RICHARD BAXTERS second Account to Mr. John Cheney of his Judgment, accused by him of Atheism, subverting all Religion, Christianity, the Gospel, the Church, all Government, Introducing Popery, &c. Especially for asserting, 1. That Christ hath Instituted one Universal Church, of which he only is the Head; and particular Churches as parts of it, of which the Pastors are Subordinate Heads or Governors, and so formally differenced. 2. That neither of them is Constituted without some signification of consent: which he never before heard one Christian deny.RICHARD BAXTERS second Account to Mr. John Cheney of his Judgment, accused by him of Atheism, subverting all Religion, Christianity, the Gospel, the Church, all Government, Introducing Popery, &c. Especially for asserting, 1. That Christ hath Instituted one Universal Church, of which he onely is the Head; and particular Churches as parts of it, of which the Pastors are Subordinate Heads or Governours, and so formally differenced. 2. That neither of them is Constituted without some signification of consent: which he never before heard one Christian deny.
pp. 1–76169 passagespart 2 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. Chenies Accusations of me about Church-Covenants, and rigid Independency, and the odiousness hereof, considered.Mr. Chenies Accusations of me about Church-Covenants, and rigid Independencie, and the odiousness hereof, considered.
XXXII. Though the Peoples consent be necessary to their relation, their Election of the Pastor (which signifieth the first determination who shall be the man) is not absolutely necessary, though of old so thought. An after-Consent may serve ad esse relationis.
XXXIV. 1. Mutual consent of the duly qualified Ordained and Ordainer, determineth who shall be a Minister in the Church Universal; as consent of the College and the Candidate do who shall be the Licensed Physician. 2. The Peoples consent and the Ministers instituted, determine who shall be the Pastor of this particular Flock or Church. 3. The King determineth whom he will tolerate, countenance and maintain.
XXXIV. 1. Mutual consent of the duely qualified Ordained and Ordainer, determineth who shall be a Minister in the Church Universal; as consent of the Colledge and the Candidate do who shall be the Licensed Physician. 2. The Peoples consent and the Ministers instituted, determine who shall be the Pastor of this particular Flock or Church. 3. The King determineth whom he will tolerate, countenance and maintain.
XXXV. Though a man may be Ordained but once to the Ministry unfixed in the Universal Church, (to which I said the Peoples consent is not necessary) yet may he be oft removed from one particular Church to another, on just cause, to which the peoples consent (if not Election) is still necessary. Though to avoid Ambition, the old Canons forbade Bishops to remove.
XXXV. Though a man may be Ordained but once to the Ministry unfixed in the Universal Church, (to which I said the Peoples consent is not necessary) yet may he be oft removed from one particular Church to another, on just cause, to which the peoples consent (if not Election) is still necessary. Though to avoid Ambition, the old Canons forbad Bishops to remove.
XXXVI. It's lawful to be ordained sine titulo only to the Ministry in general; but in settled ⟨p. 11⟩Churches it is usually inconvenient: And he that is ordained to a fixed Church, doth at once become a Minister in the universal Church (and may act as a Minister, and not as a Layman, when called elsewhere) and also a fixed Minister of a particular Church; even as he that is baptized into a particular Church, is a member of both: Though Baptism and Ordination qua tales enter but into the Universal.
XXXVII. It is not this or that mode of signification of consent that is necessary to either relation of Pastor or Flock; but Consent signified intelligibly: where Laws and Custom order it that actual ordinary attendance in public worship and communion, and submission to necessary ministration, shall be the signification, all that so do express consent by it. And therefore our ordinary Parish-Assembling and Communion, being express consent to the mutual relation, have that which is necessary ad esse to true Churches; and they slander them that say, they are not such. But ad melius esse more may oft-times be profitable; 1. Because that is the best means, which is best fitted to the end: But the end of Signs being Notification, that is, caeteris paribus, the best which is most notifying; as that is the best Language which is most significant and intelligible. Why should playing in the dark, or dealing underboard, be preferred in the greatest things? 2. It oft falls out, that some that live in the Parish are known Church-Papists, Church-Atheists & Infidels, & will tell in their meetings to their companions, [I believe not the words of the Parish-Priest: It is his Trade to talk for gain: I will do what the Law ⟨p. 12⟩requires of me, for my safety; but I will have no more to do with him, nor do I take him for a true Pastor, that hath any Authority but by Law, nor for any Pastor to me.] And 3. there are many Heretics and Schismatics, engaged Members of other Churches; who yet to avoid suffering, will do that in the Parish-Church, which the Law requireth. 4. And the Ancient Churches used express Consent, yea and Election. So for the Minister; he is no Pastor without his signified consent: but actual Ministration may be such a signification. This is enough to reconcile the difference about Church-covenants.
XXXVII. It is not this or that mode of signification of consent that is necessary to either relation of Pastor or Flock; but Consent signified intelligibly: where Laws and Custome order it that actual ordinary attendance in publick worship and communion, and submission to necessary ministration, shall be the signification, all that so do express consent by it. And therefore our ordinary Parish-Assembling and Communion, being express consent to the mutual relation, have that which is necessary ad esse to true Churches; and they slander them that say, they are not such. But ad melius esse more may oft-times be profitable; 1. Because that is the best means, which is best fitted to the end: But the end of Signes being Notification, that is, caeteris paribus, the best which is most notifying; as that is the best Language which is most significant and intelligible. Why should playing in the dark, or dealing underboard, be preferred in the greatest things? 2. It oft falls out, that some that live in the Parish are known Church-Papists, Church-Atheists & Infidels, & will tell in their meetings to their companions, [I believe not the words of the Parish-Priest: It is his Trade to talk for gain: I will do what the Law
XXXVIII. They that rail against a more express consent in cases truly dubious, as if it were tyranny and destructive to Christianity, do suppose that if the King and Law commanded such a thing they commanded Tyrannically that which destroyeth Christianity; and contradict themselves when they say that Rulers may make various orders of Church-governors, and determine of undetermined Modes.
