of Alexandria into Mark, that of Ephesus into Timothy, which Apostles and Evangelists can neither themselves be degraded by being made Bishops, nor be succeeded in their proper calling or office, and it is easy for us to proceed the same way and to find many ancient rites and customs generally received in the Church (counted by the ancients Apostolical traditions) as near the Apostles times as Bishops, which yet are, confessedly, not of Divine institution; and further, if Timothy and the rest that are first in the catalogue were Bishops with such sole Power of Ordination and Censures, as is asserted, how came their pretended successors, who were but Primi Presbyterorum (as the Fathers themselves call them) to lose so much Episcopal power as was in their Predecessors, and as was not recovered in 300 years? and therefore we cannot upon any thing yet said, recede from that of our Saviour, ab initio non fuit sic, from the beginning is was not so.
for catalogues their creditrests upon the first witnesses from whom they are reported by tradition from hand to hand, whose writings are many times suppositions, dubius or not extant, besides that these catalogues do resolve themselves into some Apostle or Evangelist as the first Bishop, as the catalogue of Ierusalem ⟨p. 20⟩into the Apostle Iames, that of Antioch into Peter, that of Rome into Peter and Paul, that of Alexandria into Marke, that of Ephesus into Timothy, which Apostles and Evangelists can neither themselves be degraded by being made Bishops, nor be succeeded in their proper calling or office, and it is easy for us to proceed the same way and to finde many antient rites and customs generally received in the Church (counted by the antients Apostolicall traditions) as neer the Apostles times as Bishops, which yet are, confessedly, not of Divine institution; and further, if Timothy and the rest that are first in the catalogue were Bishops with such sole Power of Ordination and Censures, as is asserted, how came their pretended successors, who were but Primi Presbyterorum (as the Fathers themselves call them) to lose so much Episcopall power as was in their Predecessors, and as was not recovered in 300 years? and therefore we cannot upon any thing yet said, recide from that of our Saviour, ab initio non fuit sic, from the begining is was not so.
Your Majesty saith, that we affirm but upon very weak proofs, that they were from Ephesus and Crete removed to other places, the contrary whereunto hath been demonstrated by some, who have exactly out of Scripture, compared the times, and order of the several journeys, and stations of Paul and Timothy.
Your Majesty saith, that wee affirme but upon very weak proofes, that they were from Ephesus and Crete removed to other places, the contrary whereunto hath been demonstrated by some, who have exactly out of Scripture, compared the times, and order of the severall journeyes, and stations of Paul and Timothy.
It is confessed that our assertion, that Timothy and Titus were Evangelists, lies with some stress upon this, that they removed from place to place, as they were sent by or accompanied the Apostles, the proof whereof appears to us, to be of greaten strength then can be taken off by the comparison which your Majesty makes of the Divines of the Assembly at Westminster. We begin with the Travails of ⟨p. 21⟩Timothy, as we find them in order recorded in the Scripture-places cited in the Margin, and we set forth from aBerea, where we find Timothy, then next at bAthens, from whence Paul sends him to cThessalonica, afterward having been in Macedonia, he came to Paul at dCorinth, and after that, he is with Paul at Ephesus, and thence sent by him into eMacedonia, whether Paul went after him, and was by Timothy accompanied into fAsia, who was with him at gTroas and hMiletus, to which place Saint Paul sent for the Presbyters of the Church in Ephesus, and gave them that solemn charge to take heed unto themselves, and to all the flock, over which the holy Ghost hath made them Bishops, not speaking a word of recommendation of that Church to Timothy, or of him to the Elders. And if Timothy was Bishop of Ephesus, he must be so when the first Epistle was sent to him, in which he is pretended to receive the charge of exercising his Episcopal power in Ordination and government; but it is manifest that after this Epistle sent to him, he was in continual journeys, or absent from Ephesus. For Paul left him at Ephesus when he went into iMacedonia, and he left him there to exercise his Office, in regulating and ordering that Church and in ordaining; but it was after this time that Timothy is found with Paul at Miletus, for after Paul had been at Miletus, he went to Jerusalem, whence he was sent prisoner to Rome, and never came more into Macedonia, and at
for it seems that Timothy was not there, because Paul giving Timothy 1an account of the absence of most of his companions sent into divers parts, he saith, Tychicus have I sent to Ephesus. Now if your Majesty shall be pleased, to cast up into one total that which is said; the several journeys and stations of Timothy, the order of them, the time spent in them, the nature of his employment, to negotiate the affairs of Christ in several Churches and places, the silence of the Scriptures, as touching his being Bishop of any one Church, you will acknowledge that such a man was not a Bishop fixed to one Church or precinct, and then by assuming that Timothy was such a man, you will conclude that he was not Bishop of Ephesus.
for it seemes that Timothy was not there, because Paul giving Timothy 1an account of the absence of most of his companions sent into divers parts, he saith, Tychicus have I sent to Ephesus. Now if your Majesty shall bee pleased, to cast up into one totall that which is said; the severall journeyes and stations of Timothy, the order of them, the time spent in them, the nature of his imployment, to negotiate the affaires of Christ in severall Churches and places, the silence of the Scriptures, as touching his being Bishop of any one Church, you will acknowledge that such a man was not a Bishop fixed to one Church or precinct, and then by assuming that Timothy was such a man, you wil conclude that he was not Bishop of Ephesus.
The like conclusion may be enforced from the like premisses, from the instance of Titus, whom we find at aJerusalem before he came to Crete, from whence he is sent for to bNicopolis, & after that he is sent to Corinth, from whence he is expected at cTroas, and met with Paul in dMacedonia, whence he is sent again to eCorinth, and after all this is near the time of Pauls death at Rome, from whence he went not into Crete, but unto fDalmatia, and after this is not heard on in the Scripture; and so we hope your Majesty doth conceive, that we affirm not upon very weak proofs, that Timothy and Titus were from Ephesus & Crete removed to other places.
The like conclusion may be inforced from the like premisses, from the instance of Titus, whom we finde at aJerusalem before he came to Crete, from whence hee is sent for to bNicopolis, & after that he is sent to Corinth, from whence he is expected at cTroas, and met with Paul in dMacedonia, whence he is sent againe to eCorinth, and after all this is neere the time of Pauls death at Rome, from whence he went not into Crete, but unto fDalmatia, and after this is not heard on in the Scripture; and so we hope your Majesty doth conceive, that we affirme not upon very weak proofes, that Tymothy and Titus were from Ephesus & Crete removed to other places.
In the fifth exception your Majesty takes notice of two places of Scripture cited by us, to prove that they were called away from those places of Ephesus & Crete, which if they do not conclude much of themselves, yet being accompanied by two other places which your Majesty takes no notice of, may seem to conclude more, and these are 1 Tim. v. 1. 3. Titus 1. 5. As I be sought thee to abide still at Ephesus, for this cause left I thee in Crete, in ⟨p. 23⟩both which is specified the occasional employment, for which they made stay in those places: and the expressions used, I besought thee to abide still at Ephesus, I left thee in Crete, do not sound like words of instalment of a man into a Bishopric, but of an intendment to call them away again, and if the first and last be put together, his actual revocation of them both, the intimation of his intention, that they should not stay there for continuance, and the reason of his beseeching the one to stay, & of his leaving the other behind him, which was some present defects and distempers in those Churches, they will put fair to prove that the Apostle intended not to establish them Bishops of those places, and therefore did not; For the Postscripts, because your Majesty lays no great weight upon them, We shall not be solicitous in producing evidence against them, though they do bear witness in a matter of fact, which in our opinion never was, and in your Majesties Judgement was long before they were borne, and so we conclude this discourse about Timothy and Titus with this observation, that in the same very Epistle of Paul to Timothy, out of which your Majesty hath endeavoured to prove that he was a Bishop, and did exercise Episcopal Government, there is clear evidence both for Presbyters imposing hands, in ordination, and for their Ruling.
In the fifth exception your Majesty takes notice of two places of Scripture cited by us, to prove that they were called away from those places of Ephesus & Crete, which if they doe not conclude much of themselves, yet being accompanied by two other places which your Majesty takes no notice of, may seeme to conclude more, and these are 1 Tim. v. 1. 3. Titus 1. 5
In the next point concerning the Angels of the Churches, though your Majesty saith, that you lay no weight upon the Allegory or Mystery of the denomination, yet you assert, that the persons bearing that name were personae singulars, & in a word Bishops, who yet are never so called in Scripture, & the allegorical denomination of Angels or Stars, which in the Judgement of ancient and modern Writers doth belong to the faithful Ministers and Preachers of the word in general, is appropriate ⟨p. 24⟩(as we may so say) to the Mitre and Crosier staff, and so opposed to many express testimonies of Scripture;And if your Majesty had been particular in that, wherein you say the strength of your instance lies, viz. the Judgement of all ancient, & of the best modern Writers, and many probabilities in the text it self, we hope to have made it apparent, that many ancient & eminent Writers, many probabilities out of the text it self do give evidence to the contrary. To that which is asserted, That these singular persons were Bishops in distinct sense, whether we brought any thing of moment to infirm this we humbly submit to Your Majesties judgement, and shall only represent to you that in Your Reply you have not taken notice of that which in our answer seems to us of moment, which is this, that in Mysterious & prophetic writings or visional representations (such as this of the stars and golden Candlesticks is) a number of things or persons is usually expressed in singulars, and this in visions is the usual way of Representation of things, a thousand persons making up one Church, is represented by one Candlestick; Many Ministers making up one Presbytery by one Angel. And because Your Majesty seems to call upon us to be particular, though we cannot name the Angels, nor are satisfied in our judgement, that those whom some do undertake to name were intended by the name of Angels in those Epistles; yet we say, First, that these Epistles were sent unto the Churches, and that under the expression of this thou dost, or this thou hast, and the like, the Churches are respectively intended, for the sin reproved, the Repentance commanded, the punishments threatened, are to be referred to the Churches and not to the singular Angels only, and yet we do not think that Salmatius did intend, nor do we, that in formal denomination the Angels and Candlesticks are the same;
In the next point concerning the Angels of the Churches, though your Majesty saith, that you lay no weight upon the Allegory or Mystery of the denomination, yet you assert, that the persons bearing that name were personae singulares, & in a word Bishops, who yet are never so called in Scripture, & the allegorical denomination of Angels or Stars, which in the Judgement of ancient and moderne Writers doth belong to the faithfull Ministers and Preachers of the word in generall, is appropriate
Secondly; The Angels of these Churches or Rulers were a Collective body, which we endeavoured to prove by such Probabilities as your Majesty takes no notice of, namely the instance of the Church of Ephesus, where there were many Bishops, to whom the charge of that Church was by Saint Paul at his final departure from them committed; as also by that expression Revel. 2. 24. To you, and to the rest in Thiatyra; Which distinction makes it very probable, that the Angel is explained under that Plurality to you; the like to which many expressions may be found in these Epistles, which to interpret according to the Consentient Evidence of other Scriptures of the New Testament, is not Safe only, but Solid and Evidential.
Secondly; The Angels of these Churches or Rulers were a Collective body, which wee endeavoured to prove by such Probabilities as your Majesty takes no notice of, namely the instance of the Church of Ephesus, where there were many Bishops, to whom the charg of that Church was by Saint Paul at his finall departure from them committed; as also by that expression Revel. 2. 24. To you, and to the rest in Thiatyra; Which distinction makes it very probable, that the Angel is explained under that Plurality to you; the like to which many expressions may be found in these Epistles, which to interpret according to the Consentient Evidence of other Scriptures of the New Testament, is not Safe only, but Solid and Evidentiall.
Thirdly, these Writings are directed as Epistolary, Letters, to Collective Bodies, usually are (that is) to One, but intended to the Body; which your Majesty illustrateth by your sending a Message to your. Two Houses, and directing it to the Speaker of the House of Peers; which as it doth not hinder (we confess) but that the Speaker is one single Person; so it doth not prove at all, that the Speaker is always the same Person; or if he were, that the refore because your Message is directed to him he is the Governor or Ruler of the Two Houses in the least, and so your Majesty hath given clear instance, that though these Letters be directed to the Angels, yet that notwithstanding they might neither be Bishops, not yet perpetual Moderators. For the several opinions specified in your Majesties Paper, three of them, by easy and fair accommodation (as we declared before) are soon reduced and united amongst themselves, and may be holden without ecesse ⟨p. 26⟩from the received Judgement of the Christian Church▪ by such as are far from meriting that Aspersion, which is cast upon the Reformed Divines, by Popish Writers, that they have divided themselves from the Common and received Judgment of the Christian Church; which Imputation, we hope, was not in your Majesties intention to lay upon us, until it be made clear that it is the common and received Judgement of the Christian Church that now is, or of that in former Ages, that the Angels of the Churches were Bishops having Prelacy as well over Pastors as People within their Churches.
