2 Object.1 He that is exceeding merciful doth not punish all sin with exceeding and extreme punishment, neither is to all eternity angry with sin, or looketh upon the torments of his own work. For extreme justice, which doth strictly follow right and law in punishing, admitteth no favourable equity, which yet mercy, especially exceeding mercy, doth use and show. But God is exceeding merciful. Therefore he doth not punish all sin with exceeding, that is, everlasting punishment. Or, God punisheth all sin with extreme punishment, Therefore he is not merciful. Auns. First we are to distinguish the ambiguity of the Major. He that is exceeding merciful doth not inflict exceeding and extreme punishment, that is, except his justice require it. But that God should punish all sin with everlasting punishment, his exceeding justice requireth, which is,2 earnestly and exceedingly to hate and punish all whatsoever is not agreeable to his Law: So that except he did punish it with sufficient punishment, he should not be merciful, but light and cruel. Secondly, we deny the consequence of the reason: because it is a sophism reasoning from that which is not the cause, as being the cause. For the judge is not therefore unmerciful, for that he executeth a robber on the wheel: because he doth it according, to justice, neither is delighted with the torment and death of a wretched man, but had rather he were saved, if so the Laws permitted. Right so, God, according to his infinite wisdom, even in inflicting extreme punishment on all sin, doth notwithstanding show immeasurable and manifold mercy, and contrariwise in showing exceeding mercy doth most straitly and exactly execute his justice. For 1. He punisheth our sins sufficiently and fully, not in us, but in his only begotten son, our guilt being translated on him. 2. He offereth remission of sins and grace to all men, who receive his Son the Mediator with true faith and conversion. 3. He worketh also that faith and conversion by his spirit in the Elect. 4. He preserveth his elect in afflictions. 5. At length he fully delivereth them: And all these things he doth of his free mercy, not bound or obliged thereto by any merit of ours. 6. He is not delighted with the destruction of the reprobate, who refuse that grace offered:
2 Obiect.1 Hee that is exceeding merciful doth not punish all sinne with exceeding and extreme punishment, neither is to al eternitie angrie with sinne, or looketh vpon the torments of his owne woorke. For extreme iustice, which doth strictly follow right and lawe in punishing, admitteth no fauourable equity, which yet mercie, especially exceeding mercy, doth vse and shewe. But God is exceeding mercifull. Therefore hee doth not punish all sinne with exceeding, that is, euerlasting punishment. Or, God punisheth all sinne with extreme punishment, Therefore hee is not mercifull. Auns. First wee are to distinguish the ambiguitie of the Maior. Hee that is exceeding mercifull doth not inflict exceeding and extreme punishment, that is, except his iustice require it. But that God should punish all sinne with euerlasting punishment, his exceeding iustice requireth, which is,2 earnestly and exceedingly to hate and punish all whatsoeuer is not agreeable to his Lawe: So that except hee did punish it with sufficient punishment, hee should not bee mercifull, but light and cruell. Secondly, wee deny the consequence of the reason: because it is a sophisme reasoning from that which is not the cause, as beeing the cause. For the iudge is not therefore vnmercifull, for that hee executeth a robber on the wheel: because he doth it according, to iustice, neither is delighted with the torment and death of a wretched man, but had rather he were saued, if so the Lawes permitted. Right so, God, according to his infinit wisedome, euen in inflicting extreme punishment on all sinne, doth notwithstanding shewe immeasurable and manifould mercy, and contrariwise in shewing exceeding mercy doth most straitly and exactly execute his iustice. For 1. He punisheth our sinnes sufficiently and fullie, not in vs, but in his onely begotten sonne, our guilt being translated on him. 2. He offereth remission of sinnes and grace to al men, who receiue his Son the Mediator with true faith and conuersion. 3. Hee woorketh also that faith and conuersion by his spirit in the Elect. 4. Hee preserueth his elect in afflictions. 5. At length he fully deliuereth them: And all these things hee doth of his free mercy, not bound or obliged thereto by any merite of ours. 6. He is not delighted with the destruction of the reprobate, who refuse that grace offered:
- 1Gods great mercy & his justice neither impeached by other in punishing sin with eternal punishment.Gods great mercy & his iustice neither impeached by other in punishing sin with eternal punishment.
- 2Psal. 5.5.