pp. 388–3937 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. It is false that there is no censuring of persons here, for to say nothing that Peter accuseth those of the wrong side as personally present at the Synod, either being summoned or coming thither by appeal, v. 10. Now therefore why tempt ye God to put a yoke upon the neck of the Disciples, &c. which reproof coming from one man only, cannot be called a Synodical reproof; It is more then evident that the public Synodical censure of rebuke is put upon those who held and urged the necessity of circumcision, and why not excommunication also in case of obstinacy? for the Synodical censure of a public Synodical rebuke is only gradually different, not specifically from excommunication and both must proceed from one and the same power? Now the Synodical censure is evident in the ⟨p. 389⟩Text, v. 24. certain went out from us, (so it is clear they pretended they were in this point followers of the Apostles) and Lorinus thinketh that some deemed them schismatics.
Answ. 1. It is false that there is no censuring of persons here, for to say nothing that Peter accuseth those of the wrong side as personally present at the Synod, either being summoned or comming thither by appeale, v. 10. Now therefore why tempt ye God to put a yoake upon the necke of the Discip'es, &c. which reproofe comming from one man onely, cannot be called a Synodicall reproofe; It is more then evident that the publick Synodicall censure of rebuke is put upon those who held and urged the necessitie of circumcision, and why not excommunication also in case of obstinacy? for the Synodicall censure of a publick Synodicall rebuke is onely gradually different, not specifically from excommunication and both must proceed from one and the same power? Now the Synodicall censure is evident in the ⟨p. 389⟩Text, v. 24. certaine went out from us, (so it is cleare they pretended they were in this point followers of the Apostles) and Lorinus thinketh that some deemed them schismaticks.
2. They have troubled you with words; Lorinus citeth the Sy[…] [Greek or Hebrew] vedalacachum, they have terrified you, as if your salvation were not sure, except you keep Moses his Law of ceremonies and the moral Law. 3. [Greek or Hebrew], destroying by false arguments your souls, it is a word contrary to building up in sound knowledge (as Aristotle taketh 1the word) saying that you must be circumcised and keep the Law. 4. They abused the name of the Apostles as having an Apostolic commandment, and so a divine warrant for their false doctrine, and therefore are they refuted as liars, [Greek or Hebrew], whence it is clear they did labour to prove a necessity of circumcision not only from the old Testament and an express divine Law, but also from the authority of the Apostles, which was manifestly false; out of which I argue thus. If the Apostles do not only in a doctrinal way refute a false doctrine in this Synod, but also in a Church-way, and by a juridical power rebuke and Synodically charge the authors, as subverters of souls, and liars, then they do not only use a mere doctrinal power in this Synod, but also a juridical power: but the former is true: Ergo, so is the latter. 2. Observe two things in these obtruders of circumcision. First, the error of their judgement. It is more then apparent, that they had a heterodox and erroneous opinion of God and his worship, and the way of salvation, as is clear, Act. 15. 1. And certain men which came down from Judea, taught the brethren, (and said) except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved. This doctrine is clearly refuted both by Peter v. 10. That yoke of the Law we disclaim, there is a way of salvation without that yoke, v. 11. But we believe that through the grace of the Lord Jesus, we shall be saved as they, and it is synodically refuted, v. 24. we gave no such commandment, it is not the mind of us the Apostles of the Lord that you keep Moses Law, as you hope to be saved; there was for this error in their judgement required a doctrinal or dogmatical power, and this the Synod used. 2. Besides this erroneous opinion in their judgement, ⟨p. 390⟩there was another fault and scandal that the Synod was to censure, to wit, their obtruding of their false way upon the souls and consciences of the Churches, as vers.
