5 And first let us see, whether the predestination of God touching David, were the cause why Saul was cast out of the kingdom. It seems to me that there were two causes of that casting out; one, the provoking of God, to wit, the sin of Saul; and the other was the will of God, but provoked & stirred up by sin: to which of these causes therefore shall we rather ascribe the casting out? Certainly, unto sin: for it was meet that he which had behaved himself ill, should be removed from his place. Therefore Oseas saith; Of the ô Israel cometh thy evil. Indeed we cannot deny, but that the will of God was after some manner the cause; but the true and certain cause was sin. Also another, no small difference it shall be, if we compare our sins unto the punishments, and our good works unto the reward: 1for our sins deserve punishment, but good works deserve no reward, Why so wilt thou say? Because there is a proportion between sin & punishment; but between good works and reward, there is none: for The passions of this life are not worthy of the glory to come, which shall be revealed unto us. Moreover, ill works are properly of our selves; but good works are not but of God. Wherefore eternal death may be called the reward of sin; but contrariwise, eternal life cannot be called the reward of our righteousness. So that we say, that the sin of Saul was the true cause why he fell from the kingdom; but his good works could never have been a cause for him to have continued. But whether did this counsel and decree lay a necessity upon Saul? Hereof there was no absolute necessity in him: for as touching the inward original of sinning, that had Saul in himself: and that which he did, he did it willingly, and of his own accord. Indeed God decreed the kingdom unto David, and to the tribe of Judah; but yet so, as the same should be first taken from him justly. And if God fore-saw that David should be king, he also fore-saw the sin of Saul: wherefore he saw the one thing and the other, both that the one should sin, and the other should reign: in this order there is no sin committed by God.
5 And first let vs sée, whether the predestination of God touching Dauid, were the cause why Saule was cast out of the kingdome. It séemes to me that there were two causes of that casting out; one, the prouoking of God, to wit, the sinne of Saule; and the other was the will of God, but prouoked & stirred vp by sinne: to which of these causes therefore shall we rather ascribe the casting out? Certeinlie, vnto sinne: for it was méet that he which had behaued himselfe ill, should be remooued from his place. Therefore Oseas saith; Of the ô Israel commeth thy euill. Indéed we cannot denie, but that the will of God was after some maner the cause; but the true and certeine cause was sin. Also another, no small difference it shall be, if we compare our sinnes vnto the punishments, and our good works vnto the reward: 1for our sinnes deserue punishment, but good works deserue no reward, Why so wilt thou saie? Bicause there is a proportion betwéene sin & punishment; but betwéene good works and reward, there is none: for The passions of this life are not woorthie of the glorie to come, which shall be reuealed vnto vs. Moreouer, ill works are properlie of our selues; but good works are not but of God. Wherefore eternall death may be called the reward of sinne; but contrariwise, eternall life cannot be called the reward of our righteousnes. So that we saie, that the sinne of Saule was the true cause why he fell from the kingdome; but his good works could neuer haue béene a cause for him to haue continued. But whether did this counsell and decrée laie a necessitie vpon Saule? Hereof there was no absolute necessitie in him: for as touching the inward originall of sinning, that had Saule in himselfe: and that which he did, he did it willinglie, and of his owne accord. Indéed God decréed the kingdome vnto Dauid, and to the tribe of Iuda; but yet so, as the same should be first taken from him iustlie. And if God fore-sawe that Dauid should be king, he also fore-sawe the sinne of Saule: wherefore he sawe the one thing and the other, both that the one should sinne, and the other should reigne: in this order there is no sinne committed by God.
- 1That sins deserve pu•shment, […] good […] no […] Rom. • 18.That sinnes deserue pu•shment, 〈…〉 good 〈…〉 no 〈…〉 Rom. • 18.