pp. 3941,982 passagespart 2 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thirdly, Berengarius being in deed but an Archdeacon, about v. C. years past, after he §4had openly attempted to set forth such like doctrine, recanted, & so failed in his purpose.
Thirdly, Berengarius beyng in dede but an Archdeacō, about v. C. yeres past, after he §4had openly attempted to set forth such like doctrine, recanted, & so fayled in his purpose.
Fourthly, Wycliffe not much above an C. years past, enterprised the same, whose §5teaching, God prospered not.
Fourthly, Wickliffe not much aboue an C. yeares past, enterprised the same, whose §5teaching, God prospered not.
Fifthly, how Luther in his works, handled them that would have in our time raised §6up the same doctrine in Germany, it is manifest by his & their writings, whereby appeareth the enterprise that hath had so many overthrows, so many rebuts, so often reproofs, to be desperate,1 and such as God hath not prospered and savoured to be received at any time openly, as his true teaching.
Fiftly, how Luther in his workes, handled them that would haue in our tyme raised §6vp the same doctrine in Germany, it is manifest by his & their writings, wherby appeareth the enterprise that hath had so many ouerthrowes, so many rebuts, so oftē reproofes, to be desperate,1 and such as God hath not prospered and sauoured to be receyued at any tyme openly, as his true teaching.
Herein whether I say true or no, let the stories try me, and it is matter worthy to be §7noted,1 because Gamaliel's observation written in the Acts of the Apostles in allowed to mark, how they prosper and go forward in their doctrine, that be authors of any news teaching.
Herein whether I say true or no, let the stories try me, and it is matter worthy to bée §7noted,1 because Gamaliels obseruation written in the Actes of the Apostles in allowed to marke, how they prosper and go forward in their doctrine, that be authors of any news teaching.
I Have not proved in my book my iiij. assertions by mine own wit, but §1by the collation of holy scripture, and the sayings of the old holy catholic authors. And as for your v. notes, you might have noted them against your self, who by them have much more disadvantage and hinderance, then I have.
I Haue not proued in my booke my iiij. assertions by mine owne wit, but §1by the collation of holy scripture, and the sayings of the old holy catholike authors. And as for your v. notes, you might haue noted thē against your selfe, who by them haue much more disaduauntage and hinderance, then I haue.
1As concerning the Catechism by me set forth, I have answered in my §2fourth book the 8. chapter, that ignorant men for lack of judgement and exercise in old authors, mistake my said Catechism.
1As concerning the Catechisme by me set forth, I haue answered in my §2fourth booke the 8. chapter, that ignorant men for lack of iudgement and exercise in olde authors, mistake my said Catechisme.
1And as for Bertram, he did nothing else but at the request of king §3Charles, set out the true doctrine of the holy catholic church from Christ unto his time, concerning the sacrament. And I never heard nor red any man that condemned Bertram before this time, and therefore I can take no hinderance, but a great advantage at his hands. For all men that hitherto have written of Bertram, have much commended him. And seeing that he wrote of the sacrament at king Charles request, it is not like that ⟨p. 7⟩he would write against the received doctrine of the church in those days. And if he had, it is without all doubt, that some learned man, either in his time or sithens, would have written against him, or at the least not have commended him so much as they have done.
1And as for Bertrame, he did nothing els but at the request of king §3Charles, set out the true doctrine of the holy catholike church from Christ vnto his tyme, concerning the sacrament. And I neuer heard nor red any mā that condemned Bertrame before this tyme, and therfore I can take no hinderance, but a great aduantage at his handes. For all men that hitherto haue written of Bertrame, haue much commended him. And seing that he wrote of the sacrament at king Charles request, it is not like that ⟨p. 7⟩he would write against the receiued doctrine of ye church in those daies. And if he had, it is without all doubt, that some learned man, either in his tyme or fithens, would haue written against him, or at the least not haue commended him so much as they haue done.
Berengarius of himself had a godly judgement in this matter,1 but by the tyranny of Nicholas the 2. he was constrained to make a devilish recantation, as I have declared in my first book, the 17. chapter.
Berengarius of himselfe had a godly iudgement in this matter,1 but by the tiranity of Nicholas the 2. he was constrained to make a diuelish recantation, as I haue declared in my first booke, the 17. chapter.
