THE CONFESSION of HIEROME ZANCHIVS touching the perseverance of the Saints in faith.THE CONFESSION of HIEROME ZANCHIVS touching the perseuerance of the Saints in faith.
pp. 79–303247 passagespart 3 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Neither in very deed is this […] controversy, whether the Elect and Saints do sin, only while they feel the flames of Concupiscence, ⟨p. 143⟩which to be incident to all the Saints while they remain in •his mortal flesh, none doth doubt of; or whether even sometime they fall by some consent into divers sins, and those most grievous, being committed as well against the first as second Table. For we all do know that David and Peter did commit most notorious crimes, the one against the second, the other against the first table, and that by consent and voluntarily, but yet, as hereafter I will declare, not by plenary consent. This is the error of c•rtaine Anabaptists and Libertines who affirm, That although they do likewise feel the affections of the flesh, yet they never so consent thereunto, as that they truly and properly do sin.
Neither in very deed is this 〈…〉 controuersie, whether the Elect and Saints doe sinne, onely while they feele the flames of Concupiscence, ⟨p. 143⟩which to be incident to all the Saints while they remaine in •his mortall flesh, none doth doubt of; or whether euen sometime they fall by some consent into diuers sinnes, and those most greeuous, being committed as well against the first as second Table. For we all do know that Dauid and Peter did commit most notorious crimes, the one against the second, the other against the first table, and that by consent and voluntarily, but yet, as heereafter I wil declare, not by plenary consent. This is the error of c•rtaine Anab•ptists and Libertines who affirme, That although they do likewise feele the affections of the flesh, yet they neuer so consent therevnto, as that they truely and properly do sinne.
Neither also is this the controversy, whether the Saints sinning in this manner, that is, with consent, do displease God, and provoke hi wrath against them. For all godly men do grant, that God is offended
•
⟨p. 143⟩
with all mens sins as well Godly as ungodly, and that God displeasure is provoked against […] sinners, whether godly or ungodly as well the Elect as Reprobate, […] none is ignorant what is pronounced from God by the Prophet, […] of the sons of God, Psal. 88. […] if my children for sake my l••, I […] zit their iniquities with the r•d, Li•• wise those most grievous […] wherewith we do read, in […] Scriptures that the Godly have […] punished for their sins, and we every day do see them punished, […] make proof that God is offended with all, and the sins of all, […] the Scriptures speak, provoked to […].
Neither also is this the controuersie, whether the Saints sinning in this manner, that is, with consent, do disple•se God, and prouoke hi• wrath against them. For all godly men do grant, that God is offended ⟨p. 143⟩with all mens sinnes as well Godly as vngodly, and that God displeasure is prouoked against 〈…〉 sinners, whether godly or vngodly as well the Elect as Reprobate, 〈…〉 none is ignorant what is pronounced from God by the Prophet, 〈…〉 of the sonnes of God, Psal. 88. 〈…〉 if my children for sake my l••, I 〈…〉 zit their iniquities with the r•d, Li•• wise those most greeuous 〈…〉 wherewith wee doe read, in 〈…〉 Scriptures that the Godly haue 〈…〉 punisht for their sinnes, and we euery day doe see them punished, 〈…〉 make proofe that God is offe•ded with all, and the sinnes of all, 〈…〉 the Scriptures speake, prouoked to 〈…〉.
And from hence also it is m••ifest, that it is without controvers••• whether the Saints by those […] in some sort are become the e•• mies of God, and fallen from th•• grace of God; that is, in that […] as sons are said to be […] from the fa••ur of their […] ⟨p. 145⟩children when they displease their […] •nd do now in cense them […]; are said after a manner to […] of the […] of their […] in this respect, that is •• say) That although they have […] cast of• their fatherly affection […] and their children▪ neither yet […] th•i• resolution of o•••ining ••d declaring them to be the heirs […] their good•▪ yet taking offence •• the sinne• of their children, they […] turn their fatherly cockerings (in […]) in•• […] severity, and […] effect of love into such […] as […] utterly ha•••ull▪ for […] bitterly ••full▪ and be •old […] with […] them […], and as […] they do most […] •ear […] only excepted that they […] life away. […] were […] in very deed […] and quite […] their […] of God […] •a•d ⟨p. 146⟩to be made by their sins […] of God, and to be […] from the grace of God▪••• […] God, though ••• do neu•• […] his fatherlike affection […] them, o• change his purpose of […] •nto the• by Christ […] life, yet being displ••s•d with […] sinn•• the effects of his lo•• […] change into the effects of a […] hat••d; hat•ed I say […] agai••• […] children▪ b•t hi• […] both internally in […] […] externally, of such is do […] •• wardly while he do•• bring •o […] that they feel a […] them, God to be angry […] them, and themselves made […] of death▪ outwardly again▪ […] he worketh so that they have •••• rience of God• […] against […] in the […] of […] pody and things […] T•••• fore, hereof there i• […] for that both I •y s•l•• […] both▪ know and […] • that […] when his Saints do sin, […] ⟨p. 147⟩angry with their sins, and doth hate sin in them, and punish them most extremely, and yet not •s enemy to the Saints. For he always doth correct them as a father, but as an enemy of wickedness and vice even in his children;
And from hence also it is m••ifest, that it is without controuers••• whether the Saints by those 〈…〉 in some sort are become the e•• mies of God, and fallen from th•• grace of God; that is, in that 〈…〉 as sonnes are said to be 〈…〉 from the fa••ur of their 〈…〉⟨p. 145⟩children when they disple•se their 〈…〉•nd doe now in cense them 〈…〉; are said after a manner to 〈…〉 of the 〈…〉 of their 〈…〉 in this respect, that is •• say) That although they haue 〈…〉 cast of• their fatherly affection 〈…〉 and their children▪ neither yet 〈…〉 th•i• r•solution of o•••ining ••d declaring them to be the heires 〈…〉 their good•▪ yet taking offence •• the sinne• of their children, they 〈…〉 turne their fathe•ly cockerings (in 〈…〉) in••〈…〉 seuerity, and effect of loue into such as vtterly haull for bitterly full and be old with them , and as they doe most ear onely excepted that they life away. were in very deed and quite their of God ad
and therefore in a sort, as before I have explained it may be said that the children are fallen from their fathers favour, although he yet neither ceaseth to be a father unto them, neither do they cease to be his children, and therefore never utterly can it be truly said that they are fallen from their fathers grace▪ which might very truly be said▪ if either he should cease to be a father unto them, and •ast off hi• fatherly affection towards them, […] alter his decree of making them▪ heirs of life eternal; and that they should cease to be his children, and loose all title to eternal life▪ which without blasphemy cannot be spoken.
and therefore in a sort, as before I haue explaned it may be said that the children are fallen from their fathers fauour, although he yet neither ceaseth to be a father vnto them, neither do they cease to be his children, and therefore neuer vtte•ly can it bee truely said that they are fallen from their fathers grace▪ which might very truely be said▪ if either hee should cease to be a father vnto them, and •ast off hi• fatherly affection towards th•m, 〈…〉 alter his decree of making them▪ heires of life eternall; and that they should cease to be his children, and loose all title to eternall life▪ which without blasphemy cannot be spoken.
Neither yet is the doubt whether the Saints, by those their sins, as ⟨p. 148⟩much as in them lieth, ••• […] the sentence of God touching everlasting death, and whether they […] made guilty of death eternal […] there is none but knoweth the s•• tense of the just Judge, Cursed ••• very one that doth not continue i• […] things that are written •• this […] do them; therefore all whosoeu•• they be, who do violate the […] of the Lord in their own […] ▪ and as much as lieth in them, […] accursed and liable to death […]. But the case is altered, wheth•• these sins are imputed▪ by God unto the Saints unto condemnd […] on, Paul, Rom. 8. doth give his v•• dict in this manner; There is ••••• damnation to them which ••• is Christ Jesus, which walks not •fter th• […] but after the Spirit▪ for such ••• the Saints▪ whereof I speak in▪ this Question.
Neither yet is the doubt whether the Saints, by those their sinnes, as ⟨p. 148⟩much as in them lieth, •••〈…〉 the sentence of God touching euerlasting death, and whethe• they 〈…〉 made guiltie of death aeternall 〈…〉 there is none but knoweth the s•• tence of the iust Iudge, Cursed ••• uery one that doth not continue i•〈…〉 things that are written •• this 〈…〉 doe them; therefore all whosoeu•• they be, who doe violate the 〈…〉 of the Lord in their owne 〈…〉▪ and as much as lieth in them, 〈…〉 accursed and liable to death 〈…〉. But the case is altered, wheth•• these sinnes are imputed▪ by God vnto the Saints vnto condemnd 〈…〉 on, Paul, Rom. 8. doth giue his v•• dict in this manner; There is ••••• demnation to them which ••• is Christ Iesus, which w•lks not •fter th•〈…〉 but aft•r the Spirit▪ for such ••• the Saints▪ whereof I speake in▪ this Question.
