pp. 400–471321 passagespart 6 of 9
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Another answer may be this: God creates the soul pure; but yet that soul is guilty of owing, though not of doing; debendi, though not agendi: it is charged with the debt of Adam, as children may be charged with their fathers debts. Now, this is one part of original sin. As for the other of corrupt inclination, it is to answer modestly, if we say we understand not, being assured of two things: The one, that God is the Father of spirits; and the other, that all men are infected with sin from the womb. Both are to be believed, though in this life we cannot explicate it: and what hurt is it if we be ignorant how sin entered into our natures, seeing it concerns us to know it is there, and to learn how to get our natures recovered?
Another answer may be this: God creates the soule pure; but yet that soule is guilty of owing, though not of dooing; debendi, though not agendi: it is charged with the debt of Adam, as children may be charged with their fathers debts. Now, this is one part of originall sinne. As for the other of corrupt inclination, it is to answer modestly, if we say we vnderstand not, being assured of two things: The one, that God is the Father of spirits; and the other, that all men are infected with sinne from the womb. Both are to bee beleeued, though in this life we cannot explicate it: and what hurt is it if wee bee ignorant how sinne entred into our natures, seeing it concerns vs to knowe it is there, and to learn how to get our natures recouered?
Objection 2. Other living creatures beget the like to themselves, both in body, and in soul too: and therefore by this doctrine, men should be more unable and unperfect than any living creature. For, if he do beget but only the body, he doth not beget one in specie like to himself.
Obiection 2. Other liuing creatures beget the like to themselues, both in body, and in soule too: and therefore by this doctrine, men should bee more vnable and vnperfect than any liuing creature. For, if hee doo begette but onely the body, he doth not beget one in specie like to himself.
Answer. Though GOD create the soul, yet it follows not, but that it may be truly said, that man begets a man, and that he is not more unperfect in generation than any other creature: for,
Answer. Though GOD create the soule, yet it followes not, but that it may bee truely said, that man begets a man, and that hee is not more vnperfect in generation than any other creature: for,
First, the Virgin Mary did bear Christ man in her womb: and Christ man is said to be of the seed of the Virgin, and yet his soul was created of God, as hath been showed before.
First, the Virgin Mary did bear Christ man in her womb: and Christ man is said to bee of the seed of the Virgin, and yet his soule was created of God, as hath been shewed before.
Secondly, though there be some dissimilitude in the generation of man, and of a beast, yet it doth not follow, that man is more unperfect. As for instance: The beast begets his young, and brings him forth strong, covered with a hide, able to feed himself presently, full of leaping, and other actions: But man brings forth an Infant, weak, crying, naked, unable to feed it self. What, is man therefore more unperfect? No. For, the perfection of generation doth not consist of these things, or in these things. For here man excels all other living creatures in the world in generation, because he is Gods instrument for the begetting of a body fit to be united to such a soul. God also doth hereby commend the generation of man, and dignify it, that he is pleased so to work in mans generation, as he doth not in any other creature, vouchsafing to give unto mans generation such an admirable soul to his body. For, therefore was the creation of the first man more excellent then the creation of other creatures, because God, having framed his body of the dust of the earth, did infuse such a soul into him.
Secondly, though there bee some dissimilitude in the generation of man, and of a beast, yet it doth not follow, that man is more vnperfect. As for instance: The beast begettes his young, and brings him forth strong, couered with a hide, able to feed himselfe presently, full of leaping, and other actions: But man brings foorth an Infant, weak, crying, naked, vnable to feede it selfe. What, is man therefore more vnperfect? No. For, the perfection of generation doth not consist of these things, or in these things. For heere man excels all other liuing creatures in the world in generation, because hee is Gods instrument for the begetting of a body fit to be vnited to such a soule. God also doth heereby commend the generation of man, and dignify it, that hee is pleased so to work in mans generation, as he doth not in any other creature, vouchsafing to giue vnto mans generation such an admirable soule to his body. For, therefore was the creation of the first man more excellent then the creation of other creatures, because God, hauing framed his body of the dust of the earth, did infuse such a soule into him.
