pp. 400–471321 passagespart 5 of 9
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sol. The immortality of the Soul, and the resurrection of the body, are conjoined: For the Soul without the body, can be for ever, because it is the form of the body; though God for the time do, by his power and grace, provide for the Soul in glory, yet it is not at full happiness, till it be joined to the body again: For, without the body it hath no use of vegetation, or senses, but only of reason. But for the Argument of the Apostle, it holds good of that part of man which is in question, which is the body of man: For the bodies of Godly men are more miserable then other men; kept under and exposed to many restraints and pains, either by mortification, or persecution, which the bodies of wicked men are not exposed unto.
Sol. The immortalitie of the Soule, and the resurrection of the body, are conioyned: For the Soule without the body, can be for euer, because it is the forme of the body; though God for the time do, by his power and grace, prouide for the Soule in glory, yet it is not at full happinesse, till it be ioyned to the body againe: For, without the body it hath no vse of vegetation, or sences, but onely of reason. But for the Argument of the Apostle, it holds good of that part of man which is in question, which is the body of man: For the bodies of Godly men are more miserable then other men; kept vnder and exposed to many restraints and paines, eyther by mortification, or persecution, which the bodies of wicked men are not exposed vnto.
Ob. 3. It is said of the spirit of Princes, that it returneth to his Earth, and in the day of death his thoughts perish: So the Soul thinks of nothing after death, till the day of judgement.
Ob. 3. It is said of the spirit of Princes, that it returneth to his Earth, and in the day of death his thoughts perish: So the Soule thinkes of nothing after death, till the day of iudgement.
Sol. The place is corruptly alleged two ways: One in the Words, the other in the Sense: for the text doth not say, That his Spirit returneth to his earth; but thus, his Spirit returneth, viz. ⟨p. 429⟩out of his body to God, and he not it, returneth to the earth, viz. in respect of his body: for the other, these words, his thoughts perish, must not be understood of his understanding after death, but of his projects, while he lived. For men are exhorted not to trust in Princes: For they may die, and then all their promises and projects▪ will be of no use, and come to nothing.
Sol. The place is corruptly alleaged two waies: One in the Words, the other in the Sence: for the text doth not say, That his Spirit returneth to his earth; but thus, his Spirit returneth, viz. ⟨p. 429⟩out of his body to God, and he not it, returneth to the earth, viz. in respect of his body: for the other, these words, his thoughts perish, must not be vnderstood of his vnderstanding after death, but of his proiects, while hee liued. For men are exhorted not to trust in Princes: For they may die, and then all their promises and proiects▪ will bee of no vse, and come to nothing.
Sol. That the souls of the godly in heaven do praise God, is manifest, Revel 5.11, 13.14. and 19.1. Now the Scriptures cannot be contrary one to another: and therefore the places in the Psalms must not be taken simply, but only in some respect. The dead do praise God, but not as the li•ing did in their lives: their praises cannot provoke other men to believe in God, or serve him, as in this life they might.
Sol. That the soules of the godly in heauen doe praise God, is manifest, Reuel 5.11, 13.14. and 19.1. Now the Scriptures cannot bee contrary one to another: and therefore the places in the Psalmes must not bee taken simply, but onely in some respect. The dead doe praise God, but not as the li•ing did in their liues: their praises cannot prouoke other men to beleeue in God, or serue him, as in this life they might.
Thus of the immortality of the soul.
Thus of the immortality of the soule.
The next thing to be inquired after,1 is, about the original of the soul: and about this point in several ages divers men have breathed divers and strange conceits, erring because they knew not, or regarded not the Scriptures.
The next thing to bee inquired after,1 is, about the originall of the soule: and about this point in seueral ages diuers men haue breathed diuers and strange conceits, erring because they knew not, or regarded not the Scriptures.
First, some conceived so highly of the soul, as to think, it was no creature, but uncreated, and eternal, without beginning, but this must needs be false.
First, some conceiued so highly of the soule, as to think, it was no creature, but vncreated, and eternall, without beginning, but this must needes bee false.
1. Because then the soul should be God, and infinite too, For God only is uncreated. 2. Because then the soul had understanding, ⟨p. 430⟩and thoughts, and willed from eternity, whereas till it was in our bodies, it did not work: and to imagine, it should be as a dead lump all that while, is monstrously absurd.
