By such pretty cases, of the people disappointing the priests: and of lack of store of clerks, you might daily find cavillations with all godly ordinances. For where as God ordained the paschal lamb to be eaten up clean in every house:1 and where there were not enough in one house to eat up the Lamb, they should call of their neighbours so many as should suffice to eat up the hole Lamb, so that nothing should remain: Here you might bring in your (upon a chance) that they that lacked company to eat up a hole Lamb, dwelt alone far from other houses, and could not come together: or could not get any such Lamb as was appointed for the feast, or if their neighbours lacked company also. And what if they had no spit to roast the lamb? And where as it was commanded, that they should be shooed, what if perchance they had no shoes? And if perchance a mans wife were not at home, and all his servants fallen sick of the sweat, or plague, and no man durst come to his house, then must he turn the spit him self, and eat the Lamb all alone? Such chances you purposely devise, to establish your private Mass, that the priest may eat all alone. But by such a like reason as you make here, a man might prove, that the priest should preach or say matins to him self alone, in case (as you say) that the people which should come, would disappoint him. For what if the people disappoint the priest (say you) and come not to the communion? What if the people disappoint the priest (say I) and come not to matins nor sermon? shall he therefore say matins and preach, when no man is present but him self alone? But your imagined case hath such an absurdity in it, as is not tolerable to be thought to have been in Christian people in that time, when Clements Epistles were written, that when all the people should receive the communion with the priest, yet not one would come, but all would disappoint him. And yet in that case I doubt not, but the priest would have abstained from ministration unto more opportunity and more access of Christian people, as he would have done likewise in saying of matins and preaching. Wherefore in your case I might well answer you,2 as S. Hierom answered the argument made in the name of the heretic Jovinian, which might be brought against the commendation of virginity. What if all men would live virgins, and no man marry?
By such prety cases, of the people disapoynting the priestes: and of lacke of store of clerkes, you might dayly finde cauilations with all godly ordenaunces. For where as God ordayned the pascall lambe to be eaten vp cleane in euery house:1 and where there were not inough in one house to eat vp the Lambe, they should call of their neighbours so many as should suffice to eate vp the hole Lambe, so yt nothing should remayne: Here you might bring in your (vpon a chance) that they that lacked company to eate vp a hole Lambe, dwelt alone far from other houses, and could not come together: or could not gette any such Lambe as was appoynted for the feast, or if their neighbours lacked company also. And what if they had no spitte to rost the lambe? And where as it was commaunded, yt they should be shooed, what if perchance they had no shooes? And if perchaunce a mans wife were not at home, and all his seruaunts falled sike of the sweat, or plague, and no man durst come to his house, then must he turne the spitte him selfe, and eate the Lambe all alone? Such chances you purposely deuise, to establishe your priuat Masse, that the priest may eate all alone. But by such a lyke reason as you make here, a man might proue, that the priest should preach or say mattens to him selfe alone, in case (as you say) that the people which should come, would disapoynt him. For what if the people disapoynt the priest (say you) and come not to ye communion? What if the people disapoynt ye priest (say I) and come not to mattens nor sermon? shall he therfore say mattens and preach, whan no man is present but him selfe alone? But your imagined case hath such an absurditie in it, as is not tollerable to be thought to haue beene in Christian people in that tyme, when Clements Epistles were written, that when all the people should receaue the communion with the priest, yet not one would come, but all would disapoynt him. And yet in that case I doubt not, but the priest would haue absteined from ministration vnto more opportunitie and more accesse of Christian people, as he would haue done likewise in saying of mattens and preaching. Wherfore in your case I might well answer you,2 as S. Hierom answered the argument made in the name of the heretike Iouinian, which myght be brought agaynst the commendation of virginitie. What if all men would liue virgines, and no man marry?
- 1The Paschal Lamb.The Paschall Lamb.
- 2[…], aduersus Jovinianum, lib. 1.〈…〉, aduersus Iouinianum, lib. 1.