And as for John Wycliffe he was a singular instrument of God in his time to set forth the truth of christs gospel,1 but Antichrist that sitteth in gods temple, boasting himself as god, hath by gods sufferance prevailed against many holy men, and sucked the blood of martyrs these late years.
And as for Iohn Wicklif he was a singuler instrument of God in his tyme to set forth the truth of christes gospell,1 but Antichrist that sitteth in gods temple, boasting himselfe as god, hath by gods sufferance preuayled against many holy men, and sucked the bloud of martirs these late yeres.
And as touching Martin Luther,1 it seemeth you be sore pressed, that be fain to pray aide of him, whom you have hitherto ever detested. The fox is sore hunted that is fain to take his borrow, and the wolf that is fain to take the lions den for a shift, or to run for succour unto a beast which he most hateth. And no man condemneth your doctrine of Transubstantiation, and of the propitiatory sacrifice of the mass, more severely and earnestly, then doth Martin Luther.
And as touching Martin Luther,1 it semeth you be sore pressed, that be faine to pray aide of him, whom you haue hitherto euer detested. The foxe is sore hunted that is faine to take his borow, and the wolfe that is fayne to take the lions den for a shift, or to run for succour vnto a beast which he most hateth. And no man condemneth your doctrine of Transubstantiation, and of the propiciatory sacrifice of the masse, more seuerely and earnestly, then doth Martin Luther.
But it appeareth by your conclusion,1 that you have waded so far in rhetoric, that you have forgotten your logic. For this is your argument: Bertram taught this doctrine and prevailed not, Berengarius attempted the same, and failed in his purpose: Wycliffe enterprised the same, whose teaching god prospered not, therefore god hath not prospered & favoured it to be received at any time openly as his true teaching. I will make the like reason. The Prophet Hosea taught in Samaria to the ten tribes, the true doctrine of god, to bring them from their abominable superstitions and idolatry: Joel, Am•s, and Micheas attempted the same, whose doctrine prevailed not, god prospered not their teaching among those people, but they were condemned with their doctrine, therefore god hath not prospered and favoured it to be received at any time openly as his true teaching.
But it appeareth by your conclusion,1 that you haue waded so farre in rhetorike, that you haue forgotten your logike. For this is your argumēt: Bertrame taught this doctrine and preuailed not, Berengarius attempted the same, and failed in his purpose: Wickliffe enterprised the same, whose teaching god prospered not, therefore god hath not prospered & fauoured it to be receiued at any tyme openly as his true teaching. I will make the like reason. The Prophete Osee taught in Samaria to the ten tribes, the true doctrine of god, to bring them from their abhominable superstitions and idolatry: Ioell, Am•s, and Mitheas attempted ye same, whose doctrine preuailed not, god prospered not their teaching among those people, but they were condemned with their doctrine, therefore god hath not prospered and fauoured it to be receiued at any tyme openly as his true teaching.
If you will answer (as you must needs do) that the cause why that among those people the true teaching prevailed not, was by reason of the abundant superstition & idolatry that blinded their eyes, you have fully answered your own argument, and have plainly declared the cause, why the true doctrine in this matter hath not prevailed these 500. years, the church of Rome (which all that time hath borne the chief swing) being overflowed and drowned in all kind of superstition and idolatry, & therefore might not abide to hear of the truth. And the true doctrine of the sacrament (which I have set out plainly in my book) was never condemned by no council, nor your false papistical doctrine allowed, until the devil caused Antichrist his son and heir Pope Nicholas the second, with his monks and friars, to condemn the truth, and confirm these your heresies.
If you will aunswer (as you must nedes do) that the cause why that among those people the true teaching preuailed not, was by reason of the aboundant superstition & idolatry that blinded their eies, you haue fully answered your own argument, and haue plainly declared the cause, why the true doctrine in this matter hath not preuailed these 500. yeares, the church of Rome (which all that time hath borne the chiefe swinge) being ouerflowen and drowned in all kind of superstition and idolatry, & therfore might not abide to heare of the truth. And the true doctrine of the sacrament (which I haue set out plainly in my booke) was neuer condemned by no councell, nor your false papisticall doctrine allowed, vntill the deuill caused Antichrist his sonne and heire Pope Nicholas the second, with his monkes and friers, to condemne the truth, and confirme these your heresies.
