Many enormous Crimes are no Sins at all in the Roman account.
pp. 305–390114 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I Proceed to those sins which they will have to be no sins, but need not stay long here, having given a large account of those which they make Venial; since betwixt these, and no sins, there is little difference in their Doctrine, and none in their practice. I need not stay to show, how it is no sin with them to vilify the Scriptures (the written Word of God), or to rob him of the sole glory of his Mediation, and to give much thereof to others, in all its parts and specialities, merit, satisfaction, intercession; or to put their trust in others besides God, for things which he alone can give, and for which he only is to be relied on; and this not only in Saints and Angels, but their Images, and their imaginary Relics. And how it is no sin in their account to abide in ignorance, unbelief, impenitency, or to live without the love and fear of God, and the exercising of other graces: by what is already premised, this is sufficiently manifested.
I Proceed to those sins which they will have to be no sins, but need not stay long here, having given a large account of those which they make Venial; since betwixt these, and no sins, there is little difference in their Doctrine, and none in their practice. I need not stay to shew, how it is no sin with them to vilifie the Scriptures (the written Word of God), or to rob him of the sole glory of his Mediation, and to give much thereof to others, in all its parts and specialities, merit, satisfaction, intercession; or to put their trust in others besides God, for things which he alone can give, and for which he only is to be relyed on; and this not only in Saints and Angels, but their Images, and their imaginary Reliques. And how it is no sin in their account to abide in ignorance, unbelief, impenitency, or to live without the love and fear of God, and the exercising of other graces: by what is already premised, this is sufficiently manifested.
(*)To resist the inspirations of God, drawing us to the observance ⟨p. 306⟩of his commands, or withdrawing us from wickedness, is no special sin, i. e. we contract no other kind of guilt thereby, than if we had sinned, without any such inspirations to with-hold us from it. Thus it will be no fault at all to quench the motions of Gods spirit, inducing us to turn to him, to love him, to repent, &c. or dissuading us from Blasphemy, Perjury, Adultery, Murder, or any other crime. And yet if a man be ready to commit any wickedness, it will be no sin for another to invite him to do it. Thus far men may promote all sin in others, & resist the spirit of God, moving against it. As for evil Spirits, they conclude it no sin, (a)for good men, by special instinct or revelation to make use of the ministry of Devils: they tell us that to apply themselves to Devils (b)to know, or obtain any thing of them, is to have some familiarity and society with those damned Spirits (unless it be the better to expel them out of the possessed) yet they teach it is no sin to inquire of the Devil in a possessed person; what his name is, and wherefore he vexes that person, and what Devils are his associates, and the like. But he must not believe the Devil, though he tell him (c)for this would be as bad as Necromancy): yet if he believe him not, none can tell how the Devils answering him in those inquiries can contribute any thing to his expulsion. They declare also (d)that it is lawful to use adjurations to the Devils, who possess no person, not to assist those that do, or to apply themselves to the great Devils, to cast out the less.
(*)To resist the inspirations of God, drawing us to the observance ⟨p. 306⟩of his commands, or withdrawing us from wickedness, is no special sin, i. e. we contract no other kind of guilt thereby, than if we had sinned, without any such inspirations to with-hold us from it. Thus it will be no fault at all to quench the motions of Gods spirit, inducing us to turn to him, to love him, to repent, &c. or diswading us from Blasphemy, Perjury, Adultery, Murder, or any other crime. And yet if a man be ready to commit any wickedness, it will be no sin for another to invite him to do it. Thus far men may promote all sin in others, & resist the spirit of God, moving against it. As for evil Spirits, they conclude it no sin, (a)for good men, by special instinct or revelation to make use of the ministry of Devils: they tell us that to apply themselves to Devils (b)to know, or obtain any thing of them, is to have some familiarity and society with those damned Spirits (unless it be the better to expel them out of the possessed) yet they teach it is no sin to inquire of the Devil in a possessed person; what his name is, and wherefore he vexes that person, and what Devils are his associates, and the like. But he must not believe the Devil, though he tell him (c)for this would be as bad as Necromancy): yet if he believe him not, none can tell how the Devils answering him in those inquiries can contribute any thing to his expulsion. They declare also (d)that it is lawful to use adjurations to the Devils, who possess no person, not to assist those that do, or to apply themselves to the great Devils, to cast out the less.
(*)Si tamen contingat speciales inspirations dari a'Deo, quando see off•rt occasio frangendi aliquod praeceptum, & homo resistens inspirationibus praeceptum transgrediatur; nullo modo special peccatum committit, quia resistit inspirationi, Jo. Sanc. select. disp. 7. n. 11. p. 36.Si tamen contingat speciales inspirationes dari a'Deo, quando se off•rt occasio frangendi aliquod praeceptum, & homo resistens inspirationibus praeceptum transgrediatur; nullo modo speciale peccatum committit, quia resistit inspirationi, Jo. Sanc. select. disp. 7. n. 11. p. 36.
(a)Sylvest. Sum. v. adjurat. n. 2.
(b)Si quis eos adjuret—ad aliquid ab ijs sciendum, aut ad aliquod obsequium per eos consequendum, est illicitum 1. quia hoc pertinet ad quandam societatem, vel familiaritatem cum ipsis, Sylvest. Sum. v. adjura. n. 2. Licit adjuramus in omnibus ut de corpore expellatur, utputa, quod suum nomen fateatur—similiter ut dicat causam vexandi hominem—licet non credamus, &c.Si quis eos adjuret—ad aliquid ab ijs sciendum, aut ad aliquod obsequium per eos consequendum, est illicitum 1. quia hoc pertinet ad quandam societatem, vel familiaritatem cum ipsis, Sylvest. Sum. v. adjura. n. 2. Licite adjuramus in omnibus ut de corpore expellatur, utputa, quod suum nomen fateatur—similiter ut dicat causam vexandi hominem—licet non credamus, &c.
(c)Quod si ei crederet, ut necromantici, credo esse mortale, quia pertinet ad amicitiam, ibid. n. 3.
(d)Hac etiam ratione non solum licet adjurare Daemones non obsidentes, ne adjuvent obsidentes: sed etiam superiores, ut expellant inferiores, id. ibid.
Sect. 2. So far we see (and further) they may deal with the Devil; how they may deal with God we saw before; though the whole body of Popery be corrupt, yet there is nothing more leprous than their worship; they think it not needful that it should be conformed to the divine ⟨p. 307⟩(*)rule in any thing, either as to the End, or Manner, or Matter, or Object; yet it is transcendently good in their own eyes, no sin in it, even when there is nothing else. For what sordid and wicked ends they think it fit to worship God, we have discovered already, and also in what an irreligious manner. To this latter let me add, what I meet with in Angelus, (e)when he is inquiring, whether attention, or devotion be necessary in their divine service (a strange question it might seem among any called Christians, if their divine Service were the worship of God) he tells us their Gloss maintains that it is sufficient to say it (their Service) with the mouth, though not with the heart, and that many other Canonists agree therein. Thus it seems they understand the Pope's Law for divine worship; so as to approve that in plain terms which Christ expressly, and the Prophets before him, condemns; so as to declare to the world, that the Church of Rome makes no other worship necessary, than what Christ hath openly branded as vain, false, and hypocritical, Isa. 29. 14. and Matthew 15. 7, 8, 9.
Sect. 2. So far we see (and further) they may deal with the Devil; how they may deal with God we saw before; though the whole body of Popery be corrupt, yet there is nothing more leprous than their worship; they think it not needful that it should be conformed to the divine ⟨p. 307⟩(*)rule in any thing, either as to the End, or Manner, or Matter, or Object; yet it is transcendently good in their own eyes, no sin in it, even when there is nothing else. For what fordid and wicked ends they think it fit to worship God, we have discovered already, and also in what an irreligious manner. To this latter let me add, what I meet with in Angelus, (e)when he is inquiring, whether attention, or devotion be necessary in their divine service (a strange question it might seem among any called Christians, if their divine Service were the worship of God) he tells us their Gloss maintains that it is sufficient to say it (their Service) with the mouth, though not with the heart, and that many other Canonists agree therein. Thus it seems they understand the Pope's Law for divine worship; so as to approve that in plain terms which Christ expresly, and the Prophets before him, condemns; so as to declare to the world, that the Church of Rome makes no other worship necessary, than what Christ hath openly branded as vain, false, and hypocritical, Isa. 29. 14. and Matthew 15. 7, 8, 9.
(*)Ex sententia Cajetani & Navarre. in Vasquez, Opusc. moral. dub. 3. p. 24.Ex sententia Cajetani & Navar. in Vasquez, Opusc. moral. dub. 3. p. 24.
(e)Quod attentionem vel devotionem Quaeritur utrum peccent mortaliter non dicen• officium devote & studiose? Resp. Glossa tenet, quod sufficit dicere ore, licet non corde, & cum ea concurrunt multi Canonistae in c. dolentes. Angel. Sum. v. horae. n. 27. Similiter non peccat mortaliter qui verba quidem dicit, sed ad illa non attendit: quoniam cum praeceptum de dicendo horas sit de jure positivo, non refertur nisi ad ea, quae sub judicio humano cadere possunt: & ista sunt quae exercentur per actus exteriores, non autem interiores—Et hoc idem videtur voluisse Scotus in 4.—Hostiensis etiam—Idem. Pet. de Palud. Sum. Rosel. v. Horae.
The sense of their Divines agrees so well with the Canonists, and as little with Christ (though it be expressed in other terms): that the contradiction to him, is not so open, though it be as full. (f)Angelus himself, and (g)Sylvester after him, with others, determine that wandering in one that observes it, when it is but as to the inward act, though it be temerarious and grievous, is not mortal, unless it be out of contempt; the plain English of which, is this, the departing of the mind and heart from God in worship, willingly and wittingly, how great ⟨p. 308⟩soever it be, is a small fault, if any, unless to this neglect of God, a greater contempt be added; whereas the contempt of God herein is very great: his reason is, that which others give, (h)because the Church is not to judge of mere inward acts; and therefore (i)if a Minister of the Church, when he is at Service, mind something else, he seems to be no transgressor of the Precept by that act.
The sense of their Divines agrees so well with the Canonists, and as little with Christ (though it be expressed in other terms): that the contradiction to him, is not so open, though it be as full. (f)Angelus himself, and (g)Sylvester after him, with others, determine that wandring in one that observes it, when it is but as to the inward act, though it be temerarious and grievous, is not mortal, unless it be out of contempt; the plain English of which, is this, the departing of the mind and heart from God in worship, willingly and wittingly, how great ⟨p. 308⟩soever it be, is a small fault, if any, unless to this neglect of God, a greater contempt be added; whereas the contempt of God herein is very great: his reason is, that which others give, (h)because the Church is not to judge of mere inward acts; and therefore (i)if a Minister of the Church, when he is at Service, mind something else, he seems to be no transgressor of the Precept by that act.
(f)Verb. horae. n. 27. supra.
(g)Evagatio autem advertentis secundum actum interiorem solum, licet sit temeraria & gravis forte, non tamen est mortale, nisi propter contemptum, Sylv. v. horae. n. 13. Rosella. v. horae. secundum, Petr. Paludan.
(h)Quia Ecclesia non habet judicare de actibus interioribus mere, Uterque, ibid.
(i)Propter quod Minister Ecclesiae, licet dicendo officium aliud cogitet; non videtur transgressor praecepti ex natura fact•, Angelus, ibid. Rosella. ibid.
He tells us out of Aquinas (what we saw the rest of them do before) that they need not continue actually attentive in worship, but only vertually; id est (k)if they intend to perform Service when they are going about it, that will make them pass for attentive enough all the while, though their minds be carried away after other things, when they are at it, and never heed the worship in hand. This is the common sense of their Authors, as if they should gravely tell us, that a man who goes into company with some intent (actual or virtual) to be sober, but presently falls to his Cups, is overcome and continues Drunk divers hours; yet he may be said to be Sober all the while he is Drunk, by virtue of his first intention. And so we should wrong the Romanists, if we did not think they would have as much of true Worship and Religion in their Service, as that man has of Sobriety, all the time he is dead Drunk.
He tells us out of Aquinas (what we saw the rest of them do before) that they need not continue actually attentive in worship, but only vertually; id est (k)if they intend to perform Service when they are going about it, that will make them pass for attentive enough all the while, though their minds be carryed away after other things, when they are at it, and never heed the worship in hand. This is the common sense of their Authors, as if they should gravely tell us, that a man who goes into company with some intent (actual or vertual) to be sober, but presently falls to his Cups, is overcome and continues Drunk divers hours; yet he may be said to be Sober all the while he is Drunk, by vertue of his first intention. And so we should wrong the Romanists, if we did not think they would have as much of true Worship and Religion in their Service, as that man has of Sobriety, all the time he is dead Drunk.
(k)Tunc videtur manere secundum virtutem, quum accedit ad orationem cum intentione aliquid impetrandi, vel Deo debitum obsequium reddendi: etiamsi in prosecutione mens ad alia rapiatur, idem. ibid. Adverte tamen quod intentio debita & actualis, si adsit in principio vocalis orationis licet postea mens evagetur (nisi talis evagatio interrumpat primam intentionem per contrariam intention•m) sic est meritoria & impetrativa oratio vocalis sine attention per virtutem primae intentionis, idem. v. oratio. n. 10. Rosella, v. hora. Scotus, ibid.Tunc videtur manere secundum virtutem, quum accedit ad orationem cum intentione aliquid impetrandi, vel Deo debitum obsequium reddendi: etiamsi in prosecutione mens ad alia rapiatur, idem. ibid. Adverte tamen quod intentio debita & actualis, si adsit in principio vocalis orationis licet postea mens evagetur (nisi talis evagatio interrumpat primam intentionem per contrariam intention•m) sic est meritoria & impetrativa oratio vocalis sine attentione per virtutem primae intentionis, idem. v. oratio. n. 10. Rosella, v. hora. Scotus, ibid.
Sect. 3. But there is not any more horrid abuse of divine worship, than that which they are guilty of in reference to its object: for besides what they determine concerning divine worship, to be given to other things, besides God, it is no sin with them to worship the Utensils of their worship, the Vessels, Books, Tables, Linen and Priestly Vestments, being once dedicated to divine Service, and made holy by the ⟨p. 309⟩charm of a Consecration. Antonius Corduba says, they are to be worshipped (l)for themselves, and in the judgment of (m)Clychtovius they are to have a worship, distinct from his worship, to whose honour they are dedicated. Vasquez (n)will have them worshipped relatively (as Images to whom he gives Divine adoration) with respect to him, in whose service they are used.
Sect. 3. But there is not any more horrid abuse of divine worship, than that which they are guilty of in reference to its object: for besides what they determine concerning divine worship, to be given to other things, besides God, it is no sin with them to worship the Utensils of their worship, the Vessels, Books, Tables, Linnen and Priestly Vestments, being once dedicated to divine Service, and made holy by the ⟨p. 309⟩charm of a Consecration. Antonius Corduba says, they are to be worshipped (l)for themselves, and in the judgment of (m)Clychtovius they are to have a worship, distinct from his worship, to whose honour they are dedicated. Vasquez (n)will have them worshipped relatively (as Images to whom he gives Divine adoration) with respect to him, in whose service they are used.
(l)Vasquez de adoratione l. 2. disp. 8. c. 10. n. 342. posse secundum se, cultum deferri rebus sacris, sic docet Antonius de Corduba, & alij recentiores.
(m)Vasis & al•js rebus sacris inanimis concedit cultum aliquem distinctum a cultu illius, in cujus honorem dicatae sunt. idem. ibid. c. 11. n. 360.
'Tis no sin to worship the word Jesus, whether it be pronounced or written, and some will have honour given to the word for it self, so (o)Corduba and others. (p)Some will have the word worshipped together with him, that it signifies: as the Image and the exemplar are both worshipped together; So that they will have the word Jesus to be worshipped, as the Image of Jesus.
