The First Charge made good against Transubstantiation: In which Popery is proved to be the Shame of Humane Nature, Contrary to SENSE, REASON, SCRIPTURE and TRADITION, or the judgement of the Ancient and Present Church; devised by Satan to expose Christianity to the Scorn of Infidels.The First Charge made good against Transubstantiation: In which Popery is proved to be the Shame of Humane Nature, Contrary to SENSE, REASON, SCRIPTURE and TRADITION, or the judgement of the Antient and Present Church; devised by Satan to expose Christianity to the Scorn of Infidels.
pp. 75–189300 passagespart 6 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
R. 1. But if sense be deceitful, how know you that you ever read such Decrees? 2. How know you that they are not forgeries, or since corrupted?
P. The Church is a safe keeper of its, own Records.
R. Still what mean you by the Church? The Vulgar neither keep nor understand your Councils. The Council of Trent is long ceased: No other General Council hath been since, to tell you what are the true Decrees of that Council. The Pope is not the Church: And he may err in a matter of fact: What then is the Church that tells you certainly what the Council of Trent decreed? Tell me if you can.
P. We have such common historical Evidence and Tradition, as you have for your Acts of Parliament when the Parliament is ended. The present Governors preserve them.
P. We have such common historical Evidence and Tradition, as you have for your Acts of Parliament when the Parliament is ended. The present Governours preserve them.
R. Very good: It is the Office of the Governors to take that Care, but therein they are not indefectible and infallible; but they and the published Laws, and the notice of the whole Land, and the Judicial proceedings by them in the Courts of Judicature make up a Certain Historical Evidence. And so it may be in your Case: And when you have talked your utmost, you can show no more. And have not we the same Writings of Fathers and Councils as you have? You dare not deny it. Why then may not we know what is in them as well as you? And I pray you tell me, Whether your Antiquaries, such as Albaspinaeus, Sixtus Senensis, Petavius, Sirmondus, &c. do prove what Cyprian, Optatus, Augustine, &c. held, by the judgement of the Pope or Councils, or by citing the words of the Authors themselves? And do Crab, Binnius, Surius, Caranza, &c. prove what one Council said by the authority of another, or by the Records themselves, yet visible to all?