Now these true Grounds of hope and comfort, a Minister cannot make use of, that holds absolute Reprobation; if he do usurp them, he cannot maintain them against the replies of the tempted, unless he relinquish his opinion; because (as I have said) there is a plain contradiction between them, and no man is able to maintain two propositions; which speak contrary things, to be both true, any more then he can make it good, that the same thing may have a being, and yet not have a being at the same time. For example, a Minister comes to comfort a man, that thinks himself to be an absolute Reprobate; and how doth he set about it? He tells him, that God would have all to be saved, that Christ dyed for all, &c. But what right hath he to these grounds of comfort, holding the contrary conclusions. viz. That God will have a great many to be damned, and to have no part in Christ? Well he usurps them notwithstanding, but is he able to maintain them against the answer of the tempted, can he make a good reply? No: for thus the tempted answers, God would have all to be saved with a revealed will, and, Christ died for all sufficiently, not intentionally: Or if God did intend that he should dye for all, yet he intended it upon a condition, which he purposeth, the most should never perform; What can the Minister reply upon this? If he will make a direct reply, that shall take away the answer, he must deny that God hath two wills contrary to each other; a secret will, that many shall be unavoidably damned, and a revealed will that all may be possibly saved; and he must also deny that God hath an intent, that Christ should not dye for a great many; or that he intended he should dye for all, upon condition they should believe and repent; and yet intend that the most should never believe and repent. But can he deny these things? He cannot, except he deny his own conclusion, and opinion, which is, that there are many thousands, eternally and unavoidably rejected in Gods absolute purpose, from grace and glory for ever: For that conclusion is all one, with the answer of the tempted, and contradictory to those arguments of comfort, which he is glad to make use of. Absolute reprobation therefore, bereaves that Minister, who believes it, of the solid grounds of consolation, and so makes him unable to recover a poor soul wounded with this temptation.
Now these true Grounds of hope and comfort, a Minister cannot make use of, that holds absolute Reprobation; if he doe usurpe them, he cannot maintaine them against the replyes of the tempted, unlesse he relinquish his opinion; because (as I have said) there is a plain contradiction between them, and no man is able to maintaine two propositions; which speake contrary things, to be both true, any more then he can make it good, that the same thing may have a being, and yet not have a being at the same time. For example, a Minister comes to comfort a man, that thinkes himselfe to be an absolute Reprobate; and how doth he set about it? He tells him, that God would have all to be saved, that Christ dyed for all, &c. But what right hath he to these grounds of comfort, holding the contrary conclusions. viz. That God will have a great many to be damned, and to have no part in Christ? Well he usurpes them notwithstanding, but is he able to maintaine them against the answer of the tempted, can he make a good reply? No: for thus the tempted answers, God would have all to be saved with a revealed will, and, Christ died for all sufficiently, not intentionally: Or if God did intend that he should dye for all, yet he intended it upon a condition, which he purposeth, the most should never performe; What can the Minister reply upon this? If he will make a direct reply, that shall take away the answer, he must deny that God hath two wills contrary to each other; a secret will, that many shall be unavoydably damned, and a revealed will that all may be possibly saved; and he must also deny that God hath an intent, that Christ should not dye for a great many; or that he intended he should dye for all, upon condition they should believe and repent; and yet intend that the most should never believe and repent. But can he deny these things? He cannot, except he deny his own conclusion, and opinion, which is, that there are many thousands, eternally and unavoydably rejected in Gods absolute purpose, from grace and glory for ever: For that conclusion is all one, with the answer of the tempted, and contradictory to those arguments of comfort, which he is glad to make use of. Absolute reprobation therefore, bereaves that Minister, who believes it, of the solid grounds of consolation, and so makes him unable to recover a poore soule wounded with this temptation.