Object. It is a peevish objection that some make thus: If God create the soul in all men, then when any is born of Adultery, God should cooperate with the adulterer, and so be either the Author, or the approver of the sin, that will give the soul to such a wicked generation.
Obiect. It is a peeuish obiection that some make thus: If God create the soule in all men, then when any is born of Adulterie, God should cooperate with the adulterer, and so be either the Author, or the approuer of the sin, that will giue the soule to such a wicked generation.
Solut. Some answer thus: that God is not the author or approver, because out of evil he only ⟨p. 439⟩works good for his own glory.
Solut. Some answer thus: that God is not the author or approuer, because out of euill he onely ⟨p. 439⟩workes good for his owne glory.
Others answer, That God only cooperates with the action, not with the sin of the action, or the evil of the action, or the evil which is in the will of the agents.
Others answer, That God onely cooperates with the action, not with the sinne of the action, or the euill of the action, or the euill which is in the will of the agents.
But the best answer is theirs, that answer by a similitude thus: The earth hath received her nature and vigour from God, to nourish and bring forth the seed that is cast into it, without difference, whether the seed be lawfully taken out of the barn, or stolen by fraud. The stolen grain doth not cease to grow in the earth, nor is it to be expected, that nature should cast out such seed, and yet the earth doth not justify the action of him that stole the grain: so is it with God that works according to the grounds of nature, and his own decree and providence. He is not to be blamed for the evil of the action, when he works according to the rules of nature, and will glorify himself by raising a frame of good out of that which by men was ill done.
But the best answer is theirs, that answer by a similitude thus: The earth hath receiued her nature and vigour from God, to nourish and bring foorth the seed that is cast into it, without difference, whether the seed bee lawfully taken out of the barne, or stolne by fraud. The stolne graine doth not cease to growe in the earth, nor is it to bee expected, that nature should cast out such seed, and yet the earth doth not iustifie the action of him that stole the grain: so is it with God that works according to the grounds of nature, and his owne decree and prouidence. He is not to be blamed for the euill of the action, when he works according to the rules of nature, and will glorifie himselfe by raising a frame of good out of that which by men was ill done.
Object 4. We see, that children resemble the virtues or vices of their parents; and therefore as from the bodies of their parents they receive a likeness to them in body: so is it, that from their souls they receive this similitude of their virtues or vices.
Obiect 4. Wee see, that children resemble the vertues or vices of their parents; and therefore as from the bodies of their parents they receiue a likenes to them in body: so is it, that from their soules they receiue this similitude of their vertues or vices.
Solut. Experience shows, that this is not always true. For many children have no resemblance in them of their parents qualities. Secondly, where this is true, it is not because their souls are derived from the souls of their parents, ⟨p. 440⟩but they have it from the bodies of their parents: For the soul after suffers from the sympathy with the body, as by reason of certain humours in the bodies of parents, that incite wrath or grief, or lust, or the like, may come infection to the child, but not from their souls. Thirdly, rather the Argument may be retorted upon them, that inasmuch as the souls of all children are not like in qualities to the souls of their parents, that therefore they receive not their souls from their parents.
Solut. Experience shewes, that this is not alwaies true. For many children haue no resemblance in them of their parents qualities. Secondly, where this is true, it is not because their soules are deriued from the soules of their parents, ⟨p. 440⟩but they haue it from the bodies of their parents: For the soule after suffers from the sympathy with the body, as by reason of certaine humours in the bodies of parents, that incite wrath or griefe, or lust, or the like, may come infection to the childe, but not from their soules. Thirdly, rather the Argument may be retorted vpon them, that in asmuch as the soules of all children are not like in qualities to the soules of their parents, that therefore they receiue not their soules from their parents.
Solut. The soul is in the blood, but how? By the effect of it, which is life: otherwise the soul is neither devoured in the blood, nor depends upon it in it self.