(o)Ipsi etiam voci secundum se, c•nset honorem aliquem tribui. Ibid. n. 342.
(p)Simul—cum Christo quem significat vox illa. Ibid. n. 343. Idem quod de imagine, de voce quoque Jesus & alijs rebus inanimis, manifest sequitur & quamvis diceremus, quia imagines exemplaribus substituuntur, ideo cum ipsis adorari; quis audeat asserere, vocem Jesus aut sc•iptam aut prolatam, in locum significati non subrogari? &c. Ibid. n. 344.Simul—cum Christo quem significat vox illa. Ibid. n. 343. Idem quod de imagine, de voce quoque Jesus & alijs rebus inanimis, manifeste sequitur & quamvis diceremus, quia imagines exemplaribus substituuntur, ideo cum ipsis adorari; quis audeat asserere, vocem Jesus aut sc•iptam aut prolatam, in locum significati non subrogari? &c. Ibid. n. 344.
'Tis no sin to worship the Accidents of Bread and Wine in the Eucharist, where the object worshipped is not only Christ there, nor is it the substance of Bread and Wine (for they say there is no substance left): but that which they worship, is the colour, figure, or taste of the Elements. The colour, when there is nothing that is coloured: the tartness, when there is nothing that is tart: the roundness, when there is nothing that is round. To these wonderful (not to say monstrous) accidents, some will have a single (q)worship due, but that, the very same worship that is due to Christ, and besides that Divine adoration, which is common to them with Christ, will have also a proper worship given, without reference to Christ: but all of them ⟨p. 310⟩agree, that they are to be adored with (r)Divine worship, and some say that this adoration is terminated on them, as the worship of the Exemplar upon the Image. They will not only have the Manger wherein Christ lay, and the Thorns wherewith he was Crowned, and the Spear that wounded him, to be worshipped: (s)but the Picture of these, when they are but painted, they are to have the same worship which the true Cross has, that is, Divine Adoration; and so are natural Thorns, or a common Manger or Spear to be worshipped, when they are made use of to adorn the Cross, or to set off the passion of Christ, as they are wont Theatrically to represent it.
'Tis no sin to worship the Accidents of Bread and Wine in the Eucharist, where the object worshipped is not only Christ there, nor is it the substance of Bread and Wine (for they say there is no substance left): but that which they worship, is the colour, figure, or tast of the Elements. The colour, when there is nothing that is coloured: the tartness, when there is nothing that is tart: the roundness, when there is nothing that is round. To these wonderful (not to say monstrous) accidents, some will have a single (q)worship due, but that, the very same worship that is due to Christ, and besides that Divine adoration, which is common to them with Christ, will have also a proper worship given, without reference to Christ: but all of them ⟨p. 310⟩agree, that they are to be adored with (r)Divine worship, and some say that this adoration is terminated on them, as the worship of the Exemplar upon the Image. They will not only have the Manger wherein Christ lay, and the Thorns wherewith he was Crowned, and the Spear that wounded him, to be worshipped: (s)but the Picture of these, when they are but painted, they are to have the same worship which the true Cross has, that is, Divine Adoration; and so are natural Thorns, or a common Manger or Spear to be worshipped, when they are made use of to adorn the Cross, or to set off the passion of Christ, as they are wont Theatrically to represent it.
(q)Alij vero recentiores—eodem modo de speciebus Sacramentalibus atque de imaginibus docent: nempe eas adorari posse eodem motu, & adoratione l•triae cum Christo s•b ipsis contento: p•sse etiam secundum se, propria adoratione coli, quae non reseratur in Christum ibi contentum si•ut in terminum proximum adorationis: sed tanquam in motivum remotum sicut de imaginibus, & de nomine Jesu, docuerunt. Idem. Ibid. c. 11. n. 360.
(r)Eandem adorationem qua Christum ibi colimus, ad eas terminari, dicendum est (ut docet Claudus Cello. 6.) Sed per accidens, sicut adoratio exemplaris in imaginem quoque terminatur. Id express tradit. Algelus. l. 2. de Euch. c. 3. idem. ibid.Eandem adorationem qua Christum ibi colimus, ad eas terminari, dicendum est (ut docet Claudus Cello. 6.) Sed per accidens, sicut adoratio exemplaris in imaginem quoque terminatur. Id expresse tradit. Algelus. l. 2. de Euch. c. 3. idem. ibid.
(s)Si autem pingeretur Sacrum praesepium, vel lancea, vel spinea corona, vel aliquid simile, non minus quam ipsa crux in veneratione esse debere. Id vero quod de pictura vel sculptura dicimus, de ijsdem rebus naturalibus dicendum esset, si in ornamentum crucis, & monimentum passionis, vel alterius mysterij, publice ponerentur, &c. Idem. ibid. l. 3. c. 6. disp. 2. n. 73.
'Tis no sin to worship any thing that Christ touched, or that touched him, how injuriously soever. Therefore they teach that the Ass upon which Christ rode is to be worshipped, hereby it appears, says (t)Vasquez, how rightly the Ass upon which Christ did ride may be worshipped; and that the very (u)lips of Judas (that Traitor and Devil as Christ calls him) for kissing Christ, when he betrayed him; for that very act wherein he showed himself a Traitor and Devil, are to be worshipped. If they had but those Traitors lips, they would reverently and devoutly kiss, that is, adore them; and it is strange if they have them not among their Sacred Relics, since they say they have ⟨p. 311⟩the (x)foreskin of Christ, cut off at his circumcision, and his very (y)countenance impressed by him upon a white cloth; for one would think these as hard to come by, however in diverse places they worship something at a venture, which they count so.
'Tis no sin to worship any thing that Christ touched, or that touched him, how injuriously soever. Therefore they teach that the Ass upon which Christ rode is to be worshipped, hereby it appears, sayes (t)Vasquez, how rightly the Ass upon which Christ did ride may be worshipped; and that the very (u)lips of Judas (that Traitor and Devil as Christ calls him) for kissing Christ, when he betrayed him; for that very act wherein he shew'd himself a Traitor and Devil, are to be worshipped. If they had but those Traitors lips, they would reverently and devoutly kiss, that is, adore them; and it is strange if they have them not among their Sacred Relicks, since they say they have ⟨p. 311⟩the (x)foreskin of Christ, cut off at his circumcision, and his very (y)countenance impressed by him upon a white cloath; for one would think these as hard to come by, however in diverse places they worship something at a venture, which they count so.
(t)Inde etiam constat, quo pacto recte possit asinus, cui Christus insedit, adorari. Ibid. n. 76.
(u)Nil tamen obest, quo minus aliquis sincera fide, & recta intentione, affectum & animum solum in Christum intendens, labia Judae, & alia quae injuste Christum tetigerunt, reverenter osculetur. ibid.
(x)Ex dictis infertur Christi praeputium & sanguinem relictum in terris, sive sit sub for•a sanguinis, sive sub alia, non secundum se, hyperdulia, sed ex affectu latriae circa Christum eodem motu adorationis cum ipso, sicut alias ejus reliquias, adorandum esse, ut notavit Corduba & Sylvest. Idem. ibid. disp. 4. n. 125.
(y)Antiqua etiam traditione constat vultum sanctum Domini, tempore passionis suae in linteo expressum fuisse. Qualis Romae—& in Hispania ostenditur—Taurius vero magna cum veneratione servatur, & nec minori religione colitur sindon, qua Christus in Sepulchro fuit involutus: cui impressam reliquit sui corporis siguram. Idem. ibid. l. 2. disp. 3. c. 1. n. 29.
It is no sin to worship the imaginary blood, which flows from a Crucifix or Image of Christ, when it is wounded, for they being given up to believe the most ridiculous lies, (a)do believe, that such blood hath issued from a mere Picture or Image, (b)they keep it as a most Sacred Relic, and it is to be (c)worshipped with the same worship they give to Christ himself.
It is no sin to worship the imaginary blood, which flowes from a Crucifix or Image of Christ, when it is wounded, for they being given up to believe the most ridiculous lyes, (a)do believe, that such blood hath issued from a mere Picture or Image, (b)they keep it as a most Sacred Relique, and it is to be (c)worshipped with the same worship they give to Christ himself.
(a)Vid. Aquinas 3. q. 54. art. 2.
(b)One at Berytus in Syria, pierced by a Jew, related in a Book, ascribed to Athanasius falsely (as Bellarmine confesses de script. Eccles. p. 78.) of which our Author l. 2. disp. 3. c. 1. n. 29.
(c)Idem dicendum de sanguine, qui ex aliqua imagine Christi fluxit, nisi quod ille non ratione contactus, sed repraesentationis tantum adorandus est, idem ibid. l. 3. disp. 4. c. 2. n. 125.
It is no sin to give Divine worship to any man, not only the Saints in Heaven, or holy persons on earth, but any men whatever in the world (the wickedest not excepted) may together with God, have divine worship, as the Image has with the Exemplar, (d)since every man is the living Image of God. This is not only the doctrine of Vasquez, but of Alensis, of Waldensis, and of Cardinal Cajetane. only in the practice of this there must be caution for Albertus Magnus ⟨p. 312⟩and Aquinas say, there is danger least a man, being of more excellency than an Image, divine worship should be given him, not for Gods sake, but his own dignity: (e)but where this danger is not, they would not deny but any man may be so worshipped; even with divine worship. So that if Paul and Barnabas, with the Lycaonians, Act. 14. had but proceeded with the caution of these Doctors; and taken care, that those people should so worship them only for Gods sake; they might lawfully have admitted the worship offered them, though they (not learned in this kind of Doctrine,) chose rather to be stoned than so honoured.
(d)De homine qui est viva Dei similitudo & imago, nec aliqua institutione in cultum Dei dedicata docent Alexander, Waldensis & Cajetan, cum posse esse adorationis materiam, sicut de imagine picta dixerunt: hoc est, in illo & per illum ita Deum adorari posse, ut ipse etiam homo, eodem motu, & signo submissionis colatur sicut imago cum exemplari: atque idem de Angelo dicere debent. ibid. disp. 1. c. 1. n. 4. & cap. 3. n. 17.
(e)Ubi periculum non esset, non negarent adorari posse sicut imaginem pictam. ibid.
It is lawful to worship not only rational Creatures, (f)but any thing else in the whole world, whether living or lifeless. Any beast or creeping thing may be worshipped as the Image of God, which they hold is to be honoured with divine worship. So that not only the Planets, Stars, the Queen and the Host of Heaven, may be thus adored (for which the Lord condemns Israel and Judah as Idolaters): but the vilest Creature that lives on Earth, a Fly, or a Frog, or a Serpent, or a Toad may be thus worshipped. Yea meaner Creatures than any that have life, any inanimate thing whatsoever, though it be but a wisp of Straw; that is our Authors own instance, whereas, says he, (g)the Wickliffites object, that Christians who worship Images, may as well worship a wisp of Straw (modulum straminis the same Leontius (upon whose Authority he grounds all) would as freely grant this, of a bit of Straw; as he does it of every thing else in the World, so far is it from being counted absurd; yea, they may worship not ⟨p. 313⟩only vile but sordid things, (h)and not only God, but Angels and Saints in them, quaevis alia res mundi, any thing what-ever in the World, whether lifeless, unreasonable, or rational; may rightly have divine worship with God. And this is not only the judgment of their famous Vasquez, but of Cardinal Cajetan, and in consequence, of them all; for those great wits, well discerned, that the adoration of other things, approved and practised by the Romanists, could never be defended without extending their principles to such a Latitude. Thus it is manifest, that whatsoever the Apostate Israelites adored, or the Egyptians worshipped, or the Laplanders do worship, or the grossest and the most ridiculous Idolaters in the World, ever made an Idol: all that, with much more and worse, may lawfully be worshipped by Popish principles; there never was any Idolatry so absurd or horrid in the World, but may have Patronage, or excuse by this doctrine.
It is lawful to worship not only rational Creatures, (f)but any thing else in the whole world, whether living or liveless. Any beast or creeping thing may be worshipped as the Image of God, which they hold is to be honoured with divine worship. So that not only the Planets, Stars, the Queen and the Host of Heaven, may be thus adored (for which the Lord condemns Israel and Judah as Idolaters): but the vilest Creature that lives on Earth, a Fly, or a Frogg, or a Serpent, or a Toad may be thus worshipped. Yea meaner Creatures than any that have life, any inanimate thing whatsoever, though it be but a wisp of Straw; that is our Authors own instance, whereas, sayes he, (g)the Wickliffites object, that Christians who worship Images, may as well worship a wisp of Straw (modulum straminis the same Leontius (upon whose Authority he grounds all) would as freely grant this, of a bit of Straw; as he does it of every thing else in the World, so far is it from being counted absurd; yea, they may worship not ⟨p. 313⟩only vile but sordid things, (h)and not only God, but Angels and Saints in them, quaevis alia res mundi, any thing what-ever in the World, whether liveless, unreasonable, or rational; may rightly have divine worship with God. And this is not only the judgment of their famous Vasquez, but of Cardinal Cajetan, and in consequence, of them all; for those great witts, well discerned, that the adoration of other things, approved and practised by the Romanists, could never be defended without extending their principles to such a Latitude. Thus it is manifest, that whatsoever the Apostate Israelites adored, or the Egyptians worshipped, or the Laplanders do worship, or the grossest and the most ridiculous Idolaters in the World, ever made an Idol: all that, with much more and worse, may lawfully be worshipped by Popish principles; there never was any Idolatry so absurd or horrid in the World, but may have Patronage, or excuse by this doctrine.
(f)Quaevis etiam alia res mundi sive inanima, & irrationalis, sive rationalis, ex natura rei & secluso periculo, rite cum Deo, sicut imago ipsius adorari potest. Hanc opinionem tradit. Cajetan. 2. 2. q. 103. art. 3. ad dub. 4. id docuit. Leontius. ibid. c. 2. n. 5.
(g)Frustra igitur Wiclesistae objiciebant Christianis imagines colentibus, ipsos quoque modulum straminis adorare posse—idem enim Leontius, de modulo straminis, quod de quacunque re mundi, libenter fateretur; tantum abest, ut absurdum judicari debeat. ibid. n. 10.
(h)In brutis animantibus & rebus sordidis, Deo exhibere notam submissionis primo aspectu indecens apparet: id tamen non obest, quo minus suapte natura in qualibet re mundi Deum ipsum adorare liceat: imo & sanctos homines seu Angelos, si eos cum rehus illis cogitation nostra possimus conjungere. ibid. n. 11.In brutis animantibus & rebus sordidis, Deo exhibere notam submissionis primo aspectu indecens apparet: id tamen non obest, quo minus suapte natura in qualibet re mundi Deum ipsum adorare liceat: imo & sanctos homines seu Angelos, si eos cum rehus illis cogitatione nostra possimus conjungere. ibid. n. 11.
And now Heaven and Earth being furnished with their Idols, one would think they need go no further, but be satisfied, without seeking Hell for any: yet there is an inquiry which reaches that too. 'Tis a question amongst them, if (i)the Devil should appear in a beam of light, or the form of a Crucifix, whether that apparition may be worshipped? Antisiodorensis, Alexander, Aquinas, Marsilius, Adrian and others, will not allow it should be worshipped, unless conditionally, and with a condition expressed: but Vasques is for adoration hereof absolutely, (k)no condition expressed, and he has those, who are otherwise minded, at a great advantage; because they conclude for ⟨p. 314⟩worship absolutely, in a parallel case: for they will have a consecrated Host to be worshipped, without condition, though the Devil were in it, or lurked under it; and if they think he would be worshipped in the former, without the interposal of a condition; he will be worshipped in the later, where they will have no condition to exclude it. I conclude this with what (l)Holcott determines, a man may merit by a mistaken belief, although it so fall out, that he worship the Devil.