XXXVIII. They that rail against a more express consent in cases truly dubious, as if it were tyranny and destructive to Christianity, do suppose that if the King and Law commanded such a thing they commanded Tyrannically that which destroyeth Christianity; and contradict themselves when they say that Rulers may make various orders of Church-governours, and determine of undetermined Modes.
XXXIX. As it is not needful and usual to set up a Coordinate Imperium artificum vel Philosophorum in Imperio Civili; so it seemeth also of an Imperium Religiosum. The first Question is, whether Christ hath Instituted such: The second, whether he hath given power to Men to make it. There is not in any Kingdom that I hear of, (but somewhat towards it in China) such a Society of Physicians, Astronomers, Navigators, Lawyers, Schoolmasters, Philosophers, &c. who set up a Coordinate Empire or Government, that shall have all degrees of self-governing power as a National ⟨p. 13⟩Society, with one Supreme, either Monarchical, Aristocratical, or Democratical Head, according to the order of Civil-government: Nor doth any reproach Schools, Colleges, Hospitals, or any trading Societies, that they are confused, Independent, and ungoverned, because they have no common Governor but God and the King, nor any particular Governor, but the Principal, or Master and Fellows of the Society; nor any National association, besides their subjection to one King, and their voluntary correspondence for concord and mutual assistance with one another. And much less is there any Co-ordinate, Political Regiment of any of these through all the world, under one visible humane Head, personal or collective. And yet many think that there is such a Society and Regiment for Religion; National say some, Universal say others: That all that will serve God and be saved, must be under one Co-ordinate power over all the Kingdom, or World, besides Christ and the Supreme Magistrate: and they contend whether this power be Monarchical or Aristocratical, &c. I am so far Independent, as to think that Christ hath Instituted no such Universal or National Power and Head of Religion: but that 1. his own Universal Kingdom: 2. And particular Churches under their several Bishops and Teachers: 3. And Synods for concord and mutual help: 4. And Christian Magistrates to rule all by the Sword: 5. With the improvement of Mens eminent gifts and opportunities, that these be Instituted by Christ I doubt not: 6. And whether some should succeed the Apostles (excepting their extraordinary powers) in having a visiting, instructing, ⟨p. 14⟩ordering care of many Churches and their Bishops and Teachers, I confess my self uncertain;
XXXIX. As it is not needful and usual to set up a Coordinate Imperium artificum vel Philosophorum in Imperio Civili; so it seemeth also of an Imperium Religiosum. The first Question is, whether Christ hath Instituted such: The second, whether he hath given power to Men to make it. There is not in any Kingdom that I hear of, (but somewhat towards it in China) such a Society of Physicians, Astronomers, Navigators, Lawyers, Schoolmasters, Philosophers, &c. who set up a Coordinate Empire or Government, that shall have all degrees of self-governing power as a National
and therefore will never strive against such, nor deny due obedience to them, who show a true call to such an employment. Nay, if Christ have made no such Institution; yet 1. if the Christian Magistrate, 2. or the Churches by consent, choose some faithful Ministers to such a power, only to direct, instruct, guide, admonish, reprove, exhort the Bishops and Teachers of the particular Churches, without any other force than the Apostles used, and not destroying any of their proper power and duty, or that Church-order which the Apostles settled; I am no opposer of any such, though my uncertainty disables me from subscribing and swearing to the right of their Authority. The Scots themselves, even by Knox's consent, set up Super-intendents over many Churches (John Spotswood Super-intendent of Lothian, and so others.) And the power of a President, Principal or Rector of a College of Physicians, Philosophers, or Divines, doth not make him of any other Order or species of Office and Profession than the rest. But if any affirm more than this, I will learn, but cannot yet swear or subscribe it.
and therefore will never strive against such, nor deny due obedience to them, who shew a true call to such an employment. Nay, if Christ have made no such Institution; yet 1. if the Christian Magistrate, 2. or the Churches by consent, choose some faithful Ministers to such a power, onely to direct, instruct, guide, admonish, reprove, exhort the Bishops and Teachers of the particular Churches, without any other force than the Apostles used, and not destroying any of their proper power and duty, or that Church-order which the Apostles setled; I am no opposer of any such, though my uncertainty disables me from subscribing and swearing to the right of their Authority. The Scots themselves, even by Knox's consent, set up Super-intendents over many Churches (John Spotswood Super-intendent of Lothian, and so others.) And the power of a President, Principal or Rector of a Colledge of Physicians, Philosophers, or Divines, doth not make him of any other Order or species of Office and Profession than the rest. But if any affirm more than this, I will learn, but cannot yet swear or subscribe it.
XL. Those that are for the obligation of the Jewish order, I have fully spoke to in my first Plea for Peace. Those that are only for the power of man to make such several Orders or Ranks of Governors in the Church, as are in Armies, and Kingdoms, 1. Must tell us what sort of power may be given them: 2. And who must give it. And 1. No men can Institute a power of the same species, ⟨p. 15⟩or another species from that which we call the Sacred Ministry, or as the Fathers, the Sacerdotal, but what is subordinate about the Accidentals of Religion and the Church. 1. Not the same species, because it is Instituted by God already: No Man can create a creature already created. 2. Not of another supra-ordinate or co-ordinate: for 1. they can prove no power given them to do it: 2. And that were to accuse Christ of insufficient doing his undertaken work, and being less faithful in his house than Moses: 3. And it will infer Mans introduction of a new co-ordinate Doctrine, Worship, or Religious Ministration: for the Ministration of the word and Sacraments, and Keys, is already appointed by Christ: And the Office or Order is specified by the work and terminus; and a new Office hath new work. But in the same species of Religious Ministration, there are abundance of accidentals and circumstances; and Princes or consenting Churches may give men power in those accordingly. But not to forbid what Christ commanded, nor destroy the works and power of his Institution. And if they that are for other superior or co-ordinate species of Church-power, besides what is afore-granted, say that it is a lawful humane Ordinance: 1. Those that say, Princes only may make it, confess the Church had none that was lawful for three hundred years. And they must prove the Commission. 2. Those that say the Inferior Bishops made it by consent; 1. feign Inferiors to have power to make a power above their own, (which is more than for Presbyters to ordain their like.) 2. Why may not Archbishops then make Patriarchs, and ⟨p. 16⟩they a Pope, ad summum ascendendo? 3. They must prove their power; and that they are so far equal to Apostles, (who yet were but to teach the Nations what Christ commanded them; which these Men know not but by the Scripture.) 4. What Man maketh, Man may unmake. And how came we to be less free than our Ancestors that made such Offices?
