Winchester.
pp. 354–3553 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Winchester.
True believing men are not ashamed to confess the trueth of their faith, whatsoever arguments might be brought of experience in nature to the contrary. For Christs works we know to be true by a most certain faith, what mouldeth in bread, or soureth in wine, we be not so assured, or whereon worms engender, it is not so fully agreed on among men. The learned lawyer Ulpian writeth (as I have before alleged) that wine and vinegar have in manner one substance, so as when wine soureth and is vinegar, in manner the same substance remaineth, in whom it is thought no absurdity to say by that means that the accidents only sower. And if we agree with the Philosophers that there is Materia prima, which in all things is one and altereth not, but as a new form cometh, taketh a new name, fancying that as one wave in the water thrusteth away an other, so doth one form an other. It should seem by this conclusion all alteration to be in accidents, and the corruption of accidents to be the generation of new accidents, the same Materia prima, being as it were substantia, that altereth not. And this I write that may be said as it were to make a title to this authors certainty, which is ⟨p. 355⟩not so sure as he maketh it. Amongst men have been marvellous fancies in consideration of natural things, and it is to me a very great absurdity of that secret, and therefore to our certain faith. But to come nearer to the purpose, it is wrong borne in hand, that we affirm worms to be engendered of accidents, but when the worms be engendered, we grant the worms to be, and will rather say, whereof they be we cannot tell, then to say that substance is made of accidents, and that doctrine is not annexed to the faith of transubstantiation, and such as entreat those chances and accidents do not induce that conclusion, but do reasonably avoid it. And yet by the way in moulding and souring it should me seemeth be properly said that the accidents mould, and the accidents sower, because we call mould bread, bread: sower wine, wine, and in wine as I said before, §3made vinegar, the former substance hath been in learning accounted in manner to remain, so as this author overshooteth himself, when he matcheth generation of worms with moulding and souring, which differ so far in the speculation.