A Key for Catholics, To open the jugglings of the Jesuits, and satisfy all that are but truly willing to understand, whether the cause of the Roman, or the Reformed Churches, be of God: and to leave the Reader utterly unexcusable, if after this he will be a Papist.A Key for Catholicks, To open the juglings of the Jesuits, and satisfie all that are but truly willing to understand, whether the cause of the Romane, or the Reformed Churches, be of God: and to leave the Reader utterly unexcusable, if after this he will be a Papist.
pp. 1–3761,259 passagespart 6 of 32
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Bunney the Jesuit holds [that when the patient follows a probable opinion, the confessor is bound to absolve him, though his judgement be contrary to that of the penitent: and that he sins mortally if he deny him absolution] Mister. of Jesuit. pag. 97. But the Jansenists deny this.
Bunney the Jesuite holds [that when the patient follows a probable opinion, the confessor is bound to absolve him, though his judgement be contrary to that of the penitent: and that he sins mortally if he deny him absolution] Myster. of Jesuit. pag. 97. But the Jansenists deny this.
Father Reginaldus and Cellot hold, that [the modern Casuists in questions of Morality are to be preferred before the ancient Fathers, though they were nearer the Apostles times] Pag. 98. But the Jansenists think otherwise.
Father Reginaldus and Cellot hold, that [the modern Casuists in questions of Morality are to be preferred before the antient Fathers, though they were nearer the Aposiles times] Pag. 98. But the Jansenists think otherwise.
Pope Gregory the fourteenth declareth Murderers unworthy to have Sanctuary in Churches. But the Jesuits and Jansenists agree not who are the Murderers. The 29 Jesuits in their Praxis page 600. by murderers understand those who have taken money to kill one treacherously: and that those who kill without receiving any reward, but do it only to oblige their friends, are ⟨p. 60⟩not called murderers.] But the Jansenists think otherwise. (No marvel if you cannot understand the Scripture without a judge, when you can no better understand your judge, no not what he means by a murderer.)
Pope Gregory the fourteenth declareth Murderers unworthy to have Sanctuary in Churches. But the Jesuits and Jansenists agree not who are the Murtherers. The 29 Jesuites in their Praxis page 600. by murderers understand those who have taken money to kill one treacherously: and that those who kill without receiving any reward, but do it only to oblige their friends, are ⟨p. 60⟩not called murtherers.] But the Jansenists think otherwise. (No marvail if you cannot understand the Scripture without a judge, when you can no better understand your judge, no not what he means by a murtherer.)
Vasquez the Jesuit saith [that in this Question, rich men are obliged to give alms out of their superfluity; though the affirmative be true, yet it will seldom or never happen, that it is obligatory in point of practice] Pag. 105. But the Jansenists think otherwise.
Vasquez the Jesuite saith [that in this Question, rich men are obliged to give alms out of their superfluity; though the affirmative be true, yet it will seldom or never happen, that it is obligatory in point of practice] Pag. 105. But the Jansenists think otherwise.
Valentia the Jesuit, Tom. 3. p. 2042. holds, that [If a man give money not as the price of a Benefice, but as a Motive to resign it, it is not Simony, though he that resigns do look at the money as his Principal end] and so Tannerus, p. 115. But the Jansenists think otherwise.
Valentia the Jesuite, Tom. 3. p. 2042. holds, that [If a man give money not as the price of a Benefice, but as a Motive to resign it, it is not Simony, though he that resigns do look at the money as his Principal end] and so Tannerus, p. 115. But the Jansenists think otherwise.
Father Gaspar Hurtado saith [that an Incumbent may without mortal sin wish the death of him that hath a pension out of his living, and a son his fathers death; and may rejoice when it happens, so it proceed only from a consideration of the advantage accruing to him thereby, and not out of any personal hatred] pag. 136. But the Jansenists believe not this.
Father Gaspar Hurtado saith [that an Incumbent may without mortal sin wish the death of him that hath a pension out of his living, and a son his fathers death; and may rejoyce when it happens, so it proceed only from a consideration of the advantage accrewing to him thereby, and not out of any personal hatred] pag. 136. But the Jansenists believe not this.
Layman the Jesuit, and Pet. Hurtado: thinks that a man may lawfully fight a duel, accepting the challenge to defend his honour or estate, Pag. 138. But the Jansenist thinks otherwise.
Layman the Jesuit, and Pet. Hurtado: thinks that a man may lawfully fight a duell, accepting the challenge to defend his honour or estate, Pag. 138. But the Jansenist thinks otherwise.
Sanchez and Navarrus allow a man to murder his adversary secretly, or dispatch him at unawares to avoid the danger of a duel: p. 140. And Molina thinks you may kill one that wrongfully informs against us in any Court: and Reginaldus, that you may kill the false witnesses which the prosecutor brings; And Tannerus and Emanuel Sa, that you may kill both witnesses and judge which conspire the death of an innocent person] But so think not the Jansenists.
Sanchez and Navarrus allow a man to murder his adversary secretly, or dispatch him at unawares to avoid the danger of a duell: p. 140. And Molina thinks you may kill one that wrongfully informs against us in any Court: and Reginaldus, that you may kill the false witnesses which the prosecutor brings; And Tannerus and Emanuel Sa, that you may kill both witnesses and judge which conspire the death of an innocent person] But so think not the Jansenists.
Henriquez saith [one man may kill another who hath given him a box on the ear, though he run away for it, provided he do it not out of hatred or revenge, and that by that means a gap be open for excessive murder, destructive to the State. And the reason is, a man may as well do it in pursuance of his reputation, as his goods; and he that hath had a box on the ear is accounted dishonourable till he hath killed his enemy.] And Azorius saith, Is it lawful for a person of quality to kill one that would give him a box on the ear, or a bang with a stick? some say not—But others affirm it lawful, ⟨p. 61⟩and for my part I think it probable, when it cannot be avoided otherwise: For if it were not, the reputation of innocent persons were still exposed to the insolency of the malicious.] pag. 142, 143, 144. many other are of the same mind, in so much that Father Lessius saith [It is lawful, by the consent of all Casuists, to kill him that would give a box on the ear, or a blow with a stick, when a man cannot otherwise avoid it p. 145. Father Boldellus saith It is lawful to kill him that saith to you [thou lyest] if a man cannot right himself otherwise.] And Lessius saith [If you endeavour to ruin my reputation by opprobrious speeches before persons of honour, and that I cannot avoid them otherwise then by killing you, may I do it? According to modern Authors I may; nay though the crime you lay to my charge be such as I am really guilty of, it being supposed to have been so secretly committed, that you cannot discover it by ways of justice. Tis proved, if when you would take away my reputation by giving me a box on the ear, it is in my power to prevent it by force of arms, the same defence is certainly lawful, when you would do me the same injury with your tongue. Besides, a man may avoid the affront of those whose ill language he cannot hinder. In a word, honour is more precious then life, but a man may kill in defence of his life, ergo, he may kill in defence of his honour] pag. 146. But the Jansenists are against all this.
