DISCOURSE. SECT. I.
pp. 40–5991 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 40–5991 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
They did all generally agree upon the contrary Conclusion, and taught men in their times, That it was possible for them to be saved, which in the event were not saved, and to have repented which repented not, and that there was no decree of God, which did lay a necessity of perishing upon any son of Adam.
They did all generally agree upon the contrary Conclusion, and taught men in their times, That it was possible for them to be saved, which in the event were not saved, and to have repented which repented not, and that there was no decree of God, which did lay a necessity of perishing upon any sonne of Adam.
This that I say M. Calvin himself doth ingeniously acknowledge, speaking of election, and reprobation, according to Gods foreknowledge, Neque haec vulgo recepta opinio solius vulgi est, habuit enim saeculis 1omnibu magnes Authors; The Opinion of a conditional decree hath had great Authors in all ages.
This that I say M. Calvin himselfe doth ingeniously acknowledge, speaking of election, and reprobation, according to Gods foreknowledge, Neque haec vulgo recepta opinio solius vulgi est, habuit enim saeculis 1omnibu magnes Authores; The Opinion of a conditionall decree hath had great Authors in all ages.
Reverend Beza speaking likewise of the same opinion, speaks to the same effect in these words; In quem errorem sanè turpissimum. Origenes Veteres plerosque tum Graecos, tum Latinos adegit, Into which most 1foul error Origen drew many of the Ancients both Greeks and Latins. But Prosper amongst the rest S. Austins Scholar doth very clearly witness it, Pen è omnium (saith he) parem inveniri & unam sententiam qua propositum est, Praedestinationem Dei secundum praescientiam receperunt, ut ob hoc Deus alia vasa contumeliae; alios honour is vasa fecerit, quia finem uniuscujusque praeviderit, & sub ipso gratiae adjutorio in qua futurus esset voluntate & actione praescierit. All did grant with one consent, that God decreed mens ends according to his foresight of their actions, not otherwise.
Reverend Beza speaking likewise of the same opinion, speaks to the same effect in these words; In quem errorem sanè turpissimum. Origenes Veteres plerosque tum Graecos, tum Latinos adegit, Into which most 1foule errour Origen drew many of the Ancients both Greeks and Latines. But Prosper amongst the rest S. Austins Scholler doth very cleerly witnesse it, Pen è omnium (saith he) parem inveniri & unam sententiam qua propositum est, Praedestinationem Dei secundum praescientiam receperunt, ut ob hoc Deus alia vasa contumeliae; alios honor is vasa fecerit, quia finem uniuscujusque praeviderit, & sub ipso gratiae adjutorio in qua futurus esset voluntate & actione praescierit. All did grant with one consent, that God decreed mens ends according to his foresight of their actions, not otherwise.
To these Testimonies let me add two or three particular instances for the farther clearing of the newness of it.
To these Testimonies let me adde two or three particular instances for the farther clearing of the newnesse of it.
Minutius Faelix brings in the Pagans objecting to the Christians, that they hold an inevitable event of things, and did feign and frame to themselves an unjust God, who did punish in men their unavoidable destinies, and not their ill choices in these words. Quicquid agitis ut alii Fato, ita vos Deo additis: Iniquum igitur Deum fingitis, qui sortem in hominibus puniat, non voluntatem. The objection he thus answers. Illud Fatum est quod de unoquoque Deus fatus est. Christians hold no other Fates then Gods decrees, Qui cum universam praescit materiam pro meritis & qualitatibus singulorum etiam fata determinat; & ita in nobis non genitura plectitur, sed ingenii natura punitur. God that foreknew all men and their actions did accordingly determine their retributions.
Minutius Faelix brings in the Pagans objecting to the Christians, that they hold an inevitable event of things, and did feigne and frame to themselves an unjust God, who did punish in men their unavoidable destinies, and not their ill choyces in these words. Quicquid agitis ut alii Fato, ita vos Deo additis: Iniquum igitur Deum fingitis, qui sortem in hominibus puniat, non voluntatem. The objection he thus answers. Illud Fatum est quod de unoquoque Deus fatus est. Christians hold no other Fates then Gods decrees, Qui cum universam praescit materiam pro meritis & qualitatibus singulorum etiam fata determinat; & ita in nobis non genitura plectitur, sed ingenii natura punitur. God that foreknew all men and their actions did accordingly determine their retributions.
S. Hierome an eager opposer of the Pelagians in many places of his writings hath the same thing: Ex praescientiâ dei evenit ut quem justum futurum scit prius diligat quam oriatur ex utero & quem peccatorem 1aderit antequam peccet. To the same purpose he speaks in another place, Dilectio & Odium Dei vel ex praescientiâ nascitur futurorum, vel ex operibus, alioqui novimus quod omnia Deus diligat, nec quicquam eorum oderit, quae creavit. And in his Book against Pelagius he saith, Elegit Deus quem bonum cernit. The sum of all which speaks is but this, that there is no decree of damning or of saving men, but what is built upon Gods foreknowledge of the evil and good actions of men.
S. Hierome an eager opposer of the Pelagians in many places of his writings hath the same thing: Ex praescientiâ dei evenit ut quem justum futurum scit prius diligat quam oriatur ex utero & quem peccatorem 1aderit antequam peccet. To the same purpose he speaks in another place, Dilectio & Odium Dei vel ex praescientiâ nascitur futurorum, vel ex operibus, alioqui novimus quod omnia Deus diligat, nec quicquam eorum oderit, quae creavit. And in his Book against Pelagius he saith, Elegit Deus quem bonum cernit. The summe of all which speaks is but this, that there is no decree of damning or of saving men, but what is built upon Gods foreknowledge of the evill and good actions of men.
I will shut up my instances with the judgement of the Council of Arles against the Pelagians in 1the year 490. or thereabout. This Council subscribed to the Letter which was written by Faustus against Lucidus the Praedestinarian, and made the Anathema's and curses which he therein denounceth against him and such like, to be their own; some of which were these, Anathema illi qui dixerit, illum qui peri it non accepisse ut salvus esse possit, and againe, Anathema illi qui dixerit, quòd vas contumliae non possit assurgere ut sit vas in honerem.
I will shut up my instances with the judgement of the Councell of Arles against the Pelagians in 1the yeare 490. or thereabout. This Councell subscribed to the Letter which was written by Faustus against Lucidus the Praedestinarian, and made the Anathema's and curses which he therein denounceth against him and such like, to be their own; some of which were these, Anathema illi qui dixerit, illum qui peri it non accepisse ut salvus esse possit, and againe, Anathema illi qui dixerit, quòd vas contumliae non possit assurgere ut sit vas in honerem.
By this and the like speeches which I have met with in the Ancients being convinced, that the doctrine of absolute reprobation (and election too) was unknown unto them, I begin to call it into question. For albeit I make not the decisions and determinations of the Fathers or Councils the rules of my Faith (because they are but men and therefore subject unto error) yet I honour their grey hairs, and their grave assemblies, and do vehemently mistrust those doctrines which they never approved or taught, but disliked and condemned.
By this and the like speeches which I have met with in the Ancients being convinced, that the doctrine of absolute reprobation (and election too) was unknown unto them, I begin to call it into question. For albeit I make not the decisions and determinations of the Fathers or Councells the rules of my Faith (because they are but men and therefore subject unto errour) yet I honour their gray haires, and their grave assemblies, and doe vehemently mistrust those doctrines which they never approved or taught, but disliked and condemned.
