A Key for Catholics, To open the jugglings of the Jesuits, and satisfy all that are but truly willing to understand, whether the cause of the Roman, or the Reformed Churches, be of God: and to leave the Reader utterly unexcusable, if after this he will be a Papist.A Key for Catholicks, To open the juglings of the Jesuits, and satisfie all that are but truly willing to understand, whether the cause of the Romane, or the Reformed Churches, be of God: and to leave the Reader utterly unexcusable, if after this he will be a Papist.
pp. 1–3761,259 passagespart 10 of 32
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And (by the way) I conceive you are thus to understand a clause in a late oath of Abjuration drawn up by the last Parliament to be offered to the Papists, viz. that [the Church of Rome is not the true Church] that is, 1. Not the whole Catholic Church, but part of it, as they are Christians. 2. Nor a true Church at all as Papal, and so formally as the Now Romish Church. But all this is little to our main Question.
And (by the way) I conceive you are thus to understand a clause in a late oath of Abjuration drawn up by the last Parliament to be offered to the Papists, viz. that [the Church of Rome is not the true Church] that is, 1. Not the whole Catholick Church, but part of it, as they are Christians. 2. Nor a true Church at all as Papal, and so formally as the Now Romish Church. But all this is little to our main Question.
Detect. 14. Another great Endeavour of the Papists is, to edness, unity, consistency and settledness in Religion: but we are still at uncertainty and to seek, incoherent, not tied together by any certain bond, but still upon divisions, and upon change: And they instance thus [A while ago you were Episcopal, and then Presbyterian, and now you are nothing, but every one goes his own way: A while ago you worshipped God in one manner, in Baptising, Marrying, Burying, Common Prayer, the Lords Supper; and now you have all new. Where is the Church of England now? some of you are for one Government, and some for another: the Lutherans have superintendents, the Calvinists are Presbyterians: And what names of reproach do the Episcopal give the Presbyterians? and the Presbyterians take them to be Antichristian. Some of you are Arminians; some Calvinists; some say Christ dyed for all, and some say no; some are for Justification only by Christs Passive Righteousness, and some also by his active; with other such differences even in these fundamental points.]
Detect. 14. ANother great Endeavour of the Papists is, to edness, unity, consistency and setledness in Religion: but we are still at uncertainty and to seek, incoherent, not tyed together by any certain bond, but still upon divisions, and upon change: And they instance thus [A while ago you were Episcopal, and then Presbyterian, and now you are nothing, but every one goes his own way: A while ago you worshipped God in one manner, in Baptising, Marrying, Burying, Common Prayer, the Lords Supper; and now you have all new. Where is the Church of England now? some of you are for one Government, and some for another: the Lutherans have superintendents, the Calvinists are Presbyterians: And what names of reproach do the Episcopal give the Presbyterians? and the Presbyterians take them to be Antichristian. Some of you are Arminians; some Calvinists; some say Christ dyed for all, and some say no; some are for Justification only by Christs Passive Righteousness, and some also by his active; with other such differences even in these fundamentall points.]
I repeat their words just as I have heard they make use of them with the people, and now I shall open the deceit of them in particular Answers to each part.
And 1. For the matter of unity, I have spoken of it before, and dare leave it to all the world that are judicious, whether the Papists or we are more unanimous, or more divided. Only to the Instances of division, I shall speak further now. 1. For the matter of Church Government, we are all agreed in the substance of it (except a very few stragglers;) As concerning the duty of Penitence, Confession, Restitution, Contrition, and of the excommunicating the obstinate, and Absolving the penitent, &c. All this we agree is the duty of the Presbyters; and we agree that these Presbyters may have a President, only some think that the President is ejusdem ordinis, of the same order, differing but in degree, and hath no power jure divino, but what the Presbyters have, but only the exercise is restrained as to the Presbyters, ⟨p. 108⟩by men; but others think that the President is a Bishop eminently of another order, having not only the exercise, but the power above the Presbyters. And is this difference so great a business? And do not these cheaters know, that if for this they would reproach us, they must do so by themselves? Know they not that among their own Schoolmen there is the same difference, or in most points the same? And know they not that if differences in Ceremonies or Modes should unchurch us, or disgrace us, it would fall as foul on the whole Catholic Church, and that in the very primitive times? Did they never read of the difference between the Asian and the Roman Churches, about the celebration of Easter day, and how Polycrates and the rest did plead Tradition against the Church of Romes Tradition; and how Irenaeus did reprehend the Bishop of Rome for his uncharitable censure of the Churches for so small a difference? And how Polycarp and Anicetus Bishop of Rome could not agree, as building upon contrary Traditions: but yet maintained Christian peace; as Eusebius out of Irenaeus his Epistle to Victor tells us, lib. 5. Hist. Eccl. cap. 26. And the English and Irish Churches long after that adhered to the Asian way; even after the Council of Nice had ended the controversy on the Roman side. And who knows not how many more controversies greater then these of ours have been among the Churches of Christ, without their unchurching or disparagement to Religion.
