Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The precept for observing Mass-days, as Sylvester (a)tells us, requires not the end, that is, waiting upon God, nor what is necessarily requisite thereto, but the hearing of Mass: Not waiting on God, but hearing Mass! These are distinct things, and disjoined in the sense of the Roman Doctors, the one is commanded, the other is not; so that they may duly hear Mass all their lives: and yet not wait on God one moment, the former they must do, the latter they are not obliged to regard, nor any thing that necessarily belongs to it. (b)Navarre asserts this, and would prove it by reason and the Authority of Aquinas herein generally followed. In short, if there be any worship required in the Mass it is merely external, and that disjoined from the inward service of the Soul, is, but a mere show or visor of worship, as they themselves confess in their lightsomer intervals. well, but is it worship in any sense? is there any thing Religious required of the people herein? for this they tell us it is enough, if it be an humane act, no more is enjoined, (c)the precept obligeth not, but to hear so, that it may be an humane act, saith (*)Soto, and (d)others, and if it suffice that it be a humane act, it needs not be Religious. Let it be deliberate, that is enough to make it a humane act; and then though there be no Religious ⟨p. 31⟩motion or intention in it, the precept is fulfilled. Sylvester confirms us herein, the precept (saith he) is given unto men, and therefore the work must not be the issue only of the imagination, which is common to us with Beasts, it must proceed from deliberation, which requires some attention. (a)So that there is something more required of one that goes to Mass than of a Beast; but that is before he comes there, if he advance but to it as a man, he may be excused even from humane acts, when he is at it, he needs neither exercise his understanding nor his senses. He needs not
or people not to know what they do; so reasonable is their service. The Latin makes it unintelligible enough, but if it were in a Language less known, if in
what is done, he may do all that is requisite in the Mass blindfold.
The precept for observing Masse-dayes, as Sylvester (a)tells us, requires not the end, that is, waiting upon God, nor what is necessarily requisite thereto, but the hearing of Masse: Not waiting on God, but hearing Masse! These are distinct things, and disjoyned in the sense of the Roman Doctors, the one is commanded, the other is not; so that they may duly hear Masse all their lives: and yet not wait on God one moment, the former they must do, the latter they are not obliged to regard, nor any thing that necessarily belongs to it. (b)Navar asserts this, and would prove it by reason and the Authority of Aquinas herein generally followed. In short, if there be any worship required in the Masse it is merely external, and that disjoyned from the inward service of the Soul, is, but a mere shew or vizour of worship, as they themselves confess in their lightsomer intervals. well, but is it worship in any sense? is there any thing Religious required of the people herein? for this they tell us it is enough, if it be an humane act, no more is enjoyned, (c)the precept obligeth not, but to hear so, that it may be an humane act, saith (*)Soto, and (d)others, and if it suffice that it be a humane act, it needs not be Religious. Let it be deliberate, that is enough to make it a humane act; and then though there be no Religious ⟨p. 31⟩motion or intention in it, the precept is fulfilled. Sylvester confirms us herein, the precept (saith he) is given unto men, and therefore the work must not be the issue only of the imagination, which is common to us with Beasts, it must proceed from deliberation, which requires some attention. (a)So that there is something more required of one that goes to Masse than of a Beast; but that is before he comes there, if he advance but to it as a man, he may be excused even from humane acts, when he is at it, he needs neither exercise his understanding nor his senses. He needs not (b)understand it, that is far from being a duty, they have made it impossible, it's no sin either for Priests (c)or people not to know what they do; so reasonable is their service. The Latin makes it unintelligible enough, but if it were in a Language less known, if in (d)Mosarabike or Greek, those who are present without any but their Mother-Tongue, fulfil the precept. As (e)Victorel tells us after Soto and others. He needs not see (f)what is done, he may do all that is requisite in the Masse blindfold.
(a)Non est simpliciter de sine i. e. ipsa vacatione circa Deum, vel necessario requisitis ad illam: sed de abstinentia a servilibus, & audition missa v. Dominic. n. 8.Non est simpliciter de sine i. e. ipsa vacatione circa Deum, vel necessario requisitis ad illam: sed de abstinentia a servilibus, & auditione missa v. Dominic. n. 8.
(b)Quamvis finis hujus praecepti sit, ut homo Deo vacet, ipsoque fruatur, & in eo quiescat, ut docuit. S. Thomas: quando tamen finis praecepti est aliud a re praecepta, tunc non cadit sub praeceptum sicut idem S. Thomas Communiter receptus. c. 13. n. 2. p. 198.Quamvis finis hujus praecepti sit, vt homo Deo vacet, ipsoque fruatur, & in eo quiescat, ut docuit. S. Thomas: quando tamen finis praecepti est aliud a re praecepta, tunc non cadit sub praeceptum sicut idem S. Thomas Communiter receptus. c. 13. n. 2. p. 198.
(c)Neque tale praeceptum obligat ad alium actum interiorem, quam ad illum qui propter exteriorem est necessarius, scil. vere audire missam ea attentione, ut sit actus humanus Soto. ibid. p. 51.
(*)Praeceptum audiendi missam non obligat nisi taliter, audire ut sit actus humanus. Idem. l. 10. q. 5. art. 5. p. 341.
(d)Sa• est, quod sit actus humanus. Jac. de Graff. l. 2. c. 34. n. 8. Satis est, sit actus humanus. Lopez. c. 52. p. 271.
(a)Praeceptum datur hominibus, ideoque oportet ut non procedat opus ex sola imaginatione quae communis nobis est cum bestiis sed ex deliberatione quae attentionem requirit, &c. v. hora n. 13. vid. Angelus v. hor. n. 27.
(b)Nemo teneatur ex praecepto audire, & minus intelligere verba sacerdotis, quia satis est vel ex longinquo missanti adesse Navarre. c. 21. n. 8.Nemo teneatur ex praecepto audire, & minus intelligere verba sacerdotis, quia satis est vel ex longinquo missanti adesse Navar. c. 21. n. 8.
(c)Clerici vel laici qui Divinis intersunt, si non intelligunt quae dicunt, non peccant Jac. de Graff. l. 2. c. 51. n. 12.
(d)Si audiret missam Mocaravem, compleret. Lopez. c. 42.
(e)Qui Graecam missam audiret, satisfaceret praecepto, etiam si non intelligeret. Addit. ad l. 6. c. 7. Toll. instr. vid. Bonacin. de Sacram. d. 4. q. ult. punct. 11. n. 12. & ibi plures.Qui Graecam missam audiret, satisfaceret praecepto, etiam si non intelligeret. Addit. ad l. 6. c. 7. Tol. instr. vid. Bonacin. de Sacram. d. 4. q. ult. punct. 11. n. 12. & ibi plures.
(f)Non est videre ea quae in missa aguntu•. Tolet. l. 6. c. 6.
He needs not hear it, as (g)Cajetane and others tells us, and this is much, he is enjoined only to hear Mass, and yet doth all that he is enjoined if he hear it not, if not one syllable of it reach his ears: it seems with them, to hear, is not to hear. Just by the same figure that they say they worship God, when in truth they do not worship him at all.
He needs not hear it, as (g)Cajetane and others tells us, and this is much, he is injoyn'd only to hear Masse, and yet doth all that he is injoyn'd if he hear it not, if not one syllable of it reach his ears: it seems with them, to hear, is not to hear. Just by the same figure that they say they worship God, when in truth they do not worship him at all.
(g)Utram autem audiatur vel non, utrum sit missa propria vel non, sub praecepto non cadit. Cajet. sum. v. Fest. p. 306. Navarre. c. 21. n. 8. supra de Graff. l. 2. c. 34. n. 8. Satis est praesentem esse missa, ad impletionem praecepti, licet non audiat sacerdotem secundum Sotum. Lopez. ibid. Bonacin. ibid. n. 20. ibi S. Autonin. Nagnus, Narar. Sylvest. Henrique Graft. Sot. Angelus Barthol. ab Augelo.Utram autem audiatur vel non, utrum sit missa propria vel non, sub praecepto non cadit. Cajet. sum. v. Fest. p. 306. Navar. c. 21. n. 8. supra de Graff. l. 2. c. 34. n. 8. Satis est praesentem esse missa, ad impletionem praecepti, licet non audiat sacerdotem secundum Sotum. Lopez. ibid. Bonacin. ibid. n. 20. ibi S. Autonin. Nagnus, Narar. Sylvest. Henrique Graff. Sot. Angelus Barthol. ab Augelo.
He needs not be sensible of any thing about it, to hear Mass saith Tolet is not to use any of his senses about what is done in the Mass. 1And if this be their worshipping God, a man may worship him as much as the Church of Rome requires, not only without Reverence and Devotion, without heart and affection: but without the use of sense or Reason. A Brute may do more at Mass, than they require their Catholics to do, no wonder that Church enjoins no Attention, Devotion or Reverence, nor counts them needful (as we have already manifested) for can there be any pretence to require these, when both sense and understanding are superseded? or can there be any thing that deserves the name of worship without these?
He needs not be sensible of any thing about it, to hear Masse saith Tolet is not to use any of his senses about what is done in the Masse. 1And if this be their worshipping God, a man may worship him as much as the Church of Rome requires, not only without Reverence and Devotion, without heart and affection: but without the use of sense or Reason. A Bruit may do more at Masse, than they require their Catholicks to do, no wonder that Church enjoyns no Attention, Devotion or Reverence, nor counts them needful (as we have already manifested) for can there be any pretence to require these, when both sense and understanding are superseded? or can there be any thing that deserves the name of worship without these?
1(h) Secundum Antoninum, non est necesse sentire & distinct audire verba missae, &c. Sylvest. v. miss. 2. n. 6. Audire Sacrum—non est uti aliquo sensu erga ea quae in missa guntur. l. 6. c. 6.(h) Secundum Antoninum, non est necesse sentire & distincte audire verba missae, &c. Sylvest. v. miss. 2. n. 6. Audire Sacrum—non est uti aliquo sensu erga ea quae in missa guntur. l. 6. c. 6.
They themselves cancel and overthrow all their own Pleas and pretences for their offering God any thing of worship in the Mass. For, they say, he doth not worship there, who is not present, and they cannot deny that in God's account he is absent whose mind is not present; and yet they justify (a)voluntary departures of mind and heart, when they should be worshipping, and those who would not seem to do this, do it really; when they conclude it no fault to employ themselves about other things when they are at Mass. They allow them (b)to say their hours (and so neglect the Mass, out of a neglect of their Divine office) or to recite what is enjoined them by way of Penance (and so prefer a punishment before the chief part of their Religion) ⟨p. 33⟩or other voluntary performances (so they may do what they will, rather than mind what they are about.) They know they cannot do two things at once, especially in Divine worship, which should take up the Soul. Though in their worshipping, where the Soul is not concerned they may attend a hundred acts at once; as much as they are obliged to mind the Mass, that is, actually not at all. They admit them also not only to (c)read, or write what they please; but also to sleep part of the time: so that they take not too long a Nap. It should not last above a third part, or half the Mass (for that is (d)pars notabilis) if it be but less than that, it passeth for nothing. (e)Or if they be too brisk to sleep, they may entertain themselves with familiar (f)chat. Medina (g)concludes, that he who is at Mass may spend the whole time in discourse about other things, Merchant affairs, or making Bargains, and yet fulfil the precept. They must it seems demean themselves at Mass altogether as Religiously, as at the Exchange; and no more is required. Suarez would have the Discourse neither so long, nor so serious, there should be some intermissions to attend. But what attention can be mean? He (with the rest) tells us, that to the Mass, less attention is requisite than to their Divine office; and to that office, he and they say, a virtual intention is sufficient, and this is the least of all that can be: So that to the Mass, less attention than the least of all, will suffice, and this to common apprehension is none at all. Others of them (as we saw before) will have no attention of mind needful for their office;
They themselves cancell and overthrow all their own Pleas and pretences for their offering God any thing of worship in the Masse. For, they say, he doth not worship there, who is not present, and they cannot deny that in God's account he is absent whose mind is not present; and yet they justifie (a)voluntary departures of mind and heart, when they should be worshipping, and those who would not seem to do this, do it really; when they conclude it no fault to employ themselves about other things when they are at Masse. They allow them (b)to say their hours (and so neglect the Masse, out of a neglect of their Divine office) or to recite what is injoyn'd them by way of Pennance (and so prefer a punishment before the chief part of their Religion) ⟨p. 33⟩or other voluntary performances (so they may do what they will, rather than mind what they are about.) They know they cannot do two things at once, especially in Divine worship, which should take up the Soul. Though in their worshipping, where the Soul is not concern'd they may attend a hundred acts at once; as much as they are obliged to mind the Masse, that is, actually not at all. They admit them also not only to (c)read, or write what they please; but also to sleep part of the time: so that they take not too long a Nap. It should not last above a third part, or half the Masse (for that is (d)pars notabilis) if it be but less than that, it passeth for nothing. (e)Or if they be too brisk to sleep, they may entertain themselves with familiar (f)chatt. Medina (g)concludes, that he who is at Masse may spend the whole time in discourse about other things, Merchant affairs, or making Bargains, and yet fulfil the precept. They must it seems demean themselves at Masse altogether as Religiously, as at the Exchange; and no more is required. Suarez would have the Discourse neither so long, nor so serious, there should be some intermissions to attend. But what attention can be mean? He (with the rest) tells us, that to the Masse, less attention is requisite than to their Divine office; and to that office, he and they say, a vertual intention is sufficient, and this is the least of all that can be: So that to the Masse, less attention than the least of all, will suffice, and this to common apprehension is none at all. Others of them (as we saw before) will have no attention of mind needful for their office;
(a)Sponte inter sacrum audiendum, vana cogitantem praecepto satisfacere—affirmant. Sylvest. Jo. Medina, Paludanus, Azor. in Victorel. addit. Toll. l. 6. c. 6.Sponte inter sacrum audiendum, vana cogitantem praecepto satisfacere—affirmant. Sylvest. Jo. Medina, Paludanus, Azor. in Victorel. addit. Tol. l. 6. c. 6.
(b)Vera resolutio est—posse quem eodem tempore satisfacere praecepto de audienda missa, & de dicendis horis Canonicis, aut alijs votis, juratis, vel in paenitentiam injunctis, modo non adeo uni rei intendat, ut alteri necessariam attentionem adimat, quod fieri potest, cum nemo teneatur ex praecepto audire, & minus intelligere verba sacerdotis. Navarre. c. 21. n. 8. Vid. Adrian. de satisfact. q. 7. Medina. tract. 2. de paenit. Cajetan. v. fest. Soto. 4. dist. 13. q. 2. art. 1. Lopez. c. 52. in Victorel. ibid. besides the Jesuits, Tolet. Suarez. S•. Azorius. Comitolus, &c. So they may hear 3 Masses at once, when said in one Church at the same time, and thereby satisfy, when their Penance is 3 Masses, as Bonacin. and in him Rodriquez, Graffius Scorpio, and others, de Sacrament disp. 4. q. ult. p. 11. n. 13.Vera resolutio est—posse quem eodem tempore satisfacere praecepto de audienda missa, & de dicendis horis Canonicis, aut alijs votis, juratis, vel in paenitentiam injunctis, modo non adeo uni rei intendat, ut alteri necessariam attentionem adimat, quod fieri potest, cum nemo teneatur ex praecepto audire, & minus intelligere verba sacerdotis. Navar. c. 21. n. 8. Vid. Adrian. de satisfact. q. 7. Medina. tract. 2. de paenit. Cajetan. v. fest. Soto. 4. dist. 13. q. 2. art. 1. Lopez. c. 52. in Victorel. ibid. besides the Jesuites, Tolet. Suarez. S•. Azorius. Comitolus, &c. So they may hear 3 Masses at once, when said in one Church at the same time, and thereby satisfie, when their Pennance is 3 Masses, as Bonacin. and in him Rodriquez, Graffius Scor•i•, and others, de Sacrament disp. 4. q. ult. p. 11. n. 13.
