Chapter 2
pp. 24–4724 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
CHAP. II.
Schism defined. Seminal or Actual. In the Church, or from it: There may be a Schism without Separation; and a Separation without Schism. The Characters of Schismatical Separation, Voluntariness, want of Charity, Pride, Error, breach of Sacred Unity, for little or no Cause, from the Catholic Church.
Schism defined. Seminal or Actual. In the Church, or from it: There may be a Schism without Separation; and a Separation without Schism. The Characters of Schismatical Separation, Voluntariness, want of Charity, Pride, Error, breach of Sacred Ʋnity, for little or no Cause, from the Catholick Church.
Schism is the Scissure of the Church visible, a breach of the sacred Unity of it without cause. 'Tis a Scissure of the Church, 1a renting, vestem Christi inconsutilem, the seamless Coat of Christ, as St. Cyprian speaks. It was (as St. Austin speaks) signified by the breaking of the net, Luke 5.6. The net at Sea brake, 2propter significanda Schismata, to note out the Schisms of the Church on Earth; but the Net drawn to the Shore brake not, John 21.11. to note out, that the Saints in Heaven are, in summâ pace, ⟨p. 25⟩in the highest unity. No Schisms are in that blessed Region.
SChism is the Scissure of the Church visible, a breach of the sacred Ʋnity of it without cause. 'Tis a Scissure of the Church, 1a renting, vestem Christi inconsutilem, the seamless Coat of Christ, as St. Cyprian speaks. It was (as St. Austin speaks) signified by the breaking of the net, Luke 5.6. The net at Sea brake, 2propter significanda Schismata, to note out the Schisms of the Church on Earth; but the Net drawn to the Shore brake not, John 21.11. to note out, that the Saints in Heaven are, in summâ pace, ⟨p. 25⟩in the highest unity. No Schisms are in that blessed Region.
- 1De Unitat. Eccles.
- 2Ibi Ecclesia in hocseculo, hic in fine seculi figurata est Austin in Joh. Tract. 122.
'Tis a Scissure of the Church Visible. In the Church Mystical there are no Schisms. It's true, the Flesh (which in the Saints warreth against the Spirit) is a Schismatic, and makes such rents in their Souls, that they are in a sort divided from themselves. It is not I, but sin that dwelleth in me, saith Saint Paul, Rom. 7.20. He distinguisheth his corrupt Self from his renewed Self. But yet that Flesh cannot, shall not totally, finally rent them off from the Mystical Body. They may fall into sins, yet those Principles which tie them to the Mystical Body, are not extinct; the Spirit of Grace will not leave them, but raise them up out of their Falls. Hence St. Austin saith,1 Si in aeternum caput, in aeternum & membra, If Christ the head be for ever, so are the Members. Schism then is not in the Church Mystical, but in the Church Visible.
'Tis a Scissure of the Church Visible. In the Church Mystical there are no Schisms. It's true, the Flesh (which in the Saints warreth against the Spirit) is a Schismatick, and makes such rents in their Souls, that they are in a sort divided from themselves. It is not I, but sin that dwelleth in me, saith Saint Paul, Rom. 7.20. He distinguisheth his corrupt Self from his renewed Self. But yet that Flesh cannot, shall not totally, finally rent them off from the Mystical Body. They may fall into sins, yet those Principles which tie them to the Mystical Body, are not extinct; the Spirit of Grace will not leave them, but raise them up out of their Falls. Hence St. Austin saith,1 Si in aeternum caput, in aeternum & membra, If Christ the head be for ever, so are the Members. Schism then is not in the Church Mystical, but in the Church Visible.
- 1In Psal. 88.
'Tis a breach of the Sacred Unity in the Church, I mean of an Unity founded in Scripture; every breach of that ⟨p. 26⟩Unity is Schism; but a breach of an Human Canon or Law is not Schism. St. Cyprian (showing the madness of Schismatics) saith,1 Quis audeat scindere Unitatem Dei? Who dares cut in pieces the Unity of God? So he calls the Churches Unity, because it is not Humane.2 St. Austin saith, It is a great evil to make a Schism, ab Unitate Christi, not from man's Unity, but from Christ's; and the same Author calls Schism in divers places,3 Sacrilegium Schismatis, the Sacrilege of Schism, because the Unity is not Human, but Divine. When the Papists charge Schism upon us, as casting off the Pope the Head of Unity, the Learned Dr. Hammond answers,4 He was never appointed by Christ to be Head; and the Answer is sound, No such Unity was appointed in Scripture.
