pp. 393–3942 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I answer, we do not fetch the specification of this rebuke and of these decrees from the efficient causes, but from the formal object, for an Apostle might his alone have rebuked these obtruders of circumcision, and made this decree materialiter, for Paul did, more his alone then this, when he wrote the Epistle to the Romans, but yet one Pastor could not have Synodically rebuked, and given out a decree formally Synodical, ⟨p. 394⟩laying an Ecclesiastical tie on moe Churches then one, there is great odds to do one and the same action formally, and to do the same action materially, and I believe though actions have not, by good logic, their total specification from their efficient cause, yet that ordinances of God as lawful have their specification from the efficient causes in part our brethren cannot deny. For what made the difference betwixt Aaron his fire offered to the Lord, and Nadab and Abihu their strange and unlawful fire, that they offered to the Lord, but that the on fire had God for its author, the other had men, and the like I say of Gods feasts, and the feasts devised by Jeroboam, else if a woman preach and administrate the Lords Supper in the Church, that preaching and sacrament administrated by her should not have a different specification and essence, if we speak morally or Theologically, from that same very preaching and celebration of the Supper performed in the Church by a lawful Pastor; it is (as I conceive) of the essence of an action Synodical (I say not its total essence) that it cannot be performed by one in a Church-way, and with an ecclesiastical tie, but it must be performed by many, else it is not a Synodical action, and it is true that Paul, Rom. 14. and 1 Cor. 8. 10. hath in substance the same Canon forbidding scandal, which is forbidden in this Canon prohibiting eating of meats offered to Idols, and blood, in the case of scandal; but (I pray you) is there not difference betwixt the one prohibition and the other? yea there is, for, Rom. 14. 1 Cor. 8. 10. it hath undeniably Apostolic authority, here it hath only Synodical. 2. There it is a commandment of God, here it is a Canon of the Church. 3. There it cometh from one man, here from a college of Apostles and Elders convened, and yet materially it is the same prohibition.
I answer, wee doe not fetch the specification of this rebuke and of these decrees from the efficient causes, but from the formall object, for an Apostle might his alone have rebuked these obtruders of circumcision, and made this decree materialiter, for Paul did, more his alone then this, when hee wrote the E•istle to the Romans, but yet one Pastor could not have Synodically rebuked, and given out a decree formally Synodicall, ⟨p. 394⟩laying an Ecclesiasticall tie on moe Churches then one, there is great ods to doe one and the same action formally, and to doe the same action materially, and I beleeve though actions have not, by good logick, their totall specification from their efficient cause, yet that ordinances of God as lawfull have their specification from the efficient causes in part our brethren cannot deny. For what made the difference betwixt Aaron his fire offered to the Lord, and Nadab and Abihu their strange and unlawfull fire, that they offered to the Lord, but that the on fire had God for its author, the other had men, and the like I say of Gods feasts, and the feasts devised by Jeroboam, else if a woman preach and administrate the Lords Supper in the Church, that preaching and sacrament administrated by her should not have a different specification and essence, if wee speake morally or Theologically, from that same very preaching and celebration of the Supper performed in the Church by a lawfull Pastor; it is (as I conceive) of the essence of an action Synodicall (I say not its totall essence) that it cannot bee performed by one in a Church-way, and with an ecclesiasticall tie, but it must be performed by many, else it is not a Synodicall action, and it is true that Paul, Rom. 14. and 1 Cor. 8. 10. hath in substance the same Canon forbidding scandall, which is forbidden in this Canon prohibiting eating of meats offered to Idolls, and blood, in the case of scandall; but (I pray you) is there not difference betwixt the one prohibition and the other? yea there is, for, Rom. 14. 1 Cor. 8. 10. it hath undenyably Apostolick authoritie, here it hath onely Synodicall. 2. There it is a commandement of God, here it is a Canon of the Church. 3. There it commeth from one man, here from a colledge of Apostles and Elders conveened, and yet materially it is the same prohibition.