Thirdly, these Writings are directed as Epistolary, Letters, to Collective Bodyes, usually are (that is) to One, but intended to the Body; which your Majesty illustrateth by your sending a Message to your. Two Houses, and directing it to the Speaker of the House of Peers; which as it doth not hinder (we confesse) but that the Speaker is one single Person; so it doth not prove at all, that the Speaker is alwayes the same Person; or if he were, that the refore because your Message is directed to him he is the Governour or Ruler of the Two Houses in the least, and so your Majesty hath given cleare instance, that though these Letters be directed to the Angels, yet that notwithstanding they might neither be Bishops, not yet perpetuall Moderators. For the severall opinions specified in your Majesties Paper, three of them, by easie and faire accommodati•n (as wee declared before) are soon reduced and united amongst themselves, and may be holden wihout ecesse
In the following Discourse we did deny, that the Apostles were to have any Successors in their Office, and affirmed only […] Orders of Ordinary and Standing Officers in the Church, vizt. Presbyters and Deacons. Concerning the former of which your Majesty refers to what you had in part already declared: That in those things which were extraordinary in the Apostles, as namely, the Measure of their Gifts, &c. They had no Successors in cundem graedum; but in those things which were not extraordinary, as the Office of Teaching and Power of Governing (which are necessary for the Service of the Church in all times) they were to have and had no Successors: Where your Majesty deli•••s a Doctrine new to us. Namely, that the Apopost•es had Successors into their Offices, not into their […]: For (besides that, Succession is not […] into Abilities▪ but into Office ▪ We cannot say, that one […] another in his […] ▪ o• […], ⟨p. 27⟩or Pats, but into his Room and Function, […] conceive, that the Office Apostolical was […] in whole, because their Mission and […] was •o, and the service or work of▪ Teaching and Governing being to continue in all times doth not render their Office Ordinary; as the Office of Moses was not rendered Ordinary, because many works of Government exercised by him, were re-committed to the standing Elders of Israel: And if they have Successors, it must be, either into their whole Office, or into some parts: Their Successors into the whole (however differing from them in measure of Gifts and peculiar Qualifications) must be called Apostles, the same Office gives the […] Denomination, and then we shall confess that Bishops, if they be their Successors in Office, […] of Divine Institution, because the Apostolical Office him so; if their Successors come into part of their Office only, the Presbyters may as well be called their […] ▪ •• the Bishops, and so indeed they are called by […] of the ancient Fathers, […], Origen, […], and others: Whereas in much the Apostle• […] not properly Successors into Office, but the ordinary Power of Teaching and Governing (which […] the Church for […]) is […] and […] in the hands of ordinary Officers by a […] and Commission according to the rules of […] and calling in the word, […] the Bishop hath […] yet produced for himself, and without which he cannot challenge it upon the […] by the […] without […].
And whereas your […] of their work […] in the Apostles, we could wish that you had declared ⟨p. 28⟩whether it belong to their Mission or Unction; for we humbly conceive, that their Authoritative Power to do their Work in all places of the world did properly belong to their Mission, and consequently that their Office, as well as their Abilities was extraordinary and so by your Majesties own concession not to be succeeded into by the Bishops.
And whereas your 〈…〉 of their work 〈…〉 in the Apostles, we could wish that you had declared ⟨p. 28⟩whether it belong to their Mission or Unction; for we humbly conceive, that their Authorative Power to do their Work in all places of the world did properly belong to their Mission, and consequently that their Office, as wel as their Abilities was extraordinary and so by your Majesties own concession not to be succeded into by the Bishops.
