It will be said, that our consciences are in an error, and therefore ought to be corrected by the sentence of Superiors, whose Authority Sect. II and will doeth bind us to receive and embrace the Ceremonies, though our Consciences do condemn them. Ans. Giving and not granting that our consciences do err in condemning the Ceremonies, yet so long as they can not be otherwise persuaded, the Ceremonies ought not to be urged upon us, for if we be made to do that which our consciences do condemn, we are made to sin. Rom. 14. 23. It is an audacious contempt in zCalvins judgement, to do any thing repugnant conscientia. The learned Casuists teach us, that an erring conscience, though non obligat, yet ligat; though we be not obliged to do that which it prescribeth, yet are we bound not to do that which it condemneth. Quicquid fit repugnant & reclamante conscientia, peccatum est, etiamsi repugnantia ista gravem errorem includat, saith aAlsted. Conscientia erronea obligat, sic intelligendo, quod faciens contra peccet bsaith Hemmingius. This holds ever true of an erring conscience about matters of fact, and especially about things indifferent. If any say, that hereby a necessity of sinning is laid on them, whose Consciences are in an error, I answer, that so long as a man keeps an erroneous conscience, a necessity of sinning lies on him, and that through his own fault. This necessity ariseth from this supposition, that he retain his erring conscience, and so is not absolute, because he should inform his conscience rightly, so that he may both do that which he ought to do, & do it so from the approbation of his conscience. If it be said again, what ⟨p. 17⟩should be done to them, who have not laid down the error of conscience, but do still retain the same? I answer, celigatur id quod tutius & melius est. If therefore the error of conscience be about weighty and necessary matters, then it is better to urge men to the doing of a necessary duty in the service of God, then to permit them to neglect the same, because their erring conscience disapproveth it: for example; It is better to urge a profane man to come and hear Gods Word, then to suffer him to neglect the hearing of the same, because his conscience alloweth him not to hear.
It will be said, that our consciences are in an error, and therefore ought to be corrected by the sentence of Superiours, whose Auctority Sect. II and will doeth binde us to receive and imbrace the Ceremonies, though our Consciences doe condemne them. Ans. Giving and not granting that our consciences doe erre in condemning the Ceremonies, yet so long as they can not be otherwise perswaded, the Ceremonies ought not to be urged upon us, for if we be made to doe that which our consciences doe condemne, wee are made to sinne. Rom. 14. 23. It is an audacious contempt in zCalvines judgement, to doe any thing repugnante conscientia. The learned Casuists teach us, that an erring conscience, though non obligat, yet ligat; though we be not obliged to doe that which it prescribeth, yet are we bound not to doe that which it condemneth. Quicquid fit repugnante & reclamante conscientia, peccatum est, etiamsi repugnantia ista gravem errorem includat, saith aAlsted. Conscientia erronea obligat, sic intelligendo, quod faciens contra peccet bsaith Hemmingius. This holds ever true of an erring conscience about matters of fact, and especially about things indifferent. If any say, that hereby a necessity of sinning is laid on them, whose Consciences are in an error, I answer, that so long as a man keeps an erroneous conscience, a necessity of sinning lies on him, and that through his owne fault. This necessity ariseth from this supposition, that he retaine his erring conscience, and so is not absolute, because he should informe his conscience rightly, so that he may both doe that which he ought to doe, & doe it so from the approbation of his conscience. If it be said again, what ⟨p. 17⟩should be done to them, who have not laid downe the error of conscience, but doe still retaine the same? I answer, celigatur id quod tutius & melius est. If therefore the error of conscience be about weighty and necessary matters, then it is better to urge men to the doing of a necessary duty in the service of God, then to permit them to neglect the same, because their erring conscience disapproveth it: for example; It is better to urge a prophane man to come and heare Gods Word, then to suffer him to neglect the hearing of the same, because his conscience alloweth him not to heare.
- zcome. in Rom. 14. 5.com. in Rom. 14. 5.
- aTheol. cas cap. 2.
- bEnchir. class. 2. cap. 7.
- cBald de consc. cas. lib. 1. cap. 8.