The disputation of the first day, which was the xxviij. of Maie, Anno Domini. 1549. between D. Peter Martyr, and D. William Tresham, before the kings visitors, among whom the worthy man D. Cox, Chancellor of the University of Oxford, before the disputation should begin, spake on this wise.The disputation of the first daie, which was the xxviij. of Maie, Anno Domini. 1549. betweene D. Peter Martyr, and D. VVilliam Tresham, before the kings visitors, among whom the worthie man D. Cox, Chancellor of the Vniuersitie of Oxford, before the disputation should begin, spake on this wise.
pp. 175–193143 passagespart 4 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Let us contrive the matter into the form of an argument; Whatsoever is in many places at once, the same is God; The body of Christ is not God, but a creature; Therefore the body of Christ is not in many places at once.
Let vs contriue the matter into the forme of an argument; Whatsoeuer is in manie places at once, the same is God; The bodie of Christ is not God, but a creature; Therefore the bodie of Christ is not in manie places at once.
D. Tresham. I did not affirm that the body of Christ is every-where, although it may be in divers places at once. And albeit that the body of Christ assumed be not GOD, yet is Christ, God. And as touching Basil, Didymus, and Augustine, they speak only of that, which of his own proper nature is every-where, or in many places at once; and that they prove to be God: but yet do they never abridge the power of God, but that another thing than God may by his power be in divers places at one time.
D. Tresham. I did not affirme that the bodie of Christ is euerie-where, although it may be in diuers places at once. And albeit that the bodie of Christ assumpted be not GOD, yet is Christ, God. And as touching Basil, Didymus, and Augustine, they speake onelie of that, which of his owne proper nature is euerie-where, or in manie places at once; and that they prooue to be God: but yet doo they neuer abridge the power of God, but that another thing than God may by his power be in diuers places at one time.
D. Martyr. When it is avouched that it can be together in many places, by the like reason it is appointed to be everywhere. And whereas you say, that these fathers do speak of that, which in his own proper nature may be in many places, and do name such a thing to be God; and yet that they deny not, but that any thing, which is created, may by the power of God be in many places at once: it is not true. But this rather overthroweth their argument concerning the holy Ghost. For if the holy Ghost have been in many places at once, the heretic will say; This was by the power of God, not by his own proper nature. And so by this reason it should not be proved, that he is a thing not created. And therefore, for the proof of this matter, it behooved them to understand absolutely, that whatsoever is in many places at one time, is God.