As to the Orders of standing Officers of the Church your Majesty doth reply, That although in the places cited, Phil. 1. 1. 1 Tim. 3. 8. there be no mention but of the two Orders only of Bishops or Presbyters, and Deacons, Yet it is not thereby proved that there is no other standing Office in the Church besides, which we humbly conceive is justly proved, not only because there are no other named, but because there is no rule of Ordaining any third, no Warrant or way of Mission, and so the Argument is as good, as can be made, a non cause ad non effectum; sor we do not yet apprehend that the Bishops pretending to the Apostolic Office do also pretend to the same manner of Mission, nor do we know hat those very many Divines that have asserted two orders only, have concluded it from any other grounds then the Scriptures cited.
As to the Orders of standing Officers of the Church your Majesty doth reply, That although in the places cited, Phil. 1. 1. 1 Tim. 3. 8. there be no mention but of the two Orders only of Bishops or Presbiters, and Deacons, Yet it is not thereby proved that there is no other standing Office in the Church besides, which we humbly conceive is justly proved, not only because there are no other named, but because there is no rule of Ordeyning any third, no Warrant or way of Mission, and so the Argument is as good, as can be made, a non cause ad non effectum; sor we do not yet apprehend that the Bishops pretending to the Apostolick Office do also pretend to the same manner of Mission, nor do we know hat those very many Divines that have afferted two orders onely, have concluded it from any other grounds then the Scriptures cited.
There appears (as your Majesty saith) two other manifest reasons why the Office of Bishops might not be so proper to be mentioned in those places. And we humbly conceive there is a third more manifest then those two, vizt, because, It was not.
There appears (as your Majesty saith) two other manifest reasons why the Office of Bishops might not bee so proper to be mentioned in those places. And wee humbly conceive there is a third more manifest then those two, vizt, because, It was not.
The one reason given by your Majesty, is because in the Churches which the Apostles themselves planted; they placed Presbyters under them for the Office of Teaching, but reserved in their own hands ⟨p. 29⟩the Power of Governing those Churches for a longer, or shorter time before they set Bishops over them. Which under your Majesties favour is not so much a reason why Bishops are not mentioned to be in those places as that they indeed were not; the variety of reasons (may we say or conjectures) rendered why Bishops were not set up at first, as namely because fit men could not be so soon found out, which is Epiphanius his reason, or for remedy of Schism, which is Jeromes reason, or because the Apostles saw it not expedient, which is your Majesties reason doth show that this cause labours under a manifest weakness; for the Apostles reserving in their own hands the power of Governing, we grant it, they could no more devest themselves of power of Governing, then (as Dr. Bilson saith) they could loose their Apostleship: had they set up Bishops in all Churches, they had no more pa•ted with their power of Governing, then they did in setting up the Presbyters, for we have proved that Presbyters, being called Rulers, Governors, Bishops, had the power of Governing in Ordinary, committed to them, as well as the Office of Teaching, and that both the Keys (as they are called) being by our Saviour committed into one hand, were not by the Apostles divided into two: Nor do we see, how the Apostles could, reasonably commit the Government of the Church to the Presbyters of Ephesus, Act. 20, and yet reserve the power of Governing (viz. in Ordinary) in his own hands, who took his solemn leave of them, as never to see their faces more. As that part of the power of Government, which for distinction sa•e may be called Legis-Lative, and which is one of the three fore-mentioned things challenged by the Bishops, viz giving Rules, the reserving of it in the ⟨p. 30⟩Apostles hands hindered not, but that in your Majesties Judgment Timothy and Titus were Bishops of […] and Crete, to whom the Apostles gives Rules for ••• ring and Governing of the Church: Nor is there ••y more reason, that the Apostles reserving that part of the Power of Governing which is called Ecuti in such cases, and upon such occasions as they thought […] should hinder the setting up of Bishops, if they had intended it;
and therefore the reserving of Power in their hands can be no greater reason why they did not set up Bishops at the first, then that they never did. And since (by your Majesties Concession) the Presbyters were placed by the Apostles first, in the Churches by them planted, and that with Power of Governi••, as we prove by Scripture, you must prove the […] of a Bishop over the Presbyters by the Apostles in some after times, or else we must conclude that the Bishop got both his Name and Power of Government out of the Presbyters hand, as the Tree in the ••ll m•ns out the stones by little and little as i• […] grows▪
and therefore the reserving of Power in their hands can be no greater reason why they did not set up Bishops at the first, then that they never did. And since (by your Majesties Concession) the Presbiters were placed by the Apostles first, in the Churches by them planted, and that with Power of Governi••, as wee prove by Scripture, you must prove the 〈…〉 of a Bishop over the Presbyters by the Apostles in some after times, or else we must conclude that the Bishop got both his Name and Power of Government out of the Presbyters hand, as the Tree in the ••ll m•ns out the stones by little and little as i• 〈…〉 grows▪
As touching Philippi, where you Majesty saith, it may be probable there was yet […] Bishop, it is certain there were many, like them, […] at Epheful, to whom if only the Office of Teaching did belong they had the most laborious and honourable part that which was less honourable being reserved in the Apostles hands and the Churches left in the mean time without ordinary Government.