And where of Gamaliel's words you make an argument of prosperous success in this matter, the scripture testifieth how Antichrist shall prosper and prevail against saints no short while, & persecute the truth. And yet the counsel of Gamaliel was very discrete and wife. For he perceived that God went about the reformation of religion grown in those ⟨p. 8⟩days to idolatry, hypocrisy and superstition, through traditions of Pharisees, and therefore he moved the rest of the Council to beware, that they did not rashly and unadvisedly condemn that doctrine & religion which was approved by God, least in so doing they should not only resist the Apostles, but God himself, which counsel if you had marked & followed, you would not have done so unsoberly in many things as you have done.
And where of Gamaliels wordes you make an argument of prosperous successe in this matter, the scripture testifieth how Antichrist shall prosper and preuaile against saintes no short while, & persecute the truth. And yet the counsail of Gamaliel was very discrete and wife. For he perceiued that God went about the reformation of religion growen in those ⟨p. 8⟩dayes to idolatry, hypocrisie and superstition, through traditions of Phariseis, and therfore he moued the rest of the Councell to beware, that they did not rashly and vnaduisedly condemne that doctrine & religion which was approued by God, least in so doing they should not onely resist the Apostles, but God himselfe, which counsail if you had marked & followed, you would not haue done so vnsoberly in many things as you haue done.
And as for the prosperity of them that have professed Christ & his true doctrine they prospered with the Papists, as S. John Baptist prospered with Herod, and our saviour Christ with Pilate, Annas and Caiaphas. Now which of these prospered best say you? Was as the doctrine of Christ and S. John any whit the worse, because the cruel tyrants and Jews put them to death for the same?
And as for the prosperitie of them that haue professed Christ & his true doctrine they prospered with the Papistes, as S. Iohn Baptist prospered with Herode, and our sauiour Christ with Pilate, Annas and Caiphas. Now which of these prospered best say you? Was as the doctrine of Christ and S. Iohn any whit the worse, because the cruell tirantes and Iewes put them to death for the same?
But all this set apart, and putting aside all testimonies of the old church, and resorting only to the letter of the scripture,1 there to search out an understanding, and in doing thereof, to forget what hath been taught hitherto: How shall this author establish upon §1scripture that he would have believed? What other text is there in scripture that encountereth with these words of scripture (This is my body) whereby to alter the signification of them? There is no scripture saith, Christ did not give his body, but the figure of §2his body, nor the giving of Christs body in his supper, verily and really so understanded, doth not necessarily impugn and contrary any other speech or doing of Christ, expressed §3in scripture. For the great power and omnipotency of God, excludeth that repugnance, which mans reason would deem of Christs departing from this world, and placing his humanity in the glory of his Father.
But all this set apart, and putting aside all testimonies of the olde church, and resortyng onely to the letter of the scripture,1 there to search out an vnderstanding, and in doyng therof, to forget what hath bene taught hitherto: How shall this author establish vpon §1scripture that he would haue beleued? What other text is there in scripture that en•ountreth with these wordes of scripture (This is my body) wherby to alter the signification of them? There is no scripture sayth, Christ did not geue his body, but the figure of §2his body, nor the geuing of Christes body in his supper, verily and really so vnderstāded, doth not necessarily impugne and contrary any other speach or doyng of Christ, expressed §3in scripture. For the great power and omnipotencie of God, exclodeth that repugnance, which mans reason would déeme of Christes departyng from this world, and placing his humanitie in the glory of his Father.
1The Scripture is plain, and you confess also, that it was bread that §1Christ spake of, when he said, This is my body. And what need we any other scripture to encounter with these words, seeing that all men know that bread is not Christs body, the one having sense and reason, the other none at all? Wherefore in that speech must needs be sought an other sense & meaning, then the words of themselves do give, which is (as all old writers do teach, and the circumstances of the text declare) that the bread is a figure and sacrament of Christs body. And yet as he giveth the bread to §2be eaten with our mouths, so giveth he his very body to be eaten with our faith. And therefore I say, that Christ giveth himself truly to be eaten, chewed, and digested, but all is spiritually with faith, not with mouth. And yet you would bear me in hand, that I say that thing which I say not: that is to say, that Christ did not give his body, but the figure of his body. And because you be not able to confute that I say, you would make me to say that you can confute.
