For Irenaeus most plainly pronounceth, touching that, over which thanks are given, that both it is bread, and also the body of Christ; for in that thanks are given, it noteth the time past, and nevertheless he calleth it bread as yet. Again, you pass in silence that similitude, which I most of all urged: As bread, having received a calling from the earth, is no more common bread, but is become the Eucharist, consisting of two things, earthly and heavenly; so likewise our bodies, receiving the Eucharist, are no more corruptible. And I concluded; that such a change of the bread there is in the sacrament, as there is of our bodies. Here you say nothing.
1Gregory was objected in Registro, who saith; While we receive as well the sweet bread as the leavened bread, we are made one body of the Lord. You answer, that he meant nothing else but that the sacrament may be made as well of sweet bread as of leavened bread, & not that he meant bread to remain. And here likewise you run to the accustomed shift of bread before consecration. Howbeit Gregory's words forbid you so to do; for he saith: While we receive as well sweet bread, as leavened bread. And the verb of the present tense doth plainly betoken, that we in the communion do receive either sweet bread, or leavened bread; and in truth we receive not the sacrament, but after consecration. 2The words of Epiphanius, whereof I argued, you thought good to recite all at full length, the which are on this wise; He rose up in the supper, and when he had given thanks, he said: This is mine, and this, and this. And we see that it is not of equality nor alike, neither to the image of the flesh, nor to the invisible Godhead, nor yet to the lineaments of the parts of his body: for this is of a round form, & insensible as touching power; and yet he would of his grace, say; This is mine, and this, and this; and every man doth believe it, &c. This do you interpret, that that which is of a round figure, is insensible; and you infer, that by these words it may be understood, that whosoever doth not believe, that there is the true body of Christ, falleth away from grace and salvation. My argument was brought in, that the body of Christ was by the Lord spoken concerning the bread, the which my adversary denied: for he said; It was absurd, either for the bread or the accidents to be called the body of Christ.
For Irenaeus most plainlie pronounceth, touching that, ouer which thanks are giuen, that both it is bread, and also the bodie of Christ; for in that thanks are giuen, it noteth the time past, and neuerthelesse he calleth it bread as yet. Againe, you passe in silence that similitude, which I most of all vrged: As bread, hauing receiued a calling from the earth, is no more common bread, but is become the Eucharist, consisting of two things, earthlie and heauenlie; so likewise our bodies, receiuing the Eucharist, are no more corruptible. And I concluded; that such a change of the bread there is in the sacrament, as there is of our bodies. Here you saie nothing.
1Gregorie was obiected in Registro, who saith; While we receiue as well the swéet bread as the leuened bread, we are made one bodie of the Lord. You answer, that he ment nothing else but that the sacrament may be made as well of swéet bread as of leuened bread, & not that he ment bread to remaine. And héere likewise you run to the accustomed shift of bread before consecration. Howbeit Gregories words forbid you so to doo; for he saith: While we receiue as well swéet bread, as leuened bread. And the verbe of the present tense dooth plainelie betoken, that we in the communion doo receiue either swéet bread, or leuened bread; and in truth we receiue not the sacrament, but after consecration. 2The words of Epiphanius, whereof I argued, you thought good to recite all at full length, the which are on this wise; He rose vp in the supper, and when he had giuen thanks, he said: This is mine, and this, and this. And we sée that it is not of equalitie nor alike, neither to the image of the flesh, nor to the inuisible Godhead, nor yet to the lineaments of the parts of his bodie: for this is of a round forme, & insensible as touching power; and yet he would of his grace, saie; This is mine, and this, and this; and euerie man dooth beléeue it, &c. This doo you interpret, that that which is of a round figure, is insensible; and you infer, that by these words it may be vnderstood, that whosoeuer dooth not beléeue, that there is the true bodie of Christ, falleth awaie from grace and saluation. My argument was brought in, that the bodie of Christ was by the Lord spoken concerning the bread, the which my aduersarie denied: for he said; It was absurd, either for the bread or the accidents to be called the bodie of Christ.
- 1To Gregory in Registro.To Gregorie in Registro.
- 2Epiphanius