Henriquez saith [one man may kill another who hath given him a box on the ear, though he run away for it, provided he do it not out of hatred or revenge, and that by that means a gap be open for excessive murther, destructive to the State. And the reason is, a man may as well do it in pursuance of his reputation, as his goods; and he that hath had a box on the ear is accounted dishonourable till he hath killed his enemy.] And Azorius saith, Is it lawfull for a person of quality to kill one that would give him a box on the ear, or a bang with a stick? some say not—But others affirm it lawfull,
Escombar saith, that regularly it is lawful to kill a man for the value of a crown, according to Molina. p. 151. Father Amicus saith [It is lawful for a Church-man, or a Religious man to kill a detractor that threatens to divulge the scandalous crimes of his community or himself, when there is no other means left to hinder him from doing it, as if he be ready to scatter his calumnies, if not suddenly dispatched out of the way] p. 152, 153. And Caramovel in his Fundamental Theology takes it for certain, and thence concludes, that [a Priest not only may kill a detractor on certain occasions, but sometimes ought to do it] And yet the peevish Jansenist believeth none of this.
Escombar saith, that regularly it is lawfull to kill a man for the value of a crown, according to Molina. p. 151. Father Amicus saith [It is lawfull for a Church-man, or a Religious man to kill a detractor that threatens to divulge the scandalous crimes of his community or himself, when there is no other means left to hinder him from doing it, as if he be ready to scatter his calumnes, if not suddenly dispatched out of the way] p. 152, 153. And Caramovel in his Fundamental Theologie takes it for certain, and thence concludes, that [a Priest not only may kill a detractor on certain occasions, but sometimes ought to do it] And yet the peevish Jansenist believeth none of this.
But I must stop: you may read in the said Jansenians Mystery of Jesuitism, a volume of such passages of the Jesuits, allowing men to give and receive the Sacrament when they come that day from Adultery: and allowing a man to eat and drink as much as he can with his health: and discharging men from a Necessity of Loving God, unless it be once in their lives, or as ⟨p. 62⟩others say, upon Holy-days, or as Hurtado de Mendoza, once a year, or as Conink, once in three or four years, or as Henriquez, once in five years, or as Anthon. Sirmond, not at all, so we do not hate him, and do obey his other commands, with abundance more.
But I must stop: you may read in the said Jansenians Mysterie of Jesuitism, a volumn of such passages of the Jesuites, allowing men to give and receive the Sacrament when they come that day from Adultery: and allowing a man to eat and drink as much as he can with his health: and discharging men from a Necessity of Loving God, unless it be once in their lives, or as ⟨p. 62⟩others say, upon Holy-daies, or as Hurtado de Mendoza, once a year, or as Conink, once in three or four years, or as Henriquez, once in five years, or as Anthon. Sirmond, not at all, so we do not hate him, and do obey his other commands, with abundance more.
Now Reader I would here leave it to thy consideration, whether all these differences among the Papists are so small as to be no matters of faith. And I entreat you to read over the forementioned Book, (the Mystery of Jesuitism) and then judge whether Papists or the Reformed Catholics are more at unity among themselves.
Now Reader I would here leave it to thy consideration, whether all these differences among the Papists are so small as to be no matters of faith. And I intreat you to read over the forementioned Book, (the Mysterie of Jesuitism) and then judge whether Papists or the Reformed Catholicks are more at unity among themselves.
Well! but suppose the loving of God, the avoiding murder, bribery, and the like, be no matter of faith at Rome, yet I have not done with them so. I desire to know whether the holy Scripture be matter of faith or not? They dare not deny but it is. Well! and what is the Scripture, but the words ut signa, and the sense or matter ut res significata? And are the Papists agreed among themselves about either of these? no: For the words, its well known how some of the best Learned of them have stood for the preeminence of the Hebrew and Greek Texts: and others, and the most, for the vulgar Latin. And that vulgar Latin Translation hath been altered and altered again by them. And after many others comes Pope Sixtus the fifth, and makes it so complete, that the Church is required to use his Edition; yet after him comes Pope Clement the eighth and mends it in many hundred, if not thousand places, and imposes this upon the Church; which of these Popes was Infallible? I am sure they much differ in their Translations.
Well! but suppose the loving of God, the avoiding murder, bribery, and the like, be no matter of faith at Rome, yet I have not done with them so. I desire to know whether the holy Scripture be matter of faith or not? They dare not deny but it is. Well! and what is the Scripture, but the words ut signa, and the sense or matter ut res significata? And are the Papists agreed among themselves about either of these? no: For the words, its well known how some of the best Learned of them have stood for the preheminence of the Hebrew and Greek Texts: and others, and the most, for the vulgar Latine. And that vulgar Latine Translation hath been altered and altered again by them. And after many others comes Pope Sixtus the fift, and makes it so compleat, that the Church is required to use his Edition; yet after him comes Pope Clement the eighth and mends it in many hundred, if not thousand places, and imposes this upon the Church; which of these Popes was Infallible? I am sure they much differ in their Translations.
And for the sense of scripture, though men must swear to take Scripture in the Churches sense, yet will not any Pope or Council to this day, tell us the sense of them, either by giving us an infallible Commentary, or by deciding the many thousand differences that are among their Commentators. Do not all these Commentators forswear themselves, having sworn (those that lived since the Council of Trent) to expound Scripture in the sense of the Church, and only according to the unanimous consent of the Fathers. And why doth not the Pope decide these controversies? seeing it is their happiness to have such a Judge of Controversies to keep them all of a mind?
And for the sense of scripture, though men must swear to take Scripture in the Churches sense, yet will not any Pope or Council to this day, tell us the sense of them, either by giving us an infallible Commentary, or by deciding the many thousand differences that are among their Commentators. Do not all these Commentators forswear themselves, having sworn (those that lived since the Council of Trent) to expound Scripture in the sence of the Church, and only according to the unanimous consent of the Fathers. And why doth not the Pope decide these controversies? seing it is their happiness to have such a Judge of Controversies to keep them all of a mind?