1THe Scripture is playne, and you confesse also, that it was bread that §1Christ spake of, when he sayd, This is my body. And what nede we any other scripture to encounter with these words, seyng that all men know that bread is not Christes body, the one hauing sense and reason, the other none at all? Wherfore in that speach must nedes be sought an other sence & meanyng, then the wordes of themselues do geue, which is (as all olde writers do teach, and the circumstances of the text declare) that the bread is a figure and sacrament of Christes body. And yet as he geueth the bread to §2be eaten with our mouthes, so geueth he his very body to be eaten with our faith. And therfore I say, yt Christ geueth himselfe truely to be eaten, chawed, and digested, but all is spiritually with fayth, not with mouth. And yet you would beare me in hand, that I say that thing which I say not: that is to say, that Christ did not geue his body, but the figure of his body. And because you be not able to confute that I say, you would make me to say that you can confute.
1As for the great power and omnipotency of God, it is no place here to §3dispute what God can do, but what he doth. I know that he can do what he will, both in heaven and in earth, & no man is able to resist his will. But the question here is of his will, not of his power. And yet if you can join together these two, that one nature singular shall be here and not here, both at one time, and that it shall be gone hence when it is here, you have some strong syment, and be a cunning Geometrician: but yet you shall never be good Logician, that would set together two contradictories. For that the schoolmen say, God cannot do.
1As for the great power and omnipotency of God, it is no place here to §3dispute what God can do, but what he doth. I know that he can do what he will, both in heauen and in earth, & no man is able to resist his wil. But the question here is of his will, not of his power. And yet if you cā ioyne together these two, that one nature singuler shalbe here and not here, both at one time, and that it shalbe gone hence when it is here, you haue some strōg syment, and be a cunning Geometrician: but yet you shall neuer be good Logician, that woulde set together two contradictories. For that the scholemen say, God cannot do.
If this author without force of necessity would induce it, by the like speeches, as when Christ said:1 I am the door, I am the vine, he is Elijah, and such other, and because it is a figurative speech in them, it may be so here, which maketh no kind of proof, that it is so here: But yet if by way of reasoning I would yield to him therein, and call it a figurative §2speech as he doth,2 what other point of faith is there then in the matter, but to believe the story, that Christ did institute such a supper, wherein he gave bread and wine for a token of his body and blood, which is now after this understanding no secret mystery at all,3 or any ordinance above reason. For commonly men use to ordain in sensible things remembrances of themselves when they dye or depart the country. So as in the ordinance of this supper, after this understanding Christ showed not his omnipotency, but only benevolence, that he loved us, and would be remembered of us. For Christ did not say: Whosoever eateth this token, eateth my body, or eateth my flesh, or shall have any profit of it in special, but do this in remembrance of me.
If this author without force of necessitie would induce it, by the like speaches, as whē Christ sayd:1 I am the dore, I am the vine, he is Helias, and such other, and because it is a figuratiue speach in them, it may be so here, which maketh no kynd of proofe, that it is so here: But yet if by way of reasoning I would yeld to him therein, and call it a figuratiue §2speach as he doth,2 what other poynt of faith is there then in the matter, but to beleue the story, that Christ did institute such a supper, wherin he gaue bread and wine for a token of his body and bloud, which is now after this vnderstanding no secret mysterie at all,3 or any ordinaunce aboue reason. For commonly men vse to ordeyne in sensible thinges remembraunces of themselues when they dye or depart the countrey. So as in the ordinaunce of this supper, after this vnderstanding Christ shewed not his omnipotencie, but onely beneuolence, that he loued vs, and would be remēbred of vs. For Christ did not say: Whosoeuer eateth this token, eateth my body, or eateth my flesh, or shall haue any profite of it in speciall, but do this in remembraunce of me.
