pp. 51–538 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If there be no churches established / because there are no christian Magistrates / then the churches of the Apostles were not established. And it is absurd to say / that the ministers now with the help of the magistrate / can lay surer foundations of the church / or build more cunningly or substantially / then the Apostles could / which were the master builders of the church of God. And as for the consummation of the body of the church / and the beauty of it / seeing it consisteth in Jesus Christ / which is the head / that is always joined unseperably in all times of the cross / and not the cross with his body / which is the church: I can not see why the churches under persecution / should not be established / having both the foundation and the nether most parts / as also the top and hiest part of the church / as well as those which have a christian magistrate. If in deed the magistrate / whom God hath sanctified to be a nurse unto his church / were also the head of the same / then the church could not be established without the magistrate / but we learn that although the godly magistrate be the head of the common wealth / and a great ornament unto the church / yet he is but a member of the same. The church may be established without the magistrate / and so / that all the world / and all the Devils of hell can not shake it / but it can not be in quiet / in peace / and in outward surety / without a godly magistrate: And therefore the church in that respect and such like / praiseth God and prayeth for the magistrate / by the which it enjoyeth so singular benefits. Thereupon you conclude / that the church was then popular / which is as untrue / as the former part. For the church is governed with that kind of government / which the Philosophers / that write of the best common wealths / affirm to be the best. For in respect of Christ the head / it is a Monarchy / and in respect of the ancients and pastors / that govern in common / and with like authority amongst them selves / it is an Aristocracy / or the rule of the best men / and in respect that the people are not secluded / but have their interest in church matters / it is a Democracy / or a popular estate.
If there be no churches established / because there are no christian Magistrates / then the churches of the Apostles were not established. And it is absurd to say / that the ministers nowe wyth the helpe of the magistrate / can laye surer foundations of the church / or build more cunningly or substancially / then the Apostles could / whych were the master builders of the church of God. And as for the consummation of the body of the church / and the beautie of it / seeing it consisteth in Iesus Christe / whych is the heade / that is alwayes ioyned vnseperably in all times of the crosse / and not the crosse wyth his body / whych is the church: I can not see why the churches vnder persecution / should not be established / hauing bothe the foundation and the nether most partes / as also the toppe and hyest parte of the churche / as well as those whych haue a christian magistrate. If in deede the magistrate / whom God hath sanctified to be a nurse vnto his churche / were also the head of the same / then the church could not be established wythout the magistrate / but we learne that although the godly magistrate be the head of the common wealth / and a great ornament vnto the church / yet he is but a member of the same. The churche maye be established wythoute the magistrate / and so / that all the world / and all the Deuilles of hell can not shake it / but it can not be in quiet / in peace / and in outwarde suretie / wythout a godly magistrate: And therefore the churche in that respecte and suche like / praiseth God and prayeth for the magistrate / by the whych it enioyeth so singulare benefites. Therevppon you conclude / that the church was then populare / whych is as vntrue / as the former parte. For the churche is gouerned wyth that kinde of gouernment / whych the Philosophers / that wryte of the best common wealthes / affirme to be the best. For in respecte of Christe the heade / it is a Monarchie / and in respecte of the auncientes and pastoures / that gouerne in common / and wyth like authoritie amongste them selues / it is an Aristocratie / or the rule of the best men / and in respecte that the people are not secluded / but haue their interest in churche matters / it is a Democratie / or a populare estate.
An image whereof appeareth also in the policy of this Realm / for as in respect of the Queen her majesty / it is a Monarchy / so in respect of the most honourable Council / it is an Aristocracy / and having regard to the Parliament / which is assembled of all estates / it is a Democracy. But you should have showed / how this difference of having ⟨p. 52⟩a christian magistrate / & having none / ought to bring in a diversity in the choice of the pastor by their church. It were not hard / if one would spend his time so unprofitably / to find out a hundred differences between a persecuted church / and that which is in peace / but seeing you can show me no reason / why the church may not choose her minister / as well under a godly magistrate / as under a tyrant / I will show you / how that if it were lawful to break the order of God / it were meeter in the time of persecution / that the election should be in some other discreet and learned persons hands / to be made without the consent of the church: then in that time when there is a godly magistrate / and that it is then most convenient that he should be chosen by the church.