But perhaps they will say, that all these Scriptures be not matters of faith. No! where are we then? what is matter of faith if Scripture be not? And if all be not, how shall we know which is? But at least, tell us, Is no one of all those many hundred or thousand Texts which your Commentators differ about any matter of Faith? If not, then sure you have no Faith. If it be, then surely the Papists differ among themselves in matters of Faith. It is not a few Texts that Lyra's excepter and Burgensis differ about, to name no more. And of the foresaid Editions of the Bible by Pope Sixtus, and Clement, see Dr. Jame's Bellum Papale, vel Concordia discors.
Detect. 7. BY what hath been said, you may discern how to deal with them, when they would industriously confound the Essentials and the Integral parts of our Faith: for this is another of their jugglings.
Detect. 7. BY what hath been said, you may discern how to deal with them, when they would industriously confound the Essentials and the Integral parts of our Faith: for this is another of their juglings.
They cannot endure to hear us distinguish the fundamentals (that is, the Essentials) of our Religion from the rest: and therefore they call out to us for a Catalogue of our fundamentals; and would persuade us that whatsoever is matter of faith, is of Necessity to salvation to be believed, and those are damnable Heretics that deny them, and therefore we must not make any such difference. See Knot against Chillingworth. Their design in this is to persuade people that the world must be wholly of their mind in matters of faith, or else they cannot be saved. And by this trick they would prove that the Protestants and many other Churches are all Heretics, and therefore have no place in General Councils, and are no parts of the Catholic Church. But let us consider how judiciously they proceed.
They cannot endure to hear us distinguish the fundamentals (that is, the Essentials) of our Religion from the rest: and therefore they call out to us for a Catalogue of our fundamentals; and would perswade us that whatsoever is matter of faith, is of Necessity to salvation to be believed, and those are damnable Hereticks that deny them, and therefore we must not make any such difference. See Knot against Chillingworth. Their design in this is to perswade people that the world must be wholly of their mind in matters of faith, or else they cannot be saved. And by this trick they would prove that the Protestants and many other Churches are all Hereticks, and therefore have no place in General Councils, and are no parts of the Catholick Church. But let us consider how judiciously they proceed.
1. We must desire the Papists to tell us whether Christianity be any thing or nothing? If any thing, it hath its Essence: and 2. Whether this Essence of Christianity be Knowable or not? If not, then they cannot know a Christian from another: and they cannot know the Church from other Societies. If it be knowable, then its Essence must needs be knowable. 3. And we would be informed by them, whether all true Christians in ⟨p. 64⟩the world are of the same stature or degree of knowledge and explicit belief? If they be, then there's no difference between Fathers and Babes, Strong and Weak, Priest and People; and then the Jesuits have no more Knowledge or Faith then the simplest woman of their Church: but if there be a difference, then 4. We would know whether the Essence of Christianity be varied according to these degrees. If so, then there are as many sorts of Christianity in the world, as there be degrees of Faith; which they have more wit, I suppose, then to affirm. If not, then the Essence of Christianity is distinguishable from the Integrity or superadded Degrees, which is the thing that we contend for. 5. We desire also to know whether the Apostles did not go on to teach their people more, after they had made them Christians, in a state of salvation. And whether the Priests, Fryers, and Jesuits will give men up, and teach them nothing more when they have made them Christians. I know they will say, There's more to be taught. And if so, then the Essentials of Christianity are distinguishable from the Integrals or Degrees. 6. And we would know else how they will understand that in Heb. 5. 10, 11, 12, 14. and 6. 1, 2. [For when for the time ye ought to be Teachers, ye have need that one teach you again which be the first principles of the Oracles of God, and are become such as have need of milk and not of strong meat. For every one that useth milk is unskilful in the word of righteousness, for he is a babe. But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age, who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern good and evil: therefore leaving the Principles of the doctrine of Christ, let us go on to perfection, not laying again the foundation, &c.] Tell us now whether the Apostle do not here distinguish between babes and strong men; milk and strong meat; the principles or foundation and perfection? 7.
And we would know of them whether all that is Revealed by God be of absolute Necessity to every mans salvation that do or may hear it? If so, then no man can be saved that knoweth not all that God hath revealed; and then no one in the world can be saved: for here we know but in part. And their own Commentators differ about the word of God, which showeth that they are imperfect in the Knowledge of its sense. And their Pope knows it not, or else he is shamefully to blame, that will not tell it the world, and reconcile his Commentators ⟨p. 65⟩and Disputers. But if all revealed be not of Absolute Necessity, then we may have leave to distinguish between points absolutely Necessary, and the rest. 8. And we would know whether all shall be damned, that know not as much as the most Learned and Wise? if not, then still we may have leave to distinguish. 9. Further we demand, whether any ignorance or error that is culpable, will stand with Charity and Salvation? If not, then who shall be saved? If yea; then we may still distinguish the points of Absolute Necessity from the rest. 10. We demand also, whether the whole holy Scripture be the word of God? If so, then whether we ought not to believe it all as far as we can understand it? And if so, whether it be not all, de fide matter of Faith? If not, they must tell us, what part of Gods word is to be believed, and what not. If yea; then certainly men may err de fide in points of Faith, and yet have Charity, and be saved: as their disagreeing Commentators, Casuists and Schoolmen do. 11. We would know whether the matters that their Divines are disagreed in, be Revealed by God, or things unrevealed? If not revealed, do they not deserve to be kicked out of the world, for troubling the world so with unrevealed things? If they be Revealed, are they not Revealed to be believed, and so are de fide? 12. And we would know whether there be not some things Essential to true Obedience, and some things not Essential? If not, then no sinner hath sincere Obedience, and can be saved: If yea; then why may not the same be said of faith? 13. Also we would know, when they baptize the Adult, whether they require any profession of the faith from them or not? If not, they may as well baptize Infidels or Heathens. If they do, then what is that profession? Is it a profession of every particular truth that God hath revealed to be believed? No sure:
And we would know of them whether all that is Revealed by God be of absolute Necessity to every mans salvation that do or may hear it? If so, then no man can be saved that knoweth not all that God hath revealed; and then no one in the world can be saved: for here we know but in part. And their own Commentators differ about the word of God, which sheweth that they are imperfect in the Knowledge of its sense. And their Pope knows it not, or else he is shamefully to blame, that will not tell it the world, and reconcile his Commentators
for then none but Doctors must be baptized. Nor they neither. Or is it a profession of some particular Truths only? If of some only, why of those more then the rest, if they be not the Essentials distinguishable from the rest? And do they make men true Christians by baptizing them, or not? If they do, then sure the Baptismal faith must contain all that is Essential to Christianity. 14. We desire also to be informed by them, what is the use of the Churches Creed, and why they have used frequently to make confession of their […] ⟨p. 66⟩[…] ⟨p. 67⟩⟨p. 66⟩faith? Was it not the whole faith Essential to Christianity which they confessed? If not, then it was not fit to be the badge of the Church; or of the Orthodox: if yea; then it seems those Creeds had in them the essentials distinguished from the rest. 15. we would know whether every thing delivered or defined by any General Council, be of such necessity to salvation, that all must explicitly believe them all that will be saved? If so, then whether any Papist can be saved, seeing they understand them not all? If not, then sure a distinction must be made. 16. And we would know how they can countenance ignorance so much as they do, if all things revealed be of equal necessity to salvation. 17. And what mean they to distinguish of Implicit and Explicit faith? Is it enough to believe as the Church believes, and not know what in any particular? then it is not de fide, or necessary to salvation to believe the resurrection of Christ, or of man, or the life to come. For a man may believe that the Church is in the right, and yet not know that it holdeth any of these. Is it enough to believe the formal object of faith (which with us is Gods veracity) without the material? Or is it enough to remain Infidels, and only believe that the Church are true Believers? If you hold to this, you make no act of faith, but one (the believing that the Church, that is, the Pope or Council are true believers) to be of Necessity to salvation. But if there be something that is Necessary to be actually (that is explicitly) believed, then must not that be distinguished from the rest and made known? 18. Whence is it that you denominate men fideles, believers with you? Is it from a Positive faith, or for not holding the contrary? If the latter, then Stones, and Beasts, and Pagans, and their Infants may be believers.