1. Because then the soule should bee God, and infinite too, For God onely is vncreated. 2. Because then the soule had vnderstanding, ⟨p. 430⟩and thoughts, and willed from eternity, whereas till it was in our bodies, it did not work: and to imagine, it should bee as a dead lump all that while, is monstrously absurd.
Secondly, others have conceived, that when men die, their souls go into the bodies of other men, that be borne; and so our souls heretofore were the souls of some men that be dead: This was the opinion of divers of the Philosophers: and it is apparent, that divers of the Jews were infected with it: for about Christ they said, some, that he was Elijah, some, that he was Jeremiah; and some, one of the Prophets, and some, John Baptist. Now they saw that his body was not theirs, and therefore they thought, that his soul was the soul of some of them. Now this opinion cannot be true.
Secondly, others haue conceiued, that when men die, their soules goe into the bodies of other men, that be borne; and so our soules heeretofore were the soules of some men that bee dead: This was the opinion of diuers of the Philosophers: and it is apparant, that diuers of the Iewes were infected with it: for about Christ they said, some, that hee was Elias, some, that he was Ieremias; and some, one of the Prophets, and some, Iohn Baptist. Now they saw that his body was not theirs, and therefore they thought, that his soule was the soule of some of them. Now this opinion cannot bee true.
1. Because no Scripture gives any notice of it: For in that place the conceit of the Jews is told with dislike. 2. Because the souls that were delivered out of the miseries of this life, should be brought from their blessedness into misery again, which in most absurd.
1. Because no Scripture giues any notice of it: For in that place the conceit of the Iewes is told with dislike. 2. Because the soules that were deliuered out of the miseries of this life, should be brought from their blessednes into misery againe, which in most absurd.
Thirdly, Others have imagined, that the Angels should beget our souls, as our parents beget our bodies: But this is extremely absurd.
Thirdly, Others haue imagined, that the Angels should beget our soules, as our parents beget our bodies: But this is extremely absurd.
1. Because then our souls should be in the Image of Angels, whereas they were made in the Image of God. 2. Because this was an heresy long since condemned, and with hatred cast out of the Church.
1. Because then our soules should bee in the Image of Angels, whereas they were made in the Image of God. 2. Because this was an heresy long since condemned, and with hatred cast out of the Church.
Fourthly, many Divines, both of ancient and modern Writers, have declared themselves to be of the mind, that the soul comes from the parents by generation,1 per traducem, and that the parents do beget the whole man, which consists of soul as well as body. Now, though it be true, that this opinion hath had, and still hath great patrons, and that it may not be denied, but that it is defended with marvellous great appearance of reason and truth; yet it is rejected, and hath been by the greater part of sound Divines, and by reasons unanswerable: for, if the soul come from the parents, then it must come either from the body of the parents, or from their souls. Now, it is apparent, it cannot come from their bodies, 1. Because a bodily substance cannot beget a spiritual substance, because it cannot derive from it self that which it hath not. 2. Because the soul must consist of the four elements, of which the body is compounded: but, it is apparent, there are no bodily humours in the soul; for, it is not hot, nor cold, nor moist, nor dry. 3. Because nothing that is mortal, can beget a thing that is immortal, such as the soul hath been proved to be.
Fourthly, many Diuines, both of antient and modern Writers, haue declared themselues to be of the minde, that the soule comes from the parents by generation,1 per traducem, and that the parents doo beget the whole man, which consists of soule as well as body. Now, though it bee true, that this opinion hath had, and still hath great patrones, and that it may not be denied, but that it is defended with maruellous great appearance of reason and truth; yet it is reiected, and hath been by the greater part of sound Diuines, and by reasons vnanswerable: for, if the soule come from the parents, then it must come either from the body of the parents, or from their soules. Now, it is apparant, it cannot come from their bodies, 1. Because a bodily substance cannot beget a spirituall substance, because it cannot deriue from it self that which it hath not. 2. Because the soule must consist of the foure elements, of which the body is compounded: but, it is apparant, there are no bodily humours in the soule; for, it is not hot, nor cold, nor moist, nor dry. 3. Because nothing that is mortall, can beget a thing that is immortall, such as the soule hath been proued to be.
