And you vary so much from your self herein, that although you deny the Papists sayings in words, that Christs body is made of bread, yet in effect you grant and maintain the same, which you say is intolerable, and not to be devised by a scoffer in a play. For you say, that Christ calleth bread his body, and that his calling is making. And then if he make bread his body, it must needs follow that he maketh his body of the bread: moreover you say,1 that Christs body is made present by conversion, or turning of the substance of bread, into the substance of his precious body, where of must follow, that his body is made of bread. For when so ever one substance is turned into another, then the second is made of the first. As, because earth was turned into the body of Adam,2 we say that Adam was made of earth and that Eve was made of Adams rib: And the wine in Galilee made of water,3 because the water was turned into wine, and the rib of Adams side into the body of Eve. If the water had been put out of the pots, and ⟨p. 81⟩wine put in for the water, we might have said that the wine had been made present there, where the water was before: But then we might not have said that the wine had been made of the water, because the water was emptied out, and not turned into wine. But when Christ turned the water into the wine, then by reason of that turning, we say that the wine was made of the water. So likewise if the bread be turned into the substance of Christ his body, we must not only say that the body of Christ is present, where the bread was before, but also that it is made of the bread, because that the substance of the bread is converted and turned into the substance of his body. Which thing the papists saw must needs follow, and therefore they plainly confessed, that the body of Christ was made of bread, which doctrine (as you truly say in this place) is intolerable, and not to be devised by a scoffer in a play, when his fellow had forgotten his part. And yet you so far forget your self in this book, that throughout the same (what so ever you say here) you defend the same intolerable doctrine, not to be devised by a scoffer.
And you varry so much from your selfe herein, that although you deny the Papistes sayinges in wordes, that Christes body is made of bread, yet in effect you graunt and maintayn the same, which you say is intollerable, and not to be deuised by a scoffer in a play. For you say, that Christ calleth bread his body, and that his calling is making. And then if he make bread his body, it must needes follow that he maketh his body of the bread: moreouer you say,1 that Christes body is made present by conuersion, or turning of the substance of bread, into the substance of his precious bodye, where of must follow, that his body is made of bread. For when so euer one substāce is turned into another, thē the second is made of the first. As, because earth was turned into the body of Adam,2 we say that Adam was made of earth and that Eue was made of Adams ribbe: And the wine in Galily made of water,3 because the water was turned into wine, and the ribbe of Adames side into the body of Eue. If the water had beene put out of the pottes, and ⟨p. 81⟩wine put in for the water, we might haue saide that the wine had been made present there, where the water was before: But then we might not haue said that the wine had been made of the water, because ye water was emptied out, and not turned into wine. But when Christ turned the water into the wine, then by reason of that turning, we say that ye wine was made of the water. So likewise if the bread be turned into the substance of Christ his body, we must not only say that the body of Christ is present, where the bread was before, but also that it is made of the bread, because that the substance of the bread is conuerted and turned into the substaunce of his bodye. Which thing the papists saw must needes follow, and therfore they plainly confessed, that the body of Christ was made of bread, which doctrine (as you truely say in this place) is intollerable, and not to be deuised by a scoffer in a play, when his fellow had forgotten his parte. And yet you so far forget your selfe in this booke, that throughout the same (what so euer you say here) you defend the same intollerable doctrin, not to be deuised by a scoffer.
- 1Making by conversion.Making by conuersion.
- 2Gen. 2.
- 3John. 2.Iohn. 2.