Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. 9. Further, it's no sin for the Romanists to take from those whom they count Heretics (from Protestants particularly) all that they have: This will not be Theft or Robbery, but an act justified by the Laws of their Church, which oblige them to do it; for this is one of those many punishments, which that Law will have inflicted on us; (k)the goods of Heretics are by sentence of Law immediately confiscated. There is no question of this amongst them; only as to the execution, there is some doubt, whether Heretics are bound in Conscience, as soon as they are such, to give up their possession themselves, and deliver all they have to Roman Catholics; or whether they may not without mortal guilt, keep possession, till the Papists see it fit to put them out, and seize on all they have. Their famous (l)Panormitan concludes that the Heretics are bound, under the pain of deadly sin, to do ⟨p. 361⟩this execution upon themselves, not expecting any other Sentence, or Executioner. And there is a pretty Army of Doctors (longa Doctorum phalanx) do maintain this with him: but Soto and some others determine, that they need not be so hasty to give up all they have of their own accord, but may stay for a declaratory sentence, and seizure upon it; but then a (m)general sentence will serve, without particular process or examination who are personally guilty, and a (n)sentence by some Ecclesiastical person may suffice.
Sect. 9. Further, it's no sin for the Romanists to take from those whom they count Hereticks (from Protestants particularly) all that they have: This will not be Theft or Robbery, but an act justified by the Laws of their Church, which oblige them to do it; for this is one of those many punishments, which that Law will have inflicted on us; (k)the goods of Hereticks are by sentence of Law immediatly consiscated. There is no question of this amongst them; only as to the execution, there is some doubt, whether Hereticks are bound in Conscience, as soon as they are such, to give up their possession themselves, and deliver all they have to Roman Catholicks; or whether they may not without mortal guilt, keep possession, till the Papists see it fit to put them out, and seize on all they have. Their famous
Panormitan concludes that the Hereticks are bound, under the pain of deadly sin, to do
⟨p. 361⟩
this execution upon themselves, not expecting any other Sentence, or Executioner. And there is a pretty Army of Doctors (longa Doctorum phalanx) do maintain this with him: but Soto and some others determine, that they need not be so hasty to give up all they have of their own accord, but may stay for a declaratory sentence, and seisure upon it; but then a
sentence by some Ecclesiastical person may suffice.
(k)Concil. Later. sub Innoc. 3. bona ipsorum ipso facto applicantur fisco, Angel. Sum. v. haeret. n. 5. sunt ipso jure, vel ipso facto confiscata Sylvest. v. haeret. c. 1. n. 12.
(l)Cujus regula est, quod ille cujus bona sunt ipso facto confiscata, non potest illa cum bona conscientia retinere, quia statim sunt acquisita fisco, in Soto de Just. & jure l. 3. q. 6. art. 6. p. 21.
But all of them agree in this, that Heretics lose all title and property in what-ever they possess, and that for them and their heirs; and this before any declaratory (o)sentence, even from the first day of their pretended heretical pravity, as the (p)Directory for the Inquisitors determines.
But all of them agree in this, that Hereticks lose all title and property in what-ever they possess, and that for them and their heirs; and this before any declaratory (o)sentence, even from the first day of their pretended heretical pravity, as the (p)Directory for the Inquisitors determins.
(o)Idem. ibid. v. paena. n. 3. Graft. l. 2. c. 11. n. 10, sine.Idem. ibid. v. paena. n. 3. Graff. l. 2. c. 11. n. 10, sine.
(p)Ut etiam tenet Director. l. 3. tit. 9. qui etiam dicit, quod dicta bona damnatorum propter haeresim, vel bujusmodi ad fiscum pertin•nt a Die commissi criminis, Sylvest. ibid. n. 13. Condemnatio illa vetro agitur usque ad articulum quo haereticus omni ignorantia nudatus, haeresim studio ass•ruit. Assertio est Jo. Aud. Sed nulla opus est authorum citatione: nam lex est expressa.—Et universalis usus & practica St. Senatus inquisitionis sic habet nempe secundum normam directori. l. 3. tit. 9. Soto. ibid. p. 23. vid. Sylv. ibid. n. 14. Graft. l. 2. c. 21. n. 17.Ut etiam tenet Director. l. 3. tit. 9. qui etiam dicit, quod dicta bona damnatorum propter haeresim, vel bujusmodi ad fiscum pertin•nt a Die commissi criminis, Sylvest. ibid. n. 13. Condemnatio illa vetro agitur usque ad articulum quo haereticus omni ignorantia nudatus, haeresim studio ass•ruit. Assertio est Jo. Aud. Sed nulla opus est authorum citatione: nam lex est expressa.—Et universalis usus & practica St. Senatus inquisitionis sic habet nempe secundum normam directori. l. 3. tit. 9. Soto. ibid. p. 23. vid. Sylv. ibid. n. 14. Graff. l. 2. c. 21. n. 17.
