DISCOURSE. SECT. II.
pp. 264–27888 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 264–27888 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
IT leaves men in temptation: and this it doth two ways, First by making the tempted uncapable of true comfort. 2. By making Ministers unable to give true comfort. First it maketh the tempted uncapable of true comfort; like a Gorgons head, it doth so trouble their fancies, and amaze them, especially in their paroxysms and fits, that the strongest arguments of comfort, applied with as much art and cunning as can be, will not fasten upon them. With David they say in their fear, that all men are liars, namely, all such as come to comfort them in their temptation: And the reason is, because it is an opinion incompatible with any word of comfort, that can be ministered to the distressed soul in this temptation. Gods love to mankind, Christs death for all mankind, and the calling of poor sinners without exception to repentance or salvation, with all other grounds of consolation. the tempted will easily elude with the grounds of his opinion: which that we may the better see, let us imagine that we hear a Minister and a tempted soul, reasoning in this or the like manner.
IT leaves men in temptation: and this it doth two waies, First by making the tempted uncapable of true comfort. 2. By making Ministers unable to give true comfort. First it maketh the tempted uncapable of true comfort; like a Gorgons head, it doth so trouble their fancies, and amaze them, especially in their paroxysmes and fits, that the strongest arguments of comfort, applyed with as much art and cunning as can be, will not fasten upon them. With David they say in their feare, that all men are lyars, namely, all such as come to comfort them in their temptation: And the reason is, because it is an opinion incompatible with any word of comfort, that can be ministred to the distressed soule in this temptation. Gods love to mankind, Christs death for all mankind, and the calling of poore sinners without exception to repentance or salvation, with all other grounds of consolation. the tempted will easily elude with the grounds of his opinion: which that we may the better see, let us imagine that we heare a Minister and a tempted soule, reasoning in this or the like manner.
Tempted. Woe is me; I am a castaway: I am absolutely rejected from Grace and glory.
Minister. Discourage not thy self thou poor afflicted soul; God hath not cast thee off. For he hateth nothing that he hath made; but bears a love to all men, and to thee amongst the rest.
Minister. Discourage not thy selfe thou poore afflicted soule; God hath not cast thee off. For he hateth nothing that he hath made; but bears a love to all men, and to thee amongst the rest.
Tempted. God hateth no man as he is his creature, but he hateth a great many as they are involved in the first transgression, and become guilty of Adams sin. And God hath a two-fold love, (as I have learned,) a general love, which puts forth it self in outward and temporal blessings only, and with this he loved all men: And a special love, by which he provideth everlasting life for men, and with this he loves only a very few, which out of his alone will and pleasure he singled from the rest. Under this general love am I, not the special.
Tempted. God hateth no man as he is his creature, but he hateth a great many as they are involv'd in the first transgression, and become guilty of Adams sinne. And God hath a two-fold love, (as I have learned,) a generall love, which puts forth it selfe in outward and temporall blessings only, and with this he loved all men: And a speciall love, by which he provideth everlasting life for men, and with this he loves only a very few, which out of his alone will and pleasure he singled from the rest. Under this generall love am I, not the speciall.
Minister. God so loves all men, as that he desires their eternal good, for the Apostle saith, he would have all to be saved, and he would have no man perish, nor thee in particular.
Minister. God so loves all men, as that he desires their eternall good, for the Apostle saith, he would have all to be saved, and he would have no man perish, nor thee in particular.
Tempted. All, is taken two ways: for all sorts and conditions of men, high and low, rich and poor, bond and free, Jew and Gentile; and for all particular men in those several sorts and conditions. God would have all sorts of men to be saved, but not all particular men of these sorts; some of my Country, and my calling, &c. but not all; or me in particular. Or if it be true that God would have all particular men to be saved; yet he wills it only with a revealed Will, not with a secret will, for with that he will have a great company to be damned absolutely. Under this revealed will am I, not the secret.
Tempted. All, is taken two waies: for all sorts and conditions of men, high and low, rich and poore, bond and free, Jew and Gentile; and for all particular men in those severall sorts and conditions. God would have all sorts of men to be saved, but not all particular men of these sorts; some of my Country, and my calling, &c. but not all; or mee in particular. Or if it be true that God would have all particular men to be saved; yet he wills it only with a revealed Will, not with a secret will, for with that he will have a great company to be damned absolutely. Under this revealed will am I, not the secret.
Minister. Christ came into the World to seek and to save what was lost, and is a propitiation not for our sins only, (idest) the sins of a few particular men, or the sins of all sorts of men, but for the sins of the whole world; therefore he came to save thee, for thou wast lost, and to be a propitiation for thy sins, for thou art part of the whole world.
Minister. Christ came into the World to seeke and to save what was lost, and is a propitiation not for our sinnes only, (idest) the sinnes of a few particular men, or the sinnes of all sorts of men, but for the sinnes of the whole world; therefore he came to save thee, for thou wast lost, and to be a propitiation for thy sinnes, for thou art part of the whole world.
Tempted. The World, as I have heard, is taken two ways in Scripture; largely for all mankind, and strictly in a more restrained signification, for the elect, or for believers: Or if it be true that he dyed for all mankind, yet he dyed for them but after a sort, he dyed for them all dignitate pretii, he did enough to have redeemed all, if God would have had it so: but he did not dye for all voluntate propositi, God never intended that he should shed his blood for all, and every man; but for a few select ones only, with whom it is my lot not to be numbered.
Tempted. The World, as I have heard, is taken two waies in Scripture; largely for all mankind, and strictly in a more restrained signification, for the elect, or for believers: Or if it be true that he dyed for all mankind, yet he dyed for them but after a sort, he dyed for them all dignitate pretii, he did enough to have redeemed all, if God would have had it so: but he did not dye for all voluntate propositi, God never intended that he should shed his bloud for all, and every man; but for a few select ones only, with whom it is my lot not to be numbred.
