And this your doctrine hath a very evil smack, that spirit and life should fall upon naughty men, although for their malice it tarry not. For by this doctrine you join together in one man, Christ and Belial, the spirit of God and the spirit of the devil, life and death, and all at one time:1 which doctrine I will not name what it is, for all faithful men know the name right well and detest the same.2 And what ignorance can be showed more in him that accounteth himself learned, then to gather of Christs words (where her saith, his words be spirit and life) that spirit and life should be in evil men because they hear his words.3 For the words which you recite by and by of S. Augustin, show how vain your argument is,4 when he saith, The words be spirit and life, but not to thee, that doest carnally understand them. What estimation of learning or of truth would you have men to conceive of you, that bring such unlearned arguments whereof the invalidity appeareth within six lines after? Which must needs declare in you either, much untruth and unsincere proceeding, or much ignorance, or at the least all exceeding forgetfulness, to say anything, reproved again within six lines after. And if the promises of God (as you say) be not disappointed by our infidelity, then if evil men eat the very body of Christ and drink his blood, they must needs dwell in Christ, and have Christ dwelling in them, and by him have everlasting life: because of these promises of Christ, Qui manducat ⟨p. 216⟩meam carnem, & bibit meum sanguinem, in memanet et ego in eo. Et quimanducat meam carnem & bibit meum sanguinem, habet vitam aeternam, 5He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath everlasting life. And he that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me and I in him. And yet the third promise. Qui manducat me, & ipse vives propter me, 6He that eateth me, he shall also live by me. These be .iij. promises of God, which if they can not be disappointed by our infidelity, then if evil men eat the very body of Christ and drink his blood (as you say they do in the sacrament) then must it needs follow, that they shall have everlasting life, and that they dwell in Christ and Christ in them, because our infidelity (say you) can not disappoint God's promises.
And this your doctrine hath a very euill smacke, that spirite and life should fall vppon naughty men, although for theyr malice it tary not. For by this doctrine you ioyne togither in one man, Christ and Beliall, the spirite of God and the spirite of the diuell, lyfe and death, and all at one tyme:1 which doctrine I will not name what it is, for all faythfull men know the name right well and detest the same.2 And what ignoraunce can be shewed more in him that accoumpteth himselfe learned, then to gather of Christes wordes (where her sayth, his wordes be spirit and life) that spirit and lyfe should be in euill men because they heare his wordes.3 For the wordes which you recyte by and by of S. Augustin, shew how vayne your argument is,4 when he sayth, The wordes be spirite and life, but not to thee, that doest carnally vnderstand them. What estimation of learning or of truth would you haue men to conceaue of you, that bring such vnlearned argumentes wherof the inuadilitie appeareth within six lynes after? Which must nedes declare in you either, much vntruth and vnsincere proceding, or much ignoraunce, or at the least all exceding forgetfulnes, to say anythyng, reproued agayn within six lynes after. And if the promises of God (as you say) be not disapoynted by our infidelitie, then if euyll men eate the very body of Christ and drink his bloud, they must nedes dwell in Christ, and haue Christ dwelling in them, and by him haue euerlasting lyfe: bycause of these promises of Christ, Qui manducat ⟨p. 216⟩meam carnem, & bibit meum sanguinem, in memanet et ego in eo. Et quimanducat meam carnem & bibit meum sanguinem, habet vitam aeternam, 5He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my bloud, hath euerlasting lyfe. And he that eateth my flesh and drincketh my bloud, dwelleth in me and I in him. And yet the third promise. Qui manducat me, & ipse viues propter me, 6He that eateth me, he shall also lyue by me. These be .iij. promises of God, which if they can not be disapoynted by our infidilitie, then if euyll men eat the very body of Christ and drinke his bloud (as you say they doe in the sacrament) then must it nedes follow, that they shall haue euerlasting life, and that they dwell in Christ and Christ in them, bicause our infidilitie (say you) can not disappoynt Goddes promises.
- 1Spirit and life to fall upon evil men.Spirit and lyfe to fall vpon euill men.
- 22 Cor. 6.
- 3John. 6.Iohn. 6.
- 4Aug. in John, tract. 27.Aug. in Iohn, tract. 27.
- 5John. 6.Iohn. 6.
- 6John. 6.Iohn. 6.