To lose all title to their Estates, may seem a small matter, considering that they lose all power and jurisdiction, all right to Honour and Fame, (they and theirs being infamous) to Liberty also, and Life it self: But because loss of Property is great in consequence, let us stay a little on it. All that these pretended Heretics have, being confiscated, they are liable to a Seizure presently; and though their convenience will not serve them to seize on all, a long time after; yet in the interim, the poor Heretics are responsible; for all the (q)mean profits (it may be in our case, for a hundred, or two hundred years past); and all this while, they have no power to alienate or dispose of their Goods or ⟨p. 362⟩Estates, by Gift; Sale, Will, or otherwise; yea, not of any of it, by way of Charity, for they are not their own to dispose of. Hence all Wills, Sales, Contracts, for this purpose, (it may be for some ages together) are (r)null and void. And if the Heretic will venture to alienate any thing he has, he that buys it, does it at his peril(s); for though it pass from hand to hand many years, yet it may be taken away from the Purchaser, with whom it is found, (t)without restoring the price that was paid for it: and he that sells it, is a Cheat, and (u)sins mortally, if he gives not the Purchaser notice of the hazard, and tell him, that when he sells his Estate, or Goods, he has no right to sell them. If the pretended Heretic dye, and leave what he has to his (x)Children, it is no better than if he left them another mans Goods which he had no title to. Yea, though the Children be (y)Catholics, they lose their portion. But who are those that may take from ⟨p. 363⟩Protestants (or others whom they count Heretics) what they possess? why, any that will: Authority is given to all who-ever to Rob, spoil, or bereave us. So Sylvester, and others, quoting the Rabbis of the Pontifical Law for it. It is their determination, that in point of Law and Conscience, (z)all that will, have Authority to spoil us of what we have. What he adds, is matter of caution for more plausible proceedings in the spoil and robbery. It seems safe that this be not done but by special edict of the Prince, or of the Church; this is convenient, least otherwise one might seem to do it, rather out of Covetousness or Revenge, than out of Justice and Obedience.
To lose all title to their Estates, may seem a small matter, considering that they lose all power and jurisdiction, all right to Honour and Fame, (they and theirs being infamous) to Liberty also, and Life it self: But because loss of Property is great in consequence, let us stay a little on it. All that these pretended Hereticks have, being consiscated, they are liable to a Seisure presently; and though their convenience will not serve them to seise on all, a long time after; yet in the interim, the poor Hereticks are responsible; for all the (q)mean profits (it may be in our case, for a hundred, or two hundred years past); and all this while, they have no power to alienate or dispose of their Goods or ⟨p. 362⟩Estates, by Gift; Sale, Will, or otherwise; yea, not of any of it, by way of Charity, for they are not their own to dispose of. Hence all Wills, Sales, Contracts, for this purpose, (it may be for some ages together) are (r)null and voyd. And if the Heretick will venture to alienate any thing he has, he that buyes it, does it at his peril(s); for though it pass from hand to hand many years, yet it may be taken away from the Purchaser, with whom it is found, (t)without restoring the price that was paid for it: and he that sells it, is a Cheat, and (u)sins mortally, if he gives not the Purchaser notice of the hazard, and tell him, that when he sells his Estate, or Goods, he has no right to sell them. If the pretended Heretick dye, and leave what he has to his (x)Children, it is no better than if he left them another mans Goods which he had no title to. Yea, though the Children be (y)Catholicks, they lose their portion. But who are those that may take from ⟨p. 363⟩Protestants (or others whom they count Hereticks) what they possess? why, any that will: Authority is given to all who-ever to Rob, spoil, or bereave us. So Sylvester, and others, quoting the Rabbies of the Pontifical Law for it. It is their determination, that in point of Law and Conscience,
(q)Talis clausula ipso jure vel facto, operatur restitutionem fructuum medij temporis—n•ma Die commissi criminis, non facit fructus suos, sed statim debentur fisco Fell. in cap. Rodolphus de rescript. Graff. ibid. n. 21.Talis clausula ipso jure vel facto, operatur restitutionem fructuum medij temporis—n•ma Die commissi criminis, non facit fructus suos, sed statim debentur fisco Fel. in cap. Rodolphus de rescript. Graff. ibid. n. 21.