AS touching the pretence of Antiquity; I find many are very apt to make plausible use of this, when either indeed, or at least in their imagination, it seems to serve their turns. And because I am put upon it, I will speak somewhat of it in general, and then proceed to consider it as it is appliable to the present occasion.
AS touching the pretence of Antiquity; I find many are very apt to make plausible use of this, when either indeed, or at least in their imagination, it seems to serve their turnes. And because I am put upon it, I will speak somewhat of it in generall, and then proceed to consider it as it is appyable to the present occasion.
As concerning the first, I find no small equivocation in the word Ancient: For if we compare an ancient man with a younger, in all probability the ancient is likely to be more wise then the other; because he hath more experience, by reason of the length of his days, according to that of Job. 12. 12. Amongst the ancient is wisdom, and in length of days is understanding. But this holds not of that which is ancient, as it signifies that which goes before another. For it is well known, that youth goeth before old age; yet no man will say, that the opinions of men in their youth, are more likely to be sound, then the opinions of riper age. Neither doth any man call or account youth Antiquity. Yet our Fathers we call our Ancients, because they have gone before us, but little reason there is in my judgement, to count their faith the more sound by reason of such Antiquity; no more then why the opinions of man in his youth, should be reputed more sound, then the opinions of his age. For as there is a youth in man; so there is to be acknowledged a youth of the world; and so likewise of the Christian World, even of the Church of God. The Holy Ghost speaks in this language. For even they who were the great Ancestors of the Jews in the days of Jeremiah, are called the youth of Israel, as the youth of Gods Church. Jerem. 2. 2. I remember thee with the kindness of thy youth, and the love of thy marriage, when thou wentst after me in the wilderness, in a land that was not sown. Israel was as a thing hallowed unto the Lord, &c Ezech. 16. 60. I will remember my Covenant made with thee in the days of thy youth. In like sort the Ancients counting them immediately from the Apostles days, are the very youth of the Church Christian. Now like as it is not to be expected that a man should have as great perfection of knowledge in his youth, as in his age; so neither is it to be supposed, that the Church of Christ should have as great perfection of knowledge in her youth as in her age. This is to be understood caeteris paribus; otherwise there lies a double exception against it: the One in the way of Gods extraordinary mercy, the Other in the way of Gods extraordinary judgement. For God may extraordinarily inspire a young man with the spirit of Prophecy, and so make him wiser then the aged.
As concerning the first, I find no small equivocation in the word Ancient: For if we compare an ancient man with a younger, in all probability the ancient is likely to be more wise then the other; because he hath more experience, by reason of the length of his daies, according to that of Job. 12. 12. Amongst the ancient is wisdome, and in length of daies is understanding. But this holds not of that which is ancient, as it signifies that which goes before another. For it is well known, that youth goeth before old age; yet no man will say, that the opinions of men in their youth, are more likely to be sound, then the opinions of riper age. Neither doth any man call or account youth Antiquity. Yet our Fathers we call our Ancients, because they have gone before us, but little reason there is in my judgement, to count their faith the more sound by reason of such Antiquity; no more then why the opinions of man in his youth, should be reputed more sound, then the opinions of his age. For as there is a youth in man; so there is to be acknowledged a youth of the world; and so likewise of the Christian World, even of the Church of God. The Holy Ghost speaks in this language. For even they who were the great Ancestors of the Jews in the daies of Jeremy, are called the youth of Israell, as the youth of Gods Church. Jerem. 2. 2. I remember thee with the kindnesse of thy youth, and the love of thy marriage, when thou wentst after me in the wildernesse, in a land that was not sowen. Israel was as a thing hallowed unto the Lord, &c Ezech. 16. 60. I will remember my Covenant made with thee in the daies of thy youth. In like sort the Ancients counting them immediately from the Apostles daies, are the very youth of the Church Christian. Now like as it is not to be exspected that a man should have as great perfection of knowledge in his youth, as in his age; so neither is it to be supposed, that the Church of Christ should have as great perfection of knowledge in her youth as in her age. This is to be understood caeteris paribus; otherwise there lies a double exception against it: the One in the way of Gods extraordinary mercy, the Other in the way of Gods extraordinary judgement. For God may extraordinarily inspire a young man with the spirit of Prophecy, and so make him wiser then the aged.
Such was the condition of Gods exuberant grace in the days of the Apostles, enduing them with power from on high, not only to instruct them with all spiritual wisdom and understanding in the mysteries of the Gospel, but enabling them also to express it in diverse languages, that so they might be able Ministers of Christ, to carry the glad tidings of salvation over all the World. On the other side, the sins of the Christian world not embracing Gods Truth with ⟨p. 42⟩love, may deserve at the hands of God, that he should give them over to illusions to believe lies. Then no marvel if our former light set in obscure darkness, and degenerate days come in place of better and more noble times; which may more easily come to pass, considering that the light of the Gospel is a spiritual light of faith, no natural light of reason; though even this natural light of reason comes to be amended and perfected by that light of grace.
Such was the condition of Gods exuberant grace in the daies of the Apostles, enduing them with power from on high, not only to instruct them with all spirituall wisdome and understanding in the mysteries of the Gospell, but enabling them also to expresse it in diverse languages, that so they might be able Ministers of Christ, to carry the glad tidings of salvation over all the World. On the other side, the sinnes of the Christian world not embracing Gods Truth with ⟨p. 42⟩love, may deserve at the hands of God, that he should give them over to illusions to believe lies. Then no marvaile if our former light set in obscure darknesse, and degenerate daies come in place of better and more noble times; which may more easily come to passe, considering that the light of the Gospell is a spirituall light of faith, no naturall light of reason; though even this naturall light of reason comes to be amended and perfected by that light of grace.
But it may be said, that They who lived near the Apostles days, are like to be better acquainted with the truth of God then we. I have found some to please themselves in this conceit, and it runs smooth and glib, and it seems very plausible to win approbation. But as Austin saith of some things, that acutule sonant, but discussa reperiuntur obtusa: so many times it falls out, that reasons plausible at first, when exploration comes, prove very unsound; like the fruit Solinus writes of, which grew about Sodom, Fair to the eye, but being crushed in cineres abeunt & vanam fuliginem. And for the discovering of the emptiness of this reason, I proceed thus.
But it may be said, that They who lived neer the Apostles daies, are like to be better acquainted with the truth of God then wee. I have found some to please themselves in this conceit, and it runns smooth and glibb, and it seems very plausible to winne approbation. But as Austin saith of some things, that acutule sonant, but discussa reperiuntur obtusa: so many times it falls out, that reasons plausible at first, when exploration comes, prove very unsound; like the fruit Solinus writes of, which grew about Sodome, Faire to the eye, but being crushed in cineres abeunt & vanam fuliginem. And for the discovering of the emptinesse of this reason, I proceed thus.
When you say of those Ancients, that they were near to the Apostles. I demand whether the meaning be, they were near to the times of the Apostles, or near to the Persons of the Apostles, or near to the word of the Apostles. The former two, do nothing at all conduce to the perfection of Christian knowledge, or soundness of faith. For certainly both Jews and Heathens professed enemies to the cross of Christ were as near to their Times and Persons as believing Christians, but they were not so familiarly acquainted with their word. But as touching familiar acquaintance with the word of the Apostles; as also the embracing of it by faith: Nothing I trust hindereth us from being as near to the Apostles, as the Ancients were. Nay it is well known, that as touching divers pieces of the books of the New Testament, we receive them for Canonical, which many of the Ancients doubted of. And as touching divers books concerning the times of the Old Testament, they are discovered unto us to be Apocryphal, which to many of the Ancients were not.