'Tis a breach of the Sacred Ʋnity in the Church, I mean of an Unity founded in Scripture; every breach of that ⟨p. 26⟩Unity is Schism; but a breach of an Human Canon or Law is not Schism. St. Cyprian (shewing the madness of Schismaticks) saith,1 Quis audeat scindere Ʋnitatem Dei? Who dares cut in pieces the Ʋnity of God? So he calls the Churches Unity, because it is not Humane.2 St. Austin saith, It is a great evil to make a Schism, ab Ʋnitate Christi, not from man's Unity, but from Christ's; and the same Author calls Schism in divers places,3 Sacrilegium Schismatis, the Sacriledge of Schism, because the Unity is not Human, but Divine. When the Papists charge Schism upon us, as casting off the Pope the Head of Unity, the Learned Dr. Hammond answers,
Again, 'Tis a breach of the Sacred Unity without Cause. When the Orthodox Christians separated from Arian Bishops, who subverted the Faith of Christ, it was no Schism at all. When the Protestants came out of Idolatrous Rome, it was no Schism, ⟨p. 27⟩but a Duty. Causa (say the Canonists) non secessio facit Schismaticum, it is not the separation but the cause that makes the Schismatic.
Again, 'Tis a breach of the Sacred Unity without Cause. When the Orthodox Christians separated from Arian Bishops, who subverted the Faith of Christ, it was no Schism at all. When the Protestants came out of Idolatrous Rome, it was no Schism, ⟨p. 27⟩but a Duty. Causa (say the Canonists) non secessio facit Schismaticum, it is not the separation but the cause that makes the Schismatick.
Schism is either seminal or actual. Seminal Schism stands in the carnal and corrupt Lusts of the Heart; these are the bitter Roots and Springs of Division. Whence come wars and fightings among you? come they not of your lusts that war in your members? James 4.1. Were there no warring Lusts within, there would be no jarring Discords without. The Apostle, speaking of the Divisions in Corinth, saith, Are ye not carnal, and walk as men? 1 Cor. 3.3. Divisions come from the Carnal part in Christians, not from the Spiritual. St. Austin, speaking of Abraham's dividing the Beasts, but not the Birds, saith by way of allusion,1 Carnales inter se dividuntur, Spirituals nullo modo, Carnal men are divided one from another, but not spiritual. The Lusts of men are the great Make-bates. But to instance in some particulars. Pride is an horrible Schismatic; by swelling it breaks into ⟨p. 28⟩a rupture; by lifting up a man above himself, it divides him from his Brother. The greatest instance of Pride in the World is the Bishop of Rome; he sits, as he pretends, in the Infallible Chair; he hath all Laws in scrinio pectoris; he claims all Power, Sacerdotal and Regal; he stiles himself the Head of the whole Church; he is called a God on Earth; his Title is, Dominus Deus noster Papa; and after all this state, he is no less an Instance of Schism than of Pride. He rents himself off from the Church Universal; he will not be a Member in it, but an Head, a Universal Lord over it. The Church must be only in part Papae, and no-where else. All the Protestant Churches in the World must be cast off as Schismatics, and this abominable Schism must be styled Unity. Again, Self-love is a great Schismatic; it so appropriates all to it self, that it leaves nothing in common; it is such an inordinate uniting of a man to himself, that he cannot be joined to others. That little word (Ego) is a strange divider of all Society. ⟨p. 29⟩When Novatus fell off from the Church, and became the Head of the Cathari, there was somewhat of self in it.2 The denial of an Episcopal Preferment made him set up a Church for himself; and in that Church, before he gave the Eucharist, he made the Communicants swear by the Body and Blood of Christ not to forsake him. To name but one thing more, Hatred is also an inward Schismatic; it dissolves what Love unites, and sets a man against his Brother, to whom he should be joined in amity.