(r)Dona•io vel alienatio facta per haereticum ante damnationem non tenet—sicut facta damnatione bona alienare non possunt, sic nec ante illam a die commissi criminis, Sylv. ibid. n. 14. Habetque eousque vim talis sententia, ut omnes contractus, nempe donationes, venditionis, atque alij, etiam causa dotis, quos haereticus ab illo articulo secerit, hab•antur pro infectis, Soto. ibid.
(s)Navarre. c. 17. n. 106.Navar. c. 17. n. 106.
(t)Si haereticus alienavit, fiscus vel inquisitores non tenentur restituere pretium emptori, quia •ff•ctus damnationis re•ro trahitur, Sylvest. ibid. fiscus nullo emptoribus restituto pretio sibi adjudicat dicta bona. Soto. ibid. res quaelibet per delinquentem ali•nata a fisco vindicari possit a die commissi criminis, pretio ipsi emptori minime soluto. Graft. ibid. n. 17. Non solum revocabit rem▪ pretio non restituto emptori, qui emit ab haeretico: verum etiam nec •i qui emit, quantumcunque per plures manus transierit, a qui non habuit jus vendendi, haec Jo. Manald. Archidiaconus, & Jo. Andreus & idem. Directorium in Sylvest. ibid.Si haereticus alienavit, fiscus vel inquisitores non tenentur restituere pretium emptori, quia •ff•ctus damnationis re•ro trahitur, Sylvest. ibid. fiscus nullo emptoribus restituto pretio sibi adjudicat dicta bona. Soto. ibid. res quaelibet per delinquentem alinata a fisco vindicari possit a die commissi criminis, pretio ipsi emptori minime soluto. Graff. ibid. n. 17. Non solum revocabit rem pretio non restituto emptori, qui emit ab haeretico: verum etiam nec i qui emit, quantumcunque per plures manus transierit, a qui non habuit jus vendendi, haec Jo. Manald. Archidiaconus, & Jo. Andreus & idem. Directorium in Sylvest. ibid.
By this we may understand in what condition Protestants are, by the Laws of the Romish Chuich, and how Papists are obliged to look upon us, and demean themselves towards us. No Protestant from the (*)Prince to the meanest Subject, has any Title to Lands, Houses, Money, or any thing else which they possess; or can justly call it their own. All rules of Righteousness, which concern property, are void: Papists owe them no observance. In reference to us, we are not capable of Injury upon this account; whatever they do against us, in respect of our Estates, they wrong us not, they sin not, for we have no Title. If they take from us any thing, or all we have, they steal not ought from us, they rob us not, because they take nothing from us that is our own. If they burn our Houses over our heads, and fire Towns and Cities (as they have done, and their famous (a)Simanca says they may do) they ⟨p. 364⟩do us no injury, they sin not on this account, because the Houses and Goods consumed, are none of ours. If they deprive a Protestant Prince of his Throne and Dominions, they sin not; he is by their Law and doctrine but an Usurper, and had no just (b)title to his Crown. If they draw any of his Subjects into war against him, at home or abroad, they do him no wrong; for they are (c)not his Subjects, no more than the Popish Clergy, who are sworn to another Sovereign. Or if he intrust them with the commands of Forts (d)or Garrisons, they may betray them to the Romanists, and not wrong him, because they were not his. If they take all (e)places of trust, or profit, from Nobles or Commons, they do them no wrong, because they had no right to them, nor have their Children after them any, for some generations. If they pay no (f)Debts to Protestants though they were not only under the obligation of a promise, but of solemn Oath, they may justify it, they owe them nothing. If Trust be reposed in them, or any thing be (g)deposited in their hands, or they borrow any thing of us, they may detain it; they need not restore it, for they have nothing of ours. In a word, there can be no Parliaments, or Convention of the three Estates of a Nation, because there are none in that capacity. As there are no persons ⟨p. 365⟩of Honour for Peers, all being (b)infamous, so can there be no Free-holders to choose, or to be chosen for Commons, since there are no Proprietors.