1 They taught the brethren this false doctrine. 2. That they wilfully and obstinately did hold this opinion, and raised a Schism in the Church, v. 2. wherefore Paul and Barnabas had no small [Greek or Hebrew], dissension, (the word signifieth sedition which was raised by those who held that erroneous opinion) and great disputation with them. 3. They laid a yoke upon the brethren, v. 10. and v. 7. They made great disputation against the Apostles, and v. 24. They troubled the brethren and perverted their souls. This was not simply an heterodox opinion which is the material part of a heresy, but had something of the formal part of an heresy, to wit, some degrees of pertinacie, of brutish and blind zeal, even to the troubling and perverting of the souls of the Churches, while as they would make disciples to themselves, and lead away souls from the simplicity of the Gospel; now the Synod doth not help this latter simply, in a Synodical way, by a dogmatical and doctrinal power, but by an authority Synodical, and therefore they authoritatively rebuke them, as subverters of souls; and whereas these teachers laid on an unjust yoke to keep Moses his Law upon the Churches, v. 10. the Synod by their ecclesiastical and juridical authority doth free the Churches of that yoke, and they say in their decree. v. 28. It seemed good to the holy Ghost and to us, (not to lay the yoke of Moses his Law on you, as those who trouble you have done) to lay upon you no greater burden, then these necessary things, &c. now if there had been nothing to do but to resolve the question, if this had been the total and adequate end of the Synod, in a mere doctrinal way to resolve the question, Whether must we be circumcised, and keep the Law moral and ceremonial of Moses, upon necessity of salvation, as the argument of our brethren contendeth; Peter, v. 10. 11. made a clear issue of the question, We are saved by the grace of God, both ••nes and Gentiles, and it is to tempt God to lay the yoke of the Law of Moses upon the brethren; the resolving of that question is the end of the Synod, but not the adequate end, for here that, ⟨p. 391⟩not only the doctrinal power was to be used, but beside that, 1.
1 They taught the brethren this false doctrine. 2. That they wilfully and obstinately did hold this opinion, and raised a Schisme in the Courch, v. 2. wherefore Paul and Barnabas had no small 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, dissention, (the word signifieth sedition which was raised by those who held that erroneous opinion) and great disputation with them. 3. They laid a yoake upon the brethren, v. 10. and v. 7. They made great disputation against the Apostles, and v. 24. They troubled the brethren and perverted their soules. This was not simply an heterodox opinion which is the materiall part of a heresie, but had something of the formall part of an heresie, to wit, some degrees of pertinacie, of brutish and blind zeale, even to the troubling and perverting of the soules of the Churches, while as they would make disciples to themselves, and lead away soules from the simplicitie of the Gospell; now the Synod doth not helpe this latter simply, in a Synodicall way, by a dogmaticall and doctrinall power, but by an authoritie Synodicall, and therefore they authoritatively rebuke them, as subverters of soules; and whereas these teachers laid on an unjust yoake to keepe Moses his Law upon the Churches, v. 10. the Synod by their ecclesiasticall and juridicall authoritie doth free the Churches of that yoake, and they say in their decree. v. 28. It seemed good to the holy Ghost and to us, (not to lay the yoake of Moses his Law on you, as those who trouble you have done) to lay upon you no greater burden, then these necessary things, &c. now if there had beene nothing to doe but to resolve the question, if this had beene the totall and adequat end of the Synod, in a meere doctrinall way to resolve the question, Whether must wee bee circumcised, and keepe the Law morall and ceremoniall of Moses, upon necessitie of salvation, as the argument of our brethren contendeth; Peter, v. 10. 11. made a cleare issue of the question, We are saved by the grace of God, both nes and Gentiles, and it is to tempt God to lay the yoake of the Law of Moses upon the brethren; the resolving of that question is the end of the Synod, but not the adequat end, for here that,
the schism was to be removed, and the authority of the Synod to be used against the wilfulness and obstinacy of those obtruders of circumcision, in rebuking them as perverters of souls. 2. For the scandal which might have been taken if the Gentiles should have eaten blood and things strangled, and meats offered to idols, and therefore the Apostles and Elders behoved, as a convened Synod to forbid a grievous scandal and a spiritual homicide against the Law of nature, to wit, that the Gentiles for fear of scandalizing weak. believers amongst the Jews, should abstain from the practise of some things at this time merely indifferent in their nature, though not indifferent in their use, such as were to eat things offered to idols, things strangled and blood: and whereas our brethren, 3. Object, If the Apostles did any thing more then might have been done by private Pastors out of a Synod, it was merely Apostolical, and the Elders did but assent to the Apostles Apostolical determination; and every one did here, Apostles, Elders, and Brethren, more suo, Apostles as Apostles, Elders and Brethren as Elders and Brethren, after their manner as consenters to the Apostles, but other ways it is a begging of the question, for to say the Apostles and Elders, rebuked Synodically the obtruders of circumcision, its but said, because one Pastor might have rebuked those obtruders; for the specification of actions must not be taken from their efficient causes, but from their formal objects, therefore this is no good consequence, the Synod rebuked those obtruders, Ergo, the Synod rebuked them as a Synod, and by a power of jurisdiction, it followeth not, for Paul, Gal. 2. rebuked Peter; Ergo, Paul had a power of jurisdiction over Peter. I think your selves will deny this consequence.