Wherefore it also▪ is not in Question, whether▪ the Saints by thes• their sins do so displease God their father, and so provoke his […] ⟨p. 149⟩ger against them, and so incur the sentence of eternal death, as that they have need of repentance, and a new act of faith, for their reconciliation to God, and for a new pardon of sin to be obtained, and thereupon even a new remission to be obtained of the punishment due to sin. For it is by all men yielded unto, who are truly godly & truly learned, that the Saints have need of a new Act of faith, and repentance, to attain new forgiveness of a new sin, according to that saying▪ most vulgar in Scripture; Men are justified by faith, and sins remitted: which speeches, when we make mention of men of years, are always understood of actual faith, that is, of the Act of faith▪ whereby we do not only in mind conceive, that by Christ our sins are remitted, but also we apprehend and receive in will, this forgiveness to be signified and offered in the Gospel▪ For this is most infallible and most true, that God doth never to the Elect ⟨p. 150⟩impute their sins to eternal damnation, and that for• three causes: The first, is h•• eternal and immutable love, wherewith from eternity he hath embraced his Elect in Christ, and doth continent ly prosecute without intermissio•• for there is not love when sinne• are imputed unto condemnation. The next, is the perpetual merit of Christ whereby all the debts of the Elect are plenarily paid, and the handwriting of the debts cancelled, insomuch that they cannot again by imputed unto condemnation to the Elect. The third, is the perpetual •• since of the Holy Spirit in the h••ts of the Elect, and conservation of ••• seed of faith, and regeneration. For although that this be most certain, that God doth never impute their sinne• to the Elect, both in regard of his everlasting love towards the• and for the perpetual merit of Christ imparted unto them, and for the continual inhabitation of the Holy Spirit in their hearts;
Wherefore it also▪ is not in Question, whether▪ the Saints by thes• their sinnes doe so displease God their father, and so prouokè his 〈…〉⟨p. 149⟩ger against them, and so incurre the sentence of eternall death, as that they haue need of repentance, and a new act of faith, for their reconciliation to God, and for a new pardon of sinne to be obtained, and thereupon euen a new remission to be obtained of the punishment due to sinne. For it is by all men yeelded vnto, who are truely godly & truely learned, that the Saints haue neede of a new Act of faith, and repentance, to attaine new forgiuenes of a new sinne, according to that saying▪ most vulgar in Scripture; Men are iustified by faith, and sinnes remitted: which speeches, when we make mention of men of yeares, are alwaies vnderstood of actuall faith, that is, of the Act of faith▪ whereby we doe not onely in mind conceiue, that by Christ our sinnes are remitted, but also we apprehend and rereceiue in will, this forgiuenes to be signified and offered in the Gospell▪ For this is most infallible and most true, that God doth neuer to the Elect ⟨p. 150⟩impute their sinnes to aeternall damnation, and that for• three causes: The first, is h•• eternall and immutable loue, wherewith from aeternitie hee hath embraced his Elect in Christ, and doth continen• ly prosequte without intermissio•• for there is not loue when sinne• are imputed vnto condemnation. The next, is the perpetual merit of Christ whereby all the debts of the Elect are plenarily paid, and the handwriting of the debts cancelled, insomuch that they cannot againe by imputed vnto condemnation to the Elect. The third, is the perpetuall •• si•nce of the Holy Spirit in the h••ts of the Elect, and conseruation of ••• seed of faith, and regeneration. For although that this be most certaine, that God doth neuer impute their sinne to the Elect, both in regard of his euerlasting loue towards the and for the perpetual merit of Christ imparted vnto them, and for the continuall inhabitation of the Holy Spirit in their hearts;
yet this withal ⟨p. 151⟩is most true and certain, That the Saints being fallen, though but by infirmity, into any sin, the new remission of that new sin, without a new Act of faith, and true repentance, that is, without a new knowledge & apprehension of faith, cannot again understand and perceive that new sin to be remitted unto them▪ the Father to be reconciled unto them, and the punishment due to sin to be remitted. For this is an Axiom most infallible in Christian Religion. New sin to stand in need of new remission, and new remission to be attained by new faith, that is, a new Act of faith apprehending that remission.
yet this withall ⟨p. 151⟩is most true and certaine, That the Saints being fallen, though but by infirmitie, into any sinne, the new remission of that new sinne, without a new Act of faith, and true repentance, that is, without a new knowledge & apprehension of faith, cannot againe vnderstand and perceiue that new sinne to be remitted vnto them▪ the Father to be reconciled vnto them, and the punishment due to sinne to bee remitted. For this is an A•iome most infallible in Christian Religion. New sin to stand in neede of new remission, and new remission to bee attained by new faith, that is, a new Act of faith apprehending that remission.
Neither yet is the Question, whether the Saints by these their sins do disturb, that is, as the Apostle speaketh Ephes. •. do make sad, both the Holy Spirit dwelling within them, as also their own Spirit, that is, the inward man. For this is a thing confessed, and all the Saints ⟨p. 152⟩do feel it when they sin and after they sin, that their spirit, mind•• and conscience is troubled & wounded: for (as it were) a certain violence is offered to the spirit and conscience when we sin by co• sent. From thence ariseth perturb• tion of mind. Now because the Holy Spirit inhabiting in the hea••• of the godly, and guiding and […] porting the inward man, from […] it cometh to pass, that our spirit being disturbed, that is, the […] regenerate and inward, the Holy Spirit inhabiting, is also by Paul said to be grieved, by a form •• speech borrowed from men. For thi• disturbance David likewise complaineth Psal. 29. Thou didst […] thy face from me O God▪ and I was troubled: by which words he doth manifest, as Augustine also observeth, That the Saints both do f•ll into sin, when God doth but a little turn away his face, and doth leave them to their own will, and so they are troubled; as also which ⟨p. 153⟩God again turneth his countenance and aspect upon them, then […] they again finally repurged and strengthened. So likewise it fell out i• Peter.
Neither yet is the Question, whether the Saints by these their sinnes doe disturbe, that is, as the Apostle speaketh Ephes. •. doe make sad, both the Holy Spirit dwelling within them, as also their owne Spirit, that is, the inward man. For this is a thing confessed, and all the Saints ⟨p. 152⟩doe feele it when they sinne and after they sinne, that their spirit, mind•• and conscience is troubled & wounded: for (as it were) a certaine violence is offered to the spirit and conscience when wee sinne by co• sent. From thence ariseth perturb• tion of minde. Now because the Holy Spirit inhabiting in the hea••• of the godly, and guiding and 〈…〉 porting the inward man, frō 〈…〉 it commeth to passe, that our spirit being disturbed, that is, the 〈…〉 regenerate and inward, the Holy Spirit inhabiting, is also by Paul said to bee grieued, by a forme •• speech borrowed from men. For thi• disturbance Dauid likewise complaineth Psal. 29. Thou didst 〈…〉 thy face from mee O God▪ and I was troubled: by which words hee doth manifest, as Augustine also obserueth, That the Saints both doe f•ll into sinne, when God doth but a little turne away his face, and doth leaue them to their owne will, and so they are troubled; as also which ⟨p. 153⟩God againe turneth his countenance and aspect vpon them, then 〈…〉 they againe finally repurged and strengthened. So likewise it fell out i• Peter.
And from hence likewise it is evident, that the Question is not, Whether the Saints by those sinne• do suffoc••• that ardency of Spirit in them▪ and do repress the good motions thereof, and (as it were) extinguish the good motions, Actions, and flames thereof, and therefore do •ue• weaken faith it self, and oppress prayer, fiducie, joy, and peace of conscience, and other effects of Faith. For these effects of sin are those perturbations of mind, whereof the Apostle speaketh. Ephes. 4. Make not sad the spirit; and of whom David, Thou didst turn thy face from me, and I was troubled. Of this weakening and diminution, and extinguishing of faith, the spirit, and love▪ is that Apoc. •. to be understood, I have a few things against thee, for that thou hast ⟨p. 154⟩left thy first love: but not totally▪ for he had commended him […] for his constancy; saying, Th•• […] suffered for my name, and […] n•• […]: presently he addeth, but I […] somewhat against thee, that then […] left thy first lave; he saith not […] lutely (love) but (first) that is, th•• ardent (love) therefore it was ab• ted and languishing, and not utterly extinguished.
And from hence likewise it is euident, that the Question is not, Whether the Saints by those sinne• doe suffoc••• that •rdencie of Spirit in them▪ and doe represse the good motions thereof, and (as it were) extinguish the good motions, Actions, and flames thereof, and therefore doe •ue• weaken faith it selfe, and oppresse prayer, fiducie, ioy, and peace of conscience, and other effects of Faith. For these effects of sinne are those perturbations of minde, whereof the Apostle speaketh. Eph•s. 4. Make not sad the spirit; and of whom Dauid, Thou didst turne thy face from me, and I was troubled. Of this weakning and diminution, and extinguishing of faith, the spirit, and loue▪ is that Apoc. •. to be vnderstood, I haue a few things against thee, for that thou hast ⟨p. 154⟩left thy first loue: but not totally▪ for he had commended him 〈…〉 for his constancie; saying, Th••〈…〉 suffered for my name, and 〈…〉 n••〈…〉: presently he addeth, but I 〈…〉 somewhat against thee, that then 〈…〉 left thy first laue; hee saith not 〈…〉 lutely (loue) but (first) that is, th•• ardent (loue) therefore it was ab• ted and languishing, and not vtterly extinguished.
Finally, the Question is not, whether also, so much as in them is, the Saints do utterly extinguish all the fire of faith, love, and the Spirit▪ For this is apparent, that the Saints, while they sin by any consent, d•e commit such sins for which they do worthily deserve to be dispoil•• utterly of all faith & assistance of the spirit. Neither if faith and the spirit be preserved in them, it is so preserved by their merits o• strength▪ but they are continued for the merit• and intercession of Christ, and promise of Gods mercy, by the operation of the Holy Spirit.
Finally, the Question is not, whether also, so much as in them is, the Saints doe vtterly extinguish all the fire of faith, loue, and the Spirit▪ For this is apparant, that the Saints, while they sinne by any consent, d•e commit such sinnes for which they doe worthily deserue to be dispoil•• vtterly of al faith & assistance of the spirit. Neither if faith and the spirit be preserued in them, it is so preserued by their merits o• strength▪ but they are continued for the merit• and intercession of Christ, and promise of Gods mercie, by the operation of the Holy Spirit.
Neither did I ever either teach or think otherwise in your Schools touching these things, as I have now formerly secluded from this Question, then is here manifested by me; which my Praelections in writing do plainly testify.
Neither did I euer either teach or thinke otherwise in your Schooles touching these things, as I haue now formerly secluded from this Question, then is here manifested by me; which my Praelections in writing doe plainely testifie.