When you say of those Ancients, that they were neer to the Apostles. I demand whether the meaning be, they were neer to the times of the Apostles, or neer to the Persons of the Apostles, or neer to the word of the Apostles. The former two, doe nothing at all conduce to the perfection of Christian knowledge, or soundnesse of faith. For certainly both Jews and Heathens professed enemies to the crosse of Christ were as neer to their Times and Persons as believing Christians, but they were not so familiarly acquainted with their word. But as touching familiar acquaintance with the word of the Apostles; as also the embracing of it by faith: Nothing I trust hindereth us from being as neer to the Apostles, as the Ancients were. Nay it is well known, that as touching divers peeces of the books of the New Testament, we receive them for Canonicall, which many of the Ancients doubted of. And as touching divers books concerning the times of the Old Testament, they are discovered unto us to be Apocryphall, which to many of the Ancients were not.
But it may be said, that these Ancients to whom they pretend so much reverence (which indeed is but reverence to themselves, and to serve their own turns) were so near to the Apostles, that they not only were partakers of their writings, but of their Preaching also by word of mouth? To this I answer.
But it may be said, that these Ancients to whom they pretend so much reverence (which indeed is but reverence to themselves, and to serve their own turnes) were so neer to the Apostles, that they not only were partakers of their writings, but of their Preaching also by word of mouth? To this I answer.
1. That it is a very rare thing to meet with any such now adays, unless it be some counterfeit Author: neither do I find any such alleged by any, least of all by any Arminian, who yet upon my knowledge do discourse after this manner, as touching their nearness to the Apostles.
1. That it is a very rare thing to meet with any such now adaies, unlesse it be some counterfeit Author: neither doe I find any such alleadged by any, least of all by any Arminian, who yet upon my knowledge doe discourse after this manner, as touching their neernesse to the Apostles.
2. But suppose there were any such, and they should tell us what they heard preached by the Apostles, shall we take their relations for Oracles, and make the word of God to consist, partly of that which is written by them, and partly of that which is not written, but delivered by word of mouth, and commended unto us by tradition? Then farewell the doctrine of Protestants concerning the rule of faith, that it is only the written-word; and let us with the Papists, join thereunto traditions to make up a complete Rule of Faith.
2. But suppose there were any such, and they should tell us what they heard preached by the Apostles, shall we take their relations for Oracles, and make the word of God to consist, partly of that which is written by them, and partly of that which is not written, but delivered by word of mouth, and commended unto us by tradition? Then farewell the doctrine of Protestants concerning the rule of faith, that it is only the written-word; and let us with the Papists, joyne thereunto traditions to make up a compleat Rule of Faith.
It may be farther said, that by reason of their nearness to the Apostles, they may be better acquainted with the meaning of the word written.
It may be farther said, that by reason of their neernesse to the Apostles, they may be better acquainted with the meaning of the word written.
To which I answer; if so, then either from the Apostles own mouths, or by relation from others. Of any that report what they heard from the Apostles own mouths, they allege none. If they did, what were this other then to bring in Tradition to be a Rule, if not of faith, yet of interpretation of Gods word, which is as foul every way as the former, considering that soundness of faith, is grounded upon the soundness of interpretation of Gods word. If only by relation from others, the same exceptions lye against this and over and above, this must be of somewhat far less authority then the former: it being so difficult a matter to report from another without adding somewhat of his own, whether it be much or little, as Chaucer speaketh.
To which I answer; if so, then either from the Apostles own mouthes, or by relation from others. Of any that report what they heard from the Apostles own mouths, they alleadge none. If they did, what were this other then to bring in Tradition to be a Rule, if not of faith, yet of interpretation of Gods word, which is as foule every way as the former, considering that soundnesse of faith, is grounded upon the soundnesse of interpretation of Gods word. If only by relation from others, the same exceptions lye against this and over and above, this must be of somewhat farre lesse authority then the former: it being so difficult a matter to report from another without adding somewhat of his own, whether it be much or little, as Chaucer speaketh.
Lastly, let the Commentaries of these days, be compared with the Commentaries of the Ancients, and let the indifferent reader judge, which of them are most true, most learned, most substantial. So that I suppose, I may be bold to conclude, that this reason drawn from the nearness of the Ancients to the Apostles, how plausible soever it seems at first sight, yet indeed is of no force.
Lastly, let the Commentaries of these daies, be compared with the Commentaries of the Ancients, and let the indifferent reader judge, which of them are most true, most learned, most substantiall. So that I suppose, I may be bold to conclude, that this reason drawn from the neernesse of the Ancients to the Apostles, how plausible soever it seems at first sight, yet indeed is of no force.
Now to the contrary we have these reasons.
1. Like as it is fit every man should profit in the knowledge of God more and more, as long as he lives: so in all likelihood, the Christian world doth profit more and more, as they draw nearer to the end of the world, excepting those times of Gods judgements in giving the world over to illusions to believe lies. Austin did profit, as in other points of Christian knowledge, so in this as concerning Predestination, and blames the Massilienses for not profiting with him. De Praedestin. lib. 1. cap. 4. Videtis quid tunc de fidei & operibus sentiebam, quamvis de commendandâ dei gratiâ labor arem; In qua sententia istos fratres nostros esse nunc video: quia non ficut legere libros meos, ita curaverunt proficere mecum.
1. Like as it is fit every man should profit in the knowledge of God more and more, as long as he lives: so in all likelihood, the Christian world doth profit more and more, as they draw neerer to the end of the world, excepting those times of Gods judgements in giving the world over to illusions to believe lies. Austin did profit, as in other points of Christian knowledge, so in this as concerning Predestination, and blames the Massilienses for not profiting with him. De Praedestin. lib. 1. cap. 4. Videtis quid tunc de fidei & operibus sentiebam, quamvis de commendandâ dei gratiâ labor arem; In qua sententia istos fratres nostros esse nunc video: quia non ficut legere libros meos, ita curaverunt proficere mecum.
2. We have more means and helps for our furtherance in Christian knowledge, then they had, and that in divers respects. First, because we enjoy their labours, they enjoyed not ours, nor the like before them. So that by the reading of their writings we soon attain to that knowledge which they had, they communicating it unto us; and it were very strange we should add nothing thereunto; especially considering that Veritas was wont to be accounted temporis filia: and Aristotle accounts it an easy thing to add; Any man saith he may do that, [Greek or Hebrew], and thus, saith he, Arts come to their perfection [Greek or Hebrew]. A tall man is able to discover much farther then a Dwarf, but let a Dwarf be advanced upon the shoulders of that tall man, and he will discover much farther then he. Let then those Ancients go for tall fellows in the discovery of Christian truth, let the Divines of modern ages be but Dwarfs, as the Children of Israel seemed to be, but Grasshoppers in comparison of the Canaanites, especially to the sons of Anack; yet if by their pious labours and industries, which they have with much ingenuity communicated unto us, they suffer us to get upon their shoulders, shall not we though Dwarfs, be enabled hereby to discover somewhat more then they? The Eagle is a fowl of great strength and soareth high, the highest of all Kites and Hawks, yet let her carry a Wren along with her on her shoulders in her aerial ascensions, when she is weary and can fly no higher, can it seem strange, if the Wren carried thus high by this Anakim of fowls, presumes of her own strength to fly a little higher then she? or is this any glory to the Wren, or disparagement to the Eagle?