Solut. The soule is in the blood, but how? By the effect of it, which is life: otherwise the soule is neither deuoured in the bloud, nor depends vpon it in it selfe.
Object. 6. It is said, Genes. 2. That God rested from all his works. Now if he did daily create new souls, then he rested not from all his works, but continues creation still.
Obiect. 6. It is said, Genes. 2. That God rested from all his works. Now if hee did daily create newe soules, then hee rested not from all his works, but continues creation still.
Solut. The meaning of Moses cannot be, that God rested simply from all creation. For then it must needs follow too, that the soul of Christ was not created▪ but propagated: which cannot be true. But his meaning is, that he rested from creation of things in specie; he made no more new sorts of things. That hinders not creation in individuo, which is a work of God, preserving those sorts he had made at the first, by creating successively a new supply, as in this ⟨p. 441⟩case of the souls of men. That God did not rest absolutely, is plain by the words of our Saviour Christ: My Father worketh hitherto, and I work, John 5.
Solut. The meaning of Moses cannot bee, that God rested simply from all creation. For then it must needes follow too, that the soule of Christ was not created▪ but propagated: which cannot bee true. But his meaning is, that he rested from creation of things in specie; hee made no more newe sorts of things. That hinders not creation in indiuiduo, which is a work of God, preseruing those sorts hee had made at the first, by creating successiuely a new supply, as in this ⟨p. 441⟩case of the soules of men. That God did not rest absolutely, is plaine by the words of our Sauiour Christ: My Father worketh hitherto, and I work, Iohn 5.
Fifthly, hitherto of the Original of the Soul: The union of the soul with the body follows, which is a consideration of no less difficulty, then the former, no less needful to be known, no less certain. That it is united to the body, so as to make it one man, is apparent by the words of God in the creation: He breathed into him the breath of lives, and so Adam became a living soul: He became then a man, or a living creature, distinct from other creatures, upon his conjunction of the soul with the body. And by this union with the body, doth the Spirit of man differ from the Angels, who are Spirits separate, and such as exist without relation to a body: whereas the soul of man, in the creation of it, and the disposition of it also, tends unto this conjunction with the body, and doth not fully exercise it self living without the body; and that is the reason, why man is not absolutely perfect after death in his soul, till the day of Judgement: For though the soul do enjoy an estate free from sin, or pain, or misery: yet two of the faculties of the soul are without exercise, till it be united again to the body, viz. the faculties of vegetation, and sense, which cannot be exercised but in the body.
Fiftly, hitherto of the Originall of the Soule: The vnion of the soule with the body followes, which is a consideration of no lesse difficulty, then the former, no lesse needfull to be knowne, no lesse certaine. That it is vnited to the body, so as to make it one man, is apparanti by the words of God in the creation: Hee breathed into him the breath of liues, and so Adam became a liuing soule: Hee became then a man, or a liuing creature, distinct from other creatures, vpon his coniunction of the soule with the body. And by this vnion with the body, doth the Spirit of man differ from the Angels, who are Spirits separate, and such as exist without relation to a body: wheras the soul of man, in the creation of it, and the disposition of it also, tends vnto this coniunction with the body, and doth not fully exercise it selfe liuing without the body; and that is the reason, why man is not absolutely perfect after death in his soule, till the day of Iudgement: For though the soule doe enioy an estate free fron sinne, or paine, or misery: yet two of the faculties of the soul are without exercise, till it bee vnited againe to the body, viz. the faculties of vegetation, and sense, which cannot bee exercised but in the body.
The manner how the soul is united to the body,1 is full of difficulty to express: The question ⟨p. 442⟩is, whether the soul work upon the body from without, and so is by that means joined to it, or whether it be placed in the body, and work there, and from thence. This later is the truth: for, the soul doth not work from without, which I show by a comparison. The light & the eye are joined together in seeing; but how? The light, from without, extends it self to the eye, and so is joined to it: so is not the soul joined to the body, but is seated within the body; which appears so, partly by experience: for, we may all perceive, that our thoughts, reason, will, affections, &c. do discover themselves within us; and it is manifest, that God infused the soul, not upon the body, but into the body, seating it within us.
