Poor soul, suffer not thy self to be instructed by them that labour to deprive thee not only of the comfort of Gods grace, but of the comfort of common sense: Dost thou well understand what it is to hate a man as a sinner, and not as a man? If hatred be no more then displeasure; surely whatsoever be the cause of it, in hating thee he is displeased with thee, as thou art his creature, and that in thy proper kind of man; if withal it signify punishment, whatsoever the cause thereof be, surely he punisheth thee as man, though not for thy natures sake, for that is the work of God, but for some corruption he finds in thee. And we should prove very sorry comforters; if on such a distinction as this, we should ground any true consolation; which hath his course not only with the Devils, but even with them that are already under the torments of Hell fire. But let not the authority of the book of Wisdom, with thee weigh up and elevate the authority of Scriptures; nor Philo the Jew be preferred before St Paul, or the Prophet Malachi, by whom we are taught that as God loved Jacob before he was borne, so he hated Esau; and before they were borne, what difference was there between them? Yet this passage out of the book of Wisdom is in a Collect of the Papists Liturgy; I conceive a good sense may be made thereof without any prejudice to absolute reprobation, (for of Papists we ate said to have learnt it and are reproached for it.) And what is that good sense they make of it? Take it if thou wilt from Aquinas 1. q: 23. art 3: ad. 1. Dicendum quod Deus omnes homines diligit, & etiam omnes creaturas in quantum omnibus vult aliquod bonum: non tamen quodcunque bonum vult omnibus; In quantum igitur quibusdam non vult hoc bonum, quod est vita aeterna, dicitur eos habere odio, vel reprobare: Now if we take this Collect from them, let us take also their good meaning with it; and if we can, let us make it better and not worse. We commonly say, that passions are attributed to God not quoad affectum, ⟨p. 269⟩but quoad effectum: Now the effect of hatred is either the denial of grace, or the denial of glory, or the inflicting of damnation; The two latter are executed only according to mens sins; but the first, to wit, the denial of grace, proceeds merely according to the good pleasure of Gods will;
Pooresoule, suffer not thy selfe to be instructed by them that labour to deprive thee not only of the comfort of Gods grace, but of the comfort of common sence: Dost thou well understand what it is to hate a man as a sinner, and not as a man? If hatred be no more then displeasure; surely whatsoever be the cause of it, in hating thee he is displeased with thee, as thou art his creature, and that in thy proper kind of man; if withall it signify punishment, whatsoever the cause thereof be, surely he punisheth thee as man, though not for thy natures sake, for that is the worke of God, but for some corruption he finds in thee. And we should prove very sorry comforters; if on such a distinction as this, we should ground any true consolation; which hath his course not only with the Devills, but even with them that are already under the torments of Hell fire. But let not the authority of the booke of Wisdome, with thee weigh up and elevate the authority of Scriptures; nor Philo the Jew be preferred before St Paul, or the Prophet Malachy, by whom wee are taught that as God loved Jacob before he was borne, so he hated Esau; and before they were borne, what difference was there betweene them? Yet this passage out of the booke of Wisdome is in a Collect of the Papists Liturgy; I conceive a good sence may be made thereof without any prejudice to absolute reprobation, (for of Papists we ate sayd to have learnt it and are reproached for it.) And what is that good sense they make of it? Take it if thou wilt from Aquinas 1. q: 23. art 3: ad. 1. Dicendum quod Deus omnes homines diligit, & etiam omnes creaturas in quantum omnibus vult aliquod bonum: non tamen quodcunque bonum vult omnibus; In quantum igitur quibusdam non vult hoc bonum, quod est vita aeterna, dicitur eos habere odio, vel reprobare: Now if we take this Colect from them, let us take also their good meaning with it; and if we can, let us make it better and not worse. We commonly say, that passions are attributed to God not quoad affectum, ⟨p. 269⟩but quoad effectum: Now the effect of hatred is either the denyall of grace, or the denyall of glory, or the inflicting of damnation; The two latter are executed only according to mens sinnes; but the first, to wit, the denyall of grace, proceeds meerely according to the good pleasure of Gods will;