If the former, then that Positive faith from whence all believers are denominated must be known. 19. Is not that true faith and all that is essential to Christianity, which doth consist with saving grace or (to use your phrase) with true Charity? If not, then either Infidels and no Christians may have true Charity, or else true Charity may be in the unjustified; or both: If yea, (which doubtless you will yield) then sure men of lower knowledge and faith then Doctors, may have true Charity; and therefore true faith. 20. Lastly, I appeal to your own confessions. Bellarmine often distinguisheth between the points that all must ⟨p. 67⟩of Necessity explicitly believe, and the rest. And Suarez in three parts. Thom. Disp. 43. Sect. 4. faith of the Article of Christs descending into Hell [If by an Article of faith we understand a truth which all the faithful are bound explicitly to know and believe, so I do not think it necessary to reckon this among the Articles of faith, because it is not altogether necessary for all men] Here you see that Suarez distinguisheth between Articles of Necessity to all, and those that are not: and that he excepts even the Descent into Hell from this number of Articles Necessary to all I might cite many more of your writers; but the thing is well known.
If the former, then that Positive faith from whence all believers are denominated must be known. 19. Is not that true faith and all that is essential to Christianity, which doth consist with saving grace or (to use your phrase) with true Charity? If not, then either Infidels and no Christians may have true Charity, or else true Charity may be in the unjustified; or both: If yea, (which doubtless you will yield) then sure men of lower knowledge and faith then Doctors, may have true Charity; and therefore true faith. 20. Lastly, I appeal to your own confessions. Bellarmine often distinguisheth between the points that all must ⟨p. 67⟩of Necessity explicitely believe, and the rest. And Suarez in three parts. Thom. Disp. 43. Sect. 4. faith of the Article of Christs descending into Hell [If by an Article of faith we understand a truth which all the faithfull are bound explicitely to know and believe, so I do not think it necessary to reckon this among the Articles of faith, because it is not altogether necessary for all men] Here you see that Suarez distinguisheth between Articles of Necessity to all, and those that are not: and that he excepts even the Descent into Hell from this number of Articles Necessary to all I might cite many more of your writers; but the thing is well known.
But perhaps you'll say, that though all that is de fide, be not necessary to be believed explicitly by all, yet implicitly it must. I Ans. 1. that which you call Implicit believing is no believing that point, but another point: yea a point that doth not so much as infer that: for it followeth not [the Church is infallible, therefore Christ descended into Hell.]
But perhaps you'l say, that though all that is de fide, be not necessary to be believed explicitely by all, yet implicitely it must. I Ans. 1. that which you call Implicite believing is no believing that point, but another point: yea a point that doth not so much as infer that: for it followeth not [the Church is infallible, therefore Christ descended into Hell.]
2. And we believe all that is de fide with an Implicit faith as well as you: But it is an Implicit Divine faith, and not humane: For we are sure that All that God saith is true; and this Divine veracity is the formal object of our faith. And we believe that all that is in Scripture is true, and that all that was ever delivered by the inspiration of the Holy Ghost is true.
2. And we believe all that is de fide with an Implicite faith as well as you: But it is an Implicite Divine faith, and not humane: For we are sure that All that God saith is true; and this Divine veracity is the formal object of our faith. And we believe that all that is in Scripture is true, and that all that was ever delivered by the inspiration of the Holy Ghost is true.
Object. But all that is de fide is so necessary, that it will not stand with salvation to believe the contrary, or deny or dis-believe any point of faith. Answ. 1. That cannot be true, For no man can prove that a point may not be denied and disputed against by a true Believer as long as he is ignorant that it is true, and from God: the same ignorance that keeps him from knowing it, may cause him to deny it, and gainsay it. 2. Do not your own differing Commentators, Schoolmen and Casuists (on one side at least) dispute voluminously against some Truths of Divine revelation? If you change a mans mind from the smallest error by dispute, do you take that to be a change of his state from death to life? Aeneas Sylvius thought a General Council was above the Pope: but when he came to be Pope Pins the second, he thought the Pope above a General Council; was this a change from death to life? It seems by his Bull of Retractation, he ⟨p. 68⟩thought so, but so did not several General Councils: was the Catholic Church Representative at the Council of Basil, or Constance, or Pisa in a state of death and damnation for believing the Pope to be subject to a General Council? or was the Council at Lateran (another Representative Catholic Church) in a state of death for holding the Contrary? Must either Pope John the twenty second, or Pope Nicolas be damned because of the contrariety of their Decrees? If the Council of Toletane the first ordain that he that hath a Concubine instead of a wife, shall not be kept from the Sacrament, doth it prove them all in a state of death? If Bellarmine confess that the sixth General Council at Constantinople have many errors, doth it follow that the Catholic Church representative was in a damnable state? If the second Council at Nice maintain the corporeity of Angels, and the first Council at the Lateran maintain the contrary, doth it follow that one of them was in a state of death? I think not: (though I am sure it proves a General Council fallible, when approved by the Pope, and therefore Popery a deceit.) Bellarmine sometime tells us of the change of his own mind.
