He meaneth here of Kings indefinitely, who oppressed the people with taxes and tributes, as Solomon and others. (q)Cornelius a lapide: This was an unjust law. (r)Cajetanus ⟨p. 133⟩calleth it, tyranny. (s)Hugo Cardinal, nameth them, exactiones & servitutes, exactions and slaveries: And (t)Serrarius, he speaketh not here, Quid Reges jure possint, What they may do by right and law; Sed quid audeant, What they will be bold to do, and what they tyrannically discern against all Laws of nature and humanity. And so (u)speaketh Tho. Aquinas: (x)So also Mendoza, saith he, speaketh of the law of Tyrants: and (y)amongst the fathers, Clemens Alexandrinus saith on this place, Non humanum pollicetur dominum, sed insolentem daturum minatur tyrannum, He promiseth not a humane Prince, but threateneth to give them an insolent Tyrant; and the like also saith (z)Bede. And an excellent (a)Lawyer, Pet. Rebuffus saith, Etiam loquitur de Tyranno qui non erat a Deo electus. And that he speaketh of Sauls Tyrannical usurpation, and not of the law prescribed by God, Deut. 17. I prove, 1. He speaketh of such a power, as is answerable to the Acts here spoken of; but the Acts here spoken of, are Acts of mere tyranny, Vers. 11. And this will be the manner of your King, that shall reign over you, he will take your sons, and appoint them for himself, for his Chariots, and to be his horsemen, and some shall run before his Chariots: Now to make slaves of their sons, was an Act of Tyranny. 2. To take their fields and vineyards, and oliveyards from them, and give them to his servants, was no better then Ahab's taking Naboths vineyard from him, which by Gods law he might not lawfully sell, except in the case of extreme poverty, and then in the year of Jubilee, he might redeem his own inheritance. 3. Verse 15, 16. To put the people of God to bondage and make them servants, was to deal with them, as the Tyrant Pharaoh did. 4. He speaketh of such a law, the execution whereof should make them cry out to the Lord, because of their King: but the execution of the just Law of the King, Deut. 17. is a blessing, and not a bondage which should make the people cry out of the bitterness of their spirit. 5. It is clear here, that God is by his Prophet, not instructing the King in his duty, but as (b)Rabbi Levi Ben.
He meaneth here of Kings indefinitely, who oppressed the people with taxes and tributes, as Solomon and others. (q)Cornelius a lapide: This was an unjust law. (r)Cajetanus ⟨p. 133⟩calleth it, tyranny. (s)Hugo Cardinal, nameth them, exactiones & servitutes, exactions and slaveries: And (t)Serrarius, he speaketh not here, Quid Reges jure possint, What they may do by right and law; Sed quid audeant, What they will be bold to do, and what they tyrannically decern against all Laws of nature and humanitie. And so (u)speaketh Tho. Aquinas: (x)So also Mendoza, saith he, speaketh of the law of Tyrants: and (y)amongst the fathers, Clemens Alexandrinus saith on this place, Non humanum pollicetur dominum, sed insolentem daturum minatur tyrannum, He promiseth not a humane Prince, but threatneth to give them an insolent Tyrant; and the like also saith (z)Beda. And an excellent (a)Lawyer, Pet. Rebuffus saith, Etiam loquitur de Tyranno qui non erat a Deo electus. And that he speaketh of Sauls Tyrannicall usurpation, and not of the law prescribed by God, Deut. 17. I prove, 1. He speaketh of such a power, as is answerable to the Acts here spoken of; but the Acts here spoken of, are Acts of meere tyranny, Vers. 11. And this will be the manner of your King, that shall reign over you, he will take your sons, and appoint them for himself, for his Chariots, and to be his horsemen, and some shall run before his Chariots: Now to make slaves of their sons, was an Act of Tyranny. 2. To take their fields and vineyards, and oliveyards from them, and give them to his servants, was no better then Ahabs taking Naboths vineyard from him, which by Gods law he might not lawfully sell, except in the case of extreme povertie, and then in the yeer of Jubilee, he might redeem his own inheritance. 3. Verse 15, 16. To put the people of God to bondage and make them servants, was to deal with them, as the Tyrant Pharaoh did. 4. He speaketh of such a law, the execution whereof should make them cry out to the Lord, because of their King: but the execution of the just Law of the King,
- (q)Cornelius a Lapid. in locum.
- (r)Cajetan. in locum.
- (s)Hugo Cardinal. in loc.
- (t)Serrarius in locum.
- (u)Thom. Aquin. l. 3. de Regni Princip. c. 11.
- (x)Mendoza, jus Tyrannorum.
- (y)Clemens Alexand. pag. 26.
- (z)Bede, l. 2 expo. in SamuelBeda, l. 2 expo. in Samuel
- (a)Petrus Robuffus tract. d• incongrua. prert. p. 110. Osiander, he setteth not down the Office of the King, what he ought to be, but what manner of King they should have. Pelican. that ruled by will, not by law. Willet. Such as decline to Tyranny. Borhaius, Tyrants, not Kings.Petrus Robuffus tract. d• incongrua. prert. p. 110. Osiander, he setteth not down the Office of the King, what he ought to be, but what man•ner of King they should have. Pelican. that ruled by will, not by law. Willet. Such as decline to Tyranny. Borhaius, Tyrants, not Kings.
- (b)Rabb. Levi Ben. Gersom. in 1 Sam. 8. Pezelius in exp. leg. Mosai. l. 4. c. 8. Tossan. in not. Bibl. Bosseus de Rep. Christ. potest. supra regem, c. 2. n. 103. Bodin. de Rep. l. 1. • 19. Brentius, homil. 27. in 1 Sam. 8. Mos regis non de jure, sed de vulgatâ consuctudin•.