Answ. Denying the Minor, I answer to the proof: 1. To the Major: 1. Mr. T. elsewhere pleadeth that 1 Cor. 12. speaketh of the Church-invisible only, and yet now he maketh it to be the visible. 2 [All] is oft put for the Generality and not a proper universality: And it seemeth hard to prove that every visible member hath the spirit, which is expressly there said of all the members, though whether Baptism and the Lords Supper be included, Mr. T. elsewhere maketh disputable. But I grant that it is spoken of the Church as visible, and that all the members ordinarily having Spiritus Sacramentum, are in judgement of charity said to have the Spirit. 3. But if Sacraments be indeed here included as he asserteth, then Baptism is first included: and so if we prove Infants Church-members, this Text will prove them to be baptizable, according to Mr. T. Remember that. 4. But that Mr. T.'s exposition is not true, that every member drinketh of the Cup in the Lords Supper, he may be turned about to confess himself: For, 1. Doubtless he thinks that this Chapter speaketh of the Church not only as visible (if at all) but as invisible also; and he oft saith that many real members of Christs body ⟨p. 163⟩have not the Sacrament. 2. By this his exposition, his adult Baptizing should not make or prove any to be visible Church-members till they drink of the Cup; though it were a year or many years. 3. And no one that liveth without the Lords Supper through scruples (about Church-orders, or their own fitness, which are the cases of multitudes) should be visible members: Nor those that live where they cannot have the Sacrament: Nor any Lay-man in all the Popish Church, where the Cup is denied the Laity.
Answ. Denying the Minor, I answer to the proof: 1. To the Major: 1. Mr. T. elsewhere pleadeth that 1 Cor. 12. speaketh of the Church-invisible only, and yet now he maketh it to be the visible. 2 [All] is oft put for the Generality and not a proper universality: And it seemeth hard to prove that every visible member hath the spirit, which is expresly there said of all the members, though whether Baptism and the Lords Supper be included, Mr. T. elsewhere maketh disputable. But I grant that it is spoken of the Church as visible, and that all the members ordinarily having Spiritus Sacramentum, are in judgement of charity said to have the Spirit. 3. But if Sacraments be indeed here included as he asserteth, then Baptism is first included: and so if we prove Infants Church-members, this Text will prove them to be baptizable, according to Mr. T. Remember that. 4. But that Mr. T.'s exposition is not true, that every member drinketh of the Cup in the Lords Supper, he may be turned about to confess himself: For, 1. Doubtless he thinks that this Chapter speaketh of the Church not only as visible (if at all) but as invisible also; and he oft saith that many real members of Christs body ⟨p. 163⟩have not the Sacrament. 2. By this his exposition, his adult Baptizing should not make or prove any to be visible Church-members till they drink of the Cup; though it were a year or many years. 3. And no one that liveth without the Lords Supper through scruples (about Church-orders, or their own fitness, which are the cases of multitudes) should be visible members: Nor those that live where they cannot have the Sacrament: Nor any Lay-man in all the Popish Church, where the Cup is denied the Laity.