Object. But all that is de fide is so necessary, that it will not stand with salvation to believe the contrary, or deny or dis-believe any point of faith. Answ. 1. That cannot be true, For no man can prove that a point may not be denyed and disputed against by a true Believer as long as he is ignorant that it is true, and from God: the same ignorance that keeps him from knowing it, may cause him to deny it, and gainsay it. 2. Do not your own differing Commentators, Schoolmen and Casuists (on one side at least) dispute voluminously against some Truths of Divine revelation? If you change a mans mind from the smallest error by dispute, do you take that to be a change of his state from death to life? Aenaeas Sylvius thought a General Council was above the Pope: but when he came to be Pope Pins the second, he thought the Pope above a General Council; was this a change from death to life? It seems by his Bull of Retractation, he
And the Retractations of Austin (a better man) tell us of the change of his mind in many things: And yet it followeth not that he was in a state of death and unjustified before.
Object. But all that is de fide is of Necessity to the Salvation of some, though not of all. Answ. 1. If that be granted, yet you must grant us leave to distinguish between Points necessary to be believed by all, and points that are not thus necessary to all. 2. But in what case is it that you mean, that other points are of Necessity to some? 1. Is it to those some that know them to be of Divine Revelation? we easily grant you that: But that is not because the Things themselves are simply necessary to Salvation, but because a Belief of Gods veracity, and the Truth of all that he Revealeth in general, is of necessity: and he that Believeth that God is True (verax) cannot choose but believe all to be True which he knows God revealeth. He that thinketh God to be a Liar, in one word, doth not believe his veracity, and so hath no Divine faith at all. And therefore you need not fear lest any one should be guilty of not believing that which they ⟨p. 69⟩know is the word of God, but those that take God to be a Liar, and that is those that take him not to be God, and so are Atheists. But still the thing of Absolute necessity is but first to believe in General that God is true in all his word, secondly and to believe the truth of the essential points of Christianity in particular (embracing the Good propounded in them.) Now its true that secondarily all known Truths are of necessity to be believed, because else our General belief of Gods veracity is not sincere. But yet we must say that antecedently even to that person, these superadded truths were not of Necessity to his Salvation to be believed, because they were not of such Necessity to be Known; and if they had not been known, you would say your selves there had not been such Necessity of Believing them.
Object. But all that is de fide is of Necessity to the Salvation of some, though not of all. Answ. 1. If that be granted, yet you must grant us leave to distinguish between Points necessary to be believed by all, and points that are not thus necessary to all. 2. But in what case is it that you mean, that other points are of Necessity to some? 1. Is it to those some that know them to be of Divine Revelation? we easily grant you that: But that is not because the Things themselves are simply necessary to Salvation, but because a Belief of Gods veracity, and the Truth of all that he Revealeth in general, is of necessity: and he that Believeth that God is True (verax) cannot chuse but believe all to be True which he knows God revealeth. He that thinketh God to be a Lyar, in one word, doth not believe his veracity, and so hath no Divine faith at all. And therefore you need not fear lest any one should be guilty of not believing that which they
But if you go further, and say, that all that were obliged to know them, or that had opportunity, or the Revelation if the truth, and yet did not, and thereupon deny them culpably, are in a state of death; I deny that, and shall prove it false. Its true, that a wilful refusing the Light, because men love darkness rather then light, is a certain sign of a graceless wretch. But every culpable ignorance and unbelief is not Damning ignorance or unbelief.
But if you go further, and say, that all that were obliged to know them, or that had opportunity, or the Revelation if the truth, and yet did not, and thereupon deny them culpably, are in a state of death; I deny that, and shall prove it false. Its true, that a wilfull refusing the Light, because men love darkness rather then light, is a certain sign of a graceless wretch. But every culpable ignorance and unbelief is not Damning ignorance or unbelief.
1. Otherwise no man should be saved: For no man is void of culpable ignorance, and consequently of culpable unbelief. Had we never been wanting in the use of means, there's no man but might have known more then he doth. Is there any one of you that dare refuse to ask God forgiveness of your ignorance, unbelief, or the negligence that is the culpable cause of them, or that dare say, you need no pardon of them? 2. If you plead for venial sin, how can you deny a venial unbelief upon venial ignorance? But then I pray you learn more wit and piety, 1. then to say that your venial unbelief or sin is no sin, save as Analogically so called; or 2. then to say it deserves a pardon, or deserves not everlasting punishment. But if you will call it venial, because being consistent with the true Love of God and habitual Holiness, and saving faith, the Law of Grace doth pardon it, and not condemn men for it, thus we would agree with you that there is venial sin; but then you must yield us that there is venial unbelief.
1. Otherwise no man should be saved: For no man is void of culpable ignorance, and consequently of culpable unbelief. Had we never been wanting in the use of means, there's no man but might have known more then he doth. Is there any one of you that dare refuse to ask God forgiveness of your ignorance, unbelief, or the negligence that is the culpable cause of them, or that dare say, you need no pardon of them? 2. If you plead for venial sin, how can you deny a venial unbelief upon venial ignorance? But then I pray you learn more wit and piety, 1. then to say that your venial unbelief or sin is no sin, save as Analogically so called; or 2. then to say it deserves a pardon, or deserves not everlasting punishment. But if you will call it venial, because being consistent with the true Love of God and habitual Holiness, and saving faith, the Law of Grace doth pardon it, and not condemn men for it, thus we would agree with you that there is veniall sin; but then you must yield us that there is venial unbelief.