2. We have more means and helps for our furtherance in Christian knowledge, then they had, and that in divers respects. First, because we enjoy their labours, they enjoyed not ours, nor the like before them. So that by the reading of their writings we soon attain to that knowledge which they had, they communicating it unto us; and it were very strange we should adde nothing thereunto; especially considering that Veritas was wont to be accounted temporis filia: and Aristotle accounts it an easy thing to adde; Any man saith he may doe that, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and thus, saith he, Arts come to their perfection 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. A tall man is able to discover much farther then a Dwarfe, but let a Dwarfe be advanced upon the shoulders of that tall man, and he will discover much farther then he. Let then those Antients goe for tall fellowes in the discovery of Christian truth, let the Divines of moderne ages be but Dwarfes, as the Children of Israel seemed to be, but Grashoppers in comparison of the Canaanites, especially to the sonnes of Anack; yet if by their pious labours and industries, which they have with much ingenuity communicated unto us, they suffer us to get upon their shoulders, shall not we though Dwarfes, be enabled hereby to discover somewhat more then they? The Eagle is a fowle of great strength and soareth high, the highest of all Kites and Haukes, yet let her carry a Wren along with her on her shoulders in her aëriall ascentions, when she is weary and can fly no higher, can it seem strange, if the Wren carried thus high by this Anakim of fowles, presumes of her own strengh to fly a little higher then she? or is this any glory to the Wren, or disparagement to the Eagle?
2. Secondly Have not we better helps of Art then they, especially as touching the knowledge of the Tongues, and Logical resolutions of the Text. The Latin Fathers most of them were little acquainted with the Greek; neither Latin nor Greek Fathers were usually much acquainted with the Hebrew: Origen amongst the Greek, and Hierom amongst the Latin, had not their fellows for this.
2. Secondly Have not we better helpes of Art then they, especially as touching the knowledge of the Tongues, and Logicall resolutions of the Text. The Latine Fathers most of them were little acquainted with the Greek; neither Latine nor Greek Fathers were usually much acquainted with the Hebrew: Origen amongst the Greek, and Hierom amongst the Latine, had not their fellows for this.
3. Lastly, the Ancients in their days were not so put unto it as the latter; Nothing did more quicken them, or doth us, then contentions with Heretics. And therefore look how they were exercised with Heresies, so it is to be expected they were best seen in those Articles of Faith, which were most shaken by Heretics. This both Austin and Gregory take notice of; and Austin is most frequent herein, some passages to this purpose I shall relate hereafter. Now before Pelagius his days, the Fathers were much exercised in opposing the Manichees, and accordingly gave themselves to the maintenance of Free-will, as Aniarius observes by the relation of Sixtus Senensis. But Pelagius was the first that opposed Gods grace; and therefore those 1Fathers that contended with him, gave themselves chiefly to the maintenance of Gods grace.
3. Lastly, the Ancients in their daies were not so put unto it as the latter; Nothing did more quicken them, or doth us, then contentions with Heretiques. And therefore look how they were exercised with Heresies, so it is to be expected they were best seen in those Articles of Faith, which were most shaken by Heretiques. This both Austin and Gregory take notice of; and Austin is most frequent herein, some passages to this purpose I shall relate hereafter. Now before Pelagius his daies, the Fathers were much exercised in opposing the Manichees, and accordingly gave themselves to the maintenance of Free-will, as Aniarius observes by the relation of Sixtus Senensis. But Pelagius was the first that opposed Gods grace; and therefore those 1Fathers that contended with him, gave themselves chiefely to the maintenance of Gods grace.
And now am I come to the treating of Ancients no longer in general, but in a special reference to the doctrine of predestination. Now herein the Papists themselves (who in other points labour to beat us down with nothing so much as with the noise of Antiquity) are willing to confess that in the point of grace and predestination we need not trouble our selves, with inquiry after the doctrine of the Ancients before Pelagius rose, and that upon the ground before mentioned, to wit, because they were nothing exercised hereabouts. As for example Bellarmine, De Grat. & lib. Arbitr. lib. 1. c. 14. having proposed diverse passages of the Fathers favouring, as it seemed, the doctrine wherewith Pelagius troubled the peace of Gods Church, makes Austin to answer for him, Veteres Patres qui ante Pelagium floruerunt, quaestionem istam nunquam accuratè tractasse, sed incidentèr solum, & quasi per transitum illam attigisse. Addit verò (saith Bellarmine) in fundamento hujus sententiae, quod est, Gratiam Dei non praevenire ab ullo opere nostro, sed contrà ab illâ omnia opera nostra praeveniri, ita ut nihil omnino boni quod attinet ad salutem sit in nobis, quod non sit nobis ex Deo, convenire Catholicos omnes & ibidem citat Cyprianum, Ambrosisium ⟨p. 44⟩& Nazianzenum: yet he takes a course to reconcile them to the truth; so doth Sixtus Senensis Bibl. Sanct. lib. 6. Annota. 251. so doth Alvarez. de Auxil. lib. 5. disp. 37.
And now am I come to the treating of Ancients no longer in generall, but in a speciall reference to the doctrine of predestination. Now herein the Papists themselves (who in other points labour to beat us down with nothing so much as with the noise of Antiquity) are willing to confesse that in the point of grace and predestination we need not trouble our selves, with inquiry after the doctrine of the Ancients before Pelagius rose, and that upon the ground before mentioned, to wit, because they were nothing exercised hereabouts. As for example Bellarmine, De Grat. & lib. Arbitr. lib. 1. c. 14. having proposed diverse passages of the Fathers favouring, as it seemed, the doctrine wherewith Pelagius troubled the peace of Gods Church, makes Austin to answer for him, Veteres Patres qui ante Pelagium floruerunt, quaestionem istam nunquam accuratè tractasse, sed incidentèr solum, & quasi per transitum illam attigisse. Addit verò (saith Bellarmine) in fundamento hujus sententiae, quod est, Gratiam Dei non praevenire ab ullo opere nostro, sed contrà ab illâ omnia opera nostra praeveniri, ita ut nihil omnino boni quod attinet ad salutem sit in nobis, quod non sit nobis ex Deo, convenire Catholicos omnes & ibidem citat Cyprianum, Ambrosisium ⟨p. 44⟩& Nazianzenum: yet he takes a course to reconcile them to the truth; so doth Sixtus Senensis Bibl. Sanct. lib. 6. Annota. 251. so doth Alvarez. de Auxil. lib. 5. disp. 37.