And 1. For the matter of unity, I have spoken of it before, and dare leave it to all the world that are judicions, whether the Papists or we are more unanimons, or more divided. Only to the Instances of division, I shall speak further now. 1. For the matter of Church Government, we are all agreed in the substance of it (except a very few straglers;) As concerning the duty of Penitence, Confession, Restitution, Contrition, and of the excommunicating the obstinate, and Absolving the penitent, &c. All this we agree is the duty of the Presbyters; and we agree that these Presbyters may have a President, only some think that the President is ejusdem ordinis, of the same order, differing but in degree, and hath no power jure divino, but what the Presbyters have, but only the exercise is restrained as to the Presbyters,
And for the Doctrinal Controversies mentioned, most of them lie more in words then in sense, and all of them are far from the foundation, though they be about Christ, who is the Foundation. If one of your picture-drawers mistake the complexion of Christ, or if one should say he was not buried in a sheet, these are errors about Christ that is the foundation, and yet far from the foundation. Those of us that say Christ dyed for all, and those that say he dyed not for all, do agree as your School-men do, that he dyed for all, as to the sufficiency of his death and price: but he dyed not for all as to the actual efficiency of pardon and salvation: Is not this your doctrine? and is not this ours? and are not you as much disagreed about it as we? what else meant the late decision against the Jansenists? and what meaneth the present persecution of them in France? And yet have you the faces to make this a reproach of us? And for ⟨p. 109⟩the righteousness of Christ, we are commonly agreed that it is both his Obedience and Passion that we are justified and saved by: though we are not all of a mind about the reason of their several interests; which difference is so far from unchristening us, that it makes no considerable odds among our selves, who are censorious enough in cases of difference.
And for the Doctrinal Controversies mentioned, most of them lie more in words then in sence, and all of them are far from the foundation, though they be about Christ, who is the Foundation. If one of your picture-drawers mistake the complexion of Christ, or if one should say he was not buried in a sheet, these are errours about Christ that is the foundation, and yet far from the foundation. Those of us that say Christ dyed for all, and those that say he dyed not for all, do agree as your School-men do, that he dyed for all, as to the sufficiency of his death and price: but he dyed not for all as to the actuall efficiency of pardon and salvation: Is not this your doctrine? and is not this ours? and are not you as much disagreed about it as we? what else meant the late decision against the Jansenists? and what meaneth the present persecution of them in France? And yet have you the faces to make this a reproach of us? And for ⟨p. 109⟩the righteousness of Christ, we are commonly agreed that it is both his Obedience and Passion that we are justified and saved by: though we are not all of a mind about the reason of their several interests; which difference is so far from unchristening us, that it makes no considerable odds among our selves, who are censorious enough in cases of difference.
And for different forms of worship, sure these men do wilfully forget what a number of Offices and Mass books have been among themselves and other Churches? and what a number of Litanies or Liturgies of several ages and Churches they have given us in the Bibliotheca Patrum? but more of this anon.
And for different forms of worship, sure these men do wilfully forget what a number of Offices and Mass books have been among themselves and other Churches? and what a number of Letanies or Liturgies of several ages and Churches they have given us in the Bibliotheca Patrum? but more of this anon.
2. And as for the changes and unfixedness which they charge us with, we are contented that 1. Our principles. 2. And our practises be compared with the Papists, and then let even modest and judicious enemies be judges which of us are more fixed, or more mutable.
1. For our Principles: we take only Christ to be the chief Foundation of our Faith, and his inspired Prophets and Apostles to be the secondary foundation: whereas the Papists build upon many a most ungodly ignorant man, because he is the Pope of Rome. And which of these is the firmer foundation?
2. We take nothing for our Rule but the sure word of God contained in the holy Scriptures: but the Papists take the Decrees of all Popes and Councils for their Rule: Our Rule they confess to be Divine and infallible: Their Rule we affirm to be humane and fallible. Which then is like to be more firm? Our Rule (the sacred Scriptures in the Original languages, as to the words, and the matter of them, as to the sense) the Papists themselves confess unchangeable; but whether they will say as much of their own, I will try by two or three Instances. 1. What an alteration Pope Sixtus, and Pope Clement made in the Vulgar Latin Bible, which is one part of their Rule, I told you before, and Dr. James his Bellum Papal will tell you the particulars. 2. The other part is their Decrees, of which Pope Leo the tenth in Bulla contr. Luth. in Binnius, page 655. saith [the holy Popes our predecessors never erred in their Canons and Constitutions] And yet hear what Pope Julius the second saith in his General Council at the Lateran ⟨p. 110⟩with their approbation, Cant. pragmat. sanct. monitor. Binnius, vol. 4. pag. 560. [Though the Institutions of sacred Canons, holy Fathers, and Popes of Rome—and their Decrees be judged immutable, as made by Divine Inspiration; yet the Pope of Rome, who, though of unequal merits, holdeth the place of the Eternal King, and the Maker of all things, and all Laws on earth, may abrogate these Decrees when they are abused.]