3. And we easily prove all this from the Law of God. It ⟨p. 70⟩is the nature of the preceptive part to constitute Duty only, and the violation of that is sin: But it is the sanction, the promise and threatening that Determines of the Reward and Penalty: Now it is only the old Law of works that makes the Threatening as large as the prohibition, condemning man for every sin: but so doth not the Law of Grace. The precept still commandeth Perfect obedience, and so makes it a duty; but the promise maketh not perfect obedience the condition of Salvation; but Faith, Repentance and sincere Obedience, though imperfect. The Law of Nature still makes everlasting Death due to every sin: But it is such a Due as hath a Remedy at hand provided and offered in the Gospel; and is actually remedied to all true believers. So that as it is not every sin that will damn us, though damnation be due to it (because we have a present Remedy;) so it is not every culpable ignorance or unbelief that will damn us, though it deserve damnation, because the Gospel doth not only not damn us for it, but pardons it, by acquitting us from the condemnation of the Law. All this may teach you, not only to mend your abominable doctrine about Mortal and venial sin, but also to discern the reason why a man may deny some points of faith that are not of the essence of Christianity, and yet not be damned for it, because the Law of Grace doth not condemn him for it, though he be culpable, because the Law of Grace may command further then it peremptorily condemneth in case of disobedience. It is the Promise that makes faith the Condition of Life, though it be the Precept that makes it a duty: Now it saveth not as a performed Duty directly, (because the precept gives not the Reward) but as a performed Condition: And therefore unbelief condemneth not effectually as a mere sin directly, but as such a sin as is the violation or non-performance of that condition. But it is not a belief of every thing that is preceptively de fide, which is made the condition of life.
3. And we easily prove all this from the Law of God. It ⟨p. 70⟩is the nature of the preceptive part to constitute Duty only, and the violation of that is sin: But it is the sanction, the promise and threatning that Determines of the Reward and Penalty: Now it is only the old Law of works that makes the Threatening as large as the prohibition, condemning man for every sin: but so doth not the Law of Grace. The precept still commandeth Perfect obedience, and so makes it a duty; but the promise maketh not perfect obedience the condition of Salvation; but Faith, Repentance and sincere Obedience, though imperfect. The Law of Nature still makes everlasting Death due to every sin: But it is such a Due as hath a Remedy at hand provided and offered in the Gospel; and is actually remedyed to all true believers. So that as it is not every sin that will damn us, though damnation be due to it (because we have a present Remedy;) so it is not every culpable ignorance or unbelief that will damn us, though it deserve damnation, because the Gospel doth not only not damn us for it, but pardons it, by acquitting us from the condemnation of the Law. All this may teach you, not only to mend your abominable doctrine about Mortal and veniall sin, but also to discern the reason why a man may deny some points of faith that are not of the essence of Christianity, and yet not be damned for it, because the Law of Grace doth not condemn him for it, though he be culpable, because the Law of Grace may command further then it peremptorily condemneth in case of disobedience. It is the Promise that makes faith the Condition of Life, though it be the Precept that makes it a duty: Now it saveth not as a performed Duty directly, (because the precept gives not the Reward) but as a performed Condition: And therefore unbelief condemneth not effectually as a meer sin directly, but as such a sin as is the violation or non-performance of that condition. But it is not a belief of every thing that is preceptively de fide, which is made the condition of life.
Detect. 8. Another of their Jugglings is, to extol the judgement of the Catholic Church as that which must be the ground of faith, and the decider of all Controversies: And to this end they plead against the sufficiency of Scripture, and bend all the force of their arguings and designs, as if all their hope lay in this point, and as if it were a granted thing that the day is theirs, and we are lost, if the Catholic Church be admitted to be the Judge. Hence it is that they cry out against private faith and opinions, and call men to the faith of the Church, and persuade the poor people, that the Church is for them, and we are but branches broken off.
Detect. 8. ANother of their Juglings is, to extoll the judgement of the Catholick Church as that which must be the ground of faith, and the decider of all Controversies: And to this end they plead against the sufficiency of Scripture, and bend all the force of their arguings and designs, as if all their hope lay in this point, and as if it were a granted thing that the day is theirs, and we are lost, if the Catholick Church be admitted to be the Judge. Hence it is that they cry out against private faith and opinions, and call men to the faith of the Church, and perswade the poor people, that the Church is for them, and we are but branches broken off.
Well, we are content to deal with them at their own weapon, and at that one in which they put their trust. For our parts we know that the true Catholic Church (nor any member of it, in sensu Composito) cannot err in any of the Essentials of Christianity (for then it would cease to be the Church:) But we have too much reason to Judge that it is not free from error in lesser things. But yet for all that in the main cause between the Papists and us, we refuse not their judgement. Nay we turn this Canon against the Canoneers, and easily prove that the Papists cause is utterly lost, if the Catholic Church be Judge.
Well, we are content to deal with them at their own weapon, and at that one in which they put their trust. For our parts we know that the true Catholick Church (nor any member of it, in sensu Composito) cannot err in any of the Essentials of Christianity (for then it would cease to be the Church:) But we have too much reason to Judge that it is not free from error in lesser things. But yet for all that in the main cause between the Papists and us, we refuse not their judgement. Nay we turn this Canon against the Canoneers, and easily prove that the Papists cause is utterly lost, if the Catholick Church be Judge.
But is it the Ancient Church, or the present Church that must decide the cause? Well! It shall be which you will. For the most Ancient Church in the Apostles days, we are altogether of its belief, and stand to its decision in all things; and if you prove we mistake them in any thing, we shall gladly receive instruction and be reclaimed. To them we appeal for our Essentials and Integrals. And for some following ages, we will be tried by them in the articles of our faith, and in the principal controversies we have with the Papists.
But is it the Ancient Church, or the present Church that must decide the cause? Well! It shall be which you will. For the most Ancient Church in the Apostles dayes, we are altogether of its belief, and stand to its decision in all things; and if you prove we mistake them in any thing, we shall gladly receive instruction and be reclaimed. To them we appeal for our Essentials and Integrals. And for some following ages, we will be tryed by them in the articles of our faith, and in the principal controversies we have with the Papists.
Yea, but this will not serve their turn: It is the present Church that must judge or none: For say they, if the ancient Church had power, so hath the present: and if the ancient Church had possession of the truth, how shall we know it but by the present? I answer, 1. We may know it by the Records of those times far ⟨p. 72⟩surer then by the reports of men without writing: Controversies or numerous mysterious points are sorrily carried in the memories, especially of the most, even of the Teachers. And for the Records, one diligent skilful man will know more then ten thousand others. One Baronius, Albaspinaeus, Petavius, among the Papists, and one Usher, Blondel, Salmasius, Gataker, &c. among the Protestants, knew more of the mind of antiquity, then a whole Country besides, or perhaps then some General Councils.
