Objection. But the Accidents of bread and wine, do still remain, as whiteness, softness, and such like. Answer. But so will there not be a proportion between the sign, and the thing signified, because accidents do not nourish. You can not say, as the accidents of bread and wine nourish the body, so the body of Christ nourisheth my soul unto everlasting life And further also, the promise of God would by this means be made void and frustrate. For God promised that he would give the Messiah, not of the substance of wheat and wine, but of the seed of David, Reply. But we say not that the bread and wine are converted into the substance of Christs body, but that the substance of the bread and wine vanisheth quite away, & in place thereof succeedeth the substance of the body and blood of Christ. Answer. Of this bread christ speaketh, That it is his body, and the same bread both before, and in, and after the administration of it, is called bread. Christ saith not, this which is under the form of bread, is my body: but he saith, this, that is, this bread, is my body. And Paul saith, The bread which we break, is the communion of the body of Christ: And again, For we that are many, are one bread and one body. Again, As often as ye shall eat this bread &c. And a little after, Whosoever shall eat this bread unworthily, &c. Moreover; Let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of this bread. Wherefore it is plain and evident that the substance of bread and wine neither is changed, neither perisheth, neither lieth hid under a form, but remaineth still the same bread and the same wine.
O•iection. But the Accidents of bread and wine, doe still remaine, as whitenesse, softnesse, and such like. Aunswere. But so wil there not bee a proportion betweene the signe, and the thing signified, because accidents doe not nourish. You can not say, as the accidents of bread and wine nourish the body, so the body of Christ nourisheth my soule vnto euerlasting life And further also, the promise of God would by this meanes be made voide and frustrate. For God promised that hee would giue the Messias, not of the substaunce of wheat and wine, but of the seede of Dauid, Reply. But we saie not that the bread and wine are conuerted into the substaunce of Christs bodie, but that the substaunce of the bread and wine vanisheth quite awaie, & in place thereof succeedeth the substance of the bodie and bloud of Christ. Aunswere. Of this bread christ speaketh, That it is his body, and the same bread both before, and in, and after the administration of it, is called bread. Christ saith not, this which is vnder the forme of bread, is my body: but he saith, this, that is, this bread, is my bodie. And Paul saith, The bread whith we breake, is the communion of the bodie of Christ: And againe, For we that are many, are one breade and one body. Againe, As often as yee shall eate this bread &c. And a little after, Whosoeuer shal eate this bread vnworthilie, &c. Moreouer; Let a man examine himselfe, and so let him eate of this bread. Wherefore it is plaine and euident that the substaunce of bread and wine neither is changed, neither perisheth, neither lieth hid vnder a forme, but remaineth stil the same bread and the same wine.