pp. 394–3986 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. The acts of Church-government finaliter, that is, ⟨p. 395⟩government, because to prescribe rules and directive Laws (for they are not properly Laws which the Church prescribeth, Christ is the only Law-giver) are formal acts of governing, and one power doth not make Laws for governing the Church, and another power different in nature punish the contraveners. And what power disposeth and ordereth, the means do also dispose and order the end; Canons of the Church tending to the edification of the Church are means tending to the government of the Church, and I appeal to the judgement of our reverend brethren, if we suppose that one single Congregation should do all that this Synod doth, if they would not call it a formal governing of that particular Congregation: for example, in the Church of Pergamus, one ariseth and teacheth the doctrine of the Nicolaitans, suppose that fornication is indifferent is the eating of blood, and is no sin; the Angels of the Church of Pergamus preach against this doctrine, in private, they deal by force of arguments from Scripture, that it is a wicked doctrine, and destructive to holiness, as Paul and Barnab as disputeth, Act. 15. 1. 2. with the obtruders of a necessity of Circumcision, yet they prevail not, now suppose this independent Church following the Apostle Pauls way, think good to convene a Synod or a parishionall assembly to determine Synodically that this is a wicked doctrine, and shall in their decree call the holders of this doctrine subverters of souls, and forbid fornication in their Synod, now supposing Pergamus to be a single Church in a remote Island consociated with no neighbouring Churches, who could in reason deny that this Synodical power so enacting were a power formally governing the Church of. Pergamus? it is true, some of our brethren say, that it is even to us a received tenet that the power that disposeth of the means of governing doth not for that govern in respect that we teach that the classical presbytery doth decree and in act, and the Congregation doth execute these Decreed, but I pray you doth this prove that the power ordering the means of governing is no formal act of governing?
Answ. 1. The acts of Church-government finaliter, that is, ⟨p. 395⟩government, because to prescribe rules and directive Lawes (for they are not properly Lawes which the Church prescribeth, Christ is the onely Law-giver) are formall acts of governing, and one power doth not make Lawes for governing the Church, and another power different in nature punish the contraveners. And what power disposeth and ordereth, the meanes doe also dispose and order the end; Canons of the Church tending to the edification of the Church are meanes tending to the government of the Church, and I appeale to the judgement of our reverend brethren, if wee suppose that one single Congregation should doe all that this Synod doth, if they would not call it a formall governing of that particular Congregation: for example, in the Church of Pergamus, one ariseth and teacheth the doctrine of the Nicolaitans, suppose that fornication is indifferent is the eating of blood, and is no sinne; the Angels of the Church of Pergamus preach against this doctrine, in private, they deale by force of arguments from Scripture, that it is a wicked doctrine, and destructive to holinesse, as Paul and Barnab as disputeth, Act. 15. 1. 2. with the obtruders of a necessitie of Circumcision, yet they prevaile not, now suppose this independent Church following the Apostle Pauls way, thinke good to convene a Synod or a parishionall assembly to determine Synodically that this is a wicked doctrine, and shall in their decree call the holders of this doctrine subverters of soules, and forbid fornication in their Synod, now supposing Pergamus to be a single Church in a remote Iland consociated with no neighbouring Churches, who could in reason deny that this Synodicall power so inacting were a power formally governing the Church of. Pergamus? it is true, some of our brethren say, that it is even to us a received tenent that the power that disposeth of the meanes of governing doth not for that governe in respect that we teach that the classicall presbytery doth decree and in act, and the Congregation doth execute these Decreed, but I pray you doth this prove that the power ordering the meanes of governing is no formall act of governing?
yea the contrary is true, because the Congregation executing the acts of the classical presbytery, as subordinate in that act to the classical presbytery, & by their authority, therefore while they give out these acts or Canons, do formally govern, that Congregation executing their acts, in this particular.
yea the contrary is true, because the Congregation executing the acts of the classicall presbytery, as subordinat in that act to the classicall presbytery, & by their authority, therfore while they give out these acts or Canons, doe formally governe, that Congregation executing their acts, in this particular.