I Make no such vain inductions as you imagine me to do, but such as he established by scripture, and the consent of all the old writers. And yet both you and Smith use such fond inductions for your proof of Trā substantiation, when you say, God can do this thing, and he can make that thing, whereof you would conclude, that he doth clearly take away the substance of bread and wine, and putteth his flesh and blood in their places: And that Christ maketh his body to be corporally in many places at one time, of which doctrine you have not one jot in all the whole scripture.
I Make no such vayne inductions as you imagine me to do, but such as he established by scripture, and the consent of all the olde writers. And yet both you and Smith vse such fonde inductions for your proofe of Trā substantiation, when you say, God can do this thing, and he cā make that thing, wherof you would conclude, that he doth clearely take away ye substance of bread and wine, and putteth his flesh and bloud in their places: And that Christ maketh his body to be corporally in many places at one tyme, of which doctrine you haue not one iote in all the whole scripture.
And as concerning your argument made upon the history of the institution of Christs supper,1 like fond reasoning might ungodly men make of the sacrament of Baptism, and so scoff out both these high mysteries of Christ. For when Christ said these words after his resurrection, Go into the whole world, and preach unto all people, baptising them in the name of the Father,2 the Son, and the holy Ghost: Here might wicked blasphemers say: What point of faith is in these words, but to believe the story, that Christ did institute such a sacrament, wherein he commanded to give water for a token: which is now after this understanding, no secrete mystery at all, or any ordinance above reason: so as in the ordinance of this sacrament after this understanding, Christ showed not his omnipotency: For he said not then, Whosoever receiveth this token of water, shall receive remission of sin, or the holy ghost, or shall have any profit of it in especial, but, Do this.
And as concerning your argument made vpon the history of the institution of Christes supper,1 like fonde reasoning might vngodly men make of the sacrament of Baptisme, and so scoffe out both these high mysteries of Christ. For when Christ said these wordes after his resurrection, Goe into the whole world, and preach vnto all people, baptising them in the name of the Father,2 the Sonne, and the holy Ghost: Here might wicked blasphemers say: What point of faith is in these wordes, but to beleue the story, that Christ did institute such a sacrament, wherin he commaunded to geue water for a token: which is now after this vnderstanding, no secrete mysterie at all, or any ordinaunce aboue reason: so as in the ordinaunce of this sacrament after this vnderstanding, Christ shewed not his omnipotency: For he sayd not then, Whosoeuer receiueth this token of water, shall receuie remission of sinne, or the holy ghost, or shall haue any profite of it in especial, but, Do this.
And albeit this author would not have them bare tokens,1 yet and they be only tokens, they have no warrant signed by scripture, for any apparel at all. For the vi of John speaketh not of any promise made, to the eating of a token of Christs flesh, but to the eating of Christs very flesh, whereof the bread (as this author would have it) is but a figure in Christs words, when he said (This is my body.) And if it be but a figure in Christs words, it is but a figure in S. Pauls words when he said: The bread which we break, is it not the communication of Christs body? that is to say, a figure of the communication of Christs body (if this authors doctrine be true) and not the communication in deed.2 §2Wherefore if the very body of Christ be not in the supper delivered in deed, the eating there hath no special promise,3 but only commandment to do it in remembrance. After which doctrine why should it be noted absolutely for a Sacrament and special mystery, that hath nothing hidden in it, but a plain open ordinance of a token for a remembrance: to the eating of which token, is annexed no promise expressly, ne any holiness ⟨p. 10⟩to be accounted to be in the bread or wine (as this author teacheth) but to be called holy, because they be deputed to an holy use. If I ask the use, he declareth to signify. If I should ask what to signify? There must be a sort of good words framed without scripture. For scripture expresseth no matter of signification of special effect.
And albeit this author would not haue them bare tokens,1 yet and they be only tokēs, they haue no warrāt signed by scripture, for any apparell at all. For the vi of Iohn speaketh not of any promise made, to the eating of a token of Christes flesh, but to the eating of Christes very flesh, wherof the bread (as this author would haue it) is but a figure in Christes wordes, when he sayd (This is my body.) And if it be but a figure in Christes wordes, it is but a figure in S. Paules wordes whē he said: The bread which we breake, is it not the communication of Christes body? that is to say, a figure of the communication of Christes body (if this authors doctrine be true) and not the communication in dede.