And now Heaven and Earth being furnished with their Idols, one would think they need go no further, but be satisfied, without seeking Hell for any: yet there is an inquiry which reaches that too. 'Tis a question amongst them, if (i)the Devil should appear in a beam of light, or the form of a Crucifix, whether that apparition may be worshipped? Antisiodorensis, Alexander, Aquinas, Marsilius, Adrian and others, will not allow it should be worshipped, unless conditionally, and with a condition express'd: but Vasques is for adoration hereof absolutely, (k)no condition express'd, and he has those, who are otherwise minded, at a great advantage; because they conclude for ⟨p. 314⟩worship absolutely, in a parallel case: for they will have a consecrated Host to be worshipped, without condition, though the Devil were in it, or lurked under it; and if they think he would be worshipped in the former, without the interposal of a condition; he will be worshipped in the later, where they will have no condition to exclude it. I conclude this with what (l)Holcott determines, a man may merit by a mistaken belief, although it so fall out, that he worship the Devil.
(i)An sit peccatum adorare radium luminis, vel speciem Crucifixi, sub qua Daemon delitescit. ibid. disp. 1. c. 5. n. 30. vid Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 3. q. 1. punct. 4. n. 5.
(k)Quare nec conditionem expresse addere oportet, ut recte & legitime adoratio fiat; & multo minus ea exprimenda est, quando Eucharistiam adoramus; ut optime tradunt Alexand. S. Thom. Bonaventura: qui cum dicant, necessariam esse expressam conditionem, quando adoratur Christus in specie Crucifixi, ubi Daemon delitescit: affirmant tamen, eam non esse necessariam, ut adoretur in hostia consecrata. Idem senses Gabriel. Quinimo ut Cajetan. Hosselanus & Claudius Sajnctes, docent, male faceret qui adderet conditionem, ut securus adoraret. ibid. n. 34.Quare nec conditionem expresse addere oportet, ut recte & legitime adoratio fiat; & multo minus ea exprimenda est, quando Eucharistiam adoramus; ut optime tradunt Alexand. S. Thom. Bonaventura: qui cum dicant, necessariam esse expressam conditionem, quando adoratur Christus in specie Crucifixi, ubi Daemon delitescit: affirmant tamen, eam non esse necessariam, ut adoretur in hostia consecrata. Idem sensi• Gabriel. Quinimo ut Cajetan. Hosselanus & Claudius Sajnctes, docent, male faceret qui adderet conditionem, ut securus adoraret. ibid. n. 34.
(l)Hominem posse mereri per fidem erroneam, etsi contingat ut adoret Diabolum. Resett. Humphed de vita Juel. p. 120.
These decisions were necessary to justify their devout persons, who have met with such adventures. A great part of Popery is grounded upon Visions and Apparitions; these were much affected and admired by their reputed holy Men, and Women too, who were admired and adored for them. Satan in the darkness (wherein this mystery did best thrive) had the advantage to put store of Cheats upon them. Many Monks and Hermits (says a Lapide) were deceived by him. Particularly among the rest Valens the Monk was thus deluded, the Devil frequently appearing to him as an Angel. In fine, Satan in an apparition feigned himself to be Christ, and the Monk went, and for Christ worshipped the Devil (Idem in 2 Cor. 11. 15.) They are concerned to plead for that worship, which had the same original with much of their Religion.
These decisions were necessary to justifie their devout persons, who have met with such adventures. A great part of Popery is grounded upon Visions and Apparitions; these were much affected and admired by their reputed holy Men, and Women too, who were admired and adored for them. Satan in the darkness (wherein this mystery did best thrive) had the advantage to put store of Cheats upon them. Many Monks and Heremites (says a Lapide) were deceived by him. Particularly among the rest Valens the Monk was thus deluded, the Devil frequently appearing to him as an Angel. In fine, Satan in an apparition feigned himself to be Christ, and the Monk went, and for Christ worshipped the Devil (Idem in 2 Cor. 11. 15.) They are concern'd to plead for that worship, which had the same original with much of their Religion.
Sect. 4. For Oaths or Perjury, I will only instance in those which are Fraudulent. First, they determine, that he who (m)takes an Oath, and intends not to swear, the Oath binds not, it is no sin to go against it.
(m)Quid ergo si quis exterius juret proferendo verba, & tangendo evangelia, intus tamen non habeat jurandi animum? Respondetur in illo casu, non esse verum sed fictum juramentum. Sed nunquid in conscientia qui sic jurat, tenebitur adimplere? Respondetur minime quidem, &c. Soto de just. & jur. l. 8. q. 1. art. 7. p. 262. Graft. decis. aur. l. 2. c. 17. n. 5. Ut obligationem inducat necessarium est, ut ab intentione jurandi procedat, hoc c•rtum est apud omnes. D. Thom. Cajetan, Soto, Covarruvias, Panormatan, Glossa in Suar. l. 2. de Jurament. c. 7. n 2. Necessarium est ut intentio jurandi sit sufficienter libera. Communis est. Idem ibid. n. 3.Quid ergo si quis exterius juret proferendo verba, & tangendo evangelia, intus tamen non habeat jurandi animum? Respondetur in illo casu, non esse verum sed fictum juramentum. Sed nunquid in conscientia qui sic jurat, tenebitur adimplere? Respondetur minime quidem, &c. Soto de just. & jur. l. 8. q. 1. art. 7. p. 262. Graff. decis. aur. l. 2. c. 17. n. 5. Ut obligationem inducat necessarium est, ut ab intentione jurandi procedat, hoc c•rtum est apud omnes. D. Thom. Cajetan, Soto, Covarruvias, Panormatan, Glossa in Suar. l. 2. de Jurament. c. 7. n 2. Necessarium est ut intentio jurandi sit sufficienter libera. Communis est. Idem ibid. n. 3.
(n)Secondly, when a man intends to swear, but intends not to be obliged by swearing; there he is not obliged, but may lawfully break it, as the ancienter Casuists and School-Doctors generally determine.
(n)Secondly, when a man intends to swear, but intends not to be obliged by swearing; there he is not obliged, but may lawfully break it, as the antienter Casuists and School-Doctors generally determine.
(n)Tenet S. Bonaventura quod universaliter non obligat juramentum si jurans animum se obligandi non habuit. Sylvest. jurament. 4. n. 19. vid. plures ibid. u. 7. & n. 17. Nec qui sic jurat, peccat. Angelus v. juram. 5. n. 9. & Sylvest. v. juram. 4. n. 7. Qui jurat cum intentione non se obligandi, non obligatur ex vi juramenti. Ita—D. Thom. Bonaventur. Scotus. Gabriel. Richard. Sylvest. Angelus Medina. Gutierrez. Navarre. Gloss. Felinus. Abbas. Jo. Andr. in Suar. l. 2. de juram. c. 7. n. 9. Hos & alios vid. in Bonacina. Tom. 2. disp. 4. q. 1. punct. 7. n. 3.Tenet S. Bonaventura quod universaliter non obligat juramentum si jurans animum se obligandi non habuit. Sylvest. jurament. 4. n. 19. vid. plures ibid. u. 7. & n. 17. Nec qui sic jurat, peccat. Angelus v. juram. 5. n. 9. & Sylvest. v. juram. 4. n. 7. Qui jurat cum intentione non se obligandi, non obligatur ex vi juramenti. Ita—D. Thom. Bonaventur. Scotus. Gabriel. Richard. Sylvest. Angelus Medina. Gutierrez. Navar. Gloss. Felinus. Abbas. Jo. Andr. in Suar. l. 2. de juram. c. 7. n. 9. Hos & alios vid. in Bonacina. Tom. 2. disp. 4. q. 1. punct. 7. n. 3.
There is real evidence for the practice of this from the Conclave: for, as their excellent Historian tells us, (*)in the Vacancies of the Sea the Cardinals use to compose certain capitulations, to reform the Papal Government, which all swear to perform, if they be assumed to the Popedom; though it appear by all precedent examples, that every one sweareth with a mind not to keep them, in case he shall be Pope. For so soon as he is Elected, he saith, h••ould not bind himself, and that he is at liberty by gaining the Papacy. This was remarkably exemplified in Paul 4. who resolving to break one of the Capitulations he was sworn to a little before, and some of the Cardinals being ready to put him in mind of his Oath, he declared in Consistory, (†)that it is an Article of Faith that the Pope cannot be bound, and much less can bind himself, that to say otherwise was a manifest Heresy: and threatened the Inquisition to any that hold it. It seems it is damnable error, deserving something like a Hell upon Earth, to believe that his Holiness intends to be honest, whatever he swear. It's true, every one has not the privilege of a Pope, to have it counted Heresy for any to believe that he can be bound to keep any Oaths, or ever to intend it: but all have this liberty by their Doctrine, that they may take Oaths without any intention to keep them; and are not bound to keep them, if they do not intend it.
There is real evidence for the practice of this from the Conclave: for, as their excellent Historian tells us, (*)in the Vacancies of the Sea the Cardinals use to compose certain capitulations, to reform the Papal Government, which all swear to perform, if they be assumed to the Popedom; though it appear by all precedent examples, that every one sweareth with a mind not to keep them, in case he shall be Pope. For so soon as he is Elected, he saith, h••ould not bind himself, and that he is at liberty by gaining the Papacy. This was remarkably exemplified in Paul 4. who resolving to break one of the Capitulations he was sworn to a little before, and some of the Cardinals being ready to put him in mind of his Oath, he declared in Consistory, (†)that it is an Article of Faith that the Pope cannot be bound, and much less can bind himself, that to say otherwise was a manifest Heresie: and threatned the Inquisition to any that hold it. It seems it is damnable error, deserving something like a Hell upon Earth, to believe that his Holiness intends to be honest, whatever he swear. It's true, every one has not the priviledg of a Pope, to have it counted Haeresie for any to believe that he can be bound to keep any Oaths, or ever to intend it: but all have this liberty by their Doctrine, that they may take Oaths without any intention to keep them; and are not bound to keep them, if they do not intend it.
Thirdly, to elude an Oath, and deceive those who give it, or are concerned in it, by equivocation, or other artifice of words; yea, or ⟨p. 316⟩by mental Reservation, is no sin: and that in (o)many cases. As when a man has no mind to swear, and thinks he is not bound to do it; when he is drawn to it by force, or induced by fear, or brought to it by importunity; or when the Judge is incompetent (as they count all that are Heretics or Excommunicate: and that have not lawful jurisdiction); or if the Judges are competent, yet when (*)they proceed not juridically. In these and other cases; either (*)for avoiding harm, or inconvenience; or when it may be for their advantage in any respect, they think it lawful to use these methods of deceit in swearing. Indeed the reason they give to justify the practice •n these cases, will make it as lawful in any other: for they say what is so sworn is true, in their own sense, though not in the sense of the hearers; and so they will have it in strictness to be neither Lie nor Perjury, nor any mortal sin, even when there is no honest, nor reasonable occasion, for swearing or promising, in this fraudulent manner.
Thirdly, to elude an Oath, and deceive those who give it, or are concerned in it, by aequivocation, or other artifice of words; yea, or ⟨p. 316⟩by mental Reservation, is no sin: and that in (o)many cases. As when a man has no mind to swear, and thinks he is not bound to do it; when he is drawn to it by force, or induced by fear, or brought to it by importunity; or when the Judge is incompetent (as they count all that are Hereticks or Excommunicate: and that have not lawful jurisdiction); or if the Judges are competent, yet when (*)they proceed not juridically. In these and other cases; either (*)for avoiding harm, or inconvenience; or when it may be for their advantage in any respect, they think it lawful to use these methods of deceit in swearing. Indeed the reason they give to justifie the practice •n these cases, will make it as lawful in any other: for they say what is so sworn is true, in their own sense, though not in the sense of the hearers; and so they will have it in strictness to be neither Lie nor Perjury, nor any mortal sin, even when there is no honest, nor reasonable occasion, for swearing or promising, in this fraudulent manner.
(o)Si judex juramentum exigens talis (competens) non fuerit, vel esto quod sit competens, interrogat tamen contra juris ordinem, vel est alius homo privatus, qui per metum aut importunitatem juramentum extorquet, tunc jurare poterit quod secundum suam mentem est verum, falsum autem secundum mentem alterius, cui exhibit juramentum. Sicuti fecisse B. Franciscum ferunt, qui rogatus qua perrexisset quidam bomicida, respondit, non transisse illac, intelligens, per illas manicas—Cum Adriano qui sic inique interrogatur, potest optime respondere, quod nescit, intelligendo, non eo modo se scire, quo illud dicere teneatur. Navarre. cap. 12. n. 8.Si judex juramentum exigens talis (competens) non fuerit, vel esto quod sit competens, interrogat tamen contra juris ordinem, vel est alius homo privatus, qui per metum aut importunitatem juramentum extorquet, tunc jurare poterit quod secundum suam mentem est verum, falsum autem secundum mentem alterius, cui exhibit juramentum. Sicuti fecisse B. Franciscum ferunt, qui rogatus qua perrexisset quidam bomicida, respondit, non transisse illac, intelligens, per illas manicas—Cum Adriano qui sic inique interrogatur, potest optime respondere, quod nescit, intelligendo, non eo modo se scire, quo illud dicere teneatur. Navar. cap. 12. n. 8.
(*)Vid Navarre. c 18. n. 57.Vid Navar. c 18. n. 57.
(*)Qui alio sensu ju at quam alter intelligat, non peccat, modo justam habeat causam ita jurandi—justa autem causa utendi his verbis (amphibologicis) est necessitas aut utilitas corporis, aut honoris, aut rerum familiarium—Ex quo sequitur, non esse illicitum uti verbis amphibologicis, addendo restrictionem aliquam in meant retentam, quoties aliquid incommodi, vel injuriae nobis impendet loquendo ad mentem interrogantis, addest en•m justa causa ita loquendi. Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 4. quest. 1. punct. 12. n. 2. 3, 4. Ejusmodi autem aequivocationibus uti, addito etiam juramento absque causa, non est peccatum mortale, modo ne id fiat in fraudem tertij, aut in judicio, dumb judex juridice interrogat. Ibid. vid. Dian. v. aequivoc. Videtur esse communis sententia juramentum simulatum, id est, cum justa & prudenti amphibologia factum, non obligare. D. Tho. Cajetan. Soto. Abbas. Tabiena. Covarruv•as. Navarre. in Suar. l. 2. de juram. cap. 8. n. 2. Juramentum autem dolosum cum injustitia obligare—sed tantum secundum proprium sensum. Scotus, Bonavent. Richard. Gabriel. Sylvest. Angelus. Antoninus. ibid. n. 5.Qui alio sensu ju at quam alter intelligat, non peccat, modo justam habeat causam ita jurandi—justa autem causa utendi his verbis (amphibologicis) est necessitas aut utilitas corporis, aut honoris, aut rerum familiarium—Ex quo sequitur, non esse illicitum uti verbis amphibologicis, addendo restrictionem aliquam in mente retentam, quoties aliquid incommodi, vel injuriae nobis impendet loquendo ad mentem interrogantis, adest enm justa causa ita loquendi. Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 4. quest. 1. punct. 12. n. 2. 3, 4. Ejusmodi autem aequivocationibus uti, addito etiam juramento absque causa, non est peccatum mortale, modo ne id fiat in fraudem tertij, aut in judicio, dum judex juridice interrogat. Ibid. vid. Dian. v. aequivoc. Videtur esse communis sententia juramentum simulatum, id est, cum justa & prudenti amphibologia factum, non obligare. D. Tho. Cajetan. Soto. Abbas. Tabiena. Covarruvas. Navar. in Suar. l. 2. de juram. cap. 8. n. 2. Juramentum autem dolosum cum injustitia obligare—sed tantum secundum proprium sensum. Scotus, Bonavent. Richard. Gabriel. Sylvest. Angelus. Antoninus. ibid. n. 5.