XL. Those that are for the obligation of the Jewish order, I have fully spoke to in my first Plea for Peace. Those that are only for the power of man to make such several Orders or Ranks of Governours in the Church, as are in Armies, and Kingdoms, 1. Must tell us what sort of power may be given them: 2. And who must give it. And 1. No men can Institute a power of the same species,
XLI. In my Book of Concord where this is granted, yet I say, that let Church-Patriarchs, Metropolitans, Primates, Archbishops, or Diocesans, like ours that have no Bishops under them, be never so probably maintained to be lawful, yea, and desirable; yet the uniting in them by consent and approbation, will never become the terms or way of Universal Concord, which I have fully proved; even all that is true and good, will never be the terms of Universal Concord, nor just Christian Communion; much less that which hath so much matter of doubt, and great suspicion of evil. But I will live in Christian love, peace, and submission my self, on terms uncapable of common concord, or my own approbation of the things as imposed or done by all others.
XLI. In my Book of Concord where this is granted, yet I say, that let Church-Patriarchs, Metropolitans, Primates, Archbishops, or Diocesans, like ours that have no Bishops under them, be never so probably maintained to be lawful, yea, and desirable; yet the uniting in them by consent and approbation, will never become the terms or way of Universal Concord, which I have fully proved; even all that is true and good, will never be the terms of Universal Concord, nor just Christian Communion; much less that which hath so much matter of doubt, and great suspition of evil. But I will live in Christian love, peace, and submission my self, on terms uncapable of common concord, or my own approbation of the things as imposed or done by all others.
XLII. Lay-Chancellors may do what belongeth to a Magistrate, but not use the Church-Keys, nor be the Church-Judges of Mens Communion, because Christ hath Instituted the Sacred Office for it.
XLII. Lay-Chancellours may do what belongeth to a Magistrate, but not use the Church-Keyes, nor be the Church-Judges of Mens Communion, because Christ hath Instituted the Sacred Office for it.
XLIV. The parts of the Universal Church are similar and dissimilar, more simple or more ⟨p. 17⟩compound. And the word [whole] applied to a part, disproveth not its being a part of the whole Christian world or Church. A whole hand, foot, head, &c. is part of a whole Body; and a whole Body part of a whole Man, and a whole Man part of a whole Family, and a whole Family part of a whole street, and that of a whole City, and that of a whole County or Kingdom: A whole College of a whole University, &c. All Members save Souls and Atoms, are compounds.
XLIV. The parts of the Universal Church are similar and dissimilar, more simple or more ⟨p. 17⟩compound. And the word [whole] applyed to a part, disproveth not its being a part of the whole Christian world or Church. A whole hand, foot, head, &c. is part of a whole Body; and a whole Body part of a whole Man, and a whole Man part of a whole Family, and a whole Family part of a whole street, and that of a whole City, and that of a whole County or Kingdom: A whole Colledge of a whole University, &c. All Members save Souls and Atomes, are compounds.
XLV. When we call all the Christian world [The Catholic Church] and call e. g. Hippo [A or the Catholic Church] the word [Catholic] and [The] are not univocal: In the later we mean only [The Church at Hippo] which holds the true Catholic Faith, and is a true part of the Catholic Church in the first sense. Penuria nominum necessaria reddit aequivoca.
XLV. When we call all the Christian world [The Catholick Church] and call e. g. Hippo [A or the Catholick Church] the word [Catholick] and [The] are not univocal: In the later we mean only [The Church at Hippo] which holds the true Catholick Faith, and is a true part of the Catholick Church in the first sense. Penuria nominum necessaria reddit aequivoca.
XLVI. Particular Churches are Visible in the Regent and Governed parts: The Universal Church is Visible in the Governed part, and in the Head only, so far as he was once on Earth, and is now visible in Heaven (his Court) and will be visible at last to all, and ruleth by visible Laws; but not as a Head now visible on Earth: nor is this any deformity to his Church, nor any reason why it may not be called Visible; as I have fully proved in two Books against W. Johnson, alias Terret.
XLVII. Those that deny an Universal Visible Church, differ only de nowine, not de re: They only deny any Universal Regent power, Monarchical, or Aristocratical, or Democratical, under Christ; but I know no Christian that ever denied the fore-described.
XLVII. Those that deny an Universal Visible Church, differ only de nowine, not de re: They only deny any Universal Regent power, Monarchical, or Aristocratical, or Democratical, under Christ; but I know no Christian that ever denyed the fore-described.
XLVIII. Forma dat esse: Divers constitutive forms, or specifying differences, make divers Essences. Therefore the form of a Troop being the Captains Government, differs from the form of a Regiment, which is the Colonels Governing Relation, and both from the forms of the Army, which is the Generals. The formal Essence of a College, is divers from that of an University; and of a Family from a Corporation, or City; and that from a Kingdom. And as forma dat nomen, they have divers names: A Family quatalis, is not a Kingdom, &c. Reader, forgive the mention of these things, which Children know, and till now I never read or heard any man deny or question. In that which followeth, you shall see the Reasons that excuse me.