As touching Phillippi, where you Majesty saith, it may be probable there was yet 〈…〉 Bishop, it is certaine there were many, like them, 〈…〉 at Epheful, to whom if only the Office of Teaching did belong they had the most labori•us and honorable part that which was less honorable being reserved in the Apostles hands and the Churches left in the mean time without ordinary Government.
The other reason given why two Orders only a•• mentioned in those places is, because he wrote in the […] to Timothy and Titus to them that were Bishops, •• there was no need to writ any thing concerning the […] Qualification of any other sort of […] ⟨p. 31⟩then such, as belonged to their Ordination, or inspection, which were Presbyters and Deacons only, and no Bishops. The former reason why two only Orders are mentioned in the Epistle to the Philippians, was, because there was yet •• Bishop▪ this latter reason why the same two only are mentioned in these Epistles, is because there was no Bishop i• •• Ordained we might own the reason for good, if there may be found any rule for the Ordination of the other order of Bishops in some other place of Scripture, but if the Ordination cannot be found, how should we find the Order? and it is reasonable to think, that the Apostle in the Chapter formerly alleged, 1 Tim. 3. where he passes immediately from the Bish to the De••on, would have […] expressed, or at least hinted what sort of Bishop he meant whither the Bishop •ver Presbyters, or the Presbyter Bishop, to have avoided the confusion of the name, and to have set as it were some mark of difference in the […] of the Presbyter-Bish. if there had bin some other Bishop of […]. And whereas your Ma•. saith there was no need to writ to them about […] in a distinct sense, who belonged not to their Ordination and inspection▪ We conceive that in your Majesties judgment, Bishops might then have Ordained Bishops like themselves; for there was then no Ca••• forbidding one single Bish to ordain another of his own rank, and there being many Cities in Crete, Titus might have found it expedient (as those ancient Fathers that call him Arch-Bishop think he did) to have set up Bishops in some of those Cities▪ So that this reasoning his against the principles, of those […] to have been Bishops, for our part we believe that Word- belonged unto […] and Titus with […] Churches where they might […] any time
and therefore if there had been any proper Character or Qualification of a Bishop distinct from a Presbyter, if any Ordination or Office, we think the Apostle would have signified it, but because he did not, we conclude (and the more strongly from the insufficiency of your Majesties two reasons) that there are only two Orders of Officers, and consequently that a Bishop is not superior to a Presbyter, for we find not (as we said in our Answer) that one Officer is superior to another, who is of the same Order.
and therefore if there had been any proper Character or Qualification of a Bishop distinct from a Presbyter, if any Ordination or Office, we think the Apostle would have signified it, but because he did not, we conclude (and the more strongly from the insufficiency of your Majesties two reasons) that there are onely two Orders of Officers, and consequently that a Bishop is not superiour to a Presbyter, for we find not (as we said in our Answer) that one Officer is superiour to another, who is of the same Order.