And that you may perceive the Jesuits are not the prime Masters of these Arts; I shall instance in other Authors, who were either before them, or not addicted to the Society.
For equivocations, or other slight of words in swearing, they are justified by (*)multitudes of their Writers, viz. Sairus after Aquinas, and their Gloss, Paludanus, Gabriel, Johannes Major, Adrian, Hen. Gandavensis, Angelus, Sylvester, Soto, &c. The instances which Soto gives, may serve for a taste; as for example (p)when one instead of saying I swear, uses a word which signifies another thing: but so pronounces it as the difference is not discerned. Or if the (q)word GOD in the language wherein the Oath is taken, may signify some other thing; he that swears may mean something else by it, when he that gives the Oath, understands the God of Heaven. (r)Or if the Oath be formed in this order, I swear to you to pay so much Money, he that swears may mean not to pay him, but some other: when he to whom the Oath is made, understands it, intended for himself. Such an (s)Oath says Soto is true, just, prudent, because then simulation is profitable; having said before (t)that it is lawful, with such fraud to deceive one who forces him to swear, since he who puts him to swear, hath no right to do it; and these forementioned, are the very same instances which Sanchez (u)uses; by which we see, the Jesuit was not the inventor hereof, but learned them of a Dominican.
For aequivocations, or other slight of words in swearing, they are justified by (*)multitudes of their Writers, viz. Sairus after Aquinas, and their Glosse, Paludanus, Gabriel, Johannes Major, Adrian, Hen. Gandavensis, Angelus, Sylvester, Soto, &c. The instances which Soto gives, may serve for a tast; as for example (p)when one instead of saying I swear, uses a word which signifies another thing: but so pronounces it as the difference is not discerned. Or if the (q)word GOD in the language wherein the Oath is taken, may signifie some other thing; he that swears may mean something else by it, when he that gives the Oath, understands the God of Heaven. (r)Or if the Oath be formed in this order, I swear to you to pay so much Mony, he that swears may mean not to pay him, but some other: when he to whom the Oath is made, understands it, intended for himself. Such an (s)Oath sayes Soto is true, just, prudent, because then simulation is profitable; having said before (t)that it is lawful, with such fraud to deceive one who forces him to swear, since he who puts him to swear, hath no right to do it; and these forementioned, are the very same instances which Sanchez (u)uses; by which we see, the Jesuit was not the inventor hereof, but learn'd them of a Dominican.
(*)Licet jurare cum aequivocatione. D. Tho. Scotus, Paludanus, Richard. Major. Adrian. Navarre. Covarruvias. Sylvest. Gloss. Ibid. l. 3. cap. 9.Licet jurare cum aequivocatione. D. Tho. Scotus, Paludanus, Richard. Major. Adrian. Navar. Covarruvias. Sylvest. Gloss. Ibid. l. 3. cap. 9.
(p)Si injurius ille nequam sic rogaret, juras mihi tantam numerare pecuniam? & alter responderet, sic uro (absque j.) non esset peccatum mortale, sed simplex mendacium: quia forte tunc nihil ureret. Soto. ibid. p. 263.
(q)Item si Dei nomen lingua illa qua sit juratio, diversum quoque aliud habuisset significatum, liceret illud intelligendo, dicere testis mihi est Deus, quamvis alter Deum coeli intelligeret. ibid.
(r)Aut si altero interrogante, juras mihi numerare pecuniam? alter responderet, tibi juro numerare, non esset sensus, numerare tibi, hoc est solvere aut tradere, sed tibi juro apud me pecuniam recensere, quandoquidem numerare utrumque significat.
(s)Quare tale juramentum esset verum, justum & prudens quoniam tunc simulatio (quoniam absque falsitate fieret) utilis esset.
(t)Quando vero vi illata petitur, licitum est eafraude petentem deludere. Ibid. Similis est aequivocatio quam in verbo est ponit Glossa in cap. neque. 2. 2. q. 2. & quam in nomine sororis notavit Glossa in c. ult 2. 2. q. 2.
Of mental-reservations justified by their chief (*)Authors, who were no Jesuits, instances might be given in abundance; for example, if (a)a man will have his Wife swear, that she is not an Adulteress, though she be guilty, she may deny it with an Oath, and swear what is false in his sense, if it be true in her own, by the addition of some secret reserve. (b)If a man swear to give another a Hundred Crowns, with this inward reserve, If he owe it him: he sins not, though he swears false, in the sense of him, who is to have the money. (c)A Woman who because of some secret impediment will not live with her Husband, and is Excommunicated for it, she at the point of death, that she may be absolved; being put to swear, that if she recover, she will live with him, may swear it absolutely in show, with this conditional reserve, If she may do it without sin; yet if she do it not, she is not forsworn. So Sylvester and Navarre, according to the determination ⟨p. 319⟩of Aquinas, and Jo. Major. He (d)that in the time of Pestilence comes to a Town, where the Officers, before they admit him, will have him swear, that he came from no infected place; though it be not true, he may swear it, if he think himself have got no infection. If (e)you have not a mind, or are not bound to give or lend any thing in your possession, which another desires; you may lawfully swear that you have it not, with this inward reserve, That you have it not, to give or lend. (f)If a man threaten to kill a Confessor, if he will not tell him, whether his Wife hath confessed her Adultery to him; though she have confessed it to him, yet the Priest may absolutely say, and swear, that she has not; with this reserve, So that he should be bound to tell it. (g)He that is examined upon Oath, concerning crimes that he knows, and swears to declare all he knows; may concerning some that are not known to others, though they be to him; swear without Perjury, that he knows them not, with this secret reserve, He knows not to discover them.
Of mental-reservations justified by their chief (*)Authors, who were no Jesuits, instances might be given in abundance; for example, if (a)a man will have his Wife swear, that she is not an Adulteress, though she be guilty, she may deny it with an Oath, and swear what is false in his sense, if it be true in her own, by the addition of some secret reserve. (b)If a man swear to give another a Hundred Crowns, with this inward reserve, If he owe it him: he sins not, though he swears false, in the sense of him, who is to have the money. (c)A Woman who because of some secret impediment will not live with her Husband, and is Excommunicated for it, she at the point of death, that she may be absolved; being put to swear, that if she recover, she will live with him, may swear it absolutely in shew, with this conditional reserve, If she may do it without sin; yet if she do it not, she is not forsworn. So Sylvester and Navar, according to the determination ⟨p. 319⟩of Aquinas, and Jo. Major. He (d)that in the time of Pestilence comes to a Town, where the Officers, before they admit him, will have him swear, that he came from no infected place; though it be not true, he may swear it, if he think himself have got no infection. If (e)you have not a mind, or are not bound to give or lend any thing in your possession, which another desires; you may lawfully swear that you have it not, with this inward reserve, That you have it not, to give or lend. (f)If a man threaten to kill a Confessor, if he will not tell him, whether his Wife hath confessed her Adultery to him; though she have confessed it to him, yet the Priest may absolutely say, and swear, that she has not; with this reserve, So that he should be bound to tell it. (g)He that is examined upon Oath, concerning crimes that he knows, and swears to declare all he knows; may concerning some that are not known to others, though they be to him; swear without Perjury, that he knows them not, with this secret reserve, He knows not to discover them.
(*)Navarre, Sylvest, Angelus, Lud. Lopez. Tabien. Armilla, &c. And among those who seem to dislike it. Soto fatetur licitum esse alicui jurare, se nescire quod revelare non potest, aut non tenetur; subintelligendo, nescio ut tibi dicam—quando judex non potest legitime interrogare de occultis recte illi responderi, non feci, subintelligendo publice, &c. Et ita etiam concessit aperte Cajetan. & Adrian. in Suar. ibid. cap. 10. n. art. 3.Navar, Sylvest, Angelus, Lud. Lopez. Tabien. Armilla, &c. And among those who seem to dislike it. Soto fatetur licitum esse alicui jurare, se nescire quod revelare non potest, aut non tenetur; subintelligendo, nescio ut tibi dicam—quando judex non potest legitime interrogare de occultis recte illi responderi, non feci, subintelligendo publice, &c. Et ita etiam concessit aperte Cajetan. & Adrian. in Suar. ibid. cap. 10. n. art. 3.
(a)Sylvest. sum. v. jurament. 3. n. 2. Navarre. cap. 12. n. 18. quia id injuste agit, potest illa jurare, quod secundum suam intentionem verum est, falsum autem juxta mariti mentem & Angelus. v. juram. 4. n. 1. Nam cum talis inique a tali confessionem exigat, poterit jurare secundum suam intentionem, quod verum est: licet secundum intellectum audientis sic falsum, secundum Rodo. quem sequitur Astensis:Sylvest. sum. v. jurament. 3. n. 2. Navar. cap. 12. n. 18. quia id injuste agit, potest illa jurare, quod secundum suam intentionem verum est, falsum autem juxta mariti mentem & Angelus. v. juram. 4. n. 1. Nam cum talis inique a tali confessionem exigat, poterit jurare secundum suam intentionem, quod verum est: licet secundum intellectum audientis sic falsum, secundum Rodo. quem sequitur Astensis:
(b)Si maligno sensu intendebat facere, quod jurabat, licet non in sensu ejus, cui jurabat: ut quia juravit dare centum, subaudiendo in animo suo, si debuero: tunc non peccat: quia non tenetur jurare secundum intentionem ejus, cum non sit suus judex: sed utitur simulatione licita, quae licet: ut in c. utilem 2. 2. q. 2. Sylvest. ibid. 4. n. 7. Navarre. c. 12. n. 14. Neque peccaret jurando, neque etiam non implendo amplius quam ipse intellexit; quoniam non tenetur aliquis jurare secundum intentionem illius qui perperam ipsum ad jurandum cogit.Si maligno sensu intendebat facere, quod jurabat, licet non in sensu ejus, cui jurabat: ut quia juravit dare centum, subaudiendo in animo suo, si debuero: tunc non peccat: quia non tenetur jurare secundum intentionem ejus, cum non sit suus judex: sed utitur simulatione licita, quae licet: ut in c. utilem 2. 2. q. 2. Sylvest. ibid. 4. n. 7. Navar. c. 12. n. 14. Neque peccaret jurando, neque etiam non implendo amplius quam ipse intellexit; quoniam non tenetur aliquis jurare secundum intentionem illius qui perperam ipsum ad jurandum cogit.
If one promise to another, or contract with a Woman outwardly, without an intention of promising; and is demanded of a Judge upon Oath, whether he promised or contracted: he may plainly deny ⟨p. 320⟩it, because he may have this sense, I promised not with a promise obliging me, and he has just cause so to answer, because since he cannot otherwise prove his want of intention, he will be condemned to pay what he owes not, or to cohabit with her, whom he truly contracted not(*). A witness, either when he is not interrogated juridically, or when he has good occasion not to bear witness in judgment, as if he fear great damage to himself thereby; may answer, that he knows not, or saw it not, or the like, with a mental Reservation(*). He that out of necessity, or for any profit, offers himself to swear of his own accord, may therein use such fallacy(*). He that hath good occasion to hide his goods, lest they should be seized by his creditors, being for his livelihood, and to keep him from beggary; may swear that he has not hid any, understanding not any that he could not hide, or any that he is bound to discover. The same may the witnesses swear for him (viz. That he hid none) knowing that he hid them lawfully(*). Such fallacious Oaths may be used also in Contracts and Bargaining. Those who cannot otherwise get a just price of the buyer, may swear, in a sense that he perceives not, that the Commodity cost them so much(*).
If one promise to another, or contract with a Woman outwardly, without an intention of promising; and is demanded of a Judge upon Oath, whether he promised or contracted: he may plainly deny ⟨p. 320⟩it, because he may have this sense, I promised not with a promise obligeing me, and he has just cause so to answer, because since he cannot otherwise prove his want of intention, he will be condemned to pay what he owes not, or to cohabit with her, whom he truly contracted not(*). A witness, either when he is not interrogated juridically, or when he has good occasion not to bear witness in judgment, as if he fear great damage to himself thereby; may answer, that he knows not, or saw it not, or the like, with a mental Reservation(*). He that out of necessity, or for any profit, offers himself to swear of his own accord, may therein use such fallacy(*). He that hath good occasion to hide his goods, lest they should be seized by his creditors, being for his livelihood, and to keep him from beggery; may swear that he has not hid any, understanding not any that he could not hide, or any that he is bound to discover. The same may the witnesses swear for him (viz. That he hid none) knowing that he hid them lawfully(*). Such fallacious Oaths may be used also in Contracts and Bargaining. Those who cannot otherwise get a just price of the buyer, may swear, in a sense that he perceives not, that the Commodity cost them so much(*).
(*)So Navarre. in cap. humanae aures. 2. 2. q. 5. q. 1. & 2. alleging for this Doctrine. Aquinas. Scotus. Paludanus. Richard. Major. Adrian. and others, vid. Suar. l. 3. de Juram. cap. 9. n. 5.So Navar. in cap. humanae aures. 2. 2. q. 5. q. 1. & 2. alledging for this Doctrine. Aquinas. Scotus. Paludanus. Richard. Major. Adrian. and others, vid. Suar. l. 3. de Juram. cap. 9. n. 5.
Here are a few instances, but they have rules (some of them are premised) which Licence it in cases innumerable: so that it may be a common practice, and they may use it, upon any occasion which they think reasonable.
These things considered, with others Authorized among them. I cannot devise what course can be taken to bind those who follow their doctrine; or to get from them the least security by an Oath. They have declared, that if you put an Oath upon them, which they think, ought not to be imposed, they may lawfully deceive you if they can, and put a cheat upon you, even in a Solemn Oath. Contrive then what Oath you will for your security, they will take it, so far as you ⟨p. 321⟩can judge, as much as any man in the world takes an Oath; yet if they did not intend to Swear (which none can tell but themselves) by taking this Oath; they have not Sworn, they are not obliged. Or if they had a mind to swear, as well as to make you think so, yet if they did not intend to oblige themselves thereby, their Conscience by their principles is free, the Oath does not touch them; or if they have a mind to be obliged by that Oath, yet need they not bind themselves to that, it was designed for; but to quite another thing: for they may swear in a sense, vastly distant from what you intend or imagine; and thus they are taught to do: and it is practicable, either by the fly and undiscerned change of one letter in a word, as they may pronounce it, which will turn the sense as far from yours, as burning is from swearing, which is plain in a former instance. Or else by the ambiguousness of some word in the Oath, affording another sense than you are aware of; they may fix upon that, and leave yours to your self, and so bind themselves to nothing you are concerned for, when you think you have them fast bound to all. Or if such care be taken, that in the Oath there be no ambiguous terms, which may give them the advantage to delude you by a sense foreign to your intendment; yet, do what you can, they may put forth a sense upon it by a mental restriction; for thereby adding something reserved in their mind to what is expressed in the Oath; the sense is quite changed, and the thing they swear is nothing at all, of what you would have sworn.
These things considered, with others Authorized among them. I cannot devise what course can be taken to bind those who follow their doctrine; or to get from them the least security by an Oath. They have declared, that if you put an Oath upon them, which they think, ought not to be imposed, they may lawfully deceive you if they can, and put a cheat upon you, even in a Solemn Oath. Contrive then what Oath you will for your security, they will take it, so far as you ⟨p. 321⟩can judge, as much as any man in the world takes an Oath; yet if they did not intend to Swear (which none can tell but themselves) by taking this Oath; they have not Sworn, they are not obliged. Or if they had a mind to swear, as well as to make you think so, yet if they did not intend to oblige themselves thereby, their Conscience by their principles is free, the Oath does not touch them; or if they have a mind to be obliged by that Oath, yet need they not bind themselves to that, it was designed for; but to quite another thing: for they may swear in a sense, vastly distant from what you intend or imagine; and thus they are taught to do: and it is practicable, either by the flye and undiscerned change of one letter in a word, as they may pronounce it, which will turn the sense as far from yours, as burning is from swearing, which is plain in a former instance. Or else by the ambiguousness of some word in the Oath, affording another sense than you are aware of; they may fix upon that, and leave yours to your self, and so bind themselves to nothing you are concerned for, when you think you have them fast bound to all. Or if such care be taken, that in the Oath there be no ambiguous terms, which may give them the advantage to delude you by a sense forraign to your intendment; yet, do what you can, they may put forth a sense upon it by a mental restriction; for thereby adding something reserved in their mind to what is expressed in the Oath; the sense is quite changed, and the thing they swear is nothing at all, of what you would have sworn.