1IF I granted for your pleasure that the bare bread (having no further §1respect) were but only a bare figure of Christs body, or a bare token (because that term liketh you better, as it may be thought for this consideration, that men should think that I take the bread in the holy mystery to be but as it were a token of I recommend me unto you) but if I grant I say, that the bare bread, is but a bare token of Christs body, what have you gained thereby? Is therefore the whole use of the bread in the whole action and ministration of the lords holy supper, but a naked or nude & bare token? Is not one loaf being broken and distributed among faithful people in the lords supper, taken and eaten of them, a token that the body of Christ was broken and crucified for them? and is to them spiritually and effectually given, and of them spiritually and fruitfully taken and eaten, to their spiritual and heavenly comfort, sustentation & nourishment of their souls, as the bread is of their bodies? And what would you require more? Can there be any greater comfort to a christian man then this? Is here nothing else but bare tokens?
1IF I graunted for your pleasure that the bare bread (hauyng no further §1respect) were but onely a bare figure of Christes body, or a bare token (because that terme liketh you better, as it may be thought for this consideration, that men should thinke that I take the bread in the holy mysterie to be but as it were a token of I recommend me vnto you) but if I graunt I say, that the bare bread, is but a bare token of Christes body, what haue you gayned therby? Is therfore the whole vse of the bread in the whole action and ministration of the lordes holy supper, but a naked or nude & bare token? Is not one lofe being broken and distributed among faithful people in the lordes supper, taken and eaten of them, a token that ye body of Christ was broken and crucified for them? and is to them spiritually and effectually geuen, and of them spiritually and fruitfully taken and eaten, to their spirituall and heauenly comfort, sustentation & nourishment of their soules, as the bread is of their bodies? And what would you require more? Cā there be any greater comfort to a christian man then this? Is here nothing els but bare tokens?
But yet importune adversaries, and such as be wilful and obstinate, will never be satisfied, but quarrel further, saying: What of all this? Here be a great many of gay words framed together, but to what purpose? For all be but signs and tokens as concerning the bread. But how can he be taken for a good christian man that thinketh that Christ did ordain his sacramental signs and tokens in vain, without effectual grace and operation? For so might we as well say, that the water in baptism is a bare token, and hath no warrant signed by scripture for any apparel at all: for the scripture speaketh not of any promise made to the receiving of a token or figure only. And so may be concluded after your manner of reasoning, that in baptism is no spiritual operation in deed, because that washing in water in it self, is but a token.
But yet importune aduersaries, and such as be wilful and obstinate, wil neuer be satisfied, but quarell further, saying: What of all this? Here be a great many of gay wordes framed together, but to what purpose? For all be but signes and tokens as concerning the bread. But how can he be taken for a good christian man that thinketh that Christ did ordaine his sacramentall signes and tokens in vayne, without effectuall grace and operation? For so might we as well say, that the water in baptisme is a bare token, and hath no warrant signed by scripture for any apparell at all: for the scripture speaketh not of any promise made to the receiuing of a token or figure onely. And so may be concluded after your maner of reasoning, that in baptisme is no spirituall operation in dede, because that washing in water in it selfe, is but a token.
But to express the true effect of the sacraments: As the washing outwardly in water is not a vain token, but teacheth such a washing as god worketh inwardly, in them that duly receive the same: So likewise is not the bread a vain token, but showeth and preacheth to the godly receiver, what God worketh in him by his almighty power secretly and invisibly. And therefore as the bread is outwardly eaten in deed in the lords supper, so is the very body of Christ inwardly by faith eaten in deed of all them that come thereto in such sort as they ought to do, which eating nourisheth them unto everlasting life.
But to expresse the true effect of the sacramentes: As the washing outwardly in water is not a vayne token, but teacheth such a washing as god worketh inwardly, in them that duely receiue the same: So likewise is not the bread a vayne token, but sheweth and preacheth to the godly receyuer, what God worketh in him by his almighty power secretely and inuisibly. And therfore as the bread is outwardly eaten in deede in the lordes supper, so is the very body of Christ inwardly by faith eaten in dede of al them that come therto in such sort as they ought to do, which eating nourisheth them vnto euerlasting lyfe.