2. We take nothing for our Rule but the sure word of God contained in the holy Scriptures: but the Papists take the Decrees of all Popes and Councils for their Rule: Our Rule they confess to be Divine and infallible: Their Rule we affirm to be humane and fallible. Which then is like to be more firm? Our Rule (the sacred Scriptures in the Originall languages, as to the words, and the matter of them, as to the sence) the Papists themselves confess unchangeable; but whether they will say as much of their own, I will try by two or three Instances. 1. What an alteration Pope Sixtus, and Pope Clement made in the Vulgar Latine Bible, which is one part of their Rule, I told you before, and Dr. James his Bellum Papale will tell you the particulars. 2. The other part is their Decrees, of which Pope Leo the tenth in Bulla contr. Luth. in Binnius, page 655. saith [the holy Popes our predecessors never erred in their Canons and Constitutions] And yet hear what Pope Julius the second saith in his General Councill at the Laterane ⟨p. 110⟩
You see here from the mouth of Infallibility it self (if the Roman faith have any) of what continuance we may judge their Immutable Decrees to be of, which are made as by Divine inspiration: they are Immutable till the Pope abrogate them, who being in Gods place, though of unequal merits (O humble confession!) is of power to do it.
3. We have a Rule that was perfected by Christ and his Apostles, to which nothing can be added, and therefore we are at a Certainty for our Religion: for we have a sure and perfect Rule from Heaven. Nothing may be added to it, or taken from it. But the Papists do profess that the Determinations of the Pope or Council may make a point (and so five thousand points, for there is no certain number) to be de fide articles of faith, and necessary to salvation, though not in se, yet quoad nos, as to us. (And what it is for a Law to be obligatory in se, and not quoad nos, is hard to understand.) So that the Papists never know when their faith is perfect and grown to its full stature. For ought they know a thousand more Articles yet may be added. And yet these men of uncertain growing faith, have the face to persuade men that we are mutable, and they are fixed. You see our several Principles: now to our Practices.
3. We have a Rule that was perfected by Christ and his Apostles, to which nothing can be added, and therefore we are at a Certainty for our Religion: for we have a sure and perfect Rule from Heaven. Nothing may be added to it, or taken from it. But the Papists do profess that the Determinations of the Pope or Councill may make a point (and so five thousand points, for there is no certain number) to be de fide articles of faith, and necessary to salvation, though not in se, yet quoad nos, as to us. (And what it is for a Law to be obligatory in se, and not quoad nos, is hard to understand.) So that the Papists never know when their faith is perfect and grown to its full stature. For ought they know a thousand more Articles yet may be added. And yet these men of uncertain growing faith, have the face to perswade men that we are mutable, and they are fixed. You see our several Principles: now to our Practices.
For our part, 1. We never changed our Head, our Lord, our Faith, or one Article of our Faith: if malice it self be able to charge us with changing the smallest Article of our Faith, let them say their worst: we change not our Rule, the holy Scriptures, nor one clause or sentence of it, but endeavour the preservation of the same, which at the first we received. In our contests with the Papists, our great offence is at their mutation from the ancient Rule and way; we contend but for the faith once delivered to the Saints: the old way with us is the good way: we abhor a Religion that is new sprung up, or is less then one thousand five hundred and fifty years standing at least. If we ⟨p. 111⟩change in any thing, it is but by repenting of our former changeableness while our Nation was Popish; having then changed from the Apostolic simplicity, we change from that sinful change, and return to the ancient way again. And if we have made any further changes since our first change at the Reformation, it is but a perfecting the change to Antiquity, and Apostolic simplicity which we then begun. Rome was not built in a day, and is not pulled down in a day. The work of Reformation is but one change, though it be not done all at one time. If we find some spots of Romish dirt upon us, that escaped us at our first washing, it is no dangerous mutability yet to wash it off. If a man converted by saving grace be not perfectly rid of all his former sin the first day of his Conversion, should he be reproached as mutable for striving against it all his life after, and casting it off by degrees as he is able? If a man did but recover by degrees from the relics of his disease, they will not therefore reproach him as mutable? If he sweep the dust or dirt out of his house every day, they will not say, He is mutable and knows not where to rest. These men might as well reproach us as mutable, because we rise in the morning and do not still lie in bed; or because we go to bed at night, and do not stay up still.