Minister. God hath founded an universally Covenant with men, upon the blood of Christ thy Mediator, and therefore he intended it should be shed for all men universally. He hath made a promise of salvation to every one that will believe, and excludes none, that do not exclude themselves.
Minister. God hath founded an universali Covenant with men, upon the blood of Christ thy Mediator, and therefore he intended it should be shed for all men universally. He hath made a promise of salvation to every one that will believe, and excludes none, that doe not exclude themselves.
Tempted. God purposed his Son should dye for all men, and that in his name an offer of remission of sins and salvation should be made to every one but yet upon this condition, that they will do that which he means the greatest part of them shall never do, (idest) Repent and Believe, nor I among the rest.
Tempted. God purposed his Sonne should dye for all men, and that in his name an offer of remission of sinnes and salvation should be made to every one but yet upon this condition, that they will doe that which he meanes the greatest part of them shall never doe, (idest) Repent and Believe, nor I among the rest.
Minister. God hath a true meaning that all men who are called, should repent and believe; that so they might be saved: as he would have all to be saved, so to come to the knowledge of the truth; and as he would have no man to perish, so he would have all men to repent; and therefore he calls them in the Preaching of the word to the one, as well as to the other.
Tempted. God hath a double call; an outward call by the Preaching of the word, an inward call by the irresistible work of the spirit in mens hearts. The outward call is a part of Gods outward will, with that he calls every man to believe; the inward and effectual call is a part of his secret will, and with that he doth not call every man to believe, but a very few only whom he hath infallibly and inevitably ordained to eternal life. And therefore by the outward will, which I enjoy among many others, I cannot be assured of Gods good will and meaning that I shall believe, repent, and be saved.
Tempted. God hath a double call; an outward call by the Preaching of the word, an inward call by the irresistible work of the spirit in mens hearts. The outward call is a part of Gods outward will, with that he calls every man to believe; the inward and effectuall call is a part of his secret will, and with that he doth not call every man to believe, but a very few only whom he hath infallibly and inevitably ordained to eternall life. And therefore by the outward will, which I enjoy among many others, I cannot be assured of Gods good will and meaning that I shall believe, repent, and be saved.
By this we may see, that no sound comfort can be fastened upon a poor soul, rooted in this opinion, when he lies under this horrible temptation; The example of Francis Spira an Italian Lawyer, will give some farther light and proof to this. This Spira about the year 1548, against his knowledge and conscience did openly abjure his religion, and subscribe to Popery; that thereby he might preserve his life, and goods, and liberty. Not long after he fell into a deep distress of Conscience out of which he could never wrestle, but ended his woeful days in despair. To comfort him came many Divines of worth and note; but against all the comforts that they applied unto him, he opposed two things especially. 1. The greatness of his sin: It was a sin of a deep dye, committed with many urging and aggravating circumstances, and therefore could not be forgiven. This argument they quickly took from him, and convinced him by the example of Peter, that there was nothing in his sin, that could make it irremissible. Peter that committed the same sin, and with more odious circumstances, repented and was pardoned, and so (no doubt) might he. 2: He opposed his absolute reprobation; and with that he put off all their comforts. Peter (saith he) repented and was pardoned indeed, because he was elected: as for me I was utterly rejected before I was borne; and therefore I cannot possibly repent, or be saved. If any man be elected he shall be saved, though he have committed sins, for number many, and heinous in degree: but if he be (ex repudiatis) one of the castaways, necessario condemnabitur: though his sins be small and sew. Nihil interest, an multa, an pauca, an magna, an parva sint, quando nec Dei misericordia, nec sanguis Christi quicquam ad eos pertinet. A reprobate must be damned, be his sins many or few, great or small; because Gods mercy, and Christs merits belong not to him. In this very story, (recorded by Coelius Secundus, and Calvin, with some others who lived at that time, and wrote of it to their friends;) as in a glass we may see the disconsolate condition of a poor soul, that is strongly conceited, that the greatest part of the world, are absolute reprobates, and that he is one of them; he sticketh so fast in the mire and clay, that he can very hardly be drawn out.
By this we may see, that no sound comfort can be fastned upon a poore soule, rooted in this opinion, when he lyes under this horrible temptation; The example of Francis Spira an Italian Lawyer, will give some farther light and proofe to this. This Spira about the yeare 1548, against his knowledge and conscience did openly abjure his religion, and subscribe to Popery; that thereby he might preserve his life, and goods, and liberty. Not long after he fell into a deep distresse of Conscience out of which he could never wrestle, but ended his woefull daies in despaire. To comfort him came many Divines of worth and note; but against all the comforts that they applyed unto him, he opposed two things especially. 1. The greatnesse of his sinne: It was a sinne of a deep dye, commited with many urging and aggravating circumstances, and therefore could not be forgiven. This argument they quickly took from him, and convinced him by the example of Peter, that there was nothing in his sinne, that could make it irremissible. Peter that committed the same sinne, and with more odious circumstances, repented and was pardoned, and so (no doubt) might he. 2: He opposed his absolute reprobation; and with that he put off all their comforts. Peter (saith he) repented and was pardoned indeed, because he was elected: as for me I was utterly rejected before I was borne; and therefore I cannot possibly repent, or be saved. If any man be elected he shall be saved, though he have committed sinnes, for number many, and haynous in degree: but if he be (ex repudiatis) one of the castawaies, necessario condemnabitur: though his sinnes be small and sew. Nihil interest, an multa, an pauca, an magna, an parva sint, quando nec Dei misericordia, nec sanguis Christi quicquam ad eos pertinet. A reprobate must be damned, be his sinnes many or few, great or small; because Gods mercy, and Christs merits belong not to him. In this very story, (recorded by Coelius Secundus, and Calvin, with some others who lived at that time, and wrote of it to their friends;) as in a glasse we may see the disconsolate condition of a poore soule, that is strongly conceited, that the greatest part of the world, are absolute reprobates, and that he is one of them; he sticketh so fast in the mire and clay, that he can very hardly be drawne out.