1And this eating hath a warrant signed by Christ himself in the vj. of §2John, where Christ saith: He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath life everlasting. But they that to the outward eating of the bread, join not thereto an inward eating of Christ by faith, they have no warrant by Scripture at all, but the bread and wine to them be vain, mide, and bare tokens.
1And this eating hath a warrant signed by Christ himselfe in the vj. of §2Iohn, where Christ saith: He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my bloud, hath lyfe euerlasting. But they that to the outward eatyng of the breade, ioyne not therto an inward eating of Christ by faith, they haue no warrant by Scripture at all, but the bread and wyne to them be vayne, mide, and bare tokens.
And where you say that Scripture expresseth no matter of signification ⟨p. 11⟩§3special effect in the sacraments of bread and wine, if your eyes were not blinded with popish errors, frowardness and self-love, ye might see in the 22. of Luke,1 where Christ himself expresseth a matter of signification, saying: Hoc facite in mei commemorationem. Do this in remembrance of me. And S. Paul likewise 1. Cor. 11. hath the very same thing,2 which is a plain and direct answer to that same your last question, whereupon you triumph at your pleasure, as though the victory were all yours. For ye say, when this question is demanded of me what to signify? Here must be a sort of good words framed without scripture. But here S. Paul answereth your question in express words,3 that it is the lords death that shall be signified, represented and preached in these holy mysteries, until his coming again. And this remembrance, representation and preaching of Christs death, cannot be without special effect, except you will say that Christ worketh not effectually with his word and sacraments. And S. Paul, expresseth the effect, when he saith:4 The bread which we break, is the communion of Christs body. But by this place and such like in your book, ye disclose your self to all men of judgement, either how wilful in your opinion, or how slender in knowledge of the scriptures you be.
And where you say that Scripture expresseth no matter of signification ⟨p. 11⟩§3speciall effect in the sacramentes of bread and wine, if your eyes were not blynded with popish errours, frowardnes and selfeloue, ye might see in the 22. of Luke,1
And therefore like as the teaching is new, to say it is an only figure, or only signifieth:1 so the matter of signification must be newly devised, and new wine have new bottles, and be throughly new, after xv. C. l. years in the very year of Jubilee (as they were wont to call it) to be newly erected and builded in English mens hearts.
And therfore like as the teaching is new, to say it is an only figure, or only signifieth:1 so the matter of significatiō must be newly deuised, and new wyne haue new bottels, and be throughly new, after xv. C. l. yeres in the very yere of Iubiley (as they were wont to call it) to be newly erected and builded in English mens hartes.
IT seemeth that you be very desirous to abuse the peoples ears with this term (New) and with the year of Jubilee, as though the true doctrine of the sacrament by me taught, should be but a new doctrine and yours old (as the Jews slandered the doctrine of Christ by the name of newness) or else that in this year of Jubilee,1 you would put the people in remembrance of the full remission of sin, which they were wont to have at Rome this year, that they might long to return to Rome for pardons again, as the children of Israel longed to return to Egypt for the flesh that they were went to have there.
IT semeth that you be very desirous to abuse the peoples eares with this terme (New) and with the yeare of Iubiley, as though the true doctrine of the sacrament by me taught, should be but a new doctrine and yours old (as the Iewes slaundered the doctrine of Christ by the name of newnesse) or els that in this yere of Iubiley,1 you would put the people in remembrāce of the full remission of sinne, which they were wont to haue at Rome this yere, that they might long to returne to Rome for pardons againe, as the children of Israell longed to returne to Egipt for the flesh that they were went to haue there.
But all men of learning & judgement know well enough that this your doctrine is no elder then the bishop of Romes usurped supremacy, which though it be of good age by number of years, yet is it new to Christ and his word. If there were such darkness in the world now, as hath ben in that world which you note for old, the people might drink new wine of the whore of Babylon's cup, until they were as drunk with hypocrisy and superstition, as they might well stand upon their legs, and no man once say, black is their eye. But now thanks be to God, the light of his word so shineth in the world, that your drunkenness in this year of Jubilee is espied, so that you cannot erect and build your popish kingdom any longer in Englishmen's hats, without your own scorn, shame and confusion. The old popish bottles must needs burst, when the new wine of Gods holy word is poured into them.