Yea, or if they swear, that they will observe the contents of your Oath, according to the plain and natural meaning of the words, without any equivocating or mental restriction; yet at the same time they may mean, without any mental restriction, that they will tell you of; and so delude you with a mental reservation, when they are swearing against it: nor is this an imaginary supposition of a thing that they never practised; for thus their Priests and others have taken the Oath of Allegiance, and by this art eluded it; (*)and so they are instructed, and ⟨p. 322⟩may do still, and defeat any Oath that can be devised. Yea, by their doctrine they may do it lawfully, and without sin; for in all this juggling, they teach, that they do not swear false, but by the artifice specified, it's true in their own sense, though not in theirs who give the Oath. Indeed this is a cheat (where God is called to witness) nor do they deny it: But they say such deceit is lawful, as in many other cases so, always when the Judge is incompetent: And that is our case in England, we have none from the Throne to the lowest Bench, that, in their account, have any jurisdiction(h); we have none that have power to put an Oath upon them; they may choose whether they will swear or no, or whether they will cheat them all in swearing. No Oath which can be given them, can oblige them, but in their own sense, how distant soever from the true sense of the Oath, or of the Imposer of it. This our Roman Catholics were assured of long since, by (i)instructions sent them from Rome in Queen Elizabeths time. So that they need make no Conscience (if they will follow the best Guides of their Consciences) to practise all their contrivance upon us in Oaths: (much more in promises, contracts, &c.) even such as the light of Nature has ever condemned in the world, as not only impious in point of Religion, but destructive to human society, and those which tend to subvert the main grounds and foundations of it. We can never oblige them by Oath at any time, but when they please, nor any further than they list: we can never tell when they swear, though they take Oaths, nor when they are obliged, though they swear: we cannot possibly know when we may be sure of them. When we think them fast, by all the rules that men of Conscience and common Honesty proceed by;
Yea, or if they swear, that they will observe the contents of your Oath, according to the plain and natural meaning of the words, without any equivocating or mental restriction; yet at the same time they may mean, without any mental restriction, that they will tell you of; and so delude you with a mental reservation, when they are swearing against it: nor is this an imaginary supposition of a thing that they never practis'd; for thus their Priests and others have taken the Oath of Allegiance, and by this art eluded it; (*)and so they are instructed, and ⟨p. 322⟩may do still, and defeat any Oath that can be devised. Yea, by their doctrine they may do it lawfully, and without sin; for in all this jugling, they teach, that they do not swear false, but by the artifice specified, it's true in their own sense, though not in theirs who give the Oath. Indeed this is a cheat (where God is called to witness) nor do they deny it: But they say such deceit is lawful, as in many other cases so, always when the Judge is incompetent: And that is our case in England, we have none from the Throne to the lowest Bench, that, in their account, have any jurisdiction(h); we have none that have power to put an Oath upon them; they may choose whether they will swear or no, or whether they will cheat them all in swearing. No Oath which can be given them, can oblige them, but in their own sense, how distant soever from the true sense of the Oath, or of the Imposer of it. This our Roman Catholicks were assured of long since, by (i)instructions sent them from Rome in Queen Elizabeths time. So that they need make no Conscience (if they will follow the best Guides of their Consciences) to practise all their contrivance upon us in Oaths: (much more in promises, contracts, &c.) even such as the light of Nature has ever condemned in the world, as not only impious in point of Religion, but destructive to human society, and those which tend to subvert the main grounds and foundations of it. We can never oblige them by Oath at any time, but when they please, nor any further than they list: we can never tell when they swear, though they take Oaths, nor when they are obliged, though they swear: we cannot possibly know when we may be sure of them. When we think them fast, by all the rules that men of Conscience and common Honesty procede by;
(*)Quando quis inique interrogat excludendo omnem aequivocationem, posse interrogatum uti equivocation, apponendo aliquam particulam in meant, &c. Idem dic de teste. Bonacina. Tom. 2. disp. 4. q. 1. punct. 12. & ibi plur•s. Quoties gravis causa occurrit, obquam licet uti verbis ambignis, vel mentali restrictione, ejusmode usum esse licitum, etsi interrogans urgeat, ut sine amphibologia, aut restriction loquaris. Pet. a S. Joseph. de 2 precept. art. 1.Quando quis inique interrogat excludendo omnem aequivocationem, posse interrogatum uti aequivocatione, apponendo aliquam particulam in mente, &c. Idem dic de teste. Bonacina. Tom. 2. disp. 4. q. 1. punct. 12. & ibi plur•s. Quoties gravis causa occurrit, obquam licet uti verbis ambignis, vel mentali restrictione, ejusmode usum esse licitum, etsi interrogans urgeat, ut sine amphibologia, aut restrictione loquaris. Pet. a S. Joseph. de 2 precept. art. 1.
(h)Judex haereticus aut schismaticus amittit omnem jurisdictionem. Vid. Conc. Lateran. sub Innocent. 3. in Crab. Supra.
(i)Juramentum exactum a judice non competente (quales nunc omnes sunt in Anglia) in jurisdictione Ecclesiastica, non obligat nisi secundum intentionem jurantis in Abb. de mendacio. p. 40.
yet they can juggle themselves loose by the Roman rules, at pleasure, and make sport with God and man, even in Oaths where God himself is a Witness, and the greatest of men concerned as Parties.
Sect. 5. There needs no other demonstration of the Irreligion of the Roman Church, and its utter regardlessness of God and the souls of men, ⟨p. 323⟩than their doctrine concerning the observance of the Lords day, and all other which they pretend to be set apart for holy employment. If any man would understand what Religion is left among them, he may see it there in short, and needs look no further; since there he may be satisfied that they have no design for the honour of God, or the salvation of souls. For when they have discharged the people from all duties of Religion, at any other determinate times(k), and reserved all which they make necessary for them, to Holy-days; yet even on these days, by their doctrine, nothing is made their duty, to which any regard of God, or of their souls, is needful. All that they are obliged to, is only to be present at (l)Mass, no other act, or duty of Religion or Worship is necessary; no internal (m)act at all, nor any (n)external, either public or private, but only the Mass: And that may be so external, that neither God, nor any divine thing, need to be minded in it. For this I have produced evidence enough already, let me only add this; they are wont to speak of a three-fold attending at ⟨p. 324⟩Mass (as before was showed at their divine Service.) One (*)to what is said and done by the Priest, as Sacred: A second, to the meaning of what is said or done: And the third, to God and divine things. Now the first of these, they say, (o)is enough, though it be the worst of all: therefore the second (to regard the meaning of what is said or done); and the third (to mind God or Divine things) is more than needs. So that plainly, all that is required of a Papist, by their Doctrine, in order to the honour of God, and the salvation of his soul, on any of those days, when these ought to be most minded, is only, being present at Mass, without understanding what is said, or done; and without minding God or any thing divine. Such is their worship of God, and care of souls, in the Church of Rome; this is the sum of their Religion, when it appears set forth to greatest advantage in its solemn exercises; he that understands it, and can be in love with it, must be under the power of some other consideration, than that of God and his soul.
Sect. 5. There needs no other demonstration of the Irreligion of the Roman Church, and its utter regardlesness of God and the souls of men, ⟨p. 323⟩than their doctrine concerning the observance of the Lords day, and all other which they pretend to be set apart for holy imployment. If any man would understand what Religion is left among them, he may see it there in short, and needs look no further; since there he may be satisfied that they have no design for the honour of God, or the salvation of souls. For when they have discharged the people from all dutys of Religion, at any other determinate times(k), and reserved all which they make necessary for them, to Holy-days; yet even on these days, by their doctrine, nothing is made their duty, to which any regard of God, or of their souls, is needful. All that they are obliged to, is only to be present at (l)Mass, no other act, or duty of Religion or Worship is necessary; no internal (m)act at all, nor any (n)external, either publick or private, but only the Mass: And that may be so external, that neither God, nor any divine thing, need to be minded in it. For this I have produced evidence enough already, let me only add this; they are wont to speak of a three-fold attending at ⟨p. 324⟩Mass (as before was shew'd at their divine Service.) One (*)to what is said and done by the Priest, as Sacred: A second, to the meaning of what is said or done: And the third, to God and divine things. Now the first of these, they say, (o)is enough, though it be the worst of all: therefore the second (to regard the meaning of what is said or done); and the third (to mind God or Divine things) is more than needs. So that plainly, all that is required of a Papist, by their Doctrine, in order to the honour of God, and the salvation of his soul, on any of those days, when these ought to be most minded, is only, being present at Mass, without understanding what is said, or done; and without minding God or any thing divine. Such is their worship of God, and care of souls, in the Church of Rome; this is the sum of their Religion, when it appears set forth to greatest advantage in its solemn exercises; he that understands it, and can be in love with it, must be under the power of some other consideration, than that of God and his soul.
(k)Vid. supra. cap. 1.
(l)Sola missa communiter est in praecepto. Cajetan. sum. v. fest. p. 304. Missa audienda Diebus festis ex praecepto, non tamen Contio, non preces fundendae; non exercendus alius actus cultus Divini ex praecepto (excipe diem paschatis, quo sumenda est Eucharistia) Victorel. addit ad Tol. l. 4. c. 25.
(m)Aquinas. 2. 2. q. 122. art. 4. Cajeran. Sum. v. fest. p. 305. Soto. de justit. & jur. l. 2. q. 4. art. 4. Navarre. c. 13. n. 2. &c. No act of love Bellarm. de cult. Sanct. l. 2. c. 10. Nav. c. 11. n. 7. Soto. ibid. or contrition. Soto. ibid. Sylv. Sum. v. Dominic. n. 8. Canus. relect. de paenit. pars. 4. p. 864. or sincerely no need to have that Devotion in the heart, which they outwardly make show of. No necessity of a good end in their worshipping. For that they commonly maintain after Aquinas that the end of the command for worship, is not under command vid. supra.Aquinas. 2. 2. q. 122. art. 4. Cajeran. Sum. v. fest. p. 305. Soto. de justit. & jur. l. 2. q. 4. art. 4. Navar. c. 13. n. 2. &c. No act of love Bellarm. de cult. Sanct. l. 2. c. 10. Nav. c. 11. n. 7. Soto. ibid. or contrition. Soto. ibid. Sylv. Sum. v. Dominic. n. 8. Canus. relect. de paenit. pars. 4. p. 864. or sincerely no need to have that Devotion in the heart, which they outwardly make shew of. No necessity of a good end in their worshipping. For that they commonly maintain after Aquinas that the end of the command for worship, is not under command vid. supra.
(n)Not hearing Sermons. Sylv. sum. v. Dominic. n. 8. Victorel. Supra. Nor other prayers, private Sylv. ibid. Navarre. c. 21. n. 6. vid. Suar. de fest. l. 2. c. 16. n. 4. or public. Vesperas caeteraque Divina officia, Diebus festis, non audire, non est peccatum mortale, neque veniale; nisi ratione voti aut juramenti. Graft. l. 2. c. 34. n. 12. Nemo jure communi regulariter tenetur audire de praecepto alia Divina officio, etiam vesperas Navar. c. 21. n. 1. They are not obliged to any prayers, but those in the Mass; which indeed are not theirs, nor need they concur in them, otherwise than by a virtual wish, that the Priest may be heard, satis est vel ex longuiquo missanti adesse, & surgendo, genua flectendo, vel alias actualiter vel virtualiter exoptare, ut sacerdos, qui pro omnibus loquitur, orat & sacrificat, a Deo exaudiatur. idem. ibid. n. 8.Not hearing Sermons. Sylv. sum. v. Dominic. n. 8. Victorel. Supra. Nor other prayers, private Sylv. ibid. Navar. c. 21. n. 6. vid. Suar. de fest. l. 2. c. 16. n. 4. or publick. Vesperas caeteraque Divina officia, Diebus festis, non audire, non est peccatum mortale, neque veniale; nisi ratione voti aut juramenti. Graff. l. 2. c. 34. n. 12. Nemo jure communi regulariter tenetur audire de praecepto alia Divina officio, etiam vesperas Navar. c. 21. n. 1. They are not obliged to any prayers, but those in the Mass; which indeed are not theirs, nor need they concur in them, otherwise than by a virtual wish, that the Priest may be heard, satis est vel ex longuiquo missanti adesse, & surgendo, genua flectendo, vel alias actualiter vel virtualiter exoptare, ut sacerdos, qui pro omnibus loquitur, orat & sacrificat, a Deo exaudiatur. idem. ibid. n. 8.
Having, seen how these days are sanctified, or profaned rather, by their worship, we might view, what observance they have in reference to servile works. And here they have little, but what may be done without sin; and indeed, as they order the matter, it may seem less sin to follow the works of their callings, than to forbear them, since their abstinence from them, is not, that they may better attend the worship ⟨p. 325⟩of God; (for they think it not needful to worship him, unless he can be said to be worshipped when he is not heeded) but that they may be idle, or worse employed than in their daily business. However, whether it be to indulge their ease, or serve their lusts, or to make show of some rest, (though far enough from a holy rest) they will have some works forborne; but herein they will be regulated by (*)custom, not the divine Law. Paludanus (p)and others will have them excused, who use manual labours on these days, if they omit not the Mass. And Sylvester says, this is reasonable, because Custom, the interpreter of Laws, will have it so. This may so far regulate them, that every (q)Province and City must observe those days, and those alone, in that manner, and so far only, as custom requires. Yea, it must so far prevail, that if it were the custom to observe these days, no longer than till Noon, or only till Mass were ended, (which may be dispatched in half an hour, and that before (*)Sun rise) the rest may be spent in servile works. They account it worse to spend these days in servile labour, than profane divertissements (for this, with them, is only a Venial fault, or (*)none, but that may be a mortal sin); yet they declare there is no sin in the worst, but what custom makes (they are like to make Conscience of it, when their own ⟨p. 326⟩wills and practices are their rule. This (as many other by their doctrine, which makes void the commands of God at pleasure), is but a sin at discretion; they may make it none when they please, and render all days alike, as easily as they can bring up a custom(*), such a one, to which nature is forward.
Having, seen how these days are sanctified, or prophaned rather, by their worship, we might view, what observance they have in reference to servile works. And here they have little, but what may be done without sin; and indeed, as they order the matter, it may seem less sin to follow the works of their callings, than to forbear them, since their abstinence from them, is not, that they may better attend the worship ⟨p. 325⟩of God; (for they think it not needful to worship him, unless he can be said to be worshipped when he is not heeded) but that they may be idle, or worse imployed than in their daily business. However, whether it be to indulge their ease, or serve their lusts, or to make shew of some rest, (though far enough from a holy rest) they will have some works forborn; but herein they will be regulated by (*)custom, not the divine Law. Paludanus (p)and others will have them excused, who use manual labours on these days, if they omit not the Mass. And Sylvester says, this is reasonable, because Custom, the interpreter of Laws, will have it so. This may so far regulate them, that every (q)Province and City must observe those days, and those alone, in that manner, and so far only, as custom requires. Yea, it must so far prevail, that if it were the custom to observe these days, no longer than till Noon, or only till Mass were ended, (which may be dispatched in half an hour, and that before (*)Sun rise) the rest may be spent in servile works. They account it worse to spend these days in servile labour, than prophane divertisements (for this, with them, is only a Venial fault, or (*)none, but that may be a mortal sin); yet they declare there is no sin in the worst, but what custom makes (they are like to make Conscience of it, when their own ⟨p. 326⟩wills and practices are their rule. This (as many other by their doctrine, which makes voyd the commands of God at pleasure), is but a sin at discretion; they may make it none when they please, and render all days alike, as easily as they can bring up a custom(*)
(*)Dicendum consuetudine fieri posse, ut aliquae personae licit possint in Die festo aliqua opera servilia, vel aliter in festo prohibita, exercere. Antoninus. Slyvester. Cajetan. Soto. Tabiena. Armilla. Navarre. in Suar. l. 2. de fest. c. 33. n. 12.Dicendum consuetudine fieri posse, ut aliquae personae licite possint in Die festo aliqua opera servilia, vel aliter in festo prohibita, exercere. Antoninus. Slyvester. Cajetan. Soto. Tabiena. Armilla. Navar. in Suar. l. 2. de fest. c. 33. n. 12.
