Chapter 24
pp. 115–14183 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Argum. 2. The Apostle Thomas erred in a Material point (which is now an essential) when he would not believe Christs Resurrection: and yet was a member of the true Church: therefore, &c.
Argum. 2. The Apostle Thomas erred in a Materiall point (which is now an essentiall) when he would not believe Christs Resurrection: and yet was a member of the true Church: therefore, &c.
Argum. 3. The Papists err in material points, and yet think themselves of the same true Church: therefore they must confess that differing in Material points may be the case of members of the same true Church. For proof of the Minor, I demand: ⟨p. 128⟩Are none of the points Material that have been so hotly agitated between the Jesuits, and Dominicans and Jansenists? the Papal party, and the Council party? The Thomists, Scotists, Ockamists, &c. At least review the Jesuit Casuists cited by the Jansenists Mystery of Jesuitism; and tell us whether it be no whit Material Whether a man may kill another for a Crown? or may kill both Judge and witnesses to avoid an unjust sentence? Or whether a man should go with good meanings into a Whorehouse to persuade them to penitence, that hath found by experience that when he comes there he is naught with them himself? Or whether a man may lawfully lie and calumniate to put by a calumny? Or speak falsely with mental reservations? Or forbear loving God many years together, if not all his life? Are these points no whit Material? You know that one part of you (with a Pope and General Council) are for deposing Heretical Kings, and murdering and stabbing them, and others of you disavow it: Is this no whit material? And yet you are all of one Church and Religion. A hundred more of your differences I could name.
Argum. 3. The Papists err in material points, and yet think themselves of the same true Church: therefore they must confess that differing in Material points may be the case of members of the same true Church. For proof of the Minor, I demand: ⟨p. 128⟩Are none of the points Material that have been so hotly agitated between the Jesuites, and Dominicans and Jansenists? the Papall party, and the Councill party? The Thomists, Scotists, Ockamists, &c. At least review the Jesuite Casuists cited by the Jansenists Mysterie of Jesuitism; and tell us whether it be no whit Material Whether a man may kill another for a Crown? or may kill both Judge and witnesses to avoid an unjust sentence? Or whether a man should go with good meanings into a Whorehouse to perswade them to penitence, that hath found by experience that when he comes there he is naught with them himself? Or whether a man may lawfully lie and calumniate to put by a calumny? Or speak falsly with mentall reservations? Or forbear loving God many years together, if not all his life? Are these points no whit Material? You know that one part of you (with a Pope and General Council) are for deposing Heretical Kings, and murthering and stabbing them, and others of you disavow it: Is this no whit material? And yet you are all of one Church and Religion. A hundred more of your differences I could name.