If they say nay, then they condemn the ⟨p. 255⟩Apostles of disobedience to Christs commandment, which drank not wine as he commanded them, Or rather they reprove Christ as a Juggler, which commanded his Apostles to drink wine, and when they came to the drinking thereof, he himself had conveyed it away. Moreover, before Christ delivered the cup of wine to his disciples, he said unto them: Divide this among you.1
Here I would ask the Papists an other question, what thing it was that Christ commanded his disciples to divide among them? I am sure they will not say, it was the Cup, except they be disposed to make men laugh at them. Nor I think they will not say, it was the blood of Christ, as well because the words were spoken before the consecration, as because the blood of Christ is not divided, but spiritually given whole in the sacrament. Then could it be understand of nothing else but of wine, which they should divide among them, and drink all together.
Also when the Communion was ended, Christ said unto his Apostles: Verily I say unto you, that I will drink no more henceforth of this fruit of the vine, 2until that day, that I shall drink it new with you in my fathers kingdom.
By these words it is clear, that it was very wine that the Apostles drank at that godly supper. For the blood of Christ is not the fruit of the vine, nor the accidents of wine, nor none other thing is the fruit of the vine, but the very wine only.
How could Christ have expressed more plainly, that bread and wine remain, then by taking the bread in his hands, and breaking it him self, and giving it unto his disciples, commanding them to eat it? And by taking the cup of wine in his hands, and delivering it unto them, commanding them to divide it among them, and to drink it, and calling it the fruit of the vine? These words of Christ be so plain, that if an angel of heaven would tell us the contrary, he ought not to be believed. And then much less may we believe the subtle lying Papists.
If Christ would have had us to believe (as a necessary article of our faith) that there remaineth neither bread nor wine, would he have spoken after this sort, using all such terms and circumstances, as should make us believe, that still there remaineth bread and wine?
What manner of teacher make they of Christ, that say he meant one thing, when his words be clean contrary?
If they say nay, then they condemne the ⟨p. 255⟩Apostles of disobedience to Christes commaundement, which dranke not wine as he commaunded them, Or rather they reproue Christ as a Iuggler, which commaūded his Apostles to drincke wine, and when they came to the drincking therof, he himselfe had conuayed it away. Moreouer, before Christ deliuered the cup of wine to his disciples, he sayd vnto them: Deuide this among you.1
Here I would aske the Papistes an other question, what thing it was that Christ commaunded his disciples to deuide among them? I am sure they will not say, it was the Cup, except they be disposed to make men laugh at them. Nor I thinke they will not say, it was the bloud of Christ, as well because the wordes were spoken before the consecration, as bicause the bloud of Christ is not deuided, but spiritually giuen whole in the sacrament. Then could it be vnderstand of nothing els but of wine, which they should deuide among them, and drincke all togither.
Also when the Communion was ended, Christ sayd vnto his Apostles: Verily I say vnto you, that I will drincke no more henceforth of this frute of the vine, 2vntill that day, that I shall drincke it new with you in my fathers kingdome.
By these wordes it is cleare, that it was very wine that the Apostles dranke at that godly supper. For the bloud of Christ is not the frute of the vine, nor the accidents of wine, nor none other thing is the frute of the vine, but the very wine onely.
How could Christ haue expressed more playnly, that bread and wine remayne, then by taking the bread in his handes, and breaking it him selfe, and geuing it vnto his disciples, commaunding them to eate it? And by taking the cup of wine in his handes, and deliuering it vnto them, commaunding them to deuide it among them, and to drincke it, and calling it the frute of the vine? These wordes of Christ be so playne, that if an angell of heauen would tell vs the contrary, he ought not to be beleued. And then much lesse may we beleue the subtill lying Papistes.
If Christ would haue had vs to beleue (as a necessary article of our fayth) that there remayneth neyther bread nor wine, would he haue spoken after this sort, vsing all such termes and circumstaūces, as should make vs beleue, that styll there remayneth bread and wine?
What maner of teacher make they of Christ, that say he ment one thing, when his wordes be cleane contrary?
- 1Luc. 11.
- 2Math. 16. Marc. 14.