(p)Per (Dominicum) intelligitur generaliter omnis Dies festus de praecepto, secundm Pet. de Balude, quod sentire videtur •etiam. 1. Jo. Andr. & doctores dicentes aliquos in Diebus festis excusari, nisi missam omistant. Et. est rationabile; quia consuetudo legum interpres, ita habet. Sum. v. missa. 2. n. 1.
(q)Unaquaeque provincia, aut civitas, observare teneturilla, eo modo, & tantum, quae, quomodo, & quantum consuetudo ipsius praecepit observari. Navarre. c. 13. n. 5. Si usus haberet, ut solum serventur usque ad meridiem, vel usque ad solemnia missarum peracta, postea possent opera servilia fieri. idem. ibid.Unaquaeque provincia, aut civitas, observare teneturilla, eo modo, & tantum, quae, quomodo, & quantum consuetudo ipsius praecepit observari. Navar. c. 13. n. 5. Si usus haberet, ut solum serventur usque ad meridiem, vel usque ad solemnia missarum peracta, postea possent opera servilia fieri. idem. ibid.
(*)Gabriel cum Scoto dicunt, licitum esseincho are missam, una hora & quarta partè alterius ante ortum solis—Non erit peccatum hora & dimidia ante ortum folis sacrificare: Imo addit Paludanus & clarius Victoria posse licit inchoari missam dimidia hora ante crepusculum, ita ut finis missae sit sub initium crèpusculi, plus minusve. Et hoc est in praxi servandum Suarez. tom. 3. disp. 80. sect. 4. So Mass may be ended, not only before Sun-rise, but about break of day, above an hour before the Sun is up.Gabriel cum Scoto dicunt, licitum esseincho are missam, una hora & quarta partè alterius ante ortum solis—Non erit peccatum hora & dimidia ante ortum folis sacrificare: Imo addit Paludanus & clarius Victoria posse licite inchoari missam dimidia hora ante crepusculum, ita ut finis missae sit sub initium crèpusculi, plus minusve. Et hoc est in praxi servandum Suarez. tom. 3. disp. 80. sect. 4. So Mass may be ended, not only before Sun-rise, but about break of day, above an hour before the Sun is up.
But no wonder, they think not these sacred days violated by working, since they teach, they are not profaned by any acts of wickedness. Their Divines (r)generally agree herein; (s)Contrition for sins, and the avoiding of other sins is not enjoined, says Cajetan. The day is not profaned by Fornication (t)says Soto; nor by Lying, Murder, or Blaspheming, says Bellarmin(u); nor by any wickedness whatsoever, is holy time profaned, but only by those opposite thereto (viz.) not hearing Mass and bodily labours. So that the days may be sanctified well enough, according to the holiness of that Church, if after an irreligious presence at Mass for half an hour; (the precept for which may be satisfied without minding God, or abstaining from wickedness, while they are at it) the rest thereof be spent in beastly Drunkenness or Gluttony, in Perjuries, Blasphemies, or Cursing God or Man; in Murders, Whoring, Sodomy, or Bestiality, or the most enormous debauches. And though they are not bound, as they teach, to be at the pains of one good act of ⟨p. 327⟩mind, or heart, in serving God, at the only time set apart for his Service (Scotus is almost worried by the Herd of their Divines (x)for seeming to think that a good act of mind towards God was enjoined on these days), yet they may spend their bodies, and toil themselves more in the service of their lusts, without profaning them, than in servile works. The reason why they hold, that no excess of wickedness does profane these days, is (y)because wicked acts are not servile works. It seems, slavery to Satan, and the service of the vilest lusts is not servile, whatsoever Christ or the Apostle thought thereof, John 8. 34. Rom. 6. 16. that is consistent enough, with the liberty and honour of such Christians as they are. However, hereby it is manifest, that their Religious observation of all holy times (and so all the Religiousness which that Church requires of her Catholics) is consistent with the lewdest acts of ungodliness and debauchery.
But no wonder, they think not these sacred days violated by working, since they teach, they are not prophaned by any acts of wickedness. Their Divines (r)generally agree herein; (s)Contrition for sins, and the avoyding of other sins is not injoyned, says Cajetan. The day is not prophaned by Fornication (t)says Soto; nor by Lying, Murder, or Blaspheming, says Bellarmin(u); nor by any wickedness whatsoever, is holy time prophaned, but only by those opposite thereto (viz.) not hearing Mass and bodily labours. So that the days may be sanctified well enough, according to the holiness of that Church, if after an irreligious presence at Mass for half an hour; (the precept for which may be satisfied without minding God, or abstaining from wickedness, while they are at it) the rest thereof be spent in beastly Drunkenness or Gluttony, in Perjuries, Blasphemies, or Cursing God or Man; in Murders, Whoring, Sodomy, or Bestiality, or the most enormous debauches. And though they are not bound, as they teach, to be at the pains of one good act of ⟨p. 327⟩mind, or heart, in serving God, at the only time set apart for his Service (Scotus is almost worried by the Herd of their Divines (x)for seeming to think that a good act of mind towards God was injoyned on these days), yet they may spend their bodys, and toyl themselves more in the service of their lusts, without prophaning them, than in servile works. The reason why they hold, that no excess of wickness does prophane these days, is (y)because wicked acts are not servile works. It seems, slavery to Sathan, and the service of the vilest lusts is not servile, whatsoever Christ or the Apostle thought thereof, John 8. 34. Rom. 6. 16. that is consistent enough, with the liberty and honour of such Christians as they are. However, hereby it is manifest, that their Religious observation of all holy times (and so all the Religiousness which that Church requires of her Catholicks) is consistent with the lewdest acts of ungodliness and debauchery.
(r)Cajetan. Soto. Sylvester. Victoria. Navarre. Covarruvius & alij, quosirefext & sequitur Suarez. de fest. l. c. 18. n. 3. inter quos etiam recenset S. Thom. vid. Bellarm. de cultu sanct. l. 3. c. 10. Graft. l. 2. c. 33. n. 8.Cajetan. Soto. Sylvester. Victoria. Navar. Covarruvius & alij, quosirefext & sequitur Suarez. de fest. l. c. 18. n. 3. inter quos etiam recenset S. Thom. vid. Bellarm. de cultu sanct. l. 3. c. 10. Graff. l. 2. c. 33. n. 8.
(s)Non continetur sub hoc praecepto contritio peccatorum, nec vitatio aliorum peccatorum. Sum. v. fest. p. 305.
(t)Non quod per fornicationem violetur festum. de just & jur. l. 2. q. 4. art. 4.
(u)Non enim viola•ur tempus sacrum per quaecunque peccata, sed solum per ea, quae opponuntur ipsi tempori sacro, qualia sunt non audire sacrum, & operari corporaliter. Ibid. l. 3. c. 10. p. 1610. Secunda opinio asserit—peccatum etiam mortale in Die festo commissum, non habere ex illa temporis circumstantia special•m malitiam, quae in confessione necessario operienda sit: illam docent Cajetan, Corduba. Soto Victoria. Almain. Sylvester. Armilla. Tabiena. Angl. Navarre. Covarruvias. Gutier. pro hac etiam sententia potest referri. D. Thomas. in 4. dist. 32. art. 5. q. 1. Suarez. l. 2. de festis. cap. 18. n. 3. vid. Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 5. p. 274.Non enim viola•ur tempus sacrum per quaecunque peccata, sed solum per ea, quae opponuntur ipsi tempori sacro, qualia sunt non audire sacrum, & operari corporaliter. Ibid. l. 3. c. 10. p. 1610. Secunda opinio asserit—peccatum etiam mortale in Die festo commissum, non habere ex illa temporis circumstantia special•m malitiam, quae in confessione necessario operienda sit: illam docent Cajetan, Corduba. Soto Victoria. Almayn. Sylvester. Armilla. Tabiena. Angl. Navar. Covarruvias. Gutier. pro hac etiam sententia potest referri. D. Thomas. in 4. dist. 32. art. 5. q. 1. Suarez. l. 2. de festis. cap. 18. n. 3. vid. Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 5. p. 274.
(x)Scotus sentire videtur hoc nos praecepto juberi, diebus festis bonum habere mentis actum circa Deum. Soto de just. & jur. l. 2. q. 4. art. 4. p. 51.
(y)Nec valet dicere inter ista servilia computari peccatum: quia hoc falsum est. Sylv. Sum. v. Dominic. n. 8.—nisi esset opus servile in festis prohibitum, quale non est peccatum juxta S. Thomam. in 3. sent. dist. 37. art. 5. q. 2. Navarre. c. 6. n. 10. probatur a Cajetano & caeteris—quia opus peccati ut sic non est servile Suar. ibid n. 6.
In fine, God can have no honour from men, nor they salvation from him without Religion; this cannot be kept up in the world, without the solemn exercises of it; these cannot, (or will not) be performed without time for that end; therefore hath the Lord appointed time to be set apart for these purposes; the Church of Rome hath reduced all religious Exercises at the times appointed by God, or themselves, to the peoples hearing of Mass, and there will not have the precept oblige them to any real Religiousness, not so much as to a thought of God, or any thing Divine; yea, or the forbearance of wicked thoughts and acts, while they are at Mass. Thus far is Religion (upon which the interest of God and Man so much depends) sunk among them. And it must of necessity sink (all but the shadow or froth) in any part of the world, where these principles prevail. But though they declare them not obliged to serve God any better at this, or at any other time, yet they maintain for them as much liberty to serve the Devil and their Lusts on these Holy times, as any other. Let all concerned, judge of the Roman ⟨p. 328⟩Religion and Holiness hereby; if there were nothing else, by which the measures thereof could be taken, this would suffice.
Sect. 6. In the next place, in reference to Heretics; to go no further (for that is far enough, since in their Charity the far greatest part of Christians are no better) all Relatives are discharged of their respective duties enjoined them by the Laws of God or Man. Their Decretal (the Law of their Church which presumes to over-rule all other Law, Natural, Divine, or Civil) deprives Heretics immediately of all (a)due fidelity, right, duty, observance, which any whosoever do owe them: (b)They lose all which they have by civil right. (c)Subjects owe no Allegiance or duty at all to Princes or Magistrates. (d)Children owe no duty to their Parents; they have (by their Law) no power over them, and this from the first day of their Heresy. (e)Wives owe not conjugal duty to their Husbands; and if (f)they knew they were not Papists, when contracted, they lose their Dowry. (g)Servants are freed from all Fidelity to, and observance of their Masters. (h)Yea, ⟨p. 329⟩Debtors are freed from paying what they owe to Heretics, though bound thereto, either by Penalty or Oath. They hereby oblige their Followers to make nothing of such duties, without the observance of which, Man-kind would become worse than Bruits.
Sect. 6. In the next place, in reference to Hereticks; to go no further (for that is far enough, since in their Charity the far greatest part of Christians are no better) all Relatives are discharged of their respective dutys injoyned them by the Laws of God or Man. Their Decretall (the Law of their Church which presumes to over-rule all other Law, Natural, Divine, or Civil) deprives Hereticks immediatly of all (a)due fidelity, right, duty, observance, which any whosoever do owe them: (b)They lose all which they have by civil right. (c)Subjects owe no Allegeance or duty at all to Princes or Magistrates. (d)Children owe no duty to their Parents; they have (by their Law) no power over them, and this from the first day of their Heresie. (e)Wives owe not conjugal duty to their Husbands; and if (f)they knew they were not Papists, when contracted, they lose their Dowry. (g)Servants are freed from all Fidelity to, and observance of their Masters. (h)Yea, ⟨p. 329⟩Debtors are freed from paying what they owe to Hereticks, though bound thereto, either by Penalty or Oath. They hereby oblige their Followers to make nothing of such dutys, without the observance of which, Man-kind would become worse than Bruits.
(a)Ipso jure privatos esse haereticos omni debito fidelitatis, Dominij, obligationis, & obsequij, quo illis quicunque tenebantur astricti—Decretal. Gregor. 9. l. 5. c. ult. de haeret.
(b)Amittunt omnia quae juris civilis sunt. Graff. l. 2. c. 11. n. 12. privantur j•e Dominij naturalis, oeconomici & civilis vid. Ovandus in 4. dist. 13. p. 347.
(c)Eorum vassalli absoluti sunt a debito fidelitatis & totius obsequij—& idem de vassallis Dominorum, qui contra haereticos sunt negligentes. Sylvest. v. haereses 1. n. 14. Angelus v. haeret. n. 15.
(d)Perdunt patriam potestatem, quia non habent filios in potestate. Graft. ibid. Fillj haereticorum ipso facto quo sententiatum est contra eorum parentes de haeresi, efficiuntur s•i juris, & effecti intelliguntur a Die commissi criminis. Angel. ibid. n. 10. Sylvest. ibid.Perdunt patriam potestatem, quia non habent filios in potestate. Graff. ibid. Fillj haereticorum ipso facto quo sententiatum est contra eorum parentes de haeresi, efficiuntur s•i juris, & effecti intelliguntur a Die commissi criminis. Angel. ibid. n. 10. Sylvest. ibid.
(e)Viro debitum reddere non tenetur. Simanca. Instit. Cathol. c. 45. n. 27.
(f)Uxore• scienter cum haereticis contrahentis perdunt ipso facto dotem. Sylvest. ibid. Angelus. ibid. n. 11.
(g)Et quicunque alij aliqua obligatione adstricti: ut famuli, liberti, & hujusmodi. ipso facto liberantur. Ut dicitur & notatur in c. fi. eo. ti. Angelus. ibid. n. 15. Sylvest. ibid.
(h)Omnes haereticos obligatos ex juramento, fidelitate obsequij, pactione vel promissione, liberari, ita habetur c. ultimo de Haeret. Propterea si aliquis promisisset haereticis solver sub paena vel juramento certo Die, non tenetur, ut notat Glossa ibid. Ego teneo quod eo ipso quod est manifestum in haeresin incidisse tales absoluti sunt, quantumcunque sententia non feratur contra eos. Angel. ibid. n. 15. Sylvest. ibid. n. 14. Armilla. v. haeres. n. 11. Ovandus in 4. dist. 13. propos. 30. p. 348.Omnes haereticos obligatos ex juramento, fidelitate obsequij, pactione vel promissione, liberari, ita habetur c. ultimo de Haeret. Propterea si aliquis promisisset haereticis solvere sub paena vel juramento certo Die, non tenetur, ut notat Glossa ibid. Ego teneo quod eo ipso quod est manifestum in haeresin incidisse tales absoluti sunt, quantumcunque sententia non feratur contra eos. Angel. ibid. n. 15. Sylvest. ibid. n. 14. Armilla. v. haeres. n. 11. Ovandus in 4. dist. 13. propos. 30. p. 348.