For our part, 1. We never changed our Head, our Lord, our Faith, or one Article of our Faith: if malice it self be able to charge us with changing the smallest Article of our Faith, let them say their worst: we change not our Rule, the holy Scriptures, nor one clause or sentence of it, but endeavour the preservation of the same, which at the first we received. In our contests with the Papists, our great offence is at their mutation from the antient Rule and way; we contend but for the faith once delivered to the Saints: the old way with us is the good way: we abhor a Religion that is new sprung up, or is less then one thousand five hundred and fifty years standing at least. If we
But what is it that we are changeable in? we have changed none of the substance of worship: did we baptize before, and do we not so still? Did we pray or administer the Lords Supper before, and do we not so still? what is the change? why, 1. We before used the common Prayer book and now we do not. 2. Before we used prayers at the burial of the dead, which now are omitted. 3. Before we used the Cross and Surplice, and kneeled at the Sacrament, which are now omitted. And what then? therefore we have changed our Religion. Even as a man changeth his clothes by brushing them, or his house by sweeping it, or his face by washing it. Do these men think us so sottish as to place our Religion in these Circumstances? God hath bid us Pray continually: but he hath not told us whether we shall use a Prayer book or not, but left that to mens necessities or conveniences to determine of. And doth a man change his Religion or Worship of God, if he either begin or cease to use a Book? If any man had so little wit or Religion, as to place their Religion in a Prayer book, its no great loss to them if they have lost their Religion, when the […] ⟨p. 110⟩[…] ⟨p. 111⟩⟨p. 112⟩Prayer book is taken from them. We doubt not but Prayer books are profitable to some, and hinderances to others: some should use them, and some should not: but whether we use them, or not use them, is no part of our Religion at all, but a mere Accident, or common help and appurtenance. God hath not told preachers whether they shall use any Notes for their memory in Preaching: to one it is an hinderance; to another an help. Doth a man change his Religion when he changeth a custom of using Notes? God hath not told us what Chapter we shall read, or what Psalm we shall sing, or what Text we shall Preach on this day or that day. What if one age think it best that some Pastors give Laws to all the rest, that they shall read no Chapter, preach on no Text, and sing no Psalm but by their direction: and the next age think it meeter to leave it to each Minister, as thinking it unfit to Ordain such Ministers that have not wit enough to choose their Text, or Chapter, or Psalm according to occasions. Will you say that here is a change of Religion? These outside Hypocrites tell the world what a thing they take Religion to be, and in what they place it. What if one man use an hour-glass in preaching, and another use none?
What if one read a Chapter with spectacles, and another without? or if one preach in a Pulpit, and another below: or if one preach in a white garment, or another in a black: or if one stand at the Sacrament, and another sit, and another kneel: Are we therefore of several Religions? or is this any part of the worship it self? Do we not all now either stand, sit, or kneel at the hearing of a Sermon, as we please? Do we not kneel or stand at Prayer as we please? Yea do not men commonly in singing Psalms of Prayer or Praise to God, sit or stand as they please? And what if we do so at the Sacrament? Is it not all one? Or doth standing, kneeling or sitting make another Religion, or any part of it? And for Marrying, Burying, Baptizing, and the rest, we have altered no part at all of the worship of God; but order them in that manner as seemeth most convenient. What ignorant souls are these, that think that the using a Prayer book, or praying without book, or the using this gesture, or that, these words, or those words that are to the same sense, doth make different Religions or Ordinances of worship? These are tricks that none but the sottishly ignorant will be deluded with, that know not wh••⟨p. 113⟩Religion or worship is. They may as well say, If I change my Lecture-day from Thursday to Friday, that I change my Religion or the worship of God. These are our great changes.
What if one read a Chapter with spectacles, and another without? or if one preach in a Pulpit, and another below: or if one preach in a white garment, or another in a black: or if one stand at the Sacrament, and another sit, and another kneel: Are we therefore of several Religions? or is this any part of the worship it self? Do we not all now either stand, sit, or kneel at the hearing of a Sermon, as we please? Do we not kneel or stand at Prayer as we please? Yea do not men commonly in singing Psalms of Prayer or Praise to God, sit or stand as they please? And what if we do so at the Sacrament? Is it not all one? Or doth standing, kneeling or sitting make another Religion, or any part of it? And for Marrying, Burying, Baptizing, and the rest, we have altered no part at all of the worship of God; but order them in that manner as seemeth most convenient. What ignorant souls are these, that think that the using a Prayer book, or praying without book, or the using this gesture, or that, these words, or those words that are to the same sence, doth make different Religions or Ordinances of worship? These are tricks that none but the sottishly ignorant will be deluded with, that know not wh
Well I will you now hear whether the Papists or we be the greatest Changelings? 1. Some just changes they have made themselves, that they know well enough are as great as ours. It was so common in the ancient Church to Pray only standing on every Lords day, and not to kneel at all in any part of the worship of that day, that it was taken for an universal Tradition, and to kneel was taken for a great sin, and condemned by General Councils many hundred years after Christ; and yet the Church of Rome, and other Churches as well as we, have cast off this pretended Tradition, violated this Decree of General Councils, and forsaken this universal Custom of the Church. And the Papists receive the Eucharist kneeling, for all this Law and Custom.
Well I will you now hear whether the Papists or we be the greatest Changlings? 1. Some just changes they have made themselves, that they know well enough are as great as ours. It was so common in the antient Church to Pray only standing on every Lords day, and not to kneel at all in any part of the worship of that day, that it was taken for an universal Tradition, and to kneel was taken for a great sin, and condemned by General Councils many hundred years after Christ; and yet the Church of Rome, and other Churches as well as we, have cast off this pretended Tradition, violated this Decree of General Councils, and forsaken this universal Custom of the Church. And the Papists receive the Eucharist kneeling, for all this Law and Custome.