XLVIII. Forma dat esse: Divers constitutive forms, or specifying differences, make divers Essences. Therefore the form of a Troop being the Captains Government, differs from the form of a Regiment, which is the Colonels Governing Relation, and both from the forms of the Army, which is the Generals. The formal Essence of a Colledge, is divers from that of an University; and of a Family from a Corporation, or City; and that from a Kingdom. And as forma dat nomen, they have divers names: A Family quatalis, is not a Kingdom, &c. Reader, forgive the mention of these things, which Children know, and till now I never read or heard any man deny or question. In that which followeth, you shall see the Reasons that excuse me.
§ 1. Though it tempt me not to Conformity as the way of Concord, where I see the great difference of such as plead for it amongst themselves, yet I must do that right to the Conformists, as to tell the world that they must not be judged of by Mr. Ch's opinions; and that I know no other Conformist (or Non-conformist) of his mind about Church-Forms.
§ 1. THough it tempt me not to Conformity as the way of Concord, where I see the great difference of such as plead for it amongst themselves, yet I must do that right to the Conformists, as to tell the world that they must not be judged of by Mr. Ch's opinions; and that I know no other Conformist (or Non-conformist) of his mind about Church-Forms.
§ 2. But I must add, that his Case doth increase ⟨p. 19⟩my Conviction against himself and them, that their Conformity is so far from being the necessary Cement, that it is utterly destructive of it, as so imposed: and that it must be on few plain necessary things, that common concord must be held, or we must have none. Mr. Ch. thinks me one who may be endured in the Ministry, and I think so by him; and yet how far easier and plainer than our Controversies of Conformity, are those things in which we differ to the height of his following Accusations? If none should be endured that cannot Covenant, Swear, Subscribe, Declare and Practice, as is required, how much less can such as he and I be endured in one Church, if we differ as he saith we do? O what pardon and forbearance doth our peace require!
Pag. 3. [The several Congregations and Assemblies of Pastors and People throughout the Kingdom, are not limbs and parcels of a Church, but they are so many Churches—consisting of a Pastor Governing, and people governed, joining together in public worship—It is called [the Church of England] as all the Christian Pastors and people throughout the world, are called the Universal Church—One Church, of which Christ is the transcendent Head—I do not see but it is proper to call all the Christian Pastors and people of England—One Church.—P. 6. Christ is the Head of the Church of England,—and under Christ all the Parish-Ministers are subordinate Guides and Rulers of their Flocks respectively.—P. 7. Some are as Colonels of Regiments, others as Captains of Troops; the Body ⟨p. 20⟩is but One, the Members many.—P. 13. The New Testament saith,—The Churches of Galatia, Gal. 1. 2. the Churches of Judea, Asia,—Yet One body.—All the faithful make One heavenly City,—one Church of the first born;—so that Gods Church on Earth is Many Churches, and yet but One Church.—(Do you not think now that we are agreed? But hear him judge himself.) P. 15. I will show one common Error or mistake in multitudes of our able Divines,—That those we call particular Churches, are counted Parts and Members of the Church Universal. This I deny,—Mr. Baxter makes the Church of England, or the Churches of England, to be an integral part of the Church Universal,—as a Troop of an Army, or a City of a Kingdom. So the Independents. I overthrow this Error by this Argument. One and the same thing cannot be both a Body and a Member, a whole and a part, a society and one single person.—But that which we call a single or particular Church, is not a Member but a Body; it is not a limb or part of a Church, but a whole and entire Church,—It hath a whole within it.—London is not a Member of England, but a City and aggregation of Members. It's no less than a flat contradiction in terms,—what Dr. Ames saith, Medul. l. 1. c. 32. that a particular Church est Membrum ex aggregatione variorum Membrorum singulorum compositum, contrary to common reason and plain Scripture.—P. 18. A bare Member in the Body hath no Authority, but acteth by mere natural life and appetite, and is not endued with rational authority, nor can be capable of any.—That which we call a single Church, is a Catholic or Universal Church.
Pag. 3. [The several Congregations and Assemblies of Pastors and People throughout the Kingdom, are not limbs and parcels of a Church, but they are so many Churches—consisting of a Pastor Governing, and people governed, joyning together in publick worship—It is called [the Church of England] as all the Christian Pastors and people throughout the world, are called the Universal Church—One Church, of which Christ is the transcendent Head—I do not see but it is proper to call all the Christian Pastors and people of England—One Church.—P. 6. Christ is the Head of the Church of England,—and under Christ all the Parish-Ministers are subordinate Guides and Rulers of their Flocks respectively.—P. 7. Some are as Colonels of Regiments, others as Captains of Troops; the Body
It hath an Universal Head. To be a Christian, is to be ⟨p. 21⟩of an universal impartial spirit;—where there is an All, there is an Universal.—But every single Church hath an All within it, the Pastor and all his flock.—The Church Universal and particular, do only differ as to place and number;—A Church of godly Ministers and people in France, Holland,—and England, differ but as to place.—Every Church (of Christians) must needs be a Church Universal; not a limb or member of another Church, but a true body, or entire Christian society.—P. 20. Christs Body is One: not as one is opposed to Multitude—but to division, contrariety, and destruction.