Therefore let such consider with what conscience they did so, who now first, viz. after eight years space wherein I have both taught & disputed in your School, as though I had taught in many points even flat contrary •o the things before remembered, every where have falsely accused, traduced, and calumniated me being innocent, and now for many years a Professor of sound and Orthodoxall doctrine; and that confidently, for that they saw me a stranger, ignorant of the German tongue, destitute of the popular favour, and letted likewise, lest by any means, as I could, I should at leastwise maintain the truth and my reputation in the School: I say (such let them look into their conscience) ⟨p. 156⟩who being a Christian man, a professor of the Scriptures, and a member of the Church of Christ, with grievous calumniations above on• year and an half, have traduced me with all men, and would not at any time vouchsafe me conference: such as be elected, and either of ignorance or infirmity have sinned, I do pray for repentance for them to the Lord: the rest, which are not the Lords (for the Lord knoweth ••• be his) I do summon before the Tribunal of the most High God▪ for God is a just Judge, and it […] fearful thing to fall into the •an•• of the living God.
Therefore let such consider with what conscience they did so, who now first, viz. after eight yeres space wherein I haue both taught & disputed in your Schoole, as though I had taught in many points euen flat contrarie •o the things before remembred, euery where haue falsly •ccused, traduced, and calumniated me beeing innocent, and now for many yeeres a Professour of sound and Orthodoxall doctrine; and that confidently, for that they saw mee a stranger, ignorant of the Germai•e tongue, destitute of the popular fauour, and letted likewise, lest by any meanes, as I could, I should at leastw•se maintaine the truth and my reputation in the Schoole: I say (such let them look into their conscience) ⟨p. 156⟩who beeing a Christian man, a professour of the Scriptures, and a member of the Church of Christ, with grieuous calumniations aboue on• yeere and an halfe, haue traduced me with all men, and would not at any time vouchsafe me conference: such as be elected, and either of ignorance or infirmirie haue sinned, I doe pray for repentance for them to the Lord: the rest, which are not the Lords (for the Lord knoweth ••• bee his) I doe summon before the Tribunall of the most High God▪ for God is a iust Iudge, and it 〈…〉 fearefull thing to fall into the •an•• of the liuing God.
NOW I come to the matter• in controversy, which summarily are comprised in five Questions: for my primary Antagonist did collect this also out of my Praelections, and condemn it, as may be seen in the Theses objected by him against me▪ likewise in the end of his speech against the Epilogue of my former Oration made in the Chapter •••se, he […] these ⟨p. 158⟩words: Nihilominus tamèn hanc qui facit Zanchius, &c. Notwithstanding I do asseverate as false and monstrous that distinction which Zanchius maketh in the fifth proposition, touching that perseverance of the Saints; between the double Man of the Regenerate; and that the Regenerate do sin only in the flesh, and not with the whole will and the whole heart. These things he; Whereby every one understandeth what he doth condemn in my doctrine; Verily, That the Regenerate consisteth of a double […] that they in sinning do not sin, according to the spirit, but according to the flesh, and therefore […] with full & plenary consent of will.
NOW I come to the matter• in controuersie, which summarily are comprised in fiue Questions: for my primarie Antagonist did collect this also out of my Praelections, and condemne it, as may bee seene in the Theses obiected by him against me▪ likewise in the end of his speech against the Epilogue of my former Oration made in the Chapte••••se, hee 〈…〉 these ⟨p. 158⟩words: Nihilominus tamèn hanc qui facit Zanchius, &c. Notwithstanding I doe asseuere as false and monstrous that distinction which Zanchius maketh in the fift proposition, touching that perseuerance of the Saints; betweene the double Man of the Regenerate; and that the Regenerate doe sinne onely in the flesh, and not with the whole will and the whole heart. These things hee; Whereby euery one vnderstandeth what he doth condemne in my doctrine; Verily, That the Regenerate consisteth of a double 〈…〉 that they in sinning doe not sinne, according to the spirit, but according to the flesh, and therefore 〈…〉 with full & plenarie consent of will.
Therefore touching that distinction, I do affirm it to be Apostolical, & most ancient in the Church, of God; and that by the judgment of all the learned, and men of Go•• insomuch that I cannot but wonder how it should come to pass, there Doctor in Divinity should […] ⟨p. 159⟩this distinction monstrous. Now what I meant by the name of inward and outward man, I explained in the Schools an hundred times, that is to say the inward Man to be the whole Man, as he is borne of God and renewed by the Holy Spirit, and the same whole Man, as it is borne of Adam, corrupt, and depraved, to be called the outward Man: the one whereof the Scriptures do call the n•w; and the other, the old Man. For so all men of learning do interpret, and (amongst others) Bucer▪ in Epist. a•Rom. 7 & Ephes. 3. although even this interpretation of the inward out-outward Man, as though it were only mine, mine adversaries have impugned. Put of this distinction there be many testimonies in the Apostle Rom. 7▪ I delight in the Law of GOD, according to the inward […] for I see one Law of my members rebelling against the […] of my mind. Who in this place cannot see in the Apostle, being Regenerate, ⟨p. 160⟩• double man, inward; and outward? Rom. 6. […] old man •• also true […]. The old man (in the Apostles ••• oning) in the whole man […] Adam concept both in soul and body. […] off the old […] and put on the new. What is the […] the same man totally, as he is renewed and regenerate […] Christ, Ephes. 7. That his might […] you according to the […] of […], to be strengthened in […] holy spirit •• the inward […] which place Bucer: […] (saith he) the inward […] man reformed, as by the […] understandeth the […] man; and […], and […] ward is that which […] calleth •ow, and the […], which […] are old. Thus Bucer […] putting off the old man, and p•• ting on the •ow. […] ▪ The old man of faith he […] whole […], as it is brought into the world, and […] do bring it with ⟨p. 161⟩us from the womb of our Mother, without the holy Spirit, which is called flesh, Col. 3. Thus Bucer. Therefore it is apparent, That this distinction is not monstrous.
Therefore touching that distinction, I doe affirme it to be Apostelicall, & most ancient in the Church, of God; and that by the iudgment of all the learned, and men of Go•• insomuch that I cannot but wonder how it should come to passe, there Doctor in Diuinitie should 〈…〉⟨p. 159⟩this distinction monstrous. Now what I meant by the name of inward and outward man, I explained in the Schooles an hundreth times, that is to say the inward Man to be the whole Man, as hee is borne of God and renewed by the Holy Spirit, and the same whole Man, as it is borne of Adam, corrupt, and depraued, to bee called the outward Man: the one whereof the Scriptures doe call the n•w; and the other, the old Man. For so all men of learning doe interpret, and (amongst others) Bucer▪ in Epist. a•Rom. 7 & Ephes. 3. although euen this interpretation of the inward out-outward Man, as though it were onely mine, mine aduersaries haue impugned. Put of this distinction there bee many testimonies in the Apostle Rom. 7▪ I delight in the Law of GOD, according to the inward 〈…〉 for I see one Law of my members rebelling against the 〈…〉 of my minde. Who in this place cannot see in the Apostle, being Regenerate, ⟨p. 160⟩• double man, inward; and outward? Rom. 6. 〈…〉 old man •• also true 〈…〉. The old man (in the Apostles ••• oning) in the whole man 〈…〉 Adam concept both in soule and bodie. 〈…〉 off the old 〈…〉 and put on the new. What is the 〈…〉 the same man totally, as he is renewed and regenerate Christ, Ephes. 7. That his might you according to the of , to be strengthned in holy spirit the inward which place Bucer: (saith hee) the inward man reformed, as by the vnderstandeth the man; and , and ward is that which calleth ow, and the , which are old. Thus Bucer putting off the old man, and p ting on the ow. The old man of faith hee whol , as it is brought into the world, and doe bring it with
Concerning the next point, they condemn this Proposition as false and monstrous, That the Saints, or Regenerate, when they sin, and that willingly, do sin not according to the inward man, that is, in that part wherein they are •egenerate, but only according to the outward […], that is, in that part wherein they are not regenerate, or •• sin not according to the spirit, ⟨p. 162⟩but according to the flesh▪ […] will sin by the will of th• […] but by the will of the […] therefore to sin in will […] not […]; and with consent, but not […]; which others do hold, […] much as not to sin with the […] mind: I say they do reject this P•• position, as false and horrible, as before is said: and on the other side they contend, that the Saints, […] they sin with consent, as […] and Peter sinned, that they […] with the whole and full will, and with all their heart. For so […] of Peter, that he denied […] with the whole hear•, and with […] whole heart abhorred Christ. […] therefore from hence they […] That the Saints when they sin w•• lingly, that they loose […] and the Holy Spirit totally▪ But […] the contrary part I do conde••• this their resolution, both generally, in all men sanctified, and specially in David and Peter, as re••• nant to the holy Scriptures, and the ⟨p. 163⟩[…] and holy Fathers of the Church: but that former sentence I […] approve and embrace, and am ••ereunto persuaded by many […] both out of holy Writ, and •athers, and testimonies of learned […], whereof some I will have subsequently set down.
COncerning the next point, they condemne this Proposition as false and monstrous, That the Saints, or Regenerate, when they sinne, and that willingly, doe sinne not according to the inward man, that is, in that part wherein they are •egenerate, but onely according to the outward 〈…〉, that is, in that part wherein they are not regenerate, or •• sinne not according to the spirit, ⟨p. 162⟩but according to the flesh▪〈…〉 will sinne by the will of th•〈…〉 but by the will of the 〈…〉 therefore to sinne in will 〈…〉 not 〈…〉; and with consent, but not 〈…〉; which others doe hold, 〈…〉 much as not to sinne with the 〈…〉 minde: I say they do reiect this P•• position, as false and horrible, as before is said: and on the other side they contend, that the Saints, 〈…〉 they sinne with consent, as 〈…〉 and Peter sinned, that they 〈…〉 with the whole and full will, and with all their heart. For so 〈…〉 of Peter, that hee denied 〈…〉 with the whole hear•, and with 〈…〉 whole heart abhorred Christ. 〈…〉 therfore from hence they 〈…〉 That the Saints when they sin w•• lingly, that they loose 〈…〉 and the Holy Spirit totally▪ But 〈…〉 the contrarie part I doe conde••• this their resolution, both gene••lly, in all men sanctified, and specially in Dauid and Peter, as re••• nant to the holy Scriptures, and the ⟨p. 163⟩〈…〉 and holy Fathers of the Church: but that former sentence I 〈…〉 approue and embrace, and am ••ereunto perswaded by many 〈…〉 both out of holy Writ, and •athers, and testimonies of learned 〈…〉, whereofsome I will haue subsequently set downe.
If the Saints, when they sin with will, do sin with the total and full will and with the whole heart, then they do not •ate sin in any part or detest and nill it; but this is most false, and dissonant to the holy writings; Rom. 7. The Apostle thus speaketh of all the Saints and Regenerate, being in his own person represented: The Law is spiritual, but I am carnal (scilic•t according to the outward man) sold under sin; that is, under the tyranny of original sin, as a bought servant under the tyranny of his Master; but such servants do not love their tyrannical Masters, neither do they willing service unto them, for they do always desire liberty. ⟨p. 164⟩Therefore he teacheth▪ […] Saints do always hate […] when they […] they […] full will from the heart. […] he more fully explain▪ […] addeth; for what […] I allow not; that is, […] commend it, nor in the will […] outward man do I […] it, […] of these he signifieth by the […] [Greek or Hebrew], as elsewhere often […]; as Rom. 9. •e hath […] his people which •e […], […] knew to be his, and before […] […] So Mat. 11. I kn•w you n•t; […] w•th in the Apostle, Not that […] I would, that I do, but that […] that I do, that is, that which I […] in the will of the spirit, that […] I do not. […], that […] good, but that which I hate […] spirit▪ that I do a• […] […] that which is evil. He […] teacheth that in the […] they •e regenerate, there […] an hatred of sin, although▪ […] be carnal, they do always […] ⟨p. 165⟩sin: which thing a little after […] reporteth saying; The good that ••••ld I do not, but the evil which I hate in the Spirit, that I do a• car•all; and (by and by) for I am delighted with the Law of God according to my inward […]; for I s•• o•• Law in my members ••••lling to the Law of my mind, and leading […] to the Law of sin which is in my members. Lo here an explication and confirmation of that he spoke in the beginning, […], when he said, […] carnal sold under sin. Therefore the Regenerate, in respect of the inward man which hateth sin, they do it not with all the heart, for that in spirit they detest it▪ and are as unwilling servants unto it;
If the Saints, when they sin with will, doe sinne with the totall and full will and with the whole heart, then they doe not •ate sinne in any part or detest and nill it; but this is most false, and dissonant to the holy writings; Rom. 7. The Apostle thus speaketh of all the Saints and Regenerate, being in his owne person represented: The Law is spirituall, but I am carnall (scilic•t according to the outward man) sold vnder sinne; that is, vnder the tyranny of originall sinne, as a bought seruant vnder the tyrannie of his Master; but such seruants doe not loue their tyrannicall Masters, neither do they willing seruice vnto them, for they doe alwaies desire libertie. ⟨p. 164⟩Therefore hee teacheth▪〈…〉 Saints doe alwaies hate 〈…〉 when they 〈…〉 they 〈…〉 full will from the heart. 〈…〉 hee more fully explaine▪〈…〉 addeth; for what 〈…〉 I allow not; that is, 〈…〉 commend it, nor in the will 〈…〉 outward man doe I 〈…〉 it, 〈…〉 of these he signifieth by the 〈…〉〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as elsewhere often 〈…〉; as Rom. 9. •e hath 〈…〉 his people which •e 〈…〉, 〈…〉 knew to be his, and before 〈…〉〈…〉 So Mat. 11. I kn•w you nt; wth in the Apostle, Not that I would, that I doe, but that that I doe, that is, that which I in the will of the spirit, that I doe not. , that good, but that which I hate spirit that I doe a that which is euill. Hee teacheth that in the they e regenerate, there an hatred of sinne, although bee carnall, they doe alwaies
hereupon they both lamenting this misery and […] as it were constrained, do […] ou• with the Apostle, O […] that I am •h• shall deliver […] from the ••dy of this ••ath▪ and because they do […] that they sh•ll▪ certainly be […] by Christ▪ therefore▪ they support ⟨p. 166⟩themselves with this hope, saying; The grace of God, through […] Christ our Lord. And that whi•• […] had taught in long speech, ••••• cludeth after in the end of the […], saying; Therefore I my s•lf• […] my mind s•rue the law of God, […] my flesh, the law of sin. That the • postle doth here speak of the •• generate; all learned men do […] knowledge.
hereupon they both lamenting this miserie and 〈…〉 as it were constrained, doe 〈…〉 ou• with the Apostle, O 〈…〉 that I am •h• shall deliuer 〈…〉 from the ••dy of this ••ath▪ and because they doe 〈…〉 that they sh•ll▪ certainely be 〈…〉 by Christt▪ therefore▪ they support ⟨p. 166⟩themselues with this hope, saying; The grace of God, through 〈…〉 Christ our Lord. And that whi••〈…〉 had taught in long speach, ••••• cludeth after in the end of the 〈…〉, saying; Therefore I my s•lf•〈…〉 my mind s•rue the law of God, 〈…〉 my flesh, the law of sinne. That the • postle doth here speake of the •• generate; all learned men doe 〈…〉 knowledge.
And that he doth not only […] of the motions of concupiscence, […] likewise of actual sins whi•• […] Saints sometime do commit▪ […] the testimonies of learned m••▪ these words so often repeated […] give notice; I do; I act; I […] serve. So also Buc•• writeth •••• this place; to d••, (saith he) so•• do take here for to l•st: but •o […] speaketh not, he understandeth t•• fact it self which is effected by ••• violence of concupiscence, ••• trary to that which the mind•••• gesteth, and the mind […] to the Law approveth. Therf•••⟨p. 167⟩if the Saints, even in sins actual, do work, as they be carnal, that which they would not, but hate as they be regenerate and spiritual, it is manifest that the Saints do never sin with the whole will and plenary consent. Nay the Apostle proceedeth even thus far in that place, as, because the Saints do not sin with a full will, neither according to the inward man, therefore he saith, that when they commit sin, it is not the Saints them selves who do or work evil, but sin it self, that is Original corruption which is in their members. For thus he reasoneth; But if I do• that which I would not, it is now no• I that ••rke, that is, commit it, but sin that dwelleth in me. Who may not here see, that the Apostle doth fully and clearly conclude, that the case is so far otherwise, that the Saints when they sin actually, as they call it, ought to be deemed to sin with the whole and ple•••y will, and with all the heart, and as well according to the ⟨p. 168⟩inward as the outward m•• […] rather (after a sort) they […] said, it is not they who do […] Sin dwelling within ther• […] the reason is, for that the […] doth not cons••t •• […] and yet in the mean• time th•• […] not excused from sin, neither […] their sinn•s extenuated. For […] though not according to the […] pull part, that is the inward […] they sin not, but only according to the outward, and in mind […] they serve the Law of God, but •• the flesh the Law of sin; yet •• very deed they are such as do […] by their own proper will.
And that he doth not only 〈…〉 of the motions of conc•pisence, 〈…〉 likewise of actuall sinnes whi••〈…〉 Saints somtime doe commit▪〈…〉 the testimonies of learned m••▪ these wordes so often repeated 〈…〉 giue notice; I do; I act; I 〈…〉 serue. So also Buc•• writeth •••• this place; to d••, (saith hee) so•• doe take here for to l•st: but •o 〈…〉 speaketh not, he vnderstandeth t•• fact it selfe which is effected by ••• violence of concupiscence, ••• trary to that which the mind•••• gesteth, and the minde 〈…〉 to the Law approueth. Therf•••⟨p. 167⟩if the Saints, euen in sinnes actuall, doe worke, as they bee carnall, that which they would not, but hate as they be regenerate and spirituall, it is manifest that the Saints doe neuer sinne with the whole will and plenary consent. Nay the Apostle proceedeth euen thus far in that place, as, because the Saints doe not sinne with a full will, neither according to the inward man, therefore he saith, that when they commit sinne, it is not the Saints them selues who doe or worke euill, but sinne it selfe, that is Originall corruption which is in their members. For thus hee reasoneth; But if I do• that which I would not, it is now no• I that ••rke, that is, commit it, but sinne that dwelleth in me. Who may not here see, that the Apostle doth fully and clearely conclude, that the case is so farre otherwise, that the Saints when they sinne actually, as they call it, ought to bee deemed to sinne with the whole and pley will, and with all the heart, and as well according to the
If the Godly sin with […] whole will, therefore whatsoe••• they will according to the fl••• they effect it; but this contradic•••• the Apostle who saith, […]. 5. […] •••sh ••steth against the […] spirit against the fle••: •• not […] ••• ye• would those ye• do• […] speech is to ••e underst••d •• […], for that […] ⟨p. 169⟩••ght against the spirit; that therefore the Saints cannot always effect •he things the• do will according •o the spirit, and on the contrary, because the spirit doth fight against the flesh, therefore the Saints, what things they will according to the flesh, like-wise they are not able to perform. Therefore as the Saints do not love God with all their hart •nd all their mind, for that flesh is a ••• unto them: so they love not sin, neither do sin, with the whole heart, for that the spirit doth hinder the doing thereof.
If the Godly sinne with 〈…〉 whole will, therefore whatsoe••• they will according to the fl••• they effect it; but this contradic•••• the Apostle who saith, 〈…〉. 5. 〈…〉•••sh ••steth against the 〈…〉 spirit against the fle••: •• not 〈…〉••• ye• would those ye• do•〈…〉 spe•ch is to ••e vnderst••d ••〈…〉, for that 〈…〉⟨p. 169⟩••ght against the spirit; that therefore the Saints cannot alwaies effect •he things the• doe will according •o the spirit, and on the contrary, because the spirit doth fight against the flesh, therefore the Saints, what things they will according to the flesh, like-wise they are not able to performe. Therefore as the Saints doe not loue God with all their hart •nd all their minde, for that flesh is a ••• vnto them: so they loue not sinne, neither doe sinne, with the whole heart, for that the spirit doth hinder the doing thereof.
The Saints never sin of purposed malice, or (as others will) from the whole heart, but always either of infirmity or ignorance. Now malice properly doth reside in the will and heart. Matthew. 15. Therefore the Saint• do ••rme with plenary will, the whole heart, and full consent.
The Saints neuer sinne of purposed malice, or (as others will) from the whole heart, but alwaies either of infirmity or ignorance. Now malice properly doth reside in the will and heart. Mathew. 15. Therefore the Saint• doe ••rme with plenary will, the whole heart, and full consent.
But that the Saints never of purposed malice do sin, but always either of ignorance, or by infirmity, ⟨p. 170⟩is cleared by these testimonies. Thei• Saints, according to the […] man, are delighted, in the la•• […] God, for that is good Rom. 7. And […] they are delighted, in-so-much▪ […] they who are not delighted […] are not Saints. Therefore with D• uid every holy man doth truly vouch▪ In the volume of this book •• written of m••, that I should d•• […] will, O GOD: I will (or I deligh••▪ therein, for thy law is (written) wit••• my heart. Psalm•. 89. For th•y h••• t•• law of God written i• their •••r•••• the Holy Spirit. Jerem. 31. therefore do they meditate in the same […]. Psalm•. 1▪ And in their •••rt•• there is no guil•. Psalm•. 32. for th•y are true Israelites, in whom there is •• guile. Jo•. 1. And they are •ndu•d •••• the spirit of Christ, whereby •••y […] ruled in the […] ••an, else they we•• no▪ Saints. Romans. 8. And they l••• righteousness▪ and hate iniquity. Psal▪ 44. For they lo•• the law of God▪ Psal. 118. they like-wise lament with t•• Apostle, that they are capti••s▪ […] so ⟨p. 171⟩under sin. Ro. 7. How then can they of destinate malice sin, & so with their whol• hart• Aug. To. 7. de •orr. & gratia, c. 9. by the example of David and Peter doth teach, That all Saints, when they sin▪ do sin being troubled, for that Christ doth somewhat turn away his face from them, according to that in the Psalm. 29. Thou turnedst thy face from m•, and I •as troubled. Now to sin being thus troubled, is not to sin by endeavour, & of purposed malice, but rather, besides the purpose of the mind.
But that the Saints neuer of purposed malice doe sinne, but alwaies either of ignorance, or by infirmity, ⟨p. 170⟩is cleared by these testimonies. Thei• Saints, according to the 〈…〉 man, are delighted, in the la••〈…〉 God, for that is good Rom. 7. And 〈…〉 they are delighted, in-so-much▪〈…〉 they who are not delighted 〈…〉 are not Saints. Therefore with D• uid euery holy man doth truely vouch▪ In the volume of this book •• written of m••, that I should d••〈…〉 will, O GOD: I will (or I deligh••▪ therein, for thy law is (written) wit••• my heart. Psalm•. 89. For th•y h••• t•• law of God written i• their •••r•••• the Holy Spirit. Ierem. 31. therefore doe they m•ditate in the same 〈…〉. Psalm•. 1▪ And in their •••rt•• there is no guil•. Psalm•. 32. for thy are true Isralites, in whome there is guile. Io. 1. And they are ndud the spirit of Christ, whereby y ruled in the an, else they we no Saints.
Again, To. 7. quest. 25. in Num. he maketh three sorts of sins; some of ignorance; some of infirmity; and some of the contempt of Gods commandments, or •s the Scripturephras•▪ there is with the hand of pride. It is one thing (saith he) to contemn the commandments; another thing to esteem them as precious; but yet either as ignorant, or surprised to do the contrary. But it is granted, that the Saints do not sin of contempt either of God or his commandments: ⟨p. 172⟩the which thing also […] Melanchthon in▪ 10. Cor. 1. doth write▪ That they never grow into […] picureall contempt; for they […] law and commandments of […] Psal••. 119. Now to sin of […] tempt, and of destinate mali••▪••••• one: wherefore the Saints do• […] sin of pr•tensed malice ▪ W•• then dare some divines write agai••• me. That they do sin with […] whole heart and plenary will?
Againe, To. 7. qu•st. 25. in Num. he maketh three sorts of sins; some of ignorance; some of infirmitie; and some of the contempt of Gods commandements, or •s the Scripturephras•▪ there is with the hand of pride. It is one thing (saith he) to contemne the commandements; another thing to esteeme them as precious; but yet either as ignorant, or surprised to do the contrary. But it is granted, that the Saints doe not sin of contempt either of God or his commandements: ⟨p. 172⟩the which thing •lso 〈…〉 Mel••cthon in▪ 10. Cor. 1. doth write▪ That they neuer growe into 〈…〉 picureall contempt; for they 〈…〉 law and commandements of 〈…〉 Psal••. 119. Now to sinne of 〈…〉 tempt, and of destinate mali••▪••••• one: wherefore the Saints do•〈…〉 sinne of pr•tensed malic•▪ W•• then dare some diuines write agai••• me. That they doe sinne with 〈…〉 whole heart and plenary will?
Gregory. 1. To. 1. in Job▪ c. 34 […] c▪ 11. doth deliver the same […] on, of ignorance, of infirmity, b••• devour and of set purpose. And […] saith that Paul did sin of ignorance, who saith, But I therefore •• tained mercy because I did •• […] Peter of infirmity, when he deni•• Christ▪ and those Jews purpos•• and by endeavour, of whom the Lo•d speaketh, if. I had not c•m• […] spoken unto them, they had b•• […] again, they b•th saw m•, and […] ▪•••nd my father. Joh. 15. Out of these examples he declareth what it ⟨p. 173⟩i• to sin of infirmity, and what of purpose, saying; for it is one thing not to do good; another to hate the teacher of good things▪•s it is one thing to sin of precipitation; another to sin of deliberation. For oftentimes sin is committed by precipitation, which is yet condemned by counsel & deliberation: for through infirmity often it chanceth, that we love God, and yet cannot effect it; but to sin of purpose, is neither to do good, nor love it. But the Saints do always effect that which is good, else no Saints▪ where-upon Augustine also de corr•pt, & gratia, cap. 9. according to that of the Apostle, To them that love God, all things do work together f•r good, to them that of purpose are called Saints; saith he; for these (scilic•• Saints who are called of purpose) in this that they love God they con•••ue out unto the end. •• therefore, according to Saint Gregory to sin of purpose be neither to do nor to love good; and, according to Augustine, the Saints do always love good; for ⟨p. 174⟩that in that which they love th•• continue forth to the end: it i•• good consequent, That the Sa••• do not sin of purpose, or det•• minate malice.
G••gorie. 1. To. 1. in Iob▪ c. 34 〈…〉 c▪ 11. doth deliuer the same 〈…〉 on, of ignorance, of infirmity, b••• deuour and of set purpose. And 〈…〉 saith that Paul did sinne of ignorance, who saith, But I therefore •• tained mercy because I did ••〈…〉 Peter of infirmity, when he deni•• Christ▪ and those Iewes purpos•• and by endeuour, of whom the Lo•d speaketh, if. I had not c•m•〈…〉 spok•n vnto them, they had b••〈…〉 againe, they b•th saw m•, and 〈…〉▪•••nd my father. Ioh. 15. Out of these examples he declareth what it ⟨p. 173⟩i• to sinne of infirmitie, and what of purpose, saying; for it is one thing not to do good; another to hate the teacher of good things▪•s it is one thing to sin of praecipitation; another to sinne of deliberation. For oftentimes sinne is committed by p••cipitation, which is yet condemned by counsel & deliberation: for through infirmity often it chanceth, that we loue God, and yet cannot effect it; but to sinne of purpose, is neither to doe good, nor loue it. But the Saints doe alwaies effect that which is good, else no Saints where-vpon Augustine also de corrpt, & gratia, cap. 9. according to that of the Apostle, To them that loue God, all things doe worke together fr good, to them that of purpose are called Saints; saith hee; for these (scilic Saints who are called of purpose) in this that they loue God they conue out vnto the end. therefore, according to Saint Grgory to sinne of purpose be neither to doe nor to loue good; and, according to Augustine, the Saints doe alwaies loue good; for
Luther likewise doth deliver t•• same thing, in every place, T•▪ 5▪ […] Comment major▪ in ep. ad Gal▪ 5. […] these words; The works of t•• […] are manifest. He saith in […] terms▪ That David and Peter▪ […] they committed those […] sins, did sin of infirmity and not of set malice. Here-upon▪ […] (saith he) speaking of the […] saith, the flesh in them doth lust […] the spirit: therefore the desires and conflicts of the flesh will not be •• sent, yet do they not therefore presently hurt such as feel them▪ But hereof we must thus judge▪ it is o•• thing to be solicited of the flesh▪ and not willingly to endure the co• cupiscences thereof▪ but to walk in the spirit, and to resist them▪ &•▪•nd another thing to assent •nto t•• flesh, and i• security to fulfil the ⟨p. 175⟩works thereof, and persist in them; ••d yet in the mean space to dis•••ble piety, and to brag of the spi•i• &c. The former sort he comforteth while he saith, that they are •ed by the spirit; and are under the l•w: to the other sort he threateneth eternal destruction. Nay sometime it falleth out▪ That the Saints do fall and fulfil the lusts of the flesh; as David fell with a grievous •nd terrible downfall: besides, he was the cause of many mens murder, when his will was, that Uriah should perish in the battle: and thereby also he gave occasion to the enemies of God, to boast against the people of God, to adore their own Idols, and to blaspheme the God of Israel. Peter like-wise did horribly fall, when he denied his Master. But yet although those sins were heinous, yet were they committed, not of the contempt of God▪ or malice fore-thought, but of infirmity. Besides, being admonished they do not persevere obstinate in their sins, ⟨p. 176⟩but repented. Therefore • […] Doctor did no• well, […] in the Schools, that […] Christ with the whole […] with his whole heart did […] Christ. Luther he•• […]
Luther likewise doth deliuer t•• same thing, in euery plac•, T•▪ 5▪〈…〉 Comment maior▪ in ep. ad Gal▪ 5. 〈…〉 these words; The work•s of t••〈…〉 are manifest. Hee saith in 〈…〉 termes▪ That Da•id and Peter▪〈…〉 they committed those 〈…〉 sinnes, did sinne of infirmity and not of set malice. Here-vpon▪〈…〉 (saith hee) speaking of the 〈…〉 saith, the flesh in them doth lust 〈…〉 the spirit: therefore the desires and conflicts of the flesh will not be •• sent, yet doe they not therefore presently hurt such as feele them▪ But hereof we must thus iudge▪ it is o•• thing to bee sollicited of the flesh▪ and not willingly to endure the co• cupiscences thereof▪ but to walke in the spirit, and to resist them▪ &•▪•nd another thing to assent •nto t•• flesh, and i• security to fulfill the ⟨p. 175⟩
Again, a little after th•• […] he faith whereforeth […] sin, fall, •nd even g•• […] but it is by ignorance▪ f•• […] they would not deny▪ C••i•• […] loose▪ the Gospel. Th•se […] Therefore neither did Peter▪ […] deny Christ▪ for he was […] And if he would not willingly […] him, therefore did he no• […] with a full consent of will. […] Buc•r every where doth […] same doctrine; scilicet, that th• […] do never •in with a full will or […] the heart, & of malice •o•• […] but always of ignorance▪ […] of infirmity. Take th•se […]
Againe, a little after th••〈…〉 he faith whereforeth•〈…〉 sinne, fall, •nd euen g••〈…〉 but it is by ignorance▪ f••〈…〉 they would not denye▪ C••i••〈…〉 loose▪ the Gospell. Th•se 〈…〉 Therfore neither did Peter▪〈…〉 deny Christ▪ for hee was 〈…〉 And if he would not willingly 〈…〉 him, therefore did he no•〈…〉 with a ful consent of wil. 〈…〉 Buc•r euery where doth 〈…〉 same doctrin; scilicet, that th•〈…〉 do neuer •in with a full will or 〈…〉 the heart, & of malice •o••〈…〉 but alwayes of ignorance▪〈…〉 of infirmity. Take th•se 〈…〉
Upon Rom. 7. he […] d•eth this Question▪ […] […] at &c. How can this he […] That we will that which •• […] ⟨p. 177⟩and ye• do it not; that we do ••il ••d ••• will •• not, ••• hate it▪•ay▪••at we both do▪•nd not do, that which i••uill? Now intending to determine thi• Question▪ first he •oth inquire out▪ w•at manner man •he Apostle speaketh o• in his own ••ample and summarily he concludeth▪ That the Apostle speaketh of ••••n regenerate, who by a true •aith hath already received the •aw of God, and doth love it▪•nd delight in it; but yet hath no• received such a plentiful portion of the spirit of Christ▪ that he can […] follow the same▪ as that he doth not often transgress against ••▪ not only by concupiscence, which even falleth to men most per•••t, but likewise▪ by sliding into […] and filthy offences as be fell •• D••••, and even to Peter before ••••• […] • more plentiful measure of the Spirit at the feast of ••••coast▪ For there▪ he maketh mention▪ of the examples of these two men▪ In the next place he learcheth ⟨p. 178⟩out▪ how it came to […] the same man being▪ […] doth both will and […] […] which he doth▪ The […] That it so cometh to […] that in some man there is a […] will; one whereby he doth […] to the Law▪ another whereby […] doth that which he […] which followeth the […] the Law; another which is […] knowledge drawn from the […] and which is of things […] else that this so cometh to […] for that in the regenerate▪ there […] double man, inward and […] mind and flesh, whereof one […] to the Law of God; the […] to the Law of sin▪ From […] therefore it cometh to pass […] the Saints do both the evil […] would not and the good […] they do not▪ wherefore, […] not with full consent, ••• with […] whole will, not totally, that is […] to the double man.
Vpon Rom. 7. he 〈…〉 d•eth this Question▪〈…〉〈…〉 at &c. How can this hee 〈…〉 That we will that which ••〈…〉⟨p. 177⟩and ye• doe it not; that we doe ••il ••d ••• will •• not, ••• hate it▪•ay▪••at we both doe▪•nd not doe, that which i••uill? Now intending to determi•e thi• Question▪ first hee •oth inquire out▪ w•at manner man •he Apostle speaketh o• in his owne ••ample and summ•rily he conclu•eth▪ That the Apostle speaketh of ••••n regenerate, who by a true •aith hath already receiued the •aw of God, and doth loue it nd delight in it; but yet hath no receied such a plentifull portion of the spirit of Christ that hee can follow the same as that he doth not often transgresse against not onely by concupscence, which euen faleth to men most pert, but likewise by sliding into and fithy offences as be fell D, and euen to Peter before more plentifull measure of the Spirit at the feast of coast For there he maketh mention of the examples of these two men In the next place he learcheth
Again in Rom. 8. sect. 2. […] ⟨p. 179⟩[…] not li•• after the l•sts of the flesh; […] teacheth ou• of the Apostle▪ That […] cannot be▪ that they which are ••uely Christs and have the spirit of ••rist, should li•e according to the ••esh. And he f•ameth his Argument in this form. Those whom the ••irit of Christ possesseth, cannot […] after the flesh. But they that are Christs the spirit of Christ possesseth; Therefore they that are Christs cannot live after the flesh, […]. Now to walk according to the flesh […] voluntarily, and with a willing and whole mind to follow the […] of the flesh, and to obey the l•sts thereof, with full will▪ Therefore the Saints do not sin with the whole heart and plenary c•••ent of will.
Againe in Rom. 8. sect. 2. 〈…〉⟨p. 179⟩〈…〉 not li•• after the l•sts of the flesh; 〈…〉 teacheth ou• of the Apostle▪ That 〈…〉 cannot be▪ that they which are ••uely Christs and haue the spirit of ••rist, should li•e according to the ••esh. And hee f•ameth his Argu•ent in this forme. Those whom the ••irit of Christ possesseth, cannot 〈…〉 after the flesh. But they that are Christs the spirit of Christ poss•sseth; Therefore they that are C•rists cannot liue after the flesh, 〈…〉. Now to walke according to the flesh 〈…〉 vol•ntarily, and with a willing and whole mind to follow the 〈…〉 of the flesh, and to obey the l•sts thereof, with full will▪ Therfore the Saintes do not sinne with the whole heart and ple••ry c•••ent of will.
Idem •• Mat 8▪•••t▪ 2. pag. […] saith▪ Herein the Saints in si••i•g •o differ from the Reprobate▪ for that they do hate that •uill which they do, and •resantly do dec••ne from it▪ being indeed rightly persuaded of God ••d his will: whereof it ⟨p. 180⟩is that in mind they […] his law, and do dete•t the ••ill of […] flesh▪ but the wicked do love […] evil they commit, and could […] perpetually to adh••• […] but only that they f•are […] either from God […]? And a […] after he teacheth, That the […] of the ••in•s do proceed from […] […] of faith▪ saying, […] ever the Elect do •inne▪ it […] m•th. from hence, for that •• […] they […] defective in that […] swas•on▪ Besides he faith […] the Saints mind, wanting […] ••nneth into sin▪ the […] concupiscence thereby turning […] the edge thereof.
Idem •• Mat 8▪•••t▪ 2. pag. 〈…〉 saith▪ Hearein the Saints in si••i•g •o differ from the R•proba•e▪ for that they do hate that •uill which they doe, and •resantly do dec••ne from it▪ being indeed righly perswaded of God ••d his will: whereof it ⟨p. 180⟩is that in mind they 〈…〉 his law, and do dete•t the ••ill of 〈…〉 flesh▪ but the wicked do loue 〈…〉 euil they commit, and could 〈…〉 perpe•ually to adh•••〈…〉 but onely that they f•are 〈…〉 either from God 〈…〉? And a 〈…〉 after he teacheth, That the 〈…〉 of the ••in•s do proceed from 〈…〉〈…〉 of faith▪ saying, 〈…〉 euer the Elect doe •inne it mth. from hence, for that they dfeciue in that swason Besides he faith the Saints mind, wanting nneth into sinne the concupiscce therby turning the edge thereof.
Id•• in Mat. 12. sect. 4. pag. […] hath these words. Whosoever, […] the known truth, by […] vol••••rily f•ll into […], […] willingly •o sin▪ it is necessary▪ […] they did formerly condemn […] truth; and that is to […] holy spirit. These thing•• […]
Id•• in Mat. 12. sect. 4. pag. 〈…〉 hath these wordes. Whosoeuer, 〈…〉 the knowne truth, by 〈…〉 vol••••rily f•ll into 〈…〉, 〈…〉 willingly •o sin▪ it is necessary▪〈…〉 they did formerly condemne 〈…〉 truth; and that is to 〈…〉 holy spirit. These thing••〈…〉
Whereupon it is manifest, […] ⟨p. 181⟩the Saints Elect do […] sin against the •oly Ghost, as […] there teacheth▪ therefore they ne•er […] mind to impiety, after the known truth that i•▪ willing; scil•ce•, […] full will they do never sin, as […] there doth […] what it is by relapse to fall from the heart into impiety.
Wherevppon it is man•fest, 〈…〉⟨p. 181⟩the Saints Eleect doe 〈…〉 sinne against the •oly Ghost, as 〈…〉 there teacheth▪ therefore they ne•er 〈…〉 mind to impiety, after the knowne truth that i•▪ willing; scil•ce•, 〈…〉 full will they do neuer sinne, as 〈…〉 there doth 〈…〉 what it is by relapse to fall from the heart into impiety.
Id•• sect. 4. pag. 308. The Elect (saith he) do never […] but of ignorance. Again, thou s•••• at all times perceive in the Elect a c•• taint feed of God, and st•dy of the truth▪ eve•• whe• they oppugn the truth, […] do […] l••e disagreeing with it. Again; •• many who live lewdly, being Elect, thou mayest perceive a certain […] love of right and ••st And the•e things he writeth of the Elect, before they […] tr••h▪ or are justified how •uch mor• a•e these things and of the Elect, being now ins••fied▪ wherefore of th••••e •dd•th ••g 309▪ After they ha•e received the […] ( •scilicet ⟨p. 182⟩the Elect) what they […], they sin therefore for that they are tur•ed out of the way by […] lusts of the flesh, so that they […] not attend upon the known […] but they never so far decline, […] they have and persecute •••• […] but forthwith rather out of the la• thereof they do begin to defy, a•• detest, that wherein they sinn••▪
Id•••ect. 4. pag. 308. The Elect (saith he) do neuer 〈…〉 but of ignorance. Againe, thou s•••• at all times percei•e in the Elect a c•• tain• feed of God, and st•dy of the truth▪ eue•• whe• they opp•g•e the •ruth, 〈…〉 doe 〈…〉 l••e d••agreeing with it. Againe; •• many who liue lewdly, being Elect, thou maist perceiue a certaine 〈…〉 loue of right and ••st And the•e thinges he writeth of the Elect, before they 〈…〉 tr••h▪ or are iustifyed how •uch mor• a•e these thinges and of the Elect, being now ins••fied▪ wherefore of th••••e •dd•th ••g 309▪ After they ha•e receiued the 〈…〉 ( •scilicet ⟨p. 182⟩
Ide• in Mat. 7▪ sect, 6. pag. […] ▪ Therefore a godly man thus […] not sin, for that he cannot be •• uen over from the heart to […] and sin, as it is the manner […] wicked; but with the Law of God in mind he shall be still deligh•••▪ for that the seed of God, of his word, and the Spirit of his children abideth with him, and for that h•• is borne of God▪ yet withal▪ […] that he hath no good in his […] he doth commit many things which he hateth, and are sinne• […] but because he •• not delighted therewith in the inward […] in his heart is addicted •• Christ▪⟨p. 183⟩and before all thing• de•••eth to b• correspondent to the image of Christ, neither finally maketh doubt, that all things ••• remitted unto him for the merits of Christ, and that he shall […] to that lik•ne•▪ there shall also be no […] unto him, although a sinner, for that he abideth in Christ▪Rom. 8▪ for God will not impute his sins unto him. Wherefore, neither shall they be sins, as they are no debts▪ which the Creditor hath […], […] he […] ▪ b• obliged, and hath ye• m•de no payment▪ For which […] he that is Christ•▪ as he […] ▪ that is, be wholly give••, and studi•• to sin, which only God imputeth and accounteth for sin: so it is necessary, that he endeavour ••e study of his will to his power, neither account any thing •••• p•• cious, then to compose himself •• tally according to his word▪ Ye• i• the mean while many things according to the flesh […] upon him▪•• th••••••• […] ⟨p. 184⟩pray, forgive us ••• deb•• […] by the merit of Christ, […] doth repose all his fiudci•, •• […] be pardoned, so they shall […] sins. Whosoever therefo•• shall not do• the will of the Fathe•• […] is, shall not s••die from his […] performance thereof, (for othe• […] to do it is no• inciden•• […] life) he neither hath known […] Father no• Christ, he is not […] God, and as y•t▪ wanteth the […] •• Gods Children, and so in that •• spect shall be a• hypocri•• although he call to Christ, L••d• […] that in his hea•t he doth […] knowledge the Lord, wherein […] ••n call him▪ Lo•d, but […] of a true faith▪ All these things […] ▪
Ide• in Mat. 7▪ s•ct, 6. pag. 〈…〉▪ Therefore a godly man thus 〈…〉 not sinne, for that he cannot be •• uen ouer from the heart to 〈…〉 and sinne, as it is the ma•ner 〈…〉 wicked; but with the Law of God in minde he shall be still deligh•••▪ for that the seede of God, of his word, and the Spirit of his children abideth with him, and for that h•• is borne of God▪ yet withall▪〈…〉 that hee hath no good in his 〈…〉 he doth commit many things which he hate•h, and are sinne•〈…〉 but because hee •• not delighted therewith in the inward 〈…〉 in his heart is addicted •• Christ▪⟨p. 183⟩and before all thing• de•••eth to b• correspondent to the image of Christ, neither finally maketh doubt, that all things ••• remitted vnto him for the merits of Christ, and that he shal 〈…〉 to that lik•ne•▪ there shall also be no 〈…〉 vnto him, although a sinner, for that he abideth in Christ
Idem. in Psal. •. v. 1. pag. •. F••t••• it is to be observed, that the Prophet saith not, Blessed is […] •• […] been •icked, • sins malicious, […] ••• b• hath ••t had […] with th•• hath not followed their […], […] their f•••s hath […] for […] ⟨p. 185⟩•••m that are blessed, and can live according to Gods Law, the seed •f God, and the good spirit doth so ••uaile, that they cannot sin, that […], become perverse and wicked with the whole heart▪ Which thing •• express• words Joh. •ap. •. 3. doth touch, for that they are borne of God. But we daily sin all, as he con••sseth c. 1. and not a few likewise are overtaken with evil, do follow for • time the consultations of the wicked, •• happened to David, Peter▪ and others; whereof the […], to satisfy his pleasure, did admit both adultery and […] ▪ the other, in des••• of his life, was so farr• drawn, that he denied his Saviour.
Idem. in Psal. •. v. 1. pag. •. F••t••• it is to be obserued, that the Proph•t saith not, Blessed is 〈…〉••〈…〉 been •icked, • sinnes m•licious, 〈…〉••• b• hath ••t had 〈…〉 with th•• hath not follow•d their 〈…〉, 〈…〉 their f•••s hath 〈…〉 for 〈…〉⟨p. 185⟩•••m that are blessed, and can liue according to Gods Law, the seede •f God, and the good spirit doth so ••uaile, that they cannot sinne, that 〈…〉, b•come peruerse and wicked with the whole heart▪ Which thing •• express• words Ioh. •ap. •. 3. doth touch, for that they are borne of God. But we dayly sin al, as he con••sseth c. 1. and not a few likewise are ouertaken with euill, doe follow for • time the consultations of the wicked, •• happened to Dauid, Peter▪ and others; whereof the 〈…〉, to satisfie his pleasure, did admit both adult•rie and 〈…〉▪ the other, in des••• of his life, was so farr• drawn•, that hee denied his Saiuiour.
Here by the sentence of Buc••, both David, and […] are again placed in the number of them, who• although they sin, yet sin they not, or ••• […] with the who•• heart.
Here by the sentence of Buc••, both Dauid, and 〈…〉 are again• placed in the number of them, who• although they sinne, yet sinne they not, or •••〈…〉 with the who•• heart.
Presently he […] touching Mau•••• and the Thief, saying▪⟨p. 186⟩Manasseh King of Judah may […] have sitten in the seat of the […] and wholly in malice to have […] with them, then whom […] of the Kings did ever establish […] Idolatry against the Lord, or […] more innocent blood of the P•• phets. With him happily you […] combine the Thief cruci•••• […] the Lord Christ. Both of them […] were the sons of God▪• therwise neither could he pray […] God from his heart, and […] pardon of his sins; neither […] the other have attained the •• franchment of Paradise. For such […] are not borne of God, as they understand nothing of the things of God▪ (which Paul affirmeth of them) •• there can they indeed hear: (which thing our Saviour doth testify […] 8.) so have they not any ability •• there to seek or pray for any […] matter. Therefore both of them […] ordained to life, and chosen to ••• uation, before the creation of mankind; and therefore indeed neither ⟨p. 187⟩of them was wicked, ungodly, malicious, though they committed •anythings wickedly, ungodly, and […], for that a full and […] contempt of God, and the […] and solid study of naughtiness […] never in them, although they had settled their seat with perverse wicked men, that is, a resolute course […] life they had determined amongst them. H•• ill•. But if the Elect yea even before they be regenerate, do […] in themselves a certain seed of God and of Piety▪ how much more is it so to be sentenced touching the Elect now being regenerated? If therefore such a seed of Piety be always r••iant •n them then do they never prostitute th•• s•lues into any […] the whole will, […] do […]
P••sently hee 〈…〉 touching Mau•••• and the Thiefe, saying▪⟨p. 186⟩Manasses King of Iuda may 〈…〉 haue sitten in the seat of the 〈…〉 and wholly in malice to haue 〈…〉 with them, then whom 〈…〉 of the Kings did euer establish 〈…〉 Idolatry against the Lord, or 〈…〉 more innocent bloud of the P•• phets. With him happily you 〈…〉 combine the Thiefe cruci••••〈…〉 the Lord Christ. Both of them 〈…〉 were the sonnes of God▪• therwise neither could hee pray 〈…〉 God from his heart, and 〈…〉 pardon of his sinnes; neither 〈…〉 the other haue attained the •• franchment of Paradise. For s•ch 〈…〉 are not borne of God, as they vnderstand nothing of the things of God▪ (which Paul affirmeth of them) •• ther can they indeed heare: (which thing our Sauiour doth testifie 〈…〉 8.) so haue they not any abilitie •• ther to seeke or pray for any 〈…〉 matter. Therfore both of them 〈…〉 ordained to life, and chosen to ••• uation, before the creation of mankinde; and therefore indeede neither ⟨p. 187⟩of them was wicked, vngodly, malicious, though they committed anythings wickedly, vngodly, and , for that a full and contempt of God, and the and solid study of naughtinesse neuer in them, although they had setled their seat with peruerse wicked men, that is, a resolute course life they had determined amongst them. H ill. But if the Elect yea euen before they be regenerate, doe in themselues a certaine seed of God and of Pietie how much more is it so to be sentenced touching the Elect now being regenerated? If therefore such a seede of Pietie bee alwaies riant n them then do they neuer prstitute th slues into any the whole will, doe
The Explanation of the […], How it cometh […] pass, That the same […] man the evil that he will […] not, that he doth, […] that respect also doth […] it; and the good that […] would he doth not, […] in that respect he also […] it.
The Explanation of the 〈…〉, How it commeth 〈…〉 passe, That the same 〈…〉 man the euil that he will 〈…〉 not, that hee doth, 〈…〉 that respect also doth 〈…〉 it; and the good that 〈…〉 would hee doth not, 〈…〉 in that respect hee also 〈…〉 it.
IF any man doth […] understand, how it falleth out that […] same man […] things which are right, and yet doth them not; and the evils which he would not (but loatheth and detesteth) yet he doth: let him read Bucer upon the place of the Apostle Rom. 7. where how ⟨p. 189⟩that can be, he handleth that question most learnedly and devoutly▪••d by the examples of David, when he committed adultery; and of Peter, when he de••ed Christ, he doth manifest the matter before our […]. The like •ee doth ••br• controllers. Eccles. in […] de Justif. pag▪ 132▪
IF any man doth 〈…〉 vnderstand, how it falleth out that 〈…〉 same man 〈…〉 things which are right, and yet doth them not; and the euils which hee would not (but loatheth and detesteth) yet he doth: let him reade Bucer vpon the place of the Apostle Rom. 7. where how ⟨p. 189⟩that can be, he handleth that question most learnedly and deuou•ly▪••d by the examples of Dauid, when he committed adulterie; and of Peter, when hee de••ed Christ, hee doth manifest the matter before our 〈…〉. The like •ee doth ••br• contro••rs. Eccles. in 〈…〉 de Iustif. pag▪ 132▪
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
•••
▪
〈…〉
••
▪
•
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
•
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
•
•
⟨p. 146⟩
to be made by their sinnes 〈…〉 of God, and to be 〈…〉 from the grace of God▪•••〈…〉 God, though ••• doe neu••〈…〉 his fatherlike •ffection 〈…〉 them, o• change his purpose of 〈…〉•nto the• by Christ 〈…〉 life, yet being displ••s•d with 〈…〉 sinn•• the effects of his lo••〈…〉 change into the effects of a 〈…〉 hat••d; hat•ed I say 〈…〉 agai•••〈…〉 children▪ b•t hi•〈…〉 both internally in 〈…〉〈…〉 externally, of such is do 〈…〉•• wardly while he do•• bring •o 〈…〉 that they feele a 〈…〉 them, God to be •ngry 〈…〉 them, and themselues made 〈…〉 of death▪ outwardly againe▪〈…〉 he worketh so that they haue •••• rience of God•〈…〉 against 〈…〉 in the 〈…〉 of 〈…〉 pody and thinge•〈…〉 T•••• fore, heereof there i•〈…〉 for that both I •y s•l••〈…〉 both▪ know and 〈…〉• that 〈…〉 when his Saints do sin, 〈…〉
⟨p. 147⟩
angry with their sinnes, and doth hate sinne in them, and punish them most extreamely, and yet not •s enemy to the Saints. For hee alwaies doth correct them as a father, but as an enemie of wickednes and vice euen in his children;
•
•
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
••
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
•
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
••
•
〈…〉
▪
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
⟨p. 161⟩
vs from the wombe of our Mother, without the holy Spirit, which is called flesh, Col. 3. Thus Bucer. Therfore it is apparant, That this distinction is not monstrous.
•
〈…〉
•
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
▪
•
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
〈…〉
•
〈…〉
▪
〈…〉
〈…〉
⟨p. 165⟩
sinne: which thing a little after 〈…〉 reporteth saying; The good that ••••ld I doe not, but the euill which I hate in the Spirit, that I doe a• car•all; and (by and by) for I am de••ghted with the Law of God according to my inward 〈…〉; for I s•• o•• Law in my members ••••lling to the Law of my minde, and leading 〈…〉 to the Law of sinne which is in my members. Loe here an expli•a•ion and confirmation of that he spoke in the beginning, 〈…〉, when hee said, 〈…〉•arnall sold vnder sinne. Therefore the Regenerate, in respect of the inward man which hateth sin, they doe it not with all the heart, for that in spirit they detest it▪ and are as vnwilling seruants vnto it;
•••
⟨p. 168⟩
inward as the outward m••〈…〉 rather (after a sort) they 〈…〉 said, it is not they who doe 〈…〉 Sinne dwelling within ther•〈…〉 the reason is, for that the 〈…〉 doth not cons••t ••〈…〉 and yet in the mean• time th••〈…〉 not excused from sinne, neither 〈…〉 their sinn•s extenuated. For 〈…〉 though not according to the 〈…〉 pull part, that is the inward 〈…〉 they sinne not, but onely according to the outward, and in mind 〈…〉 they serue the Law of God, but •• the flesh the Law of sinne; yet •• very deed they are such as doe 〈…〉 by their owne proper will.
. And they l••• righteousnesse▪ and hate i•iquity. Psal▪ 44. For they lo•• the law of God▪ Ps•l. 118. they like-wise lament with t•• Apostle, that they are capti••s▪〈…〉 so
⟨p. 171⟩
vnder sin. Ro. 7. How thē can they of destinate malice sin, & so with their whol• hart• Aug. To. 7. de •orr. & gratia, c. 9. by the example of Dauid and Peter doth teach, That all Saints, when they sinne▪ doe sinne being troubled, for that Christ doth somewhat turn away his face from them, according to that in the Psalme. 29. Thou turnedst thy face from m•, and I •as troubled. Now to sinne being thus troubled, is not to sinne by endeuour, & of purposed malice, but rather, besides the purpose of the mind.
▪
•
•
••
•••
••
•
⟨p. 174⟩
that in that which they loue th•• continue forth to the end: it i•• good consequent, That the Sa••• doe not sinne of purpose, or det•• minate malice.
workes thereof, and persist in them; ••d yet in the meane space to dis•••ble piety, and to brag of the spi•i• &c. The former sort hee comfor•eth while hee saith, that they are •ed by the spirit; and are vnder the l•w: to the other sort hee threateneth aeternall destruction. Nay somtime it falleth out▪ That the Saints doe fall and fulfill the lusts of the flesh; as Dauid fell with a greiuous •nd terrible downefall: besides, hee was the cause of many mens murther, when his will was, that Ʋriah should perish in the battel: and therby also he gaue occasion to the enemies of God, to boast against the people of God, to adore their owne Idolls, and to blaspheme the God of Israel. Peter like-wise did horribly fall, when hee denied his Maister. But yet although those sinnes were h•inous, yet were they committed, not of the contempt of God▪ or malice fore-thought, but of infirmity. Besides, being admonished they doe not perseuer obstinate in their sins,
⟨p. 176⟩
but repented. Therefore •〈…〉 Doctor did no• well, 〈…〉 in the Schooles, that 〈…〉 Christ with the whole 〈…〉 with his whole heart did 〈…〉 Christ. Luth•r he••〈…〉
▪
•
•
•
▪
〈…〉
▪
••
▪
•
•••
▪
〈…〉
•
••
••••
••
•••
〈…〉
•
••••
▪
▪
▪
▪
⟨p. 178⟩
out▪ how it came to 〈…〉 the same man being▪〈…〉 doth both will and 〈…〉〈…〉 which he doth▪ The 〈…〉 That it so commeth to 〈…〉 that in some man there is a 〈…〉 will; one whereby he doth 〈…〉 to the Law▪ another whereby 〈…〉 doth that which he 〈…〉 which followeth the 〈…〉 the Law; another which is 〈…〉 knowledge drawne from the 〈…〉 and which is of thinges 〈…〉 else that this so commeth to 〈…〉 for that in the regenerate▪ there 〈…〉 double man, inward and 〈…〉 mind and flesh, whereof one 〈…〉 to the Law of God; the 〈…〉 to the Law of sinne▪ From 〈…〉 therefore it commeth to passe 〈…〉 the Saints doe both the euill 〈…〉 would not and the good 〈…〉 they doe not▪ wherefore, 〈…〉 not with full consent, ••• with 〈…〉 whole will, not totally, that is 〈…〉 to the double man.
▪
〈…〉
•
••
〈…〉
〈…〉
•
•
〈…〉
•
▪
〈…〉
〈…〉
••
▪
〈…〉
••
〈…〉
the Elect) what they 〈…〉, they sinne therefore for that they are tur•ed out of the way by 〈…〉 lusts of the flesh, so that they 〈…〉 not attend vpon the knowne 〈…〉 but they neuer so farre d••line, 〈…〉 they haue and persecute ••••〈…〉 but forthwith rather out of the la• thereof they doe begin to desie, a•• detest, that wherein they sinn••▪
▪ for God will not impute his sinnes vnto him. Wherefore, neither shall they bee sinnes, as they are no debts▪ which the Creditor hath 〈…〉, 〈…〉 he 〈…〉▪ b• obliged, and hath ye• m•de no payment▪ For which 〈…〉 he that is Christ•▪ as he 〈…〉▪ that is, be wholly giue••, and studi•• to sinne, which onely God imputeth and accompteth for sinne: so it is necessaire, that hee endeuour ••e studie of his will to his power, neither accompt any thing •••• p•• cious, then to compose himselfe •• tally according to his word▪ Ye• i• the meane while many things according to the flesh 〈…〉 vppon him▪•• th•••••••〈…〉
⟨p. 184⟩
pray, forgiue vs ••• deb••〈…〉 by the merit of Christ, 〈…〉 doth repose all his fiudci•, ••〈…〉 be pa•doned, so they shall 〈…〉 sinnes. Whosoeuer therefo•• shall not do• the will of the Fathe••〈…〉 is, shall not s••die from his 〈…〉 performance thereof, (for othe•〈…〉 to doe it is no• inciden••〈…〉 life) hee neither hath knowne 〈…〉 Father no• Christ, he is not 〈…〉 God, and as y•t▪ want•th the 〈…〉•• Gods Children, and so in that •• spect shall be a• hypocri•• although hee call to Christ, L••d•〈…〉 that in his hea•t hee doth 〈…〉 knowledge the Lord, wherein 〈…〉••n call him▪ Lo•d, but 〈…〉 of a true faith▪ All these things 〈…〉▪