By this we may understand in what condition Protestants are, by the Laws of the Romish Chuich, and how Papists are obliged to look upon us, and demean themselves towards us. No Protestant from the (*)Prince to the meanest Subject, has any Title to Lands, Houses, Money, or any thing else which they possess; or can justly call it their own. All rules of Righteousness, which concern property, are voyd: Papists owe them no observance. In reference to us, we are not capable of Injury upon this account; whatever they do against us, in respect of our Estates, they wrong us not, they sin not, for we have no Title. If they take from us any thing, or all we have, they steal not ought from us, they rob us not, because they take nothing from us that is our own. If they burn our Houses over our heads, and fire Towns and Citys (as they have done, and their famous (a)Simanca says they may do) they ⟨p. 364⟩do us no injury, they sin not on this account, because the Houses and Goods consumed, are none of ours. If they deprive a Protestant Prince of his Throne and Dominions, they sin not; he is by their Law and doctrine but an Ʋsurper, and had no just (b)title to his Crown. If they draw any of his Subjects into war against him, at home or abroad, they do him no wrong; for they are (c)not his Subjects, no more than the Popish Clergy, who are sworn to another Soveraign. Or if he intrust them with the commands of Forts (d)or Garisons, they may betray them to the Romanists, and not wrong him, because they were not his. If they take all (e)places of trust, or profit, from Nobles or Commons, they do them no wrong, because they had no right to them, nor have their Children after them any, for some generations. If they pay no (f)Debts to Protestants though they were not only under the obligation of a promise, but of solemn Oath, they may justifie it, they owe them nothing. If Trust be reposed in them, or any thing be (g)
(*)A Constitution of Pope Paul 4. subscribed by all the Cardinals, declares that all Prelates and Princes, even Kings and Emperors fallen into Heresy, should be, and should be understood to be deprived of all their Benefices, States, Kingdoms and Empires, without farther declaration, and uncapable to be restored to them, even by the Apostolic Sea•; and their Goods, States, Kingdoms, and Empires shall be understood to be common, and to belong to those Catholics who can get them, Hist. of Counc. of Tr. lib. 5. p. 409.A Constitution of Pope Paul 4. subscribed by all the Cardinals, declares that all Prelats and Princes, even Kings and Emperors fallen into Haeresy, should be, and should be understood to be deprived of all their Benifices, States, Kingdoms and Empires, without farther declaration, and uncapable to be restored to them, even by the Apostolick Sea•; and their Goods, States, Kingdoms, and Empires shall be understood to be common, and to belong to those Catholicks who can get them, Hist. of Counc. of Tr. lib. 5. p. 409.
(a)Institut. Cathol. Tit. 45. Sect. 13.
(b)Tenens regnum contra formam juris & mentem papae dicitur tyrannus, Mascon. de imper. Reg. pars. 1. c. 2. Propter haeresin rex non solum regno privatur, sed & filij ejus a succession regni pelluntur. Simanc. ibid. tit. 9. Sect. 259. Post latam sententiam declarativam de crimine haeresis, injuste princeps possidet regnum, & principatum, & excercet jurisdictionem in subditos: tenenturque subditi eximere se ab ejus obedientia, & bellum gerere contra illum, si virus illis suppe•ant, Bannes in 22. q. 10 p. 614. Yea, Bannes says, it is the more common opinion with Aquinus and his followers, that before the sentence declaratory, Subjects may lawfully, if they have strength, exempt themselves from the power of the Prince. p. 590.Tenens regnum contra formam juris & mentem papae dicitur tyrannus, Mascon. de imper. Reg. pars. 1. c. 2. Propter haeresin rex non solum regno privatur, sed & filij ejus a successione regni pelluntur. Simanc. ibid. tit. 9. Sect. 259. Post latam sententiam declarativam de crimine haeresis, injuste princeps possidet regnum, & principatum, & excercet jurisdictionem in subditos: tenenturque subditi eximere se ab ejus obedientia, & bellum gerere contra illum, si vir•s illis suppe•ant, Bannes in 22. q. 10 p. 614. Yea, Bannes says, it is the more common opinion with Aquinus and his followers, that before the sentence declaratory, Subjects may lawfully, if they have strength, exempt themselves from the power of the Prince. p. 590.
