N20568:3123
The new and complete book of martyrs; or, An universal history of martyrdom: being Fox's Book of martyrs, revised and corrected, with additions and great improvements. : Containing an authentic account of the lives, persecutions and sufferings of the holy martyrs; and the many dreadful persecutions against the Church of Christ in all parts of the world, by pagans, Jews, Turks, papists, and others, from earliest ages of the church to the present period. ... The whole forming at once a general Christian martyrology, and a complete history of persecutions. / By the Rev. Mr. John Fox, M.A. late of Magdalen College, Oxford. ; Now revised, corrected and improved, with many additional articles, relating to the acts and monuments of the church. By Paul Wright, D.D. ; Embellished with forty elegant copper plate engravings. ; In two volumes. Vol. I[-II].The new and complete book of martyrs; or, An universal history of martyrdom: being Fox's Book of marytrs, revised and corrected, with additions and great improvements. : Containing an authentic account of the lives, persecutions and sufferings of the holy martyrs; and the many dreadful persecutions against the Church of Christ in all parts of the world, by pagans, Jews, Turks, papists, and others, from earliest ages of the church to the present period. ... The whole forming at once a general Christian martyrology, and a complete history of persecutions. / By the Rev. Mr. John Fox, M.A. late of Magdalen College, Oxford. ; Now revised, corrected and improved, with many additional articles, relating to the acts and monuments of the church. By Paul Wright, D.D. ; Embellished with forty elegant copper plate engravings. ; In two volumes. Vol. I[-II].
New-York: printed by William Durell, 1794
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WEST. Because we will not consume and spend the time in waste, this your writing which you exhibit, hereafter shall be read in this place. ⟨p. 314⟩In the mean season let us now fall to the arguments.
CHED. The scriptures in many places do affirm, that Christ gave his natural body, Matth xxvi. Mark xiv. Luke xxii. ERGO, I do conclude that the natural body is in the sacrament.
CRAN. TO your argument I answer: If you understand by the body natural [organicum], that is, having such proportion and members as he had living here, then I answer negatively. FURTHERMORE, concerning the evangelists, this I say and grant, that Christ took bread, and called it his body.
CHED. The text of scripture maketh against you, for the circumstances thereunto annexed doth teach us, not only there to be the body, but also teacheth us what manner of body it is, and saith, The same body which shall be given. THAT thing is here contained, that is given for us. BUT the substance of bread is not given for us. ERGO, The substance of bread is not here contained.
CRAN. I understand not yet what you mean by this word [contained]. If you mean really, then I deny your major.
CHED. The major is the text of scripture. He that denieth the major, denieth the scripture. For the scripture saith, This is my body which is given for you.
CRAN. I grant he said it was his body which should be given, but he said it was not his body which is here contained; but the body (saith he) that shall be given for you. As though he should say, This bread is the breaking of my body, and this cup is the shedding of my blood. What will […] say the•? […] the bread the breaking of his body, and the cup the shedding of his blood really? If you say so, I deny it.
CRAN. I grant he said it was his body which should be given, but he said it was not his body which is here contained; but the body (saith he) that shall be given for you. As though he should say, This bread is the breaking of my body, and this cup is the shedding of my blood. What will 〈…〉 say the•? 〈…〉 the bread the breaking of his body, and the cup the shedding of his blood really? If you say so, I deny it.
CHED. If you ask what is the thing therein contained; because his apostles should not doubt what body it was that should be given, he saith, This is my body which shall be given for you, and my blood which shall be shed for many. ERGO, Here is the same substance of the body, which the day after was given, and the same blood which was shed. And here I urge the scripture, which teacheth that it was no fantastical, no feigned, no spiritual body, nor body in faith, but the substance of the body.
CHED. If you ask what is the thing therein contained; because his apostles should not doubt what body it was that should be given, he saith, This is my body which shall be given for you, and my blood which shall be shed for many. ERGO, Here is the same substance of the body, which the day after was given, and the same blood which was shed. And here I urge the scripture, which teacheth that it was no phantastical, no feigned, no spiritual body, nor body in faith, but the substance of the body.
CRAN. You must prove that it is contained, but Christ said not which is contained. He gave bread, and called that his body. I stick not in the words of scripture, but in your word, which is feigned and imagined by yourself.
CHED. When Christ took bread and brake it, what gave he?
CRAN. He gave bread; the bread sacramentally, and his body spiritually; and the bread there he called his body,
CHED. This answer is against the scripture, which saith, that he gave his body.
CRAN. It did signify that which he did eat.
CHED. They did not eat the body as the Capernaites did understand it, but the self-same body which was given for the sins of the world. Ergo, It was his body which should be given, and his blood which should be shed. IN some other copies (says Mr. Fox) I Find this argument to be made by Chedsey. THE same body is in the sacrament, which was given for us on the cross. BUT bread was not given for us on the cross. ERGO (therefore) bread is not given in the sacrament.
CRAN. I deny the major, which is, that the same natural body is given in the sacrament, which was given on the cross, except you understand it spiritually. And after he denied also the argument as utterly void, as he might well do, the major in the second figure being not universal. WHEN Mr. Chedsey had put forth his argument, and prosecuted the same, and Dr. Cranmer answered as before is showed, Dr. Oglethorpe, one of those doctors which the prolocutor called Censors (who sat as arbiters to order the disputation) said on this wise.
CRAN. I deny the major, which is, that the same natural body is given in the sacrament, which was given on the cross, except you understand it spiritually. And after he denied also the argument as utterly void, as he might well do, the major in the second figure being not universal. WHEN Mr. Chedsey had put forth his argument, and prosecuted the same, and Dr. Cranmer answered as before is shewed, Dr. Oglethorpe, one of those doctors which the prolocutor called Censores (who sat as arbiters to order the disputation) said on this wise.
D. OGLE. You come in still with one evasion or starting hole to flee to. He urgeth the scriptures, saying that Christ gave his very body. You say, that he gave his body in bread. Quomodo praedicatur corpus? qualis est corpus? qualis est praedicatio? panis est corpus.