In the primitive Church, and in Tertullians days, a Common Feast of the Church was used with the Lords Supper, and the Sacrament taken then. But now this Custom is also changed. It was then the Custom to sing extempore in the Congregation to Gods praise. But now Rome it self hath no such Custom. It was once the Custom to give Infants the Lords Supper: but now Rome it self hath cast off that Custom. Once it was a Canon that Bishops must not read the books of Gentiles, (Concil. Carthag. 4.) which yet Paul made use of, and the Papists now do too much value. Abundance such changes might be mentioned, greater then ours, in which we are justified by the Papists themselves.
In the primitive Church, and in Tertullians dayes, a Common Feast of the Church was used with the Lords Supper, and the Sacrament taken then. But now this Custom is also changed. It was then the Custom to sing extempore in the Congregation to Gods praise. But now Rome it self hath no such Custom. It was once the Custom to give Infants the Lords Supper: but now Rome it self hath cast off that Custom. Once it was a Canon that Bishops must not read the books of Gentiles, (Concil. Carthag. 4.) which yet Paul made use of, and the Papists now do too much value. Abundance such changes might be mentioned, greater then ours, in which we are justified by the Papists themselves.
2. But they have yet other kind of changes then these. They have changed the very Essence of the Catholic Church (in their esteem;) they have changed the Officers, the Doctrine, the Discipline, the Worship, and what not, as though they had been born for change, to turn all upside down.
2. But they have yet other kind of changes then these. They have changed the very Essence of the Catholick Church (in their esteem;) they have changed the Officers, the Doctrine, the Discipline, the Worship, and what not, as though they had been born for change, to turn all upside down.
In the Primitive times Rome was but a particular Church, as […] ⟨p. 112⟩[…] ⟨p. 113⟩⟨p. 114⟩Jerusalem and other Churches were: but they have changed it, to be the Mistress of all Churches.
In the Primitive times Rome was but a particular Church, as 〈…〉⟨p. 112⟩〈…〉⟨p. 113⟩⟨p. 114⟩Jerusalem and other Churches were: but they have changed it, to be the Mistris of all Churches.
In the ancient Church all sorts were earnestly exhorted to read, or hear, and study the Scripture in a known tongue: but they have changed this into a desperate restraint, proclaiming it the cause of all Heresies.
In the antient Church all sorts were earnestly exhorted to read, or hear, and study the Scripture in a known tongue: but they have changed this into a desperate restraint, proclaiming it the cause of all Heresies.
In the ancient Church the Bread and Wine was the Body and Blood of Christ Representative and Relative: but they have changed it into the real Body and Blood.
In the antient Church the Bread and Wine was the Body and Blood of Christ Representative and Relative: but they have changed it into the real Body and Blood.
Heretofore there was Bread and Wine remaining after the words of Consecration: but they have changed so, that there remaineth neither Bread nor Wine, but the qualities and quantity, without the substance, and this must be believed, because they say it, against Scripture and Antiquity, and in despite of sense it self.
Heretofore there was Bread and Wine remaining after the words of Consecration: but they have changed so, that there remaineth neither Bread nor Wine, but the qualities and quantity, without the substance, and this must be believed, because they say it, against Scripture and Antiquity, and in despight of sense it self.
In the ancient Church the Lords Supper was administered in both kinds, bread and wine to all: but they have lately changed this into one kind only to the people, denying them one half of the Sacrament.
In the antient Church the Lords Supper was administred in both kinds, bread and wine to all: but they have lately changed this into one kind only to the people, denying them one half of the Sacrament.
Of old the Lords Supper was but the Commemoration of the sacrifice of Christ upon the Cross, and a Sacrament of our Communion with him and his members: but now they have changed it into a propitiatory sacrifice for the sins of the quick and dead: and in it they adore a piece of Bread as very God, with Divine worship.
Of old, men were taught to make daily confession of sin, and beg pardon, and when they had done all, to confess themselves unprofitable servants: but now they are so changed, that they pretend not only to be perfect without sin, and to Merit by the Condignity of their works with God, but to supererogate and be more perfect then innocency could make them, by doing more then their duty.
Of old those things were accounted sins deserving Hell, and needing the blood of Christ for pardon, which now are changed into venial sins, which properly are no sins, and deserve no more then temporal punishment.
Of old the Pastors of the Churches were subject to the Rulers of the Commonwealth; even every soul, not only for wrath, but for Conscience sake was obliged to be subject: but now all the Clergy are exempted from secular Judgement, and yet the secular power is subject to them: for the Pope hath power to depose Princes, and dispossess them of their Dominions, and put others in their rooms, and dissolve the bonds of Oaths and Covenants, in which the subjects were obliged to them, and to allow men to murder them by stabbing, poisoning, &c. If you do not believe me, stay but till I come to it, and I shall give you yet some further proof.
Of old the Pastors of the Churches were subject to the Rulers of the Commonwealth; even every soul, not only for wrath, but for Conscience sake was obliged to be subject: but now all the Clergy are exempted from secular Judgement, and yet the secular power is subject to them: for the Pope hath power to depose Princes, and dispossess them of their Dominions, and put others in their rooms, and dissolve the bonds of Oaths and Covenants, in which the subjects were obliged to them, and to allow men to murder them by stabbing, poysoning, &c. If you do not believe me, stay but till I come to it, and I shall give you yet some further proof.