An image whereof appeareth also in the pollicye of thys Realme / for as in respecte of the Queene her maiestie / it is a Monarchie / so in respecte of the moste honourable Counsell / it is an Aristocratie / and hauing regard to the Parliament / whych is assembled of al estates / it is a Democratie. But you should haue shewed / howe this difference of hauing ⟨p. 52⟩a christian magistrate / & hauing none / ought to bryng in a diuersity in the choise of the pastoure by their churche. It were not harde / if one woulde spende hys time so vnprofitably / to finde oute a hundred differences betweene a persecuted church / and that whych is in peace / but seeing you can shewe me no reason / why the church may not chuse her minister / as well vnder a godly magistrate / as vnder a tyrante / I will shewe you / howe that if it were lawfull to breake the order of God / it were meeter in the time of persecution / that the election shoulde be in some other discreate and learned persons hands / to be made without the consent of the churche: then in that time when there is a godly magistrate / and that it is then most conuenient that he should be chosen by the church.
In the time of persecution a church chooseth an unlearned minister / or one that is wicked in life / howsoever it be / he is unfit / the churches round about by their ministers or elders admonish this church of her fault / and move to correct it / the church will by no means be admonished: what can now the other churches do in the time of persecution? if they excommunicate the whole church / it is a hard matter / & yet if they may do that / there is all they can do: the evil is not remedied / which may be easily taken away / where there is a godly magistrate / and the church (as is before said) compelled to a better choice / so you see that there are inconveniences in the choosing of the pastor / and other the governors of the church / by the church / in the time of persecution / which are not in the time of peace under a christian magistrate.
In the time of persecution a churche chuseth an vnlearned minister / or one that is wicked in life / howsoeuer it be / he is vnfit / the churches rounde about by their ministers or elders admonishe this church of her fault / and moue to correct it / the church will by no meanes be admonished: what can nowe the other churches do in the time of persecution? if they excommunicate the whole churche / it is a hard matter / & yet if they may do that / there is all they can do: the euil is not remedied / whych may be easely taken awaye / where there is a godly magistrate / and the churche (as is before sayde) compelled to a better choyse / so you see that there are inconueniences in the chusing of the pastor / and other the gouernors of the churche / by the churche / in the time of persecution / whych are not in the time of peace vnder a christian magistrate.
Now I will show you (which think that the consent of the church in their minister / can not stand with the time of a christian magistrate) that it hath not only stood / but hath been confirmed in their times / and by them. In codice Justiani: it is thus written / following the doctrine of the holy Apostles. &c. we ordain / that as often as it shall fall out / that the ministers place shall be void in any city / that voices be given of the inhabitants of that city / that he of three (which for their right faith / holiness of life / and other good things are most approved) should be chosen to the Bishopric / which is the most meet of them. Also Carolus Magnus / which was the first German Emperor in. 63. distinct. sacrorum canonum saith / being not ignorant of the holy Canons / that the holy church in the name of God should use her honour the freelyer / we assent unto the Ecclesiastical order / that the bishops be chosen by election of the clergy and people / according to the statutes of the canons of that diocese.
Now I wil shew you (which thinke that the consent of the church in their minister / can not stand with the time of a christian magistrate) that it hathe not only stode / but hath bene cōfirmed in their times / and by them. In codice Iustiani: it is thus wrytten / following the doctrine of the holy Apostles. &c. we ordaine / that as often as it shall fall out / that the ministers place shall be voyde in any citie / that voyces be geuen of the inhabiters of that city / that he of three (which for their right faith / holines of life / and other good things are most approued) should be chosen to the Byshoprike / whych is the moste meete of them. Also Carolus Magnus / whych was the first Germaine Emperoure in. 63. distinct. sacrorum canonum sayth / being not ignorante of the holy Canons / that the holy churche in the name of God should vse her honoure the freelyer / we assent vnto the Ecclesiasticall order / that the byshops be chosen by election of the cleargye and people / according to the statutes of the canons of that diocesse.
In the. 63. distinction it appeareth / that Ludovicus Carolus his son decreed / that he should be bishop of Rome / whom all the people of Rome should consent to choose. Platina also in the life of pope Adrian. 2. writeth that Ludovike the second by his letters commanded the Romans / that they should choose their own bishop / not looking for other mens voices / which being strangers / could not so well tell what was done in the common weal where they were strangers / and that it appertained to the Citizens.