Yea, but this will not serve their turn: It is the present Church that must judge or none: For say they, if the ancient Church had power, so hath the present: and if the ancient Church had possession of the truth, how shall we know it but by the present? I answer, 1. We may know it by the Records of those times far ⟨p. 72⟩surer then by the reports of men without writing: Controversies or numerous mysterious points are sorrily carryed in the memories, especially of the most, even of the Teachers. And for the Records, one diligent skilfull man will know more then ten thousand others. One Baronius, Albaspinaeus, Petavius, among the Papists, and one Usher, Blondell, Salmasius, Gataker, &c. among the Protestants, knew more of the mind of antiquity, then a whole Country besides, or perhaps then some Generall Councils.
2. Well! but if you appeal to the greater number, to them shall you go. You must be tried by the present Church; Why then you are condemned. Is it the lesser number, or the greater, or the better that must be judge? You will not say the lesser, as such: If you do, you know where you are. If you say, the Better part shall be judge: who shall be Judge which is the Better part? we are ready to prove the Reformed Churches the Better part: and if we do not, we will give you the day, and lose our cause. But I suppose you will appeal to the Greater part. Content! Then the world knows you are lost. The Greeks, Muscovites, Armenians, Abassines, and all other Churches in Asia, Africa and Europe are far more then the Papists; and your own pens and mouths tell us that these are against you. Many of them curse you as Heretics or Schismatics; the rest of them know you not, or refuse your government. They all agree against your Popes universal Headship or Sovereignty, and so against the very form of your new Catholic Church: So that the world knows the Judgement of the far greatest part of Christians on earth to be against you in the main, so that you see what you get by appealing to the Catholic Church.
2. Well! but if you appeal to the greater number, to them shall you go. You must be tried by the present Church; Why then you are condemned. Is it the lesser number, or the greater, or the better that must be judge? You will not say the leser, as such: If you do, you know where you are. If you say, the Better part shall be judge: who shall be Judge which is the Better part? we are ready to prove the Reformed Churches the Better part: and if we do not, we will give you the day, and lose our cause. But I suppose you will appeal to the Greater part. Content! Then the world knows you are lost. The Greeks, Moscovites, Armenians, Abassines, and all other Churches in Asia, Africa and Europe are far more then the Papists; and your own pens and mouths tell us that these are against you. Many of them curse you as Hereticks or Schismaticks; the rest of them know you not, or refuse your government. They all agree against your Popes universall Headship or Soveraignty, and so against the very form of your new Catholick Church: So that the world knows the Judgement of the far greatest part of Christians on earth to be against you in the main, so that you see what you get by appealing to the Catholick Church.
But I know you will say, that all these are Schismatics, or Heretics, and none of the Catholic Church: But they say as much by you, some of them, and all of them abhor your charge; and how do you prove it? and who shall be Judge whether they, or you be the Catholic Church? You tell us of your succession, and of twenty tales that are good, if you may be Judges your selves; but so do they say as much which is good if they be Judges. When we offer to dispute our case with you, you ask us Who shall be Judge, and tell us the Catholic Church must be Judge: But who shall be Judge between you and them which is the Catholic ⟨p. 73⟩Church? you will not let us be Judges in our own cause, and why then should you? Are we Protestants the lesser number as to you? so are you to all the rest that are against you. And what reason have we to let the lesser number Judge over the Greater? If still you say, because you are the Better, let that be first tried; but no reason you should there also be the Judges.
But I know you will say, that all these are Schismaticks, or Hereticks, and none of the Catholick Church: But they say as much by you, some of them, and all of them abhor your charge; and how do you prove it? and who shall be Judge whether they, or you be the Catholick Church? You tell us of your succession, and of twenty tales that are good, if you may be Judges your selves; but so do they say as much which is good if they be Judges. When we offer to dispute our case with you, you ask us Who shall be Judge, and tell us the Catholick Church must be Judge: But who shall be Judge between you and them which is the Catholick ⟨p. 73⟩Church? you will not let us be Judges in our own cause, and why then should you? Are we Protestants the lesser number as to you? so are you to all the rest that are against you. And what reason have we to let the lesser number Judge over the Greater? If still you say, because you are the Better, let that be first tryed; but no reason you should there also be the Judges.
So that the case is plainly come to this, Either the Papists must stand to the Greater number, and then the controversy is at end: or they must shamefully say, we will not dispute with you, unless we may be the Judges our selves, though the fewer. Or else they must lay by their talk of a Judge, and dispute it equally with us, by producing their evidence, which we are ever ready for.
So that the case is plainly come to this, Either the Papists must stand to the Greater number, and then the controversie is at end: or they must shamefully say, we will not dispute with you, unless we may be the Judges our selves, though the fewer. Or else they must lay by their talk of a Judge, and dispute it equally with us, by producing their evidence, which we are ever ready for.
Detect. 9. THE most common and prevalent Deceit of the Papists is, by ambiguous terms to deceive those that cannot force them to distinguish, and to make you believe they mean one thing, when they mean another, and to mock you with cloudy words. I shall here warn you to look to them therefore especially in three terms, on which much of their controversies lies, that is, the words Church, Pope, and Council. For there's but few understand what they mean by any one of these words.
⟨p. 61⟩
and for my part I think it probable, when it cannot be avoided otherwise: For if it were not, the reputation of innocent persons were still exposed to the insolency of the malicious.] pag. 142, 143, 144. many other are of the same mind, in so much that Father Lessius saith [It is lawfull, by the consent of all Casuists, to kill him that would give a box on the ear, or a blow with a stick, when a man cannot otherwise avoid it p. 145. Father Boldellus saith It is lawfull to kill him that saith to you [thou lyest] if a man cannot right himself otherwise.] And Lessius saith [If you endeavour to ruine my reputation by opprobrious speeches before persons of honour, and that I cannot avoid them otherwise then by killing you, may I do it? According to modern Authors I may; nay though the crime you lay to my charge be such as I am really guilty of, it being supposed to have been so secretly committed, that you cannot discover it by ways of justice. Tis proved, if when you would take away my reputation by giving me a box on the ear, it is in my power to prevent it by force of arms, the same defence is certainly lawfull, when you would do me the same injury with your tongue. Besides, a man may avoid the affront of those whose ill language he cannot hinder. In a word, honour is more precious then life, but a man may kill in defence of his life, ergo, he may kill in defence of his honour] pag. 146. But the Jansenists are against all this.