And as no Laws can be made, can be valid, there being none who have any power to make them: so there can be no Aids or Subsidies granted, or required, since they cannot be given or required of those who have nothing of their own to give.
Thus by the Popish principles, the foundations of the civil constitution in England, and other Countries in like circumstances, are quite blown up, as if they had been at the mercy of Faux. And those who will follow their conduct, must hold, that we have no Government, no King, no Subjects, no Parliaments, no Laws, no Liberties, no Property; and indeed, none of the rest, because not this last. And all that will be true to the Doctrine and Laws of Popery, must believe this, and may lawfully deal with us accordingly; they sin not if they do, there is no Conscience in the case to hinder them, or secure us; nay, they are bound to do it, if that which they account most sacred, can oblige them, and that as soon as they can. That which restrains them, is not the fear of God, but of the penalties of our Laws, which yet are of no more force by their determination, than the agreement of a company of Robbers, or the constitutions of mere Usurpers, which will stand in their way no longer than till they can master the power which bears them up; against that which the Roman Decrees and Edicts have made equity and justice, in despite of the Laws of God and Nations.
Thus by the Popish principles, the foundations of the civil constitution in England, and other Countrys in like circumstances, are quite blown up, as if they had been at the mercy of Faux. And those who will follow their conduct, must hold, that we have no Government, no King, no Subjects, no Parliaments, no Laws, no Libertys, no Property; and indeed, none of the rest, because not this last. And all that will be true to the Doctrine and Laws of Popery, must believe this, and may lawfully deal with us accordingly; they sin not if they do, there is no Conscience in the case to hinder them, or secure us; nay, they are bound to do it, if that which they account most sacred, can oblige them, and that as soon as they can. That which restrains them, is not the fear of God, but of the penalties of our Laws, which yet are of no more force by their determination, than the agreement of a company of Robbers, or the constitutions of mere Usurpers, which will stand in their way no longer than till they can master the power which bears them up; against that which the Roman Decrees and Edicts have made equity and justice, in despite of the Laws of God and Nations.
all that will, have Authority to spoyl us of what we have. What he adds, is matter of caution for more plausible proceedings in the spoil and robbery. It seems safe that this be not done but by special edict of the Prince, or of the Church; this is convenient, least otherwise one might seem to do it, rather out of Covetousness or Revenge, than out of Justice and Obedience.
•
▪
•
(u)Navarre. c. 23. n. 89. Sylv. ibid.Navar. c. 23. n. 89. Sylv. ibid.
(x)Nihil habebunt de bonis parentum filij, nec etiam agnati Angel. ibid. n. 7. Si aliquis sit declaratus haereticus, statim potest sieri executio in bonis ejus, exclusis filijs, etiam de legitima. Graff. ibid. n. 10.
(y)Si habue•int Catholicos silios nibilominus confiscantur secundum Gloss. in. Sylvest. ibid. Angelus. ibid. Quinimo veniunt privandi ipsi filij Catholici etiam legitima ita notatur per Genzelinum—quem sequitur, Zabarella & ratio est, quia legitima est quota bonorum, quae pater habebat tempore mortis, sed pater eo in tempore nihil habet quando bona sunt confiscata, Graff. ibid. n. 9.