Mr. Mather and Mr. Thomson against Mr. Herle, c. 1. p. 9. teach that there is a power of clearing truth dogmatically, and that […] […], ultimately, where the controversy is ended, but they will have this ultimate power not in a Synod only, but also in a Congregation. But 1. they seem to make this dogmatical power a Church-power, and the exercise thereof formally an act of Church-government, and so it must be Church-power and Church-government in the Synod, as well as in the Congregation. 2. The last period and conclusion of the controversy cannot be both in the Congregation, de jure, by right only, and in the Synod by right only, for two last powers cannot be properly in two subordinate judicatures, for if Antioch appeal to a Synod, as they doc, Act. 15. 2. then Antioch is not the sole, last and ultimate and final judge; and 3. If the controversy concern many Churches, as this doth, Act. 15. 2. 23. 24. I see not how a Congregation, except they transgress their line, can finally determine it.
Mr. Mather and Mr. Thomson against Mr. Herle, c. 1. p. 9. teach that there is a power of clearing truth dogmatically, and that 〈…〉 〈…〉, ultimately, where the controversie is ended, but they will have this ultimate power not in a Synod onely, but also in a Congregation. But 1. they seeme to make this dogmaticall power a Church-power, and the exercise thereof formally an act of Church-government, and so it must bee Church-power and Church-government in the Synod, as well as in the Congregation. 2. The last period and conclusion of the controversie cannot bee both in the Congregation, de jure, by right onely, and in the Synod by right onely, for two last powers cannot bee properly in two subordinate judicatures, for if Antioch appeale to a Synod, as they doc, Act. 15. 2. then Antioch is not the sole, last and ultimate and finall judge; and 3. If the controversie concerne many Churches, as this doth, Act. 15. 2. 23. 24. I see not how a Congregation, except they transgresse their line, can finally determine it.
And here while as our brethren do all edge that a Synod hath a power to decree, and make laws, but hath no power at all to execute these Laws or to punish the contraveners, but power of punishing is all in the single Congregation. •. They tie all governing power to a punishing power, as if there were no other ways to govern, but upon supposal of scandals, whereas all Scripture and politicians make a power of giving Laws formally a governing power. 2. When one society and Synod maketh the Laws, and another must execute them and punish the contraveners, the single Congregation that punisheth, is more subjected by a truly prelatical bondage, then if the Law-makers had only the power of punishing the contraveners, at they only have the power of making the Laws. I take not here Laws for Laws properly so called, but for ministerial directories having ecclesiastical authority: and here in effect, our brethren lay truly a prelatical bondage on the Churches of Christ, for they teach that a Synod may make a Law by a pastoral power, and that this Synod is an ordinance of Christ by Act. 15. and that as Prelates did, they send those Synodical decrees to be obeyed and put in execution by the Churches, and ordain the contraveners to be punished by the Churches, and here is a power above a power, and mandates for government ⟨p. 397⟩sent by the Synod to the Churches to be obeyed, and a Synod governing by Churches, this they call prelatical in us.