1. We must desire the Papists to tell us whether Christianity be any thing or nothing? If any thing, it hath its Essence: and 2. Whether this Essence of Christianity be Knowable or not? If not, then they cannot know a Christian from another: and they cannot know the Church from other Societies. If it be knowable, then its Essence must needs be knowable. 3. And we would be informed by them, whether all true Christians in
⟨p. 64⟩
the world are of the same stature or degree of knowledge and explicite belief? If they be, then there's no difference between Fathers and Babes, Strong and Weak, Priest and People; and then the Jesuites have no more Knowledge or Faith then the simplest woman of their Church: but if there be a difference, then 4. We would know whether the Essence of Christianity be varyed according to these degrees. If so, then there are as many sorts of Christianity in the world, as there be degrees of Faith; which they have more wit, I suppose, then to affirm. If not, then the Essence of Christianity is distinguishable from the Integrity or superadded Degrees, which is the thing that we contend for. 5. We desire also to know whether the Apostles did not go on to teach their people more, after they had made them Christians, in a state of salvation. And whether the Priests, Fryers, and Jesuits will give men up, and teach them nothing more when they have made them Christians. I know they will say, There's more to be taught. And if so, then the Essentials of Christianity are distinguishable from the Integrals or Degrees. 6. And we would know else how they will understand that in Heb. 5. 10, 11, 12, 14. and 6. 1, 2. [For when for the time ye ought to be Teachers, ye have need that one teach you again which be the first principles of the Oracles of God, and are become such as have need of milk and not of strong meat. For every one that useth milk is unskilful in the word of righteousness, for he is a babe. But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age, who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern good and evil: therefore leaving the Principles of the doctrine of Christ, let us go on to perfection, not laying again the foundation, &c.] Tell us now whether the Apostle do not here distinguish between babes and strong men; milk and strong meat; the principles or foundation and perfection? 7.
⟨p. 65⟩
and Disputers. But if all revealed be not of Absolute Necessity, then we may have leave to distinguish between points absolutely Necessary, and the rest. 8. And we would know whether all shall be damned, that know not as much as the most Learned and Wise? if not, then still we may have leave to distinguish. 9. Further we demand, whether any ignorance or error that is culpable, will stand with Charity and Salvation? If not, then who shall be saved? If yea; then we may still distinguish the points of Absolute Necessity from the rest. 10. We demand also, whether the whole holy Scripture be the word of God? If so, then whether we ought not to believe it all as far as we can understand it? And if so, whether it be not all, de fide matter of Faith? If not, they must tell us, what part of Gods word is to be believed, and what not. If yea; then certainly men may err de fide in points of Faith, and yet have Charity, and be saved: as their disagreeing Commentators, Casuists and Schoolmen do. 11. We would know whether the matters that their Divines are disagreed in, be Revealed by God, or things unrevealed? If not revealed, do they not deserve to be kickt out of the world, for troubling the world so with unrevealed things? If they be Revealed, are they not Revealed to be believed, and so are de fide? 12. And we would know whether there be not some things Essential to true Obedience, and some things not Essential? If not, then no sinner hath sincere Obedience, and can be saved: If yea; then why may not the same be said of faith? 13. Also we would know, when they baptize the Adult, whether they require any profession of the faith from them or not? If not, they may as well baptize Infidels or Heathens. If they do, then what is that profession? Is it a profession of every particular truth that God hath revealed to be believed? No sure:
for then none but Doctors must be baptized. Nor they neither. Or is it a profession of some particular Truths only? If of some only, why of those more then the rest, if they be not the Essentials distinguishable from the rest? And do they make men true Christians by baptizing them, or not? If they do, then sure the Baptismal faith must contain all that is Essential to Christianity. 14. We desire also to be informed by them, what is the use of the Churches Creed, and why they have used frequently to make confession of their 〈…〉
⟨p. 66⟩
〈…〉
⟨p. 67⟩
⟨p. 66⟩
faith? Was it not the whole faith Essential to Christianity which they confest? If not, then it was not fit to be the badge of the Church; or of the Orthodox: if yea; then it seems those Creeds had in them the essentials distinguished from the rest. 15. we would know whether every thing delivered or defined by any General Council, be of such necessity to salvation, that all must explicitely believe them all that will be saved? If so, then whether any Papist can be saved, seeing they understand them not all? If not, then sure a distinction must be made. 16. And we would know how they can countenance ignorance so much as they do, if all things revealed be of equal necessity to salvation. 17. And what mean they to distinguish of Implicite and Explicite faith? Is it enough to believe as the Church believes, and not know what in any particular? then it is not de fide, or necessary to salvation to believe the resurrection of Christ, or of man, or the life to come. For a man may believe that the Church is in the right, and yet not know that it holdeth any of these. Is it enough to believe the formal object of faith (which with us is Gods veracity) without the material? Or is it enough to remain Infidels, and only believe that the Church are true Believers? If you hold to this, you make no act of faith, but one (the believing that the Church, that is, the Pope or Council are true believers) to be of Necessity to salvation. But if there be something that is Necessary to be actually (that is explicitely) believed, then must not that be distinguished from the rest and made known? 18. Whence is it that you denominate men fideles, believers with you? Is it from a Positive faith, or for not holding the contrary? If the latter, then Stones, and Beasts, and Pagans, and their Infants may be believers.
⟨p. 68⟩
thought so, but so did not several General Councils: was the Catholick Church Representative at the Councill of Basil, or Constance, or Pisa in a state of death and damnation for believing the Pope to be subject to a General Council? or was the Council at Laterane (another Representative Catholick Church) in a state of death for holding the Contrary? Must either Pope John the twenty second, or Pope Nicolas be damned because of the contrariety of their Decrees? If the Council of Toletane the first ordain that he that hath a Concubine instead of a wife, shall not be kept from the Sacrament, doth it prove them all in a state of death? If Bellarmine confess that the sixth General Council at Constantinople have many errors, doth it follow that the Catholick Church representative was in a damnable state? If the second Council at Nice maintain the corpercity of Angels, and the first Council at the Latarane maintain the contrary, doth it follow that one of them was in a state of death? I think not: (though I am sure it proves a General Council fallible, when approved by the Pope, and therefore Popery a deceit.) Bellarmine sometime tells us of the change of his own mind.
⟨p. 69⟩
know is the word of God, but those that take God to be a Lyar, and that is those that take him not to be God, and so are Atheists. But still the thing of Absolute necessity is but first to believe in General that God is true in all his word, secondly and to believe the truth of the essential points of Christianity in particular (embracing the Good propounded in them.) Now its true that secondarily all known Truths are of necessity to be believed, because else our General belief of Gods veracity is not sincere. But yet we must say that antecedently even to that person, these superadded truths were not of Necessity to his Salvation to be believed, because they were not of such Necessity to be Known; and if they had not been known, you would say your selves there had not been such Necessity of Believing them.