§ 4. P. 21. This leads me to show the unsoundness of another part of Mr. Baxters Doctrine, and some others with him: He saith, [There are two essentially different Policies or Forms of Church-Government of Christs Institution, never to be altered by man: 1. The Form of the Universal Church as Headed by Christ himself, which all Christians own as they are Christians, in their Baptism. 2. Particular Churches headed by their particular Bishops or Pastors, and are parts of the Universal, as a Troop of an Army, or a City of a Kingdom.—And he defines the Universal Church to be, The universality of Baptized Christians, headed by Christ himself. These his sayings contain many Errors; I will first note them out, and then confute and prove them to be Errors. 1. It is an Error in the art of defining, to put in those words, [Headed by Christ himself.] 2. It is another Error to define the Universal Church without Guides and Ministers, as one essential constituent part. 3. It is another Error to say, that the Universal Church, and Churches particular, differ essentially. 1. It is an Error in the art of defining to ⟨p. 22⟩say,—Headed by Christ himself] that's supposed, but need not be in the definition. He finds fault himself with such a defect in the definition of a particular Church. Grant them to be Christians, and you grant they own Christ.—2. It is an Error to define the Universal Church without Pastors,—So doth the Assemblies Confession, and Mr. Hudson—His definition of the Church without Pastors, is, as if he defined a living healthful man, without a stomach, liver or lungs.—P. 24. 3. If there be an essential difference between Church and Church, what then is the difference between the Church and the World! Heaven and Hell! the righteous and the wicked!—How can any man know which is the right Church? We shall never be able to confute Popery nor Infidelity by this Doctrine: For this Doctrine supposeth two essentially different Churches: The Universal Church without Pastors, and of this Christ is Head himself: Particular Churches, of which Christ is no Head, but particular Pastors are the Heads.—By this Doctrine the same thing shall be contrary to it self.—Christs Church in this world is but one! And can one and the same thing have two different Essences, beings, and definitions? Quae conveniunt uno tertio, &c.
§ 4. P. 21. This leads me to shew the unsoundness of another part of Mr. Baxters Doctrine, and some others with him: He saith, [There are two essentially different Policies or Forms of Church-Government of Christs Institution, never to be altered by man: 1. The Form of the Universal Church as Headed by Christ himself, which all Christians own as they are Christians, in their Baptism. 2. Particular Churches headed by their particular Bishops or Pastors, and are parts of the Universal, as a Troop of an Army, or a City of a Kingdom.—And he defines the Universal Church to be, The universality of Baptized Christians, headed by Christ himself. These his sayings contain many Errours; I will first note them out, and then confute and prove them to be Errours. 1. It is an Errour in the art of defining, to put in those words, [Headed by Christ himself.] 2. It is another Errour to define the Universal Church without Guides and Ministers, as one essential constituent part. 3. It is another Errour to say, that the Universal Church, and Churches particular, differ essentially. 1. It is an Errour in the art of desining to
But the Church Universal and particular agree in uno tertio. They stand on one foundation, are directed by one rule, quickened by one spirit; an addition of homogeneous Particles makes no essential difference. It will necessarily infer, that God is contrary to himself, and that the essentiating principles of Church holiness, order and government, are black and white, darkness and light,—P. 25. If this opinion stand, Religion cannot stand, Two essentially different Forms of ⟨p. 23⟩Churches, will infer two sorts of Holiness, the one repugnant to the other, (yet) subordinata non pugnant. If Christ set up two repugnant, or essentially different Church-Forms, he is not the Saviour, but the deceiver of the world. (O dreadful!)
But the Church Universal and particular agree in uno tertio. They stand on one foundation, are directed by one rule, quickned by one spirit; an addition of homogeneous Particles makes no essential difference. It will necessarily infer, that God is contrary to himself, and that the essentiating principles of Church holiness, order and government, are black and white, darkness and light,—P. 25. If this opinion stand, Religion cannot stand, Two essentially different Forms of ⟨p. 23⟩Churches, will infer two sorts of Holiness, the one repugnant to the other, (yet) subordinata non pugnant. If Christ set up two repugnant, or essentially different Church-Forms, he is not the Saviour, but the deceiver of the world. (O dreadful!)
§ 5. P. 92. A word more ad hominem of that opinion, That particular Churches are parts of the Universal, as a Troop is of an Army, or a City of a Kingdom.
This is Mr. Baxters opinion: why then do you blame the turning all the Parish-Churches into Chapels, and making them to be but parts of the Diocesan, as a Troop is of an Army, &c. who sees not that your Doctrine doth the same that you condemn, &c. If they are but parts and Members of another Church, (the Universal) then they are not Churches.—It is not unlikely but you can find somewhat to say in defence of this your self-contradicting Doctrine; but I believe it will match your wit, were it ten times more, and prove too hard for you. Look to it; if your disputations against Prelacy stand, down goes this main assertion of yours. If your disputations against Prelacy be found to have a hollow and false bottom, then you have made you work for repentance, you have greatly injured the Church of God, and particularly the Church of England, and have deceived a great many. Look what Bellarmine maketh the Pope to be to all the Pastors, Churches, and Christians through the world, That do you make this which you call the Church Universal: for you say that particular Churches, as headed by their respective Bishops and Pastors, are parts and members of another Church called the Church Universal: By which assertion you set up an Universal ⟨p. 24⟩Head or Government over all the Pastors, Churches, and Christians in the world besides Christ; and you say this is of Divine Institution; and you lay the concord of all the Churches upon it. Do but grant the Papists this one assertion, that particular Churches, as headed by their respective Pastors, are parts and members of the Universal Church, as a City is of a Kingdom, and overthrow the Popes headship over all if you can. It will follow that there must be, besides Christ, an Universal Ecclesiastical Monarch on Earth, either personal or collective, who must have the Supreme power. P. 96. But indeed you have gone beyond Bellarmine in setting up Papal Monarchy. Your other assertion sets up Atheism, by making the Holy God the Author and Founder of two essentially different Churches, or Church-Forms. According to Bellarmines assertion for the Pope, there would be Pastors, &c. But according to your assertion, all the world must be Atheists, of no Religion at all.—P. 224, 225. Your division of the Church into Universal and particular, is plainly against that Rule in Logic; Membra omnis bonae divisionis debent esse inter se opposita.