Again consider. The decrees of predestination and reprobation are secret, neither do they appear of what condition they are, but by the manner of their executions. Now their executions do consist partly in bestowing salvation on some, and inflicting damnation on others; partly in bestowing the grace of faith and repentance on some, and denying it unto others. As touching salvation and damnation we willingly profess, that the salvation of men of ripe years, doth always presuppose Faith and perseverance therein; and the damnation of others doth always presuppose final perseverance in sin unrepented of. But we deny that herehence it followeth, that either faith precedes the decree of salvation, or sin precedes the decree of damnation, or the prescience of either. That faith cannot precede election, nor sin reprobation, is evident; For as much as election and reprobation are eternal, but faith and sin are things temporal: but that with is temporal cannot precede that which is eternal. Neither doth it follow, that because faith precedes salvation, therefore faith precedes the decree of salvation. For it is faith existent in time that precedes salvation; but no Divine will say that faith existent in time, precedes Gods decree of salvation, unless it be some such as maintain with Vorstius, that Gods decrees are not eternal. In like sort, it is sin existent in time, that precedes damnation; but no wise Divine will say, that sin existent in time precedes Gods decree of damnation; the former being a thing temporal but this decree eternal. Lastly, neither will it follow that because faith precedes salvation and sin damnation, therefore the foresight of faith, is antecedanious to the decree of salvation, and the foresight of sin is antecedent to the decree of damnation. For no Enthymeme of this nature is sound, but so far forth as it is reducible into a good Categorical Syllogism, whereof these Enthymemes are uncapable. For Enthymemes reducible unto good Syllogisms must agree, either in their Subjects or in their Predicates, but these do not. Again all the terms in a good Enthymeme must be expressed in that Syllogism whereunto it is reduced▪ But each of these Enthymemes consisteth manifestly of four terms; as in the first, the•e, Faith, and the Foresight of faith, Salvation and the Decree of salvation;
Again consider. The decrees of predestination and reprobation are secret, neither doe they appeare of what condition they are, but by the manner of their executions. Now their executions doe consist partly in bestowing salvation on some, and inflicting damnation on others; partly in bestowing the grace of faith and repentance on some, and denying it unto others. As touching salvation and damnation we willingly professe, that the salvation of men of ripe years, doth alwaies presuppose Faith and perseverance therein; and the damnation of others doth alwaies presuppose finall perseverance in sinne unrepented of. But we deny that herehence it followeth, that either faith precedes the decree of salvation, or sinne precedes the decree of damnation, or the prescience of either. That faith cannot precede election, nor sinne reprobation, is evident; For as much as election and reprobation are eternall, but faith and sinne are things temporall: but that wich is temporall cannot precede that which is eternall. Neither doth it follow, that because faith precedes salvation, therefore faith precedes the decree of salvation. For it is faith existent in time that precedes salvation; but no Divine will say that faith existent in time, precedes Gods decree of salvation, unlesse it be some such as maintaine with Vorstius, that Gods decrees are not eternall. In like sort, it is sinne existent in time, that precedes damnation; but no wise Divine will say, that sinne existent in time precedes Gods decree of damnation; the former being a thing temporall but this decree eternall. Lastly, neither will it follow that because faith precedes salvation and sinne damnation, therefore the foresight of faith, is antecedanious to the decree of salvation, and the foresight of sinne is antecedent to the decree of damnation. For no Enthymeme of this nature is sound, but so farre forth as it is reducible into a good Categorical Syllogisme, whereof these Enthymems are uncapable. For Enthymems reducible unto good Syllogismes must agree, either in their Subjects or in their Predicates, but these doe not. Again all the termes in a good Enthymeme must be expressed in that Syllogisme whereunto it is reduced▪ But each of these Enthymemes consisteth manifestly of four termes; as in the first, the•e, Faith, and the Foresight of faith, Salvation and the Decree of salvation;
Of the second, these, Sin, and Foresight of sin, Damnation and the Decree of damnation; and consequently that Syllogism whereunto either of these quaternary of terms is clapped, cannot be good; For no Categorical Syllogism is good that consisteth of four terms. As for the reducing of them into a Syllogism Hypothetical, such Reductions were never heard of in the Schools of the learned and that for just reason; because that is no course to justify the soundness of the Enthymemes, but a mere begging of that which is in question. As in case a man should reduce it thus; If faith be precedanious to salvation, then the foresight of faith is precedanious to the decree of salvation; But faith is precedanious to salvation, Therefore it is precedanious to the decree of salvation. In this Hypothetical Syllogism, the consequence of the Major is the very Enthymeme which is in question, for the substance of it and consequently no proving of it, but a mere begging of it. Yet notwithstanding we do not deny, but that God did decree that no man should be saved, but such as being of ripe years, should be found to persevere in faith unto death none should be damned, but such as should be found finally to persevere in sin. The other execution of these decrees consists (as I said) in the bestowing of the grace of faith and repentance on some, and denying it unto others. Now the question is, Whether God be indeed the author of faith and repentance, yea, or no; and because the Arminians dare not professedly deny this. (though lately they are come so far as professedly to deny that Christ merited it) therefore let the question proceed about the manner how God bestows it, as namely, whether he bestows it of his mere pleasure on some, denying it to others, or, Whether the reason why God bestows it on some and not on others, be, because God finds some good work in one, which he finds not in another. This question being decided, it will clearly appear, whether predestination proceeds upon the foresight of ought in man, yea or no. For if God of his mere pleasure doth bestow faith on one, and not on another, it follows undeniably, that God predestinated him hereunto absolutely, and of his mere pleasure, without consideration of any future work of man.
Of the second, these, Sinne, and Foresight of sinne, Damnation and the Decree of damnation; and consequently that Syllogisme whereunto either of these quaternary of termes is clap'd, cannot be good; For no Categoricall Syllogisme is good that consisteth of foure termes. As for the reducing of them into a Syllogisme Hypotheticall, such Reductions were never heard of in the Schooles of the learned and that for just reason; because that is no course to justify the soundnesse of the Enthymemes, but a meer begging of that which is in question. As in case a man should reduce it thus; If faith be precedanious to salvation, then the foresight of faith is precedanious to the decree of salvation; But faith is precedanious to salvation, Therefore it is precedanious to the decree of salvation. In this Hypotheticall Syllogisme, the consequence of the Major is the very Enthymeme which is in question, for the substance of it and consequently no proving of it, but a meere begging of it. Yet notwithstanding we doe not deny, but that God did decree that no man should be saved, but such as being of ripe years, should be found to persevere in faith unto death none should be damned, but such as should be found finally to persevere in sinne. The other execution of these decrees consists (as I said) in the bestowing of the grace of faith and repentance on some, and denying it unto others. Now the question is, Whether God be indeed the author of faith and repentance, yea, or no; and because the Arminians dare not professedly deny this. (though lately they are come so farre as professedly to deny that Christ merited it) therefore let the question proceede about the manner how God bestowes it, as namely, whether he bestowes it of his meer pleasure on some, denying it to others, or, Whether the reason why God bestowes it on some and not on others, be, because God findes some good work in one, which he findes not in another. This question being decided, it will clearly appeare, whether predestination proceeds upon the foresight of ought in man, yea or no. For if God of his meer pleasure doth bestow faith on one, and not on another, it followes undeniably, that God predestinated him hereunto absolutely, and of his meer pleasure, without consideration of any future work of man.
But if God bestows faith on man upon consideration of some precedent work of his, which was ⟨p. 45⟩not the work of God, then (and not otherwise neither) it will follow, that upon the consideration of that future work of man, God did elect him unto faith, or predestinate faith unto him. So that if we desire sincerely and ingeniously to inquire what was the opinion of the Ancients about the absoluteness of predestination, we should state the question as touching Predestination unto faith, and not as touching Predestination unto salvation. For we all confess that God predestinated no man unto salvation, but such as he foresaw, coming unto ripe years, would believe sooner or later. And therefore the main question between the Remonstrants and Contraremonstrants was, whether this decree were the whole decree of Predestination, and whether there were not another decree of Predestination besides, as namely, whether God did not decree to bestow faith on some, and deny it unto others. And secondly to inquire, Whether this decree of bestowing faith on some, did not proceed according to Gods good pleasure, without consideration of any different work in man. And the most compendious resolution hereof, is to inquire of the manner how God carrieth himself in the bestowing of faith and repentance on some, and denying it unto others; as namely, Whether on his mere pleasure he hath not mercy on some, giving them faith and repentance, and of his mere pleasure, denies the gift of faith and repentance unto others. Now let the Fathers, (whosoever thinks good) be admitted to bring in their suffrages on this Article, and remember what was decreed in the first Synod that was gathered, to make peace in the Church after Pelagius had disturbed it, namely, Gratiam non dari secundum merita, that is, as Bellarmine acknowledgeth, Gratiam non dari secundum opera. Lastly, all of us now a days consent, as 1touching Gods concourse to the substance of every act of the creature whether good or evil. Now let this Author or any other, represent unto us, what footing he finds in Antiquity concerning this. But I come to answer particularly, according to this Authors text.