(c)Peccat mortaliter—in aliqua ejus part notabili colloquendo, pingendo, scribendo, dormiendo N•v. c. 21. n. 6. parvit as in omni muteria excusat a mortali n. 2.Peccat mortaliter—in aliqua ejus parte notabili colloquendo, pingendo, scribendo, dormiendo N•v. c. 21. n. 6. parvit as in omni muteria excusat a mortali n. 2.
and so with them, none will serve the Mass. Their Catholics may have their choice here, and satisfy their Devotion at Mass, either with the attention of this Doctor and some other late Authors, which is none at all: or (if this seem too much) with ⟨p. 34⟩that of their ancienter Doctors, which is less than none. And what must they attend to, who need neither hear, nor see, nor understand what is said, or done? It would puzzle one as subtle as himself, to tell one how he can attend to that, which is neither offered to his senses, nor his intellect. And therefore the Jesuit though he seems more strict, yet herein is less rational, than Medina, and not so consistent with himself or their common Doctrine. Also he would not have the Discourse at Mass so grave and serious, as that of Merchants, (h)it should be more light, more idle than that about Trade and Business. It seems the levity of the Stage suits with the Mass better than the seriousness of the Exchange. Answerably if their (i)Discourse be not decent, nor the Subject of it very modest, the Mass will comport with it, and the Churches precept will bear it without a breach. And no wonder, since it hath been the custom of that Church (as many of their (k)Writers inform us) to sing, not only profane, but f•l•hy Songs at high Mass; and that to the Organ, that the people might not only be refreshed by their own private immodest Discourse, but edified more effectually this way, by the louder voice of the Church. And how, we learn by a grave Cardinal (though little herein more rigid than others) who tells us, that the (m)hearers were thereby excited, to what was profane and filthy, as experience witnessed. And still notwithstanding any pretence of Reformation, tunes to the Organ at Divine service or Mass, though lascivious and very profane, will pass for a small fault (n)(in the judgment of those who seem most ⟨p. 35⟩severe in the case) if either the matter be slight, or the intention good, or the Actors inconsiderate. Here's provision enough, that the Scenes in their Mass may not be dull and heavy. Yet further they may laugh, and be pleasant, and when the Music (which sounds not always) doth it not, they may make themselves merry in the height of their worship. But this with some caution, (o)their talk, and laughter may break out into such noise, that possibly it may prove a sin of irreverence.
and so with them, none will serve the Masse. Their Catholicks may have their choice here, and satisfie their Devotion at Masse, either with the attention of this Doctor and some other late Authours, which is none at all: or (if this seem too much) with ⟨p. 34⟩that of their ancienter Doctors, which is less than none. And what must they attend to, who need neither hear, nor see, nor understand what is said, or done? It would puzle one as subtile as himself, to tell one how he can attend to that, which is neither offered to his senses, nor his intellect. And therefore the Jesuite though he seems more strict, yet herein is less rational, than Medina, and not so consistent with himself or their common Doctrine. Also he would not have the Discourse at Masse so grave and serious, as that of Merchants, (h)it should be more light, more idle than that about Trade and Business. It seems the levity of the Stage suits with the Masse better than the seriousness of the Exchange. Answerably if their (i)Discourse be not decent, nor the Subject of it very modest, the Masse will comport with it, and the Churches precept will bear it without a breach. And no wonder, since it hath been the custome of that Church (as many of their (k)Writers inform us) to sing, not only prophane, but f•l•hy Songs at high Masse; and that to the Organ, that the people might not only be refreshed by their own private immodest Discourse, but edified more effectually this way, by the lowder voice of the Church. And how, we learn by a grave Cardinal (though little herein more rigid than others) who tells us, that the (m)hearers were thereby excited, to what was prophane and filthy, as experience witnessed. And still notwithstanding any pretence of Reformation, tunes to the Organ at Divine service or Masse, though lascivious and very prophane, will pass for a small fault (n)(in the judgment of those who seem most ⟨p. 35⟩severe in the case) if either the matter be slight, or the intention good, or the Actors inconsiderate. Heres provision enough, that the Scenes in their Masse may not be dull and heavy. Yet further they may laugh, and be pleasant, and when the Musick (which sounds not alwayes) doth it not, they may make themselves merry in the height of their worship. But this with some caution,
(h)Qui voluntarie confabulatur—non satisfacere, nisi vel confabulatio esset discontinua, partim scil. loquendo, partim attendendo ut communiter fieri solet: vel non de re seria, sed levi, &c. Idem. ibid.
(i)Soto m 4. dist. 13. q. 2. art. 3. dicit quod licet indecentia sint colloquia inter audiendam missum, non tamen propterea fit transgressor praecepti. Ibid.
(k)Cornelius Agrippa, de vanit. Scient. cap. 17. Cajetan. Sum. v. Organ. Soto. de just. & jur. l. 10. q. 5. art. 2. p. 336. Navarre. Cap. 13. n. 87. Lopez. cap. 51. p. 263.Cornelius Agrippa, de vanit. Scient. cap. 17. Cajetan. Sum. v. Organ. Soto. de just. & jur. l. 10. q. 5. art. 2. p. 336. Navar. Cap. 13. n. 87. Lopez. cap. 51. p. 263.
(m)In cujus signum, audientes ex illo sono excitantur ad illa profana seu turpia, ut experientia testatur: ita quod non est inficiationi locus. Cajetan. ibid.
(n)Canticus—ratione soni quia est lascivus aut valde saecularis—potest esse venialis culpa, vel ratione materiae minimae, vel ex bona intentione vel inadvertentia ut Cajetanus dixit in Suar. de horis Can. l. 4. Cap. 13 n. 17. materia parva—si organista loco kyrie eleison, cantilenam profanam organo canat, Villalobus in Dian. v. Blasph. n. 4.
(o)Sed possent voces & risus in tantum prorumpere, quod esset peccatum irreverentiae & scandali; Lopez. c. 52. Soto in 4. dist. 13. quaest. 2. art. 1.
Here is some show of danger, but it will vanish presently; For if it should be a very loud extravagance, and the irreverence great; (p)yet great irreverence may, with them, be but a small fault, and they have the authority of a Pope to warrant this. Nor must this seem strange to us, since they will not have all contempt (q)of God criminal; that which is material may be venial; and it is not formal, unless besides the contempt of God, there be also an intention to contemn him. Such is the most solemn worship in the Roman-Church, and so is God worshipped amongst them; and that not by the unwarranted presumption of the profane multitude: but by the Rules and Conclusions of those, who direct their worship and guide their Consciences. Here we may see in the Mass the Religion of Roman-Catholics, they call it (r)the chiefest, the best part of their Religion, that we may not look for any thing better amongst them, nor any thing Religious, if it be not found here, yea it is all (better and worse) that the people are obliged to in public (and in private their Church doth not trouble them with any.) He that views it well, and believes he hath a Soul, and that there is a God; must have little, or no regard of either, if he do not bless himself from it, as a thing which hath nothing of Religion, but the name, and that merely usurped. A Religion which ⟨p. 36⟩needs nothing, by the Doctrine of its chief Professors, that is either Godly, or so good as humane: no regard of God at all, so much as in one thought of him; nor any act of Reason, yea or of sense either about any thing Religious or Divine; yet allows a free exercise of both, about that which is profane and irreligious. He that counts this Religion indeed, must stifle the common notions of Religion and Christianity: and he, that understanding it, makes choice thereof; had need first be very indifferent, whether he have any Religion, or none. Had the ancient Fathers talked after this senseless, lewd, extravagant rate, concerning the worship of God, how would Celsus, Porphyry, and Julian have Triumphed over them? nay, they might justly have challenged them to have instanced in any one that bore the name of a Philosopher, that ever treated of the worship of God with so little Reverence and Discretion.
Here is some shew of danger, but it will vanish presently; For if it should be a very loud extravagance, and the irreverence great; (p)yet great irreverence may, with them, be but a small fault, and they have the authority of a Pope to warrant this. Nor must this seem strange to us, since they will not have all contempt (q)of God criminal; that which is material may be venial; and it is not formal, unless besides the contempt of God, there be also an intention to contemn him. Such is the most solemn worship in the Roman-Church, and so is God worshipped amongst them; and that not by the unwarranted presumption of the prophane multitude: but by the Rules and Conclusions of those, who direct their worship and guide their Consciences. Here we may see in the Masse the Religion of Roman-Catholicks, they call it (r)the chiefest, the best part of their Religion, that we may not look for any thing better amongst them, nor any thing Religious, if it be not found here, yea it is all (better and worse) that the people are obliged to in publick (and in private their Church doth not trouble them with any.) He that views it well, and believes he hath a Soul, and that there is a God; must have little, or no regard of either, if he do not bless himself from it, as a thing which hath nothing of Religion, but the name, and that merely usurped. A Religion which ⟨p. 36⟩needs nothing, by the Doctrine of its chief Professors, that is either Godly, or so good as humane: no regard of God at all, so much as in one thought of him; nor any act of Reason, yea or of sense either about any thing Religious or Divine; yet allowes a free exercise of both, about that which is prophane and irreligious. He that counts this Religion indeed, must stifle the common notions of Religion and Christianity: and he, that understanding it, makes choice thereof; had need first be very indifferent, whether he have any Religion, or none. Had the ancient Fathers talk'd after this senseless, lewd, extravagant rate, concerning the worship of God, how would Celsus, Porphyrie, and Julian have Triumph'd over them? nay, they might justly have challeng'd them to have instanced in any one that bore the name of a Philosopher, that ever treated of the worship of God with so little Reverence and Discretion.
(p)Jac. de Graff. l. 2. c. 52. Supra.
(q)Contemptus ille qui continetur in irreverentia Dei per se, & ut talis est, non semper est formalis sed materialis, qui non semper sufficit ad malitiam mortalem. Nos autem loquimur de contemptu formali, quo ipsa Dei irreverentia intenditur, Suar. de juram. l. 3. c. 12. n. 4. & 6. vid. Cajetan. sum. v. Contempt. vid. Bonacin. de legibus disp. 2. q. 3. p. 5. n. 10. l. 15.
(r)In qua (sc. missa) praecipua pars Religionis nostrae, Bellar. de miss. lib. 1. cap. 1. p. 679.
Had such loose and wild Doctrines been broached by the first Teachers of Christianity, the Heathens needed not have raised so fierce a persecution against it, they might with ease have hissed it out of the World.
Had such loose and wild Doctrines been broach'd by the first Teachers of Christianity, the Heathens needed not have rais'd so fierce a persecution against it, they might with ease have hiss'd it out of the World.
But this is not the worst, they encourage that in the Mass which they cannot but condemn as wicked; and maintain that the precept for hearing Mass may be satisfied by such wickedness. Melchior Canos to this Objection (that the Command of God, or the Church, cannot be fulfilled by sin) answers according to the opinion commonly maintained amongst them. (a)That he is no Transgressor of the precept, who to the Act enjoined, and good, in its kind, adds something sinful. He supposeth that the Act commanded by the Church, is some way good; but withal, that the precept may be satisfied, though it be done wickedly, and that by their common Doctrine. Whether the circumstances may be venially or mortally wicked, he saith not, but leaves us to understand it of either. Dominicus a Soto, tells us expressly, that though what is added to the Act (b)enjoined, be a mortal wickedness, yet the Precept may thereby be satisfied substantially. With these Divines of ⟨p. 37⟩greatest reputation amongst them, concurs Navarre (c)no less renowned (and none of them Jesuits) the opinion of Antoninus (which he is disproving) presupposeth, saith he, that by a sinful Act, especially if it be a mortal sin, the Command of the Church cannot be fulfilled; but that this is false we have largely proved. He would have us know that he hath fully demonstrated, that the Precept for hearing Mass, may be entirely accomplished by deadly crimes. This is the judgment of the most eminent Doctors amongst them, such as are not of the Society; and (if they will believe their famous Bishop of the Canaries) the common Doctrine in the Roman Church: and by this, the world may judge what a Church it is, what her Religion, what her Worship, what her Precepts for it are: When all that she requires for that worship, which is the principal part of her Religion, may be satisfied by acts of wickedness, such as are mortal and damnable to the Worshippers, and most (of all others) dishonourable to God, whom they pretend to worship: And let those that are seduced, or may be tempted by Seducers, seriously consider, whether they can wisely trust their souls to such a conduct, or be safe in such a communion, where there is no more tenderness for the salvation of souls, than to be satisfied with such a worshipping of God as will confessedly damn them.
But this is not the worst, they encourage that in the Mass which they cannot but condemn as wicked; and maintain that the precept for hearing Mass may be satisfied by such wickedness. Melchior Canos to this Objection (that the Command of God, or the Church, cannot be fulfilled by sin) answers according to the opinion commonly maintained amongst them. (a)That he is no Transgressor of the precept, who to the Act enjoyn'd, and good, in its kind, adds something sinful. He supposeth that the Act commanded by the Church, is some way good; but withal, that the precept may be satisfied, though it be done wickedly, and that by their common Doctrine. Whether the circumstances may be venially or mortally wicked, he saith not, but leaves us to understand it of either. Dominicus a Sato, tells us expresly, that though what is added to the Act (b)enjoyned, be a mortal wickedness, yet the Precept may thereby be satisfied substantially. With these Divines of ⟨p. 37⟩greatest reputation amongst them, concurs Navarre (c)no less renowned (and none of them Jesuites) the opinion of Antoninus (which he is disproving) presupposeth, saith he, that by a sinful Act, especially if it be a mortal sin, the Command of the Church cannot be fulfilled; but that this is false we have largely proved. He would have us know that he hath fully demonstrated, that the Precept for hearing Mass, may be intirely accomplished by deadly crimes. This is the judgment of the most eminent Doctors amongst them, such as are not of the Society; and (if they will believe their famous Bishop of the Canaries) the common Doctrine in the Roman Church: and by this, the world may judge what a Church it is, what her Religion, what her Worship, what her Precepts for it are: When all that she requires for that worship, which is the principal part of her Religion, may be satisfied by acts of wickedness, such as are mortal and damnable to the Worshippers, and most (of all others) dishonourable to God, whom they pretend to worship: And let those that are seduced, or may be tempted by Seducers, seriously consider, whether they can wisely trust their souls to such a conduct, or be safe in such a communion, where there is no more tenderness for the salvation of souls, than to be satisfied with such a worshiping of God as will confessedly damn them.
(a)Nos cum communi opinione in praesentia teneamus, non esse transgressorem praecepti, qui actui bono ex genere suo quem lex praecipiebat, apponit aliquam malam circumstantiam, Relect, de paenit, part. 4. p. 936. vid. Bonacinum de legibus disp. 1. q. 1. punct. 9. n. 1. ibi. S. Thomas, Soto, Navarre, Medina, & plures alij.Nos cum communi opinione in praesentia teneamus, non esse transgressorem praecepti, qui actui bono ex genere suo quem lex praecipiebat, apponit aliquam malam circumstantiam, Relect, de paenit, part. 4. p. 936. vid. Bonacinum de legibus disp. 1. q. 1. punct. 9. n. 1. ibi. S. Thomas, Soto, Navar, Medina, & plures alij.
(b)Quamvis simul habeat propositum aliud mortal, satisfaciet praecepto quantum ad substantiam. Ibid. l. 10. q. 5. a. 5.Quamvis simul habeat propositum aliud mortale, satisfaciet praecepto quantum ad substantiam. Ibid. l. 10. q. 5. a. 5.
(c)Non tamen est tenendum illud Antonini—quia praesupponit, malo praesertim mortali non posse adimpleri praeceptum, quod esse falsum, late probavimus. c. 21. n. 7.
Sect. 3. Thus much for the manner of their public worship, all of it, who ever amongst them it concerns; whereby it appears that they count it not necessary that God should have any real worship from them. This will be further manifest by what they teach concerning the end of it.
Sect. 3. Thus much for the manner of their publick worship, all of it, who ever amongst them it concerns; whereby it appears that they count it not necessary that God should have any real worship from them. This will be further manifest by what they teach concerning the end of it.