The manner how the soule is vnited to the body,1 is full of difficulty to expresse: The question ⟨p. 442⟩is, whether the soule work vpon the body from without, and so is by that means ioyned to it, or whether it be placed in the body, and work there, and from thence. This later is the truth: for, the soul doth not work from without, which I shew by a comparison. The light & the eye are ioyned together in seeing; but how? The light, from without, extends it self to the eye, and so is ioyned to it: so is not the soule ioyned to the body, but is seated within the body; which appears so, partly by experience: for, wee may all perceiue, that our thoughts, reason, will, affections, &c. doo discouer themselues within vs; and it is manifest, that God infused the soule, not vpon the body, but into the body, seating it within vs.
The soul, then, is within the body, and so joined to it; but how? Divines have sought out diverse similitudes to express their minds. And first to show how it is not joined:
The soule, then, is within the body, and so ioyned to it; but how? Diuines haue sought out diuerse similitudes to expresse their mindes. And first to shew how it is not ioyned:
First, not as water, and the vessel that holds it, are joined by contact, or touching one another: for, the soul is not a bodily substance, and therefore cannot be joined by touching; nor do the water and vessel make one thing, as the soul and body do one man; nor do they work together, as the soul and body do: for, the water doth all the work thereof in watering or cleansing, without the vessel.
First, not as water, and the vessell that holds it, are ioyned by contact, or touching one another: for, the soule is not a bodily substance, and therefore cannot be ioyned by touching; nor doo the water and vessel make one thing, as the soule and body doo one man; nor do they work together, as the soule and body doo: for, the water doth all the work therof in watering or clensing, without the vessell.
Secondly, not by mixture; as water and wine are mingled together: for, things mingled cease to be what they were: for, there is no longer water nor wine, now they are mingled; nor is the ⟨p. 443⟩soul material, to suffer such a mingling.
Secondly, not by mixture; as water and wine are mingled together: for, things mingled cease to be what they were: for, there is no longer water nor wine, now they are mingled; nor is the ⟨p. 443⟩soule materiall, to suffer such a mingling.
Thirdly, not as the heat of the fire is united to the water, when the water is heated: for, though the heat be joined to the water as the former, yet it is but an accidental form; and they are one by accident, not per se.
Thirdly, not as the heat of the fire is vnited to the water, when the water is heated: for, though the heat bee ioyned to the water as the former, yet it is but an accidentall form; and they are one by accident, not per se.
Thirdly, not as the voice is in the air: for, though the voice be dispersed abroad the air, and do likewise carry something to the understanding, besides the sound, yet doth not this reach to express the union of the soul with the body. For, the voice is not the form of the air, nor is it conceived in the air, without the breaking of the air; and besides, it presently vanisheth: whereas the soul is a substance, and doth not easily depart out of the body.
Thirdly, not as the voice is in the aire: for, though the voice be dispersed abroad the air, and doo likewise carry something to the vnderstanding, besides the sound, yet doth not this reach to express the vnion of the soule with the body. For, the voice is not the form of the air, nor is it conceiued in the air, without the breaking of the air; and besides, it presently vanisheth: whereas the soule is a substance, and doth not easily depart out of the body.
Fifthly, nor as the Mariner is in the ship with the Governor, for the dispatch of his journey: for, though the body be as a tabernacle wherein the soul dwells, yet that similitude doth not express this union, because the soul & body make one thing; whereas the ship and the Mariner do not make one thing, but are two distinct sorts of things: yea, the soul and body are so one, that by sympathy what one suffers, the other feels; whereas the wounding of the Mariner is not the tearing of the ship, or contrariwise.
Fiftly, nor as the Mariner is in the shippe with the Gouerner, for the dispatch of his iourney: for, though the body be as a tabernacle wherein the soule dwels, yet that similitude doth not express this vnion, because the soule & body make one thing; whereas the ship and the Mariner do not make one thing, but are two distinct sorts of things: yea, the soule and body are so one, that by sympathy what one suffers, the other feeles; whereas the wounding of the Mariner is not the tearing of the ship, or contrariwise.