But if God bestowes faith on man upon consideration of some precedent work of his, which was ⟨p. 45⟩not the work of God, then (and not otherwise neither) it will follow, that upon the consideration of that future work of man, God did elect him unto faith, or predestinate faith unto him. So that if we desire sincerely and ingeniously to inquire what was the opinion of the Ancients about the absolutenesse of predestination, we should state the question as touching Predestination unto faith, and not as touching Predestination unto salvation. For we all confesse that God predestinated no man unto salvation, but such as he foresaw, coming unto ripe years, would believe sooner or later. And therefore the main question between the Remonstrants and Contraremonstrants was, whether this decree were the whole decree of Predestination, and whether there were not another decree of Predestination besides, as namely, whether God did not decree to bestow faith on some, and deny it unto others. And secondly to inquire, Whether this decree of bestowing faith on some, did not proceed according to Gods good pleasure, without consideration of any different work in man. And the most compendious resolution hereof, is to inquire of the manner how God carrieth himselfe in the bestowing of faith and repentance on some, and denying it unto others; as namely, Whether on his meer pleasure he hath not mercy on some, giving them faith and repentance, and of his meer pleasure, denyes the gift of faith and repentance unto others. Now let the Fathers, (whosoever thinks good) be admitted to bring in their suffrages on this Article, and remember what was decreed in the first Synode that was gathered, to make peace in the Church after Pelagius had disturbed it, namely, Gratiam non dari secundum merita, that is, as Bellarmine acknowledgeth, Gratiam non dari secundum opera. Lastly, all of us now a daies consent, as 1touching Gods concourse to the substance of every act of the creature whether good or evill. Now let this Author or any other, represent unto us, what footing he finds in Antiquity concerning this. But I come to answer particularly, according to this Authors text.
He cannot find absolute and inevitable reprobation to have any footing in Antiquity. Belike he can find reprobation evitable; a strange phrase either way. These attributes applied to damnation do carry a fair sense with them, damnation being a work of God wrought in time, and undoubtedly may be avoided, may be incurred for the time to come. But reprobation is eternal as God himself, and how that should be fancied to be of an avoidable condition for the time to come, I cannot comprehend, unless this Author be of their opinion, who desire to shape Gods decrees of a revocable nature, as being both to impute unto him an impotent immutability, as some are pleased to phrase it.
He cannot find absolute and inevitable reprobation to have any footing in Antiquity. Belike he can find reprobation evitable; a strange phraise either way. These attributes applied to damnation doe carry a faire sense with them, damnation being a work of God wrought in time, and undoubtedly may be avoided, may be incurred for the time to come. But reprobation is eternall as God himselfe, and how that should be fancied to be of an avoidable condition for the time to come, I cannot comprehend, unlesse this Author be of their opinion, who desire to shape Gods decrees of a revocable nature, as being both to impute unto him an impotent immutability, as some are pleased to phraise it.
But leave we reprobation unavoidable, take we the absolute nature of it into consideration: this he cannot find in all Antiquity. But consider I pray, he pretends these motives, as inducements to change his former opinion: so then belike, he stood sometimes for reprobation absolute; but did he find any footing in Antiquity for it, what time he embraced it? if he did formerly embrace it, notwithstanding he found no footing in Antiquity for it, why should he now relinquish it, for finding no footing in Antiquity for it? Belike the older he waxeth, the more he groweth in love with Antiquity. Again when formerly he did embrace the doctrine of absolute reprobation, upon what grounds did he embrace it? was it because he was in hope he should hereafter find Antiquity for it? or was it only for the authority of them who brought him up in this opinion? What sorry grounds are these to build a mans faith upon? Yet this is not our course to impose Articles of faith on any, but rather to endoctrinate them out of the word of God. If then a mans Christian faith be built upon the Word of God, is it a Christian course to renounce it, or to question the integrity of it, because he finds no footing in Antiquity for it? What then shall become of the faith of Laics, and such as are unlearned? Must the writings of the Fathers be translated into all vulgar Languages, and the unlearned addict themselves to the study of them, least otherwise their faith prove a wavering faith, for want of finding Antiquity to favour it? Belike the writings of the Prophets and Apostles, are no part of Antiquity, in this Authors more mature judgement. But if formerly the doctrine of absolute reprobation were received upon the evidence of Gods word, as it is fit the faith of every Christian should be grounded thereupon, especially the faith of a Divine called to be a Teacher of others; I should think there were no just cause of alteration, but upon discovery of the error of those grounds, whereupon formerly it was builded; and the discovery hereof alone, were chiefly to the present purpose, ⟨p. 46⟩namely to show just cause of change of mind, & alteration of judgement, but no such course do I find taken here.
But leave we reprobation unavoidable, take we the absolute nature of it into consideration: this he cannot find in all Antiquity. But consider I pray, he pretends these motives, as inducements to change his former opinion: so then belike, he stood sometimes for reprobation absolute; but did he find any footing in Antiquity for it, what time he embraced it? if he did formerly embrace it, notwithstanding he found no footing in Antiquity for it, why should he now relinquish it, for finding no footing in Antiquity for it? Belike the older he waxeth, the more he groweth in love with Antiquity. Again when formerly he did embrace the doctrine of absolute reprobation, upon what grounds did he embrace it? was it because he was in hope he should hereafter find Antiquity for it? or was it only for the authority of them who brought him up in this opinion? What sorry grounds are these to build a mans faith upon? Yet this is not our course to impose Articles of faith on any, but rather to endoctrinate them out of the word of God. If then a mans Christian faith be built upon the Word of God, is it a Christian course to renounce it, or to question the integrity of it, because he finds no footing in Antiquity for it? What then shall become of the faith of Laicks, and such as are unlearned? Must the writings of the Fathers be translated into all vulgar Languages, and the unlearned addict themselves to the study of them, least otherwise their faith prove a wavering faith, for want of finding Antiquity to favour it? Belike the writings of the Prophets and Apostles, are no part of Antiquity, in this Authors more mature judgement. But if formerly the doctrine of absolute reprobation were received upon the evidence of Gods word, as it is fit the faith of every Christian should be grounded thereupon, especially the faith of a Divine called to be a Teacher of others; I should think there were no just cause of alteration, but upon discovery of the errour of those grounds, whereupon formerly it was builded; and the discovery hereof alone, were chiefly to the present purpose, ⟨p. 46⟩namely to shew just cause of change of mind, & alteration of judgement, but no such course doe I find taken here.
These motives and reasons here proposed, may carry a show of reason, why a man being yet to choose his faith in these particulars, possessed with neither way, but indifferent, might prefer one way before another, one opinion before another, but nothing sufficient to justify a change, unless the weakness of former grounds be laid open. For it may be that the former grounds might be such as upon due comparison would be found to overweigh these pretences. For upon view that I have taken of the discourse following, I find not one argument drawn from those places of Scripture that treat of election and reprobation; these I find are purposely declined as so many rocks, as if the Author feared to make shipwreck of his errors (pardon my boldness in so naming them, Austin is my precedent in this saying, Hoc scio contra istam praedestinationem quam secundum scripturas defendimus, neminem nisi errando disputare posse) but in the mean time while he fears to make shipwreck of his errors, let him take heed least he make shipwreck of a good conscience.