This is Mr. Baxters opinion: why then do you blame the turning all the Parish-Churches into Chappels, and making them to be but parts of the Diocesan, as a Troop is of an Army, &c. who sees not that your Doctrine doth the same that you condemn, &c. If they are but parts and Members of another Church, (the Universal) then they are not Churches.—It is not unlikely but you can find somewhat to say in defence of this your self-contradicting Doctrine; but I believe it will match your wit, were it ten times more, and prove too hard for you. Look to it; if your disputations against Prelacie stand, down goes this main assertion of yours. If your disputations against Prelacie be found to have a hollow and false bottom, then you have made you work for repentance, you have greatly injured the Church of God, and particularly the Church of England, and have deceived a great many. Look what Bellarmine maketh the Pope to be to all the Pastors, Churches, and Christians through the world, That do you make this which you call the Church Universal: for you say that particular Churches, as headed by their respective Bishops and Pastors, are parts and members of another Church called the Church Universal: By which assertion you set up an Universal
But in this your division the Membra dividentia are not inter se opposita: you oppose the same thing against itself. You make the Church at Corinth a particular Church,—The whole or the Universal Church at Corinth is sound and good. You plainly leave out of your description, the differencing Form or token of that which you call a particular Church, and that is Neighbourhood, or dwelling or abiding in this or that place,—you make a new essential of Church-Membership and Church-Communion, and lay the peace of all the Churches on it, and say it is Divine, ⟨p. 25⟩sure, harmless, fitted to the interest of all good men. This startles me, I strive to be silent and cannot: The more I strive, the more I am overcome*. Mr. Cawdrey was lately with me, and we had Conference about this point,—suspecting mine own judgment; I have conferred with divers about your other Notions, two Churches, or two Church-Forms differing essentially; and they cannot apprehend how it can stand! you make the Universal Church-Form, and the particular Church-Form to differ essentially, and this by Divine Law. I prove to you from the nature of the thing it self, and the express word of God, that the Universal Church of God at Corinth, and the particular Church of God at Corinth, are one and the same.—To oppose the Universal and particular Church, and say they differ essentially, is to oppose the same thing against itself, and make the Lord Jesus Christ the Author and Founder of self-subverting Principles. P. 226, 227. As for that other point, of the Church particular being part of the Church Universal, it is to say, that the whole Church at Corinth is a part of the whole Church, which is absurd.
But in this your division the Membra dividentia are not inter se opposita: you oppose the same thing against itself. You make the Church at Corinth a particular Church,—The whole or the Universal Church at Corinth is sound and good. You plainly leave out of your description, the differencing Form or token of that which you call a particular Church, and that is Neighbourhood, or dwelling or abiding in this or that place,—you make a new essential of Church-Membership and Church-Communion, and lay the peace of all the Churches on it, and say it is Divine, ⟨p. 25⟩sure, harmless, fitted to the interest of all good men. This startles me, I strive to be silent and cannot: The more I strive, the more I am overcome
Reader, I must not Transcribe the whole Book: the rest is too like this; exercise your patience in receiving a short Answer to the several parts which seemeth needful.
§ 1. What Christians heart can choose but mourn for the Church of God, and the puzzling confounding temptations of the ignorant, that must hear men charged thus publicly with Atheism, and the overthrow of all Religion, for that which the Christian world agreeth in; and this by Preachers of professed humility, sincerity and zeal? How shall the unlearned know when they are safe? yea, what snares are thus laid to rob men of their time, as well as their Faith and Charity? I must not give such lines their proper names: but I will say that it remembereth me of Isa. 1. 6. and it crieth out unclean, unclean. How few words of Truth, and soberness, and soundness, can you number among all these? Had he written and published it in his sleep, as some talk, and walk, it were some excuse! But for a Man, a Minister, awake, and after public admonition, deliberately, on consultation, a second time, to talk at this rate in the Press!—And yet cannot we be endured without their Ceremonies, &c. When the Friendly Debater and Mr. Shurlocke have compared such Books as this with those that they reprehended, perhaps they will say, Iliacos intramuros, &c.
§ 1. WHat Christians heart can choose but mourn for the Church of God, and the puzzling confounding temptations of the ignorant, that must hear men charged thus publickly with Atheism, and the overthrow of all Religion, for that which the Christian world agreeth in; and this by Preachers of professed humility, sincerity and zeal? How shall the unlearned know when they are safe? yea, what snares are thus laid to rob men of their time, as well as their Faith and Charity? I must not give such lines their proper names: but I will say that it remembreth me of Isa. 1. 6. and it cryeth out unclean, unclean. How few words of Truth, and soberness, and soundness, can you number among all these? Had he written and published it in his sleep, as some talk, and walk, it were some excuse! But for a Man, a Minister, awake, and after publick admonition, deliberately, on consultation, a second time, to talk at this rate in the Press!—And yet cannot we be endured without their Ceremonies, &c. When the Friendly Debater and Mr. Shurlocke have compared such Books as this with those that they reprehended, perhaps they will say, Iliacos intramuros, &c.
To begin at the end, I am sorry to read what ⟨p. 27⟩he saith of the Divers he Conferred with, &c. 1. I never till now read or heard Papist, Protestant, or any Christian of his mind: And, alas, are divers of it now? Are Conformists come to that? Either they were at Manhood, or in breeches at least, or not: If not, he should have chosen other Counsellors: If yea, were they Laymen or Clergymen? He was to blame if he took up with the former alone in such a case. If the later, he greatly disgraceth them.
To begin at the end, I am sorry to read what ⟨p. 27⟩he saith of the Divers he Conferred with, &c. 1. I never till now read or heard Papist, Protestant, or any Christian of his mind: And, alas, are divers of it now? Are Conformists come to that? Either they were at Manhood, or in breeches at least, or not: If not, he should have chosen other Counsellers: If yea, were they Laymen or Clergymen? He was to blame if he took up with the former alone in such a case. If the later, he greatly disgraceth them.
But we must say somewhat of our Atheistical Errors. The beginning of his words, which say the same thing which he so abominateth, I will not charge with contradiction in sense from the rest: for if he mean the same thing by [One and Two, A Church and no Church, A part and no part, Yea and Nay] they are no contradictions in sense. And indeed I cannot perceive that he understandeth what he readeth and answereth, nor well what he saith. And therefore I am not sure when I understand him; but I will review some of the things that his words seem to accuse in order.
But we must say somewhat of our Atheistical Errours. The beginning of his words, which say the same thing which he so abominateth, I will not charge with contradiction in sence from the rest: for if he mean the same thing by [One and Two, A Church and no Church, A part and no part, Yea and Nay] they are no contradictions in sence. And indeed I cannot perceive that he understandeth what he readeth and answereth, nor well what he saith. And therefore I am not sure when I understand him; but I will review some of the things that his words seem to accuse in order.
§ I. The Universal Church, as I defined it, is a True Church. Proved: Where there is a true Church-Head and a Body of all Christians on earth, united and subjected to that Head by mutual consent and Covenant, there is a true Universal Church: but such is that which I named and defined as the Church Universal.—Ergo.—The Major is from the definition to the thing denominated. As to the Minor, 1. That Christ is the True Head. 2. And all Christians the Universal true body, (visible as Baptized, and mystical ⟨p. 28⟩as Heart-Covenanters.) 3. And that mutual Covenanting is a sufficient bond for this Church union, the Christian Reader will chide me if I stay to prove.
§ I. The Universal Church, as I defined it, is a True Church. Proved: Where there is a true Church-Head and a Body of all Christians on earth, united and subjected to that Head by mutual consent and Covenant, there is a true Universal Church: but such is that which I named and defined as the Church Universal.—Ergo.—The Major is from the definition to the thing denominated. As to the Minor, 1. That Christ is the True Head. 2. And all Christians the Universal true body, (visible as Baptized, and mystical ⟨p. 28⟩as Heart-Covenanters.) 3. And that mutual Covenanting is a sufficient bond for this Churchunion, the Christian Reader will chide me if I stay to prove.
§ 11. Particular Churches existent, are true Churches in Essence. Proved to him: 1. He oft confesseth this and the former. 2. A true pars dirigens & pars subdita, necessarily qualified, ad esse, and united in those relations for Church-ends, are a true particular Church: But such are many existent particular Churches (and all that I defined:) Ergo. 1. That a true Bishop, at least with his Presbyters, is a true pars dirigens: 2. And a qualified flock, a true pars subdita: 3. And that such are found united in these relations, I will take for granted with the Reader, except Mr. Ch. And the Major is the definition.
§ III. That the Relative union of the governing Part, or nearest Head to the Governed body, is the specifying form. The proof being de Ente politico & notion Logicâ, is the consent of all Politics, Logics, and use of speech by the professors of both, known to us in the world. I oft enough distinguishing de nomine aequivoco, have told men that it is not every Christian Assembly that we speak of, but societas politica. And all Politics call the form of the Government, the specifying form of the Politic Society, throughout the known world. So Monarchy, Aristocracy, Democracy, are specifying forms of Republics: And Schools, Armies, Navies, have divers Relative forms, specified by the union of the various Regent Relative parts to the rest.
§ III. That the Relative union of the governing Part, or nearest Head to the Governed body, is the specifying form. The proof being de Ente politico & notione Logicâ, is the consent of all Politicks, Logicks, and use of speech by the professours of both, known to us in the world. I oft enough distinguishing de nomine aequivoco, have told men that it is not every Christian Assembly that we speak of, but societas politica. And all Politicks call the form of the Government, the specifying form of the Politick Society, throughout the known world. So Monarchy, Aristocracie, Democracie, are specifying forms of Republicks: And Schools, Armies, Navies, have divers Relative forms, specifyed by the union of the various Regent Relative parts to the rest.
§ VI. It is not the generical form that specifieth. Else all things that are ejusdem generis, should be ejusdem speciei. All bodies are not Animate, nor all Animals Men, nor all Men Bishops or Physicians.
⟨p. 12⟩
requires of me, for my safety; but I will have no more to do with him, nor do I take him for a true Pastor, that hath any Authority but by Law, nor for any Pastor to me.] And 3. there are many Hereticks and Schismaticks, engaged Members of other Churches; who yet to avoid suffering, will do that in the Parish-Church, which the Law requireth. 4. And the Antient Churches used express Consent, yea and Election. So for the Minister; he is no Pastor without his signified consent: but actual Ministration may be such a signification. This is enough to reconcile the difference about Church-covenants.
⟨p. 13⟩
Socity, with one Supreme, either Monarchical, Aristocratical, or Democratical Head, according to the order of Civil-government: Nor doth any reproach Schools, Colledges, Hospitals, or any trading Societies, that they are confused, Independent, and ungoverned, because they have no common Governour but God and the King, nor any particular Governour, but the Principal, or Master and Fellows of the Society; nor any National association, besides their subjection to one King, and their voluntary correspondence for concord and mutual assistance with one another. And much less is there any Co-ordinate, Political Regiment of any of these through all the world, under one visible humane Head, personal or collective. And yet many think that there is such a Society and Regiment for Religion; National say some, Universal say others: That all that will serve God and be saved, must be under one Co-ordinate power over all the Kingdom, or World, besides Christ and the Supreme Magistrate: and they contend whether this power be Monarchical or Aristocratical, &c. I am so far Independent, as to think that Christ hath Instituted no such Universal or National Power and Head of Religion: but that 1. his own Universal Kingdom: 2. And particular Churches under their several Bishops and Teachers: 3. And Synods for concord and mutual help: 4. And Christian Magistrates to rule all by the Sword: 5. With the improvement of Mens eminent gifts and opportunities, that these be Instituted by Christ I doubt not: 6. And whether some should succeed the Apostles (excepting their extraordinary powers) in having a visiting, instructing,
⟨p. 14⟩
ordering care of many Churches and their Bishops and Teachers, I confess my self uncertain;
⟨p. 15⟩
or another species from that which we call the Sacred Ministry, or as the Fathers, the Sacerdotal, but what is subordinate about the Accidentals of Religion and the Church. 1. Not the same species, because it is Instituted by God already: No Man can create a creature already created. 2. Not of another supra-ordinate or co-ordinate: for 1. they can prove no power given them to do it: 2. And that were to accuse Christ of insufficient doing his undertaken work, and being less faithful in his house than Moses: 3. And it will infer Mans introduction of a new co-ordinate Doctrine, Worship, or Religious Ministration: for the Ministration of the word and Sacraments, and Keys, is already appointed by Christ: And the Office or Order is specified by the work and terminus; and a new Office hath new work. But in the same species of Religious Ministration, there are abundance of accidentals and circumstances; and Princes or consenting Churches may give men power in those accordingly. But not to forbid what Christ commanded, nor destroy the works and power of his Institution. And if they that are for other superiour or co-ordinate species of Church-power, besides what is afore-granted, say that it is a lawful humane Ordinance: 1. Those that say, Princes only may make it, confess the Church had none that was lawful for three hundred years. And they must prove the Commission. 2. Those that say the Inferiour Bishops made it by consent; 1. feign Inferiours to have power to make a power above their own, (which is more than for Presbyters to ordain their like.) 2. Why may not Archbishops then make Patriarks, and
⟨p. 16⟩
they a Pope, ad summum ascendendo? 3. They must prove their power; and that they are so far equal to Apostles, (who yet were but to teach the Nations what Christ commanded them; which these Men know not but by the Scripture.) 4. What Man maketh, Man may unmake. And how came we to be less free than our Ancestors that made such Offices?
⟨p. 20⟩
is but One, the Members many.—P. 13. The New Testament saith,—The Churches of Galatia, Gal. 1. 2. the Churches of Judea, Asia,—Yet One body.—All the faithful make One heavenly City,—one Church of the first born;—so that Gods Church on Earth is Many Churches, and yet but One Church.—(Do you not think now that we are agreed? But hear him judge himself.) P. 15. I will shew one common Errour or mistake in multitudes of our able Divines,—That those we call particular Churches, are counted Parts and Members of the Church Universal. This I deny,—Mr. Baxter makes the Church of England, or the Churches of England, to be an integral part of the Church Universal,—as a Troop of an Army, or a City of a Kingdom. So the Independents. I overthrow this Errour by this Argument. One and the same thing cannot be both a Body and a Member, a whole and a part, a society and one single person.—But that which we call a single or particular Church, is not a Member but a Body; it is not a limb or part of a Church, but a whole and entire Church,—It hath a whole within it.—London is not a Member of England, but a City and aggregation of Members. It's no less than a flat contradiction in terms,—what Dr. Ames saith, Medul. l. 1. c. 32. that a particular Church est Membrum ex aggregatione variorum Membrorum singulorum compositum, contrary to common reason and plain Scripture.—P. 18. A bare Member in the Body hath no Authority, but acteth by mere natural life and appetite, and is not endued with rational authority, nor can be capable of any.—That which we call a single Church, is a Catholick or Universal Church.
⟨p. 22⟩
say,—Headed by Christ himself] that's supposed, but need not be in the definition. He finds fault himself with such a defect in the definition of a particular Church. Grant them to be Christians, and you grant they own Christ.—2. It is an Errour to define the Universal Church without Pastors,—So doth the Assemblies Confession, and Mr. Hudson—His definition of the Church without Pastors, is, as if he defined a living healthful man, without a stomach, liver or lungs.—P. 24. 3. If there be an essential difference between Church and Church, what then is the difference between the Church and the World! Heaven and Hell! the righteous and the wicked!—How can any man know which is the right Church? We shall never be able to confute Popery nor Infidelity by this Doctrine: For this Doctrine supposeth two essentially different Churches: The Universal Church without Pastors, and of this Christ is Head himself: Particular Churches, of which Christ is no Head, but particular Pastors are the Heads.—By this Doctrine the same thing shall be contrary to it self.—Christs Church in this world is but one! And can one and the same thing have two different Essences, beings, and definitions? Quae conveniunt uno tertio, &c.
⟨p. 24⟩
Head or Government over all the Pastors, Churches, and Christians in the world besides Christ; and you say this is of Divine Institution; and you lay the concord of all the Churches upon it. Do but grant the Papists this one assertion, that particular Churches, as headed by their respective Pastors, are parts and members of the Universal Church, as a City is of a Kingdom, and overthrow the Popes headship over all if you can. It will follow that there must be, besides Christ, an Universal Ecclesiastical Monarch on Earth, either personal or collective, who must have the Supreme power. P. 96. But indeed you have gone beyond Bellarmine in seting up Papal Monarchy. Your other assertion sets up Atheism, by making the Holy God the Author and Founder of two essentially different Churches, or Church-Forms. According to Bellarmines assertion for the Pope, there would be Pastors, &c. But according to your assertion, all the world must be Atheists, of no Religion at all.—P. 224, 225. Your division of the Church into Universal and particular, is plainly against that Rule in Logick; Membra omnis bonae divisionis debent esse inter se opposita.
. Mr. Cawdrey was lately with me, and we had Conference about this point,—suspecting mine own judgment; I have conferred with divers about your other Notions, two Churches, or two Church-Forms differing essentially; and they cannot apprehend how it can stand! you make the Universal Church-Form, and the particular Church-Form to differ essentially, and this by Divine Law. I prove to you from the nature of the thing it self, and the express word of God, that the Universal Church of God at Corinth, and the particular Church of God at Corinth, are one and the same.—To oppose the Universal and particular Church, and say they differ essentially, is to oppose the same thing against itself, and make the Lord Jesus Christ the Authour and Founder of selfsubverting Principles. P. 226, 227. As for that other point, of the Church particular being part of the Church Universal, it is to say, that the whole Church at Corinth is a part of the whole Church, which is absurd.