and thus I write to show that such an answer to say the accidents be broken, hath no such clear absurdity, as this author would have it seem. But leaving of the matter of Philosophy to the schools. I will grant that accidents §6to be without substance is against the common course of natural things, and therefore therein is a special miracle of God. But when the accidents be by miracle without substance as they be in the visible part of the sacrament, then the same accidents to be broken, eaten, and drunken with all additions this author for his pleasure maketh them, is no miracle, or marvel: and as for absurdity no point at all, for by quantity which remaineth is all division, we ought to confess and good christen men do proofs the mystery of the sacrament to be supernatural, and above the order of nature, and therefore it is a travail in vain to frame the consideration of it to agree with the terms of philosophy. But where this author saith that nothing can be answered to be broken §7but the accidents: yes verily, for in time of contention, as this is, to him that would ask what is broken, I would in other terms answer thus, that thou seest is broken. And then if he would ask further, what that is, I would tell him, the visible matter of the sacrament, under which is present invisibly the substance of the most precious body of Christ. If he will ask yet further, is that body of Christ broken? I will say, no. For I am learned in faith, that that glorious body now impassible cannot be divided, or broken, and therefore it is whole in every part of that is broken, as the substance of bread is in common bread in every part that is broken.1 According whereunto it is in the book of §8common prayer set forth how in each part of that is broken of the consecrate bread, is the whole body of our saviour Christ. If this questioner be further curious and say, Is not that, that is broken, bread? I would answer as a believing man by faith, truly no. For in faith I must call it, because it is truly so, the body of Christ invisibly there, and the breaking to be not in it, but in the visible figure. Yea ye will call it so saith this questioner §9but yet it is bread:
and thus I write to shew that such an aunswere to say the accidents be broken, hath no such clere absurdity, as this author would haue it séeme. But leauing of the matter of Philosophy to the scholes. I will graunt that accidentes §6to be without substaunce is agaynst the common course of naturall thinges, and therefore therein is a speciall miracle of God. But when the accidentes be by miracle without substāce as they be in the visible part of the sacrament, then the same accidents to be broken, eaten, and drunken with all additions this author for his pleasure maketh them, is no miracle, or maruaile: and as for absurdity no point at all, for by quantitye which remayneth is all diuision, we ought to confes and good christen men do profes the mistery of the sacrament to be supernaturall, and aboue the order of nature, and therefore it is a trauaile in vayne to frame the consideration of it to agrée with the termes of philosophy. But where this author sayth that nothing can be aunswered to be broken §7but the accidents: yes verely, for in time of contention, as this is, to him that would aske what is broken, I would in other termes aunswere thus, that thou seest is broken. And then if he would aske further, what that is, I would tell him, the visible matter of the sacrament, vnder which is present inuisibly the substaunce of the most precious bodye of Christ. If he will aske yet further, is that body of Christ broken? I wil say, no. For I am learned in fayth, that that glorious body now impassible cannot be deuided, or broken, and therefore it is whole in euery part of that is broken, as the substaunce of bread is in common bread in euery part that is broken.1 According whereunto it is in the booke of §8common prayer sette forth howe in ech part of that is broken of the consecrate bread, is the whole body of our sauior Christ. If this questioner be further curious and say, Is not that, that is broken, bread? I would aunswere as a beleuing man by fayth, truely no. For in fayth I must call it, because it is truely so, the bodye of Christ inuisibly there, and the breaking to be not in it, but in the visible figure. Yea ye will call it so sayth this questioner §9but yet it is bread:
- 1The book of Common prayer.The booke of Commō praier.