Would you have any more of the Popish Changes? Why I might fill a volume with them. Should I but recite all the changes they have made in Doctrines, and all that they have made in Church Orders, and Discipline, and Religious Orders and their Discipline, and in Worship, and Ceremonies, I should be over tedious: their very Liturgy or Mass-book hath been changed, and made by changes, such abundance of additions it hath had since the beginning of it. What changes Sixtus the fifth, and Clement the eighth made in their Bibles, I told you before: as also what changes they have had in the election of their Popes.
Would you have any more of the Popish Changes? Why I might fill a volume with them. Should I but recite all the changes they have made in Doctrines, and all that they have made in Church Orders, and Discipline, and Religious Orders and their Discipline, and in Worship, and Ceremonies, I should be over tedious: their very Liturgy or Mass-book hath been changed, and made by changes, such abundance of additions it hath had since the beginning of it. What changes Sixtus the fift, and Clement the eighth made in their Bibles, I told you before: as also what changes they have had in the election of their Popes.
And now I am content that any impartial man be judge whether Papists or the Reformed Churches are the more mutable and unsettled in their Religion? and which of them is at the greater certainty, firmness, and immutability?
And now I am content that any impartial man be judge whether Papists or the Reformed Churches are the more mutable and unsetled in their Religion? and which of them is at the greater certainty, firmness, and immutability?
Detect. 15. Another fraud of the Papists, which they place not the least of their confidence in, is this: They persuade the people that our Church and Religion is but new, of the other days invention: and that theirs is the only old Religion. And therefore they call upon us to give them a Catalogue of the professors of our Religion in all ages; which they pretend we cannot do: and ask us where our Church was before Luther?
Detect. 15. ANother fraud of the Papists, which they place not the least of their confidence in, is this: They perswade the people that our Church and Religion is but new, of the other dayes invention: and that theirs is the only old Religion. And therefore they call upon us to give them a Catalogue of the professors of our Religion in all ages; which they pretend we cannot do: and ask us where our Church was before Luther?
To this we shall give them once more a brief, but satisfactory answer. I. We are so fully assured that the oldest Religion is the best, (since the date of the Gospel) that we are contented that our whole cause do stand or fall by this trial. Let him be esteemed of the true Religion, that is of the oldest Religion. This is the main difference between us and the Papists: We are for no Religion that is not as old as the days of the Apostles: but they are for the Novelties and Additions of Popes and Councils. Their own Polidore Virgil de Inven. Rerum, p. 410. lib 8. c. 4. calling us a Sect, doth give you a just description of us [Ita licentia pacta loquendi, &c. i. e. Having once got leave to speak, that sect did marvellously increase in a short time; which is called Evangelical, because they affirm that no Law is to be received which belongeth to salvation, but what is given by Christ or the Apostles.] Mark what they confess themselves of our Religion: And yet these very men have the face to charge us with Novelty; as if Christ and his Apostles were not of sufficient Antiquity for them. Our main quarrel with them is, for adding new inventions in Religion, and their principal business against us is to defend it, and yet they call theirs the old Religion, and ours the new.
To this we shall give them once more a brief, but satisfactory answer. I. We are so fully assured that the oldest Religion is the best, (since the date of the Gospell) that we are contented that our whole cause do stand or fall by this tryall. Let him be esteemed of the true Religion, that is of the oldest Religion. This is the main difference between us and the Papists: We are for no Religion that is not as old as the dayes of the Apostles: but they are for the Novelties and Additions of Popes and Councils. Their own Polidore Virgil de Inven. Rerum, p. 410. lib 8. c. 4. calling us a Sect, doth give you a just description of us [Ita licentia pacta loquendi, &c. i. e. Having once got leave to speak, that sect did marvailously increase in a short time; which is called Evangelicall, because they affirm that no Law is to be received which belongeth to salvation, but what is given by Christ or the Apostles.] Mark what they confess themselves of our Religion: And yet these very men have the face to charge us with Novelty; as if Christ and his Apostles were not of sufficient Antiquity for them. Our main quarrel with them is, for adding new inventions in Religion, and their principal business against us is to defend it, and yet they call theirs the old Religion, and ours the new.
Our Argument lieth thus. That which is most conform to the Doctrine and Practice of Christ and his Apostles, is the truly Ancient Religion and Church. But our Religion and Church is most conform to the doctrine and practice of the Apostles: therefore it is the truly ancient Religion and Church. The Major they will yield: For no older Religion is desirable, further then as the Law of Nature and Moral Determinations of God are still in force. I suppose they will not plead for Judaism. For the Minor, we lay our cause upon it, and are ready to produce our evidence for the Conformity of our Religion and Churches to the doctrine and practice of the Apostles.
Our Argument lieth thus. That which is most conform to the Doctrine and Practice of Christ and his Apostles, is the truly Antient Religion and Church. But our Religion and Church is most conform to the doctrine and practice of the Apostles: therefore it is the truly antient Religion and Church. The Major they will yield: For no older Religion is desirable, further then as the Law of Nature and Moral Determinations of God are still in force. I suppose they will not plead for Judaism. For the Minor, we lay our cause upon it, and are ready to produce our evidence for the Conformity of our Religion and Churches to the doctrine and practice of the Apostles.