In the. 63. distinction it appeareth / that Ludouicus Carolus hys sonne decreed / that he should be bishop of Rome / whom all the people of Rome should cōsent to chuse. Platina also in the life of pope Adrian. 2. writeth that Ludouike the seconde by hys letters commaunded the Romaines / that they shoulde chuse their owne bishop / not loking for other mennes voyces / whych being straūgers / could not so well tell what was done in the common weale where they were straungers / and that it appertained to the Citizens.
The same Platina witnesseth in the life of Pope Leo the. 8. that when the people of Rome were earnest with the Emperor Otho the first / that he would take away one Pope John that lived very licentiously and riotously / and place an other / the same Emperor answered / that it pertained to the clergy and people to choose one / and willed them that they should choose / and he would approve it: and when they had chosen Leo / and after put him out without cause / and chose one Pope Benet / he compelled them to take Leo again. Whereby appeareth that in those estates where Magistrates were Christian / and where the estate was most of all Monarchical / that is subject to ones government / that this use of the Church remained and was confirmed by the Emperors / and also when the church put out any without good cause / that then the Magistrates should compel the churches to do their duty. In deed the bishop ⟨p. 53⟩of Rome gave the election then into the Emperor his hands / because of the lightness of the people / as Platina maketh mention / but that is not the matter / for I do nothing else here but show / that the elections of the ministers by the Church / were used in the times of the Emperors / and by their consents: and seeing that Otho confessed it pertained not unto him / it is to be doubted / whether he took it at the Bishop his hands.
The same Platina witnesseth in the life of Pope Leo the. 8. that whē the people of Rome were earnest with the Emperoure Otho the first / that he wold take awaye one Pope Iohn that liued very licentiously and riotously / and place an other / the same Emperoure answeared / that it pertained to the cleargye and people to chuse one / and willed them that they shoulde chuse / and he woulde approue it: and when they had chosen Leo / and after put hym out wythout cause / and chose one Pope Benet / he compelled them to take Leo agayne. Whereby appeareth that in those estates where Magistrates were Christian / and where the estate was moste of all Monarchicall / that is subiecte to ones gouernment / that thys vse of the Churche remained and was confirmed by the Emperours / and also when the churche put oute any wythout good cause / that then the Magistrates shoulde compell the churches to doe their duetye. In deede the byshop ⟨p. 53⟩of Rome gaue the election then into the Emperoure hys handes / because of the lyghtnesse of the people / as Platina maketh mention / but that is not the matter / for I do nothing else heere but shew / that the elections of the ministers by the Church / were vsed in the times of the Emperoures / and by their consentes: and seeing that Otho confessed it pertayned not vnto him / it is to be doubted / whether he tooke it at the Bishop his handes.
And if the Emperors permitted the election of the bishop to that City / where it made most for their surety to have one of their own appointment / as was Rome / which with their bishops did often times put the good Emperors to trouble: it is to be thought / that in other places both Cities & towns / they did not deny the elections of the ministers / to the people. Besides that / certain of those constitutions are not of Rome / but of any city whatsoever. And these Emperors were / and lived between 500. and odd years / until the very point of a thousand years after Christ / so that hither to this liberty was not gone out of the Church / albeit the Pope which brought in all tyranny / and went about to take all liberty from the churches / was now on horse back / & had placed him self in that Antichristian seat.
And if the Emperoures permitted the election of the byshop to that Citie / where it made most for their suertie to haue one of their owne appoyntment / as was Rome / which with their byshoppes dyd often tymes put the good Emperoures to trouble: it is to be thought / that in other places both Cities & townes / they dyd not deny the elections of the ministers / to the people. Besides that / certayne of those constitutions are not of Rome / but of any citie whatsoeuer. And these Emperoures were / and lyued betweene 500. and odde yeares / vntill the very poynt of a thousande yeares after Christ / so that hyther to thys lyberty was not gone out of the Church / albeit the Pope which brought in all tyranny / and went about to take all libertie from the churches / was now on horse backe / & had placed hym selfe in that Antichristian seate.