Now whether your fantasy of Transubstantiation be a Dream, or no, by the Constancy, and Certainty thereof, and by the agreement of your Doctors, y• founded it first▪ it may appear. Petrus Lombardus, y• only General of all this Camp,1 hereof useth these speaches: Quibusdam ita Videtur: Quidā dicunt: Quidā tradunt: Quidam concedunt: Alij putaverunt, Substantiam ibi Panis & Vini remanere: Somme men Judge thus: Somme say thus: Somme have written thus: Somme grant this: Somme others have thought thus, that y• very Substance of the Bread, and Wine remaineth still. Here is a strange agreement of Learned men, specially in a case of the Catholic Faith. But hereto what saith Peter Lombard him self, that taketh upon him as a Judge to determine these doubts? How is he resolved? Or how agreeth he in Judgement with him self? His answer is this, Si autem quaeritur, qualis sit illa Conuersio, An Formalis, An Substantialis, An alterius generis, definire non sufficio: If a question were moved, what manner of Conversion, or change this is: Whether it be in Form, or in Substance, or of some other sort, I am not able to discuss it. Here we may see, the blind leadeth the blind. He that ⟨p. 238⟩setteth him self before all the rest, 2and would be taken for a guide, knoweth not where to set his own foots. Gabriel Biel saith, Quomodo sit ibi Corpus Christi, Utrùm per Conuersionem alicuius in ipsum, an sine Conuersine incipiat esse Corpus Christi cum Pane, manentibus Substantia, & Accidentibus Panis, non inuenitur expressum in Canone Bibliae: Howe the Body of Christ is there, whether it be by changing of some thing into it, 3Or Christs Body begin to be there together with the Bread, both the Substance, and the Accidents of the Bread remaining still without changing, it is not found expressed in the Canon of the Bible. I leave Innocentius, Scotus, and sundry others of your Scholastical Doctors, with their doubtful dreams, and guesses to like purpose.
Nowe whether your fantasie of Transubstantiation be a Dreame, or no, by the Constancie, and Certainetie thereof, and by the agréemente of your Doctours, y• founded it firste▪ it maie appeare. Petrus Lombardus, y• onely General of al this Camp,1 herof vseth these speaches: Quibusdam ita Videtur: Quidā dicunt: Quidā tradunt: Quidam concedunt: Alij putauerunt, Substantiam ibi Panis & Vini remanere: Somme menne Iudge thus: Somme saie thus: Somme haue vvritten thus: Somme graunte this: Somme others haue thought thus, that y• very Substance of the Breade, and Wine remaineth stil. Here is a strange agréemente of Learned menne, specially in a case of the Catholique Faith. But hereto what saithe Peter Lombarde him selfe, that taketh vpon him as a Iudge to determine these doubtes? How is he resolued? Or howe agréethe he in Iudgemente with him selfe? His answeare is this, Si autem quaeritur, qualis sit illa Conuersio, An Formalis, An Substantialis, An alterius generis, definire non sufficio: If a question were moued, what manner of Conuersion, or change this is: Whether it be in Fourme, or in Substance, or of somme other sorte, I am not hable to discusse it. Here wée maie sée, the blinde leadeth the blinde. He that ⟨p. 238⟩setteth him selfe before al the reste, 2and woulde be taken for a guide, knoweth not where to sette his owne foots. Gabriel Biel saithe, Quomodo sit ibi Corpus Christi, Vtrùm per Conuersionem alicuius in ipsum, an sine Conuersine incipiat esse Corpus Christi cum Pane, manentibus Substātia, & Accidentibus Panis, non inuenitur expressum in Canone Bibliae: Howe the Body of Christe is there, whether it be by changinge of somme thinge into it, 3Or Christes Body beginne to be there togeather with the Breade, both the Substance, and the Accidentes of the Breade remaininge stil vvithout changinge, it is not founde expreste in the Canon of the Bible. I leaue Innocentius, Scotus, and sundrie others of your Scholastical Doctours, with theire doubteful dreames, and gheasses to like pourpose.
- 1Senten 4. dist. 11. Si autem, &c.
- 2Transubstantiation New, & doubtful.Transubstantiation Nevve, & douteful.
- 3Gabriel. in Canonem, Lect. 40.