Origo Schismatis est odium fraternum, saith St. Austin, The hatred of a Brother is the origin of Schism. In the Council at Ephesus, called Concilium praedatorium, the Eutychian hatred broke out sadly against the Orthodox. The Bishops that favoured that Heresy, carried the matter by mere force and violence, crying out, Qui dicit duas Naturas, in duo dividit. He that confesseth two Natures in Christ, divides him into two. Such a desperate thing is Hatred, that it prompts men to divide even unto blood. Such Lusts as ⟨p. 30⟩these are the roots of gall and wormwood, which bear the bitter fruits of Schism and Division.
Actual Schism is either a Schism in the Church, or a Schism from it.
Actual Schism is either a Schism in the Church, or a Schsm from it.
A Schism in the Church stands in the Differences and Dissentions of the Members in it. We have in the Church of Corinth three instances of it. They differed about the Excellencies of their Teachers. Every one of you saith, I am of Paul, and I of Apollos, and I of Cephas, 1 Cor. 1.12. They differed about the manner and time of the Holy Eucharist. They did not wait one for another, the rich contemned the poor, 1 Cor. 11.21, 22. They differed about the variety of Gifts among them; the inferior in gifts envied the superior, and the superior in gifts despised the inferior; the feet envied the hand, and the head undervalued the feet; 1 Cor. 12.15, & 21. And every one of these differences is in these Texts called [Greek or Hebrew], a Schism in the Church; and the reason is, because every one of them did break the Unity of the Church in Ordinances. When ⟨p. 31⟩they looked more on the Teacher, than on the Truth, there could not be an entire communion in hearing the pure word, they heard it but partially in the gifts of one, rather than of another. When at the Lord's Supper they did not wait for, but contemn one another, there could not be an unanimous conjunction in that Ordinance. The Eucharist, the Seal and Bond of Union, was as it were rent and torn in pieces. When the inferior in gifts envied, and the superior despised, they could not worship and serve God like those, Acts 2.1. [Greek or Hebrew], with one accord. Those Differences did make a breach upon that Worship that should have been entire. Now here it is to be noted, that every difference among Christians doth not amount to Schism. There was a Paroxysm, a hot fit between Paul and Barnabas, yet no Schism, Acts 15.39. In the Church of Corinth, Brother went to law with Brother, 1 Cor. 6.6. The Apostle blames the difference, but calls it not Schism. Stephen, Bishop of Rome, was against Rebaptization; ⟨p. 32⟩Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage, was for it;
the difference, non impedit, [Greek or Hebrew], hinders not the unity of the Faith, saith Dr. Ward. But then Differences amount to Schism when they break the unity of Faith, 1or the unanimous Communion in Ordinances. Such were the Differences above-mentioned in Corinth; there was no separation from the Church there; yet because those Differences broke the unity of Ordinances, they are called Schism.
the difference, non impedit, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, hinders not the unity of the Faith, saith Dr. Ward. But then Differences amount to Schism when they break the unity of Faith, 1or the unanimous Communion in Ordinances. Such were the Differences above-mentioned in Corinth; there was no separation from the Church there; yet because those Differences broke the unity of Ordinances, they are called Schism.
- 1Determ. fol. 3.
A Schism from the Church stands in a criminous separation from it. The word [Greek or Hebrew], when it relates to the Church, doth, as I take it, only denote ⟨p. 33⟩in Scripture, Divisions in a Church. But the word [Greek or Hebrew], doth seem to denote division from a Church. Such a kind of dissension, in which men separate one from another in body and place, as well as mind. Yet in that, 1 Cor. 3.3. it seemeth to be no more than division in a Church. However this be, the word [Greek or Hebrew], Jud. 19. doth properly signify to separate, or put ones self extra terminos Ecclesiae, out of the bounds of the Church. Now this Schism from a Church is either negative or positive. Negative Schism is, when men separate from a Church, and go no further; no new Church or Assembly is set up. Positive Schism is, when there is not only a simple Separation, but a new Church or Assembly is instituted, in which the Word and Sacraments are administered. This is called struere Altar contra Altar. A negative Secession may in some case be lawful, as when one is unjustly ejected out of a Church he may recede from it. Yet (saith the Learned Camero) a positive Secession in that case is not lawful,1 he may not ⟨p. 34⟩immediately set up a new Church, at least not without some other Reasons or Circumstances.