But this may seem a smaller matter to them; they go higher, and allow any one to kill a Heretic, as though Murder were no sin; (i)they may be killed with impunity, says de Graffiis, and proves it out of their Church Laws. Pope (k)Urban 2. declared that they are not guilty of Murder, who kill any that are Excommunicate: Now all Heretics are Excommunicate by the Council of Lateran, under Innocent the third; and the Sentence which lies dormant there, is roused once a year. The Pope in person denouncing it in a solemn manner, and very gravely with a Peacock-tail on either side his head. We in England particularly are under Excommunication to this day; and Cardinal Barbarin thought fit, not long since, to give special notice of it in a Letter to some of the Irish. They forget not how obnoxious we are, and we may remember, how much we are obliged by them, that any of us are suffered to live, when they may kill us without Murder.
But this may seem a smaller matter to them; they go higher, and allow any one to kill a Heretick, as though Murder were no sin; (i)they may be killed with impunity, says de Graffiis, and proves it out of their Church Laws. Pope (k)Ʋrban 2. declared that they are not guilty of Murder, who kill any that are Excommunicate: Now all Hereticks are Excommunicate by the Council of Lateran, under Innocent the third; and the Sentence which lyes dormant there, is rouzed once a year. The Pope in person denouncing it in a solemn manner, and very gravely with a Peacock-tail on either side his head. We in England particularly are under Excommunication to this day; and Cardinal Barbarin thought fit, not long since, to give special notice of it in a Letter to some of the Irish. They forget not how obnoxious we are, and we may remember, how much we are obliged by them, that any of us are suffered to live, when they may kill us without Murder.
(i)Possunt etiam impune occidi. Facit. Gloss. sing. in Capital. faelic, &c. Graft. l. 2. c. 11. n. 12.Possunt etiam impune occidi. Facit. Gloss. sing. in Capital. faelic, &c. Graff. l. 2. c. 11. n. 12.
(k)Non enim eos homicidas arbitramur, quos adversus excommunicatos, zelo matris Catholicae Ecclesiae ardentes, aliquos eorum trucidasse contigerit. Refert ex Ivo & laudat Baronius. an. 1089. n. 11. Omnis haereticus sive occultus sive manifestus, est ipso jure excommunicatus. Rosel. v. haeret. n. 14. Quoting their Law for it.
Sect. 7. But we may the better bear with them in this, because they seem not very tender of killing one another. A man is not to be punished who kills his Wife, taken in Adultery, and the Adulterer together with her. (l)He may Kill his own Daughter in like case, or his Sister, yea, or his own Mother, if his Father give order for it; and he may do it as safely though these his Female Relatives be quick with child. For the Child in the Womb (say they) being the same morally with the Mother; he that may kill the Mother, may kill the Child too. Thus a private person may be judge in his own cause, and proceed to ⟨p. 330⟩mortal execution without Trial, and sacrifice the guilty and innocent, both at once; to his own or another's passion, and destroy together the Body and Soul of his nearest Relations; and all this with impunity. They deliver it for certain, that a mother in danger, may lawfully use a Medicine which tends directly to her cure, though it be probable that it will make her miscarry. (m)And because she may take such a course to secure her life, or recover her health: they conclude it lawful to do this, to preserve her state, or reputation. (n)So that if a Maid or married Woman, have prostituted her self to another's lust, she may procure abortion, when otherwise the Crime might be discovered, and her life or credit in hazard. Thus neither Families, nor Parishes, nor Monasteries need be pestered with natural children, how many soever be got: the shame of their birth, and the pain too, may be prevented, and the trouble and expense of their education avoided, by a receipt approved by the Roman Doctors, if it be but taken in time. As for the censures of their Church in this case, or worse, there's no fear, for even (o)a Nun got with Child may procure abortion, and not be Excommunicate (so much more favourable is New-Rome to her Vestals than the old was, though their crimes be doubled.) Any who are so disposed, have encouragement enough, to venture upon both. For as to the murder, they are secured from the Laws of God by this Doctrine, which makes it no sin; from the Laws of the Church by her natural indulgence; and may be from those of the state, by their own private conduct: And as to the Whoredom, they may be quitted upon as easy terms, as they would wish. For the the Priest, if he get the child, is empowered to absolve the Mother;
Sect. 7. But we may the better bear with them in this, because they seem not very tender of killing one another. A man is not to be punished who kills his Wife, taken in Adultery, and the Adulterer together with her. (l)He may Kill his own Daughter in like case, or his Sister, yea, or his own Mother, if his Father give order for it; and he may do it as safely though these his Female Relatives be quick with child. For the Child in the Womb (say they) being the same morally with the Mother; he that may kill the Mother, may kill the Child too. Thus a private person may be judge in his own cause, and proceed to ⟨p. 330⟩mortal execution without Trial, and sacrifice the guilty and innocent, both at once; to his own or anothers passion, and destroy together the Body and Soul of his nearest Relations; and all this with impunity. They deliver it for certain, that a mother in danger, may lawfully use a Medicine which tends directly to her cure, though it be probable that it will make her miscarry. (m)And because she may take such a course to secure her life, or recover her health: they conclude it lawful to do this, to preserve her state, or reputation. (n)So that if a Maid or married Woman, have prostituted her self to anothers lust, shee may procure abortion, when otherwise the Crime might be discovered, and her life or credit in hazard. Thus neither Families, nor Parishes, nor Monasteries need be pester'd with natural children, how many soever be got: the shame of their birth, and the pain too, may be prevented, and the trouble and expence of their education avoided, by a receipt approved by the Roman Doctors, if it be but taken in time. As for the censures of their Church in this case, or worse, there's no fear, for even (o)a Nun got with Child may procure abortion, and not be Excommunicate (so much more favourable is New-Rome to her Vestals than the old was, though their crimes be doubled.) Any who are so disposed, have incouragement enough, to venture upon both. For as to the murder, they are secured from the Laws of God by this Doctrine, which makes it no sin; from the Laws of the Church by her natural indulgence; and may be from those of the state, by their own private conduct: And as to the Whoredom, they may be quitted upon as easie terms, as they would wish. For the the Priest, if he get the child, is impowered to absolve the Mother;
(l)Pet. a. S. Joseph. de 5. praecepto art. 6. p. 258. 259.
(m)Videtur etiam satis certum. &c. Idem. ibid. art. 2. p. 218. vid. Corduba. Pet. Navarre. Aragon. Lopez in Fill. tr. 29. n. 104.Videtur etiam satis certum. &c. Idem. ibid. art. 2. p. 218. vid. Corduba. Pet. Navar. Arragon. Lopez in Fill. tr. 29. n. 104.
(n)Liceret etiam procurare abortum nondum animatum cum ad famam & statum conservandum opus erit. Basil. de Leon, de matrim. l. 10. c. 13. n. 2. Liceret etiam faeminae nuptae, aut virgini fornicanti idem efficere, quando nullo alio quaesito medio sibi consulere possint, ne crimine detecto, famae vitaeque jacturam facerent. Pet. Navar. l. 2. de Restit. c. 3. diff. 2. n. 130.
(o)Secundum Sylvestrum Monialis solicitans aborsum non est excommunicata, quia non injuriam sibi sed proli facit. Lopez. cap. 64. p. 322. vid. Nald•m in Bonacin. de restit. d. 2. q. ult. p. 7. n. 6.
and he need not be so strict, as to enjoin for penance, the avoiding of the sin. Yet for all this, they ⟨p. 331⟩seem so tender (which may amuse us) of unborn Infants in other cases, thus they will have (p)it lawful to cut up the Mother quick, and she obliged to suffer, yea procure it, that the child in her Womb may not perish un-baptized. Thus their Doctrine will have them more regard the Reputation of a Whore, than the life of an honest Woman; yea the child may perish without regard of its wanting Baptism, when the credit of a Strumpet is concerned: but a chaste Woman must be killed in the other case, that the Infant in her Womb may have it. Yet one would think the issue of Whoredom in as much danger for want of Baptism, as the fruit of lawful Matrimony.
and he need not be so strict, as to injoyn for penance, the avoiding of the sin. Yet for all this, they ⟨p. 331⟩seem so tender (which may amuse us) of unborn Infants in other cases, thus they will have (p)it lawful to cutt up the Mother quick, and she obliged to suffer, yea procure it, that the child in her Womh may not perish un-baptized. Thus their Doctrine will have them more regard the Reputation of a Whore, than the life of an honest VVoman; yea the child may perish without regard of its wanting Baptism, when the credit of a Strumpet is concerned: but a chast VVoman must be killed in the other case, that the Infant in her VVomb may have it. Yet one would think the issue of VVhoredomin as much danger for want of Baptism, as the fruit of lawful Matrimony.
(p)Aliqui affirmant non tantum id licere, sed •tiam matrem teneri talem sectionem procurare, & far, ne illius infans sine Baptismointereat. Pet. a S. Joseph. ibid. p. 220.Aliqui affirmant non tantum id licere, sed •tiam matrem teneri talem sectionem procurare, & ferre, ne illius infans sine Baptismointereat. Pet. a S. Joseph. ibid. p. 220.
They teach further, that a man may kill another, either to secure his own person, or his Goods, or his Reputation. In defence of his person they hold it lawful to slay any one; (q)a Servant may kill his Master assaulting him unjustly, or a Monk his Abbot, or a Subject his Prince, or a Child his own Father. This is their common Doctrine, and thereby there is warranty for it, not only to secure ones life, but to avoid a wound or a blow(r). Any one may do this at any time, (s)even a Priest while he is celebrating, may kill one that invades him: and when he has shed his blood, may go on with his other Sacrifice, which will be unbloody notwithstanding. If he that (t)assails him be Frantic, or in Drink, yea or asleep, and has no sense that he offers any wrong; he may innocently kill him for all that, whoever he be, if he cannot otherwise avoid the injury; yea though the aggressor have had the highest provocations, (u)by intolerable reproaches, or the loss of ⟨p. 332⟩his Estate, or the defiling of his bed: yet in this case he that has given the occasion, and done the wrong, may kill the sufferer; the Thief may lawfully slay him whom he has Robbed; and the Adulterer may kill the Husband, after he has abused the Wife, or deflowered his Sister, or Buggered his Child. He may not only kill the aggressor, but an innocent person also to escape himself(x). As if he cannot be secured from Peter, without killing Paul, he may be the death of them both; or state it thus, and they cannot stick at it, if he cannot escape his Father without killing his Mother, he may slay both Father and Mother at once. Thus they may deprive any of life, not only when they are actually assaulted, but before any blow is given. (y)When a man perceives one coming towards him with his Weapon ready, and fears he is not able to deal with him, he may shoot him dead at a distance. Nor need he be hindered by the consideration, that killing him in such circumstances (since he is in mortal sin) will be the destruction both of Body and Soul together. Soto objects this to himself, but abates nothing of his conclusion notwithstanding. Yea he answers, that to hold it not lawful to kill in this case (with the destruction of the slain mans Soul too) is both to pervert the Law of nature, (z)and to render the sweet and easy yoke of Christ intolerable.
They teach further, that a man may kill another, either to secure his own person, or his Goods, or his Reputation. In defence of his person they hold it lawful to slay any one; (q)a Servant may kill his Master assaulting him unjustly, or a Monk his Abbot, or a Subject his Prince, or a Child his own Father. This is their common Doctrine, and thereby there is warranty for it, not only to secure ones life, but to avoid a wound or a blow(r). Any one may do this at any time, (s)even a Priest while he is celebrating, may kill one that invades him: and when he has shed his blood, may go on with his other Sacrifice, which will be unbloody notwithstanding. If he that (t)assails him be Frantick, or in Drink, yea or asleep, and has no sense that he offers any wrong; he may innocently kill him for all that, whoever he be, if he cannot otherwise avoid the injury; yea though the aggressor have had the highest provocations, (u)by intolerable reproaches, or the loss of ⟨p. 332⟩his Estate, or the defiling of his bed: yet in this case he that has given the occasion, and done the wrong, may kill the sufferer; the Thief may lawfully slay him whom he has Robbed; and the Adulterer may kill the Husband, after he has abused the Wife, or deflowred his Sister, or Buggar'd his Child. He may not only kill the aggressor, but an innocent person also to escape himself(x). As if he cannot be secured from Peter, without killing Paul, he may be the death of them both; or state it thus, and they cannot stick at it, if he cannot escape his Father without killing his Mother, he may slay both Father and Mother at once. Thus they may deprive any of life, not only when they are actually assaulted, but before any blow is given. (y)When a man perceives one coming towards him with his Weapon ready, and fears he is not able to deal with him, he may shoot him dead at a distance. Nor need he be hindred by the consideration, that killing him in such circumstances (since he is in mortal sin) will be the destruction both of Body and Soul together. Soto objects this to himself, but abates nothing of his conclusion notwithstanding. Yea he answers, that to hold it not lawful to kill in this case (with the destruction of the slain mans Soul too) is both to pervert the Law of nature,
(q)Bonacin. ibid. punct. 8. n. 4. ubi Sylvester, Julius Clarus & alij communiter.
(r)Si non •ossum effugere quiu me percu•ias, nisi te interficiam, licit te interficio. Angel. Sum. v. defens. n. 4. ibi Bartolus, Florianus, Navarre. cap. 15. n. 4. Lopez part 1. c. 62. Pet. a S. Joseph. ibid. p. 221. Bonacin. ibid. n. 3. & alij communiter.Si non •ossum effugere quiu me percu•ias, nisi te interficiam, licite te interficio. Angel. Sum. v. defens. n. 4. ibi Bartolus, Florianus, Navar. cap. 15. n. 4. Lopez part 1. c. 62. Pet. a S. Joseph. ibid. p. 221. Bonacin. ibid. n. 3. & alij communiter.
(s)Angel. Sum. v. homicid. 3. n. 2. Sylvest. v. homicid. 1. n. 13. Graft. l. 2. c. 64. n. 8.Angel. Sum. v. homicid. 3. n. 2. Sylvest. v. homicid. 1. n. 13. Graff. l. 2. c. 64. n. 8.
(t)Bonacin. ibid. n. 5. ibi. Bartolus, Gomez. & alij.
(u)Pet. a S. Joseph. ibid. p. 222. & 230. Bonacin. ibid. n. 3. ubi Pet. Navar. Sotus, Julius Clarus, Rodriguez.
(x)Petrus a S. Joseph. de 5. praecept. art. 2. p. 223. Pet. Navar. de restit. l. 1. c. 3. n. 147. Bonacin. ibid. punct. 7. n. 1. ubi Julius Clarus. Corduba. Cajetan. & alij.
(y)Graft. l. 2. c. 64. n. 4. Soto de Just. & jure. l. 5, q. 1. art. 8. p. 143.Graff. l. 2. c. 64. n. 4. Soto de Just. & jure. l. 5, q. 1. art. 8. p. 143.
They give further instances wherein they will have it no sin to kill a person, that has not yet touched them; it is sufficient, in their account, if they know that he is prepared for it, yea or does but design it. (a)In case one be shut up in a House or a City, so that he cannot get out, and knows there is one in the Town that designs upon his life, and waits but an opportunity to execute it: he may prevent the designer, and fall upon him unawares, and kill him. They declare it lawful for a man to kill his Wife taken in Adultery: but then they allow the Adulteress to be before-hand with ⟨p. 333⟩her Husband, and kill him first if she can; (b)she may dispatch him with the poison prepared for her, or stab him with the Weapon he has ready, and so secure her Adultery by Murder, and yet be innocent.
They give further instances wherein they will have it no sin to kill a person, that has not yet touched them; it is sufficient, in their account, if they know that he is prepared for it, yea or does but design it. (a)In case one be shut up in a House or a City, so that he cannot get out, and knowes there is one in the Town that designs upon his life, and waits but an opportunity to execute it: he may prevent the designer, and fall upon him unawares, and kill him. They declare it lawful for a man to kill his Wife taken in Adultery: but then they allow the Adulteress to be before-hand with ⟨p. 333⟩her Husband, and kill him first if she can; (b)she may dispatch him with the poyson prepared for her, or stab him with the Weapon he has ready, and so secure her Adultery by Murder, and yet be innocent.