They maintain, that it is lawful for their Clergy and Monastics too (who profess perfection) to serve God for their own ends, viz. to get preferment, or compass a dignity, or gain some worldly advantage, and so to prostitute the Honour and Worship of God to such low, earthly, sordid designs, as Religious persons would never appear to own; but that Irreligion is grown too monstrously big for its visor. He that riseth to their morning Service for this end, that he may have his daily dividend, if it be not principally for this, he sins not. So their glossa celeberrima, the two Popes Urbane & Caelestine determine that it is lawful ⟨p. 38⟩for their Clergy to serve God in their Churches for this design, and hope to get Ecclesiastical dignity in (d)Navarre. But then this great Casuist, (of so high esteem amongst them, that he was sent for from Spain to Rome, to give advice and direction to the old Gentleman there, that cannot err) understands (after (a)Aquinas & Jo. Major. as he pretends) the principal end to be something else than others do. It is not that which so much moves the Agent, as that without it he would not be drawn to act by any other end and accordingly he will have the premised testimony to be understood. (b)So that one of their Perfectionists, who riseth to morning prayer for this end, that he may have his dividend; & would not stir (c)out of his Bed to attend the Worship of God for God's sake, or any other end beseeming a Religious person, if the consideration of his daily allowance did not rouse him: yet he serves God so well herein, as that he is sinless, and not so much as venially tainted. Likewise the Clergy who address themselves to the Worship of God, moved thereto, more by hopes to gain preferment and dignity than any respect to God, yet they sin not. That is, they worship God well enough, though they respect themselves and their own ends more than him: or which is all one, though they serve themselves rather than God whom they are to worship. They are all concerned to maintain this: for he tells them, if (d)such acts of Virtue, or Worship, were Vicious, all their acts in a manner would be stark naught, ⟨p. 39⟩since there are extremely few amongst them that are purely done for God. They are a Church in the mean time that worthily profess godliness, since nothing is done, or needs be done by them, even in the worship of God, for him, so much as for themselves;
They maintain, that it is lawful for their Clergy and Monasticks too (who profess perfection) to serve God for their own ends, viz. to get preferment, or compass a dignity, or gain some wordly advantage, and so to prostitute the Honour and Worship of God to such low, earthly, sordid designes, as Religious persons would never appear to own; but that Irreligion is grown too monstrously big for its vizard. He that riseth to their morning Service for this end, that he may have his daily devidend, if it be not principally for this, he sins not. So their glossa celeberrima, the two Popes Ʋrbane & Caelestine determine that it is lawful ⟨p. 38⟩for their Clergy to serve God in their Churches for this design, and hope to get Ecclesiastical dignity in (d)Navarre. But then this great Casuist, (of so high esteem amongst them, that he was sent for from Spain to Rome, to give advice and direction to the old Gentleman there, that cannot erre) understands (after (a)Aquinas & Jo. Major. as he pretends) the principal end to be something else than others do. It is not that which so much moves the Agent, as that without it he would not be drawn to act by any other end and accordingly he will have the premised testimony to be understood. (b)So that one of their Perfectionists, who riseth to morning prayer for this end, that he may have his dividend; & would not stir (c)out of his Bed to attend the Worship of God for God's sake, or any other end beseeming a Religious person, if the consideration of his daily allowance did not rouse him: yet he serves God so well herein, as that he is sinless, and not so much as venially tainted. Likewise the Clergy who address themselves to the Worship of God, moved thereto, more by hopes to gain preferment and dignity than any respect to God, yet they sin not. That is, they worship God well enough, though they respect themselves and their own ends more than him: or which is all one, though they serve themselves rather than God whom they are to worship. They are all concerned to maintain this: for he tells them, if (d)such acts of Vertue, or Worship, were Vicious, all their acts in a manner would be stark naught, ⟨p. 39⟩since there are extremely few amongst them that are purely done for God. They are a Church in the mean time that worthily profess godliness, since nothing is done, or needs be done by them, even in the worship of God, for him, so much as for themselves;
(d)Glossa illa celeberrima ait peccare quidem eum, qui surgit ad matutinas preces principaliter propter distributiones quotidianas, non autem illum, qui surgit principaliter ut Deo inserviat, & minus principaliter, & secundario, ut eas lucretur—Urbanus Papa & Coelestinus determinarunt licere clericis servire Deo in Ecclesijs ob spem ascendendi ad dignitates illarum. Imo Gelasius dixit eos ad hunc ascensum spe maioris commodi compellendos—Glossa recepta dicit express per illum textum, licere clerico servire in Ecclesia ad quaerendam aliquam dignitatem, modo principaliter ob id non serviat. &c. cap. 23. n. 101.Glossa illa celeberrima ait peccare quidem eum, qui surgit ad matutinas preces principaliter propter distributiones quotidianas, non autem illum, qui surgit principaliter ut Deo inserviat, & minus principaliter, & secundario, ut eas lucretur—Urbanus Papa & Coelestinus determinarunt licere clericis servire Deo in Ecclesijs ob spem ascendendi ad dignitates illarum. Imo Gelasius dixit eos ad hunc ascensum spe maioris commodi compellendos—Glossa recepta dicit expresse per illum textum, licere clerico servire in Ecclesia ad quaerendam aliquam dignitatem, modo principaliter ob id non serviat. &c. cap. 23. n. 101.
(a)Ut probavimus non est bona definitio illa Bartoli, qua definit causam principalem esse causam qua cessante cessat effectus id. ibid. Ut aliquis finis sit principalis non sufficit quod ille non fieret sine illo, sed oportet, quod pluris vel tanti aestimetur, ac alius finis, propter quem ille fit. id. c. 17. n. 209. &c. 20. n. 11. p. 459.
(b)Per supra dictos textus & glossas, quae habent locum etiam in his, qui non servirent, Ecclesijs vel praelatis, nisi sperarent beneficia. c. 23. n. 101.
(c)Surgens ad matutinas ob distributiones, alias non surrecturus. ibid.
(d)Alioqui enim omnes fere actus nostri essent vitiosi; quia paucissimi fiunt pure propter solum Deum, & solam virtutem, &c. ibid. p. 590.
and indeed Sylvester deals ingenuously when he tells us plainly, without the cover of any pitiful shift (e)that it is no sin to serve God principally for their own profit.
and indeed Sylvester deals ingenuously when he tells us plainly, without the cover of any pittiful shift (e)that it is no sin to serve God principally for their own profit.
(e)Licitum est etiam aliquid operari principaliter propter propriam u•ilitatem. Sum. v. charitas. n. 5. and that of Navarre is plain enough, diximus quod falsum est, esse mortale facere ordinata ad cultum principaliter ob bona temporalia cap. 23. n. 14. p. 555. &c. 13. n. 14. Solet circa hanc voluntatem inquiry, an debeat esse honesta; & specialiter, an voluntas confitendi propter humanum motivum, scilicet inanem gloriam, vel commodum temporale, sufficiat ad valorem Sacramenti: nam in caeteris Sacramentis certum est sufficere; in hoc—affirmant Soto. dist. 18. q. 3. art. 3. Navarre. c. 21. n. 40. Negant enim illam voluntatem ex illo fine, esse peccatum mortale, sed veniale tantum: quod non repugnat valori Sacramenti. Quae sententia per se loquendo, vera mihi videtur. Suarez. tom. 4. disp. 20. sect. 3. n. 4. p. 273.Licitum est etiam aliquid operari principaliter propter propriam u•ilitatem. Sum. v. charitas. n. 5. and that of Navar is plain enough, diximus quod falsum est, esse mortale facere ordinata ad cultum principaliter ob bona temporalia cap. 23. n. 14. p. 555. &c. 13. n. 14. Solet circa hanc voluntatem inquiri, an debeat esse honesta; & specialiter, an voluntas confitendi propter humanum motivum, scilicet inanem gloriam, vel commodum temporale, sufficiat ad valorem Sacramenti: nam in caeteris Sacramentis certum est sufficere; in hoc—affirmant Soto. dist. 18. q. 3. art. 3. Navar. c. 21. n. 40. Negant enim illam voluntatem ex illo fine, esse peccatum mortale, sed veniale tantum: quod non repugnat valori Sacramenti. Quae sententia per se loquendo, vera mihi videtur. Suarez. tom. 4. disp. 20. sect. 3. n. 4. p. 273.
Moreover, and yet worse, They teach it is no sin to worship God for an end that is in it self a sin, if it be not principally intended, it is lawful by their doctrine to Preach, to Pray, say Mass, &c. for praise of men (though Christ will have those that designed it as (f)Cajetane notes, even when he is excusing this to have no better reward:) or for vain glory (though they reckon this amongst (a)capital crimes) only he must not make so wicked a thing his chief end, and then he is innocent enough, though sin against God be his design in worshipping him. 3It is no sin, yea, it is meritorious to do these things, viz. to Preach, and say Mass, and to do other things of like nature principally for God, and secondarily for vain glory and praise of men, aptly directed as our end. Thus Navarre determines after their great Saint and Doctor, Aquinas. Now he had taught us before, that these acts of worship are but done secondarily (and so unlawfully) for these criminal ends when they so much sway a man, as that he would not worship God unless he were excited by them; and that vain glory is not his principal end, even when he is so much influenced thereby, as that he would not Pray or Preach, &c. ⟨p. 40⟩if this were not his motive, this in the judgment of others, as he acknowledgeth is to make sin his principal end, and to advance wickedness above God, even when he pretends to worship him. But let us not interrupt this great Doctor in his way, it is soul enough as himself makes it; for hereby a man may serve God, and that meritoriously (after the Roman mode) though he never would let him have an act of worship, if pride and vain glory did not set him a-work. He would never Pray or Preach, &c. if he were not more moved to it by sin, and out of regard to some wickedness, than out of respect to God.
Moreover, and yet worse, They teach it is no sin to worship God for an end that is in it self a sin, if it be not principally intended, it is lawful by their doctrine to Preach, to Pray, say Mass, &c. for praise of men (though Christ will have those that design'd it as (f)Cajetane notes, even when he is excusing this to have no better reward:) or for vain glory (though they reckon this amongst (a)capital crimes) only he must not make so wicked a thing his chief end, and then he is innocent enough, though sin against God be his design in worshipping him. 3It is no sin, yea, it is meritorious to do these things, viz. to Preach, and say Mass, and to do other things of like nature principally for God, and secondarily for vain glory and praise of men, aptly directed as our end. Thus Navarre determins after their great Saint and Doctor, Aquinas. Now he had taught us before, that these acts of worship are but done secondarily (and so unlawfully) for these criminal ends when they so much sway a man, as that he would not worship God unless he were excited by them; and that vain glory is not his principal end, even when he is so much influenced thereby, as that he would not Pray or Preach, &c. ⟨p. 40⟩if this were not his motive, this in the judgment of others, as he acknowledgeth is to make sin his principal end, and to advance wickedness above God, even when he pretends to worship him. But let us not interrupt this great Doctor in his way, it is soul enough as himself makes it; for hereby a man may serve God, and that meritoriously (after the Roman mode) though he never would let him have an act of worship, if pride and vain glory did not set him a-work. He would never Pray or Preach, &c. if he were not more moved to it by sin, and out of regard to some wickedness, than out of respect to God.
3(b) Nullum autem peccatum immo meritum est facere illa (viz concionare, missam celebrare, precari & id genus alia) principaliter propter Deum, & secundario propter vanam gloriam, vel laudem humanam, in finem aptum relatum per ibi dicta post S. Thomam. c. 23. n. 13.
Further yet: They hold it is but a venial fault to worship God principally for vain glory, and other designs of like quality. 1Aquinas, as he is represented by Sylvester determining that it is no mortal sin to serve God principally for vain glory; if that be ones chief end actually only, and not both habitually and actually. 2Sylvester declares it as his own persuasion, that it is both against Aquinas and the Truth, to hold it is a mortal sin, when those things which are ordained for the glory of God, are used principally for a mans own glory. He instances in the Sacraments, saying Mass, the Scriptures and Preaching.
Further yet: They hold it is but a venial fault to worship God principally for vain glory, and other designes of like quality. 1Aquinas, as he is represented by Sylvester determining that it is no mortal sin to serve God principally for vain glory; if that be ones chief end actually only, and not both habitually and actually. 2Sylvester declares it as his own perswasion, that it is both against Aquinas and the Truth, to hold it is a mortal sin, when those things which are ordained for the glory of God, are used principally for a mans own glory. He instances in the Sacraments, saying Mass, the Scriptures and Preaching.
1(c) Ex quo infert quod mortale est praedicare aut missam celebrare, & hujusmodi, propter inanem gloriam, quod verum est solum ut dicit S. Thom. Si in ea ponatur ultimus finis, ita quod ipsa intenditur principaliter actu & habitu, secus si actu tantum, ut iste intendit Sum. v. vana gloria. n. 2.
2(d) Ex quibus patet, quod Sum. Ang. contra. S. Thom. & veritatem dicit, quod est mortale, quando ea quae ordinata sunt ad Dei gloriam, facit ad gloriam suam, ut Sacramenta & Scripturae Sacrae. ibid.
(a)Cardinal Cajetan declares himself thus in one instant, which involves the rest: It is but venial to Preach for vain glory, or hopes of a gainful alms, signifying, that he means such vain glory as Christ condemned in the Pharisees, when he told them this was like to be their reward.
(a)Cardinal Cajetan declares himself thus in one instant, which involves the rest: It is but venial to Preach for vain glory, or hopes of a gainful almes, signifying, that he means such vain glory as Christ condemned in the Pharisees, when he told them this was like to be their reward.
(a)Veniale autem si vane propter gloriam aut spem quaestuariae eleemosynae praedicaretur, receperunt enim mercedem suam. Sum. v. praedicat. p. 480.
(b)Navarre affirms, that to Preach, or say Mass, or Pray, and such things as are instituted for the Honour and Worship of God, and the Salvation of Souls, for vain glory principally, or more than principally, is but a venial fault; and that such as gain-say this (who are but two) have been confuted by others, and by himself after them. These are the chief of their Doctors, whom the rest commonly follow, (and none of them Jesuits) who unanimously assert this. Now it is not necessary with them, for any man to avoid a venial sin, since by their doctrine a world of them can never damn a man: and therefore it is not necessary for any Papist, to worship God otherwise, than principally for vain glory, or ends equally criminal, i. e. it is not needful for them to worship him at all; for no man can imagine, that he is worshipped, when he is in the highest degree dishonoured and affronted: and what greater affront can be put upon him, than under a pretence of worship to debase the great God, and thrust him lower in our designs, not only than our selves and earthly trifles, but lower than sin, the vilest thing on Earth, yea, or in Hell? and this is evidently done when vain glory (a capital sin) hath the preeminence of God in addresses to him, and is regarded as principal: when the Lord of Heaven and earth hath no regard at all, or only in a lower place. It is not worshipping of God, but a horrid impiety, for men to serve themselves instead of God; but more intolerably impious to worship sin: and that hath the worship and is honoured in the place of God, which hath the highest advancement, and is principal in Religious addresses; yet no better than this is all the worship, which by the Roman Doctrine is necessary from their Catholics.
(b)Navarre affirmes, that to Preach, or say Mass, or Pray, and such things as are instituted for the Honour and Worship of God, and the Salvation of Souls, for vain glory principally, or more than principally, is but a venial fault; and that such as gain-say this (who are but two) have been confuted by others, and by himself after them. These are the chief of their Doctors, whom the rest commonly follow, (and none of them Jesuits) who unanimously assert this. Now it is not necessary with them, for any man to avoyd a venial sin, since by their doctrine a world of them can never damn a man: and therefore it is not necessary for any Papist, to worship God otherwise, than principally for vain glory, or ends equally criminal, i. e. it is not needful for them to worship him at all; for no man can imagine, that he is worshipped, when he is in the highest degree dishonoured and affronted: and what greater affront can be put upon him, than under a pretence of worship to debase the great God, and thrust him lower in our designs, not only than our selves and earthly trifles, but lower than sin, the vilest thing on Earth, yea, or in Hell? and this is evidently done when vain glory (a capital sin) hath the preheminence of God in addresses to him, and is regarded as principal: when the Lord of Heaven and earth hath no regard at all, or only in a lower place. It is not worshipping of God, but a horrid impiety, for men to serve themselves instead of God; but more intolerably impious to worship sin: and that hath the worship and is honoured in the place of God, which hath the highest advancement, and is principal in Religious addresses; yet no better than this is all the worship, which by the Roman Doctrine is necessary from their Catholicks.
(b)Peccat, qui res principaliter institutas ob honorem Dei & cultum ejus, & salutem animarum, principalius, vel aeque principaliter ob vanam gloriam facit: quale est concionari, missam celebrare, precari & id genus alia secundum Abulensem & Angelum, quod post […] efficaciter confutavimus, dicentes esse solum veniale. c. 34. n. 13. p. 554. Dicendum est intentionem bonam simpliciter non esse de substantia orationis vocalis. Itaque si quis habet intentionem orandi, & exilla proferet ve ba de se sufficientia ad orandum, & consentanea laudi, vel reverentiae divinae, licet hoc faciat ex intentione laudis humanae, vel alicujus commodi temporalis in illud principaliter intuendo, vere orat, quamvis non bene orat. Haec est communis sententia.—Talis oratio est sufficiens ad implendum praeceptum ecclesiasticum recitandi horas, ut omnes fatentur. Suar. de orat. l. 3. cap. 3. n. 5.Peccat, qui res principaliter institutas ob honorem Dei & cultum ejus, & salutem animarum, principalius, vel aeque principaliter ob vanam gloriam facit: quale est concionari, missam celebrare, precari & id genus alia secundum Abulensem & Angelum, quod post 〈…〉 efficaciter confutavimus, dicentes esse solum veniale. c. 34. n. 13. p. 554. Dicendum est intentionem bonam simpliciter non esse de substantia orationis vocalis. Itaque si quis habet intentionem orandi, & exilla proferet ve ba de se sufficientia ad orandum, & consentanea laudi, vel reverentiae divinae, licet hoc faciat ex intentione laudis humanae, vel alicujus commodi temporalis in illud principaliter intuendo, vere orat, quamvis non bene orat. Haec est communis sententia.—Talis oratio est sufficiens ad implendum praeceptum ecclesiasticum recitandi horas, ut omnes fatentur. Suar. de orat. l. 3. cap. 3. n. 5.
In short, whereas by their Doctrine of non-attention formerly examined, it is so evident that they discharge themselves from all real worship, as they have no colour to hide it, no shift to evade it; but a supposal of some previous intention to serve God, when they are addressing themselves to their service: this their last reserve they themselves ruin, by their Doctrine concerning the end of worship. For they teach (besides what is premised) that a man who comes to Mass, or Divine service; with a purpose not to worship God, but to serve his Lusts, doth satisfy the Precept. (a)We are not obliged (saith Soto) to hear Mass but only so, that it may be a humane act, which it may be, though there be a sinister intention in it. Yea though the thing intended be a sin, and that highly criminal, for he adds (b)if one attend prayer, though he do it for vain glory (that is a small matter to stick at) yea though it be with a purpose mortally wicked, yet he fulfils the precept substantially. Such are the commands of the Church of Rome for her most Sacred worship, they may be fully satisfied by deadly wickedness, there needs no purity of heart or hand for her Devotions; a design damnably evil will serve the turn. 3That of Antoninus (saith Navarre) is not to be maintained, that he doth not satisfy the precept, who comes to Church principally to look on a handsome Woman, or to talk with her, or for any other sinful thing. If a man in going to Mass, designs to satisfy his curiosity, or his lust, or any thing else which is wicked: that Church is so good natured, she will be satisfied with it, and think ⟨p. 43⟩her precept for worship well observed, and you must believe (if you can) that the is a good Christian-Church, that will have Christ worshipped at this rate. He adds reason for it, a (d)man may come to Church for a wicked end, and yet hear Mass well enough there.
In short, whereas by their Doctrine of non-attention formerly exaamined, it is so evident that they discharge themselves from all real worship, as they have no colour to hide it, no shift to evade it; but a supposal of some praevious intention to serve God, when they are addressing themselves to their service: this their last reserve they themselves ruine, by their Doctrine concerning the end of worship. For they teach (besides what is premised) that a man who comes to Masse, or Divine service; with a purpose not to worship God, but to serve his Lusts, doth satisfie the Precept. (a)We are not obliged (saith Soto) to hear Masse but only so, that it may be a humane act, which it may be, though there be a sinister intention in it. Yea though the thing intended be a sin, and that highly criminal, for he adds (b)if one attend prayer, though he do it for vain glory (that is a small matter to stick at) yea though it be with a purpose mortally wicked, yet he fulfills the precept substantially. Such are the commands of the Church of Rome for her most Sacred worship, they may be fully satisfied by deadly wickedness, there needs no purity of heart or hand for her Devotions; a design damnably evil will serve the turn. 3That of Antoninus (saith Navarre) is not to be maintained, that he doth not satisfie the precept, who comes to Church principally to look on a handsome Woman, or to talk with her, or for any other sinful thing. If a man in going to Masse, designs to satisfie his curiosity, or his lust, or any thing else which is wicked: that Church is so good natur'd, she will be satisfied with it, and think ⟨p. 43⟩her precept for worship well observed, and you must believe (if you can) that the is a good Christian-Church, that will have Christ worshipped at this rate. He adds reason for it, a (d)man may come to Church for a wicked end, and yet hear Masse well enough there.
(a)Praeceptum audiendi missam non obligat, nisi taliter audire, ut sit actus humanus: qualis esse potest, etiamsi aliud simul ad sit sinistrum propositum. de just. & jur. l. 10. q. 5. art. 5.
(b)Quod si quis attente oret, quamvis id faciat adjunctam habens vanam gloriam, imo quamvis simul habeat propositum aliud mortal, satisfaciet praecepto, quantum ad substantiam: ita ut non teneatur officium iterare. Ibid.Quod si quis attente oret, quamvis id faciat adjunctam habens vanam gloriam, imo quamvis simul habeat propositum aliud mortale, satisfaciet praecepto, quantum ad substantiam: ita ut non teneatur officium iterare. Ibid.
3(c) Non tamen est tenendum illud, S. Antonini, scilicet, eum qui ecclesiam a lit princi• liter ad videndum, aut alloquendum faeminam pulchram, aut ob aliud quodvis illi•i• non satisfacere huic praecepto. cap. 21. n. 7. with him concurs Medina. Addendum […] est pravam intentionem adjunctam voluntati audiendi missam, non esse contrariam impletioni hujus praecepti. Itaque quamvis quis eat ad ecclesiam ex libidinosa intentione videndi faeminam, vel etiamsi officio missae cum eadem intentione ass•stat, tamen si non excludat voluntatem implendi hoc praeceptum; & sufficientur sit attentus, implet illud. It a Medina in Suarez. tom. 3. desp. 88. Sect. 3.(c) Non tamen est tenendum illud, S. Antonini, scilicet, eum qui ecclesiam a lit princi• liter ad videndum, aut alloquendum faeminam pulchram, aut ob aliud quodvis illi•i• non satisfacere huic praecepto. cap. 21. n. 7. with him concurs Medina. Addendum 〈…〉 est pravam intentionem adjunctam voluntati audiendi missam, non esse contrariam impletioni hujus praecepti. Itaque quamvis quis eat ad ecclesiam ex libidinosa intentione videndi faeminam, vel etiamsi officio missae cum eadem intentione ass•stat, tamen si non excludat voluntatem implendi hoc praeceptum; & sufficientur sit attentus, implet illud. It a Medina in Suarez. tom. 3. desp. 88. Sect. 3.
(d)Potest quis malo fine ecclesiam adire, & been in ea missam audire. Ibid. p. 469.
(*)Bonacina, instances in several sorts of wickedness, whereby the command for worship may be fulfilled. This is one amongst the rest, if a man go to Church on purpose to gaze on, or to lust after Women lecherously, he satisfies the precept, and for the general Rule vouches not only Sotus, Navarre, Medina, and others of greatest Reputation in their Church; but also their Angelical Saint Thomas.
(*)Bonacina, instances in several sorts of wickedness, whereby the command for worship may be fulfilled. This is one amongst the rest, if a man go to Church on purpose to gaze on, or to lust after Women lecherously, he satisfies the precept, and for the general Rule vouches not only Sotus, Navar, Medina, and others of greatest Reputation in their Church; but also their Angelical Saint Thomas.
(*)Qui ecclesiam adit causa videndi, vel etiam concupiscendi libidinose faeminas—satisfacit. De legib. Disp. 1. q. 1. p. 9. n. 1.
I need not censure these things, let those that are impartial consider the premises, and see if this be not their sense, that the people in the Papacy, by its order, do not, or are not obliged to give God any real worship in public: and by their leaders, are taught and encouraged instead of worship, to present him with gross wickedness. If the measures of Religion may be best taken by its worship, what can any indifferent person judge of Popery; where a service so palpably irreligious, is the best and the most excellent worship they have? if this were duly considered, I think it alone, might be sufficient to reduce those, that are deluded; and to secure those against Temptations, who are not yet ensnared.
I need not censure these things, let those that are impartial consider the premises, and see if this be not their sense, that the people in the Papacy, by its order, do not, or are not obliged to give God any real worship in publick: and by their leaders, are taught and encouraged instead of worship, to present him with grosse wickedness. If the measures of Religion may be best taken by its worship, what can any indifferent person judge of Popery; where a service so palpably irreligious, is the best and the most excellent worship they have? if this were duely considered, I think it alone, might be sufficient to reduce those, that are deluded; and to secure those against Temptations, who are not yet ensnared.
Sect. 4. There is another public exercise which Christ makes as necessary, as any Evangelical service what-ever, and that is Preaching and hearing the word of God. But the Romanists are not of his mind, in this. (e)The Mass is commanded, but not Preaching saith Sylvester, and he one of the order of Predicants. Accordingly hearing Mass is commanded, but hearing Sermons is only matter of Advice (saith (f)another) which may be neglected without imputation of sin, and if observed, is an act of Supererogation.
Sect. 4. There is another publick exercise which Christ makes as necessary, as any Evangelical service what-ever, and that is Preaching and hearing the word of God. But the Romanists are not of his mind, in this. (e)The Masse is commanded, but not Preaching saith Sylvester, and he one of the order of Predicants. Accordingly hearing Masse is commanded, but hearing Sermons is only matter of Advice (saith (f)another) which may be neglected without imputation of sin, and if observed, is an act of Supererogation.
(e)Cum missa sit sub praecepto, non praedicatio. Sum. v. Domin. n. 8. Audire missam est in praecepto; audire autem concionem non ita. Suar. 13. tom. 3. disp. 88. Sect. 1. vid. v. 2. defess.
(f)Audire praedicationem in festis non est de praecepto simpliciter, patet per praedicta; ac etiam nullo jure cavetur, sed solum de missa, Sum. Rosell. Dominic. n. 4.
They conclude it no duty in such circumstances where it would be counted necessary, if ever; it is no duty on the Lords day, (g)or any other time set apart for the public worship. Mass must be heard then, but no need to hear a Sermon. If it were any mans duty in their account, it would be so in that case, when one wants the knowledge which is necessary to Salvation, and hath opportunity to get it by hearing: but even then they declare him not obliged. Sylvester propounds the case in these terms. (h)Doth he sin mortally, who is ignorant of those common things, which are necessary to Salvation; and may hear Sermons, but doth not? he answers. He so sins, who omits it out of contempt, or with notorious scandal, but not always, when it is out of negligence; because according to Aquinas▪ negligence is not mortal, unless something be omitted which is under precept, or with contempt. Adding, such negligence may possibly be a mortal sin, hut when it is so, it cannot be determined. It seems no man can tell when it will be a crime, for a person damnably ignorant, to neglect the means of instruction; but more briefly, and positively he resolves it elsewhere, that he is not commanded to hear a Sermon upon the Lords-day; 3although he be ignorant of those things which are necessary to Salvation, because he may otherwise satisfy the precept for learning.
They conclude it no duty in such circumstances where it would be counted necessary, if ever; it is no duty on the Lords day, (g)or any other time set apart for the publick worship. Masse must be heard then, but no need to hear a Sermon. If it were any mans duty in their account, it would be so in that case, when one wants the knowledge which is necessary to Salvation, and hath opportunity to get it by hearing: but even then they declare him not obliged. Sylvester propounds the case in these terms. (h)Doth he sin mortally, who is ignorant of those common tbings, which are necessary to Salvation; and may hear Sermons, but doth not? he answers. He so sins, who omits it out of contempt, or with notorious scandal, but not alwayes, when it is out of negligence; because according to Aquinas▪ negligence is not mortal, unless something be omitted which is under precept, or with contempt. Adding, such negligence may possibly be a mortal sin, hut when it is so, it cannot be determined. It seems no man can tell when it will be a crime, for a person damnably ignorant, to neglect the means of instruction; but more briefly, and positively he resolves it elsewhere, that he is not commanded to hear a Sermon upon the Lords-day; 3although he be ignorant of those things which are necessary to Salvation, because he may otherwise satisfie the precept for learning.
(g)Jac. de Graff. l. 2. c. 33. n. 8. 16. Sotus & Covarruvias. Navarre. c. 21. n. 1. Missa audienda diebus festis ex praecepto, non tamen concio, non preces fundendae; non exercendus alius actus cultus divini, ex praecepto. (excipe diem paschatis, quo sumenda est Eucharistia) Victorel ibid. ad. l. 4. c. 25. p. 693. Dico nullum esse praeceptum, quod obliget in rigour, ac per se ad audiendam concionem in die festo. Ita supponunt ut clarum Doctores Omnes, & constat ex communi usu, & sensu fidelium. Item quia nullib extat hoc praeceptum, praeterea est optimum argumentum, quia si fideles tenerentur audire concionem sacram, pastores ecclesiae tenerentur providere, ut omnibus diebus Dominicis & festis fieret concio in ecclesia. Pastores autem ad hoc non tenentur, nec de facto ita fit. Suar. l. 2. de fest. c. 16. n. 6.Jac. de Graff. l. 2. c. 33. n. 8. 16. Sotus & Covarruvias. Navar. c. 21. n. 1. Missa audienda diebus festis ex praecepto, non tamen concio, non preces fundendae; non exercendus alius actus cultus divini, ex praecepto. (excipe diem paschatis, quo sumenda est Eucharistia) Victorel ibid. ad. l. 4. c. 25. p. 693. Dico nullum esse praeceptum, quod obliget in rigore, ac per se ad audiendam concionem in die festo. Ita supponunt ut clarum Doctores Omnes, & constat ex communi usu, & sensu fidelium. Item quia nullib extat hoc praeceptum, praeterea est optimum argumentum, quia si fideles tenerentur audire concionem sacram, pastores ecclesiae tenerentur providere, ut omnibus diebus Dominicis & festis fieret concio in ecclesia. Pastores autem ad hoc non tenentur, nec de facto ita fit. Suar. l. 2. de fest. c. 16. n. 6.
(h)Quaeritur, utrum peccet mortaliter, qui ignorat communia necessaria ad salutem, & potest audire praedicationem, & non audit? Et dico quod sic, si hoc facit ex contemptu vel ex scandalo notabili: non autem semper si omittit ex negligentia, quia secundum S. Thom. 22. q. 54. negligentia non est mortale, nisi omittatur aliquid, quod sit sub praecepto vel ratione contemptus. v. praedicat. n. 6. quando hoc sit, non potest sermone determinari. Ibid.
3(i) Etiamsi talis habeat ignorantiam necessariorum ad salutem, quia alias poterit implere praeceptum de addiscendo. v. Dominic. n. 8.
Sect. 5. As to the Sacraments, and the worship in them, the dispatch may be quick, there are none considerable here, but Baptism and the Eucharist, for their other five are not of Divine appointment, nor the worship of God, but their own inventions, and therefore how needful so ever they count them, thereby they make no true worship necessary. But indeed none of them are in their own account necessary to Salvation; save only Penance, and that we shall meet with hereafter. What worship they will have in the Eucharist is sufficiently discovered, by what they are satisfied with in the Mass, where we have found them contented with none at all, or that which is worse than none. Neither do they account this Sacrament simply necessary, for although it be required that they Communicate once a year; yet that is but by humane Law or Custom as they teach. (k)The Sacrament of the Eucharist saith Canus, is not a Sacrament of necessity.
Sect. 5. As to the Sacraments, and the worship in them, the dispatch may be quick, there are none considerable here, but Baptism and the Eucharist, for their other five are not of Divine appointment, nor the worship of God, but their own inventions, and therefore how needful so ever they count them, thereby they make no true worship necessary. But indeed none of them are in their own account necessary to Salvation; save only Pennance, and that we shall meet with hereafter. What worship they will have in the Eucharist is sufficiently discovered, by what they are satisfied with in the Masse, where we have found them contented with none at all, or that which is worse than none. Neither do they account this Sacrament simply necessary, for although it be required that they Communicate once a year; yet that is but by humane Law or Custome as they teach. (k)The Sacrament of the Eucharist saith Canus, is not a Sacrament of necessity.
(k)Sermo est de Eucharistiae Sacramento, quod non est Sacramentum necessitatis. pars. 5. relict. de paenit. p. 892. Many of them count it not necessary by virtue of any Divine Precept, and so not requisite jure divino. Est prima opinio negans esse praeceptum jure divino quam tenuit, Alexander Alensis, D. Thomas Carthusianus, Palacius, Bonaventura, Gabriel. Sylvester, Ferrariensis, Cajetan. in Suarez. tom. 3. disp. 69. Sect. 1. p 879.Sermo est de Eucharistiae Sacramento, quod non est Sacramentum necessitatis. pars. 5. relict. de paenit. p. 892. Many of them count it not necessary by vertue of any Divine Precept, and so not requisite jure divino. Est prima opinio negans esse praeceptum jure divino quam tenuit, Alexander Alensis, D. Thomas Carthusianus, Palacius, Bonaventura, Gabriel. Sylvester, Ferrariensis, Cajetan. in Suarez. tom. 3. disp. 69. Sect. 1. p 879.
For Baptism, if they account any worship necessary, it must be either in respect of the Administrator, or the Baptized, as to the former none with them is needful. (a)For by their Doctrine it may be validly Administered by any Man, or Woman, or one that is both; yea or by a Child, by those also that are strangers, or enemies to all Christian worship, by Jews, Pagans or Infidels of any sort, by such as worship not the true God (as Sylvester tells us out of Aquinas, Paludanus and their Churches Law.) By such as believe that Baptism is good for naught, and minister it in scorn. By such as believe that it is not a Sacrament, that it hath no spiritual virtue, and intend not, while they Baptize, to Administer a Sacrament, but only think to do, as the Church does; although ⟨p. 46⟩they account that to be nothing at all, so (b)Aquinas, and Pope Innocent saith it will be effectual, though the Baptizer neither know nor believe what Baptism is, but counts it a trifle, though he neither know what the Church is, nor minds to do what the Church doth, but means to do the contrary. No other worship is necessary upon the account of the Ministers, but what might be expected from such as these. Nor any more upon the account of the persons Baptized. For as to the Adult (there being no pretence in reference to infants) they think it sufficiently administered by force, to those who would not endure it, but for fear of death (c)if they did not yield: to such as make all the resistance they can (d)and offer foul injury to the Sacrament, and defile the water: to those who receive it, not for the purpose for which it is intended, but for quite 5other ends than ever it was designed for: yea to those that are Frantic and never had the use of Reason, or are (f)stark mad, and that in the height of their madness: to those also (g)that are fast a sleep, if they had a mind to it when they were waking. Since they think it duly administered, to such as these, they cannot count any worship necessary herein, upon the account of the partakers, but what such as these now mentioned may offer.
For Baptism, if they account any worship necessary, it must be either in respect of the Administrator, or the Baptized, as to the former none with them is needful. (a)For by their Doctrine it may be validly Administred by any Man, or Woman, or one that is both; yea or by a Child, by those also that are strangers, or enemies to all Christian worship, by Jews, Pagans or Infidels of any sort, by such as worship not the true God (as Sylvester tells us out of Aquinas, Paludanus and their Churches Law.) By such as believe that Baptism is good for naught, and minister it in scorn. By such as believe that it is not a Sacrament, that it hath no spiritual vertue, and intend not, while they Baptize, to Administer a Sacrament, but only think to do, as the Church does; although ⟨p. 46⟩they account that to be nothing at all, so (b)Aquinas, and Pope Innocent saith it will be effectual, though the Baptizer neither know nor believe what Baptism is, but counts it a trifle, though he neither know what the Church is, nor minds to do what the Church doth, but means to do the contrary. No other worship is necessary upon the account of the Ministers, but what might be expected from such as these. Nor any more upon the account of the persons Baptized. For as to the Adult (there being no pretence in reference to infants) they think it sufficiently administred by force, to those who would not endure it, but for fear of death (c)if they did not yield: to such as make all the resistance they can (d)and offer foul injury to the Sacrament, and defile the water: to those who receive it, not for the purpose for which it is intended, but for quite 5other ends than ever it was designed for: yea to those that are Frantick and never had the use of Reason, or are (f)stark madd, and that in the height of their madness: to those also (g)that are fast a sleep, if they had a mind to it when they were waking. Since they think it duely administred, to such as these, they cannot count any worship necessary herein, upon the account of the partakers, but what such as these now mentioned may offer.
(a)Sum. v. Baptism. 3. n. 1. Secundum omnes Doctores precip•e. S. Thom. & Pet. de Pal omnis homo dare potest Baptisma—si sit clericus aut laicus, vir aut mulier, aut uterque simul i. e. Hermaphroditus. Etiamsi esset infidelis, i. e. Judaeus aut paganus. Dicit S. Tho. quod quamvis ille qui non credit baptisma esse Sacramentum, aut habere aliquam spiritualem virtutem, non intendat dum baptizat conferre Sacramentum, tamen intendit facere quandoque quod facit ecclesia; etiamsi illud reputet nihil esse.
(b)Ibid. n. 2. Innocentius dicit, quod baptismus habebit effectum, etiamsi baptizans nec sciat nec credat, quid sit baptismus, sed hoc reputet truffem, & etiamsi non sciat quod sit ecclesia, nec gerat in mente facere, quod facit ecclesia: immo si gereret contrarium scil. non facere quod facit ecclesia sed tamen facit & formam servat, &c.
(c)Id ibid. 4. n. 10. Si consentit quis per minas vel poenas habendo volunt atem coactam, coactione conditionally, cligendo scil. potius baptizari quam mori vel aliud pa•i. & n. 3. Si oporteat eos ligari.Id ibid. 4. n. 10. Si consentit quis per minas vel poenas habendo volunt atem coactam, coactione conditionali, cligendo scil. potius baptizari quam mori vel aliud pa•i. & n. 3. Si oporteat eos ligari.
(d)Vel etiam si faciant injuriam Sacramento, ut mingendo in aquam vel hujusmodi et (e) Si vero usum rationis nunquam habuit, Baptizatur in intentione parentum &c. n 10. Si Baptizetur infidelis non quia credat sed ut sanetur, vel careat foetere, aut vexation diabolica—aut propter quaestum, ut faciunt crebro Judaei.Vel etiam si faciant injuriam Sacramento, ut mingendo in aquam vel hujusmodi et (e) Si vero usum rationis nunquam habuit, Baptizatur in intentione parentum &c. n 10. Si Baptizetur infidelis non quia credat sed ut sanetur, vel careat foetere, aut vexatione diabolica—aut propter quaestum, ut faciunt crebro Judaei.
5(e) Si vero usum rationis nunquam habuit, Baptizatur in intentione parentum &c.
(f)Si autem usum rationis habuit aliquando, sed non quando baptizatur, propter phrenesim vel amentiam vel dormitionem & hujusmodi, requiritur intentio quae praesuerit, tempore usus rationis. n. 3.
Sect. 6. For fuller and more particular satisfaction, it is observable, that they divide their Sacraments into some for the Dead, and some for the Living: those for the Dead are Baptism and Penance. As to these two, some count no disposition requisite, (h)but only a willingness to receive them. Others (who would seem to be more severe) ⟨p. 47⟩count Attrition sufficient; (which is a slender dislike of sin, not as it is an offence to God, but out of some other consideration Humane, Natural, or Servile.) And the lowest degree of this possible; and that dispatched in a moment; and this moment need not be, while they are at these Sacraments, but either (i)before or after. Their Penitents (*)may make their Confession with laughter instead of grief; yet have as much grief at their Sacrament of Penance as they require, this is past doubt with them. So that it is their common Doctrine that no good act, or motion at all, no not so little, and low as that of Attrition (much less any ingenuous Reverence or Devotion; any act of grace or holy affection) is needful, while they are at the Sacrament, either of Baptism, or their Penance.
Sect. 6. For fuller and more particular satisfaction, it is observable, that they divide their Sacraments into some for the Dead, and some for the Living: those for the Dead are Baptism and Pennance. As to these two, some count no disposition requisite, (h)but only a willingness to receive them. Others (who would seem to be more severe) ⟨p. 47⟩count Attrition sufficient; (which is a slender dislike of sin, not as it is an offence to God, but out of some other consideration Humane, Natural, or Servile.) And the lowest degree of this possible; and that dispatch't in a moment; and this moment need not be, while they are at these Sacraments, but either (i)before or after. Their Penitents (*)may make their Confession with laughter instead of grief; yet have as much grief at their Sacrament of Pennance as they require, this is past doubt with them. So that it is their common Doctrine that no good act, or motion at all, no not so little, and low as that of Attrition (much less any ingenuous Reverence or Devotion; any act of grace or holy affection) is needful, while they are at the Sacrament, either of Baptism, or their Pennance.
(h)Scotus quem sequitur Sylvester sum. v. confess. 1. n. 24.
(*)Judicandum non erit dolore carere ob risum, potuit enim domi de illis dolere, & postea ad Sacramentum accedens, actualem poenitentiam non adducere. At ad valorem & fructum percipiendum Sacramenti confessionis non requiri actualem dolorem, sed virtualem sufficere veram esse sententiam quis dubitet? Jo. Sancius select. disp. 31. n. 8.
The Sacraments of the living are their other five, Confirmation, Orders, Matrimony, extreme Unction, and the Eucharist: these they say were instituted for the increase of Grace, this is their proper effect; and that they may have their effect, there is not requisite in the partakers any actual disposition at all, not the least inward act or motion that is good; no, not so little as that of attrition, which in their account is of all others (k)the least and lowest disposition. And well may they count it so, since the best sort of it, with them, is but the issue of servile fear; which, as such, is below the least degree of moral goodness; and so far from being supernaturally good, that it is morally evil, as we shall see hereafter. All that is needful, is only that the partakers be in a state of Grace, (such as a Priest may put a sinner into who is impenitent, and never truly contrite) though he show it not by any act in the Sacraments where, if ever, it should appear. ⟨p. 48⟩(l)That the Sacraments may confer an increase of Grace, they only require an habitual disposition, i. e. that they be received in the state of Grace: this is the judgment of Aquinas and Scotus, whom the rest generally follow. So that to partake worthily of these Sacraments, no actual disposition, no act of reverence or devotion, not any inward motion (such as should be in true worshippers) is more required or expected than in the senseless Statues which they idolize. Their souls need act or move no more as worshippers of God herein, than if they were neither Christians nor men; than if they were so far from having grace, as to have no souls. Yea, these Sacraments may be valid, and duly celebrated, as their Church requires they should be; while the partakers are, not only void of all good motion towards God; but while their souls are in motion against him, and all that is divine and sacred. Their minds and hearts may, during the celebration, be taken up with acts, not only of folly and vanity, but of pride, or lusts, or revenge, or infidelity, or atheism, or what is most contrary to the most holy God and his worship, and yet partake as well as the Church requires. (m)For the precepts of their Church, concerning the administering of the Sacraments, and all other things by her enjoined, may be entirely satisfied by acts of wickedness. So notoriously holy is that Church, by the report of their chief Writers.
The Sacraments of the living are their other five, Confirmation, Orders, Matrimony, extreme Ʋnction, and the Eucharist: these they say were instituted for the increase of Grace, this is their proper effect; and that they may have their effect, there is not requisite in the partakers any actual disposition at all, not the least inward act or motion that is good; no, not so little as that of attrition, which in their account is of all others (k)the least and lowest disposition. And well may they count it so, since the best sort of it, with them, is but the issue of servile fear; which, as such, is below the least degree of moral goodness; and so far from being supernaturally good, that it is morally evil, as we shall see hereafter. All that is needful, is only that the partakers be in a state of Grace, (such as a Priest may put a sinner into who is impenitent, and never truly contrite) though he shew it not by any act in the Sacraments where, if ever, it should appear. ⟨p. 48⟩(l)That the Sacraments may confer an increase of Grace, they only require an habitual disposition, i. e. that they be received in the state of Grace: this is the judgment of Aquinas and Scotus, whom the rest generally follow. So that to partake worthily of these Sacraments, no actual disposition, no act of reverence or devotion, not any inward motion (such as should be in true worshippers) is more required or expected than in the sensless Statues which they idolize. Their souls need act or move no more as worshippers of God herein, than if they were neither Christians nor men; than if they were so far from having grace, as to have no souls. Yea, these Sacraments may be valid, and duly celebrated, as their Church requires they should be; while the partakers are, not only void of all good motion towards God; but while their souls are in motion against him, and all that is divine and sacred. Their minds and hearts may, during the celebration, be taken up with acts, not only of folly and vanity, but of pride, or lusts, or revenge, or infidelity, or atheism, or what is most contrary to the most holy God and his worship, and yet partake as well as the Church requires. (m)For the precepts of their Church, concerning the administring of the Sacraments, and all other things by her enjoyned, may be intirely satisfied by acts of wickedness. So notoriously holy is that Church, by the report of their chief Writers.
(k)Est minima & imperfectissima dispositio quae in ordine supernaturali requiri potest.
(l)Ut Sacramenta conferant augmentum gratiae solum requirunt habitualem gratiae dispositionem, id est, quod in statu gratiae recipiantur. Haec est sententia D. Thom. Scoti & aliorum in Suar. tom. 3. disp. 7. Sect. 4. All that is required to put them into this state, and free them from conscience of mortal sin, (and so to give them all the disposition necessary for the Eucharist, and so for the other Sacraments) is their ritual confession: yet even this they may neglect lawfully, or without any great fault, as divers amongst them (and those Dominicans) determine. Cajetan. sum v. communio. Fumus v. Paludanus, Sylvester in Ledesma de Eucharist. C. 11. Jo. de la Cruz de Eucharist. q. 5. concl. 2.
(m)Praeceptum adimpleri potest peractum ex aliqua circumstantia malum it a S. Thom. Medina, Navarre, & alii in Bonac. supra. Nam alia praecepta tum sacramentorum tum in aliis materiis, impleri possunt per actum p•cc•minosum Suar. ibid. disp. 70. Sect. 3. after Corduba, Soto, Covarruvius, whether it be less or more wicked, is all one, disp. 88. Sect. 3.Praeceptum adimpleri potest peractum ex aliqua circumstantia malum it a S. Thom. Medina, Navar, & alii in Bonac. supra. Nam alia praecepta tum sacramentorum tum in aliis materiis, impleri possunt per actum p•cc•minosum Suar. ibid. disp. 70. Sect. 3. after Corduba, Soto, Covarruvius, whether it be less or more wicked, is all one, disp. 88. Sect. 3.
Sect. 7. If they count any of their Sacraments more worthy of holier treatment than that now mentioned, it will be the Eucharist; for this they count more worthy than the rest, and have it in such veneration, as not only to worship Christ in it; but to worship it even as Christ himself; and therefore here, if ever, they will judge it requisite to show themselves worshippers indeed. Yet for all this, what-ever ⟨p. 49⟩worship of this Sacrament they count needful, they conclude no true worship of Christ necessary; no, not so much as the least inward act of reverence, devotion, or honour: for this is their common Doctrine, (n)that besides the disposition of habitual Grace, there is no precept so rigorous as to require any actual disposition for the worthy receiving of this Sacrament, so as that the omission of it can be a mortal sin. In this all their Divines agree: so that any one may partake worthily of this Sacrament, and be free of mortal guilt, without any actual reverence or devotion, any act of grace or holy affection, while he is communicating. This one Maxim (wherein they all concur) quite stifles the spirit of Christianity, and bereaves it of its life and soul; it leaves nothing that can honour or please Christ, or be of any advantage to souls, needful in any Christian duty. For no good motion of mind or heart, being needful in the celebrating of this Sacrament, which requires it more, they cannot imagine it necessary in any other duty, of less consequence. And the want hereof being but a venial fault, there is no more necessity to have it, than there is to avoid a venial sin, which they make nothing of. In this very case, they hold that (o)a venial sin, even in the act of communicating, will not hinder the effect of the Sacrament. Yea, it may not be so much as a venial fault, if the vagaries of the mind, which exclude attention and reverence due to such a religious ⟨p. 50⟩act (p)be natural. But will it not be more than so slight a fault, voluntarily to abandon every good motion in the celebrating of this Sacrament? No, to decline every good act of mind or heart, and that voluntarily, it can be no worse, (q)if it be without contempt, it will be no mortal fault; & that also in the judgment of all their Divines.
Sect. 7. If they count any of their Sacraments more worthy of holier treatment than that now mentioned, it will be the Eucharist; for this they count more worthy than the rest, and have it in such veneration, as not only to worship Christ in it; but to worship it even as Christ himself; and therefore here, if ever, they will judge it requisite to shew themselves worshippers indeed. Yet for all this, what-ever ⟨p. 49⟩worship of this Sacrament they count needful, they conclude no true worship of Christ necessary; no, not so much as the least inward act of reverence, devotion, or honour: for this is their common Doctrine, (n)that besides the disposition of habitual Grace, there is no precept so rigorous as to require any actual disposition for the worthy receiving of this Sacrament, so as that the omission of it can be a mortal sin. In this all their Divines agree: so that any one may partake worthily of this Sacrament, and be free of mortal guilt, without any actual reverence or devotion, any act of grace or holy affection, while he is communicating. This one Maxim (wherein they all concur) quite stifles the spirit of Christianity, and bereaves it of its life and soul; it leaves nothing that can honour or please Christ, or be of any advantage to souls, needful in any Christian duty. For no good motion of mind or heart, being needful in the celebrating of this Sacrament, which requires it more, they cannot imagine it necessary in any other duty, of less consequence. And the want hereof being but a venial fault, there is no more necessity to have it, than there is to avoid a venial sin, which they make nothing of. In this very case, they hold that (o)a venial sin, even in the act of communicating, will not hinder the effect of the Sacrament. Yea, it may not be so much as a venial fault, if the vagaries of the mind, which exclude attention and reverence due to such a religious ⟨p. 50⟩act (p)be natural. But will it not be more than so slight a fault, voluntarily to abandon every good motion in the celebrating of this Sacrament? No, to decline every good act of mind or heart, and that voluntarily, it can be no worse, (q)if it be without contempt, it will be no mortal fault; & that also in the judgment of all their Divines.
(n)Praeter dispositionem gratiae habitualis, nullam actualem requiri ex rigoroso praecepto ad dignam sumptionem bujus sacramenti, it a ut illius omissio peccatum mortal sit. In quo conveniunt omnes Theologi. Et a fortiori patet ex eo, quod supra diximus, ad effectum hujus sacramenti nullam actualem dispositionem requiri. Ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1. Those who seem to require some actual devotion, yet count it but a venial fault to want it, Alexander, Antonin, Sylvester, Paludan, Cajetan, in Vasquez in 3. tom. 3. disp. 206. c. 1. Not only attention and devotion are accounted needless for Communicants, but sobriety, and the use of reason: for they teach, that not only young children, and such as are half fools; but also persons so frantic, as it will be necessary to have them bound, and those also who are possessed of the Devil, and whom he has seized on for their enormous wickedness, may partake of this Sacrament, and have it duly administered to them, and that even when they are blaspheming. Jo. Sanc. disp. 38. Imo licet arreptus quis sit a daemon ob mores depravatos, & quia viveret in lenocinio,—non minus talibus ministrare tenebitur parochus Eucharistiam, n. 7. praeterea ministrare tenebitur parochus licet videat obsessum sive insanum blasphemantem; n. 8.Praeter dispositionem gratiae habitualis, nullam actualem requiri ex rigoroso praecepto ad dignam sumptionem bujus sacramenti, it a ut illius omissio peccatum mortale sit. In quo conveniunt omnes Theologi. Et a fortiori patet ex eo, quod supra diximus, ad effectum hujus sacramenti nullam actualem dispositionem requiri. Ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1. Those who seem to require some actual devotion, yet count it but a venial fault to want it, Alexander, Antonin, Sylvester, Paludan, Cajetan, in Vasquez in 3. tom. 3. disp. 206. c. 1. Not only attention and devotion are accounted needless for Communicants, but sobriety, and the use of reason: for they teach, that not only young children, and such as are half fools; but also persons so frantick, as it will be necessary to have them bound, and those also who are possessed of the Devil, and whom he has seized on for their enormous wickedness, may partake of this Sacrament, and have it duly administred to them, and that even when they are blaspheming. Jo. Sanc. disp. 38. Imo licet arreptus quis sit a daemone ob mores depravatos, & quia viveret in lenocinio,—non minus talibus ministrare tenebitur parochus Eucharistiam, n. 7. praeterea ministrare tenebitur parochus licet videat obsessum sive insanum blasphemantem; n. 8.
But though there be not any good disposition in the soul towards Christ, in partaking of his Supper, yet is it not necessary that vile and wicked dispositions should be excluded? No, there is no more need of this than the other. The mind and the heart may actually entertain such as are sinful; without any more danger than it rejects those that are good. It is but a slight fault (r)to communicate out of ostentation and vain glory; and so to nourish pride while he should be feeding upon Christ; and to design his own honour without any act of reverence for Christ: he may let his thoughts run out upon vanity, or entertain his soul with vain delights, without the least motion of love, or delight, or desire for Christ, without the least act of Faith in him: and may be pleasing himself with sin, in stead of grieving for it; when he hath the greatest advantage to look upon him whom he hath pierced. And all this he may do without any guilt, that need be repented of, or regarded. This is all the worship and honour that it is needful their souls should give to Christ, even in the Sacrament of his body ⟨p. 51⟩and blood; who will have others cursed to hell, and burnt beforehand, for not giving divine worship to a Wafer. But this is not all, their Church will be satisfied with greater indignity offered to Christ than this: for they teach, that those who communicate unworthily, to such a degree as they count sacrilege, (and that so heinous, as they question whether it be not as tolerable, to cast that which they count their God, to be devoured by dogs; or throw it into the dirt to be trampled on; and (t)many of them are positive, that it is greater wickedness than murder or adultery, or that uncleanness against nature, which is most abominable) (u)do fully satisfy the precept of the Church for this Communion. Thus Soto, Corduba, Covarruvius, and others alleged by them. And this is all derived from their St. Thomas, that Maxim of his so generally received. (x)The Law commanding an act, enjoins the substance of it, but not the manner. By which we must understand, that the Church would have the thing done, but regards not how they do it, whether as Christians or as Atheists.
But though there be not any good disposition in the soul towards Christ, in partaking of his Supper, yet is it not necessary that vile and wicked dispositions should be excluded? No, there is no more need of this than the other. The mind and the heart may actually entertain such as are sinful; without any more danger than it rejects those that are good. It is but a slight fault (r)to communicate out of ostentation and vain glory; and so to nourish pride while he should be feeding upon Christ; and to design his own honour without any act of reverence for Christ: he may let his thoughts run out upon vanity, or entertain his soul with vain delights, without the least motion of love, or delight, or desire for Christ, without the least act of Faith in him: and may be pleasing himself with sin, in stead of grieving for it; when he hath the greatest advantage to look upon him whom he hath pierced. And all this he may do without any guilt, that need be repented of, or regarded. This is all the worship and honour that it is needful their souls should give to Christ, even in the Sacrament of his body ⟨p. 51⟩and blood; who will have others cursed to hell, and burnt beforehand, for not giving divine worship to a Wafer. But this is not all, their Church will be satisfied with greater indignity offered to Christ than this: for they teach, that those who communicate unworthily, to such a degree as they count sacriledge, (and that so hainous, as they question whether it be not as tolerable, to cast that which they count their God, to be devoured by dogs; or throw it into the dirt to be trampled on; and (t)many of them are positive, that it is greater wickedness than murther or adultery, or that uncleanness against nature, which is most abominable) (u)do fully satisfy the precept of the Church for this Communion. Thus Soto, Corduba, Covarruvius, and others alledged by them. And this is all derived from their St. Thomas, that Maxim of his so generally received. (x)The Law commanding an act, injoyns the substance of it, but not the manner. By which we must understand, that the Church would have the thing done, but regards not how they do it, whether as Christians or as Atheists.
(r)Dicendum videtur, si peccatum venial sit aliquando circumstantia ipsius actus communicandi, peccatum esse veniale sic communicare v. g. si quis communicat propter ostentationem seu vanam gloriam; vel certe si actu sit in ipso peccato veniali, ut in vana aliqua cogitation aut delectatione, & ea ratione accedat distractus, & sine debita attention & devotion, ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1. Ostentation and vain-glory are here counted venial faults, because they are directly opposite to the act of communicating: and so is outward irreverence, vain prating, and gestures, inconsistent with modesty, while they are at the Sacrament, for the same reason. But other sins, not so opposite to the act, as studying a lye, or revenge, or detraction, (or uncleanness, or any the like in venial degrees) while they are communicating (though the distraction there be voluntary, and all holy fervour be thereby hindered,) are no faults at all in reference to the Sacrament. Jo. Sanc. disp. 23. alleging for it Scotus, Richardus de St. Vict. Major, Adrian, Margarita Casuum, Soto, Marcella, Ledesma, Vivaldus, Coriolanus, and divers others, n. 20. 21.Dicendum videtur, si peccatum veniale sit aliquando circumstantia ipsius actus communicandi, peccatum esse veniale sic communicare v. g. si quis communicat propter ostentationem seu vanam gloriam; vel certe si actu sit in ipso peccato veniali, ut in vana aliqua cogitatione aut delectatione, & ea ratione accedat distractus, & sine debita attentione & devotione, ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1. Ostentation and vain-glory are here counted venial faults, because they are directly opposite to the act of communicating: and so is outward irreverence, vain prating, and gestures, inconsistent with modesty, while they are at the Sacrament, for the same reason. But other sins, not so opposite to the act, as studying a lye, or revenge, or detraction, (or uncleanness, or any the like in venial degrees) while they are communicating (though the distraction there be voluntary, and all holy fervour be thereby hindred,) are no faults at all in reference to the Sacrament. Jo. Sanc. disp. 23. alledging for it Scotus, Richardus de St. Vict. Maior, Adrian, Margarita Casuum, Soto, Marcella, Ledesma, Vivaldus, Coriolanus, and divers others, n. 20. 21.
(t)An hoc peccatum sit gravius homicidio—aut adulterio, vel omnibus peccatis contra naturam: quidam enim Theologi ita existimant, ut Gabriel. Petr. Soto, Ledesma, Dominic. Soto, Suar. ibid. Sect. 2.
(u)Dicendum est cum qui voluntarie suscipit sacramentum Eucharistiae, etiamsi indigne sumat, implere praeceptum communicandi; etiamsi alias peccet mortaliter per sacrilegium indignae sumptionis. Ita tenet in specie Corduba in genere Soto, Covarruvius, qui alios referunt, ibid. disp. 70. Sect. 3.
She is indifferent as to devotion or sacrilege in her Catholics, having something else in design, than to be concerned in the honouring of God, and the happiness of men, which so much depends upon the manner of worshipping. It is too plain to be denied, that such a treatment of holy things (to use their own words) is not at all for the worship of God, or the salvation of souls, but opposite to both; yet their Churches precept is entirely thereby fulfilled. So that if God have no worship, and men no salvation, yet the Church is satisfied. This and other outward acts must be visibly done, that the World may not think but they have something like Religion amongst them: but though in stead of the ⟨p. 52⟩worship due to the Divine Majesty, they perform the acts of it in such a manner, as no less dishonours and provokes him, than the crying sins of Murder or Sodomy; their Church hath full contentment, it's all she requires.
She is indifferent as to devotion or sacriledge in her Catholicks, having something else in design, than to be concerned in the honouring of God, and the happiness of men, which so much depends upon the manner of worshipping. It is too plain to be denied, that such a treatment of holy things (to use their own words) is not at all for the worship of God, or the salvation of souls, but opposite to both; yet their Churches precept is intirely thereby fulfilled. So that if God have no worship, and men no salvation, yet the Church is satisfied. This and other outward acts must be visibly done, that the World may not think but they have something like Religion amongst them: but though in stead of the ⟨p. 52⟩worship due to the Divine Majesty, they perform the acts of it in such a manner, as no less dishonours and provokes him, than the crying sins of Murther or Sodomy; their Church hath full contentment, it's all she requires.
Thus we have surveyed the Church-service amongst the Romanists in the several parts of it, and cannot discern any real worship therein, to which they are obliged: but rather that all such worship of God in in public is by their rules and orders rendered either impossible, or unnecessary.
Thus we have surveyed the Church-service amongst the Romanists in the several parts of it, and cannot discern any real worship therein, to which they are obliged: but rather that all such worship of God in in publick is by their rules and orders rendred either impossible, or unnecessary.
Sect. 8. Let us inquire in the next place, whether they count it needful that God should have any worship from them in private: and this we may discover by what they determine concerning Meditation, reading the Scripture, and private Prayer. For Meditation, the Casuists speak little of it, nothing at all (that I have met with) of its necessity; it is like they reserve it for their contemplative persons, as a degree of perfection, to which others need not aspire. (*)(*)The Perfectionists themselves may wave it, but when they will be so over-good as to supererogate, and do better than God commands them; if they judge it necessary at any time, sure it would be on those days, when such acts are most proper and requisite. But they conclude it no duty upon the Lords-day, or any other devoted by them, as they pretend, to the observance of God. For they generally agree that no inward worship is then required, and (a)meditation is discharged by name: now if they need not think of God on his own day, or any other, wherein a particular observance of him is requisite, it is ground enough to conclude, they do not count it needful to think of him at all. Who can imagine that they judge it necessary to think of God at any time, who count it needless to have God in their thoughts, when they are at his worship?
(*)Si patres, theology—meditationem laudant & consulunt, non tam•n docent esse omnibus praeceptam.Si patres, theologi—meditationem laudant & consulunt, non tam•n docent esse omnibus praeceptam.
(*)Ecclesiastici, Clerici, religiosi non tenentur ex vi sui status & juris divini, ad hunc meditandi, recogitandi, aut mentaliter orundi usum, vid. Suar. de Orat. ment. l. 2. c. 4. n. 7. Navar. Enchirid, de Orat. l. 20. n. 61.
(a)Neque praecipitur cultus divinus internus qui in meditando & colendo Deo consistit. Navar. Manual. C. 13. n 2. Non praecipitur cultus divinus interior, qui in meditatione interiori de Deo consistit, Lopez. C. 42. p. 266.
Sect. 9. As for the reading the Word of God in private, they are so far from esteeming this a duty, that they will scarce excuse it from a crime: all that can be obtained for it, is only a toleration, (as a thing that passeth under an ill character,) and that but in some places, and there but for some persons; with more restriction and caution than the public Stews are tolerated by their holy Bishop in Rome. So much friends are they to the Word of God, or so little do they judge it a friend to them; they are the best Catholics in their account, who do not desire to look into it, or to understand from God what he would have them to be: they think it advisable (b)that no mortal should be acquainted with more of the Scriptures than is in the Mass; where they can understand nothing, and need hear nothing of it at all.
Sect. 9. As for the reading the Word of God in private, they are so far from esteeming this a duty, that they will scarce excuse it from a crime: all that can be obtained for it, is only a toleration, (as a thing that passeth under an ill character,) and that but in some places, and there but for some persons; with more restriction and caution than the publick Stews are tolerated by their holy Bishop in Rome. So much friends are they to the Word of God, or so little do they judge it a friend to them; they are the best Catholicks in their account, who do not desire to look into it, or to understand from God what he would have them to be: they think it advisable (b)that no mortal should be acquainted with more of the Scriptures than is in the Mass; where they can understand nothing, and need hear nothing of it at all.
(b)Consil. de stabiliend. Rom. seed p. 6.Consil. de stabiliend. Rom. sede p. 6.
Sect. 10. For private Prayer, it is either vocal or mental: (a)that which they call vocal, they generally count not necessary by any Law, either of God, or Nature, or the Church; and so all praying with Families is quite cashiered from the rank of Christian duties; there, to call upon God's name together they are not concerned, though some think the Heathen are: they count it not a duty to say so much as the (b)Lords Prayer, (if they understand but otherwise what is to be prayed for:) this is the common opinion in Suarez; nor do they think an (c)Ave Mary (though these are the Prayers most in request with them) more needful: they are not obliged to say it, when the public sign is given at night for that purpose; nor need they use any vocal prayer at all, no, not so much as on the solemn days for worship.(d)
Sect. 10. For private Prayer, it is either vocal or mental: (a)that which they call vocal, they generally count not necessary by any Law, either of God, or Nature, or the Church; and so all praying with Families is quite cashiered from the rank of Christian duties; there, to call upon God's name together they are not concerned, though some think the Heathen are: they count it not a duty to say so much as the (b)Lords Prayer, (if they understand but otherwise what is to be prayed for:) this is the common opinion in Suarez; nor do they think an (c)Ave Mary (though these are the Prayers most in request with them) more needful: they are not obliged to say it, when the publick sign is given at night for that purpose; nor need they use any vocal prayer at all, no, not so much as on the solemn days for worship.(d)
(a)Vid. Suarez de Oration. l. 3. cap. 6. n. 3. 5. 8. ut ibi Medina. Uldericus dicit—ad orationem vocalem ex divino praecepto non tenetur; sed ex statuto Ecclesiae, quae ministris suis missas, & horas canonicas indixit, vel etiam ex injunctione confessoris—, & hoc sequitur sum. confess. & Pisa. in Sylv. v. Orat. n. 8. ut Angelus sum. v. Orat. n. 20.Vid. Suarez de Oration. l. 3. cap. 6. n. 3. 5. 8. ut ibi Medina. Uldericus dicit—ad orationem vocalem ex divino praecepto non tenetur; sed ex statuto Ecclesiae, quae ministris suis missas, & horas canonicas indixit, vel etiam ex injunctione confessoris—, & hoc sequitur sum. confes. & Pisa. in Sylv. v. Orat. n. 8. ut Angelus sum. v. Orat. n. 20.
(b)Videtur tamen sufficere si quis sciat—quod debemus a Deo petere omnia bona corporis & animae, & hujusmodi, licet nesciat pater noster idem v. scientia, vid. sum. Angel. v. scientia, & Suarez ibid. n. 8.
(c)Idem multo magis dicendum est de salutatione Angelica vel Salve Regina, idem, ibid. n. 11.
(d)Diebus autem festis neque est obligatio ad orationem vocalem, n. 13. nec in principio aliquarum actionum n. 14. nec hora prandii, ne clericis quidem, n. 16. Nec quando datur signum publicum—consuetudo recepta est ratione devotionis, non obligationis, ibid.
But is mental prayer a duty when the other is not used? So it seems: but the question (as in all affirmative precepts) is when? (e)Lessius thinks it should not be put off above a month or two, that would signify too much neglect of our Salvation. It seems those that pray but once in two months do not much neglect it; but this Jesuit is too strait laced: that opinion is probable enough, saith one of the greatest Casuist's of this age, which (f)assigns 3 times for prayer, once when we come to the perfect use of Reason (suppose (g)when they think him capable of fasting, about 21 years of age); and again at the point of death, and in the interval, when we are obliged to love God (that is once in five, or once in seven years). But is not this Jesuit too severe also? It may be those of other Orders will not oppress us so much, or wish us so unlike to Atheists, as to have us pray once in seven years. The Jesuits, though accounted most licentious, yet seldom exceed, and sometimes fall short herein of their other Divines. Sylvester, a Dominican of greatest reputation amongst the Casuists, thus determines the question after Aquinas, (h)When one first comes to the use of Reason, he should pray for Gods assistance, (videtur) he is not peremptory that he must, and speaks but conditionally too; for he adds, If he be thus inspired, otherwise he is not determined to that time. When then? (a)Why the providence of God moves him to it, when it is necessary. Thus he leaves it, and finds no other time, when a man is obliged to pray once for himself, but when he sees his soul in greatest danger, (b)which it may be ⟨p. 55⟩he will never see. Their common doctrine is yet worse, thereby we are not bound to pray, but in the Article of Necessity; and that is, when we are in such extremity, as there is (c)no other remedy for us: if we judge that we can any way else obtain what we would have, we need not pray: The Law of God, or Nature makes it not then our duty. They help us to understand this by two instances, the one to show when it is requisite to pray for our selves; the second, when for others. (d)When a man falls into most grievous temptations, to Impatience or to Lust, if there can be no other remedy against it, but the grace of God, to be obtained by prayer, then it may be his duty.
But is mental prayer a duty when the other is not used? So it seems: but the question (as in all affirmative precepts) is when? (e)Lessius thinks it should not be put off above a month or two, that would signifie too much neglect of our Salvation. It seems those that pray but once in two months do not much neglect it; but this Jesuit is too strait lac'd: that opinion is probable enough, saith one of the greatest Casuist's of this age, which (f)assignes 3 times for prayer, once when we come to the perfect use of Reason (suppose (g)when they think him capable of fasting, about 21 years of age); and again at the point of death, and in the interval, when we are obliged to love God (that is once in five, or once in seven years). But is not this Jesuit too severe also? It may be those of other Orders will not oppress us so much, or wish us so unlike to Atheists, as to have us pray once in seven years. The Jesuits, though accounted most licentious, yet seldom exceed, and sometimes fall short herein of their other Divines. Sylvester, a Dominican of greatest reputation amongst the Casuists, thus determins the question after Aquinas, (h)When one first comes to the use of Reason, he should pray for Gods assistance, (videtur) he is not peremptory that he must, and speaks but conditionally too; for he adds, If he be thus inspired, otherwise he is not determined to that time. When then? (a)Why the providence of God moves him to it, when it is necessary. Thus he leaves it, and finds no other time, when a man is obliged to pray once for himself, but when he sees his soul in greatest danger, (b)which it may be ⟨p. 55⟩he will never see. Their common doctrine is yet worse, thereby we are not bound to pray, but in the Article of Necessity; and that is, when we are in such extremity, as there is (c)no other remedy for us: if we judge that we can any way else obtain what we would have, we need not pray: The Law of God, or Nature makes it not then our duty. They help us to understand this by two instances, the one to shew when it is requisite to pray for our selves; the second, when for others.
(e)Addit Lessius obligari nos, ut non multo tempore abstineamus ab oratione: ut verbi gratia, ad mensem unum vel alterum: alioquin esset signum magnae negligentiae propriae salutis in Fill. t. 23. l. 2. n. 44.
(f)Videtur tamen salis probabilis ea sententia, quae tria tempora assignat: primum est circa initium morale perfecti discursus, secundum articulus mortis: tertium aliquoties i• vita: ut diximus de praecepto claritatis. idem. n. 43. vid. tr. 22. c. 9. n. 290. & tr. 6. c. 8. n. 208. in universum intra annum non videtur obligare, quolibet septennio est probabale.
(g)Communiter theologi tenent quod usque ad vigesimum: alij vigesimum primum excusantur (a jejunio). Secundum alios ad 25. annum. sum. Angeli. v. jejunium. n. 15.
(h)Quod tempus videtur determinatum, quantum ad instans quo quis incipit uti ratione in quo tenetur se dirigere & ordinare in Deum: &, ut videtur, ejus auxilium precari, si hoc suae menti inspiretu•. sum. v. orat. n. 8.
(a)Alias vero determinate non potest, sed divina providentia ad hoc movet, quando est necessarium. ibid.
(b)Quum homo videt seipsum in gravi tentation, & periculo animae suae, ibid.Quum homo videt seipsum in gravi tentatione, & periculo animae suae, ibid.
(c)Idem dicendum est de illo qui preces ad Deum facere praetermisit eo tempore, in quo nullum aliud remedium suae salutis aut proximi esse videbatur. Tunc enim lex divina naturalis ad id nos obligat, ut probavimus sequuti mentem Paludani & Sylvestri
(d)Ubi posuimus exemplum de illo qui in gravissimam tentationem impatientiae aut libidinis injectus, judicat nullum aliud remedium ad victoriam superesse, praeterquam speciale auxilium Dei oratione impetrandum.
But it seems, if he can rid himself of it any other way, or but think he can, then though the temptation be never so violent or dangerous, he needs not pray. (e)(e)The other is, when a man at a distance sees two ready to sight a Duel, and makes account there is no remedy, but the help of God for parting them, then he is to seek it (which is not the case of one in a thousand). 3Yet if perhaps he can any otherwise more help them than by praying, he may let it alone. So that private prayer needs not be their daily practice, nor used as a Christian exercise in ordinary; but in extremity only, and cases otherwise desperate, and as the last remedy, and when there is no other indeed, or in their apprehension; it will not be ⟨p. 56⟩a duty, but in such circumstances as do very rarely, if ever, concur. They are not to use it as their common repast, but as physic; not for prevention neither, but when they are already surprised with extreme danger. And if such extremity occur not once in seven years, they need not pray for so many years; nay, perhaps it may not befall them, or they may not be apprehensive of it, while they live, and then they need not pray at all. This is not my inference only, it is their own, and acknowledged to be the consequence of their common doctrine. (g)Thereby there is no divine precept for prayer, which can oblige any directly; only by: accident it may happen sometimes to be a duty, but such an accident as few may meet with. Its said expressly, that from thence it follows, (h)that many may pass their whole lives, without ever praying to God, and this without any great fault. It should be said, without the least fault, for where there is no obligation, there is no duty at all; and then no sin great, or little in the want of performance.
But it seems, if he can rid himself of it any other way, or but think he can, then though the temptation be never so violent or dangerous, he needs not pray. (e)(e)The other is, when a man at a distance sees two ready to sight a Duel, and makes account there is no remedy, but the help of God for parting them, then he is to seek it (which is not the case of one in a thousand). 3Yet if perhaps he can any otherwise more help them than by praying, he may let it alone. So that private prayer needs not be their daily practice, nor used as a Christian exercise in ordinary; but in extremity only, and cases otherwise desperate, and as the last remedy, and when there is no other indeed, or in their apprehension; it will not be ⟨p. 56⟩a duty, but in such circumstances as do very rarely, if ever, concurr. They are not to use it as their common repast, but as physick; not for prevention neither, but when they are already surprised with extream danger. And if such extremity occurr not once in seven years, they need not pray for so many years; nay, perhaps it may not befal them, or they may not be apprehensive of it, while they live, and then they need not pray at all. This is not my inference only, it is their own, and acknowledged to be the consequence of their common doctrine. (g)Thereby there is no divine precept for prayer, which can oblige any directly; only by: accident it may happen somtimes to be a duty, but such an accident as few may meet with. Its said expresly, that from thence it follows, (h)that many may pass their whole lives, without ever praying to God, and this without any great fault. It should be said, without the least fault, for where there is no obligation, there is no duty at all; and then no sin great, or little in the want of performance.
(e)Et de illo qui eminus intuens duos in duello conserturos manus, existimat nullum aliud esse remedium nisi speciale auxilium Dei oratione impetrandum ad dirimendum illud duellum injustum, in his enim casibus id a Deo petere tenetur. Navarre. cap. 13. n. 18. Lex naturalis quae obligat aliquem preces ad Deum fundere & tempore, in quo nullum aliud remedium suae salutis aut proximi esse videtur secundum Sylvestrum. Eadum obligat ad idem positum in tentation impatientiae, aut libidinis, cui videtur nullum aliud suppet•re remedium nisi oratio, &c. Lopez. c. 52. p. 272. Est communis sententia, quod obligat solum pro articulo necessitatis. Duplex autem necessitas communiter proponitur: prima est propria ipsius hominis, ut si aliqua tentation vehem•nt•r pulsatur, quam sine auxilio divino vincere non potest.Et de illo qui eminus intuens duos in duello conserturos manus, existimat nullum aliud esse remedium nisi speciale auxilium Dei oratione impetrandum ad dirimendum illud duellum injustum, in his enim casibus id a Deo petere tenetur. Navar. cap. 13. n. 18. Lex naturalis quae obligat aliquem preces ad Deum fundere & tempore, in quo nullum aliud remedium suae salutis aut proximi esse videtur secundum Sylvestrum. Eadum obligat ad idem positum in tentatione impatientiae, aut libidinis, cui videtur nullum aliud suppet•re remedium nisi oratio, &c. Lopez. c. 52. p. 272. Est communis sententia, quod obligat solum pro articulo necessitatis. Duplex autem necessitas communiter proponitur: prima est propria ipsius hominis, ut si aliqua tentatione vehem•nt•r pulsatur, quam sine auxilio divino vincere non potest.
(e)Alia est necessitas proximi ut si quis videat aliquos ad duellum properare, nec possit eos aliter impedire.—D. Tho. Paludan. Sylvest. Navarre. Abulens. vid. Suar. l. 1. de Orat. c. 36.Alia est necessitas proximi ut si quis videat aliquos ad duellum properare, nec possit eos aliter impedire.—D. Tho. Paludan. Sylvest. Navar. Abulens. vid. Suar. l. 1. de Orat. c. 36.
3(f) Nisi forte posset aliter melius, quam per orationem suffragari Sylvest. ibid.
(g)One of their greatest Divines, having acknowledged this to be their common Doctrine, thus argues, Hoc est obligare quasi per accidens propter necessitatem conting• tem & ext insecam—qui nunquam sentiret illam vehementem & urgentem tentation nec videret proximum in simile necessitate, nunquam teneretur orare,
This is some of their Churches sense, but they speak it more fully who tell us, that mental prayer is to be reckoned amongst Counsels (i)(which none are obliged to observe) and this by the common consent of Aquinas and their other Doctors. And accordingly, that there i•(k)no Divine Precept, or of natural Law, of it self, obliging to meant prayer, meditation, (some peculiar engagements or occasions set apart wherein mental prayer is not concerned) and this is counted so certain, that to teach the contrary is temerarious, because against the comm• use and sense of the whole Church. So that they are not far from the sense of the Church, who (without excepting public or private, mental ⟨p. 57⟩or vocal) deny (l)that there is any Divine Precept in special for Prayer. And these are not only their modern Divines, but some of the Ancienter also, particularly Alexander Alensis (m)(the Prime of all their School Doctors) in strictness seems to deny, that there is any proper command by Divine Law for Prayer, taking it properly, but only in a most large sense, as any pious act, or good desire may be called Prayer. And those who would not seem to like this in general, yet allow it when they come to particulars, since they teach, that the Precept obligeth not at any such particular time, or occasion, when it would oblige, if ever. There is no command they tell us, which binds them to pray in private at any set time (n)what ever. They are not obliged to Pray when they first come to the use of Reason(o): Nor on common days afterwards, not the least Prayer, not a Pater Noster, not once a day, no, not at their Meals, (p)even their Clergy need not do it. Nor on Holy-days neither, (q)no, not when they have quite neglected their service in public. (r)Nor on their Fasts, though Scripture still joins these, as all Christians, who minded Religion, were wont to do of old. Their Fasts are no more Religious for Prayer or any holy exercise, than the abstinence of their Cattle. Nor to prepare themselves for sacred or solemn employments, for their Sacraments of Penance, or else for the Eucharist (though this would but trouble them once a year), (s)not at the beginning of any service or undertaking what-ever. To pray at such times and occasions is mere matter of Counsel, (t)which none can be blamed for neglecting:
This is some of their Churches sense, but they speak it more fully who tell us, that mental prayer is to be reckoned amongst Counsels (i)(which none are obliged to observe) and this by the common consen• of Aquinas and their other Doctors. And accordingly, that there i•(k)no Divine Precept, or of natural Law, of it self, obliging to ment• prayer, meditation, (some peculiar engagements or occasions set apart wherein mental prayer is not concerned) and this is counted so certain, that to teach the contrary is temerarious, because against the comm• use and sense of the whole Church. So that they are not far from the sense of the Church, who (without excepting publick or private, mental ⟨p. 57⟩or vocal) deny (l)that there is any Divine Precept in special for Prayer. And these are not only their modern Divines, but some of the Ancienter also, particularly Alexander Alensis (m)(the Prime of all their School Doctors) in strictness seems to deny, that there is any proper command by Divine Law for Prayer, taking it properly, but only in a most large sense, as any pious act, or good desire may be called Prayer. And those who would not seem to like this in general, yet allow it when they come to particulars, since they teach, that the Precept obligeth not at any such particular time, or occasion, when it would oblige, if ever. There is no command they tell us, which binds them to pray in private at any set time (n)what ever. They are not obliged to Pray when they first come to the use of Reason(o): Nor on common days afterwards, not the least Prayer, not a Pater Noster, not once a day, no, not at their Meals, (p)even their Clergy need not do it. Nor on Holy-days neither, (q)
(i)Vid. Jo. Sanc. disp. 7. n. 10.
(k)Nullum invenitur praeceptum divinum, seu naturalis juris obligans per se ad ment• lirer orandum, meditandum, seu recogitandum. Quod ita censeo verum, ut contrarium • ne temeritate doceri nen possit, quia est contra communem usum, & sensum totius Ecclesia Suar. de Orat. l. 2. c. 4. n 5.
(l)Quidam negant dari praeceptum divinum speciale de oratione, Ibid. •. c. 28. n. 1.
(m)Alex. Alensis in rigour videtur negare proprium praeceptum jure divino datum de oratione proprie sumpta, sed solum largissime pr•ut pia operatio vel bonum desiderium dicitur oratio. Ibid. l. 28. n. 2.Alex. Alensis in rigore videtur negare proprium praeceptum jure divino datum de oratione proprie sumpta, sed solum largissime pr•ut pia operatio vel bonum desiderium dicitur oratio. Ibid. l. 28. n. 2.
(n)Idem Ibid. t. 1. c. 30. n. 4.
(o)Ibid. n. 9.
(p)n. 5. & 7.
(q)l. 3. c. 6. n. 16. n. 12.
(r)Antonius, Adrian. infra. Navarre. cap. 21. n. 7. Bonacina de Sacrament. d. 4. q. ult. p. ult. n. 16. ibi. Barthol. ab Angelo & alij comuniter. Qui non potest aut non vult, missam eo die (festo) audire, non tenetur recitare alias orations.Antonius, Adrian. infra. Navar. cap. 21. n. 7. Bonacina de Sacrament. d. 4. q. ult. p. ult. n. 16. ibi. Barthol. ab Angelo & alij comuniter. Qui non potest aut non vult, missam eo die (festo) audire, non tenetur recitare alias orationes.
(s)Nulla obligatio orandi in principio aliquarum actionum, Suar. ibid. 14.
Nor when a man hath Vowed, and solemnly promised to God, and sworn too, that he will pray, even then If it ⟨p. 58⟩be but a little prayer, (u)it will be but a small fault to omit it, for all this. In short, which compriseth all, there (x)can be no certain time assigned (unless the hour of death) in which, by any precept of Religion, we are bound to worship God, or seek his help by an act of prayer, as in like case is said of an act of contrition and love to God. So Bonacina. No time for Prayer certain, none determined; but as they conjecture, perhaps, it may be a duty, when they apprehend themselves under grievous and dangerous temptations, and judge there is no remedy but prayer. This, or none at all, is the time for it by their common doctrine; and this is in effect to say, it is a duty at no time, for no person. For those under temptation may not apprehend it dangerous, or a remedy needful; as all will be ready to do, who either regard not temptations, or are pleased with them, or what they lead to. And neither these, nor any else can judge there is no other remedy but prayer; if they believe their doctrine, which offers them divers other remedies, and those more relied on than this. To mention none else, almost any of their Sacramentals (of which they have multitudes) will serve their turn, even a little Salt, (y)conjured after the mode of holy Church, may do it. Thus we see these Catholics secured from all divine obligations to pray while they live. But they have another way to do it; for, if any apprehend themselves in dangerous temptations, and also that there is no other remedy against it but prayer, they determine; (z)that if such be ignorant that it is then a duty; or if they know it, but do not consider it, they are excused from sin, though then they neglect to pray. Now the people may well be ignorant, that they are in such case obliged, ⟨p. 59⟩when their learned men scarce know it. And for those that do know it, the violence of the temptation (and the case supposeth it violent) may leave no place for consideration. However, no man considers this or other things, unless he will: and so it will be no sin to neglect prayer at that time, when only they count it a duty, unless he list. Yea, (a)though the ignorance, or inconsiderateness be culpable, and through his own default; yet the neglect of the duty, which is thereby occasioned, they can excuse from sin.
Nor when a man hath Vowed, and solemnly promised to God, and sworn too, that he will pray, even then If it ⟨p. 58⟩be but a little prayer, (u)it will be but a small fault to omit it, for all this. In short, which compriseth all, there (x)can be no certain time assigned (unless the hour of death) in which, by any precept of Religion, we are bound to worship God, or seek his help by an act of prayer, as in like case is said of an act of contrition and love to God. So Bonacina. No time for Prayer certain, none determined; but as they conjecture, perhaps, it may be a duty, when they apprehend themselves under grievous and dangerous temptations, and judge there is no remedy but prayer. This, or none at all, is the time for it by their common doctrine; and this is in effect to say, it is a duty at no time, for no person. For those under temptation may not apprehend it dangerous, or a remedy needful; as all will be ready to do, who either regard not temptations, or are pleased with them, or what they lead to. And neither these, nor any else can judge there is no other remedy but prayer; if they believe their doctrine, which offers them divers other remedies, and those more relyed on than this. To mention none else, almost any of their Sacramentals (of which they have multitudes) will serve their turn, even a little Salt, (y)conjured after the mode of holy Church, may do it. Thus we see these Catholicks secured from all divine obligations to pray while they live. But they have another way to do it; for, if any apprehend themselves in dangerous temptations, and also that there is no other remedy against it but prayer, they determine; (z)that if such be ignorant that it is then a duty; or if they know it, but do not consider it, they are excused from sin, though then they neglect to pray. Now the people may well be ignorant, that they are in such case obliged, ⟨p. 59⟩when their learned men scarce know it. And for those that do know it, the violence of the temptation (and the case supposeth it violent) may leave no place for consideration. However, no man considers this or other things, unless he will: and so it will be no sin to neglect prayer at that time, when only they count it a duty, unless he list. Yea, (a)
(u)A mortali excusantur—qui precationem Angelicam, & alia similia parva pollicentur, etiamsi juramento, aut voto id ipsum confirmassent. Navar. c. 18. n. 7. Secundum alios.
(x)Non potest aliud certum tempus assignari in quo ex praecepto religionis teneamur Deum colere, & auxilium ab eo per actum orationis implorare, ut in simili dictum est de actu contritionis & charitatis, Bonacina, tom. 1. divin. offic. disp. 1. q. 2. p. 1. n. 12.
(y)Exorciso te creatura salis, &c. I conjure thee Creature Salt—that thou mayest be hallowed—to drive away all the temptations of the Devil.Exorciso te creatura salis, &c. I conjure thee Creature Salt—that thou maiest be hallowed—to drive away all the temptations of the Devil.
(z)Quando tentationes ingruunt cum periculo succumbendi, tunc enim medium ad peccatorum veniam & auxilium impetrandum adhibendum est—quanquam a peccato multi excusantur, ignorantes, vel non advertentes ad hanc obligationem, Bonacina divin. offic. disp. 1. q. 2. p. 1. n. 12. ibi Medina. Navar. Malderus, Sylvester, & alij.
(a)Utrum excusetur a peccato, qui praeceptum aliquod non implet ob inadvertentiam, vel ignorantiam, quae ipsius culpa contigit?—Respondeo excusari a peccato. Idem de peccat. disp. 2. q. 8. p. 3. n. 28. ibi Clavis Regia & alij.
Besides, if (b)they should both know and consider that prayer is then their duty, yet they teach that the omission of it is then no special sin: i. no other sin then that which they should seek to avoid by praying. Whereby they plainly declare that there is in their account no special precept for prayer, no, not in that case wherein alone they would have it thought a duty, otherwise they would judge it a special sin then to neglect it.
Besides, if (b)they should both know and consider that prayer is then their duty, yet they teach that the omission of it is then no special sin: i. no other sin then that which they should seek to avoyd by praying. Whereby they plainly declare that there is in their account no special precept for prayer, no, not in that case wherein alone they would have it thought a duty, otherwise they would judge it a special sin then to neglect it.
(b)Scientes vero & advertentes graviter peccant, utpote negligentes medium ad vincendas tentationes—omissio tamen orationis tunc temporis non habet malitiam distinctam ab eo peccato quod cavere tenemur. Idem. De divin. offic. d. 1. q. 2. p. 1. n. 12. ibi (besides the chief of all the Jesuits). Medina, Sylvester, Navarre, Malderus.Scientes vero & advertentes graviter peccant, utpote negligentes medium ad vincendas tentationes—omissio tamen orationis tunc temporis non habet malitiam distinctam ab eo peccato quod cavere tenemur. Idem. De divin. offic. d. 1. q. 2. p. 1. n. 12. ibi (besides the chief of all the Jesuites). Medina, Sylvester, Navar, Malderus.
Sect. 11. But though their Catholics be thus sufficiently eased of all Obligations to private prayer, all their lives, by virtue of any Divine command, it may be there is some precept of the Church for it. Can she be content that they should live so much without God, or any acknowledgement of their dependence on him, more like Atheists than Christians? yes there's not any thing for private addresses to God amongst all her precepts; she is too indulgent to trouble them with any such thing; she requires not of them the least prayer, or such as are accounted best, not so much as a Pater-noster, there is no Ecclesiastical precept for this, to make it so much as a venial fault, not to use it, says (c)Medina, not a Salve-Regina, no nor an Ave-Mary. They have indeed a special respect to this last, and prefer it Ten to one before any other ⟨p. 60⟩(though they might use this every minute, without ever praying once to God all their life.) And Pope John the 22. ordained, that thrice every Evening the Bell should sound, that every one might say an Ave-Mary thrice; and since it is grown a custom (and a Church custom usually stands for a Law with them) that not only at Evening, but at Noon and Morning too, a Bell should sound for the same purpose. So that this, if any, is under injunction: There is a fair show for it, but it is no more than a show, for they assure us, this is only a (d)voluntary Devotion, and hath nothing of Obligation in it: Those that never use this and such prayers, it is, they say, a shrewd sign, they do not live well, but the omission thereof, is no special sin with respect unto any precept either of God or the Church.
Sect. 11. But though their Catholicks be thus sufficiently eased of all Obligations to private prayer, all their lives, by vertue of any Divine command, it may be there is some precept of the Church for it. Can she be content that they should live so much without God, or any acknowledgment of their dependance on him, more like Atheists than Christians? yes there's not any thing for private addresses to God amongst all her precepts; she is too indulgent to trouble them with any such thing; she requires not of them the least prayer, or such as are accounted best, not so much as a Pater-noster, there is no Ecclesiastical precept for this, to make it so much as a venial fault, not to use it, sayes (c)Medina, not a Salve-Regina, no nor an Ave-Mary. They have indeed a special respect to this last, and prefer it Ten to one before any other ⟨p. 60⟩(though they might use this every minute, without ever praying once to God all their life.) And Pope John the 22. ordained, that thrice every Evening the Bell should sound, that every one might say an Ave-Mary thrice; and since it is grown a custome (and a Church custome usually stands for a Law with them) that not only at Evening, but at Noon and Morning too, a Bell should sound for the same purpose. So that this, if any, is under injunction: There is a fair shew for it, but it is no more than a shew, for they assure us, this is only a (d)voluntary Devotion, and hath nothing of Obligation in it: Those that never use this and such prayers, it is, they say, a shrewd sign, they do not live well, but the omission thereof, is no special sin with respect unto any precept either of God or the Church.
(c)Nullum esse de hac re praeceptum etiam Ecclesiasticum vel sub veniali, Medina de Orat. q. 10. in Suar. de Orat. l. 3. c. 6. n. 7. Solum tradidit Christus formam, non vero dedit praeceptum obligans ad exercitium, n. 5.
(d)Consuetudo recepta est ratione devotionis, non obligationis—si haec nunquam recitet, magnum indicium est, ipsum non recte vivere, etiamsi omissio illa speciale peccatum non sit. Idem. ibid.
And is not this a very pious concession, that they are pleased to grant, that for a man never to say his prayers is a general bad sign, that he does not live as he ought, though they will by no means allow it to be any special sin? Oh! the Piety and tenderness of this Mother and head of all Churches!
If for all this, any of them should conceive themselves obliged to pray sometimes; or if without such opinion, they should find some season for private prayer, though God (as they dream) and the Church (as they know) hath prescribed none: as when a Confessor enjoins it for Penance; or out of voluntary Devotion, when they have a mind to Supererogate, and do better than God requires, upon which accounts, some of them may be found now and then very busy with their Beads: yet in these cases, there is by their principles no more need to worship God in their private, than in their public prayers, where (as we have showed) they account no actual observance of God at all necessary: As for the prayer enjoined them by way of Penance, these are not necessary for them, but as their punishment; and then they pray not, for that is an act of the Soul, but this a suffering of the outward man. The Church as (they say) it cannot judge of inward acts, so it cannot order them to be penal. And the Male-factors here being their own executioners; as there is no need, ⟨p. 61⟩so there is no fear, that they will punish their Souls; but leave them untouched, unconcerned, what ever their lips, or fingers, or Beads may suffer, by that grievous penalty of praying. But it were well, if God did not suffer more by such abuse of his name and worship, than those malefactors, who count i• a suffering to do any thing like his service. And it sounds not well, that prayer must pass for a punishment. It is as Damascene defines it, and they after him, the ascent of the mind unto God. (e)Now is the approach of the Soul to God a punishment? One would think the Devils should think better of it; for the misery of Hell is distance from God, without hopes of having access to him. But they can solve the difficulty well enough; for they mean not do any such thing as praying in the case, but only to suffer some thing, which they call so. Their care and pains is about their Beads, not their Souls: if they keep but count, and bring in the full tale which the Confessor enjoins: though in as many Crowns and Rosaries, as there are Ave-Maries, in each Ten thousand times over, they have not one thought of God, nor the least motion of mind or heart towards him: yet they give full satisfaction, and undergo all they were adjudged to.
If for all this, any of them should conceive themselves obliged to pray sometimes; or if without such opinion, they should find some season for private prayer, though God (as they dream) and the Church (as they know) hath prescribed none: as when a Confessor enjoyns it for Pennance; or out of voluntary Devotion, when they have a mind to Supererogate, and do better than God requires, upon which accounts, some of them may be found now and then very busie with their Beads: yet in these cases, there is by their principles no more need to worship God in their private, than in their publick prayers, where (as we have shewed) they account no actual observance of God at all necessary: As for the prayer enjoyned them by way of Pennance, these are not necessary for them, but as their punishment; and then they pray not, for that is an act of the Soul, but this a suffering of the outward man. The Church as (they say) it cannot judge of inward acts, so it cannot order them to be penal. And the Male-factors here being their own executioners; as there is no need, ⟨p. 61⟩so there is no fear, that they will punish their Souls; but leave them untouched, unconcerned, what ever their lips, or fingers, or Beads may suffer, by that grievous penalty of praying. But it were well, if God did not suffer more by such abuse of his name and worship, than those malefactors, who count i• a suffering to do any thing like his service. And it sounds not well, that prayer must pass for a punishment. It is as Damascen defines it, and they after him, the ascent of the mind unto God. (e)Now is the approach of the Soul to God a punishment? One would think the Devils should think better of it; for the misery of Hell is distance from God, without hopes of having access to him. But they can solve the difficulty well enough; for they mean not do any such thing as praying in the case, but only to suffer some thing, which they call so. Their care and pains is about their Beads, not their Souls: if they keep but count, and bring in the full tale which the Confessor enjoyns: though in as many Crowns and Rosaries, as there are Ave-Maries, in each Ten thousand times over, they have not one thought of God, nor the least motion of mind or heart towards him: yet they give full satisfaction, and undergoe all they were adjudged to.
(e)O•at•o in genere sumpta est a•ensus mentis ad Deum & hoc essentialiter includit Idem. ibid. c. 4. n. 4.
In their voluntary prayers, there is less of worship required than the other, if there can be less than none. For (f)when they need not use such prayers, unless they please, they may do it as they list: it being no duty enjoined, the manner of performance is arbitrary, and wholly at discretion. Hence those who think something (of some sort) of attention requisite in commanded prayers count none at all necessary in these; no not that which is Superficial, not so little of that as they call virtual. So that if herein, they mind nothing at all, wherein worshippers at prayer are concerned, not so little as the bare words; yet they acquit themselves well enough, yea if this neglect of all be wilful, ⟨p. 62⟩(g)and the mind not only run of its own accord, but be sent away and employed about something else on set purpose; it will but be at worst a slight fault.
In their voluntary prayers, there is less of worship required than the other, if there can be less than none. For (f)when they need not use such prayers, unless they please, they may do it as they list: it being no duty enjoyned, the manner of performance is arbitrary, and wholly at discretion. Hence those who think something (of some sort) of attention requisite in commanded prayers count none at all necessary in these; no not that which is Superficial, not so little of that as they call vertual. So that if herein, they mind nothing at all, wherein worshippers at prayer are concerned, not so little as the bare words; yet they acquit themselves well enough, yea if this neglect of all be wilful, ⟨p. 62⟩(g)and the mind not only run of its own accord, but be sent away and employed about something else on set purpose; it will but be at worst a slight fault.
(f)Orationes voluntariae—cum penitus omitti possent, consequitur quod evagatio mentis Tollens attentionem non indu•it peccatum mortal. Graft. part. 1. l. 2. c. 51. n. 11.Orationes voluntariae—cum penitus omitti possent, consequitur quod evagatio mentis Tollens attentionem non indu•it peccatum mortale. Graff. part. 1. l. 2. c. 51. n. 11.
(g)Ubi autem libere & citra obligationem oratur, Sola est culpa venialis indecenter orare: quare distractio etiam meditata, nisi contemptio adsit, nunquam erit mortalis. Soto de just. l. 10. q. 5. art. 5. in fin. Graft. p. 1. l. 2. c. 51. n. 11. Gabriel. ibi. Angel. v. hor. n. 27. Bonacin. de divin. offic. disp. 1. q. 3. p. 2. Sect. 2. n. 7. ibi. Maldarus & alij.Ubi autem libere & citra obligationem oratur, Sola est culpa venialis indecenter orare: quare distractio etiam meditata, nisi contemptio adsit, nunquam erit mortalis. Soto de just. l. 10. q. 5. art. 5. in fin. Graff. p. 1. l. 2. c. 51. n. 11. Gabriel. ibi. Angel. v. hor. n. 27. Bonacin. de divin. offic. disp. 1. q. 3. p. 2. Sect. 2. n. 7. ibi. Maldarus & alij.
Secundum Archidiaconum praeceptum non observat. qui partem notabilem amittit, puta medietatem aut tertiam partem: secus qui modicam, Sylv. v. miss. 2. n. 1.
(e)Modicum enim pro nihilo reputatur. Cajet. v. Fest.
(f)Nonnulla modica misceantur colloquia, Lopez. c. 52. p. 271.
(g)(h) Medina docet, si quis missae interest semper tamen confabulatur, aut alia negotia futura cum mercatoribus tractat, nihilominus implere praeceptum. in Suar. tom. 3. disp. 18. sect. 3. Respondetur autem ex Cajetano una cum Soto, quod sufficiat missae esse praesentem, unde qui longe stat, eam non audiens, vel cum alio loquens, non propterea est praecepti transgressor. Corradus in Resp. quaest. 198.
their talk, and laughter may break out into such noyse, that possibly it may prove a sin of irreverence.
Potest quis malo fine ecclesiam adire, & bene in ea missam audire. Ibid. p. 469.
Dicit de dormientibus quod ratione pericult baptizari possunt, si prius in iis apparuit voluntas baptismi: sicut de amentibus dictum est.
(p)Excusabitur tamen homo, ab hujusmodi culpa veniali, si fortasse ex naturali tantum distraction hujusmodi attentionem omittat, ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1.Excusabitur tamen homo, ab hujusmodi culpa veniali, si fortasse ex naturali tantum distractione hujusmodi attentionem omittat, ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1.
(q)Talis culpa (scil. voluntaria carentia actualis dispositionis) non est mortalis, secluso contemptu ex omnium sententia, ibid. disp. 63. Sect. 3.
(x)
Ratio autem sumitur ex principio generali quod tradit D. Thom. 1. 2. q. 101. art 9. quia lex praecipiens actum, praecipit substantiam ejus non autem modum. Ibid. vid. Bonacin. and in him, besides the principal of the society, (Azorius, Valentia, Suarez, Sanchez,) Aquinas, Sotus, Navar, Medina, qui vero indigne, & sine devotion communicate tempore Paschatis, satisfacit praecepto de leg. d. 1. q. 1. p. 9. n. 2. & 3.Ratio autem sumitur ex principio generali quod tradit D. Thom. 1. 2. q. 101. art 9. quia lex praecipiens actum, praecipit substantiam ejus non autem modum. Ibid. vid. Bonacin. and in him, besides the principal of the society, (Azorius, Valentia, Suarez, Sanchez,) Aquinas, Sotus, Navar, Medina, qui vero indigne, & sine devotione communicat tempore Paschatis, satisfacit praecepto de leg. d. 1. q. 1. p. 9. n. 2. & 3.
When a man falls into most grievous temptations, to Impatience or to Lust, if there can be no other remedy against it, but the grace of God, to be ohtained by prayer, then it may be his duty.
•
One of their greatest Divines, having acknowledged this to be their commo• Doctrine, thus argues, Hoc est obligare quasi per accidens propter necessitatem conting• tem & ext insecam—qui nunquam sentiret illam vehementem & urgentem tentation• nec videret proximum in simili necessitate, nunquam teneretur orare,
(h)possent ergo m• totam vitam sine oratione transigere, absque gravi peccato, Suar. l. 1. de Orat. cap. 30•
no, not when they have quite neglected their service in publick.
Nor on their Fasts, though Scripture still joyns these, as all Christians, who minded Religion, were wont to do of old. Their Fasts are no more Religious for Prayer or any holy exercise, than the abstinence of their Cattle. Nor to prepare themselves for sacred or solemn imployments, for their Sacraments of Pennance, or else for the Eucharist (though this would but trouble them once a year),
though the ignorance, or inconsiderateness be culpable, and through his own default; yet the neglect of the duty, which is thereby occasioned, they can excuse from sin.