A Schism from the Church stands in a criminous separation from it. The word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, when it relates to the Church, doth, as I take it, only denote ⟨p. 33⟩in Scripture, Divisions in a Church. But the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, doth seem to denote division from a Church. Such a kind of dissention, in which men separate one from another in body and place, as well as mind. Yet in that, 1 Cor. 3.3. it seemeth to be no more than division in a Church. However this be, the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Jud. 19. doth properly signify to separate, or put ones self extra terminos Ecclesiae, out of the bounds of the Church. Now this Schism from a Church is either negative or positive. Negative Schism is, when men separate from a Church, and go no further; no new Church or Assembly is set up. Positive Schism is, when there is not only a simple Separation, but a new Church or Assembly is instituted, in which the Word and Sacraments are administred. This is called struere Altare contra Altare. A negative Secession may in some case be lawful, as when one is unjustly ejected out of a Church he may recede from it. Yet (saith the Learned Camero) a positive Secession in that case is not lawful,
Touching this Separating Schism, it is first to be noted, that there may be a Schism without a Separation, and there may be a Separation without a Schism.
There may be a Schism without a Separation, [Greek or Hebrew], a Schism in the body, 1 Cor. 12.25. when there is no schism from it. There was not (for ought I can see) any Separation in the Church of Corinth. Yet the Dissentions there making a breach upon the Communion in Ordinances, did amount to Schism. St. Cyprian saith,1 That all believers are in one House, The Church, saith he, is unanimit at is hospitium, an House of amity and unanimity, where they sweetly dwell together in the unanimous Worship and Service of God. If a man do not go out of this House, and leave the Unity of it; yet if he make Dissentions there, and disturb that Unity he is guilty of Schism.
There may be a Schism without a Separation, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, a Schism in the body, 1 Cor. 12.25. when there is no schism from it. There was not (for ought I can see) any Separation in the Church of Corinth. Yet the Dissentions there making a breach upon the Communion in Ordinances, did amount to Schism. St. Cyprian saith,1 That all believers are in one House, The Church, saith he, is unanimit at is hospitium, an House of amity and unanimity, where they sweetly dwell together in the unanimous Worship and Service of God. If a man do not go out of this House, and leave the Unity of it; yet if he make Dissentions there, and disturb that Unity he is guilty of Schism.
- 1De Unit. Eccl.
Again, There may be a Separation without a Schism. In many Cases one part of a Congregation may depart from the other, and become a Church of it self, and yet there may be no Schism at all. What if it be done in a Congregation too great to meet together, for convenience, and by common consent? This will be no Schism at all. 'Tis but as when Abraham and Lot parted asunder, because the Land was not able to bear them: Or, as when the Hive being too little for the Bees, one part goes away, and dwells by it self in a new Family. What if there be a Law or Canon made to allow such a Separation? It will hardly be called Schism; and yet Church-unity doth not vary as Human Laws and Canons do, for then it might be something or nothing, as men please. If in a Church the foundations of the holy Faith be destroyed, what can the Righteous do? Join they cannot, separate they must. When Eunomius the Arian was made a Bishop,1 not one of his Flock, rich or poor, young or old, man or woman, would communicate ⟨p. 36⟩with him in the Service of God, but left him to officiate alone. When Nestorius did first publish his Heresy in the Church, the people made a noise,2 and ran out of the Assembly. When under the Emperor Basiliscus five hundred Bishops condemned the Council of Chalcedon, it was hard for Christians to join with them. The Church is where the Truth is, and no where else. What if the terms of Communion be sinful? we are rather to break with all Churches, than to commit one sin against God. The breaking off from him is more than breaking off from all men. Thus in some cases there may be a Separation without Schism. Indeed Schism is not a mere local defection, but a moral one. Non •liscessies corporalibus motibus, 3sed spirit alibus est metiendus, saith St. Austin, The departure is not to be measured by corporal motions, but by spiritual: but enough of this.
- 1Theod. l. 4. c. 14.
- 2Evagr. l. 3. cap. 5.
- 3
In the next place, I shall endeavour to lay down some Characters whereby it may be known when Separation is Schismatical.