It is confessed that our assertion, that Timothy and Titus were Evangelists, lies with some stresse upon this, that they removed from place to place, as they were sent by or accompanied the Apostles, the proofe whereof appeares to us, to bee of greaten strength then can bee taken off by the comparison which your Majesty makes of the Divines of the Assembly at Westminster. Wee begin with the Travailes of ⟨p. 21⟩Timothy, as we finde them in order recorded in the Scripture-places cited in the Margin, and we set forth from aBerea, where we finde Timothy, then next at bAthens, fromwhence Paul sends him to cThessalonica, afteward having been in Macedonia, he came to Paul at dCorinth, and after that, he is with Paul at Ephesus, and thence sent by him into eMacedonia, whether Paul went after him, and was by Timothy accompanied into fAsia, who was with him at gTroas and hMiletus, to which place Saint Paul sent for the Presbyters of the Church in Ephesus, and gave them that solemne charge to take heede unto themselves, and to all the flock, over which the holy Ghost hath made them Bishops, not speaking a word of recommendation of that Church to Timothy, or of him to the Elders. And if Timothy was Bishop of Ephesus, he must bee so when the first Epistle was sent to him, in which he is pretended to receive the charge of exercising his Episcopall power in Ordination and government; but it is manifest that after this Epistle sent to him, he was in continuall journeyes, or absent from Ephesus. For Paul left him at Ephesus when he went into iMacedonia, and he left him there to exercise his Office, in regulating and ordering that Church and in ordaining; but it was after this time that Timothy is found with Paul at Miletus, for aftur Paul had been at Miletus, he went to Jerusalem, whence he was sent prisoner to Rome, and never came more into Macedonia, and at kRome we find Timothy a prisoner with him, and these Epistles which Paul wrote while he was prisoner at Rome, namely the Epistle to the Philippians, to Philemon, to the Colossians, to the Hebrewes, doe make mention of Timothy as his companion at these times, nor doe we ever finde him againe at Ephesus, for we finde that after all this, towards the end of Saint Pauls life, after his first answering before ⟨p. 22⟩Nero, and when he said his departing was at hand, hee sent for Timothy to Rome, not from Ephesus;
In the following Discourse we did deny, that the Apostles were to have any Successors in their Office, and affirmed onely 〈…〉 Orders of Ordinary and Standing Officers in the Church, vizt. Presbiters and Deacons. Concerning the former of which your Majesty refers to what you had in part already declared: That in those things which were extraordinary in the Apostles, as namely, the Measure of their Gifts, &c. They had no Sucessors in cundem graedum; but in those things which were not extraordinary, as the Office of Teaching and Power of Governing (which are necessary for the Service of the Church in all times) they were to have and had no Successours: Where your Majesty deli•••s a Doctrine new to us. Namely, that the Apopost•es had Successors into their Offices, not into their 〈…〉: For (besides that, Succession is not 〈…〉 into Abiliti•s▪ but into Offic• ▪ We cannot say, that one 〈…〉 another in his 〈…〉 ▪ o• 〈…〉, ⟨p. 27⟩or Patts, but into his Roome and Function, 〈…〉 ••nceive, that the Office Apostolicall was 〈…〉 in whole, because their Mission and 〈…〉 was •o, and the service or work of▪ Teaching and Governing being to continue in all times doth not render their Office Ordinary; as the Office of Moses was not rendred Ordinary, because many workes of Government exercised by him, were re-committed to the standing Elders of Israel: And if they have Successors, it must be, either into their whole Office, or into some parts: Their Successors into the whole (however differing from them in measure of Gifts and peculiar Qualifications) must be called Apostles, the same Office gives the 〈…〉 Denomination, and then we shal confesse that Bishops, if they be their Successors in Office, 〈…〉 of Divine Institution, because the Apostolicall Office him so; if their Successors come into part of their Office only, the Presbiters may as well bee called their 〈…〉 ▪ •• the Bishops, and so indeed they are called by 〈…〉 of the ancient Fathers, 〈…〉, Origen, 〈…〉, and others: Whereas in much the Apostle• 〈…〉 not properly Successors into Office, but the ordin•ry Power of Teaching and Governing (which 〈…〉 the Church for 〈…〉) is 〈…〉 and 〈…〉 in the hands of ordinary Officers by a 〈…〉 and Commission according to the rules of 〈…〉 and calling in the word, 〈…〉 the Bishop hath 〈…〉 yet produced for himselfe, and without which he cannot challenge it upon the 〈…〉 by the 〈…〉 without 〈…〉.