That Religion which is most conform to the Holy Scripture is most conform to the doctrine and practice of Christ and his Apostles: But our Religion (and Churches) is most conform to the holy Scriptures: therefore, &c. They can say nothing against the Major, but that the Scripture is Insufficient without Tradition: But for that, 1. We have no Rule of faith but what is by themselves confessed to be ⟨p. 117⟩true: They acknowledge Scripture to be the true word of God; So that the Truth of our Rule is Justified by themselves. 2. Let them show us as good Evidence that their Additional Articles of faith or Laws of life came from the Apostles, as we do that the Scriptures came from them, and then we shall confess that we come short of them: Let them take the Controversies between us point by point, and bring their proof, and we will bring ours, and let that Religion carry it that is Apostolical: But we are sure that by this means they will be proved Novelists. For 1. Their Traditions in matter of faith superadded to the Scripture, are mere Heretical or Erroneous forgeries, and they can give us no proof that ever they were Apostolical. 2. The Scripture affirmeth its own sufficiency; and therefore excludeth their Traditions. 3. I showed you how in their own General Council at Basil, the Scripture sufficiency was defended. 4. I have showed you in my Book called the Safe Religion, that the ancient Fathers were for the sufficiency of Scripture. 5. Their Traditions are the opinions of a dividing sect, contrary to the Traditions or doctrine of the present Catholic Church: the far greater part of Christians being against them. 6. We are able to show that the time was for some hundred years after Christ, when most of their pretended Traditions were unknown or abhorred by the Christian Church, and no such things were in being among them. 7. And we can prove that the chief points of Controversy maintained against us, are not only without Scripture, but against it, and from thence we have full particular evidence to disprove them. If the Scriptures be true, as they confess them to be, then no Tradition can be Apostolical or true that is contrary to them: For example: the Papists Tradition is, that the Clergy is exempt from the Magistrates judgement: But the holy Scripture saith [Let every soul be subject to the higher power, Rom. 13. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.
That Religion which is most conform to the Holy Scriture is most conform to the doctrine and practice of Christ and his Apostles: But our Religion (and Churches) is most conform to the holy Scriptures: therefore, &c. They can say nothing against the Major, but that the Scripture is Insufficient without Tradition: But for that, 1. We have no Rule of faith but what is by themselves confessed to be
The Papists Tradition is for serving God publicly in an unknown tongue. But the holy Scripture is fully against it. Their Tradition is against Lay mens reading the Scripture in a known tongue, without special License from their ordinary: But Scripture and all antiquity is against them. The like we may say of many other Controversies.
The Papists Tradition is for serving God publickly in an unknown tongue. But the holy Scripture is fully against it. Their Tradition is against Lay mens reading the Scripture in a known tongue, without special License from their ordinary: But Scripture and all antiquity is against them. The like we may say of many other Controversies.
So that these seven ways we know their Traditions to be ⟨p. 118⟩deceitful; because they are 1. Unproved. 2. Against the sufficiency of Scripture. 3. Against their own former confessions. 4. Against the consent of the Fathers. 5. Contrary to the judgement of most of the Catholic Church. 6. We can prove that once the Church was without them. 7. And they are many of them contrary to express Scripture.
So that these seven wayes we know their Traditions to be ⟨p. 118⟩deceitfull; because they are 1. Unproved. 2. Against the sufficiency of Scripture. 3. Against their own former confessions. 4. Against the concent of the Fathers. 5. Contrary to the judgement of most of the Catholick Church. 6. We can prove that once the Church was without them. 7. And they are many of them contrary to express Scripture.
⟨p. 108⟩
by men; but others think that the President is a Bishop eminently of another order, having not only the exercise, but the power above the Presbyters. And is this difference so great a business? And do not these cheaters know, that if for this they would reproach us, they must do so by themselves? Know they not that among their own Schoolmen there is the same difference, or in most points the same? And know they not that if differences in Ceremonies or Modes should unchurch us, or disgrace us, it would fall as foul on the whole Catholick Church, and that in the very primitive times? Did they never read of the difference between the Asian and the Roman Churches, about the celebration of Easter day, and how Polycrates and the rest did plead Tradition against the Church of Romes Tradition; and how Irenaeus did reprehend the Bishop of Rome for his uncharitable censure of the Churches for so small a difference? And how Polycarp and Anicetus Bishop of Rome could not agree, as building upon contrary Traditions: but yet maintained Christian peace; as Eusebius out of Irenaeus his Epistle to Victor tels us, lib. 5. Hist. Eccl. cap. 26. And the English and Irish Churches long after that adhered to the Asian way; even after the Councill of Nice had ended the controversie on the Roman side. And who knows not how many more controversies greater then these of ours have been among the Churches of Christ, without their unchurching or disparagement to Religion.
with their approbation, Cant. pragmat. sanct. monitor. Binnius, vol. 4. pag. 560. [Though the Institutions of sacred Canons, holy Fathers, and Popes of Rome—and their Decrees be judged immutable, as made by Divine Inspiration; yet the Pope of Rome, who, though of unequal merits, holdeth the place of the Eternal King, and the Maker of all things, and all Laws on earth, may abrogate these Decrees when they are abused.]
