The second sophism, of the cause of sin.The second sophisme, of the cause of sinne.
pp. 409–41511 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The second sophism, of the cause of sin.
The second sophisme, of the cause of sinne.
1 Objection. All the actions and motions of all creatures are done by the will and working of God. Many actions (as the selling of Joseph, the Assyrians warring against the Jews) are sins. Therefore sins are done by the will and working of god. 1Answer. There is a fallacy of the accident in the Minor proposition. Actions are sins, not in themselves, and as they are actions, but by an accident, by reason of the corruption of the instrument, in those actions, which God worketh most justly by him, he not respecting this, as to obey therein the known will of God. This corruption or defect of the creature, & the action, which god worketh by the creature concur together by an accident. For neither is essential to other, neither the cause of other, but each is to other accidentary. For both god could have wrought that selfsame punishment, which he inflicted justly on the Jews by the Assyrian sinning, by an instrument not sinning: and the Assyrian, if it had pleased god to correct his will, might have been notwithstanding the instrument of gods wrath, and yet good, how great soever severity he had exercised toward the Jews: As when GOD by his good Angel slayeth the wicked host of the Assyrians. Sin therefore, which is in the actions of the creature, is not done by the will and working of GOD, but by an accident, to wit, as God will and worketh those actions, which are sins by the fault of the creature. The sum of all cometh to this: The most good action of GOD exercised by an evil and corrupt instrument, is no otherwise the sin of the bad instrument, than water which cometh pure out of the fountain, is made impure, running thorough unclean places: or the best wine coming out of a good vessel waxeth sour and eager, being put in a corrupt vessel, according to that of Horace, Lib. 1 Epist. 2. Unless the vessel be pure, whatsoever thou pourest in, soureth: or further than the good work of a good judge is the evil work of an evil servant or minister: or the riding of a good horse man is the halting of a lame horse. In all these is a Paralogism or fallacy of the accident, that is, there is a proceeding from the essence or thing it self, to that, which is but an accident to the thing, and doth but by an accident concur with