The one reasun given by your Majesty, is because in the Churches which the Appostles themselves planted; they placed Presbiters under them for the Office of Teaching, but reserved in their own hands ⟨p. 29⟩the Power of Governing those Churches for a longer, or shorter time before they set Bishops over them. Which under your Majesties favour is not so much a reason why Bishops are not mentiioned to bee in those places as that they indeed were not; the variety of reasons (may we say or conjectures) rendred why Bishops were not set up at first, as namely because fit men could not be so soon found out, which is Epiphanius his reason, or for remedy of Schisme, which is Jeromes reason, or because the Apostles saw it not expedient, which is your Majesties reason doth shew that this cause labours under a manifest weaknesse; for the Apostles reserving in their own hands the power of Governing, we grant it, they could no more devest themselves of power of Governing, then (as Dr. Bilson saith) they could loose their Apostleship: had they set up Bishops in all Churches, they had no more pa•ted with their power of Governing, then they did in seting up the Presbyters, for we have proved that Presbyters, being called Rulers, Governours, Bishops, had the power of Governing in Ordinary, committed to them, as well as the Office of Teaching, and that both the Keys (as they are called) being by our Saviour comitted into one hand, were not by the Apostles divided into two: Nor do we see, how the Apostles could, reasonably commit the Government of the Church to the Presbyters of Ephesus, Act. 20, and yet reserve the power of Governing (viz. in Ordinary) in his own hands, who took his solemn leave of them, as never to see their faces more. As that part of the power of Government, which for distinction sa•e may be called Legis-Lative, and which is one of the three fore-mentioned things challenged by the Bishops, viz giving Rules, the reserving of it in the ⟨p. 30⟩Apostles hands hindred not, but that in your Majesties Iudgment Timothy and Titus were Bishops of 〈…〉 and Creete, to whom the Apostles gives Rules for ••• ring and Governing of the Church: Nor is there ••y more reason, that the Apostles reserving that part of the Power of Governing which is called E••cuti•• in such cases, and upon such occasions as they thought 〈…〉 should hinder the setting up of Bishops, if they had intended it;
The other reason given why two Orders only a•• mentioned in those places is, because he wrot in the 〈…〉 to Timothy and Titus to them that were Bishops, •• there was no need to writ any thing concerning the 〈…〉 Qualification of any other sort of 〈…〉 ⟨p. 31⟩then such, as belonged to their Ordination, or inspection, which were Presbyters and Deacons only, and no Bishops. The former reason why two only Orders are mentioned in the Epistle to the Philip••ans, was, because there was yet •• Bishop▪ this latter reason why the same two onely are mentioned in these Epistles, is because there was no Bishop i• •• Ordained we might own the reason for good, if there may bee found any rule for the Ordination of the other order of Bishops in some other place of Scripture, but if the Ordination cannot be found, how should we find the Order? and it is reasonable to think, that the Apostle in the Chapter formerly alleadged, 1 Tim. 3. where he passes immediatly from the Bish to the De••on, would have 〈…〉 exprest, or at least hinted what sort of Bishop he meant whither the Bishop •ver Presbyters, or the Presbiter Bishop, to have avoyded the confusion of the name, and to have set as it were some mark of difference in the 〈…〉 of the Presbiter-Bish. if there had bin some other Bishop of 〈…〉. And wheras your Ma•. saith there was no need to writ to them about 〈…〉 in a distinct sence, who belonged not to their Ordination and inspection▪ We conceive that in your Majesties judgment, Bishops might then have Ordeined Bishops like themselves; for there was then no Ca••• forbiding one single Bish to ordain another of his own rank, and ther being many Cities in Creete, Titus might have found it expedient (as those ancient Fathers that call him Arch-Bishop think he did) to have set up Bishops in some of those Cities▪ So that this reasoning his against the principles, of those 〈…〉 to have been Bishops, for our part we beleeve that •Word-• belonged unto 〈…〉 and Titus with 〈…〉 Churches where they might 〈…〉 any time ⟨p. 32⟩have the Office of Ordeyning and Governing, as it is written in the same Chapter, 1 Tim. 3. 14, 15. Those things I have written unto th••, &c. that thou mayest know how to be have thy selfe in the House of God, which is the Church;