There are two similitudes do more nearly reach this Secret.
There are two similitudes doo more neerly reach this Secret.
The first is of Christ. For, as God & man make one Christ: so the soul & body make one man. But I will not meddle with the breaking open of that dreadful mystery.
The first is of Christ. For, as God & man make one Christ: so the soule & body make one man. But I will not meddle with the breaking open of that dreadfull mystery.
The other is of the light of the Sun in the air: for, there are many things in this comparison, do fitly resemble this divine light which is, our souls, as they are joined to our bodies.
The other is of the light of the Sun in the air: for, there are many things in this comparison, do fitly resemble this diuine light which is, our soules, as they are ioyned to our bodies.
1. This light doth fitly resemble the soul, because it is a thing that cannot be corrupted or divided. 2. This light doth so pierce into, and penetrate the air, that they are both made one, and are not separated: so doth the soul the body. 3. The light and the air, though joined together, are not confounded or mingled together: for, the light remaineth light, and the air the air: so is it in this union between the soul and the body. 4. The light is so in the air, that the air being smitten, yet the light is not touched, nor divided, nor carried about, as the air is: so doth the soul remain unpierced, though the body be wounded, and fall, yea, and die too. 5. As the light is only from the Sun: so is the soul only from God. 6. As the air, without the light, is as it were dead, because it is dark, and cold, and will putrefy: so is the body, without the soul. 7. As no man can show, by what bands the light is fastened to the air: so is it extremely difficult to show how the soul is fastened to the body.
1. This light doth fitly resemble the soule, because it is a thing that cannot bee corrupted or diuided. 2. This light doth so pearce into, and penetrate the air, that they are both made one, and are not separated: so doth the soule the body. 3. The light and the air, though ioyned together, are not confounded or mingled together: for, the light remaineth light, and the air the air: so is it in this vnion between the soule and the body. 4. The light is so in the air, that the air beeing smitten, yet the light is not touched, nor diuided, nor carried about, as the air is: so doth the soule remain vnpearced, though the body bee wounded, and fall, yea, and die too. 5. As the light is onely from the Sun: so is the soule onely from God. 6. As the air, without the light, is as it were dead, because it is dark, and colde, and will putrefie: so is the body, without the soule. 7. As no man can shew, by what bands the light is fastned to the air: so is it extremely difficult to shew how the soule is fastned to the body.
This similitude, we see, doth in many things fit this case, but yet not fully. For, the light is not the essential form of the air: only this comparison doth in many things satisfy the question, in ⟨p. 445⟩that it shows, that the soul is in the body by Penetration, or Immeation, as they call it: It pierceth through the whole body, only we must take heed of two things.
This similitude, wee see, doth in many things fit this case, but yet not fully. For, the light is not the essential form of the air: onely this comparison doth in many things satisfie the question, in ⟨p. 445⟩that it shewes, that the soule is in the body by Penetration, or Immeation, as they call it: It pearceth thorow the whole body, onely wee must take heed of two things.
First, that we imagine not the soul to be in the body, as in a place, or as contained of it: For the soul cannot be circumscribed by the measure of a place: we may not imagine, that the soul is just as big as the body, and no bigger: For though it be true, that the soul is in the body, and the whole soul too, yet it is not contained there, as bodies be contained in their places: For rather the soul sustaineth the body.
First, that wee imagine not the soule to bee in the body, as in a place, or as contained of it: For the soule cannot bee circumscribed by the measure of a place: wee may not imagine, that the soule is iust as big as the body, and no bigger: For though it bee true, that the soule is in the body, and the whole soule too, yet it is not contained there, as bodies bee contained in their places: For rather the soule sustaineth the body.
Secondly, God is said to be in us: and so is the soul, but not alike. For God is in us by his virtue, and grace, and operation, but not as our former: whereas the soul is the form of the body, and both make one man.