This Section I may fitly divide into two parts. The first whereof is a pretty Comedy. The second a Tragedy. The first is practised by this Author in a dialogue, shaped by himself and accordingly accommodated to his own stage, as an Interlude of his own making. The Tragedy is related only of Francis Spira; and I willingly confess, It is the strangest that ever, I heard or read, of a man going on soberly to the utter undoing of himself both body and soul. But the relation of it is most hungrily performed by this Author as if his care were ⟨p. 266⟩only to serve his own turn, and then cares not what becomes of the main condition of the story, which indeed is most remarkable: I have but touched upon it in former passages, but here I shall insist upon it more at large; and the rather, because it is here proposed not more unfaithfully then impiously, to deface or out-face the precious truth of God concerning his absoluteness in making whom he will a vessel of wrath. But first I must dispatch my answer to the Antegredients of those two parts. And let it be remembered what formerly I have delivered, that still he confounds reprobation from grace, with reprobation from glory; as if we maintained the absoluteness of the one, as well as we do maintain the absoluteness of the other; which is most untrue. For albeit, we maintain that God hath decreed absolutely to bestow grace upon some, (which are Gods elect,) and absolutely to deny grace unto others, (whom we account Reprobates here upon,) not conditionally; for if grace were ordained to be bestowed conditionally, to wit, upon condition of some work performed by man; then should grace be bestowed according unto works, which in the phrase of the Ancients is all one, with saying, that grace is bestowed according unto merits. And this was condemned above 1200 years ago in the Synod of Palestine, & Pelagius driven to subscribe unto it, lest otherwise himself had bin excommunicated. But we, do not maintain that God hath ordained that damnation shall be absolutely inflicted on any but only conditionally, to wit, in case they dye in sin.
THis Section I may fitly divide into two parts. The first whereof is a pretty Comedy. The second a Tragedy. The first is practised by this Authour in a dialogue, shaped by himselfe and accordingly accomodated to his owne stage, as an Enterlude of his owne making. The Tragedy is related only of Francis Spira; and I willingly confesse, It is the strangest that ever, I heard or read, of a man going on soberly to the utter undoing of himselfe both body and soule. But the relation of it is most hungryly performed by this Authour as if his care were ⟨p. 266⟩only to serve his owne turne, and then cares not what becomes of the maine condition of the story, which indeed is most remarkable: I have but touched upon it in former passages, but here I shall insist upon it more at large; and the rather, because it is here proposed not more unfaithfully then impiously, to deface or out-face the precious truth of God concerning his absolutenesse in making whom he will a vessell of wrath. But first I must dispatch my answer to the Antegredients of those two parts. And let it be remembred what formerly I have delivered, that still he confounds reprobation from grace, with reprobation from glory; as if we maintained the absolutenesse of the one, as well as we do maintain the absolutenesse of the other; which is most untrue. For albeit, we maintaine that God hath decreed absolutely to bestow grace upon some, (which are Gods elect,) and absolutely to deny grace unto others, (whom we account Reprobates here upon,) not conditionally; for if grace were ordayned to be bestowed conditionally, to wit, upon condition of some worke performed by man; then should grace be bestowed according unto workes, which in the phrase of the Ancients is all one, with saying, that grace is bestowed according unto merits. And this was condemned above 1200 yeares agoe in the Synod of Palestine, & Pelagius driven to subscribe unto it, lest otherwise himselfe had bin excommunicated. But we, doe not maintain that God hath ordayned that damnation shall be absolutely inflicted on any but only conditionally, to wit, in case they dye in sin.
Yet it became this Authors wisdom to confound them, least distinguishing them as they ought to be distinguished, & carrying himself fairly in opposing the absoluteness of reprobation there alone, where alone it is maintained by his adversaries, to wit, in the particular of reprobation from grace, he should at first dash manifest himself to maintain, that grace is bestowed not according to the good pleasure of God, but according to the works of men; and that upon this ground it is, that he buildeth the comfortable condition of his doctrine, concerning predestination, which indeed makes no difference in Gods proceedings between the elect and reprobate, but respects them all alike; For their power to believe and repent is their grace universal, which they say is given to all alike. So exciting grace in the ministry of the Word is equally made to all that hear it, whether elect or reprobate. And these are the kinds of grace prevenient: Then as for grace subsequent, that consists only in Gods concurrence unto the act of faith and repentance which depends merely upon mans will (in their opinion) and God is as ready to concur to the working of it as well in one as in another, in case man will. On the other side it would appear that our doctrine is censured as uncomfortable, only because it teacheth man for the obtaining of true comfort to depend merely upon the grace of God, and not upon his own free-will.
Yet it became this Authors wisdom to confound them, least distinguishing them as they ought to be distinguished, & carrying himselfe fairly in opposing the absolutenes of reprobation there alone, where alone it is maintained by his adversaries, to wit, in the particular of reprobation from grace, he should at first dash manifest himselfe to maintain, that grace is bestowed not according to the good pleasure of God, but according to the workes of men; and that upon this ground it is, that he buildeth the comfortable condition of his doctrine, concerning predestination, which indeed makes no difference in Gods proceedings between the elect and reprobate, but respects them all alike; For their power to believe and repent is their grace universall, which they say is given to all alike. So exciting grace in the ministry of the Word is equally made to all that heare it, whether elect or reprobate. And these are the kinds of grace prevenient: Then as for grace subsequent, that consists only in Gods concurrence unto the act of faith and repentance which depends meerely upon mans will (in their opinion) and God is as ready to concurre to the working of it as well in one as in another, in case man will. On the other side it would appeare that our doctrine is censured as uncomfortable, only because it teacheth man for the obtaining of true comfort to depend meerely upon the grace of God, and not upon his owne free-will.
Again, observe how that like as Gregory observes that the same spirit of Antichrist might be found in them that are far distant in time, so an Arminian spirit savoureth the same things one with an other, and perhaps at unawares, though they in whom it is found be much distant in place. Vossius in his last book of his History of the Pelagian heresy saith, That our Divines do allege that place of St Paul against their adversaries in the point of predestination, as the head of Medusa; a place indeed that clearly justifies Gods absoluteness both in predestination and reprobation: And this Author sayeth that our doctrine on the same point is like to Gorgons head: Now the Learned well know that Gorgon and Medusa's head have no difference. Now whether our doctrine be so uncomfortable as this Author objects, it will appear when we come to examine the paroxysm and fit of temptation, especially the kind of it being such, as this Author out of his fruitful invention hath made choice of to represent, as able to elude the strongest arguments of comfort, and they applied with as much art and cunning as can be; supposing that of this art and cunning also, he hath given plentiful testimony in the succeeding dialogue; which is a very remarkable passage of this Authors sufficiency, especially coming out of his own mouth; Of the integrity whereof there seems no cause to doubt, considering that Arminian ingenuity and modesty whereunto he hath lately arrived.
Againe, observe how that like as Gregory observes that the same spirit of Antichrist might be found in them that are farre distant in time, so an Arminian spirit savoreth the same things one with an other, and perhaps at unawars, though they in whom it is found be much distant in place. Vossius in his last booke of his History of the Pelagian heresy sayth, That our Divines doe aleadge that place of St Paul against their adversaries in the poynt of predestination, as the head of Medusa; a place indeed that clearely justifies Gods absolutenesse both in predestination and reprobation: And this Authour sayeth that our doctrine on the same poynt is like to Gorgons head: Now the Learned well know that Gorgon and Medusas head have no difference. Now whether our doctrine be so uncomfortable as this Authour objects, it will appeare when we come to examine the paroxysme and fit of temptation, especially the kind of it being such, as this Authour out of his fruitfull invention hath made choyce of to represent, as able to elude the strongest arguments of comfort, and they applyed with as much art and cunning as canne be; supposing that of this art and cunning also, he hath given plentifull testimony in the succeeding dialogue; which is a very remarkeable passage of this Authours sufficiency, especially comming out of his owne mouth; Of the integrity whereof there seemes no cause to doubt, considering that Arminian ingenuity and modesty whereunto he hath lately arrived.
He further adds as much weight to his former assertions as words can, which though they be but wind, yet with some, who Chameleon like live by the air, may prove very weighty, saying, that this doctrine of ours is incompatible with any word of comfort (which is very much, though a word and any word be very little) that can be ministered to a distressed soul in this temptation. Now it is very likely that in his dialogue ⟨p. 267⟩following he brings in as potent arguments of consolation, as our doctrine will afford. The heads or places of consolation he reckons up, Gods love to mankind, Christs death for all mankind, and the calling of poor sinners without exception to repentance and Salvation with all other grounds of comfort, and all arguments (he sayeth) drawn from hence our opinion will elude and preclude all consolation from the distressed soul. But give me leave to make a fair motion as touching the special heads of consolation here particulated. If it shall be found that these heads of consolation do admit a double sense, one of the Arminian making, an other of our interpreting; if consolations drawn therefrom in an Arminian sense be eluded by our Tenet, will any disparagement thereby arise to our tenet, provided we find store of consolation from them taken in our sense, especially being ready to admit any indifferent trial concerning the sense thereof, whether theirs or ours prove most agreeable to the word of God; But Ecce Rhodus, ecce Saltus, we are come to the Dialogue it self, where he undertakes to make good, that which he saith And here begins the Interlude.
He further addes as much weight to his former assertions as words can, which though they be but wind, yet with some, who Camelion like live by the ayre, may prove very weighty, saying, that this doctrine of ours is incompatable with any word of comfort (which is very much, though a word and any word be very little) that can be ministred to a distressed soule in this temptation. Now it is very likely that in his dialogue ⟨p. 267⟩following he brings in as potent arguments of consolation, as our doctrine will afford. The heads or placss of consolation he reckons up, Gods love to mankind, Christs death for all mankind, and the calling of poore sinners without exception to repentance and Salvation with all other grounds of comfort, and all arguments (he sayeth) drawne from hence our opinion will elude and preclude all consolation from the distressed soule. But give me leave to make a faire motion as touching the speciall heades of consolation here particulated. If it shall be found that these heads of consolation doe admit a double sense, one of the Arminian making, an other of our interpreting; if consolations drawne therefrom in an Arminian sence be eluded by our Tenet, will any disparagement thereby arise to our tenet, provided we find store of consolatiō from them taken in our sense, especially being ready to admit any indifferent tryal concerning the sense thereof, whether theirs or ours prove most agreeable to the word of God; But Ecce Rhodus, ecce Saltus, we are come to the Dialogue it selfe, where he undertakes to make good, that which he saith And here begins the Enterlude.
Woe is me; I am a Castaway; I am utterly rejected from grace and Glory.
Let me take liberty to set down what I should think fit to answer unto such a complaint, Now my Answer is this, Who hath revealed this unto thee? Art thou privy Counsellor to the Almighty? We are taught that secret things belong to the Lord our God, 1but the things revealed are for us and for our Children to do them. Now where, and when, and how hath God revealed this his counsel unto thee, namely, concerning thy rejection from Grace, & Glory? We know no other revelations divine then are contained in his Word: Now hath God in his word revealed unto thee more then unto me that thou art a reprobate. The word saith unto thee, If thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus: and believe in thy heart that God raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved, Rom: 10. 9. Now how canst thou make it appear that this belongs less unto thee then to any Martyr that ever was content to lay down his life for Christ? Wilt thou say, Thy sins make thee to conceive so: I answer, are thy sins greater then were the sins of Manasseh, who made his sons pass through the fire to Molech, gave himself to witchcraft and sorcery, and filled Jerusalem with blood from corner to corner? If his sins were not sufficient to conclude that he was a Reprobate, why should thy sins be thought sufficient to conclude that thou art a Cast-away? Are thy sins greater then Sauls were, who was a Blasphemer, a Persecutor of the Saints of God from City to City; Yet was he received unto mercy. Wilt thou say, Thy sins have been committed since thy calling? Yet are they greater then was the sin of Peter, in denying Christ his Master, with execrations and oaths? And these sins were committed not only after his calling; but even within his Masters hearing too. Yet he went out and wept bitterly. And Christ as soon as he was risen, sent word of his resurrection by name to Peter to comfort him. Nay hath not God taught us in his word, that the blood of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin, 1 John. 1.? And how canst thou make it appear, that any one that ever was or is, hath greater interest therein then thy self? wilt thou say this remedy belongs unto none, but such as believe and repent; but I do not. I answer, in like sort there was a time when Paul believed not, and when every one believed not; yet at length they believed, and so mayest thou:
Let me take liberty to set down what I should think fit to answer unto such a complaint, Now my Answer is this, Who hath revealed this unto thee? Art thou privy Councellour to the Almighty? We are taught that secret things belong to the Lord our God, 1but the things revealed are for us and for our Children to doe them. Now where, and when, and how hath God revealed this his counsell unto thee, namely, concerning thy rejection from Grace, & Glory? We know no other revelations divine then are contayned in his Word: Now hath God in his word revealed unto thee more then unto me that thou art a reprobate. The word saith unto thee, If thou shalt confesse with thy mouth the Lord Jesus: and believe in thy heart that God raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved, Rom: 10. 9. Now how canst thou make it appeare that this belongs lesse unto thee then to any Martyr that ever was content to lay downe his life for Christ? Wilt thou say, Thy sinnes make thee to conceive so: I answer, are thy sinnes greater then were the sinnes of Manasses, who made his sonnes passe through the fire to Molech, gave himselfe to witchcraft and sorcery, and filled Jerusalem with bloud from corner to corner? If his sinns were not sufficient to conclude that he was a Reprobate, why should thy sins be thought sufficient to conclude that thou art a Cast-away? Are thy sinnes greater then Sauls were, who was a Blasphemer, a Persecutor of the Saints of God from Citty to Citty; Yet was he received unto mercy. Wilt thou say, Thy sinnes have been committed since thy calling? Yet are they greater then was the sinne of Peter, in denying Christ his Master, with execrations and oathes? And these sinns were committed not only after his calling; but even within his Masters hearing too. Yet he went out and wept bitterly. And Christ as soone as he was risen, sent word of his resurrection by name to Peter to comfort him. Nay hath not God taught us in his word, that the bloud of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sinne, 1 John. 1.? And how canst thou make it appeare, that any one that ever was or is, hath greater interest therein then thy selfe? wilt thou say this remedy belongs unto none, but such as believe and repent; but I doe not. I answere, in like sort there was a time when Paul believed not, and when every one believed not; yet at length they believed, and so maist thou:
wilt thou say, But I cannot believe and repent? I answer, this is the condition of all till God takes away the stony heart out of their bowels, and gives them a heart of flesh, and puts his own spirit within them; wilt thou say God gives grace to others, but not to thee? I answer, there was a time when God had not mercy on them, at length an hour came wherein he called them: so an hour may come wherein he may call thee. And thou hast no more cause to conclude that he hath rejected thee, then every Child of God had before his calling, that God had rejected him: without grace neither thou canst, nor they could believe; but grace can bring all to faith and repentance; and thou hast no more cause to think that God will not bring thee to faith, then any elect had, before his calling, to think that God would not bring him to faith. Now seeing this grace is given in the Word, do thou wait upon God in his own ordinance, (which any natural man hath power to do; as namely, to go hear a sermon) ⟨p. 268⟩thou knowest not how it may work upon thee, yea though thou comest thither with a wicked mind. For we read of some that coming to take Christ were taken 1by him. And Father Latimer taking notice of some that come to Church to take a nap, yet never the less (saith he) let them come, they may be taken napping.
wilt thou say, But I cannot believe and repent? I answer, this is the condition of all till God takes away the stony heart out of their bowells, and gives them a heart of flesh, and puts his owne spirit within them; wilt thou say God gives grace to others, but not to thee? I answer, there was a time when God had not mercy on them, at length an houre came wherin he called them: so an houre may come wherin he may call thee. And thou hast no more cause to conclude that he hath rejected thee, then every Child of God had before his calling, that God had rejected him: without grace neither thou canst, nor they could believe; but grace can bring all to faith and repentance; and thou hast no more cause to think that God will not bring thee to faith, then any elect had, before his calling, to think that God would not bring him to faith. Now seeing this grace is given in the Word, doe thou wait upon God in his owne ordinance, (which any naturall man hath power to doe; as namely, to goe heare a sermon) ⟨p. 268⟩thou knowest not how it may worke upon thee, yea though thou commest thither with a wicked mind. For we read of some that comming to take Christ were taken 1by him. And Father Latimer taking notice of some that come to Church to take a nap, yet never the lesse (saith he) let them come, they may be taken napping.
Discourage not thy self thou poor afflicted soul, God hath not cast thee off, for he hateth nothing that he hath made, but bears a love to all men, and to thee amongst the rest.
Discourage not thy selfe thou poore afflicted soule, God hath not cast thee off, for he hateth nothing that he hath made, but bears a love to all men, and to thee amongst the rest.
And not only poor, but miserable also is that afflicted soul that hath no better comforter; whether we consider the nature of the consolation, or the warrant of it. For first, hath not God made Frogs, and Toads, and Devils, as well as man; And hath an Arminian that boasts so much of strongest arguments of comfort, no better comfort to an afflicted soul, then that she is Gods creature, which is the condition of a Frog, and a Divill, and a damned spirit. 2. Then as touching the warrant of it; Is the book of Wisdom the best store-house of comfort for an afflicted soul, a book written by Philo the Jew that living after Christs passion, resurrection and ascension, yet never believed in him. Again speak out and tell us what is the fruit of that love, which God bears to all men; Hath he ordained to give Salvation unto all, & to this afflicted soul in particular? If he hath not, but damnation rather unto some, and particularly to this soul; (for upon what ground darest thou say, or canst assure he hath not:) art not thou as miserable a comforter to her, as ever Jobs friends were to him? Or hath God ordained to give all men the grace of regeneration, the grace of faith and repentance; if so, then either absolutely or conditionally; if absolutely, then all must be regenerate, all must believe and repent. If conditionally, speak it out, and let thy Patient know what condition that is, on performance whereof by man, God will give him faith; say what thou wilt, the comfortable issue shall be this, That grace is given according to works; and this indeed is the only Arminian consolation.
And not only poore, but miserable also is that afflicted soule that hath no better comforter; whether we consider the nature of the consolation, or the warrant of it. For first, hath not God made Froggs, and Toades, and Devills, as well as man; And hath an Arminian that boasts so much of strongest arguments of comfort, no better comfort to an afflicted soule, then that she is Gods creature, which is the condition of a Frogge, and a Divill, and a damned spirit. 2. Then as touching the warrant of it; Is the booke of Wisdome the best store-house of comfort for an afflicted soule, a booke writen by Philo the Jew that living after Christs passion, resurrection and ascention, yet never believed in him. Againe speake out and tell us what is the fruit of that love, which God beares to all men; Hath he ordained to give Salvation unto all, & to this afflicted soule in particular? If he hath not, but damnation rather unto some, and particularly to this soule; (for upon what ground darest thou say, or canst assure he hath not:) art not thou as miserable a comforter to her, as ever Jobs friends were to him? Or hath God ordained to give all men the grace of regeneration, the grace of faith and repentance; if so, then either absolutely or conditionally; if absolutely, then all must be regenerate, all must believe and repent. If conditionally, speake it out, and let thy Patient know what condition that is, on performance whereof by man, God will give him faith; say what thou wilt, the comfortable issue shall be this, That grace is given according to workes; and this indeed is the only Arminian consolation.
1. God hateth no man as he is his creature, but he hates a great many as they are involved in the first transgression, and become guilty of Adams sin.
1. God hateth no man as he is his creature, but he hates a great many as they are involved in the first transgression, and become guilty of Adams sinne.
Poor soul, suffer not thy self to be instructed by them that labour to deprive thee not only of the comfort of Gods grace, but of the comfort of common sense: Dost thou well understand what it is to hate a man as a sinner, and not as a man? If hatred be no more then displeasure; surely whatsoever be the cause of it, in hating thee he is displeased with thee, as thou art his creature, and that in thy proper kind of man; if withal it signify punishment, whatsoever the cause thereof be, surely he punisheth thee as man, though not for thy natures sake, for that is the work of God, but for some corruption he finds in thee. And we should prove very sorry comforters; if on such a distinction as this, we should ground any true consolation; which hath his course not only with the Devils, but even with them that are already under the torments of Hell fire. But let not the authority of the book of Wisdom, with thee weigh up and elevate the authority of Scriptures; nor Philo the Jew be preferred before St Paul, or the Prophet Malachi, by whom we are taught that as God loved Jacob before he was borne, so he hated Esau; and before they were borne, what difference was there between them? Yet this passage out of the book of Wisdom is in a Collect of the Papists Liturgy; I conceive a good sense may be made thereof without any prejudice to absolute reprobation, (for of Papists we ate said to have learnt it and are reproached for it.) And what is that good sense they make of it? Take it if thou wilt from Aquinas 1. q: 23. art 3: ad. 1. Dicendum quod Deus omnes homines diligit, & etiam omnes creaturas in quantum omnibus vult aliquod bonum: non tamen quodcunque bonum vult omnibus; In quantum igitur quibusdam non vult hoc bonum, quod est vita aeterna, dicitur eos habere odio, vel reprobare: Now if we take this Collect from them, let us take also their good meaning with it; and if we can, let us make it better and not worse. We commonly say, that passions are attributed to God not quoad affectum, ⟨p. 269⟩but quoad effectum: Now the effect of hatred is either the denial of grace, or the denial of glory, or the inflicting of damnation; The two latter are executed only according to mens sins; but the first, to wit, the denial of grace, proceeds merely according to the good pleasure of Gods will;
Pooresoule, suffer not thy selfe to be instructed by them that labour to deprive thee not only of the comfort of Gods grace, but of the comfort of common sence: Dost thou well understand what it is to hate a man as a sinner, and not as a man? If hatred be no more then displeasure; surely whatsoever be the cause of it, in hating thee he is displeased with thee, as thou art his creature, and that in thy proper kind of man; if withall it signify punishment, whatsoever the cause thereof be, surely he punisheth thee as man, though not for thy natures sake, for that is the worke of God, but for some corruption he finds in thee. And we should prove very sorry comforters; if on such a distinction as this, we should ground any true consolation; which hath his course not only with the Devills, but even with them that are already under the torments of Hell fire. But let not the authority of the booke of Wisdome, with thee weigh up and elevate the authority of Scriptures; nor Philo the Jew be preferred before St Paul, or the Prophet Malachy, by whom wee are taught that as God loved Jacob before he was borne, so he hated Esau; and before they were borne, what difference was there betweene them? Yet this passage out of the booke of Wisdome is in a Collect of the Papists Liturgy; I conceive a good sence may be made thereof without any prejudice to absolute reprobation, (for of Papists we ate sayd to have learnt it and are reproached for it.) And what is that good sense they make of it? Take it if thou wilt from Aquinas 1. q: 23. art 3: ad. 1. Dicendum quod Deus omnes homines diligit, & etiam omnes creaturas in quantum omnibus vult aliquod bonum: non tamen quodcunque bonum vult omnibus; In quantum igitur quibusdam non vult hoc bonum, quod est vita aeterna, dicitur eos habere odio, vel reprobare: Now if we take this Colect from them, let us take also their good meaning with it; and if we can, let us make it better and not worse. We commonly say, that passions are attributed to God not quoad affectum, ⟨p. 269⟩but quoad effectum: Now the effect of hatred is either the denyall of grace, or the denyall of glory, or the inflicting of damnation; The two latter are executed only according to mens sinnes; but the first, to wit, the denyall of grace, proceeds meerely according to the good pleasure of Gods will;
like as the giving of grace (as the Apostle (not Philo) signifies, that God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth; Now to show mercy is to bring a man to faith. Rom. 11. 30. And if grace be not given according to the mere pleasure of Gods will, it must be given according unto works, which is as much as to say in the phrase of the ancients, according unto merits, which all along hath been condemned in the Church of God, as mere Pelagianism. Yet hitherto tends all the consolation that Arminianism can reach forth unto thee; which is to afford thee no better consolation then can be afforded to a Reprobate.
like as the giving of grace (as the Apostle (not Philo) signifies, that God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth; Now to shew mercy is to bring a man to faith. Rom. 11. 30. And if grace be not given according to the meere pleasure of Gods will, it must be given according unto workes, which is as much as to say in the phrase of the ancients, according unto merits, which all along hath been condemned in the Church of God, as meere Pelagianisme. Yet hitherto tends all the consolation that Arminianisme can reach forth unto thee; which is to afford thee no better consolation then can be afforded to a Reprobate.
2. As for Adams transgression, let not that affright thee, who art borne within the pale of the Church, and of Christian parents; for the children of such are holy. 1 Cor. 7. when all others are unclean. Yet why should any man find it strange, that some of them who are guilty of eternal death, should suffer eternal death? And this Author hath formerly confessed, that Adams sin hath made all his posterity guilty of eternal death. Now albeit God hates many, whether as involved in Adams transgression, or no, what matters that to thy discomfort, if he hate not thee. And what ground hast thou to conceive, that thou art in the number of them whom he hates, rather then of those whom he loves? He is no good Physician, that looks not into the cause of the disease, to remove that; nor he any good comforter that looks not into the cause of thy discomfort, to remove them; It is to be thought that such an one desires rather to feed thy discomfort, then to cure it. Such is the practice of this comforter, otherwise he should not apply his arguments of comfort (which he magnifies as the strongest) with as much art and cunning as can be: But understand him aright, this art and cunning tends not to the furtherance of thy consolation, but to the advantage of his own Arminian cause;; and to this end, I confess, he doth apply them with as much art and cunning as he can.
2. As for Adams transgression, let not that affright thee, who art borne within the pale of the Church, and of Christian parents; for the children of such are holy. 1 Cor. 7. when all others are uncleane. Yet why should any man find it strange, that some of them who are guilty of eternall death, should suffer eternall death? And this Author hath formerly confessed, that Adams sinne hath made all his posterity guilty of eternall death. Now albeit God hates many, whether as involved in Adams transgression, or no, what matters that to thy discomfort, if he hate not thee. And what ground hast thou to conceive, that thou art in the number of them whom he hates, rather then of those whom he loves? He is no good Physitian, that lookes not into the cause of the desease, to remoove that; nor he any good comforter that lookes not into the cause of thy discomfort, to remoove them; It is to be thought that such an one desires rather to feed thy discomfort, then to cure it. Such is the practice of this comforter, otherwise he should not apply his arguments of comfort (which he magnifies as the strongest) with as much art and cunning as can be: But understand him aright, this art and cunning tends not to the furtherance of thy consolation, but to the advantage of his owne Arminian cause;; and to this end, I confesse, he doth apply them with as much art and cunning as he can.
2. And God hath a two-fold love, a general love, which puts forth it self in outward and temporal blessings only, and with this he loves all men. And a special, by which he provides everlasting life for men, and with this only he loves a very few, which out of his alone will and pleasure he singled from the rest. Under this general love am I, not the special.
2. And God hath a two-fold love, a generall love, which puts forth it selfe in outward and temporall blessings only, and with this he loves all men. And a speciall, by which he provides everlasting life for men, and with this only he loves a very few, which out of his alone will and pleasure he singled from the rest. Under this generall love am I, not the speciall.
1. As touching the distinction, hold thee to it, least otherwise thou never prove capable of more comfort then a Reprobate is capable of. No Arminian hath the face to deny that God saves but a very few; And the reason is, because very few do believe and repent: in this we all agree. Again, no Arminian denies that very few do believe and repent, and finally persevere therein. Again, no Arminian denies faith and repentance to be the gift of God, and that hereby alone men are singled out from the rest. Now the question is, Whether God singleth out some men from the rest by giving them faith and repentance according to the mere pleasure of his will, or according to their works? We say, according to the mere pleasure of Gods will, for he hath mercy on whom he will. Rom: 9. 18. Arminians say according to mens works; and hereupon in the issue comes all their consolations to be grounded, that is upon a notorious Heresy condemned above 1200 year ago.
1. As touching the distinction, hold thee to it, least otherwise thou never proove capable of more comfort then a Reprobate is capable of. No Arminian hath the face to deny that God saves but a very few; And the reason is, because very few doe believe and repent: in this we all agree. Againe, no Arminian denies that very few doe believe and repent, and finally persevere therein. Againe, no Arminian denies faith and repentance to be the gift of God, and that hereby alone men are singled out from the rest. Now the question is, Whether God singleth out some men from the rest by giving them faith and repentance according to the meere pleasure of his will, or according to their workes? We say, according to the meere pleasure of Gods will, for he hath mercy on whom he will. Rom: 9. 18. Arminians say according to mens workes; and hereupon in the issue comes all their consolations to be grounded, that is upon a notorious Heresy condemned above 1200 yeare agoe.
2. But as touching the accommodation of this distinction unto thy self, saying thou art under Gods general love not under his special: I pray the tell me what ground thou hast for that? what one of Gods elect, while they were in the state of nature, had not as great cause to be as uncomfortable as thy self; and why mayest not thou be in Gods good time in as comfortable a condition as any of them, and to say as John doth, see what love the father hath showed us that we should be called the sons of God? dost thou mourn for thy sin or no? if thou dost not, Why shouldest thou look to be partaker of those comforts which are peculiar to them that mourn? If thou dost, thy Saviour hath said, Blessed are they that mourn for they shall be comforted. Dost thou hunger and thirst after the favour of God, and to be made partaker of the righteousness of Christ which alone can give thee assurance ⟨p. 270⟩of thine election? If thou doest not hunger and thirst after this, why shouldest thou be cast down, because thou hast not this assurance? If thou doest desire this assurance, and to that purpose hast an hungry appetite after the righteousness of Christ; thy Saviour saith, Blessed are they that hunger and thirst after righteousness, for they shall be filled. Or hast thou a desire to have thy sins pardoned, and thy soul saved; but not any desire that thy soul may be sanctified; what comfort shouldest thou or any such expect at the hands of God? Thou wouldest serve the Devil, but thou, wouldest not go to hell with the Devil. But I tell thee, God hath decreed the contrary, namely, that all such shall have this doom; Go ye cursed into everlasting fire prepared for the Devil and his Angels. Yet I will not leave thee, nor give over all hope of thee; for I am glad to hear thee confess, that though thou desirest thy sin may be pardoned, and thy soul saved, yet thou hast no desire that thy soul should be sanctified; therefore answer me but to one thing more, and I have done with thee; Is it thy grief and sorrow, that thou hast no desire, that thy nature may be sanctified, or is it no grief at all unto thee? If it be no grief unto thee, then still thou takest delight in sin; and how can delight in sin, stand with the fear of Gods judgements, and if thou fearest not God, how canst thou break out into such complaints, Woe is me for I am a Cast-away:
2. But as touching the accommodation of this distinction unto thy selfe, saing thou art under Gods generall love not under his speciall: I pray the tell me what ground thou hast for that? what one of Gods elect, while they were in the state of nature, had not as greate cause to be as uncomfortable as thy selfe; and why maist not thou be in Gods good time in as comfortable a condition as any of them, and to say as John doth, see what love the father hath shewed us that we should be called the sonnes of God? dost thou mourne for thy sinne or no? if thou dost not, Why shouldest thou looke to be partaker of those comforts which are peculiar to them that mourne? If thou dost, thy Saviour hath said, Blessed are they that mourne for they shall be comforted. Dost thou hunger and thirst after the favour of God, and to be made partaker of the righteousnesse of Christ which alone can give thee assurance ⟨p. 270⟩of thine election? If thou doest not hunger and thirst after this, why shouldest thou be cast downe, because thou hast not this assurance? If thou doest desire this assurance, and to that purpose hast an hungry appetite after the righteousnesse of Christ; thy Saviour saith, Blessed are they that hunger and thirst after righteousnesse, for they shall be filled. Or hast thou a desire to have thy sinnes pardoned, and thy soule saved; but not any desire that thy soule may be sanctified; what comfort shouldest thou or any such expect at the hands of God? Thou wouldest serve the Devill, but thou, wouldest not goe to hell with the Devill. But I tell thee, God hath decreed the contrary, namely, that all such shall have this doome; Goe ye cursed into everlasting fire prepared for the Devill and his Angells. Yet I will not leave thee, nor give over all hope of thee; for I am glad to heare thee confesse, that though thou desirest thy sinne may be pardoned, and thy soule saved, yet thou hast no desire that thy soule should be sanctified; therefore answer me but to one thing more, and I have done with thee; Is it thy griefe and sorrow, that thou hast no desire, that thy nature may be sanctified, or is it no griefe at all unto thee? If it be no griefe unto thee, then still thou takest delight in sinne; and how can delight in sinne, stand with the feare of Gods judgements, and if thou fearest not God, how canst thou breake out into such complaints, Woe is me for I am a Cast-away:
These motions usually proceed from the terrors of God; And if thou art once acquainted with Gods terrors, in consideration of thy sinful condition; then be of good cheer, for these symptoms are commonly as the pangs of Child-birth, whereby it comes to pass, that a Christian soul is at length brought forth into the world of grace. And therefore the spirit of bondage, to make us fear, doth prepare, and make way for the spirit of adoption, whereby we cry Abba Father. And by experience I have known some, being 1thus cast down, and stricken with fears of being cast-aways, when they have been demanded which condition they have thought better of, either this present condition of fear and terror, or the former condition of their profaneness, when they were without all remorse or check of consciences; they have readily professed, that this present condition of fear and terror, was the better of the two. Now let us hear how well the comforter plays his part.
These motions usually proceed from the terrours of God; And if thou art once acquainted with Gods terrours, in consideration of thy sinnefull condition; then be of good cheere, for these symptomes are commonly as the pangs of Child-birth, whereby it comes to passe, that a Christian soule is at length brought forth into the world of grace. And therefore the spirit of bondage, to make us feare, doth prepare, and make way for the spirit of adoption, whereby we cry Abba Father. And by experience I have known some, being 1thus cast downe, and stricken with feares of being cast-awayes, when they have been demanded which condition they have thought better of, either this present condition of feare and terrour, or the former condition of their prophanenesse, when they were without all remorse or check of consciences; they have readily professed, that this present condition of feare and terrour, was the better of the two. Now let us heare how well the comforter plaies his part.