the schisme was to bee removed, and the authoritie of the Synod to bee used against the wilfulnesse and obstinacie of those obtruders of circumcision, in rebuking them as perverters of soules. 2. For the scandall which might have been taken if the Gentiles should have eaten blood and things strangled, and meats offered to idols, and therefore the Apostles and Elders behoved, as a conveened Synod to forbid a grievous scandall and a spirituall homicide against the Law of nature, to wit, that the Gentiles for feare of scandalizing weake. beleevers amongst the Jewes, should abstaine from the practise of some things at this time meerely indifferent in their nature, though not indifferent in their use, such as were to eate things offered to idols, things strangled and blood: and whereas our brethren, 3. Object, If the Apostles did any thing more then might have been done by private Pastors out of a Synod, it was meerely Apostolicall, and the Elders did but assent to the Apostles Apostolicall determination; and every one did here, Apostles, Elders, and Brethren, more suo, Apostles as Apostles, Elders and Brethren as Elders and Brethren, after their manner as consenters to the Apostles, but other wayes it is a begging of the question, for to say the Apostles and Elders, rebuked Synodically the obtruders of circumcision, its but said, because one Pastor might have rebuked those obtruders; for the specification of actions must not bee taken from their efficient causes, but from their formall objects, therefore this is no good consequence, the Synod rebuked those obtruders, Ergo, the Synod rebuked them as a Synod, and by a power of jurisdiction, it followeth not, for Paul,
I Answer, 1. These two answers are contradictory, and showeth that our brethren are not true to their own principles, for sometime they say the Apostles gave out this decree as Apostles, and sometime there is nothing here done by a mere doctrinal power, such as Paul had over Peter, or one single Pastor hath over another, now it is sure that Paul had no Apostolic, power over Peter, and that one Pastor have not Apostolic power over another. 2. When our brethren say here that the Apostles as Apostles by an infallible spirit gave out this Decree, ⟨p. 392⟩they do in this help the Papists, as Bellarmine, Becanus, Gr•• rut, and in particular the Jesuit aLorinus, who saith, decr•um authenticum cujus inspirator spiritus sanct•, and so saith bCornelius a lapide, visi•m est nob is inspiratis & decretis a Spiritu sanctus, therefore saith he the council cannot err, and so cSalmeron and dCajetan say, and expressly eStapleton saith this Apostosack definition flowed from the instinct of the holy Ghost; observandum (saith Stapleton) quanta habenda sit ecclesiae definienth authorit•s; hence our brethren here must yield either that all Synods are infallible, as Papists say, this Synod the pattern of all Synods being concluded by an Apostolic spirit could not err, and so neither can councils err, or they must with Socinians and Arminians say there is no warrant for Synods here at all. And certainly though we judge our brethren as far from Popery and Socinianism, as they think we detest Anti-Christian Presbytery, yet if this Synod be concluded by an Apostolic spirit, it is no warrant to be imitated by the Churches, and we have no ground hence, for lawful Synods. Whittakerus, Calvin, Beza, Luther, and all our Divines do all allege this place as a pregnant ground not of Apostolic, but of ordinary and constant Synods to the end of the world; and
2. If our brethren mean that the Elders and brethren were in this Apostolic and immediately inspired Synodical determination, not as collateral penners of Scriptures joined with the Apostles, but only as consenters and as consenters by power of an ordinary holy Ghost working consent in them, more suo, according to their capacity as ordinary Elders. 