And here while as our brethren doe all edge that a Synod hath a power to decree, and make lawes, but hath no power at all to execute these Lawes or to punish the contraveners, but power of punishing is all in the single Congregation. •. They tie all governing power to a punishing power, as if there were no other wayes to governe, but upon supposall of scandalls, whereas all Scripture and polliticians make a power of giving Lawes formally a governing power. 2. When one societie and Synod maketh the Lawes, and another must execute them and punish the contraveners, the single Congregation that punisheth, is more subjected by a truely prelaticall bondage, then if the Law-makers had onely the power of punishing the contraveners, at they onely have the power of making the Lawes. I take not here Lawes for Lawes properly so called, but for ministeriall directories having ecclesiasticall authoritie: and here in effect, our brethren lay truely a prelaticall bondage on the Churches of Christ, for they teach that a Synod may make a Law by a pastorall power, and that this Synod is an ordinance of Christ by
But 3. there is no penal power here (say they) and nothing deserved to be obeyed, sub paena, under the pain of excommunication, therefore no power of jurisdiction. But this consequence is justly denied, for no politician, no reason in the world can say that all power of jurisdiction is included in the power of excommunication. What? hath the Church a Church-power to threaten, and no Church-power to pardon the penitent? I think if the Church as the Church, Matth. 18. receive a power from Christ to bind in heaven and earth, doth not Christ in that same patent give to her also a power to loose in earth and heaven? and when he saith, if be refuse to bear the Church, let him be to thee • aube•hen and publican; doth he not give to the Church a power to command? if he command to hear and obey the Church, he must give a power of jurisdiction to the Church to command, and a power to command not penal only, but promissory also, to loose and absolve upon condition of professed repentance. Now suppose the Church make a Law, that the resurrection of the dead is a truth of God to be believed, and professed, upon occasion that in the Congregation Hymeneus & Alexander den yeth that Article, in that very Commandment doctrinal the Church doth govern the whole Congregation, and exerciseth a power of formal governing, though in their act they say nothing of the censure of excommunication, to those who shall deny that Article of the resurrection, for (I hope) a simple sanction maketh a Law, though no penalty be expressed in it, and though there had been in the Decree, Act 15. 28. an express punishment, this should, to our brethren prove no power of jurisdiction exercised by many, for this which is said, Gal. 1. 8. Though we or an Angel from heaven preach unto you (another Gospel) then that which we have preached let him be accursed, and that 1 Cor. 9. 16. Woe unto me if I preach not the Gospel, and many other threatenings in Scripture, though a punishment be annexed expressly, cease not to be merely doctrinal, and are not threatenings importing formally any power of Church-jurisdiction, and therefore ⟨p. 398⟩though mention should have been made of a censure, if there be not here a Synod. 2. Having power and authority from Christ. 3. Commanding by the holy Ghost, (as these indeed are all here) the name of censure should prove no power of jurisdiction.
But 3. there is no penall power here (say they) and nothing decerved to bee obeyed, sub paena, under the paine of excommunication, therefore no power of jurisdiction. But this consequence is justly denyed, for no politician, no reason in the world can say that all power of jurisdiction is included in the power of excommunication. What? hath the Church a Church-power to threaten, and no Church-power to pardon the penltent? I think if the Church as the Church, Matth. 18. receive a power from Christ to bind in heaven and earth, doth not Christ in that same patent give to her also a power to loose in earth and heaven? and when hee saith, if bee refuse to beare the Church, let him be to thee • aube•hen and publican; doth hee not give to the Church a power to command? if hee command to heare and obey the Church, hee must give a power of jurisdiction to the Church to command, and a power to command not penall onely, but promissorie also, to loose and absolve upon condition of prosessed repentance. Now suppose the Church make a Law, that theresurrection of the dead is a truth of God to bee beleeved, and professed, upon occasion that in the Congregation Hymeneus & Alexander den yeth that Article, in that very Commandement doctrinall the Church doth governe the whole Congregation, and exerciseth a power of formall governing, though in their act they say nothing of the censure of excommunication, to those who shall deny that Article of the resurrection, for (I hope) a simple sanction maketh a Law, though no penaltie bee expressed in it, and though there had beene in the Decree, Act 15. 28. an expresse punishment, this should, to our brethren prove no power of jurisdiction exercised by many, for this which is said, Gal. 1. 8. Though wee or an Angel from heaven preach unto you (another Gospel) then that which wee have preached let him bee accursed, and that 1 Cor. 9. 16. Woe unto mee if I preach not the Gospel, and many other threatnings in Scripture, though a punishment bee annexed expressely, cease not to bee meerely doctrinall, and are not threatnings importing formally any power of Church-jurisdiction, and therefore ⟨p. 398⟩though mention should have beene made of a censure, if there bee not here a Synod. 2. Having power and authoritie from Christ. 3. Commanding by the holy Ghost, (as these indeed are all here) the name of censure should prove no power of jurisdiction.