These motives and reasons here proposed, may carry a shew of reason, why a man being yet to chuse his faith in these particulars, possessed with neither way, but indifferent, might preferre one way before another, one opinion before another, but nothing sufficient to justify a change, unlesse the weaknesse of former grounds be laid open. For it may be that the former grounds might be such as upon due comparison would be found to overweigh these pretences. For upon view that I have taken of the discourse following, I find not one argument drawn from those places of Scripture that treat of election and reprobation; these I find are purposely declined as so many rocks, as if the Author feared to make shipwrack of his errours (pardon my boldnesse in so naming them, Austin is my precedent in this saying, Hoc scio contra istam praedestinationem quam secundum scripturas defendimus, neminem nisi errando disputare posse) but in the mean time while he fears to make shipwrack of his errours, let him take heed least he make shipwrack of a good conscience.
But proceed we with him about the inquiry what footing this doctrine finds in Antiquity. 1He saith he cannot find it; but it is more then I find that ever he made any convenient search after it, his whole discourse hereupon is of so hungry a nature. The absoluteness of election and reprobation, we conclude in Christian reason from Gods absolute carriage in giving and denying grace, understanding thereby the grace of regeneration. Now the absoluteness herein, as we suppose, consists in bestowing this grace on some, and denying it to others, according to the mere pleasure of the Lords will. Now hath not the Apostle (more ancient then all the Antiquity he speaketh of) professed in express terms, that God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth? What need we seek farther amongst the Ancients for the justification 2of this? And that mercy here is meant, such a mercy in bestowing faith on some, which is denied to others, in converting the wills of some unto good, when others are not converted, I could prove by variety of places out of Austin, whose authority in this case is far more worthy, then all the authority this Author produceth. Neither is this the voice of Austin only, but of Ambrose also in that famous saying of his Quem vult religiosum, facit, so much magnified by Austin. And not Ambrose alone, but Nazianzen 3also, and Cyprian are alleged by him, as concurring with him in the foundation of the doctrine of predestination, which he makes to be the freedom of Gods grace in converting whom he will. And which is far more then this, yea far more then all that can be produced to the contrary, by the very Prayers of the Church every where in use, he justifies the general concurrence in that which he accounts the foundation of predestination. As when their common course was to pray unto God, that he would be pleased to convert unto the faith of Christ the hearts of Heathens; and wherein did this conversion consist, but in giving them faith and repentance: manifestly giving us to understand thereby, that the whole Catholic Church did concur in this Article of Faith, that it was in the power of God according to his free grace, to convert whom he would unto the faith of Christ, and consequently not to convert whom he would.
But proceed we with him about the inquiry what footing this doctrine finds in Antiquity. 1He saith he cannot find it; but it is more then I find that ever he made any convenient search after it, his whole discourse hereupon is of so hungry a nature. The absolutenesse of election and reprobation, we conclude in Christian reason from Gods absolute carriage in giving and denying grace, understanding thereby the grace of regeneration. Now the absolutenesse herein, as we suppose, consists in bestowing this grace on some, and denying it to others, according to the meer pleasure of the Lords will. Now hath not the Apostle (more ancient then all the Antiquity he speaketh of) professed in expresse termes, that God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth? What need we seek farther amongst the Ancients for the iustification 2of this? And that mercy here is meant, such a mercy in bestowing faith on some, which is denied to others, in converting the wills of some unto good, when others are not converted, I could prove by variety of places out of Austin, whose authority in this case is farre more worthy, then all the authority this Author produceth. Neither is this the voyce of Austin only, but of Ambrose also in that famous saying of his Quem vult religiosum, facit, so much magnified by Austin. And not Ambrose alone, but Nazianzen 3also, and Cyprian are alleaged by him, as concurring with him in the foundation of the doctrine of predestination, which he makes to be the freedome of Gods grace in converting whom he will. And which is farre more then this, yea farre more then all that can be produced to the contrary, by the very Prayers of the Church every where in use, he iustifies the generall concurrence in that which he accounts the foundation of predestination. As when their common course was to pray unto God, that he would be pleased to convert unto the faith of Christ the hearts of Heathens; and wherein did this conversion consist, but in giving them faith and repentance: manifestly giving us to understand thereby, that the whole Catholique Church did concurre in this Article of Faith, that it was in the power of God according to his free grace, to convert whom he would unto the faith of Christ, and consequently not to convert whom he would.
For if there were any cause on mans part, why he doth not convert some converting others, then there were also on mans part, a cause why God doth convert some not converting others, and consequently grace should be given according unto works, that is in the phrase of the Ancients, Gratiam dari secundum merita (as Bellarmine acknowledgeth) which was ever accounted express Pelagianism, 1and was as expressly condemned in the Council of Palestine above 1200 years ago, and Pelagius himself was driven to subscribe unto it, by shameful dissimulation so to prevent Anathematization of his own person.
For if there were any cause on mans part, why he doth not convert some converting others, then there were also on mans part, a cause why God doth convert some not converting others, and consequently grace should be given according unto works, that is in the phrase of the Ancients, Gratiam dari secundum merita (as Bellarmine acknowledgeth) which was ever accounted expresse Pelagianisme, 1and was as expressely condemned in the Councel of Palestina above 1200 years agoe, and Pelagius himselfe was driven to subscribe unto it, by shamefull dissimulation so to prevent Anathematization of his own person.