Secondly, God is said to bee in vs: and so is the soule, but not alike. For God is in vs by his vertue, and grace, and operation, but not as our former: whereas the soule is the forme of the body, and both make one man.
Quest. But some one will say, Can it not be showed by what band the soul is tied to the body?
Quest. But some one will say, Can it not bee shewed by what band the soule is tied to the body?
Ans. Some divines and Philosophers undertake to determine that, and say, that God hath created in the body of man a certain humour, which is fitted for this union; and so they say, the soul is united to the body by the vital spirits, which are of nature mixed, partly Corporeal, and partly Spiritual: For as those vital spirits do consist for the matter of them, of the radical heat and moisture in man, so they are corporeal; and as they have an unexpressable nimbleness in working, or sparkling in the body: so they draw ⟨p. 446⟩near to the nature of the soul; and by these vital spirits thus inlived, are the soul and body joined together.
Ans. Some diuines and Philosophers vndertake to determine that, and say, that God hath created in the body of man a certaine humour, which is fitted for this vnion; and so they say, the soule is vnited to the body by the vitall spirits, which are of nature mixt, partly Corporeall, and partly Spirituall: For as those vitall spirits doe consist for the matter of them, of the radicall heat and moisture in man, so they are corporeall; and as they haue an vnexpressable nimblenes in working, or sparkling in the body: so they draw ⟨p. 446⟩neer to the nature of the soule; and by these vitall spirits thus inliued, are the soule and body ioyned together.
Quest. There yet remaineth another question, and that is, Where the soul resides in the body, in what place is it centred?
Quest. There yet remaineth another question, and that is, Where the soule resides in the body, in what place is it centred?
Ans. The most say, that the whole soul is in the whole body, and the whole soul in every part of the body.
Ans. The most say, that the whole soule is in the whole body, and the whole soule in euery part of the body.
Others say: It is a vain question, seeing the soul is not in the body as in a place. For it cannot be measured by length, breadth, or depth, but it is in the body as the essential form is in the matter, which cannot be locally.
Others say: It is a vaine question, seeing the soule is not in the body as in a place. For it cannot bee measured by length, breadth, or depth, but it is in the body as the essentiall forme is in the matter, which cannot bee locally.
Others say, that the soul is seated in one principal place of the body, as the chief palace and seat of residence, and is in all other parts by diffusion of virtues, through the instruments thereunto fitted, and placed of purpose by God in the framing of the body: and thus the soul reasons in the head, wills and affects in the heart, sees in the eyes, &c. The chiefest mansion of the soul seems to be in the heart, because it is the last that dies in us.
Others say, that the soule is seated in one principall place of the body, as the chiefe palace and seat of residence, and is in all other parts by diffusion of vertues, through the instruments thereunto fitted, and placed of purpose by God in the framing of the body: and thus the soule reasons in the head, wills and affects in the heart, sees in the eyes, &c. The chiefest mansion of the soule seemes to bee in the heart, because it is the last that dies in vs.
Sixthly, hitherto of the union of the soul with the body: The faculties of the soul follow.
Sixtly, hitherto of the vnion of the soule with the body: The faculties of the soule follow.
There are three faculties, or powers of the soul, by which it works: or there are three things which the soul effects, viz. 11. Vegetation: 2. Sense: 3. Reason.
There are three faculties, or powers of the soul, by which it works: or there are three things which the soule effects, viz. 11. Vegetation: 2. Sense: 3. Reason.
And thus the soul may be considered, either as it works upon, or by the body only, or as it works in and by it self chiefly. Upon the body, & by certain instruments in the body, it works vegetation, and sense; and by it self, without the necessity of using the body, it works reason.
And thus the soule may be considered, either as it workes vpon, or by the body onely, or as it works in and by it self chiefly. Vpon the body, & by certaine instruments in the body, it works vegetation, and sense; and by it selfe, without the necessity of vsing the body, it works reason.