Nor can the soul come from the soul of the parents,
Nor can the soule come from the soule of the parents,
First, because if it did, either the whole soul was derived of the parents, or but a part of it. If the whole soul was derived, then the parents ⟨p. 432⟩should die: nor can a part of the soul be derived, because the soul is indivisible: there can be no partition in an essence which is simple and uncompounded.
First, because if it did, either the whole soule was deriued of the parents, or but a part of it. If the whole soule was deriued, then the parents ⟨p. 432⟩should die: nor can a part of the soule bee deriueed, because the soule is indiuisible: there can be no partition in an essence which is simple and vncompounded.
Secondly, we know, that the Angels produce not Angels: nor can the souls of men produce souls, because they are spirits, as the Angels are.
Secondly, wee knowe, that the Angels produce not Angels: nor can the soules of men produce soules, because they are spirits, as the Angels are.
Nor can the soul come from the whole man:
Nor can the soule come from the whole man:
First, because it is evident by experience, that after the parents have done the work of generation, the first matter lies divers days in the womb; in which, the parts of the body are secretly formed, before it have life, or a living and quickening soul: which is an evident demonstration, that from the parents comes nothing but the bodily substance, which is fashioned by degrees, to be a meet Tabernacle for the soul afterwards to be infused into.
First, because it is euident by experience, that after the parents haue done the work of generation, the first matter lies diuers daies in the womb; in which, the parts of the body are secretly formed, before it haue life, or a liuing and quickning soule: which is an euident demonstration, that from the parents comes nothing but the bodily substance, which is fashioned by degrees, to be a meet Tabernacle for the soule afterwards to bee infused into.
Secondly, because if the parents did propagate the soul, they must propagate such a soul as at that time they had; which cannot be: for, then godly parents should derive a soul to their children, which at the least in part was regenerate. But this is evidently against all Scripture; all confessing, that the child is born infected with original sin.
Secondly, because if the parents did propagate the soule, they must propagate such a soule as at that time they had; which cannot bee: for, then godly parents should deriue a soule to their children, which at the least in part was regenerate. But this is euidently against all Scripture; all confessing, that the childe is born infected with originall sin.
Thirdly, because it is contrary to the Scriptures; which acknowledge, that the soul was formed by God himself: which was true both of our first parent Adam, Gen. 2.7. and of the souls of all his posterity, which are expressly said to be ⟨p. 433⟩made by GOD, Isaiah 57. verse 16.
Thirdly, because it is contrary to the Scriptures; which acknowledge, that the soule was formed by God himself: which was true both of our first parent Adam, Gen. 2.7. and of the soules of all his posterity, which are expresly said to bee ⟨p. 433⟩made by GOD, Esay 57. verse 16.
Lastly, it remains then, that the souls come from God. Now, if the souls come from God, then it must needs be, as GOD is the material cause, or as he is the efficient cause.
Lastly, it remains then, that the soules come from God. Now, if the soules come from God, then it must needs bee, as GOD is the materiall cause, or as he is the efficient cause.
It is true, that some have imagined, that the soul of man was made of the substance of God, because it is said, GOD breathed into man the breath of life, Gen. 2.7. as if he infused into him somewhat from himself, as a part of his divine substance. And the Apostle Paul saith, Acts 17.18. We are the Progeny of God: and Saint Peter saith, We partake of the divine Nature, 2. Pet. 1.4.
It is true, that some haue imagined, that the soule of man was made of the substance of God, because it is said, GOD breathed into man the breath of life, Gen. 2.7. as if hee infused into him somewhat from himself, as a part of his diuine substance. And the Apostle Paul saith, Acts 17.18. We are the Progeny of God: and Saint Peter saith, We partake of the diuine Nature, 2. Pet. 1.4.
Now, this opinion cannot be true, and was worthily condemned by the Fathers, as heretical: for,
Now, this opinion cannot bee true, and was worthily condemned by the Fathers, as hereticall: for,
Then man should be God. For, whatsoever God begets from himself, is God: and therefore we say, Christ is God.
Then man should bee God. For, whatsoeuer God begets from himself, is God: and therefore we say, Christ is God.
Then some part of God's nature should be infected with sin and ignorance, and be damned in hell too; which is wonderful blasphemous to believe.
