And where you say that I affirm it to be bred still as Luther doth / the same I say again / not because Luther so saith / but because I can prove my words true by scripture / reason of nature / and doctors. Paul calleth it breed saying:1 the breed which we break / is it not the fellowship of the body of christ? For we though we be many / are yet one body and one breed: as many as are partakers of one breed. And again he sayeth / as often as ye eat of this breed / or drink of this cup / you shall show the lords death until he come.2 Also luke caulleth it breed in the acts saying:3 they continued in the fellowship of the apostles and in breaking of breed / and in prayer.4 Also Christ called the cup / the fruit of vine saying / I shall not from hence forth drink of the fruit of the vine / until I drink that new in the kingdom of my father Furthermore nature doth teach you that both the breed and wine continue in their nature, For the breed moleth if it be kept long / yea and worms breed in it. And the poor mouse will run away with it / and desire no nother meat to her dinner / which are evident enough that there remaineth breed. Also the wine if it were reserved would wax sour as they confess them selves / and therefore they housell the lay people but with one kind only / because the wine can not continue nor be reserved / to have ready at hand when need were. And surely ⟨image 16⟩as if there remained no breed it could not mould nor wax full of worms. Even so if there remained no wine / it could not wax sower / and therefore it is but false doctrine / that our prelates so long have published. Finally that there remaineth bred might be proved by the authority of many doctors / which caul it bred and wine / as Christ and his apostles did. And though some sophisters would wrest their sayings and expound them after their fantasy / yet shall I allege them one doctor (which was also pope of Rome) that maketh so plain with us that they shall be compelled with shame to hold their tongues. For pope Gelasius writeth on this manner. Certe sacramenta que. sumimus corporiset sanguinis thirsty divinae ressun• & propterea per illa, participes facti sumus divinae naturae, & tamen non de•init esse substantia uel panis & uini, sed permanent in suae proprietati naturae.
And wher yow saye that I affyrme yt to be bred styll as Luther doth / the same I say agayne / not because Luther so saythe / but because I can proue my wordes true by scrypture / reason of nature / ād doctours. Paulle calleth yt brede saynge:1 the brede wc we breake / ys yt not the felowship of the bodye of christe? For we though we be manye / are yet one bodye and one brede: as manye as are pertakers of one brede. And agayne he sayeth / asoftyn as ye eate of this brede / or drinke of this cuppe / yow shall shewe the lordes deth vntyll he cōme.2 Allso luke caulleth yt brede in the actes saying:3 they cōtinued in the felowshyp of the apostylles and in breakinge of brede / and in prayer.4 Allso Christe caulyd the cuppe / the frute of vyne sayinge / I shall not frō hence forthe dryncke of the frute of the vyne / vntyll I drynke that newe in the kyngdom of my father Furthermore nature doth teache yow that both the brede and wyne cōtynewe in their nature, For the brede mouleth yf yt be kepte lō ge / ye and wurmes brede in yt. And the poore mouse wyll ronne awaye wt yt / and de•yre no nother meate to herdynner / whiche are euident ynough that there remayneth brede. Allso the wyne yf yt were reseruyd wold wex souer as they confesse them selues / and therfore they housell the laye people but wt one kynde only / because the wyne can not continue nor be reserued / to haue ready at hande when nede were. And surely ⟨image 16⟩as yf ther remayned no brede yt coulde not mould nor wex full of wormes. Euyn so yf ther remayned no wyne / yt coulde not wex sower / and therfore yt ys but faulse doctryne / that our prelates so longe haue puplyshed. Finally that there remaynethe bred might be proued by the auctorite of many doctours / which caule yt bred and wyne / as Christ and his apostels did. And though some sophysters wolde wreast their sayings and expound them after their phantasie / yet shall I allege them one doctour (which was allso pope of Rome) that makyth so playne with vs that they shalbe compelled with shame to holde their tonges. For pope Gelasius wryteth on this maner. Certe sacramenta que. sumimus corporiset sanguinis •hristi diuinae ressun• & propterea per illa, participes facti sumus diuinae naturae, & tamen non de•init esse substantia uel panis & uini, sed permanent in suae proprietati naturae.
- 11 Cor. 10.
- 21. Cor. 11.
- 3Actuū. 2Actuū. 2
- 4Luc. 22.