1. They yet more help the Papists because they must say only Apostles, and so only their successors; the Prelates had definitive voices in this Synod, the Presbyters and Brethren did ⟨p. 393⟩no more then Papists and Prelates say Presbyters did in general councils of old, and therefore the Presbyter is to subscribe, Ego, A. N. Presbyter consentiens subseribo, whereas the Prelate subscribed (say they) Ego, A. B. Episcopus definiens subscribo; we crave a warrant in Gods Word to make an Apostle or a Prelate a Synodical definer, having a definitive voice, and the Elder Brother, or Presbyter to have a consultative voice, for here all the multitude (if there was a multitude present) do make Synodical decrees by consulting and consenting, yea all the nation may come to a national Synod, and both reason, dispute, and consent, because matters of doctrine and government of the Church concerneth all, therefore all have an interest of presence, and all have an interest of reasoning; and 3. by consequent all have an interest of consenting; yea of protesting on the contrary, if the Synod determine any thing against the Word of God. If they say there is a threefold consent in this Synod, 1. an Apostolical, 2. a second Synodical agreeing to Elders as Elders, and a third, that of the people, or a popular; What a mixed Synod shall this be? but 1. then as the Epistle to the Thessalonians is called the Epistle of Paul, not the Epistle of Silvanus and Timotheus, though Silvanus and Timotheus did consent, so these (dogmata) or decrees should not be called the decrees of the Apostles and Elders, as they are called, Act. 16. 4. Act. 15. 6. Act. 21. 25. but only the decrees of the Apostles; seeing the Elders did only consent, and had no definitive influence in making the decree, by this doctrine, as Silvanus and Timotheus were not joint pen-men of Scripture with Paul.
2. If our brethren meane that the Elders and brethren were in this Apostolick and immediatly inspired Synodicall determination, not as collaterall penners of Scriptures joyned with the Apostles, but onely as consenters and as consenters by power of an ordinary holy Ghost working consent in them, more suo, according to their capacitie as ordinary Elders. 1. They yet more helpe the Papists because they must say onely Apostles, and so onely their successors; the Prelates had definitive voices in this Synod, the Presbyters and Brethren did
I Answer, 1. These two answers are contradictory, and sheweth that our brethren are not true to their owne principles, for sometime they say the Apostles gave out this decree as Apostles, and sometime there is nothing here done by a meere doctrinall power, such as Paul had over Peter, or one single Pastor hath over another, now it is sure that Paul had no Apostolick, power over Peter, and that one Pastor have not Apostolick power over another. 2. When our brethren say here that the Apostles as Apostles by an infallible spirit gave out this Decree, ⟨p. 392⟩they doe in this helpe the Papists, as Bellarmine, Becanus, Gr•• rut, and in particular the Jesuit aLorinus, who saith, decr•um authenticum cujus inspirator spiritus sanct•, and so saith bCornelius a lapide, visi•m est nob is inspiratis & decretis a Spiritu sanctus, therefore saith hee the councell cannot erre, and so cSalmeron and dCajetan say, and expresly eStapleton saith this Apostosack definition flowed from the instinct of the holy Ghost; observandum (saith Stapleton) quanta habenda sit ecclesiae definienth authorit•s; hence our brether here must yeeld either that all Synods are infallible, as Papists say, this Synod the patterne of all Synods being concluded by an Apostolick spirit could not erre, and so neither can councells erre, or they must with Socinians and Arminians say there is no warrant for Synods here at all. And certainly though wee judge our brethren as farre from Popery and Socinianisme, as they thinke wee detest Anti-Christian Presbytery, yet if this Synod bee concluded by an Apostolick spirit, it is no warrant to bee imitated by the Churches, and wee have no ground hence, for lawfull Synods. Whittakerus, Calvin, Beza, Luther, and all our Divines do all alledge this place as a pregnant ground not of Apostolick, but of ordinary and constant Synods to the end of the world; and fDiodatus, good to the holy Ghost) because they did treat of ecclesiasticall reders concerning the quietnes and order of the Church, wherein ecclesiasticall authoritie hath place, the Assembly used this tearme, it seemed good to us, which is not used, neither in articles of faith, nor in the commandements which meerely concerned the conscience: and to shew that authoritie was with holy reason and wisedome, there is added, and to the holy Ghost, who guided the Apostles in these outward things also, 1. Cer. 7. 25. 40.