⟨p. 111⟩
change in any thing, it is but by repenting of our former changeableness while our Nation was Popish; having then changed from the Apostolick simplicity, we change from that sinful change, and return to the antient way again. And if we have made any further changes since our first change at the Reformation, it is but a perfecting the change to Antiquity, and Apostolick simplicity which we then begun. Rome was not built in a day, and is not pulled down in a day. The work of Reformation is but one change, though it be not done all at one time. If we find some spots of Romish dirt upon us, that escaped us at our first washing, it is no dangerous mutability yet to wash it off. If a man converted by saving grace be not perfectly rid of all his former sin the first day of his Conversion, should he be reproached as mutable for striving against it all his life after, and casting it off by degrees as he is able? If a man did but recover by degrees from the relicks of his disease, they will not therefore reproach him as mutable? If he sweep the dust or dirt out of his house every day, they will not say, He is mutable and knows not where to rest. These men might as well reproach us as mutable, because we rise in the morning and do not still lie in bed; or because we go to bed at night, and do not stay up still.
But what is it that we are changeable in? we have changed none of the substance of worship: did we baptize before, and do we not so still? Did we pray or administer the Lords Supper before, and do we not so still? what is the change? why, 1. We before used the common Prayer book and now we do not. 2. Before we used prayers at the buria of the dead, which now are omitted. 3. Before we used the Cross and Surplice, and kneeled at the Sacrament, which are now omitted. And what then? therefore we have changed our Religion. Even as a man changeth his cloaths by brushing them, or his house by sweeping it, or his face by washing it. Do these men think us so sottish as to place our Religion in these Circumstances? God hath bid us Pray continually: but he hath not told us whether we shall use a Prayer book or not, but left that to mens necessities or conveniences to determine of. And doth a man change his Religion or Worship of God, if he either begin or cease to use a Book? If any man had so little wit or Religion, as to place their Religion in a Prayer book, its no great loss to them if they have lost their Religion, when the 〈…〉
⟨p. 110⟩
〈…〉
⟨p. 111⟩
⟨p. 112⟩
Prayer book is taken from them. We doubt not but Prayer books are profitable to some, and hinderances to others: some should use them, and some should not: but whether we use them, or not use them, is no part of our Religion at all, but a meer Accident, or common help and appurtenance. God hath not told preachers whether they shall use any Notes for their memory in Preaching: to one it is an hinderance; to another an help. Doth a man change his Religion when he changeth a custome of using Notes? God hath not told us what Chapter we shall read, or what Psalm we shall sing, or what Text we shall Preach on this day or that day. What if one age think it best that some Pastors give Laws to all the rest, that they shall read no Chapter, preach on no Text, and sing no Psalm but by their direction: and the next age think it meeter to leave it to each Minister, as thinking it unfit to Ordain such Ministers that have not wit enough to choose their Text, or Chapter, or Psalm according to occasions. Will you say that here is a change of Religion? These outside Hypocrites tell the world what a thing they take Religion to be, and in what they place it. What if one man use an hour-glass in preaching, and another use none?
••
⟨p. 113⟩
Religion or worship is. They may as well say, If I change my Lecture-day from Thursday to Friday, that I change my Religion or the worship of God. These are our great changes.
⟨p. 117⟩
true: They acknowledge Scripture to be the true word of God; So that the Truth of our Rule is Justified by themselves. 2. Let them shew us as good Evidence that their Additional Articles of faith or Laws of life came from the Apostles, as we do that the Scriptures came from them, and then we shall confess that we come short of them: Let them take the Controversies between us point by point, and bring their proof, and we will bring ours, and let that Religion carry it that is Apostolicall: But we are sure that by this means they will be proved Novelists. For 1. Their Traditions in matter of faith superadded to the Scripture, are meer Hereticall or Erroneous forgeries, and they can give us no proof that ever they were Apostolicall. 2. The Scripture affirmeth its own sufficiency; and therefore excludeth their Traditions. 3. I shewed you how in their own General Council at Basil, the Scripture sufficiency was defended. 4. I have shewed you in my Book called the Safe Religion, that the ancient Fathers were for the sufficiency of Scripture. 5. Their Traditions are the opinions of a dividing sect, contrary to the Traditions or doctrine of the present Catholick Church: the far greater part of Christians being against them. 6. We are able to shew that the time was for some hundred years after Christ, when most of their pretended Traditions were unknown or abhorred by the Christian Church, and no such things were in being among them. 7. And we can prove that the chief points of Controversie mantained against us, are not only without Scripture, but against it, and from thence we have full particular evidence to disprove them. If the Scriptures be true, as they confess them to be, then no Tradition can be Apostolicall or true that is contrary to them: For example: the Papists Tradition is, that the Clergy is exempt from the Magistrates judgement: But the holy Scripture saith [Let every soul be subject to the higher power, Rom. 13. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.