Reply. Satisfaction is perfect obedience: we are not bound to satisfaction: Therefore neither are we bound to perfect obedience, no not in the life to come. For, whom another hath satisfied for, he himself is not enforced to satisfy. But the obedience of Christ is not a full satisfaction for our sins. Therefore the former consequence is true. Answer. There is yet more concluded than the premisses would afford: For this should follow, that obedience is never at any time to be performed of us, as thereby to satisfy for our sins already committed, or which shall be committed until the end of our life. But it followeth not hereof, that we must not be perfect in the life to come. For then also we shall be bound to perfect obedience; we shall be like unto the Angels, and our work shall ⟨p. 836⟩be perfectly good; although that perfect obedience, then due, neither shall, nor can be a satisfaction, or ransom for our sins, to wit, for that obedience which we omitted in this life, and yet was due to be performed of us. For he that oweth twenty florins, doth not pay his debt if he repay ten florins. Wherefore the Major proposition hath a double meaning, and is true, if it be taken in this sense: whom an other hath satisfied for, he himself is not bound to satisfy, to wit, for those things, for which satisfaction was made before. So we are not bound to satisfy for our sins, which we now commit. For Christ hath fully & perfectly satisfied his Father for all our sins, and hath performed perfect obedience unto the Law in our behalf, which otherwise we should have performed in this life unto the law, and which we in this life omit, and are no way able to perform. Now for this end hath Christ satisfied for us, and redeemed us by his blood, that at length we might in the life to come cease from sin, and perform that obedience unto him, which then we are to perform. Neither doth it for all this hereof follow, that God requireth a double obedience or satisfaction of us. For God exacteth obedience hence-forward of us, as thereby to show our thankfulness, and not to satisfy for those sins which we commit in this life. For we are never able to satisfy by that obedience, which we owe, for that obedience, which we do not perform:
Reply. Satisfaction is perfect obedience: we are not bound to satisfaction: Therefore neither are we bound to perfect obedience, no not in the life to come. For, whō another hath satisfied for, he himselfe is not enforced to satisfie. But the obedience of Christ is not a ful satisfaction for our sinnes. Therefore the fomer consequence is true. Aunswere. There is yet more concluded than the premisses would afford: For this should followe, that obedience is neuer at any time to bee performed of vs, as thereby to satisfie for our sins already cōmitted, or which shall be committed vntill the end of our life. But it followeth not hereof, that wee must not bee perfect in the life to come. For then also wee shall bee bound to perfect obedience; we shall be like vnto the Angels, and our worke shall ⟨p. 836⟩be perfectly good; although that perfect obedience, then due, neither shall, nor can be a satisfaction, or ransome for our sinnes, to wit, for that obedience which we omitted in this life, and yet was due to be performed of vs. For he that oweth twenty florens, doth not pay his debt if he repay ten florens. Wherefore the Maior proposition hath a double meaning, and is true, if it be taken in this sense: whom an other hath satisfied for, hee himselfe is not bound to satisfie, to wit, for those thinges, for which satisfaction was made before. So we are not bound to satisfie for our sinnes, which we now commit. For Christ hath fully & perfectly satisfied his Father for all our sinnes, and hath performed perfect obedience vnto the Lawe in our behalfe, which otherwise wee shoulde haue performed in this life vnto the lawe, and which we in this life omit, and are no way able to perfourme. Now for this end hath Christ satisfied for vs, and redeemed vs by his bloud, that at length we might in the life to come cease from sinne, and performe that obedience vnto him, which then we are to performe. Neither dooth it for all this hereof followe, that God requireth a double obedience or satisfaction of vs. For God excteth obedience hence-forward of vs, as thereby to shewe our thankefulnesse, and not to satisfie for those sins which we commit in this life. For wee are neuer able to satisfie by that obedience, which we owe, for that obedience, which we doe not performe: