(t)Self pollution is no mortal sin, in any that desire, it may befall them in their sleep for the ease of nature: nor is it a sin to be pleased with it when it is (u)past for a good end, and so Aquinas, Paludanus, and the common Doctrine: Nor to be pleased with it as future, if the pleasure do not cause it: Nor to be pleased with it when it befalls them awake, (x)if the pleasure be but sensual, and not rational. Under the favour of this distinction they may act uncleanness, either natural, or against nature, and that with delight too: for though the lower faculties take pleasure therein, yet if the superior either check it, or run not into a full compliance there with, they are safe. They encourage them to venture upon, and continue in such occasions of uncleanness; as those who think it needful to avoid the acts, cannot but judg necessary, to be abandoned. They (y)that eat hot meats, such as provoke and cause uncleanness; or otherwise eat excessively: if they do it not with such an intention, but to satisfy their gluttony, or for other cause: yea though they doubt uncleanness will be the issue of it, offend but Venially. Carnal (z)touches used, for sensual pleasure, without designing the act of uncleanness, ⟨p. 237⟩or the delight of it (though it be confessed, that of all other occasions, this leads most directly, and most dangerously to the consummation of the act): yet are they but Venial faults, with many of their Writers. (a)To go to the place, or company, where is danger of sinning mortally, by reason of the sights, persuasions, opportunities, or any thing of this nature, though it be done without any cogent necessity, is not a mortal sin with them; and the reason is, because it rests in the mans free will, not to sin mortally, though such occasions of sinning be offered. Filthy (b)discourse when it is out of lightness and curiosity, without any other ill design; or when it is merely for the pleasure taken in the obscene talk, without any further intention; is no worse than a Venial fault. The filthiness which the Apostle forbids, Eph. 5. 4. Bellarmine (c)understanding thereby filthy words, will have it be but a Venial, and the same he determines, not only of filthy talking, but scurrility; and Cardinal Cajetan (d)before him, says, in its own nature it is not a mortal sin, though he describes it to be shameless mirth; and Alensis (e)refers it to lascivious affection;
(t)Self polution is no mortal sin, in any that desire, it may befall them in their sleep for the ease of nature: nor is it a sin to be pleased with it when it is (u)past for a good end, and so Aquinas, Paludanus, and the common Doctrine: Nor to be pleased with it as future, if the pleasure do not cause it: Nor to be pleased with it when it befalls them awake, (x)if the pleasure be but sensual, and not rational. Under the favour of this distinction they may act uncleanness, either natural, or against nature, and that with delight too: for though the lower faculties take pleasure therein, yet if the superiour either check it, or run not into a full compliance there with, they are safe. They incourage them to venture upon, and continue in such occasions of uncleanness; as those who think it needful to avoid the acts, cannot but judg necessary, to be abandoned. They (y)that eat hot meats, such as provoke and cause uncleanness; or otherwise eat excessively: if they do it not with such an intention, but to satisfy their gluttony, or for other cause: yea though they doubt uncleanness will be the issue of it, offend but Venially. Carnal (z)touches used, for sensual pleasure, without designing the act of uncleanness, ⟨p. 237⟩or the delight of it (though it be consessed, that of all other occasions, this leads most directly, and most dangerously to the consummation of the act): yet are they but Venial faults, with many of their Writers. (a)To go to the place, or company, where is danger of sinning mortally, by reason of the sights, perswasions, opportunities, or any thing of this nature, though it be done without any cogent necessity, is not a mortal sin with them; and the reason is, because it rests in the mans free will, not to sin mortally, thoughsuch occasions of sinning be offered. Filthy (b)discourse when it is out of lightness and curiosity, without any other ill design; or when it is meerly for the pleasure taken in the obscene talk, without any further intention; is no worse than a Venial fault. The filthiness which the Apostle forbids,
- (t)Antoninus, Sylvester, Cajetan. in Navarre. in Lopez. c. 74. p. 252. tenent quod ita licet cupere et ita complacere. Vid. Navarre. Cap. 16. n. 7.Antoninus, Sylvester, Cajetan. in Navar. in Lopez. c. 74. p. 252. tenent quod ita licet cupere et ita complacere. Vid. Navar. Cap. 16. n. 7.
- (u)Ibid. S. Thomas, Paludanus ut communes asserunt non esse peccatum complacere sibi de praeterita pollutione ob sanctum finem. Vid. Sylvest. v. pollutio post placentia non faciat praeteritam pollutionem esse peccatum.
- (x)Non est autem peccatum saltem mortale, pollutio illa, quae incipit evenire alicui, dumb dormit, & finitur postquam est experrectus, si voluntas superior, sive rationalis deliberata, in illam non consentiat quamvis sensualitas ea delectetur, &c. Navarre. ibid. n. 8. & Cardin Turrecremata.Non est autem peccatum saltem mortale, pollutio illa, quae incipit evenire alicui, dum dormit, & finitur postquam est experrectus, si voluntas superior, sive rationalis deliberata, in illam non consentiat quamvis sensualitas ea delectetur, &c. Navar. ibid. n. 8. & Cardin Turrecremata.
- (y)Non esse peccatum mortale, comedere nimis, aut calida edusia, ob quod pollutio evenit, dummodo non comedat ea eo fine, sed solum ut suae gulae satisfaciat. Navarre. C. 16. n. 8. Si non intenditur, sed quid tale fiat propter gulositatem aut aliam causam, cum dubio tamen secuturae pollutionis, esset veniale. Sylv. v. Pollut. Lopez. Cap. 74. p. 354.Non esse peccatum mortale, comedere nimis, aut calida edusia, ob quod pollutio evenit, dummodo non comedat ea eo fine, sed solum ut suae gulae satisfaciat. Navar. C. 16. n. 8. Si non intenditur, sed quid tale fiat propter gulositatem aut aliam causam, cum dubio tamen secuturae pollutionis, esset veniale. Sylv. v. Pollut. Lopez. Cap. 74. p. 354.
- (z)Martinus de Magistris, Gabriel, Javellus, Navarre, Soto, Nider, Antoninus, & alii in Sanch, l. 9. de matr. disp. 46. n. 6. & Bonacin. Tom. 1. p. 318.Martinus de Magistris, Gabriel, Javellus, Navar, Soto, Nider, Antoninus, & alii in Sanch, l. 9. de matr. disp. 46. n. 6. & Bonacin. Tom. 1. p. 318.
- (a)Ire ad locum sive ad societatem, ubi est periculum peccandi mortaliter propter aspectum, persuasiones, commoditates, aut aliquid bujusmodi, non est ex suo genere peccatum mortal, licet sine urgenta necessitate fiat, ad peccatum incantelae spectet. Haec est Cajetani, & probatur, quia in suae libertatis arbitrio restat non peccare mortaliter, etiam praesentibus talibus occasionibus. Lopez. cap. 20. p. 112.