But the upper way (saith this Author) was never taught or approved by any of the Fathers for 600 years. Here breaks forth another reason of this Authors (or his that directed him) cunning carriage in distinguishing the two ways of our Divines in maintaining the absoluteness of election and reprobation, to wit, that in the course of his discourse he might serve his turn with both, and where Antiquity served not his turn against the one, yet might it serve his turn, as he thought against the other. But the truth is, there was no such question at all ventilated in those days, as touching the object of predestination, no nor in Austins neither, nor many hundred years after, that I know. And no marvel; For it concerns the ordering of Gods decree aright, which is merely Logical, as I have showed in my Vind. Grat. Dei. Its true that St Austin doth usually accommodate that of St Paul, Rom. 9. 21. concerning the Mass, unto ⟨p. 47⟩mankind considered in Massa damnata as he commonly calls it, that is, in the corrupt Mass; but not always, but sometimes he speaks of it, and accommodates it clearly unto the Mass of mankind uncorrupt, yea, as yet not created, as there I have showed. And as for the right ordering of Gods decrees, and the right stating of the object of predestination and reprobation, We desire no better, nor other ground then that of the Apostle, God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth, that is, he cures infidelity and hardness of heart in whom he will, by bestowing faith and repentance upon them, and leaves it uncured in whom he will by denying faith and repentance unto them. And as for the rigour of this Tenet (as it is commonly accounted) of making the Mass of mankind not created the object of predestination, I have already showed the vanity of that conceit and denomination; for as much as hereby neither is the decree of damnation made to precede the consideration of sin, no nor of final impenitency in any moment of nature, nor in any moment of nature is the decree of salvation made by me, to precede the consideration of final perseverance in faith and repentance. But whereas some, who are most rigid indeed in their discourse, make the decree of saving some and damning others to precede the decree of creating and permitting of sin both original and actual;
But the upper way (saith this Author) was never taught or approved by any of the Fathers for 600 years. Here breaks forth another reason of this Authors (or his that directed him) cunning carriage in distinguishing the two waies of our Divines in maintaining the absolutenesse of election and reprobation, to wit, that in the course of his discourse he might serve his turne with both, and where Antiquity served not his turne against the one, yet might it serve his turne, as he thought against the other. But the truth is, there was no such question at all ventilated in those daies, as touching the obiect of predestination, no nor in Austins neither, nor many hundred years after, that I know. And no marvell; For it concernes the ordering of Gods decree aright, which is meerly Logicall, as I have shewed in my Vind. Grat. Dei. Its true that St Austin doth usually accommodate that of St Paul, Rom. 9. 21. concerning the Masse, unto ⟨p. 47⟩mankind considered in Massa damnata as he commonly calls it, that is, in the corrupt Masse; but not alwaies, but sometimes he speaks of it, and accommodates it cleerely unto the Masse of mankind uncorrupt, yea, as yet not created, as there I have shewed. And as for the right ordering of Gods decrees, and the right stating of the object of predestination and reprobation, We desire no better, nor other ground then that of the Apostle, God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth, that is, he cures infidelity and hardnes of heart in whom he will, by bestowing faith and repentance upon them, and leaves it uncured in whom he will by denying faith and repentance unto them. And as for the rigour of this Tenent (as it is commonly accounted) of making the Masse of mankind not created the object of predestination, I have already shewed the vanity of that conceit and denomination; for as much as hereby neither is the decree of damnation made to precede the consideration of sinne, no nor of finall impenitency in any moment of nature, nor in any moment of nature is the decree of salvation made by mee, to precede the consideration of finall perseverance in faith and repentance. But whereas some, who are most rigid indeed in their discourse, make the decree of saving some and damning others to precede the decree of creating and permitting of sinne both originall and actuall;
others who are most dissolute, make the decree of creating and permitting of sin, to precede the decree of saving some and damning others, My Opinion is equally removed from these extremes, and conceives none of these decrees to be either way subordinate, but all coordinate and simultaneous, as being decrees only of various means, tending to one and the same end; thus God doth decree both to create some, and to permit to sin, and finally to persevere therein, and to damn them for their sin, to the manifestation of his glory in the way of justice vindicative. On the other side, God doth decree to create others, and permit them to sin, and raise them out of sin by faith and repentance, and reward them with everlasting life, to the manifestation of his glory, in the way of mercy mixed with justice.
others who are most dissolute, make the decree of creating and permitting of sinne, to precede the decree of saving some and damning others, My Opinion is equally removed from these extreames, and conceives none of these decrees to be either way subordinate, but all coordinate and simultaneous, as being decrees only of various means, tending to one and the same end; thus God doth decree both to create some, and to permit to sinne, and finally to persevere therein, and to damne them for their sinne, to the manifestation of his glory in the way of justice vindicative. On the other side, God doth decree to create others, and permit them to sinne, and raise them out of sinne by faith and repentance, and reward them with everlasting life, to the manifestation of his glory, in the way of mercy mixed with justice.
Farther consider that as touching predestination it self, there was no question moved thereabouts in the Church of God, before the days of Pelagius; and what credit can they get, who consult with them in such points, wherein they were not exercised. For we find by experience, that to contend with Heretics hath been an ordinary means in the course of Gods providence, for the more diligent inquisition after the truth of God and happy discovery thereof. Sancta Ecclesia (saith Gregory) in 1suâ semper eruditione instruitur, dumb Haereticorum quaestionibus impugnatur. And Austin in like manner, Didiscimus, saith he, singulas quasque Haereses intulisse Ecclesiae proprias questions, contra quas diligentius defenderetur scriptura divina, quam si nulla talis necessitas cogeret. And on the other side, before question hath been moved on a point, the Fathers have delivered themselves somewhat improvidently, whereupon Heretics have taken advantage to countenance their errors by the writings of the Ancient. This Hierome observes in the point of Arianism, proving thereby, that the Ancient 2Writers before the Arian Heresy arose, were no competent judges in that point. Si me causas vitiorum (saith he) in Patrum Scriptis nescire respondero non statim illos Haereticos judicabo. Fieri enim potest ut vel simpliciter erraverint, vel alio sensu scripserint, vel a Librariis imperitis eorum paulatim scripta corrupta sunt, vel certè antequam in Alexandriâ quasi daemonium Meridianum Arrius nasceretur. Innocenter quaedam & minus cautè locuti sunt & quae non possunt perversorum hominum calumniam declinare. Mark it well, Before Arrius like a Devil from the South rose up, the Fathers delivered some things innocently, yet lose warily, and such as cannot avoid the calumny of perverse persons. Upon the same ground it is, that Austin excuseth Ticonius, and that in 3the same particular wherein he approached near to Pelagianism, to wit, before the Church of God was acquainted with that Heresy; his words are these, Sed non erat expertus hanc Haeresin Ticonius quae nostro tempore exorta multum nos, ut gratia Dei quae per Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum est adversus eos defenderemus, exercuit; & secundum id quod ait Apostolus, Oportet Haereses esse ut probati manifesti fiant in vobis, multò vigilantiores diligentioresque reddidit:
Farther consider that as touching predestination it selfe, there was no question moved thereabouts in the Church of God, before the daies of Pelagius; and what credit can they get, who consult with them in such points, wherein they were not exercised. For we find by experience, that to contend with Heretiques hath been an ordinary means in the course of Gods providence, for the more diligent inquisition after the truth of God and happy discovery thereof. Sancta Ecclesia (saith Gregory) in 1suâ semper eruditione instruitur, dum Haereticorum quaestionibus impugnatur. And Austin in like manner, Didiscimus, saith he, singulas quasque Haereses intulisse Ecclesiae proprias quaestiones, contra quas diligentius defenderetur scriptura divina, quam si nulla talis necessitas cogeret. And on the other side, before question hath been moved on a poynt, the Fathers have delivered themselves somewhat improvidently, whereupon Heretiques have taken advantage to countenance their errours by the writings of the Ancient. This Hierome observes in the poynt of Arrianisme, proving thereby, that the Ancient 2Writers before the Arrian Heresy arose, were no competent judges in that poynt. Si me causas vitiorum (saith he) in Patrum Scriptis nescire respondero non statim illos Haereticos judicabo. Fieri enim potest ut vel simpliciter erraverint, vel alio sensu scripserint, vel a Librariis imperitis eorum paulatim scripta corrupta sunt, vel certè antequam in Alexandriâ quasi daemonium Meridianum Arrius nasceretur. Innocenter quaedam & minus cautè locuti sunt & quae non possunt perversorum hominum calumniam declinare. Marke it well, Before Arrius like a Devill from the South rose up, the Fathers delivered some things innocently, yet lese warily, and such as cannot avoid the calumny of perverse persons. Upon the same ground it is, that Austin excuseth Ticonius, and that in 3the same particular wherein he approached neere to Pelagianisme, to wit, before the Church of God was acquainted with that Heresy; his words are these, Sed non erat expertus hanc Haeresin Ticonius quae nostro tempore exorta multum nos, ut gratia Dei quae per Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum est adversus eos defenderemus, exercuit; & secundum id quod ait Apostolus, Oportet Haereses esse ut probati manifesti fiant in vobis, multò vigilantiores diligentioresque reddidit: