10. Is it not a plain Judgement of God upon you, that while you make the Scripture so dark and not intelligible, ⟨p. 49⟩and cry up the Necessity of a living Judge, you should not only swarm with differences among your selves, but should be utterly disagreed, and at a loss to know who is this Judge of Controversies, one saying it is the Pope, and another that its the Council; and what the better are you for saying, There must be a Judge, as long as you cannot tell Who it must be? Its not only uncertain among you Whether Pope or Council be the Infallible Judge, but also which is a true Pope, and which is a lawful General Council? For forty years at least together, the Church could not know the true Pope, but the more learned and conscionable men were divided: Nor is it known to this day. Frequently the strongest hath carried it, and success been his best title. Nay General Councils themselves knew not the right Pope. The Council at Constance and Basil knew not the right Pope. They of Basil thought Felix the fifth the true Pope, and Eugenius no Pope: But friends and strength confuted a General Council, and proved deposed Eugenius the Pope. And for Councils themselves, who knows which to take for currant and of Authority? What Catalogues have you of reprobated Councils, and of doubtful Councils, and partly approved, partly reprobate, and who knows which and how far; but only that is approved, that pleaseth the Pope, and that reprobate that displeased him, and yet perhaps approved by a former Pope: So that you are all in a confusion and uncertain about your true Popes and General Councils.
10. Is it not a plain Judgement of God upon you, that while you make the Scripture so dark and not intelligible, ⟨p. 49⟩and cry up the Necessity of a living Judge, you should not only swarm with differences among your selves, but should be utterly disagreed, and at a loss to know who is this Judge of Controversies, one saying it is the Pope, and another that its the Council; and what the better are you for saying, There must be a Judge, as long as you cannot tell Who it must be? Its not only uncertain among you Whether Pope or Councill be the Infallible Judge, but also which is a true Pope, and which is a lawfull General Council? For fourty years at least together, the Church could not know the true Pope, but the more learned and conscionable men were divided: Nor is it known to this day. Frequently the strongest hath carried it, and success been his best title. Nay General Councils themselves knew not the right Pope. The Council at Constance and Basil knew not the right Pope. They of Basil thought Felix the fifth the true Pope, and Eugenius no Pope: But friends and strength confuted a General Council, and proved deposed Eugenius the Pope. And for Councils themselves, who knows which to take for currant and of Authority? What Catalogues have you of reprobated Councils, and of doubtfull Councils, and partly approved, partly reprobate, and who knows which and how far; but only that is approved, that pleaseth the Pope, and that reprobate that displeased him, and yet perhaps approved by a former Pope: So that you are all in a confusion and uncertain about your true Popes and General Councils.