But, good sir Defender, what meant you to name the Nominals and Reals? Understand you what they be? If a man should upon the sudden demand of you that question,* perhaps you would be to seeking of an answer. Sir if you be an Oxford man, as I suppose you be, you may remember, if ever you learned your Logic after that trade it was taught in, when we resorted to the Paruis there, what ado was made in daily disputations for exercise of young wits, about Genus and Species, and the rest of the Universals: Whether they were termini Primae, or Secundae intentionis, whether they were entia Realia, or Rationis. Which is a matter pertaining to Logic, not to Divinity. Now some Schoolmen be of the opinion, that the five Universals be termini, or nomina secundae intentionis: And they be called thereof Nominals. Some hold opinion, they are entia realia, and thereof they be named Reals, &c. In the behalf of those Holy Religious men,2 we tell you, ye are to blame to belie them. For what Discipline and order of Life so ever they have addicted them selves unto, for better opportunity to serve God: truth is truth, they put not great Holiness (as ye say) in eating of Fish, nor of Herbs: in Shoes, nor in Sandals: in Linen, nor in Woollen garments: in white, nor in black: in broad, nor in narrow Crowns: in going on Pattens, nor on the bare ground: in girding them selves, nor in being Ungirded. They be not so ignorant, as to put Holiness in such outward things, though their obedience performed in the humble observation of these outward things according to their rule,3 be an Holy thing. These things they use for restraint of their will, and for discipline, according to the order, and rule, under which, the better to serve God, they have promised obediently and humbly to live. Neither put they more holiness in the things by you scoffed at, them Elijah did in his Mantel and leathern girdle, wherewith he girded his loins: then John Baptist did in Eating of Locusts and wild Honey, in wearing a garment of Camels hear, and in girding him self about the loins with a skin.
But, good sir Defender, what meante you to name the Nominals and Reals? Vnderstande you what they be? If a man shoulde vpon the sudda•ne demaunde of you that question,* perhaps you would be to seekinge of an answere. Sir if you be an Oxforde man, as I suppose you be, you maie remember, if euer you learned your Logike after that trade it was taught in, when we resorted to the Paruis there, what adoo was made in daily disputations for exercise of younge wittes, aboute Genus and Species, and the reste of the Vniuersals: VVhether they were termini Primae, or Secundae intentionis, whether they were entia Realia, or Rationis. VVhiche is a matter perteigninge to Logike, not to Diuinitie. Nowe some Schoolemen be of the opinion, that the fiue Vniuersals be termini, or nomina secundae intentionis: And they be called thereof Nominals. Some holde opinion, they are entia realia, and thereof they be named Reals, &c. In the behalfe of those Holy Religious menne,2 we tell you, ye are to blame to belie them. For what Discipline and order of Life so euer they haue addicted them selues vnto, for better oportunitie to serue God: truthe is truthe, they put not greate Holinesse (as ye saie) in eatinge of Fishe, nor of Hearbes: in Shoes, nor in Sandals: in Linnen, nor in VVollen garmentes: in white, nor in blacke: in broade, nor in narrowe Crownes: in goinge on Patens, nor on the bare grounde: in girdinge them selues, nor in beinge Vngirded. They be not so ignorant, as to put Holinesse in suche outwarde thinges, though their obedience performed in the humble obseruation of these outwarde thinges accordinge to their rule,3 be an Holy thinge. These thinges they vse for restrainte of their will, and for discipline, accordinge to the order, and rule, vnder whiche, the better to serue God, they haue promised obediently and humbly to liue. Neither put they more holinesse in the thinges by you scoffed at, them Elias did in his Mantell and letherne girdle, wherewith he girded his loines: then Iohn Baptist did in Eatinge of Locustes and wilde Honie, in wearinge a garmente of Camelles heare, and in girdinge him selfe aboute the loines with a skinne.
- *A great doubtful question. Every poor Logician may easily know it.A greate doubteful question. Euery poore Logician maie easily knovve it.
- 2The Catholic Religious men put no holiness in outward observances.The Catholike Religious men put no holinesse in outvvarde obseruāces.
- 3To what end be those observances of the Religious. Elijah.To vvhat ende be those obseruances of the Religious. Elias.