And as for S. Augustine serveth nothing for your purpose, to prove that §3Christs body is eaten with the mouth.1 For he speaketh not one word in the place by you alleged, neither of our mouths, nor of Christs body. But it seemeth you have so fervent desire to be doing in this matter, that you be like to certain men which have such a fond delight in shooting, that so they be doing, they pass not how far they shoot from the mark. For in this place of S. Augustine against the Donatists, he shooteth not at this butte, whether Christs very natural body be received with our mouths, but whether the Sacraments in general be received both of good and evil. And there he declareth that it is all one water, whether Simon Peter, or Simon Magus be christened in it. All one Table of the Lord and one cup, whether Peter sup thereat or Judas. All one oil, whether David or Saul were anointed therewith. Wherefore he concludeth thus:2 Memento ergo Sacramentis Dei nihil obesse mores malorum hominum, quo illa vel omnino non sint, vel minus sancta sint, sed ipsis malis hominibus ut haec habeant ad testimonium damnationis, non ad adiutorium sanitatis. Remember therefore (saith S. Augustine) that the manners of evil men hinder not the Sacraments of God, that either they utterly be not, or be less holy, but they hinder the evil men them selves, so that ⟨p. 56⟩they have the Sacraments to witness of their damnation, not to help of their salvation. And all the process spoken there by S. Augustine, is spoken chiefly of Baptism, against the Donatists, which said that the Baptism was naught, if either the minister or the receiver were naught. Against whom S. Augustine concludeth, that the Sacraments of themselves be holy, and be all one, whether the minister or receiver be good or bad. But this place of S. Augustine proveth as well your purpose, that Christs body is received by the mouth, as it proveth that Paul's steeple is higher then the cross in Cheap. For he speaketh not one word of any of them all. And therefore in this place where you pretend to shoot at the butte, you shoot quite at rovers, and clean from the mark.
And as for S. Augustine serueth nothing for your purpose, to proue that §3Christes body is eaten with the mouth.1 For he speaketh not one word in the place by you alleadged, neither of our mouthes, nor of Christes body. But it seemeth you haue so feruent desire to be doing in this matter, that you be like to certain men which haue such a fond delight in shooting, that so they be doyng, they passe not how farre they shoote from the marke. For in this place of S. Augustine against the Donatists, he shooteth not at this butte, whether Christes very naturall body be receaued with our mouthes, but whether the Sacramentes in generall be receaued both of good and euill. And there he declareth that it is all one water, whether Symon Peter, or Symon Magus be christned in it. All one Table of the Lord and one cup, whether Peter suppe thereat or Iudas. All one oyle, whether Dauid or Saule were annointed therewith. Wherfore he concludeth thus:2 Memento ergo Sacramentis Dei nihil obesse mores malorum hominum, quo illa vel omnino non sint, vel minus sancta sint, sed ipsis malis hominibus vt haec habeant ad testimonium damnationis, non ad adiutorium sanitatis. Remēber therfore (saith S. Augustine) that the manners of euill men hinder not the Sacramentes of God, that either they vtterly be not, or be lesse holy, but they hinder the euill men them selues, so that ⟨p. 56⟩they haue the Sacramentes to witnesse of their damnatiō, not to helpe of their saluation. And all the processe spoaken there by S. Augustine, is spoaken chiefly of Baptisme, against the Donatistes, which sayd that the Baptisme was naught, if either the minister or the receauer were naught. Against whom S. Augustine concludeth, that the Sacramentes of themselues be holy, and be all one, whether the minister or receauer be good or bad. But this place of S. Augustine prooueth as wel your purpose, that Christes body is receaued by the mouth, as it prooueth that Poules steeple is higher then the crosse in Cheape. For he speaketh not one worde of any of them al. And therefore in this place where you pretēd to shoote at ye butte, you shoote quite at rouers, and cleane from the marke.
- 1August contra lit. Peti. lib. 2. cap. 47.
- 2August. contra lit. Peti. lib. 2. cap. 47.