(a)Graft. l. 2. c. 64. n. 5.Graff. l. 2. c. 64. n. 5.
(b)Navarre. c. 15. n. 3. Lopez. c. 62. p. 311. Bonacin. de restit. d 2. q. ult. p. 9. n. 2. Ubi Julius Clarus, Bannes, Rodriquez, Corduba & alij.Navar. c. 15. n. 3. Lopez. c. 62. p. 311. Bonacin. de restit. d 2. q. ult. p. 9. n. 2. Ubi Julius Clarus, Bannes, Rodriquez, Corduba & alij.
They maintain it is lawful to kill others to secure their goods. (c)So it is no sin with them, to take away the life of him, that would take away part of their Goods by night or day; yea if he that steals makes no resistance, or defence, but flies, he may be pursued and slain, to recover what he has taken. And although the Goods may be recovered otherwise, and in a legal way, (d)yet if it be not certain, that he may get them with the greatest ease, but doubtful that it may give him some trouble, he may use his liberty, and send him to Hell to save himself a little trouble. But of what value must the Goods be? (that we may discern at what rate they set the life and Soul of a man). It must not (says Soto) be a vile thing, it should not be so little worth as 2 or 3 Ducats(e). So that it seems, if what is stolen, be of the value of about Twenty shillings, a man may be killed for it, and his Body and Soul destroyed together. And since a Crown or a Shilling may be more to some than Twenty to others; those who follow him, might well infer from hence, that a mans life might be taken away for a Crown or less: yea for an Apple, since to some persons that may be of more value, than the sums mentioned. Accordingly, they conclude expressly, (f)that he who takes a thing, the owner or keeper of it seeing, and offering to hinder him, may be lawfully slain for it; though it be but of the value of one Crown or less either, because thereby he offers an ⟨p. 334⟩affront. That's another ground of their Lawful murder. (g)A man, they avow, may kill others for his Honour or Reputation; for though it be so slight a thing, that it will be scarce a fault in a man to throw it away himself (as we heard before): yet they will have him maintain it at the expense of the blood, and life of others, and his own too. For example, (h)If he sees one approach to assault him, though he might avoid the danger by retiring, yet he may kill him rather than so avoid it; because it would be a disparagement to him to fly, and so rather than suffer the least, in the repute of the injudicious Rabble, he may be the death of any person; and be a man of blood, that he may be the Master of such honour, as a truly generous spirit must despise. They advance further yet; if one should offer to (i)give a person a blow with a Cudgel, or a light Switch;
They maintain it is lawful to kill others to secure their goods. (c)So it is no sin with them, to take away the life of him, that would take away part of their Goods by night or day; yea if he that steals makes no resistance, or defence, but flyes, he may be pursued and slain, to recover what he has taken. And although the Goods may be recovered otherwise, and in a legal way, (d)yet if it be not certain, that he may get them with the greatest ease, but doubtful that it may give him some trouble, he may use his liberty, and send him to Hell to save himself a little trouble. But of what value must the Goods be? (that we may discern at what rate they set the life and Soul of a man). It must not (sayes Soto) be a vile thing, it should not be so little worth as 2 or 3 Duckats(e). So that it seems, if what is stoln, be of the value of about Twenty shillings, a man may be kill'd for it, and his Body and Soul destroy'd together. And since a Crown or a Shilling may be more to some than Twenty to others; those who follow him, might well infer from hence, that a mans life might be taken away for a Crown or less: yea for an Apple, since to some persons that may be of more value, than the sums mentioned. Accordingly, they conclude expresly, (f)that he who takes a thing, the owner or keeper of it seeing, and offering to hinder him, may be lawfully slain for it; though it be but of the value of one Crown or less either, because thereby he offers an ⟨p. 334⟩affront. That's another ground of their Lawful murder. (g)A man, they avow, may kill others for his Honour or Reputation; for though it be so slight a thing, that it will be scarce a fault in a man to throw it away himself (as we heard before): yet they will have him maintain it at the expence of the blood, and life of others, and his own too. For example, (h)If he sees one approach to assault him, though he might avoid the danger by retiring, yet he may kill him rather than so avoid it; because it would be a disparagement to him to fly, and so rather than suffer the least, in the repute of the injudicious Rabble, he may be the death of any person; and be a man of blood, that he may be the Master of such honour, as a truly generous spirit must despise. They advance further yet; if one should offer to
(c)Soto. ibid. Graft. ibid. n. 17. Lopez. Cap. 62. Navarre. c. 15. n. 2. ibi Cajetan. Antoninus, Sylvester.Soto. ibid. Graff. ibid. n. 17. Lopez. Cap. 62. Navar. c. 15. n. 2. ibi Cajetan. Antoninus, Silvester.
(d)Non licet furem occidere—si spes esset certissima quod facilimo negotio recuperari posset—ubi autem res esset dubia, posset liberum esse Domino jure uti suo, Soto. ibid.
(e)Ibid. p. 144.
(f)Etiamsi res sit valoris unius aurei aut minoris—videtur posse occidi Bonacin. de restit. d. 2. q. ult. p. 10. n. 1.
(g)Comuniter omnes docent, Vid. Victorel. add. Toll. l. 5. c. 6. famam suam—negligere & prodigere potest sine peccato. Pet. S. Joseph, de 8. praecept. art. 2. vid. Navarre. c. 18. n. 27.Comuniter omnes docent, Vid. Victorel. add. Tol. l. 5. c. 6. famam suam—negligere & prodigere potest sine peccato. Pet. S. Joseph, de 8. praecept. art. 2. vid. Navar. c. 18. n. 27.
(h)Soto ibid.
(i)Si quempiam aggrederetur, ut eum fuste levissime percuteret, posset id alter etiam hostem interimendo repellere. ibid. Victoria. Navarre. & Sylvester in Fill. tr. 29. n. 50.Si quempiam aggrederetur, ut eum fuste levissime percuteret, posset id alter etiam hostem interimendo repellere. ibid. Victoria. Navar. & Sylvester in Fill. tr. 29. n. 50.
he that is offered such an affront may lawfully kill him for it, especially in Spain, where this is counted a great injury says Soto. And elsewhere a box on the ear may be resented, as such an injury. Accordingly others determine, that he who gives it, may lawfully (k)be slain for it, yea or he that does but offer it. If he be any person of any moment that is thus attempted, he need not stay till he feel it, but may prevent it by killing him that offers it, if there be no other honourable way to avoid it. He need not fly to avoid it, if that would be a disgrace, for he is not obliged to suffer such an inconvenience, though by retiring he might save both his own life, and the aggressors, says Bonacina after others. In this manner when one smites them on the Cheek, do they turn the other; and thus do they comply exactly with Christ's advice by stabbing him to the heart, who smites their Cheek, or does but offer at it.
he that is offered such an affront may lawfully kill him for it, especially in Spain, where this is counted a great injury sayes Soto. And elsewhere a box on the ear may be resented, as such an injury. Accordingly others determine, that he who gives it, may lawfully (k)be slain for it, yea or he that does but offer it. If he be any person of any moment that is thus attempted, he need not stay till he feel it, but may prevent it by killing him that offers it, if there be no other honourable way to avoid it. He need not fly to avoid it, if that would be a disgrace, for he is not obliged to suffer such an inconvenience, though by retiring he might save both his own life, and the aggressors, sayes Bonacina after others. In this manner when one smites them on the Cheek, do they turn the other; and thus do they comply exactly with Christ's advice by stabbing him to the heart, who smites their Cheek, or does but offer at it.
(k)Ad vitandum vulnus vel alapam—potest occidere. Navar. c. 15. n. 4. Lopez. p. 1. c. 62. p. 316. Bonacin. ibid. n. 6. & alij.
•
•
(c)Aquinas & Jo Major. in Navarre. c 12. n. 9. Sylvest. ibid. 3. n. 2. Angelus. Sum. v. juram 4. n. 1. Quum quis ex juramento exigit ab aliquo quod ipse non potest sine peccato implere: potest habere intentionem, cum jurat illud facere scil. Quantum poterit sine peccato. Sic & Sylvester. Sic secundum Rich. de St. Victore obstetrices non peccassent, licet non respondissent ad intentionem Pharaonis, quia non fuit ei data Authoritas ad aliquid agendum contra Deum. Secundum Innocent. in c. veniens de curia. in juramento determinato super aliquo singulari, sic interpretatur in foro animae, secundum intentionem jurantis. Angel. ibid.Aquinas & Jo Major. in Navar. c 12. n. 9. Sylvest. ibid. 3. n. 2. Angelus. Sum. v. juram 4. n. 1. Quum quis ex juramento exigit ab aliquo quod ipse non potest sine peccato implere: potest habere intentionem, cum jurat illud facere scil. Quantum poterit sine peccato. Sic & Sylvester. Sic secundum Rich. de St. Victore obstetrices non peccassent, licet non respondissent ad intentionem Pharaonis, quia non fuit ei data Authoritas ad aliquid agendum contra Deum. Secundum Innocent. in c. veniens de curia. in juramento determinato super aliquo singulari, sic interpretatur in foro animae, secundum intentionem jurantis. Angel. ibid.
(d)Sylvest. v. juram. 3. n. 2. Navarre. c. 12. n. 19. Bonacin. ubi supra.Sylvest. v. juram. 3. n. 2. Navar. c. 12. n. 19. Bonacin. ubi supra.
(e)An qui jurat se non habere rem aliquam ab alio petitam, ut ab ea danda vel accommodanda se excuset, peccet? responderi enim debet, piccare si mens ejus verbis consonat: sed non, si non tenetur ad dandam vel accommodandam, neque respondendum juxta mentem petentis, & ea mente juret, quod non habant illam, ad eam illi dandam aut accommodandam. Navarre. c. 12. n. 18. Bonacin. ibid. Idem. c. 8. n. 19. Lopez. cap. 37. p. 211.An qui jurat se non habere rem aliquam ab alio petitam, ut ab ea danda vel accommodanda se excuset, peccet? responderi enim debet, piccare si mens ejus verbis consonat: sed non, si non tenetur ad dandam vel accommodandam, neque respondendum juxta mentem petentis, & ea mente juret, quod non habant illam, ad eam illi dandam aut accommodandam. Navar. c. 12. n. 18. Bonacin. ibid. Idem. c. 8. n. 19. Lopez. cap. 37. p. 211.
(f)And this they maintain not only in this case, but as to all sins confessed. Quod si judex instat vel exigit juramentum a sacerdote, an per confessionem sciat aliquid de tali facto? Dico quod secundum S. Thom. & omnes doctores. Sacerdos si ab eo quaeratur de aliquo absente, an aliquid sciat, quod audivit in confessione: jurare potest se nescire illud: quia non scit illud in quantum homo, &c. Sylvest. v. confess. 3. n. 6. Sic Angelus. v. confess. 8. n. 4. secundum Scotum & Richardum, &c. Graft. l. r. c. 23. n. 2. For the Seal of Confession must not be violated; no, not to secure the soul of the penitent, or the life of a King, or a whole Commonwealth from temporal or spiritual destruction. Vid. ibid. n. 4. & 20. authors contra unum Altisiodorensem in Suarez. tom. 4. disp. 33. Sect. 1.And this they maintain not only in this case, but as to all sins confessed. Quod si judex instat vel exigit juramentum a sacerdote, an per confessionem sciat aliquid de tali facto? Dico quod secundum S. Thom. & omnes doctores. Sacerdos si ab eo quaeratur de aliquo absente, an aliquid sciat, quod audivit in confessione: jurare potest se nescire illud: quia non scit illud in quantum homo, &c. Sylvest. v. confess. 3. n. 6. Sic Angelus. v. confess. 8. n. 4. secundum Scotum & Richardum, &c. Graff. l. r. c. 23. n. 2. For the Seal of Confession must not be violated; no, not to secure the soul of the poenitent, or the life of a King, or a whole Commonwealth from temporal or spiritual destruction. Vid. ibid. n. 4. & 20. auctores contra unum Altisiodorensem in Suarez. tom. 4. disp. 33. Sect. 1.
(g)Quamvis juret se dicturum, quod scit, vere respondere potest se illa nescire absque perjurij metu, intelligendo intra se, illud se non ita scire ut detegere teneatur. Navarre. c. 18. n. 61. vid. cap. 17. n. 116.Quamvis juret se dicturum, quod scit, vere respondere potest se illa nescire absque perjurij metu, intelligendo intra se, illud se non ita scire ut detegere teneatur. Navar. c. 18. n. 61. vid. cap. 17. n. 116.
(*)This all the praying of the people (when they have reduced all their Religious acts to this) in Popery. All that the Church makes necessary, or leaves possible to them in public, which yet is no praying, otherwise, than one while he is at Paris, may be said to be praying at Rome; because he virtually wishes success to a Priest saying Mass there: Or then one in their Purgatory, may be said to be praying at the same time in Heaven; because he would have the supposed intercession of the Saints there, to be successful.This all the praying of the people (when they have reduced all their Religious acts to this) in Popery. All that the Church makes necessary, or leaves possible to them in publick, which yet is no praying, otherwise, than one while he is at Paris, may be said to be praying at Rome; because he virtually wishes success to a Priest saying Mass there: Or then one in their Purgatory, may be said to be praying at the same time in Heaven; because he would have the supposed intercession of the Saints there, to be successful.
(o)Haec satis est, licet omnium imperfectissima. Fill. tr. 5. n. 214. Suarez. Having, premised, that he believes, there is no dissension or difficulty amongst them concerning attention at the time of Mass: reckons after Aquinas the 3. sorts of attention and adds of the first. Haec attentio est infima omnium, tamen sufficiens: quia illa sa•is est, ut illa missae auditio seu praesentia sit bumana, moralis, & ex objecto religiosa. Tom. 3. disp. 88. sect. 3. This being sufficient, the Second and Third are more than needs: and yet in the third (this excluded as needless), he acknowledges all inward reverence and worship is included. Sub hac autom attentione ad Deum omnis interior reverentia & cultus, omnis oratio & petitio includitur, ut eleganter describit Gregorius 10. in c. decet. ibid.Haec satis est, licet omnium imperfectissima. Fill. tr. 5. n. 214. Suarez. Having, premised, that he believes, there is no dissention or difficulty amongst them concerning attention at the time of Mass: reckons after Aquinas the 3. sorts of attention and adds of the first. Haec attentio est infima omnium, tamen sufficiens: quia illa sa•is est, ut illa missae auditio seu praesentia sit bumana, moralis, & ex objecto religiosa. Tom. 3. disp. 88. sect. 3. This being sufficient, the Second and Third are more than needs: and yet in the third (this excluded as needless), he acknowledges all inward reverence and worship is included. Sub hac autom attentione ad Deum omnis interior reverentia & cultus, omnis oratio & petitio includitur, ut eleganter describit Gregorius 10. in c. decet. ibid.
, such a one, to which nature is forward.
Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 5. p. 277. n. 25. p. 274. n. 3.
(*)Observatio Diei Dominicae non est de jure Divino, sed Canonico, ut aiunt communiter Doctores—& consequenter posse consuetudine, vel humana potestate abrogari. Bonacin. Tom. 2. disp. 5. n. 4. p. 272. Sayrus & alij ibi.
Nec valet dicere inter ista servilia computari peccatum: quia hoc falsum est. Sylv. Sum. v. Dominic. n. 8.—nisi esset opus servile in festis prohibitum, quale non est peccatum juxta S. Thomam. in 3. sent. dist. 37. art. 5. q. 2. Navar. c. 6. n. 10. probatur a Cajetano & caeteris—quia opus peccati ut sic non est servile Suar. ibid n. 6.