A DIALOGUE BETWEEN A. (an Arminian) and B. (the Conciliator.)
pp. 2991,951 passagespart 3 of 49
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The third Crimination.
A. III. You make God necessitate mens sin and damnation by your negative decrees, as well as others by their positive: For you hold, That no man can believe and repent, but such as God decreeth to give Faith and Repentance to: And no man can do any more good than God decreeth that he shall do. And some say that God decreeth, Not to give men any more Grace than he giveth them (which is a Decree objectively negative de non dando); And you and others say, That he doth not Decree to give them more. And so as a stone is not culpable for not flying, no more are Sinners, not elected, for not believing and obeying God.*
- *Note what Vasquez. granteth in 1. Tho. q. 23. a. 5. disp. 92. c. 2. Certum est praedestinationem gratiae, & ipsam primam gratiam (quod idem est) non esse in nostra potestate, sicut & praedestinationis & ipsius gratiae nullam causam aut occasionem ex nobis praecedere.
B. You wholly mistake and misreport us. If we differ from you, it is by going further from the matter of the Objection than you do your selves. 1. We hold, that God giveth many men power to do more than they do: And consequently that he decreeth to give it them. Men do not do all that they can do. Indeed we hold, That no man can do any thing, which God doth not give him power to do, and decree to give it him. And dare any of you deny this. There is no power but of God. 2. I hold not, that God hath any Will or Decree in proper sense, Not to give Grace, not to give Faith, not to give Repentance, Help, Means, &c. But only that he doth not decree to give it, where he giveth it not indeed; But as Lombard afore-cited, saith, He neither Willeth, nor Nilleth 1it. My Reasons are, 1. Only Good is the Object of Gods Will, and Evil of his Nolition. But nothing is not Good, nor Faith, Repentance, &c. nor Grace, evil: Therefore God doth not will nothing, or nill the said good. 2. Frustra fit per plura, &c. It is presumptuous to feign needless Decrees and Volitions in God: But the Decree of nothing (of not giving Grace) is vain: For nothing will be nothing, without any Decree or Volition of God, as well as without any efficiency. If God neither make, nor will more Worlds, more Sons, more Men, there will be no more, though he have no Will or positive Decree that there shall be no more. 3. No man knoweth where to bound the Doctrine of Decrees de nihilo; And to make them infinite or boundless, soundeth so presumptuously and profanely, that common reason doth disclaim it. It is possible that there be as many more sands, pebbles, straws, &c. made as are: It is possible to make every stone, or sand, an Animal, or the choice of a thousand other things: It's possible to give each man and Creature the choice of a thousand other names, places, circumstances: And must we feign in God a positive Will or Decree of every one of these possibles that they shall never be? That this Sand shall not be a Man, nor that Bird a Stone,