But all men of learning & iudgement know well inough that this your doctrine is no elder then the bishop of Romes vsurped supremacy, which though it be of good age by nomber of yeres, yet is it new to Christ and his worde. If there were such darkenes in the world now, as hath ben in that world which you note for olde, the people might drinke new wyne of the whore of Babilons cup, vntil they were as dronke with hypocrisie and superstition, as they might well stand vpon their legs, and no man once say, blacke is their eye. But now thankes be to God, the light of his worde so shineth in the world, that your dronkennes in this yeare of Iubiley is espied, so that you cannot erect and build your popish kingdome any longer in Englishmens hattes, without your owne scorne, shame and confusiō. The old popish bottels must nedes brast, when ye new wyne of Gods holy word is poured into them.
Which new teaching, whether it proceedeth from the spirit of truth or no, shall more ⟨p. 12⟩plainly appear by such matter as this author uttereth wherewith to impugn the true faith taught hitherto.1 For among many other proofs, whereby truth after much travail in contention, at the last prevaileth and hath victory, there is none more notable, then when the very adversaries of truth (who pretend nevertheless to be truths friends) do by some evident untruth bewrap them selves. According whereunto, when the two women contended before King Solomon for the child yet alive: Solomon discerned the true natural mother from the other,2 by their speeches and sayings. Which in the very mother were ever conformable unto nature, and in the other, at the last evidently against nature. The very true mother spake always like her self, and never disagreed from §1the truth of nature, but rather: then the thilde should be killed (as Solomon the eatned, when he called for a Sword) required it to be given whole alive to the other woman. The other woman that was not the true mother, cared more for victory then for the child,3 and therefore spake that was in nature, an evidence that she lien calling her self mother, and saying let it be divided, which no natural mother could say of her own child. Whereupon proceedeth Solomons most wise judgement, which hath this lesson in it, ever where contention is, on that part to be the truth,4 where all sayings and doings appear uniformly consonant to the truth pretended, and on what side a notable •y• appeareth, the rest may be judged to be after the same sort. For truth needeth no aid of lies, exast or sleight wherewith to be supported or maintained. So as in the entreating of the truth of this high and ineffable mystery of the sacrament, on what past thou reader seest craft, sleight, shift, obliquity, or in any one point, an open manifest lye, there thou mayst consider what soever pretence be made of truth,
Which new teaching, whether it procedeth from the spirite of truth or no, shall more ⟨p. 12⟩plainly appeare by such matter as this author vttereth wherewith to impugne the true fayth taught hetherto.1 For amōng many other profes, wherby truth after much trauail in contention, at the last preuayleth and hath victory, there is none more notable, then when the very aduersaries of truth (who pretend neuerthelesse to be truthes frendes) do by some euident vntruth bewrap them selues. According wherunto, when the two women contended before King Salomon for the child yet aliue: Salomon decerned the true naturall mother from the other,2 by their speeches and sayinges. Which in the very mother were euer conformable vnto nature, and in the other, at the last euidētly against nature. The very true mother spake alwayes like her selfe, and neuer disagreed from §1the truth of nature, but rather: then the thilde should be killed (as Salomon the eatned, when he called for a Sword) required it to be geuen whole aliue to the other woman. The other woman that was not the true mother, cared more for victory then for the child,3 and therfore spake that was in nature, an euidence that she lyen callinge her selfe mother, and saying let it be deuided, which no natural mother could say of her own child. Wherupon procéedeth Salomons most wise iudgement, which hath this lesson in it, euer where contention is, on that part to be the truth,4 where all sayinges and doinges appeare vniformely consonant to the truth pretended, and on what side a notable •y• appeareth, the rest may be iudged to be after the same sort. For truth néedeth no ayde of lyes, exast or sleight wherwith to be supported or maintayned. So as in the intreating of the truth of this high and ineffable mistery of the sacrament, on what past thou reader séest crafte, sleight, shift, obliquitie, or in any one poynt, an open manifest lye, there thou mayst consider what soeuer pretence be made of truth,5 yet the victory of truth not to be §2there intended, which loueth simplicity, playnnesse, direct speach, without admixtion of shift or colour.