Then some part of God's nature should bee infected with sinne and ignorance, and be damned in hell too; which is wonderfull blasphemous to beleeue.
Now, for the places alleged, That in Genes. 2. must be understood figuratively: for, God hath not properly breath; but he meaneth, that God after a wonderful manner did infuse the soul into the body. And for the place in the Acts, we are said to be the progeny of God, not in regard of substance, but in respect of resemblance in gifts, with which man's nature is adorned. And for the place in Peter, we are said to partake of the ⟨p. 434⟩divine nature in the same sense, namely, as we are qualified with gifts; as, wisdom, goodness, holiness, in some kind of likeness of God.
Now, for the places alleaged, That in Genes. 2. must be vnderstood figuratiuely: for, God hath not properly breath; but he meaneth, that God after a wonderfull manner did infuse the soule into the body. And for the place in the Acts, we are said to be the progeny of God, not in regard of substance, but in respect of resemblance in gifts, with which man's nature is adorned. And for the place in Peter, we are said to partake of the ⟨p. 434⟩diuine nature in the same sense, namely, as we are qualified with gifts; as, wisdome, goodnes, holinesse, in some kinde of likenes of God.
It remains then, that we are of God effectually, because God hath created our souls,1 and formed them in us. This then is the truth, that God doth create the particular soul of every man, and inhere it to the body, when it is formed and distinguished in the parts thereof. This may be proved diversly.
It remains then, that we are of God effectually, because God hath created our soules,1 and formed them in vs. This then is the truth, that God doth create the particular soule of euery man, and inhere it to the body, when it is formed and distinguished in the parts thereof. This may bee proued diuersly.
First, it is clear, it was so done with the soul of Adam: for, his body was already framed, and then his soul breathed into him. Now, if the soul of Eve, and of all others, had another manner of beginning than the creation of GOD, it would have been mentioned in the Scriptures: but that is no where mentioned.
First, it is cleer, it was so done with the soule of Adam: for, his body was already framed, and then his soule breathed into him. Now, if the soule of Eue, and of all others, had another manner of beginning than the creation of GOD, it would haue been mentioned in the Scriptures: but that is no where mentioned.
Secondly, Moses calls God the God of the spirits of all flesh, Numb. 16.22. and 27.16.
Secondly, Moses cals God the God of the spirits of all flesh, Numb. 16.22. and 27.16.
Thirdly, David saith, The Lord fashioneth the hearts of all men alike, Psalm. 33.15. It is GOD's work then to create the heart.
Thirdly, Dauid saith, The Lord fashioneth the hearts of all men alike, Psalm. 33.15. It is GOD's work then to create the heart.
Fourthly, Solomon saith, Eccles. 12.7. The body returns to the dust, and the soul to GOD that gave it: in the dissolution of all things, they return to the first causes and matter. As the body may be proved originally to be of the earth, because it returns to dust: so must the soul be of God, because it returns to God which is said to have given it.
Fourthly, Salomon saith, Eccles. 12.7. The body returns to the dust, and the soule to GOD that gaue it: in the dissolution of all things, they return to the first causes and matter. As the body may be proued originally to bee of the earth, because it returns to dust: so must the soule bee of God, because it returns to God which is said to haue giuen it.
Fifthly, the Prophet Isaiah useth this phrase concerning God, and in his name: The souls which ⟨p. 435⟩I have made, Isaiah 57.16. Do you ask how the soul comes into the body? The Lord answers, I made it.
Fiftly, the Prophet Esay vseth this phrase concerning God, and in his name: The soules which ⟨p. 435⟩I haue made, Esay 57.16. Doo you ask how the soule comes into the body? The Lord answers, I made it.
Sixthly, the Prophet Ezekiel, showing how man becomes a living creature, speaks thus: Thus saith the Lord to these bones: I will cause a spirit to enter into them, and they shall live, Ezech. 37.5.
Sixtly, the Prophet Ezechiel, shewing how man becoms a liuing creature, speaks thus: Thus saith the Lord to these bones: I will cause a spirit to enter into them, and they shall liue, Ezech. 37.5.