(z)Si aliter fieri non potest, manu armata sunt eis omnia bona auferenda ut, 23. q. 3 c. 1. Sicut tamen dicit Raynuc. & Gosredus licet Ecclesia videatur dare generalem authoritatem Omnibus expoliandi eos: tamen satis videtur tutum, quod non fiat nisi speciali edicto, vel principis vel ecclesiae: ne aliter videatur quis potius ex cupiditate vel ultione, quam ex justitia & obedientia pugnare, Sylvest. ibid. n. 13. Infidelitas haereticorum est pessima, utrum infideles qui non recognoscunt dominium Ecclesiae licit possint suis rebus spoliari? Resp. Hostiensis, quod sic per illud Mat. ult. data est mihi omnis potestas, &c. quam quidem transtulit in vicarium suum, Angel. Sum. v. infidel. n 3. & n. 7.Si aliter fieri non potest, manu armata sunt eis omnia bona auferenda ut, 23. q. 3 c. 1. Sicut tamen dicit Raynuc. & Gosredus licet Ecclesia videatur dare generalem authoritatem Omnibus expoliandi eos: tamen satis videtur tutum, quod non fiat nisi speciali edicto, vel principis vel ecclesiae: ne aliter videatur quis potius ex cupiditate vel ultione, quam ex justitia & obedientia pugnare, Sylvest. ibid. n. 13. Infidelitas haereticorum est pessima, utrum infideles qui non recognoscunt dominium Ecclesiae licite possint suis rebus spoliari? Resp. Hostiensis, quod sic per illud Mat. ult. data est mihi omnis potestas, &c. quam quidem transtulit in vicarium suum, Angel. Sum. v. infidel. n 3. & n. 7.
deposited in their hands, or they borrow any thing of us, they may detain it; they need not restore it, for they have nothing of ours. In a word, there can be no Parliaments, or Convention of the three Estates of a Nation, because there are none in that capacity. As there are no persons
infamous, so can there be no Free-holders to choose, or to be chosen for Commons, since there are no Proprietors.
(c)Vassalli haereticorum ipso facto liberantur, Angel. Sum. v. haeret. Sylvest. ibid. n. 14. principibus apostantibus a fide non est obediendum, Aquinas 2. 2. q. 10. Concil. Lateran. cap. 3.
(d)Absoluti sunt subditi a debito fidelitatis etiam custodes arcium Simanca, ibid. tit. 46. Sect. 73. Concil. Lateran. ibid.
(e)Angelus. Sum. v. haeret. n. 8. Sylvest. ibid. n. 14. Concil. Lateran. infra.
(f)Si quis promisisset eis solver certo die sub juramento, vel paena, non tenetur ut ibi notat gloss. Sylv. ibid. Angel. ibid. n. 15. Armilla. v. haeret. n. 11. Ovandus. infra.Si quis promisisset eis solvere certo die sub juramento, vel paena, non tenetur ut ibi notat gloss. Sylv. ibid. Angel. ibid. n. 15. Armilla. v. haeret. n. 11. Ovandus. infra.
(g)Simanca. ibid. tit. 45. Sect. 27.
(b)Ipso jure sunt infames, ut neque ad publica offi•ia sen consilia seu ad eligendos ad hujusmodi aliquos; neque ad testimonium admittuntur. Sunt intestabiles etiam, nec ad successiones admittuntur, Angel▪ Sum. n. 21. ibid. For this there is a decree of one of their general Councils (that of Lateran under Innocent. 3) involving not only Heretics themselves, but expressly all the receivers, defenders, and favourers of such. Ex tunc ipso jure sit factu• infamis, nec ad publica officia seu consilia, nec ad eligendos aliquos ad hujusmodi, nec ad testimonium admittitur, sit etiam intestabilis, &c. cap. 3. in Crab. Tom. 2. p. 948.Ipso jure sunt infames, ut neque ad publica offi•ia sen consilia seu ad eligendos ad hujusmodi aliquos; neque ad testimonium admittuntur. Sunt intestabiles etiam, nec ad successiones admittuntur, Angel▪ Sum. n. 21. ibid. For this there is a decree of one of their general Councils (that of Lateran under Innocent. 3) involving not only Hereticks themselves, but expresly all the receivers, defenders, and favourers of such. Ex tunc ipso jure sit factu• infamis, nec ad publica officia seu consilia, nec ad eligendos aliquos ad hujusmodi, nec ad testimonium admittitur, sit etiam intestabilis, &c. cap. 3. in Crab. Tom. 2. p. 948.