1st. Schismatical Separation is intentional, and perfectly voluntary. Thus the [Greek or Hebrew], those that separate themselves, Jud. 19. do by their own voluntary act put themselves out of the bounds of the Church. Thus they that went out of the Apostolical Church, 1 Joh. 2.19. did it intentionally and freely. It is the observation of Aquinas, That as in natural things,1 that which is by accident doth not constitute the Species: So in moral, not that which is besides the intention, for that is accidental; hence he infers, Peccatum Schismatis proprie est speciale peccatum, ex eo quod intendit se ab unitate separare quam charit as facit. Proprie Schismatici dicuntur, qui propria sponte & intentione se ab unitate Ecclesiae separant. The sin of Schism is a special sin, in that it intends to separate from that unity which charity makes. Schismatics are properly those, who of their own accord and intention do separate themselves from the unity of the Church. It's true, every Schismatic doth not say as Marcion did, Ego sindam Ecclesiam, I will cleave the Church ⟨p. 38⟩in two; yet this is that which he means in his Separation. As in our Common-Law, when we would know whether an entry amount to a disseisin, we enquire,2 quo animo fecerit, with what mind it was done. So in Theology, if we would know whether a Separation amount unto Schism, we must enquire with what mind it was done. Schism, saith Dr. Hammond, is a voluntary dividing. The Schismatic is he that divides himself from the Church; not he that is cut off from it, but he that goes out, and recedes of his own accord. He condemns himself, being out of the Church, not by Censure, but suo arbitrio, by his own free Choice. The Donatists were in their minds and wills so set upon their own way,3 that after a long series of Debates and Hearings, they were still the same as before. A right Schismatic makes it his business to divide;4 A Matre Filios segregat, Oves à Pastores solicitat; He severs the Sons from the Mother, he entices the Sheep from the Pastor. This is the first Character.
2dly. Schismatical Separation proceeds from Hatred, or at least from a want of charity. 1Quisque (saith St. Bernard) sibi unus debet esse per integritatem virtutis, & unum cum proximis per vinculum dilectionis. Every one ought to be one with himself by the integrity of Virtue, and one with his Neighbour by the bond of Charity. 2Love unites, but hatred divides, and breaks out into Schism. Nulli (saith St. Austin) Schisma facerent, si fraterno odio non excaecarentur. None would make Schisms, unless they were blinded with the hatred of their Brethren. This Character was evident in the Donatists; 3hence the same Father tells them, Sacramenta habetis, charitatem non habet is, Sacraments you have, but Charity you have not. And withal, he tells them, that though they had, multa & magna, 4many and great things, yet all was nothing, si unum defuerit, if that one thing Charity were wanting; and what Charity they could have who allowed no Church but their own, I know not. When there are no just Scruples, no reasonable Causes of Separation, ⟨p. 40⟩surely the departure must be for want of Charity.
2dly. Schismatical Separation proceeds from Hatred, or at least from a want of charity. 1Quisque (saith St. Bernard) sibi unus debet esse per integritatem virtutis, & unum cum proximis per vinculum dilectionis. Every one ought to be one with himself by the integrity of Vertue, and one with his Neighbour by the bond of Charity. 2Love unites, but hatred divides, and breaks out into Schism. Nulli (saith St. Austin) Schisma facerent, si fraterno odio non excaecarentur. None would make Schisms, unless they were blinded with the hatred of their Brethren. This Character was evident in the Donatists; 3
3dly. Schismatical Separation issues out of Pride and Contempt. When they went out from the Apostolical Church, 1 Joh. 2.19. there was somewhat of Antichristian Pride and Contempt in it; for in the verse precedent, Antichrists are said to be then in being. Those that separated themselves Jud. 19. did it, as a Learned man saith, cum contemptu aliorum, as if they had some peculiar Doctrine or Sanctity. This Character may be seen in the Novatians and Donatists. Novatus is said to be Superbiâ inflatus, puffed up with pride, when he set up his Separate Church, that he might be head of those who called themselves pure.1 The Roman Synod takes notice of this, and decreed, That he, cum simul elatis, with his proud companions, should be esteemed as Aliens to that Church. St. Austin saith of the Donatists, that Superbi ruperunt rete & fecere altar contra altar. Proud men broke the net, and set up Altar against Altar. ⟨p. 41⟩It was indeed horrible pride in them to say, that the Church was only in part Donati; and it is no less in the Papists to say, that it is only in part Papae. For any one Party to boast, as if the Church were with them only, and not elsewhere, is Schismatical Pride, or proud Schism. Then is Separation a Schism, when it is done in pride and contempt.
3dly. Schismatical Separation issues out of Pride and Contempt. When they went out from the Apostolical Church, 1 Joh. 2.19. there was somewhat of Antichristian Pride and Contempt in it; for in the verse precedent, Antichrists are said to be then in being. Those that separated themselves Jud. 19. did it, as a Learned man saith, cum contemptu aliorum, as if they had some peculiar Doctrine or Sanctity. This Character may be seen in the Novatians and Donatists. Novatus is said to be Superbiâ inflatus, puft up with pride, when he set up his Separate Church, that he might be head of those who called themselves pure.1 The Roman Synod takes notice of this, and decreed, That he, cum simul elatis, with his proud companions, should be esteemed as Aliens to that Church. St. Austin saith of the Donatists, that Superbi ruperunt rete & fecere altare contra altare. Proud men broke the net, and set up Altar against Altar.
4thly. Schismatical Separation is ordinarily, if not always, attended with some error or other, It is a very are thing to see a mere simple Schism, sine ullâ depravatâ Doctrinâ, without some mixture of depraved Doctrine. Every Zimri hath its Cosby; every Divider hath some lie or other to which he is joined. Neque Schisma feri potest, nisi diversum aliquid sequantur qui faciunt, saith St. Austin. 1Neither can there be a Schism made, unless they that make it follow some different Doctrine. Nullum Schisma non •bi aliquam fingit Haeresin ut recte •b Ecclesia recessisse videatur,2 saith •t. Jerome; There is no Schism but it ⟨p. 42⟩frames to it self some Heresy, that it may seem to have rightly departed from the Church. Novatus did not only separate from the Church, but set up his own Error, That the lapsed were not to be received in the Church, no, not upon their repentance, no more than dead men. Donatus did not merely separate, but advanced his uncharitable Error, That the Church was only in part Donati; 3upon which account St. Austin tells him, that he did, aliud Evangelizare, preach another Gospel. 4Neither did the Luciferiani only separate, but they had their propria Dogmata, their proper Errors. Thus the Learned Whitaker, 5Non est Schisma nisi cum Errore aliquo conjunctum fuerit. There is no Schism, but it is in conjunction with some Error. The Schismatic ever hath some peculiar Opinion to promote in the world, and upon that account he separates from the Church, and sets up for himself.
4thly. Schismatical Separation is ordinarily, if not always, attended with some error or other, It is a very are thing to see a mere simple Schism, sine ullâ depravatâ Doctrinâ, without some mixture of depraved Doctrine. Every Zimri hath its Cosby; every Divider hath some lie or other to which he is joined. Neque Schisma feri potest, nisi diversum aliquid sequantur qui faciunt, saith St. Austin.
5thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of some Sacred Unity. The Schismatic doth indeed adhere to the ⟨p. 43⟩Church in part, but with all he breaks in part. There is some breach of Unity. He adheres to the Church in part, but not in all. St. Austin saith of the Donatists, In multis erant mecum, 1in Schismate non mecum. In many things they are with me, but in their Schism they are not with me. And in another place he saith, That they were with the Church in Sacraments, but not in vinculo pacis, in the bond of peace. Thus the Schismatic adheres in part, but then he breaks in part: There is some breach of sacred Unity, I mean of that Unity that is founded in Scripture. Hence St.2 Cyprian expostulates with the Schismatics, Quis audeat scindere unitatem Dei, vestem Domini, Ecclesiam Christi? Who dares break the Unity of God, the seamless Coat of the Lord, the Church of Christ? 3Hence St. Austin tells them, Non est quicquam gravius Sacrilegio Schismatis; There is nothing more grievous than the Sacrilege of Schism. Were there no breach of Unity, it would not be Schism; were not the Unity sacred, it would not be Sacrilege. Then is Separation ⟨p. 44⟩Schism when there is a breach of some sacred Unity.
5thly. Schismatical Separation is a breach of some Sacred Ʋnity. The Schismatick doth indeed adhere to the ⟨p. 43⟩Church in part, but with all he breaks in part. There is some breach of Unity. He adheres to the Church in part, but not in all. St. Austin saith of the Donatists, In multis erant mecum, 1in Schismate non mecum. In many things they are with me, but in their Schism they are not with me. And in another place he saith, That they were with the Church in Sacraments, but not in vinculo pacis, in the bond of peace. Thus the Schismatick adheres in part, but then he breaks in part: There is some breach of sacred Ʋnity, I mean of that Unity that is founded in Scripture. Hence St.
6thly, Schismatical Separation is a breach of Sacred Unity, for little or no cause at all. The memorable Mr.1 Hale's speaking about the Schism touching the keeping of Easter, saith, This matter tho most unnecessary, most vain, yet caused as great a Combustion, as ever was in the Church; the West separating and refusing Communion with the East for many years together. In this fantastical Hurry, I cannot see but all the World were Schismatics, neither can any thing excuse them from that imputation, excepting only this that we charitably suppose all Party out of Conscience did what they did. Thus he. This great Schism was for just little or nothing, and so is every Schism, that is properly so called The Separation is as the cause is When the cause is weighty and just the Separation is innocent. When the Cause is light and inconsiderable the Separation is Schism. Schismatics are but tanquam paleae, as chaff• ⟨p. 45⟩and as St. Austin speaks,2 Occasion venti volant foras: A little Wind drives them out of doors.
6thly, Schismatical Separation is a breach of Sacred Unity, for little or no cause at all. The memorable Mr.1 Hale's speaking about the Schism touching the keeping of Easter, saith, This matter tho most unnecessary, most vain, yet caused as great a Combustion, as ever was in the Church; the West separating and refusing Communion with the East for many years together. In this fantastical Hurry, I cannot see but all the World were Schismaticks, neither can any thing excuse them from that imputation, excepting only this that we charitably suppose all Partie out of Conscience did what they did. Thus he. This great Schism was for just little or nothing, and so is every Schism, that is properly so called The Separation is as the cause is When the cause is weighty and just the Separation is innocent. When the Cause is light and inconsiderable the Separation is Schism. Schismaticks are but tanquam paleae, as chaff• ⟨p. 45⟩
7thly, Schismatical Separation is not only from a particular Church, but from the Catholic one. As by a just Excommunication a Man is cast out from the Church Catholic, so by an unjust Separation a man casts out himself from the same. The Reverend Primate Bramhall in his Vindication of the Church of England, lays down two things; the one is this, If one Part of the Universal Church separate it self from another, not absolutely, or in essentials, but respectively in Abuses and Innovations; not as it is a part of the Universal Church, but only so far as it is corrupted and degenerated, it doth still retain a Communion not only with the Catholic Church, but even with that corrupted Church from which it is separated, except only in Corruptions. The other is this, Whosoever separates himself from any part of the Catholic Church, as it is a part of the Catholic ⟨p. 46⟩Church, doth separate himself from every part of the Catholic Church, and consequently from the Universal Church, which hath no Existence but in its Parts. Thus that Learned Man. It is one thing to separate from a Particular Church as it is corrupted and degenerated; another thing to separate from a Particular Church, as it is a part of the Catholic Church. The Learned Dr. Prideaux saith,1 Non habendus est Schismaticus, qui Romam aut aliam quamvis deserit particularem Ecclesiam, ob additamenta non serenda; sed qui aversatur Communionem & unitatem Ecclesiae Universalis & Catholicae. He is not to be esteemed a Schismatic, who forsakes Rome, or any other Particular Church, because of some Additions not to be born; but he that turns away from the Union and Communion of the Church Catholic and Universal. 2St. Cyprian charges it upon the Novatians, that they did, Catholicae Ecclesiae corpus unum scindere: Cut in pieces that one Body of the Church Catholic. 3St. Austin charges it upon the Donatists, A Christianâ ⟨p. 47⟩unitate, quae toto orbe diffunditur, sacrilego schismate separatos esse: That they were by a Sacrilegious Schism separated from that Christian Unity, which is diffused over the whole world. Separation is then Schism, when it is from a particular Church, as it is a part of the Church Catholic; for then it is from every part of the Catholic Church, and by consequence from the whole Church.
These Characters may suffice to show what Separation amounts to Schism.
These Characters may suffice to shew what Separation amounts to Schism.