Seventhly, the words of the Prophet Zechariah are yet more clear. Thus saith the Lord: The Lord which spreads out the heavens, and foundeth the earth, and formed the spirit of man in him. Out of these words it may be proved, that God created the soul of every man, and that it is his only work. For, first, he saith expressly, God formed the spirit in man. Secondly, this work of God is compared to two other works, viz. the spreading out of the heavens, and the laying of the foundation of the earth. Now, it is evident, that those two things he did of himself, of nothing, without any means.
Seuenthly, the words of the Prophet Zacharie are yet more cleer. Thus saith the Lord: The Lord which spreads out the heauens, and foundeth the earth, and formed the spirit of man in him. Out of these words it may be proued, that God created the soule of euery man, and that it is his onely work. For, first, he saith expresly, God formed the spirit in man. Secondly, this work of God is compared to two other works, viz. the spreading out of the heauens, and the laying of the foundation of the earth. Now, it is euident, that those two things hee did of himself, of nothing, without any means.
Lastly, that place in Hebr. 12.9. is most clear. The words are these: We have had the fathers of our flesh, which chastised us, and we reverenced them: how much more should we be subject to the Father of our spirits, and live? Where is a manifest antithesis between the flesh and the Spirit; and the fathers of our flesh, and God the Father of our spirit: we had our flesh from our parents, and our spirit from God. I might add the reason, taken from the manner of giving of the soul of Christ: for, he was made in all things like to us, sin only excepted. Now, it is evident, ⟨p. 436⟩that Christ's soul was not begot by carnal propagation; and therefore it was created of God.
Lastly, that place in Hebr. 12.9. is most cleer. The words are these: Wee haue had the fathers of our flesh, which chastised vs, and we reuerenced them: how much more should wee bee subiect to the Father of our spirits, and liue? Where is a manifest antithesis between the flesh and the Spirit; and the fathers of our flesh, and God the Father of our spirit: wee had our flesh from our parents, and our spirit from God. I might adde the reason, taken from the manner of giuing of the soule of Christ: for, he was made in all things like to vs, sin onely excepted. Now, it is euident, ⟨p. 436⟩that Christ's soule was not begot by carnall propagation; and therefore it was created of God.
Object. Now, against this is strongly objected, that, if the soul be created immediately of God, then it is created either pure, or sinful; if pure, then how is it, that the soul is guilty of original sin? if impure, then how can it be avoided, but that God must be the Author of sin?
Obiect. Now, against this is strongly obiected, that, if the soule be created immediately of God, then it is created either pure, or sinfull; if pure, then how is it, that the soule is guilty of originall sinne? if impure, then how can it be auoided, but that God must be the Author of sin?
Answer. This reason drave diverse of the Fathers in the time of Hierome, especially the Western Fathers, to believe, that the soul was propagated from the parents: and Saint Augustine is doubtful which opinion to take to, the inconveniences of each opinion seemed so great.
Answer. This reason draue diuerse of the Fathers in the time of Hierome, especially the Western Fathers, to beleeue, that the soule was propagated from the parents: and Saint Augustine is doubtfull which opinion to take to, the inconueniences of each opinion seemed so great.
But, other Divines answer this objection in this manner:
But, other Diuines answer this obiection in this manner:
First, that the soul is created of God, pure, but joined to a body conceived in sin: which is no injustice in God, because he delivers the soul but into such an estate as man had cast himself into by his own wilful sin, bringing this corruption not only upon himself, but upon all his posterity, who fell in him. He, by agreement with GOD, being as the common sort of mankind, was with him to stand or fall, in that general respect. Nor may it be doubted, but that the body may work upon the soul: as we see by experience, when the body is full of choleric humours, it inclines the soul to anger; and so when the body is burdened with melancholy humours, it evidently makes sadness even in the very mind, &c.
First, that the soule is created of God, pure, but ioined to a body conceiued in sinne: which is no iniustice in God, because hee deliuers the soule but into such an estate as man had cast himself into by his owne wilfull sinne, bringing this corruption not onely vpon himself, but vpon all his posterity, who fell in him. Hee, by agreement with GOD, being as the common sort of mankinde, was with him to stand or fall, in that generall respect. Nor may it be doubted, but that the body may work vpon the soule: as we see by experience, when the body is full of cholerick humours, it inclines the soule to anger; and so when the body is burdened with melancholy humours, it euidently makes sadnes euen in the very minde, &c.